Skip to main content

tv   CNN Newsroom Live  CNN  April 20, 2022 11:00pm-12:01am PDT

11:00 pm
hello. el km to our viewers in the united states and around the world. i am john vause live in lviv, ukraine. mariupol, fighters in that port city who held up a russian' assault for weeks may now have just days or hours left. and i want rosemary church live at cnn head quarters in atlanta. uk prime minister pors johnson has apologized twice in two days for party gate. today, mp's debate, will he misled them and what do about it. it is 9:00 a.m. here in ukraine, where russian forces are tightening their strangle democracy hold on the port city of mare yoep. a ukrainian commander says as many as you a thousand civilians
11:01 pm
and the last remainian soldiers in a steel factory with supplies running low. they will try again in the coming hours. president volodymyr zelenskyy says up to 120,000 civilians are trapped in mariupol. >> translator: we don't know when we can unblock mariupol and i say this openly. all the boys want a free city. none of them are going to surrender to the enemy. this is their internal feeling. this is what they are. first, it involves serious and heavy weapons. at the moment, we don't have enough of these weapons to free mariupol. the second path is diplomatic. so far, russia hasn't agreed to this. >> taking mariupol is part of russia's plan to control the eastern part of ukraine, donbas
11:02 pm
region. a u.s. defense tells cnn moscow's added 17 ba tall kron tactical groups over the past week. the military governor in luhansk reports russian troops control 80% of territory there as they destroy everything in their palgt. and images circulating on social media, show force russians have taken the nearby village. meanwhile, world war ii soviet-victory flags appearing across occupied parts of ukraine, ahead of may 9th victory celebrations. wants to report a major progress in this invasion by that date as celebration for vladimir putin. to senior ukrainian noebters say they are prepared to secure the evacuation of soldiers. nato allies could also be part of that process, as well. more details now from cnn's matt rivers. >> reporter: the azov steal plan housing mariupol's last line of defense.
11:03 pm
if defenders here fall, so goes the city. a fuj fie days ago, george says he was right in the heart of the fight. >> honestly, i never seen such brutal, devastating war, 'cause russians are just trying to execute the civilians. >> reporter: he spoke to us via video chat from an undisclosed location. severely injured during the nighting, he says he was smulgled out to recover. he is a georgian national, and a commander in the azov battalion, one of the few remaining units left defending the city. he says he was among the soldiers fighting the russians while, at the same time, taking care of hundreds of civilians sheltering in the area. some of which, purportedly seen here in video cnn can't verify posted on the ukrainian government's social media. >> so how long do you think your group can take care of all of those people and -- and yourselves? >> that's hard to answer.
11:04 pm
time is short. >> reporter: tens of thousands of citizens in besieged mariupol still need to be evacuated. on wednesday, a slight glimmer of hope -- a humanitarian corridor, agreed to by bog sides, where civil yaps could evacuate mariupol, eventually to zaporizhzhia. the city' mayor urging people to use it. he said during these long and difficult days you survived in inhumane conditions, you may have heard different things but i want you to know the main thing. they are waiting for you in zaporizhzhia. it is safe there. video from mariupol city council shows buses lined up ready to take those who wanted to leave. it is unclear how many got on but a regional official says fewer people left than he had hoped. for many, leaving is a difficult choice. it requires trusting that the
11:05 pm
russian military will not harm those trying to leave. and yet, this is the same military that has spent the entire war systematically targeting civilians across the country ask yet the city has become unlivable. for the military units still resisting, they are scaring for soldiers and civilians, sometimes with the same injuries due to russian' shelling. >> a child or soldier ask lot of times i see a soldier say go ahead take a child, it is a priority. >> reporter: a commander has urked the international community to set up an evacuation route using a third party, another country that might be able to facilitate the transfer of soldiers ask civilians to safety. if that doesn't happen, he says russia will continue the b bombardment and it will end only one way. >> there will be nobody left in this area. they will be dead, all the
11:06 pm
children. i am not talking about children but the civilians will be eliminated ask it's going to be on us. on a civilized world. >> matt rivers, cnn, lviv, ukraine. well, until now, the u.s. and nato allies have not sent fighter jets to ukraine, despite the president here asking for those planes. the reason why is that the u.s. believes it would be seen as a provocation to russia. but aircraft parts -- that's another story. the u.s. says it sent enough poorts to ukraine to get 20 more fighter jets into the sky. now, these jets, along with surface to air missiles and anti-aircraft missiles have kept russia from establishing air superiority. there is also word the u.s. will send yet another aid package worse $800 million. u.s. president joe biden says it is all part of american's pledge to help the people of ukraine. >> i new they were tough and proud but i tell you what, they are tougher and more proud than i thought. i am amazed what they're doing
11:07 pm
in terms of providing advice and -- and -- and weaponry provided along with the rest of nato. >> so, with russia re focusing on the eastern part of ukraine, ukraine's military has held off russian' advances so far but u.s. defense officials are warning of a much larger assault to come. let's get more on this, we are joinedpy colonel andrew melvin. he is retired special operations commander for the u.s. marine corps, and he set up a traping center here in ukraine to help troops get ready for war. kerm, thank you for being with us, sir. in the past two months aileen since this fighting began, the u.s. has shipped close to, i think, $4 billion in weapons to ukraine? that's more than the entire annual-defense budget for hungary, the slovak republic, lithuania, latvia. i mean, that list goes on. is anyone asking if these weapons are actually reaching the soldiers on the frontline? what's been your experience? >> well, john, first of all,
11:08 pm
good morning to all of your listeners and as you may have seen in previous interviews, i did try and explain why this stuff is not reaching the frontline. clearly, it is not. and, i know, anyone who says it is, i challenge them to go up and we will gladly accompany any correspondent to a frontline unit and -- ask, you know, show them it's not the case and it's not -- here, i want to emphasize something very quickly, though, john. this is not because of any krumgz here in ukraine. it's not because people are doing bad things or stealing this stuff. it upsets me when i hear rumors like this. it's simply because the nature of -- of -- of any logistics' supply chain, if you don't have full visibility ask control, as the u.s. does not, once it crosses the border, then there is no one who is motivated to hurry things on the way or even knows where it is. if united states loses what he
11:09 pm
call intransit visibility but look, john, i have talked enough about the problem. there is solutions. or at least one group of which i am the founder. we have got, you know, over 100 volunteers, carefully-vetted, former-uk, u.s., handful of australians and others, former-special operationers. we are not here as mercenaries. we are here to help expedite, solve problems like this, expedite logistics items, critically needed items into the hands of frontline units. not only that, i just listened to your story about mariupol. it is breaking all of our hearts, too. but we are prepared to do something about it. we have evacuation teams ready. in fact, we are doing a [ inaudible ] tomorrow and prepared to once -- once these humanitarian corridor -- if it is established and ukrainian military m.o.d. requests to do so, to move forward and -- and enable civilians to es came cape from the city. we are ready. we have good relations with
11:10 pm
ukraine soft special operations forces and with mod. so i -- in -- in a position to help us, um, i -- i urge them to direct any resources they have our way but we don't need any adigle resources right now in order to help with this evacuation. >> so, your only ask is by the ukrainian authorities. >> yes absolutely because, otherwise, we run the risk of just adding more problems to the situation. one thing ukrainian authorities do not need are units running back and forth across the front lines. you know, there is also enough prk problems demfication, ukrainians and russians using much of the same paefrt. they don't need third-paefrt nationals messing things up. of however, given the go ahead, we don't need -- we don't need assistance from ukrain ukrainia military, aside from
11:11 pm
identification and coordination. we are prepared to push in our own small way with enabling evacuation down the safe corridors. >> president zelenskyy increase supplies -- sorry, go on. >> yeah. just safe cover dors is a very relative tomorrow as you heard. russians really have no respect for these things but nevertheless, it is a lower level -- slightly lower level of risk, than running through the blockade which would frankly be suicidal right now. >> but no more humanitarian corridors as promised by the russians out of mariupol has actually worjed out as advertised. zelenskyy has made this cop telling case for increased weapon supplies. i am wonderling from what you know, the amount of weapons which are already in country, if supply lines could be secured, if those logistics could be worked out, that alone would make a huge difference in this fight, right? >> yeah, john, the solution is
11:12 pm
right simple. for instance, my organization just needs authorization to go down ask start freeing the staff from warehouses and putting out, you know, feelers to find out where it all is. we already have a good idea. we just need -- we just need the u.s. government to authorize us being able to deliver it to frontline units but because we don't have visibility, u.s. government is not -- is not coordinating directly with -- with my organization. i think they -- they -- i think they are quite cagey. this constant, constant fear of escalation has caused paralysis up and down the u.s.' chain of command. you know, it is sad for me as -- >> that's what -- >> can i just finish? it's really sad for me as a former marine. >> of course. >> in the military and to see my open country paralyzed in this way, we keep backing down, p backpeddling ask it doesn't matter how big a military you have unless you have the resolve
11:13 pm
to use it, at times for the good. pituitary way, it is minimum risk, then it's useless and every time he back peddle, putin fills the gap. main, how -- how many already lessons do we need and yet when people stand up to him, he himself pack peddles. remember the turks shot down a aircraft in 2013, putin wanted to talk. remember when his mercenaries were killed in syria, i believe 20 s 2017 or 2018, again he back peddled and packed down. why do we not learn from this? >> when it comes to escalation -- had it comes to escalation, how much worse can it get than raping women and children and then burning them alive? >> yeah, it's like i -- it -- you know, yoent to get too emotional about this. but yoez of us used to wear the uniform for the united states -- a lot of us, deeply disgusted by our country's foreign policy from the -- from the retreat
11:14 pm
from after ghanistan to what is happening here, we seem to be running way from our allies. it really is time -- it really is time to show some resolve, show some backbone. it doesn't matter what the president sighs about admiring ukrain ukrainian people from afar-let i feel shame and contempt for our policies here. no-fly zone. we have got the largest, most powerful air force in the world. we have deposit the most sophisticated systems. we could put down audio no-fly zone in a heartbeat here. and we don't have to put it over russian-occupied territory if they are so scared of escalation. but are we that scared? it's -- and what do allies think? you know, thinking say, if it comes to nato, we are twlal going do something. but you got -- you can't blame them if in the back of their minds, yeah, is that really the case? why hasn't the president visit kyiv? you know, world leaders -- local
11:15 pm
leaders, even -- even boris jontsen has been to kyiv. why is the president not here if he cares so much about it? is there anything more important happening in the world? >> colonel, lot of questions. a lot of issues raised there. and um, you know, there are -- there are reasons why joe biden hasn't been here, whole lot of stuff, you raise some very important points there. out of time. if you can make it quick, sure. >> yeah. okay. the group, please look at what we doing. with when we are prepared to assist with evacuation civilians, it is a no-lose situation for u.s. government/western community. thank you, john. >> thank you, sir. just this into cnn. ukraine deputy prime minister says foyer evacuation buses did manage to leave mariupol wednesday through that humanitarian corridor. officials earlier said a large
11:16 pm
evacuation effort from the besieged city did not go as planned. they hoped to evacuate a lot more women, ellerly, and children. those are expected in zaporizhzhia in southern eastern ukraine nae now. when we come back, the leader battle just is not over yet. u.s. justice department is appealing a judge's decision to strike down mask mandates on public transportation. the reason behind that move ahead. also, mass testing, endless lockdowns, and angry residents. china's covid policy, kim brunhuber will have that in a moment andnd a live report from shanghai. it was so easy. [laughs] we'll drive you happy atat carvana.
11:17 pm
11:18 pm
11:19 pm
11:20 pm
welcome back, everyone. well, the u.s. justice department is appealing monday's court ruling, striking down the mask mandate for public transportation. airlines and transit agencies moved quickly to make masks optional. the white house waited for guidance from the centers for disease control, before taking any action. the cdc's open map shows a low risk of covid across the country. so, there may be confusion as to
11:21 pm
why the agency is pushing to keep a mandate that was going to expire in two weeks, anyway. white house' press secretary jen psaki explains the reasoning. >> that is important for two reasons. one, because we think it is entirely reasonable, as does incident of justice, health experts most importantly, and our administration to be able to have time to evaluate. but also, because they want to fight to ensure the cdc's authority and ability to put in manu dates in the future remains intact. >> cnn legal analyst jeffrey toobin says the appeal only adds to the existing done fusion ab confusion about mask mandates. >> i think the technical-legal term for what is going on here is a mess. um, there are so many contradictory and -- and puzzling things going on here. um, the -- the -- to -- to add
11:22 pm
yet more, you know e the biden administration is appealing this order but not asking for a stay. so there is no case will be revolved before may 3rd. >> a new poll finds a majority of i say adults favor mask requirements for traveling on planes, trains, and public transit. only 24% oppose the mandate. and 20% were neutral on the issue. the poll was conducted just before the judge struck down the mandate. shanghai reported more than 18,000 new covid cases wednesday, and eight new deaths with officials claiming all those who died had serious-underlying health conditions. but anger and frustration are growing among those still under lockdown with some residents refusing to get pcr testing and cnn's kristie lu stout joins nous live from hong kong with more on this. good to see you, so with cases
11:23 pm
turning is the covid turning? >> shanghai appears to approximate turning the corner. earlier today, authorities announced 18,500 new cases of covid-19 down from the previous day. shanghai thurts announced two districts achaefbed zero casings of covid at community level and there ever reports tesla has re-opened its production facility in shanghai after it was suspended over three weeks. that being said, shanghai is not giving up on zero covid. millions of residents are still under lockdown, and audio fresh new mandatory mass testing campaign is underway and there is significant pushback. we ever been monitoring social meed dwra to see that pushback and want to share a couple examples with you. the first example is this. you see a wechat conversation. this involves neighbors, rez tents of a building in shanghai. when discussing the topic whether they are willing to go outside to do a government-mandated pcr test,
11:24 pm
they say they are not willing to oh do so. this additional example i want to schhare with you is notices people posting outside the doors of their homes and in these notices, they are basically saying, look, i have already tested with a rapid an anti-gen test, i don't need to do a government pcr test outside. residents of shanghai are fed ip, frustrated, angry over inadequate access to food, inadequate access to medical care, family spraelgzs which have been reported, children, as well as elderly being tested for covid and then taken to quarantine. they are also fed up with uncertainty after weeks and weeks of lockdown, there is sill no end in sight, rosemary. >> absolutely. and in hong kong where you are, what is the latest on the flight pans there with more carriers being hit with suspensions and
11:25 pm
an effort contain the virus? >> rosemary, the list of temporary banned airlines just gets locker and longer. covid-19 cases may be falling here but it is still extremely difficult to fly in and out of the city. hong kong kong government authorities have temporarily banned for seven days a growing list of passengers who have inadequate health documentation. let's bring up the updated list of suspended airlines for you and in this list, you will see a lot of familiar names. you will see singapore airlines. you will sica tar, malaysia airlines, two two names from the list from yesterday, thai airways and emirates and there is a lot of frustration in hong kong and those that want to travel from overseas to hopg kong about this. this is the third year of the pandemic and still, rosemary, hong kong remains virtually sealed off, locked away from the rest of the world. back to you. >> just amazing. kristie lu stout from hong kong,
11:26 pm
many thanks. a billionaire russian who founded one of the country's biggest dip dij tall banks is lashing out what he calls the insane war in ukraine after he was slapped international sanctions. a live report from london just ahead.
11:27 pm
♪ ♪ ♪i'm so defensive,♪ ♪i got bongos thumping in my chest♪ ♪and something tells me they don't beat me♪ ♪ ♪ ♪he'd better not take the ring from me.♪ we have to be able to repair the enamel on a daily basis. with pronamel repair toothpaste,
11:28 pm
we can help actively repair enamel in its weakened state. it's innovative. my go to toothpaste is going to be pronamel repair. before i went to aspen dental, i had a lot of infection going on and i was having extractions done on a traditional, regular basis. when terry first came in, he wanted a long term solution, and that's something we were able to offer him. their care, their consideration, their empathy, all of that. i can't say enough about. absolutely hands down,
11:29 pm
aspen dental changed my life. at aspen dental, our team of denture experts will do anything to make you smile. schedule your complimentary denture consultation today.
11:30 pm
when it comes to tech, everyone wants the next best thing. now with xfi complete from xfinity, you can get updated wifi technology with the new tech upgrade program. plus, protection from cyber threats at home and now on the go. so staying up to date is easier than ever. you look great by the way. right? unbeatable internet. made to do anything so you can do anything. only xfinity will upgrade your tech after 3 years for a more reliable connection. get that and more with xfi complete. upgrade today. the russian row treat from
11:31 pm
areas around the ukrainian capital continues to reveal atrocities suffered by ukrainians ask ukraine yas who survived the onslaught, now speaking out about what they endured. cnn's phil black has their story. >> reporter: andre says his life will be forever split in two, before and after the day the russians came. he remembers the skies over his home in hostomel, near kyiv, suddenly swarming with dozens of attack helicopters. he says they fly in a low formation, like they were on parade. and soon after he say, russian ground forces approached his home. this is re says they hoopened fe from a distance. an explosive lound land lanned close by, fracturing his leg. shrapnel piercing much of of his boud but he was luck kri, he got to rusout before the russians w
11:32 pm
the outside. many were deliberately killed during the occupation. >> reporter: if i had not been wounded, i would have been shot too, he says. he also survived russia's occupation but at great cost. the city wiz shocked by the russian numbered, andf firepowe that rolled into a tiny village northeast of the capital. so many tanks passed, he says, so much ammunition, every house had 20 soldiers occupying it, inclulging the house where he, his neighbors, ask family were sheltering. they stayed in the basement. the russians stayed above. one night he says four drunk soldiers pushed open the basement door ask screamed, everyone out by the count ten or
11:33 pm
all will approximate killed. he says women were screaming, children crying and as he was the last one through the door, he was blasted from behind with a shotgun. he says nothing was lieft of th leg or bones destroyed, just a puddle of blood in minutes. some two days later, some russian soldiers helped him get to hospital. he still thinks they're beasts, not people. the russian' invasion of areas around kyiv, violently interrupted and ended many people's lives, and some with would somehow survive brutal, intimate encounters leaving them forever changed. phil black, cnn, ukraine. >> tensions boil over wednesday as finance ministers from the world's 20 largest economies met in washington. canadian minister shared a photo of western officials, who walked
11:34 pm
out of a session when the russian delegate started to speak. u.s. treasury secretary janet y yellen took part in that boycott. she said there can be no business ooze usual for russia in the global economy. as one of the russian oligarchs is speaking out against the war calling it insane. the billionaire founder of a big-russian digital bank says the west should offer vladimir putin a way out. cnn claire se bran chas following this for us from london. that walkout by the g20 meeting by the u.s. and other dell dates there. that was a powerful symbol and also indication of what is in store for russia when it comes to these meetings? >> yeah, john, increasing isolation. it cements, according to white house press secretary, russia's pariah status on the global stage. it was expected janet yellen said she would not be attending sessions that included russia at the g20 but of course she was joined by others. isn't total isolation from
11:35 pm
russia. still the support from the likes of china and india, so err likely to see enough consensus within that group. so for the moment i think you are looking at the division and these -- these sort of symbolic acts that -- that are designed to show russia that it -- that it's not welcome according to some nations but combine that with what we heard from the russian former oligarch, he has lost a lot of wealth since the start of the war. he had a digital bank. really striking in his statement on instagram pause he overtly criticizes the russian army. he says how could -- how could the army be good and everything else in the country is nepotism, sycophancy, and we really haven't heard much from russian oligarchs who have spoken up. he does mention putin in his post, asking the west to give him an effort to save face and asked them to show more humanity, and be more rational so that was interesting.
11:36 pm
it is unlikely, though, to move the needle. i think it is worth remembering there are few people in russia who hold any sway over vladimir putin. it was interesting the exile of a former russian oligarch said to cnn's fareed zakaria russia is not an oligarchy, it is a dictatorship. so significantly very unlikely to provide much of a deterrent. >> yeah, also sim poe lizm coming from wimbledon and belarus as well. lot of moves to isolate russia increasingly. claire, thanks for the update there. claire sebastian reporting live for us in london. when we come back, british prime min stir is getting a bit of a break. rosemary church has details on the festering party gate scandal and the push to punish him, which is moving forward. isn'n'? i saved d 25%. booyah. you protected your casa? sure did. and the frank tank? you know it.t. and now you're relaxing. i'm working from home. sure you are.
11:37 pm
alright i see a lot of head nods. let's circle back tomorrow. you weren't kidding. save up to 25% when you bundle home and auto with allstate. click or call for a quote today.
11:38 pm
11:39 pm
11:40 pm
xfinity mobile runs on america's most reliable 5g network, but for up to half the price of verizon, so you have more money for more stuff. this phone? fewer groceries. this phone? more groceries! this phone? fewer concert tickets. this phone? more concert tickets. and not just for my shows. switch to xfinity mobile for half the price of verizon. that's a savings of over $500 a year. switch today. welcome back, everyone. a short time ago, british prime
11:41 pm
minister arrived in western india for two days of talks. the big focus on their visit? jobs and ukraine. but back home, many lawmakers and voters are not ready to forgive and forget the party-gate scandal. in the whicoming hours, there cd be a vote on whether to investigate claims that boris johnson misled parliament about illegal locke down peerts parties the at government buildings. he apologized twice in two days for violating covid rules by he has rejected calls to resign, and stopped short of admitting he broke the law. he is now vowing to, quote, get on with the job. >> we're gonna get on delivering for the british people. making sure -- making sure that we power out of the -- the problems that covid has left us. more people in work than there were before the pandemic, mr. speaker. fixing our energy problems, and leading the world in standing up
11:42 pm
in the aggression of vladimir putin. >> john rendam is the chief political commentator for the indpenlt and joins me now from london. good to have you us. >> hello, rosemary. >> so, despite all boris skronsen's efforts to put this party date scandal behind him, it isn't going away but the government is trying to delay a vote on investigation into whether he misled mps about his lockdown parties. how long can he hold off a vote? and will his defense of knowingly misleading work out for him? >> well, he's -- he is not trying to delay the vote. there will be a vote today in the house commons. but he is tried to delay the referral of his conduct to the privileges committee, which is committee of mps. he doesn't -- he doesn't want them to be investigating this question of whether he misled the house of commons so he has put down an amendment which he is asking mps to vote for, which
11:43 pm
will -- which will delay any referral to that committee until after the police have completed their inquiries. now, of course, by -- by deferring it, by putting it off to another day, he is hoping -- he is hoping things will have moved on by then. >> yeah. ministers insist that a vote should actually wait until the police have finished their investigation and civil servant sue gray has published her report but when this does eventually happen, some conservative mps have threatened to vote wp opposition or abstain. what does that signal to you as calls for boris johnson grow to resign? >> a lot of them don't want to put their name to a vote in defense of the prime minister. because they know that the labor party is going to use that -- they will put the -- the labor party will put their names on leaflets. this mp voted to block an
11:44 pm
inquiry into the prime minister's conduct. and they won't want do that. backbench mps who have nothing to lose don't want to come to the aid of the prime minister in this way and so the government is very worried about the turnout for that vote. although they got a majority at 77 so they will win comfortably anyway. >> on his flight to india for that two-day official visit, mr. johnson said he will fight the next general election buld not say in there were any circumstances under which he would resign. what does that tell you about where he sees ail this going? >> the prime minister has to say they will fight the next general election, until -- until they are forced -- forced to say otherwise as tony blair was. uh, you know, it is not the end for boris johnson yet, at all. he came very close, i think, to losing his job in january. some of the mps were with very
11:45 pm
worried that he was a -- a big-vote loser for them. they have recovered somewhat in the opinion polls since then, and the obvious alternative prime minister, the chancellor, his stock has really tumbled following a disastrous mini budget when he announced last month and revelations about his wife not paying tax on her international income in this country. so boris johnson's got -- got some time but he is obviously very worried about how long conservative mps will give him. >> and of course he has said he just wants to get on with the job but the public is not happy with what he's been doing. and they haven't forgeten about party gate but it sounds like you think he can sort of work through this, and eventually people will forgive and forget? >> i don't know about fordpichbing and forgetting but i mean, the public -- if -- if you ask the public whether a
11:46 pm
politician should resign, they will usually say yes. and they usually think the politicians are up to no good. at the moment, boris johnson's stock is low ask the public are really not at all impressed by him. but when it comes to a general election, you are asking people to choose between one prime minister and a different one and in those circumstances, i think p boris johnson will do rather better if as the next election approaches and it's -- it's two years away, after all. and anything can happen in two years. but if -- if as that election approaches, it is obvious that boris johnson's going to lose it for the conservatives, then i think the mps will do the ruthless thing gee place him but at the moment, they don't have anyone to replace him with. >> many thank. still to come. a fiery debate in france, as the two candidates in sunday's presidential runoff come face to face. that's next. she'll say she's got goals.
11:47 pm
and since e she's got goals, she might need help reachihing them, and so she'll l get some help from fidelity, and at f fidelity, someone wil help her create a plan for all her goals, which means suzie will be feeling so good about that plan, she can just enjoy right now. that's the planning effect, from fidelity.
11:48 pm
allergies don't have to be scary.
11:49 pm
spraying flonase daily stops your body from overreacting to allergens all season long. psst! psst! flonase all good.
11:50 pm
11:51 pm
in the coming hours maureen le pen is expected to hold a final rally in advance of sunday's election. on wednesday they went head to head on a tv debate that saw them clashing over russia and the economy. cnn's melissa bell has the debate from paris. >> reporter: it was the only debate that had them pitted against each other. centrist, noblist emmanuel macron. on the other that of far right nationalist marie le pen.
11:52 pm
the debate began on questions of concern. >> translator: here again i must be the spokesperson of the french people because, mr. macron, i heard you and your government. you are delighted to have french people's purchasing power. to me, i only saw french people who told me they can't make it anymore. they can't get by. they can't make ends meet at the end of the month. >> translator: i am proud that altogether we have made it possible to create 1.2 million pay slips. because i was looking at your program, the 22 measures, there is not even the word unemployment in it which is striking. >> reporter: the war in ukraine is a word that has loomed large and featured heavily in wednesday night's debate with emmanuel macron attacking
11:53 pm
maureen le pen on her relationship with vladimir putin. >> translator: you still haven't paid back that loan. >> translator: it's quite long, mr. macron. we are a poor party but this is not shameful. >> translator: i never thought it was shameful. my problem, mrs. le pen, i hope you'll recognize this is creating dependence. >> your loan was not contracted with any bank but with russia but with the interests, power everyone will be able to verify it so you need to own up to it. that's all. own up to it, mrs. le pen. >> reporter: from one area, maureen le pen has come back a bit still wants to see europe reform in order that it becomes a much looser alliance with sovereign nations. >> translator: let me say to
11:54 pm
emmanuel macron there is no european sovereignty because there is no sovereign people. you've done it by replacing the french fry. >> translator: changing a club by reducing your membership fee, by saying i choose my rules. well, either the others follow you because that's europe. there are 27 of us around the table or you go your own way and what you describe in your program sounds like going your own way. the second thing you propose is an alliance with russia, which is amongst your priorities. it's always in your program. it's amazing. >> reporter: in 2017 maureen le pen was seen to have rost the election. this time she spent a couple of days preparing. if the polls have been widening
11:55 pm
in favor of emmanuel macron, it seems there is everything to play for when france goes to the polls and it's very much at stake. melissa bell, cnn, paris. actor johnny depp returned to the stabbed inside a virginia court in his defamation case against ex-wife amber heard. he described his relationship. depp said an argument between the two in 2015 ended with him seeking medical care. >> she threw the large bottle and it made contact and shattered everywhere and then i looked down and realized that the tip of my finger had been
11:56 pm
severed. >> depp is suing her for $50 million over a 2018 washington post op ed in which she wrote about her experience with domestic abuse. even though she didn't name him, depp claims it cost him film work. thank you so much for your company. i'm rosemary church. we will go back to john vause live as cnn's coverage continues.
11:57 pm
stuff. we love stuff. and there's some really great stuff out there. but i doubt that any of us
11:58 pm
will look back on our lives and think, "i wish i'd bought an even thinner tv, found a lighter light beer, or had an even smarter smartphone." do you think any of us will look back on our lives and regret the things we didn't buy? or the places we didn't go? ♪ i'd go the whole wide world ♪ ♪ i'd go the whole wide world ♪
11:59 pm
12:00 am
this is cnn breaking news. hello. welcome to our viewers in the united states and around the world. i'm john vause live in lviv, ukraine. coming up, negotiations continue to open up evacuation corridors for the hard-hit city mariupol. still, too, the russia

467 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on