wearing a make america great hat. there's definitely a connection there. >> did he support trump or do you think he saw this as an opportunity to advance his own agenda? >> i think initially he definitely supported trump. more recently, he's fallen back on sort of this idea that trump was compromiedsed by the deep state and to longer works for them. he still regards trump as this lesson that nationalism can win. he changed the conversation and things of bad nature. but he's always -- since the start of trump's campaign, he's definitely been an admirer of trump, i would say. >> do you know if your uncle has any regrets about how heather heyer was killed and all the violent that took place down there? >> no. from what he's said, it sounds like he blames the charlottesville police. i'm not sure what his rationale is for that, but, you know, he's

planning -- he said that he's planning some kind of event here in fargo in october where he's going to get a bunch of his nazi friends together and considering the national profile he's accrued, he could very well end up summoning quite a few nazis. we're going to go out and counter protest him for sure, but who knows how many people he's going to bring. so if there are any people out there that are dsa, who want to stand by us and march with us. we'd welcome that. >> just remember you have a right to speak and be there and the point is to keep it nonviolent and try to move this country forward. that's what everybody should try to do. thank you very much for being with us. i'm sorry you are family is

going through this. be well. all right. let's go going. top of another hour. we want to welcome our viewers in h the united states and around the world. this is "new day." alisyn is off. poppy is joining me. president trump is under fire for once again blaming both side force the violence that killed a woman in charlottesville. the president's condemnation for white supremacist on monday seemingly meaningless. >> republicans in congress are united in denouncing hate but very few are calling out the president by name and laying this in his lap. newspapers around the country -- as this nation today mourns the death in heather heyer, her memorial service held in hours. another american city, this time baltimore remove the confederate

monuments over night. >> the president with the press conference yesterday wasn't even supposed to be about this topic but became all about it for him, the media and the country. here's a little bit of it. the president in his own words. >> i do think there's blame on both sides. you look at both sides. i think there's blame on both sides. and i have no doubt about it, and you don't have any doubt about it either. >> what about -- >> excuse me. what about the alt left that came charging as you say the alt-right? do they have any semblance of guilt? let me ask you this. what about the fact they came charging with clubs in their hands swinging clubs. do they have any problem? i think they do. >> all right. let's bring in our panel. chr chris, david axelrod and don

lemon. the president's factual basis about this being equal combatance on the ground. our sister network was on the ground there. a here's what was being said and done on the ground. >> you will not replace us. jews will not replace us. blood and soil! blood and soil! who is streets? our streets. >> i'm here to spread ideas, talk in the hopes that somebody more capable will come along and do that. somebody like donald trump who does not give his daughter to a

jew. >> so donald trump -- a lot more racist than donald trump. i don't think you could feel about race the way i do and watch that -- >> the president wants to talk about the fact basis. yeah, they had a permit, but this was supposed to be moved to a different site. they didn't want it moved. they actually won the legal battle. they wanted this to be as provacative as possible. they wound up being cited for unlawful assembly because of what happened. this isn't about the facts. this is about moral agency and what do you make of the president saying it's wrong on both sides. >> no one has a permit for hate. we all know the history. clan and white supremacist. this is the rambling of a man who's ignorant of this country and the facts of what went on, on the ground.

this is what he believes. there is no other way around it. the he said it in so many terms after being kwed about it over and over and over again. he's ill informed. he doesn't know the history of this country. he should go back to school and get an elementary history education of what the difference is between a hate group and a protest group who is protesting fascism and racism and bigotry. it is a sad state of affairs when you have a president of the united states defending bigots, defending the offspring. k clan in this country. >> there was a big question as we watched the people around the president, cabinet members, ste steve -- general kelly with his arms crossed. a tweet of gary was disgusted

and upset both in quotes by the president's comments on white nationalists, according to three different people with knowledge. that's one thing. and then, what do you do about it? you worked in the white house. if you fundamentally disagree with what the president has done can you stand by? should you stand by? >> i think a lot of people are going to have to wrestle with that he kquestion. >> i have a feeling some of these people are saying i'm a thin blue line between an unstable president and the rest of the world, therefore i should stay here and try to guide him. the question is how much can he be guided. let me say generally, i share in the outrage and disappointment. i'm the son of a jewish refugee. i very much feel that, but i'm not surprised, because this is exactly who the president was when he was running for president. he retweeted neo-nazi tweets,

retweeted white supremacist tweets. he said things that caused speaker ryan to say last year that he had engaged in the textbook of a racist comment. and so now, he is who is he. michele obama said in her convention speech the presidency doesn't change you, it reveals you. this is who donald trump is. at the question is who are we? now as a country and how are we going to react to this? he is not going to change but are we going to react to what he has said and done and to this sort of embrace of racism, and that is a question for republicans. it's a question for democrats. it's a question for all of us. >> well, chris, saved axle rod just mentioned paul ryan. the who's that? i haven't heard from him. said well we're on vacation now. what is going on here? he didn't even mention the president by name.

john mccain did in his tweet. but look, again, the job is to fight injustice, and to reinforce morality, to stand firm. how do these men and women justify being so quiet? we couldn't get them on television this morning. this wasn't to defend the health care bill that doesn't make a lot of sense. this is about moral agency and fighting hate. we got one congressman scott tailor. th none of them would come on. >>they're cowards. >> on the one side people do this. on the other side people do that. this is just frankly not true. as don rightly pointed out, on the one side you have hate-filled people who want to eliminate people because of what they believe or look like. on the other side you have people who don't agree with that viewpoint. that is not a reasonable

argument. when you try to put it in a political context, place it on a political spectrum i'm sure their advisers say away from this. this is radioactive, you talking about neo-nazis and donald trump is a 100% loser. this isn't a political issue. really isn't. talking about it because donald trump is president of the united states. this is moral. this is a moral issue of moral leadership. can we condemn things as a society that are based on hate, and intel rons. the answer to that has to be yes. right? i remind people, this republican party, paul ryan, mitch mcconnell, lots of other folks, i went through two days ago before the press conference i went through and found nine instances when i found none, or all of them denounced, ran away and say they couldn't support trump over the last few months.

yet here we are pushing his health care bill. at some point you have to stand up and say this isn't about politics, it's about doing what is right. where do you go from there? because donald trump ain't changing. right? so where do you take this as a paul ryan or mitch mcconnell is harder to determine. i do think you need to stand up and say this isn't what we are. >> can we stop beating around the bush. let's let's honest. the us new yorkers, we've known who donald trump was for a very long time. we've known him with the housing discrimination and the pushing the whole -- we know why he's so obsessed with barack obama. barack obama was a black president. maybe he didn't think that barack obama was fit to be in office. he traded on racial animus and racial bs and been doing it for

decades and we're going to pretend we're surprised. what's going on in his head, how can anyone defend what the president said yesterday? it is indefensible. i can't believe people actually try to defend. what donald trump said yesterday? is this there is no defense for what he said. what he said was disgusting and unamerican. anyone who is american and believes in this country should be speaking out against this person and saying that it is wrong for him to do this. the let me be plainly clear. anyone who is in that white house and who is supporting him is complicit in their racism as well. >> the then then becomes what do americans waking up across this country in the heartland on main street america, what do they do with that? because the president won't denounce this. and many people around him won't

denounce it and all it out by name and call him out by name. so what does that leave america with this morning? >> well, first of all, americans themselves have to pull together and make statements in h their own lives that they reject this. they need to call on their elected officials to do it. let me get back to the question you asked chris and put a finer point on it. the reason the republicans don't speak out is a, they're afraid of donald trump and his twitter account. b, the -- the alt-right tloup is actually a force within the republican party, and they're afraid of taking on breitbart and that crowd, who have given comfort to these groups. and the third is that they've made this bargain with donald trump if you sign our stuff, if you do the things we want then we will give you support. and i think that they're going to have to re-examine all of those things right now. and decide if they're going to

stand up as john mccain stood up and a few others yesterday. >> you saw it, what the president said yesterday about the alt-right. when he was saying who the media who es at alt-right. go ask steve bannon. the he created a supposed fair media outlet that was painfully quiet about what happened in charlottesville. the it is pretty clear, chris, he wants to defend these groups and these people in the alt-right. that's why he compares them to the alt left when there is no such ekwi lensy and he continues toe do so. >> i wanted to take slight issue with don's point earlier when he said donald trump is ignorant of history. i think if that's true, it's the best outcome for donald trump. i think if you look at the body of what he has said and done since he's been a candidate, it is difficult to conclude that he's not doing this stuff on

purpose. with a knowledge -- i'm no the saying he's a historian, but with a working knowledge of the kind of racially coated language, the provocation that it causes. the i think it's virtually impossible now to say, oh, well, he may not know -- i'm not saying this is what don was saying but he may not know what he's doing but it has these impacts. it seems clear that a reasonable person would have to conclude he knows exactly what he's doing. the and that's -- >> when he say he's ignorant, i'm talking about when he compare is george washington and. >> right, right. >> he doesn't understand why people -- offensive that there's a robert e. lee statue. >> he says they were all slave owners -- one of them led a -- >> that's right. >> but i feel like --

>> hang on one second. >> sure, dave. >> just i wanted to say wasn't it in that very building that he began his campaign. >> that's right. >> what was essentially a racist appeal. his campaign was predicated on appeals to bias. that's not to say that everybody who voted for donald trump voted for him for that reason. i think we ought to make thatter cloo. i think a lot of people voted for him because they were frustrated with the economy and frustrated with washington and he was a vote for change. they weren't signing on for all of this. but at the core of his appeal, certainly at the beginning and throughout the campaign, really, was this racist notion that began at that building on that day when he came down the escalator. so i just echo what i said before what don said. this is not a surprise. the donald trump -- this was nts a bait and switch. he ran this way. we expected somehow the presidency would lift him.

clearly that's not going to happen. le. >> if that's the case, donald trump supporters and not all of them are racist, the bulk are them or not racist. the so all the more reason for those who are good americans to stand up against this kind of language and belief that the president -- if you believe in the president, then you should speak out and let it be known that that behavior he displayed yesterday was not right. >> that's why the silence is so problematic from -- look, the democrats have to stand up and especially the republicans have to stand up, david, and they're not. a tweet doesn't cut it in this situation. it just doesn't. this is a big moral failing. it's not about politics. the and it really is a time for leadership. i mean if you look at the people who support trump on social media, that's a big part of where they live, you have these groups he's em powered. there's no coincidence that david duke and all those guys were thanking him for what he said. that tells you everything you need to know. then you have all these real

republicans who do not espouse bigoted views. where are their leaders? >> they count espouse bigoted views but do benefit from the party. they're afraid to defy that base or a president who's proven himself to be spiteful. and they're hopeful that this will blow over and somehow they can move on to tax reform. >> but why, if you're paul ryan and saying i'm sort of made this bargain and he can get my agenda through, he's not. for what? >> they're the beneficiary of it. >> keeping their job? >> getting their agenda across? how much? when do republicans stand up and say enough a enough. at what cost? is it -- listen, how much of a

tax benefit is worth giving away your humanity? how much -- i don't understand it. >> well said. >> put it in political terms. sorry poppy. put it in political terms. what will be left of the post donald trump republican party if this is allowed to fester? i think the moral question is far more important. who we are. who are we? what are we as a society? but even if p you look at it in pure political terms, you're not -- being a party that tries to make moral equivalence between white supremacy and people protesting that that's not a majority vote in this country. the there's so many reasons why it doesn't make any sense here and what he is doing is dangerous. the genuinely dangerous for our society and politics. >> gentlemen.

>> how can they say we're the party of lincoln? >> not only that, it's a family betrayal. if you look at that sound bite of the guy saying how can donald trump allow his daughter, beautiful daughter to marry that b word jared kushner. >> don lemon, thank you for being here. david axelrod, chris, as always. while politicians aren't doing what they need to do, faith leaders are. the they're weighing in on charlottesville and the conversation that needs to happen. the rabbi from president trump's inauguration is speaking out about what he thinks happened yesterday. next. [upbeat music]

>> announcer: no one loves a road trip like your furry sidekick! so when your "side glass" gets damaged... [dog barks] trust safelite autoglass to fix it fast, and we'll get you back on the road! [dog barks] ♪safelite repair, safelite replace.♪ they always refer to me as master sergeant. they really appreciate the military family, and it really shows. we've got auto insurance, homeowners insurance. had an accident with a vehicle, i actually called usaa before we called the police. usaa was there hands-on very quick very prompt. i feel like we're being handled as people that actually have a genuine need. we're the webber family and we are usaa members for life. usaa, get your insurance quote today.

and life's beautiful moments.ns get between you flonase outperforms the #1 non-drowsy allergy pill. it helps block 6 key inflammatory substances that cause symptoms. pills block one and 6 is greater than 1. flonase changes everything. [radi♪ alarm] julie is living with metastatic breast cancer, which is breast cancer that has spread to other parts of her body. she's also taking prescription ibrance with an aromatase inhibitor, which is for postmenopausal women with hormone receptor- positive her2- metastatic breast cancer as the first hormonal based therapy. ♪ ibrance plus letrozole was significantly more effective at delaying disease progression versus letrozole.

and ibrance plus letrozole shrunk tumors in over half of these patients. patients taking ibrance can develop low white blood cell counts, which may cause serious infections that can lead to death. before taking ibrance, tell your doctor if you have fever, chills, or other signs of infection liver or kidney problems, are pregnant, breastfeeding, or plan to become pregnant. common side effects include low red blood cell and low platelet counts... ...infections, tiredness, nausea, sore mouth, abnormalities in liver blood tests, diarrhea, hair thinning or loss, vomiting, rash, and loss of appetite. julie calls it her "new" normal. because a lot has changed, but a lot hasn't. ask your doctor about ibrance, the number-one-prescribed, fda-approved oral combination treatment for hr+/her2- mbc. tand the alzheimer'sf association is going to make it happen. but we won't get there without you.

visit alz.org to join the fight. the rabbi who offered a prayer add president trump's inauguration is speaking out disagreeing with how the president's response to the deadly violence in charlottesville came across. rabbi marvin here joins us. thank you very much for taking the time to join us. what do you make of what the president said yesterday? >> well, if the president would have asked me, i would have advised him that you cannot equate neo-nazi, the clan and white supremacists with the other demonstrators because those three, that's a code word for an america without jews, for an america

out-african-americans, without latinos. the now, it's true that in every demonstration, you may have average citizens that violate the law, but the president of the united states should make it very clear that is no comparison with the bigots and haters that is represented in h the philosophy of neo-nazis, white supremacists and the klan. let me say something else. these demonstrations are very dangerous. people forget. the third riots started with small demonstrations, it got bigger and bigger and the next thing we knew is that adolf hitler became chancellor of nazi germany. i would have told him, mr. president, go out there, condemn these racists and bigots and that's all. and i make one other comment.

it takes away from -- in my opinion -- from some of the good things president trump has done. like standing up tough to the north korean dictator. you can't kick the ball down the line if we stood up to him 15 years ago, we wouldn't be facing int intercontinental missiles today. and his -- the fact that he's -- he went to saudi arabia trying to make peace between the saudis and the is raelis. >> here's the thing. this is about what's in his heart, what happened yesterday because you have to explain why he did it. and that answer is going to wind up casting a shadow, or, a ray of sunlight on everything else that happens, because if someone wants to defend these types of

haters, it doesn't matter what they do with north korea. because the presidency is about moral agency. t i know you know this. it was part of yo you are prayer. so why do you think the president chose to say what he said yesterday, something that's so clearly wrong to you and so many others? >> i have no idea. i tried to analyze it. i have no idea. i think that the president should correct this cause. he should choose an occasion now to make it very clear that there's no comparison between other demonstrators on the left and bigots like nazis, the klan and white supremacists. i would make one other comment, which i think is very important. you know, there's other bikgots in the world. often inconsistencies in our society. the greatest deny is of the hol

a cost today in the world are the iranians. the we sh mooz with them, invite them to cocktail parties. they're on television. their diplomats are welcome. we don't take them to task that they say the hall la cost never happened. on the very day the identify ya toll la said there was no holocaust. if i were the pope i would have said you're not welcome until your leader stops saying that it never happened. >> rabbi, i reach iat your thoughts on this. you were a powerful voice on the day of the inauguration. the you're a powerful voice today as well. be well. >> thank you. the statue of robert e. lee still stands in charlottesville but overnight one came down in baltimore. we're going to talk about the

battle over these confederate symbols with the may mayor who is dealing with it. the finally, listening to my wife, went to a doctor. and i became diagnosed with hodgkin's lymphoma ...that diagnosis was tough. i had to put my trust in somebody. when i first met steve, we recommended chemotherapy, and then we did high dose therapy and then autologous stem cell transplant. unfortunately, he went on to have progressive disease i thought that he would be a good candidate for immune therapy. it's an intravenous medicine that is going to make his immune system evade the tumor. with chemotherapy, i felt rough, fatigue, nauseous. and with immune therapy we've had such a positive result. i'm back to working hard. i've honestly never felt this great. i believe the future of immunotherapy at ctca is very bright. the evolution of cancer care is here. learn more at cancercenter.com

appointments available now. oh, it's actually... sfx: (short balloon squeal) it's ver... sfx: (balloon squeals) ok can we... sfx: (balloon squeals) goodbye! oof, that milk in your coffee was messing with you, wasn't it? try lactaid, it's real milk, without that annoying lactose. good right? yeah. lactaid. the milk that doesn't mess with you.

when you think of saving money, ♪ music plays throughout) what comes to mind? your next getaway? connecting with family and friends? a big night out? or maybe your everyday shopping. whatever it is, aarp member advantages can help save you time and money along the way. so when you get there, you can enjoy it all the more. for less. surround yourself with savings at aarpadvantages.com

holoca overnight the city of bault pore removed four confederate statues as the battle to take down the symbols plays out in h cities across the country. still the robert e. lee statue stands in charlottesville. the president weighed in h. >> so, this week it's robert e. lee. i noticed that stone wall jackson is coming down. i wonder is it george washington, thomas jefferson. you really do have to ask yourself where does it stop. >> the fundamental m misunderstanding of history. talking about us mayors. gentlemen, nice to have you. le you have both been in the midst of this fight over the monuments and what they stand for. we'll begin with you. you made the choice last year at the university of louisville campus to move the statue

elsewhere. you asked the commission what to do with the others. the president equated thomas jefferson and george washington the founding fathers, who, of course, had faults and flaws but put them on the same plane as robert e. lee. how do you see the argument? >> well there's a big difference between people that started this country recognizing it was an imperfect union and those who tried to destroy our country and celebrate slavery. it certainly is a false equivalence. the we're using this as another moral moment in our city to lean into racism, to have community conversations, how we need to be a strong diversity. >> major benjamin, the constituents on the streets of your city saying this morning. >> people are generally sad, poppy. they're sad. they're outraged. they're gravely concerned about

the future of our great country. south carolina is a state whose history has been challenged over the course of the life of this great federal republic. over the last several years after we've been challenged, the state came together, democrats republicans, everybody came together to move forward in the state. remove the confederate battle flag from the state capitol and do it peaceably. we've been able to do these things together. we can fight the battles of 150 years ago. we need our president to be looking forward to creating this country in which every single person has value. every single person has -- we believe here is a child of god and we've got to start making sure we elect leaders and support leaders who speak to that value, the value of human dignity and life. >> mayor fisher, you used the

word compassion a lot as a way to dejibe your city and the way you work and hope to lead it. there are -- republicans in congress are united right now on one thing. that is condemning hatred and bigotry. but they are pretty much, with the exception of senator john mccain, governor john kasich, silent when it comes to call out this president by name in all of this and laying it in his lap. in his hand. how do you see that? >> well, i mean the big issue here is how do we rise above any person and relate to what we all have. we are all born compassionate peeping, loving people, kind people. and that discourse is so absent in the public arena today, if people are quick to go to hatred, division. what leaders should be doing is encouraging us to greater aspirations where we're coming together around the basic human notions.

when a little baby is born, what does it do? does it crawl over to somebody and slap them in the face? no. they want a hug. so we are all compassionate beings. that's what we should be focusing on now. we have to deal with the reality of the day. i get this. but let's have a discussion around unity. the world in louisville is determination. we're not going to let situations like this destroy our city or country. le we're going to work with basic human values. realizing we're imperfect people but we're in it together. >> mayor benjamin but do you believe unity can come from this president? do you believe he has done anything to unite america with the comments he made yesterday? >> poppy, i believe that in some odd almost perverse way some of what we're saying from the president is pulling people together. it's pulling a whole lot of folks in my community together

who know this does not speak to the ideals of who america is. it doesn't speak to the critical words articulated in our declaration of independence. our u.s. constitution. the challenges that i will say here since i have a very brief moment, is that we're still trying to figure out how to make sure that millions of americans have havg health care: we're trying address trillions of dollars of needs across this country. we have a president who is focused on some shiny illegitimate object in the corner. and people suffering who need to be prepared for the information of work. people have real needs, destroying our environment. the there's work to be done on behalf of the wealthiest and most powerful democratic nation in the history of the world and it's not being done, because the president wants to focus on

division and hatred. we can do better. we must ask our president, members of congress, governors to join with our mayor us because i will say that the work in louisville and anaheim, compassion, the leadership we're receiving from your president, mitch landrieu. le we have mayors leading all across this country, working to make sure this wonderful american ex-experiment works for all of god's children. >> thank you. >> thank you both for being here. >> thank you. it you have to remember what matters and who matters. just hours, charlottesville is going to remember the brave young woman, heather heyer, her life taken by a man using a car as a weapon of terror. we're going to talk with one of heather's friends next.

in just a few hours, a memorial service is going to be held for the woman on your screen, charlottesville victim heather heyer. she wasn't at the protest in an equally extreme and violent alt

lefty capacity as the president assumed. she was there to oppose hate, and it cost her her life. joining us now is alfred wilson who worked with her. he will be speaking at today's memorial service. thank you very much for joining us. i'm sorry for your loss. >> thank you for having me here this morning. >> now we know, i see from your bow tie heather loved purple. people are going to be wearing purple. i see purple ribbons everywhere. what do you want people to know about what the legacy should be? >> well, heather, as you pointed out, loved purple. purple, as you may know is a color of royalty. other thing about purple is interesting enough, purple actually is a symbol of when people wear purple is a symbol

of openness, basically lets other people know i'm willing to work with you. the that's something that heather was. willing to work with anyone. she was a very kind generous person and someone that was actually very opinionated and spoke up for what she believed was right. >> what do you make of what she's become symbolic of in this situation? her loss of life is an absolute wrong and tragedy, it's a crime. and it is a huge hole in the lives of all who knew and loved her but she has now become symbolic of the struggle in h charlottesville and the national dialogue that has come from it. how do you see that part of it? >> i see that part as something i know heather would have em braced. the struggle that all of us are going through as far as basically social equality, as far as basically embracing the fact that there is so much

racism still going on in our country, i just know that heather would be proud to know that she's being recognized for such a fight or such a struggle. one of the things about heather is she's a very humble young woman. a woman that would do anything for anyone to help anyone, and to see that anyone would actually get a fair treatment. but the fact that the country is standing behind this 32-year-old woman, it just amazes me. the i'm so proud of her for what these's been doing. >> we have sound from her mother who was addressing the man who took her daughter from her, who killed, murdered heather heyer. here's a little bit of what she said. i want to get your reaction. >> you took my child from me, and i'm going to be the voice that she could no longer be. and so you gave us a national forum and maybe i should thank you for that, but i can't. i would rather have my child.

>> terrible situation for the mother to be in and have to try and make some significance out of this. how is the pain among those who loved her? is i know she was tight with her coworkers, i know her desk is filled with flowers. the what's the hadest part emotionally for you? >> missing her smile. missing her challenging intellect. i'm still speechless about that. i've cried many times. yesterday was the first time back in the office. and i shed a lot of tears about it. the it was an amazing time just to try to actually overcome it. heather, when she came down here on saturday, she wanted to basically stand up for what was right. one of the things that bothered -- i know myself, about this whole protest or rally that

was coming up is those individuals came here to that rally, they made no effort to educate anyone about why they wanted this statue for robert e. lee to stay there. the this guy wasn't born in h chrl chrl lots vil. he had no reason to have any significance in charlottesville. this organization provided no educational materials or any witness why they should be here. what they came to do is basically promote hate and try to suppress individuals. that's what heather was basically standing up gueagains. you need to give everyone a fair chance and understand all of us are equal. heather wanted individuals to know that she believed that we are all here equally and that we all should have the same opportunities in life. when heather came to work with us, one of the things she was so

humble and always second-guessed herself about, how valuable she is, and used to tell me, alfred i'm just a high school graduate. i said no you're more than that. you're a woman with a voice. somebody that individuals will listen to and wanted to talk to. >> well that voice -- >> that's something i really enjoyed about heather. is her voice. >> that voice is going to echo through your memories today at the memorial and what everybody else has been saying and what was in her heart that hopefully will remain in yours. alfred, thank you very much for joining us. and again, i'm sorry to have to meet you under these circumstances but hopefully something bigger than just her death will come out of that memorial today. >> yes, i hope so as well. thank you for having me this morning. >> thank you for taking the time. changing history. that is what president trump called the removal of confederate monuments. is that the case? we will put the question to a

leading civil war historian. ey w deals every day up to 60% off. that's how kaley and i got to share this trip together at this amazing hotel. go to priceline and get the hotel deals you won't find anywhere else. [car tires screech] [bell rings] and life's beautiful moments.ns get between you flonase outperforms the #1 non-drowsy allergy pill. it helps block 6 key inflammatory substances that cause symptoms. pills block one and 6 is greater than 1. flonase changes everything.

mikboth served in the navy.s, i do outrank my husband, not just being in the military, but at home. she thinks she's the boss. she only had me by one grade. we bought our first home together in 2010. his family had used another insurance product but i was like well i've had usaa for a while, why don't we call and check the rates? it was an instant savings and i should've changed a long time ago. there's no point in looking elsewhere really. we're the tenneys and we're usaa members for life. usaa. get your insurance quote today. president trump criticizing the removal of robert e. lee and other confederate statues as "changing history" even conflating lee with presidents george washington and thomas jefferson. let's bring in harold hole zer. he's a leading historian of the civil war era and author of

"lincoln and the power of the press." let's talk about what the concepts are that are involved here. the president saying who's next? washington? jefferson? why does that make sense? why does it not? >> well it's false equivalency. one set of people, the founders, may have been hypocritical in the conset of liberty but created the foundations of government. articulated the provision of men all power created equal even if not able to live by it. the people who are monumentalized in h the south defies that tradition. in their own bloodlines in h some cases and they tried to wreck the republic the founders had created. it was all about slavery, one stain on the founders founding of the country. >> i think concepts are

important because i bet a lot of american the don't know when these statues went oup. most at two isn't pos, first during the turn of the century in jim video, second in 50 z and 60s. >> two subjects, history and memory. history is not erasable. we know what happened. we know the death toll which most historians think is 750,000 which is worse than we imagine for a century. but the way memory was altered to create her rowism out of destrik tivism is the truly disturbing part. the statues fall somewhere in the middle for me. but that's another story. the first major statue of lee was like a mummy lying down. hands on chest in the college, the chapel of the college that he was president of in retirement. sort of appropriate. his cause was over. he was dead and so was the idea

of secession and slavery. but then he stood up in the next series of statues and eventually rose to the symbolic might of at equestrian sta statue. >> there's an iconology of what that is a supposed to symbol ize. he was in there in your face about the confederacy. what does that mean to you about what's in the president's head? >> i don't think he knows that much about history. i don't think anything is in his head except people didn't like his first statement. that's my political view which i'll try not to dwell on because i'm supposed to talk about the statues. i don't think he gets it or knows the difference between history and memory. i don't think he understands the nuances. >> but that's dangerous. >> it's highly dangerous, not only should we have maybe a week

ago discussed whether she is statues are so offensive to so many people that they ought to be either counter sculptured. the people of richmond put up a statue of arthur ash to confront them and the controversy was unbelievable. tragic, but they did it. maybe there should be frederick douglas in maryland, for example where they're taking down another statue. there are these ideas of doing parallel statues to give bothsides of the story. what the president has done unfortunately along with the demonstrators but what he has condoned is the idea these statues are the -- resurrect naziism. the statues are going to be the losers at this point or maybe deserve to be. >> thank you.

it's an important history lesson for earn. thank you all for being with us. quick break then news room with john berman. sensing and automatically adjusting to your every move. there. i can even warm these. does your bed do that? i'm the new sleep number 360 smart bed. let's meet at a sleep number store.

when heartburn hits fight back fast with new tums chewy bites. fast relief in every bite. crunchy outside. chewy inside. tum tum tum tum new tums chewy bites. the good morning everyone john berman here. the big question this morning is what now? what now after the president made his feelings crystal clear on the violence and death sparked by white supremacists this weekend. what now for republicans critical for the president's words on hate but less critical of the man or his agenda. what now for the white house staff, those of the jewish staff, what now for the military whose leaders have made unusual bold statements in reaction, if not opposition to the president's words? what now for the family of heather heyer, killed, perhaps murdered because of the hate. her