tv CNN Newsroom Live CNN June 24, 2022 10:00pm-11:00pm PDT
10:00 pm
dr. sanjay gupta sat down with sean penn. >> do you think of your work as heroic? >> i have gotten to have a front row seat to what heroism is. when i was walking back over the border after the trip during the invasion into poland and almost every car that was lined up and almost every adult person was a woman with one or multiple children who had no interest in leaving their husbands who both by choice and also by mandate had to stay in the country from 18 to 60. you know, what's a hero? if your eyes are open, if your
10:01 pm
heart's open, boy, it's not hard to find it. >> you can find out more about his philanthropic efforts along with more this saturday night when cnn hero salutes premieres at 10:00 p.m. eastern. news continues. i want to hand it over to sarah schneider and "cnn tonight." (vo) with every generation, the subaru forester has been a leader in crash safety, working to undo the impact a crash can have on your life. which has led the forester to even be able to detect danger and stop itself. the subaru forester has earned the i-i-h-s top safety pick plus eight times. more than honda c-r-v or toyota rav-four.
10:02 pm
love. it's what makes subaru, subaru. hybrid work is here. it's there. it's everywhere. but for someone to be able to work from here, there has to be someone here making sure everything is safe. secure. consistent. so log in from here. or here. assured that someone is here ready to fix anything. anytime. anywhere. even here. that's because nobody... and i mean nobody... makes hybrid work, work better.
10:04 pm
- common percy! - yeah let's go! on a trip. book with priceline. you save more, so you can “woooo” more. - wooo. - wooo. wooooo!!!!! woohooooo!!!! w-o-o-o-o-o... yeah, feel the savings. priceline. every trip is a big deal. i'm sara snider and this is "cnn tonight." this is the scene outside the united states supreme court this evening after one of the most consequential rulings in modern history, a reversal of a precedent that has been in place for nearly 50 years. women in america no longer have a constitutional right to an
10:05 pm
abortion. a live look now at the demonstrations which have popped up around the country and earlier in the day when the supreme court decision came down reversing roe v. wade, this is what it looked like when conservatives who believe they are saving unborn children heard the decision. happiness, hugging and cheering, the opposite emotions from those who say this is just another way to control a woman and limit the choices she can make about her own life. >> the supreme court issued an illegitimate fascist ruling. this decision is an outrage. >> the fight over the issue is by no means over, but the decision is already having real world impact. tonight for the first time since richard nixon was in office abortion is now illegal in eight
10:06 pm
states -- south dakota, oklahoma, missouri, arkansas, louisiana, wisconsin, kentucky and alabama. and they will not be the only ones. between states with so-called trigger laws that were designed to go into effect for precisely this moment and states that may be able to use old, unenforced bans, more than half of the states could make abortion illegal in the coming hours, days and weeks. headlines from across the country, in new orlen's the city's only abortion clinic closed by lunchtime. in wisconsin planned parenthood saw four patients today but 70 more were sent home or had appointments for tomorrow canceled. in texas not only have clinics closed, groups that provide financial assistance to people seeking abortions for paused their funding. writing for the high courts decision 5-4 ruling justice samuel alito said, quote, roe was wrong from the start.
10:07 pm
its reasoning was exceptionally weak and decision has had consequences. roe and casey have inflamed debate and deepened division. if that section sounds familiar it's because justice alito wrote word for word the same thing in the draft opinion leaked, one strikingly similar overall to the final product. in his remarks condemning today's ruling president biden focused on the recent justices to join the court and the man who put them there. >> it's a sad day for the court and the country. now with roe gone let's be very clear, the health and life of women in this nation are now at risk. it was the three justices named by one president, donald trump, who are the core of today's decision to upend the scales of justice and eliminate a fundamental right for women in this country. >> the president also made clear
10:08 pm
he has no executive power to undo that ruling, instead putting the burden on congress to try and restore roe's protections. house republicans meanwhile aric looing at trying to get a 15-week abortion ban passed on the federal level. something kevin mccarthy tells cnn he's open to. but as of tonight the matter is now one for the states. i'm joined tonight by the president and ceo of the center for reproductive rights which represented the mississippi abortion clinic at the center of today's supreme court ruling. nancy, welcome. >> thank you. >> nancy, you've anticipated this could happen. a lot of people did after they saw that leaked document. now that it has, can you give me a sense of what that moment was like when you heard the supreme court's decision knocking down roe v. wade? what was that like for you? >> it was absolutely gut wrenching even though i intellectually knew this was the
10:09 pm
decision going to come down from the court. as soon as i saw on the scotus blog, you know, feed that the daubs decision was out and it was just uhalito's opinion it w clear it was going to be -- the clinic in mississippi at the center of this case and other abortion providers across the country and our lawyers had to be on the phone with them today talking about what the future holds because of this decision. >> can i ask you in a follow up question what does the future hold? what is the future of your fight? >> well, in the very immediate term it's going to be to try and stop these trigger laws from going into effect. 13 states have them, and they purport to say as soon as roe v. wade is overturned that they will be banning abortion, some say right away like louisiana.
10:10 pm
others say maybe ten days, two weeks. but we'll be seeking to stop those from going into effect, so stay tuned for that. also to make sure that at every level of government and every branch of government we look to both the white house and the executive branch for the full ability to use their power to keep abortion access. we look to states that are going to be able to strengthen their own laws. michigan has got a issue on the ballot, protect abortion rights this fall. that's going to be important. so we're going to be making sure state constitutions we'll be seeking to get those. many states already have constitutional protections. it's going to be really, really tough, which is why people out on the streets right now in the united states making their voices heard is so incredibly important. >> we are seeing that in plenty of spaces across the country. right now you're seeing in san francisco a very high up shot of people in the streets protesting.
10:11 pm
but i do want to talk to you about the other side of this argument. have you ever tried to understand, emphasize with the point of view many conservatives certainly take and those who are against abortions being legal that they're on the side of the unborn because the unborn cannot speak for themselves? >> the supreme court has made clear in this debate which has gone on for decades, people have strong feelings on both sides of it. but the supreme court in the roe decision -- and again, they asked this very issue 30 years ago in planned parenthood vs. casey, what do you do when there's such division of opinion? and the court has reached a compromise previously ipits decisions where it recognizes how central to a woman's health and life and future plan it is to be able to control a pregnancy and have recognized that the state could regulate some in abortion because of the
10:12 pm
interest of developing embryonic and fetal life. the court upset that today and completely removed the pregnant person's side of the equation, completely removed it. >> abortion clinics across the south and midwest have already started to close as you have mentioned. in your estimation what does this mean for some women who live in those states for their reproductive health. and for those who want an abortion, what does it mean for them? >> look, it means that people who are seeking abortion care are going to have to leave their states traveling hundreds maybe thousands of miles if they have the means to do so. now, luckily we have employers, companies stepping up and saying they're going to cover their employees ability to do that. others will rely on abortion funds, which are important to support people having to leave the state. but some aren't going to have the means to do so and they're
10:13 pm
going to be forced to carry their pregnancies to term. and the other thing people might not realize is that for women who are miscarrying, this is going to get them caught up and we already saw this in texas with its extreme ban that was previously and currently in effect, that they get caught up with not being able to get the care they need for miscarriage management because of the chilling effect of abortion bans. so as soon as you start criminalizing abortion, you're making every miscarriage possibly a crime scene, and this is why it's so clear that none of this should be part of the criminal law. it should be part of medical care, between the patient and their doctor. >> you had mentioned the trigger laws. there are already abortion bans being implemented. 13 states have those laws in place. 13 will likely follow. and conservatives are already talking about getting a federal law ban on abortions up to 15 weeks. what will be your move? because this is definitely clear that the fight is not over, and
10:14 pm
there are people who feel very deeply and strongly and have very strong convictions that they want abortion to end in this country. >> well, the vast majority as recent polls have shown, in fact we had an all-time high of people in the united states that want access to abortion to be legal. and the fight will continue. it will continue at the state level. it will continue in ballot initiatives. it will continue in the court with state constitutional protections and continue at the federal level. the president said today that the administration would be looking to protect abortion access. he referenced both medication abortion and also the ability for people to go to other states. and look, the united states is an enormous outlier to the rest of the world which has been moving forward in the last 30 years. 60 countries have liberalized their abortion laws. today we went backward, way behind the rest of the world and we're seeing outrage from around the world about this decision.
10:15 pm
>> of course the folks on the other side of this think this is a great day in america. nancy, thank you so much for taking the time to speak with us. please stick with us. in just a bit we have a passionate panel of women with very different views on the supreme court's roe v. wade decision between them. one is celebrating, the others infuriated. but first one of the most well-known political candidates in the state of georgia looking to ban abortion. stacey abrams is now going to join me in the next break.
10:16 pm
10:17 pm
we need to reduce plastic waste in the environment. that's why at america's beverage companies, our bottles are made to be re-made. not all plastic is the same. we're carefully designing our bottles to be 100% recyclable, including the caps. they're collected and separated from other plastics, so they can be turned back into material that we use to make new bottles. that completes the circle and reduces plastic waste. please help us get every bottle back. to support a strong immune system your body needs a routine. centrum helps your immune defenses every day, with vitamin c, d and zinc* season after season. ace your immune support with centrum.
10:18 pm
now with a new look! some health experts are warning that the overturning of roe versus wade will worsen maternal death rates. the u.s. already has the highest maternal mortality rate among developed nations. and black women are three times more likely to die in child birth than white women. the mortality crisis hits especially hard in the state of georgia, where the racial disparities in health care are even worse. and maternal death rates are the second highest in the united states. joining me now is stacey abrams, the democratic nominee for georgia governor. we should also mention that we invited your -- your opposite on from the republican side of things, and he declined. i want to start with what we are seeing right now from the
10:19 pm
supreme court. there are people out in droves protesting the roe versus wade decision. but there are some also out celebrating it. i want to get your reaction on today's ruling and what it will mean for the women in your state especially in your view the women of color. >> it's dangerous. it is appalling. i am angry. but i'm also committed. we know that georgia has -- our population is 33% african american. now, as you pointed out, black women face three times higher maternal mortality rate than their white counterparts. for hispanic women, it's nearly the same. and we have two of the largest populations in this state. we also are ranked near the bottom in term of access to health care. we are number two in the number of uninsured. we have a very broken health care system.
10:20 pm
we have refused to expand medicaid. our maternal mortality rates are extraordinary. we are number six in terms of infant mortality. and what all of this means is that we have a health care system that is not equipped to do the very job it should do. and now we are going to add additional pressure by not only denying women access to medical care, but we're also going to criminalize and prosecute doctors for providing that care. that is setting up a situation where georgia becomes dangerous for women. and that is untenable. >> that's a really strong statement that you are saying, your state becomes, as you put it, dangerous for women. i want to talk about a recent poll out of georgia. it shows that 68% of georgia voters oppose the supreme court's action today. 54% are also against the state's six-week abortion ban, which is sure to be reinstated. governor kemp has vowed to go further. he said he wants to outdo other governors in passing the toughest anti-abortion laws. what does that mean for your political run? and do you or any time in your
10:21 pm
life did you think that abortion should be illegal? >> let's start with that part of the question. i was very much on the side of anti-abortion through much of my upbringing. i grew up in mississippi in a very religious family, in a religious community. and i was raised to have a very uncritical eye to this question. once i really started thinking about what it meant and more importantly when i had a friend who had to confront the very real consequences of an unwanted pregnancy and i wasn't able to give any help to her, i had to re-evaluate where i stood. i understand the sincere concerns, but those are religious concerns or driven by personal morality. and that should be your choice. but abortion is a medical issue. it is about a medical decision. and there is no place in that medical decision for ideology or for politicians. and so the question of what we should do, politics is about how we make choices in a democracy. and in our country and as of today, that choice has to be made by the governors in each of our states. the governor of georgia has
10:22 pm
already said he does not care about women and their bodily autonomy. he does not care about their health because he has not only already adopted and signed into law the most restrictive abortion law in georgia's history with the restrictions at six weeks. he has said in interviews that he also supports eliminating access for incest and rape. this is someone who cannot be trusted to simply stop at the water's edge. he is going to go further and further. anyone who doubts simply has to listen to his words. for women in georgia, especially women of color in georgia, brian kemp is dangerous. he does not intend to protect women or their bodies, or worse he does not intend to give them the health care they need. he refuses to do what's right for the women of georgia. this is the same man who claims to care about women and children who was throwing away thousands of canisters of baby formula as recently as a month ago because he does not care what happens after birth. he does not care about what happens to our communities.
10:23 pm
and i would dare anyone to look at his record and to look at his rhetoric and tell me how this is someone who should be in charge of the lives of women in the state of georgia. >> i do not speak for governor kemp, but i know that he would push back to say he does very much care about women and families. you are saying in your view that when you look at some of the things that he has said and some of the legislation he's pushing for, you completely disagree. i'd like to turn to another major issue brought up by the u.s. supreme court. congress finally passed bipartisan gun reforms today, which you've called an important step. we also, though, have this ruling by the supreme court that basically says states can't really regulate, you know, guns, especially when it comes to being able to just carry them around in the streets. what do you think are the challenges going forward in georgia and the rest of the country? >> and i think this goes to my earlier point, and i appreciate the even-handedness that you're taking. but let's be clear. i'm not speaking from rhetorical
10:24 pm
space. i'm speaking from the record that we have seen in georgia. on the issue of gun violence in the state of georgia, my opponent in the face of opposition from law enforcement, eased gun laws in the state of georgia. after a massacre just a year ago. he has taken steps to make it easier for criminals to carry weapons, for those who have domestic violence convictions to carry weapons, for those who have mental health concerns to carry weapons in the streets. his hypocrisy is what i want people to look at. and what we know is that what the supreme court has done is still less than what georgia has already done. the supreme court did by rolling back new york's laws made it less safe for new yorkers but brian kemp has already done that here in the state of georgia. and my deep concern is you cannot claim to care about the people in your state and take actions using the law to limit their protection, to undercut their safety, and to place them in harm's way.
10:25 pm
that contradiction and that hypocrisy, to me, is unfathomable. and we know if you look at his record -- put rhetoric aside -- his record does not show a concern for the life and welfare of georgians. there are those he will speak up for, but too often in our state, the people who are the most vulnerable, who are the most fragile, or who are in the most need of assistance do not receive it. and whether we're talking about babies trying to get formula or women who simply want to survive, his decisions are harming them. and for communities that are afraid of gun violence, which has increased under his watch, he has made it easier to carry those weapon of violence. >> stacey abrams, i appreciate you coming on, democratic nominee for the governor of georgia. i do want to, again, extend a request from governor kemp. come on the show. we will talk through this. thank you so much for being here, stacey. >> thanks for having me. >> we're watching the scenes outside the supreme court and throughout the nation on this extraordinary night. ahead we'll look at what's next for the court as justice thomas looks at potentially reviewing
10:26 pm
other rulings. and what do democrats do after this massive defeat for reproductive rights? we'll have the conversation when "cnn tonight" returns. you need to hire. i need indeed. indeed you do. indeed instant match instantly delivers quality candidates matching your job description. visit indeed.com/hire people with plaque psoriasis, are rethinking the choices they make. like the shot they take. the memories they create. or the spin they initiate. otezla. it's a choice you can make. otezla is not a cream. it's a pill that treats plaque psoriasis differently. with otezla, you can achieve clearer skin. don't use if you're allergic to otezla. otezla can cause serious allergic reactions. it may cause severe diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. otezla is associated with an increased risk of depression. tell your doctor if you have a history of depression or suicidal thoughts or if these feelings develop. some people taking otezla reported weight loss. your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. upper respiratory tract infection and headache may occur. tell your doctor about your medicines
10:28 pm
we've been streaming all day from every room. the power and speed of this super-sonic wifi from xfinity is incredible. mom! mass speeds was my idea, remember? get minion net, with speeds of up to one minion bite per hour. [ low screaming ] but that was an epic fail. with xfi we can stream, share, swipe, like... impress your mom with super-sonic wifi. it's unbeatable internet for a more unbeatable gru. i mean, you. this is xfinity rewards. our way of showing our appreciation. with rewards of all shapes and sizes.
10:29 pm
[ cheers ] are we actually going? yes!! and once in a lifetime moments. two tickets to nascar! yes! find rewards like these and so many more in the xfinity app. are you a christian author with a book that you're ready to share with the world? get published now, call for your free publisher kit today! two precedents erased in about 20 hours. roe with the law of the land for nearly 50 years.
10:30 pm
and the new york gun law for more than a century. we watched as history was rewritten after justices who said they wouldn't dare change long-held precedent. >> it is a precedent that has now been on the books for several decades. it has been challenged. it has been reaffirmed. >> part of being a good judge is coming in and taking precedent as it stands. >> as a judge, it is an important precedent of the supreme court. by "it" i mean roe v. wade. >> a fetus is not a person. that's the law of the land. i accept the law of the land. >> we should note, before all this confidence in the supreme court had hit a historic low, down 11% from just a year ago. we have lots to talk about as i'm joined by jennifer rogers, former congresswoman, and conservative commentator, kerry sheffield. lady, ladies and gentlemen so much for being here. it is an incredibly emotional
10:31 pm
night for many people on both sides of the aisle. i'm going to start with you, jennifer. in roe v. wade, the justices said that abortion was a constitutional right. now the justices are saying it is absolutely not a constitutional right. it is now up to the states. is this the first time that the supreme court made a decision saying something was constitutional and has taken that back? >> well, it's the first time that the court has affirmatively recognized a constitutional right that it says is new or just newly discovered. so, in roe they said there is now a constitutional right to abortion, grounded in the right of privacy. that is the first time that was said. now 49 years later they said, when we reaffirmed it again and again and again across all these different supreme courts, we were wrong. we didn't mean it. we're taking it back. it's the first time that has ever happened.
10:32 pm
>> when you saw what happened, kerry, what did you think? and what do you think about this argument that this is a precedent-setting case, and you heard the justices there saying, we would not mess with precedent. precedent is precedent and we're going to leave it as is. that's not what happened today. >> i rejoiced. i felt like we finally had justice for the unborn, the pre-born children. so i felt deep gratitude this has finally been recognized after 50 years of striving and fighting for this moment. in terms of the precedent, i think what i've heard from people who work and work with these justices, they said they would respect precedent. just because you understand or respect precedent does not mean precedent should stand. in the case of plessy versus ferguson that established separate but equal, that was 1896 and it was overturned before the brown v. board of education many decades later. the precedent is no means ironclad. there is a moral weight that the
10:33 pm
person is a child should be recognized as enumerated to the states. the word, enumeration, in the constitution, which i have right here tonight -- >> i saw. >> -- it is an enumerated right states have. anything that is not enumerated to the federal government shall be with the states. and that is what we see here. >> let me ask you this. because the states are doing this -- this is now up to the states. but there are republicans trying to push forward a federal ban on abortions that are more than 15 weeks. do you agree that a federal ban should be put in place? >> well, i think what's important to just take a step back and note if you're living in california or new york or more progressive areas, nothing will change. this is where things are. >> i knew this was going to happen. >> abby -- >> so, you don't -- yes or no, do you think this should be a federal ban eventually in your mind? >> i personally prefer that but i know that people on the other side don't prefer that.
10:34 pm
that is the beauty of federalism to say that people will migrate. they will vote with their feet at the end of the day. as much as i would like to see a federal ban, i know that is politically unlikely. so, that, i think, is the best compromise. in fact ruth bader ginsburg said -- >> she did not say -- >> let me quote her. >> excuse me. >> i'm going to go to break -- >> you literally just cited a case from 1896 before women had the right to vote in this country. what happened today is absolutely horrifying. every single person in this country, including you, who's celebrating today about this overturning, you support a 12-year-old who's been raped to have to actually carry her pregnancy to term. that is what you support. you support women dying in this country if they have an atopic pregnancy because that is what will happen. >> i don't. are you putting words in my mouth. >> that is not okay. >> you're putting words in my mouth. >> let me jump in. >> i never said anything about that. >> that is what this decision is going to cause. >> hold on a second.
10:35 pm
hold on, hold on. okay. >> you're taking away my rights and supporting it is disrespectful. >> so, abby makes one point about plessy vs. ferguson and i think everyone has heard the argument that this was back in the 1800s and then 54 years later, brown versus board of education came up and a decision was made that reversed that. i do want to ask you, abby, what do you think about that particular argument? because all americans, probably at this point -- i would say most americans, think that was the right decision. and what kerry is saying is this is also a moral decision. >> well, you can have your moral decisions and your moral beliefs sincerely, your religious beliefs, your moral beliefs. you should be able to have those in this country. it is the united states of america and you should be able to act on your moral and religious beliefs. but what i am asking tonight is that people wake up in this
10:36 pm
country and respect me, respect women across this country, our choices, respect doctors. that is what this is about. literally women will die. that is what's happening. when roe, again, is being overturned today, you will have 12 year olds having to carry a rapist pregnancy to term. >> abortion is violence for an unborn child. >> forced birth is -- >> okay, so we've got the two very strong arguments and to be fair, in this country, both arguments have been so strongly put on the table. you can talk to anybody about it if they're on either side of this. you're going to get this. i do applaud you for caring so much about this issue because it is a issue that deeply affects women and ostensibly children. all right, the legal side of this. because we talked about plessy
10:37 pm
vs. ferguson, brown vs. board of education, weigh in on that argument. >> if you're going to overturn a precedent, it's supposed to be one of the fundamental foundational things that the supreme court is based on. that's what justice roberts says in his concurring opinion. he didn't want to go as far as to overturn roe versus wade because judicial restraint dictated they did not do that. but they did anyway. the difference between what happened today and what happened in brown v. board of education is plessy v. ferguson was a decision that was made that didn't -- it didn't grant a right but it didn't take away a right. >> it didn't grant a constitutional right. >> it didn't grant a constitutional right. all these years later, the court said, hey, we got that wrong when we made that decision. now all these years later with society having changed and us frankly having understood the rights -- it was a racial discrimination case, of course -- we now are making the right decision and overturning that wrong decision. but they didn't take away a right that had been granted. today, the court really goes backward. so, in other words, in brown, they're moving forward. they're moving forward with the
10:38 pm
progress of society. today, we're moving backward more than 50 years saying you had a right, women, for all those years. it was great. but guess what, it's gone now. that's moving us backwards against the will of society which is very much in favor of safe and legal abortion. >> we're going to talk about that in a minute. kerry, i'll let you weigh in on that. but not yet. we're going to go to the break real quick. we're going to stick with you. we're going to keep talking about this because this is something that has really affected everyone, not just women in this country. ♪ ♪ ♪ introducing the all-new infiniti qx60. take on your wild world in style. ♪
10:42 pm
10:43 pm
there should be some restrictions. a lot of people, when you talk to them about their feelings about it, it changes a little. but in general. so, do you think that this is the minority leading the majority? in other words, the supreme court has taken the side of the people in the minority when the majority of americans actually believe that roe should be the law of the land with the caveat of some restrictions on abortion. >> right and those restrictions are key. so, gallup has tracked this for decades. when you see there is a spectrum in term of intensity and propensity to support abortion or be pro-life, the longer the gestation period, the weaker the support for abortion becomes. so, once you hit about after the first trimester, it becomes a majority of americans who say they support restrictions on abortion. at what point is the minority leading majority to say this is a federal right. it is not a federal right. i want to quote ruth bader ginsburg. he said that the roe decision halted a political process that was moving in a -- deferred stable sentiment of the issue.
10:44 pm
you're going to have a much higher propensity in a state where i'm from, missouri, for example, which has one of these trigger laws. it's great in my home state, whereas in new york or california this is i believe the way forward and roe was a monkey wrench in this process. >> she's not the only person that brought this up. but it is clear ruth bader ginsburg thought roe should be the law of the land, even though that legal argument had been made by others. when this decision was made, it caused this tension. the states were already going this way. what do you make of this idea that a lot of people in our country when they are poll say roe should stand, even though as we talked about, there should be restrictions. it is now not the law of the land. it is up to the states. >> i think it is imperative right now that democrats, in particular, people who care about freedom, care about women and our health care, get very loud but very, very honest about what this really, really means.
10:45 pm
i mean, we've had conservatives talking about the extremes and all of that for all of these years. i remember running for office in 2018. the attacks used against me were basically saying i was ripping babies out of wombs and selling their body parts on the street corner. that's absurd. those are lies. we don't need lies. we just have facts. and the fact is right now because of the overturning of roe v. wade, again, you will have children who are raped having to carry a pregnancy to term in this country. women will die. that is what this decision means. and if you support the overturning of roe today, you support those things happening. that is the fact because that is what will happen in kentucky. that's what's going to happen in oklahoma. that is what's going to happen quite frankly in states like iowa where you're going to have these governors who are conservatives tripping over
10:46 pm
themselves just trying to get to the furthest right as they can because they want to run for president next or they want to the vice president next. that is what's going to happen. and again, women will die. >> in states -- hold on a second. >> you're inflaming and using rhetoric that is untrue -- >> come on -- >> hold on. >> i let you speak without interrupting you. you want to know the truth -- >> i am stating the facts. >> planned parenthood says it is not an abortion. >> it is an abortion. >> check with planned parenthood. >> medical care for women is -- >> we're going to leave it there, ladies. ladies, we're going to leave it there because we have another -- we have another big issue to talk about. guys, guys, guys -- let's stop here because i know what your answer is going to be. we're going to talk about another issue that came up that isn't just about abortion. it is about something justice thomas said. he made big news because if you start reading this decision, he
10:47 pm
talks about and argues that other precedent-setting cases should by be revisited like contraception, like gay marriage. i've got to ask you -- and i'm going the ask this to all of you but first to kerry because you're the legal mind here. does this hurt the legitimacy of the supreme court? >> well, it seems to. i mean -- >> not kerry, i'm sorry. jess. >> their approval ratings are certainly way, way down. part of it is the inconsistency. we talk about states' rights and yesterday came out with this big decision. states, you would like to do what you want with conceal carry but we're not going to let you because everyone has a right to carry whatever they want outside of the home. today the court goes in the opposite direction and says states no longer can do what you want -- or you can do what you want with respect to abortion. there's no federal right. so, some of it is the inconsistency. some of the it is this flat out -- at least he's honest -- statement by justice thomas
10:48 pm
saying, we're not done. there is no principled legal distinction between abortions right to privacy and the gay marriage, the same sex sexual conduct right to privacy, even the contraception right to privacy. these are based on the same thing the court has now said no longer exists. people don't like that. people don't want to think that their right to go out and get contraception even as a married couple can be taken away from them. they say abortion is different. why? because abortion is a tough moral question. it's a moral issue. >> but the court is supposed to be doing the moral question. >> do you know what else is a moral question for a lot of people. contraception. gay rights. the same people will find serious moral question with those things too. thomas is telling us where he wants to go. this is not the roberts' court anymore. this is the thomas and alito court and they're going to get some of those people on to take
10:49 pm
away other rights too. >> i know you agree with this court a lot of conservatives do, most conservatives do. abby, i know where you stan. i know where you stand. we will continue this conversation over the next days and weeks. thank you for being here and so knowledgeable and passionate. we're going to have someone coming up, a unique perspective really on this week's action on gun violence legislation in congress and the supreme court. i'll be joined by a doctor who has not only seen the crisis in the emergency room. but he is also a survivor himself of gun violence. that is coming up next. um, oh wow. um, the future is, uh, what's ahead of us. i don't get it. yeah. maybe this will help. so now we're in the present. and now... we're in the future. the all-electric chevy bolt euv with available super cruise™ for hands-free driving. - dad. - yeah? do fish get thirsty? eh. find new answers. find new roads.
10:50 pm
chevrolet. we need to reduce plastic waste in the environment. that's why at america's beverage companies, our bottles are made to be re-made. not all plastic is the same. we're carefully designing our bottles to be 100% recyclable, including the caps. they're collected and separated from other plastics, so they can be turned back into material that we use to make new bottles. that completes the circle and reduces plastic waste. please help us get every bottle back.
10:51 pm
oh, hey. buying a car from vroom is so easy, all you need is a phone and a finger. just go to vroom.com, scroll through thousands of cars. then, tap to buy. that's it. no sales speak. no wasted time. just, straight up great cars. right from your phone to your driveway. go to vroom.com and pick your favorite. wooo. oh yeah, she digs it. buy your car on vroom.com vroom. get in. i've got moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. now, there's skyrizi. 3 out of 4 people achieved 90% clearer skin at 4 months, after just 2 doses. skyrizi may increase your risk of infections and lower your ability to fight them. before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tuberculosis. tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms such as fever, sweats, chills, muscle aches, or coughs, or if you plan to, or recently received a vaccine. ♪ nothing is everything ♪ talk to your dermatologist about skyrizi. learn how abbvie could help you save.
10:52 pm
at bath fitter, every quality bath starts with quality people. our consultants help you choose from hundreds of bath options so we fit your style. our installers complete your work in as little as a day so we fit your schedule. our manufacturing team custom crafts your bath so we fit your standards, and it's guaranteed for life. when you can trust the people who create your new bath, it just fits. bath fitter. visit bathfitter.com to book your free consultation. congress just did what many thought was unthinkable. they passed a bipartisan gun bill. this just a day after the supreme court expanded access to firearms. the concern now is about how these actions will affect the rise in gun violence. my next guest knows the i want
10:53 pm
emergency general surgery at johns hopkins. doctor, i really appreciate you coming in on this day. >> thanks so much for having me, sarah. >> first of all, i want to explain a little bit about your story. you don't just treat people and you are not just familiar people who have injuries ask sometimes die from being shot. you, yourself, experienced it. can you tell us what that was like for you? yeah. i mean, so look, i come to this conversation as someone who, as a 17-year-old high school student, went from a healthy teenager to collateral damage after i was nearly killed when i was shot in the throat with a .38 caliber bullet. and i think, you know, when something like that happens, you know, for me at least, it inspired me to go into medicine, and inspired me to panic a
10:54 pm
trauma surgeon because i was trying to give other people the same second chance that i was given. and i think, you know, sarah, as time progressed, i started to realize that, you know, we need to be thinking beyond our trauma center, beyond the operating room. because as good of a trauma surgeon that i think i am, as incredible as my team is, the reality is the best medical treatment is prevention and that's why we have been working at this intersection of medicine, public health, ask public policy to try to make that happen. >> can i ask you what it is that we all, you know, who are not dealing with this kind of trauma, of people coming in with gunshot wounds, what are you seeing? and what are other doctors seeing around the country, whether they are in rural places where there isn't care close by or whether they are in big cities, like chicago or new york or oakland or, you know, los angeles, and they have large numbers of people who are getting shot on a regular basis. what kind of injuries? what are we missing?
10:55 pm
what kind of things happen to the body? >> well so, i think, you know, let me just, first, say had we talk about this, we often talk about this as it relates to the mass shootings, right? but what we, as healthcare professionals, as trauma surgeons see, is the everyday toll of gun violence. and i can tell you, you know, it's operating on children that have been shot because of an unlocked, you know, and loaded weapon. it's having to deliver a baby in a pregnant mom that was shot and killed. it's trying to operate on high school students that are bleeding, and have pulverized bone and ripped arteries because of assault weapons. it's a variety of these spectrums, and every day in cities like palate more ask chicago and philadelphia, we have young black men that are being killed on our streets. and so, we have a responsibility to kind of elevate and tell those stories because we, as healthcare professionals, are seeing this every day. and i will tell ya, i -- when he were in the senate the other night getting ready to witness. >> we should mention that. you were there in the senate when the senate was passing this bill.
10:56 pm
>> yeah. >> what was that moment like? because most people said nothing's going to be done. 19 children slaughtered, blown to bits an ar-style rifle and nobody cares just like when sandy hook happened. and then, something did happen. what do you think about the legislation? >> i think it's -- let me just first say i think it's historic. i think it's historic and i think it's the first step, right? like any complex public-health problem, we need a variety of issues that is going to tackle this. and when i was sitting there, you know, in the senate committee hearing waiting to be ushered into the gallery, i looked around and i saw, you know, survivors, right? people that had lost their children. children that had lost their parents. right? people that had been shot themselves. all, in this room, waiting for
10:57 pm
this historic moment. for nearly 30 years, right, we have been begging the senate and congress to pass meaningful, common-sense laws. >> do you think this is meaningful? >> i do think it was meaningful. >> but more needs to happen? is that kind of where you are? >> exactly. more needs to happen and i tell you what. we saw both democrats and republicans come together on this. the commonality that exists in america is tremendous and i think that sometimes doesn't get seen. >> absolutely. >> thanks so much for having me, sarah. >> all right. we'll be right back. (music) who said you have to starve yourself to lose weight? who said you can't do dinner? who said only this is good? and this is bad? i'm doing it my way. meet plenity. an fda -cleared clinically proven weight management aid for adults with a bmi of 25-40 when combined with diet and exercise. plenity is not a drug - it's made from naturally derived building blocks and helps you feel fuller and eat less. it is a prescription only treatment and is not for
10:58 pm
10:59 pm
135 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d3a69/d3a697250bfddce49655da574ef6f433d2337ffa" alt=""