tv Smerconish CNN September 10, 2022 6:00am-7:00am PDT
6:00 am
♪ >> a fanfare of trumpeters king charles iii is formally proclaimed britain's new monarch. i'm michael smerconish with cnn's continuing special coverage of the death of queen elizabeth. this hour the new king is expected to hold audiences at buckingham palace. we'll go straight to that when it happens.
6:01 am
charles' ascension to the throne marks a pivotal moment for the united kingdom. it's facing a potential breakup scotland braces for independence. and uncertain world after leaving the eu. max foster is at buckingham palace. max, i show enjoyed your commentary. you've been doing a great job. what is occurring at this particular moment? >> reporter: audiences at buckingham palace, so we're into the more mundane matters, if you like, after a lot of the pomp and ceremony where the king has to meet all the key people in the state and have meetings with them in order to govern over this state. look at the crowds. today the barriers have gone up. the roads are being closed. they're preparing for the massive state funeral which president biden confirmed he will be going to. we could see all the seniors heads of state from all around the world coming in. i know president putin enjoyed his visit to london. will he be allowed to come under sanctions is a big question. president xi enjoyed his state
6:02 am
visit to the united kingdom. the thing about the queen, she rose above politics. she was the most revered head of state in the world, i would argue, certainly the longest serving. so we're gearing up to a massive state event. i think something of the likes we have never seen before. >> so on that issue of the way in which she was always able to be elevated from the politics of the day, must he now comport himself differently say than he did on matters of public policy as the prince of wales? >> as the prince of wales, he professionalized what it was to be heir to the throne. he had his playboy years early on, but many of his predecessors were playboys up until the time they took the throne. that wasn't the case for charles. he very early on set up the prince's trust and committed to issues like climate change, to religious tolerance, to youth unemployment. these were issues that he has nurtured for decades and cares so deeply about them he would
6:03 am
write to ministers about them. he was accused of meddling in politics. his view was that he was allowed to express opinions while he wasn't on the throne. but once he reached the throne, he would rise above politics in the same way his mother did. so we never knew any of the queen's opinions about anything beyond resources, frankly. she always kept a straight face and never knew where she was. we were able to project our own thoughts on to her. she was a mirror. charles won't be that because we know he's had opinions, but he made very clear in his address to the nation last night that the issues he cares deeply -- he cares so deeply about he will now leave to other people, so he has to redefine himself apolitical independent head of state. that's his big challenge now. even to the senior figures that he's meeting in the palace behind me today. >> so, as he's about to receive the archbishop of canterbury, i wanted to ask max foster, what does it mean to be defender of the faith?
6:04 am
i keep hearing these references made to this role of the king of england as being defender of the faith. >> reporter: so the king has many roles. they are head of the armed forces. they are a branch of parliament. they are also head of the judiciary, head of the commonwealth, but also head of church of england. so the king is the supreme governor of the church of england and defender of the faith. there's an interesting moment today where we had -- where the accession council and the first thing that charles did was guarantee the independence of the church of scotland. so he isn't the head of the church of scotland. in scotland, church and state are separated, but because of history, there's a huge sensitivity around that and he assured the church of scotland they would remain independent. this is part of all the boxes that needed to be ticked today. what we had the accession council was an unbelievable
6:05 am
moment, quite plain television pictures you could argue. but this accession council goes right back to the early days of monarchy, more than 1,000 years and never before has the public been allowed in. this is the moment where the british establishment endorsed effectively the new king and then that endorsement is proclaimed to the nation afterwards on the balcony there. that moment there, saint james palace, the oldest palace, the most revered palace arguably. so it was declared to the nation and those declarations continue now in the nations but also in the realms around the world. so that was a huge moment. all the formalities are now ticked off and he's now king of the united kingdom, head of the commonwealth and all of those things, but it's a complex role. >> max, from this side of the pond, and just looking at the imagery from cnn, it looks like the crowds are building. over the span of the next week, what do you think will be the best opportunity for public
6:06 am
parties snags i have in my mind, of course, that scene of diana's coffin, the envelope, the word mummy, and the throngs and throngs of people. when will there be the moment for public participation? >> so people are coming down here, laying flowers. they don't want all the flowers to be gathered up outside the palace, so what they're doing slightly different this year is they're creating a garden of remembrance in the big park next to palace. they're taking all the flowers there and what you'll see is a sea of flowers developing. that will be quite profound. if i think back to the most comparable moment, although not nearly on the scale of this, diana died, there was a sea of flowers, people standing around silently looking at the nowers and occasionally you would hear someone wailing. i think that's the place where people come to get therapy effectively in a situation like this. but over the course of the next few days, and we're getting details of this confirmed right
6:07 am
now because the king has to sign everything off, i expect the king to travel around the nations and to meet as many people as he can. so there will be moments there. but all building up to the state funeral, the exact date of which we don't have. but probably in just over a week's time. and there will be processions. so what i expect to see is, you know, we'll have this incredible moment where the queen's body will lie in state in westminster. and people will be queueing up, have an opportunity to pass the coffin and they are planning for miles and miles and miles of queues. so that's going to be an opportunity i think later on next week. then we have the point where the casket is taken to westminster abby for the funeral. then there will be a procession after that all the way to windsor where the queen will be laid to rest alongside her parents and prince philip. the moment you're talking about with diana is really that procession from westminster abby to windsor.
6:08 am
and that will be in just over a week's time. >> max, final question, if i may, i know those residences only as a tourist wood. is it clear to you as an expert where everyone will live? >> no. what we had in recent years -- so the way the structure works is that each principle as they're called will have their own household. we did until relatively recently have four household. the sussexs had their own household attached to buckingham palace and kensington palace, now prince and princess of wales. clarence house, which is charles and camilla and they had buckingham palace the queen. we have two households and many residences. i don't know how it's going to play out. i do know that charles' favorite home is high grove, his country house but he now has balmoral, buckingham palace, clarence house. william is keen, i think, to
6:09 am
keep slim down next in line throne. will he move? i don't think he will. he's very committed to kensington palace. there are empty residences. the other big question is what happens to windsor castle, which is where the queen always liked to be. so potentially william could move in there. he has a house on the grounds at the moment, but buckingham palace, i don't think prince charles necessarily that fond or looking forward to living in buckingham palace. we wonder if he might make that a headquarters for the monarchy, functional place, perhaps for conferences. i think my personal view that might be damaging in the sense that these crowds, they come here. why do they come here? they come here as they look to see if the monarchs flag is flying above. might we see the monarch go in and out and see the curtains twitch. in terms of numbers this is the biggest tourist attraction in the uk. they come here because they think it's a living, breathing monarchy. so i wonder what charles will do there. but he would have decided
6:10 am
everything years ago. we'll get a sense in the coming weeks and months. >> it's funny you say that because i remember taking the tour of buckingham palace and thinking, we're unlikely to see much of anything, but frankly it was tremendous. i was stunned by just how much of that massive edifice you actually do get to see. max, thank you so much. i really appreciate your expertise. >> thank you. still to come, more than a dozen united states presidents came and went during her 70-year rule. she met with all but one of them. so what was the special relationship like between the queen and these leaders of her country's former colony? and her passing comes at a rocky time for the monarchy and harry and meghan bailing, prince andrew under a cloud of scandal, young people, young brits not sharing the affinity for the crown of their parents. it's been a rocky time for democracy in america. will england and america post-elizabeth survive as we know them? brings me to this week's
6:11 am
poll question at smerconish.com, which is more secure, american democracy or the british monarchy? go vote. ♪ striving to reach the ultimate goal of zero poverty takes more than everyone's hopes and dreams. at citi, it tas a financial commitment to companies who empower peopleo lift themselves up. at citi, it tas a financial it takes funding and building on our know-how to help communities grow. that's how citi is helping create a better future by committing one trillion dollars in sustainable finance by 2030. because it takes everything to reach zero poverty. ♪ ♪ it's time for the biggest sale of the year, on the sleep number 360 smart bed. it senses your movements and automatically adjusts to keep you both comfortable. our smart sleepers get 28 minutes more restful sleep per night. don't miss the final days where all smart beds are on sale. save 50% on the sleep number 360
6:12 am
6:13 am
most people saw 90% clearer skin at 16 weeks. the majority of people saw 90% clearer skin even at 5 years. tremfya® is the first medication of its kind also approved for adults with active psoriatic arthritis... ...and it's 6 doses a year after 2 starter doses. serious allergic reactions may occur. tremfya® may increase your risk of infections and lower your ability to fight them. tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms or if you had a vaccine or plan to. emerge tremfyant®. with tremfya®... ask your doctor about tremfya® today. enjoy two pancakes, two eggs your way, and two pieces of bacon for only $5. the two by two by two from ihop. hurry in and enjoy this deal for a limited time. download the app and earn free food with every order.
6:14 am
some people have minor joint pain, plus high blood pressure. and since pain relievers may affect blood pressure, they can't just take anything for their pain. tylenol® is the #1 dr. recommended pain relief brand for those with high blood pressure. if you have questions on whether tylenol is right for you, talk to your doctor.
6:15 am
for most of us, not just her subjects, elizabeth is the only ruler of england we have ever known. quick story, july of 1953, my father was serving in the u.s. army during the korean conflict. on leave he travelled to london with a buddy. they had a chance encounter with the queen. she was reviewing troops at hyde park and he suddenly found himself just four feet away from a car carrying her majesty and prince philip. trouble was his camera was set for 10 feet. nevertheless the blurry image he captured became a family
6:16 am
keepsake. okay. fast forward 64 summers later, one of his grandsons, my middle son, arrives in london to study. by chance day one happens upon buckingham palace in the midst of a celebration of the queen's official 91st birthday and using an iphone, like his grandfather, took her photo on the balcony. 15 prime ministers, 14 u.s. presidents, spanning three generations of my family, just one queen. she's the reason the monarchy has survived these last 70 years, whether it continues might depend on how well she's emulated. for decades, queen elizabeth was near the top of the list of the most admired people in the world. and that's despite the fact that to many the monarchy is an inak row nichl on democratic, el elitist, essence of privilege. yet the queen overcame those impediments to popularity because of who she was as a human being. in the platinum jubilee celebration people were asked what one word they associated
6:17 am
with her. >> dignity. >> unifying. >> inspirational. >> wisdom. >> she's loyal. >> consistency. >> think about how much we would be better off if our political leaders were more like her? and think about how they too could become among the most admired people in the world if they followed her lead. elizabeth has been rightly credited with sustaining, humanizing, modernizing the royals at a time when their purpose and function seemed to be archaic and outmoted. but will her efforts survive her? will either charles or william command any of the same level of respect, impact, gravitas, not just worldwide but even domestically. clive irving predicted her passing would cause problems for the royals among the 14 other countries around the world for which elizabeth was head of state. writing, quote, when the queen's reign end, their all go off the precipice, i think.
6:18 am
they just drive off a precipice because it's only the presence of the queen. as for england, tom put it this way in the atlantic, generations have known nothing but the queen. she became almost above reproach, an icon on a wall, a symbol. charles by contrast is human and flawed and distinctly reproachable. with the queen goes the monarchy's protective shield. can the next generation escape the racism or scandals of prince andrew? how long can such an institution really survive in an era of black lives matter and imperial guilt? can an african child once again be pictured kneeling before distant monarch happened for the queen's diamond jubilee in 2012. a poll by u gof down at the time of the platinum jubilee just this last may found that 62% of britains said their country should continue to have a monarchy in the future. with only 22% saying it should instead move to having an elected head of state.
6:19 am
but there's a stark generational divide asked if the monarchy is, quote, good for britain, 74% of those 65 and up say yes. 67% of those 50 to 64. but ages 25 to 49, the number drops to 49. and among the 18 to 24-year-olds, it's just 24%. today's front page of the new york times has this headline in london, mourning for queen exposes a generational divide. support for monarchy fades among the youth. there's a chance that post-elizabeth the affection for the whole system may splinter. some of that may just be youthful hostility that could soften over time. look no further than england's new prime minister herself back in 1994 liz truss gave a fiery speech calling for the end of the monarchy. >> we do not believe that people should be born to rule. or that they should put up and shut up about decisions that affect their everyday lives.
6:20 am
we met another group of people and another group of people and all three groups of people said abolish the monarchy. in fact, conference, we couldn't find a single monarchist outside the royal pavilion. how ironic. >> now, of course, in her new position of power, truss ended her public condolence speech for the queen on thursday with god save the king. a phrase that hasn't been uttered in england for seven decades. elizabeth's death also comes at a time when there are worries about the stability of democracy around the globe, including here in america. president biden hosted a group of historians last month at the white house who warned him the current moment is among the most dangerous to democracy in our history. they liken today's unrest with the period leading up to world war ii when growing authoritarianism abroad was being echoed in the united states. and it's not just the historians. in a recent quinnipiac survey, 67% of american adults said they
6:21 am
thought the country's democracy was, quote, in danger of collapse. that's up nine points from january. according to a study from pew research, 85% of americans said the u.s. political system either needs major changes or needs to be completely reformed. and among those who say they want significant political reform, 58% said they're not confident the system can change. just this week, a cbs poll found that a majority of americans believe political violence in the u.s. will increase and country will be less of a democracy for future generations. so are we witnessing not just the end of a reign but the possible end of two eras? the british monarchy and american democracy. i want to know what you think. go to my website smerconish.com this hour and answer this week's poll question. which is more secure? american democracy or the british monarchy? joining me now to discuss is sean woolents.
6:22 am
attended the meeting with president biden, professor of history at princeton university, jefferson to lincoln, a finalist for the pulitzer prize. professor, how will you be answering the poll question this week, which is more secure, democracy in the united states or the monarchy abroad? >> oh, well, good morning, michael. first of all, you know, something of a trick question because they're two very different kinds of institutions. i want to make that clear. you know, the monarchy at this point is largely symbolic politically and great deal of influence but not the same thing as american democracy. there are different currents going on. but look, i think the monarchy will probably last for a long time. it's been there forever. it has changed over the years. and you know, there was a time in the early 19th century, for example, when the monarchy was pretty tawdry. not like what we see today.
6:23 am
traditions were invented to prop up the monarchy. the monarchy has gone through ebbs and flows. but i think that right now it's not going to go away any time soon. what its fate will be will largely be in the hands of charles iii. as far as american democracy is concerned, now that's a much more volatile situation. i mean, the head of state in britain is a symbolic, unifier, supposedly. some people don't like it, but that's what it is. american democracy is another matter. we don't have a symbolic figure like that. so, the volatility alone makes, i think, the situation in the united states a lot more rocky than it is in britain. >> okay. i recognize that you don't appreciate the question itself, which is fine. but it sounds to me like you're saying if you had to answer it, you would be saying more secure is the monarchy than american democracy. >> yes. >> what if i asked about democracy in england, the united kingdom, generally, as compared to the united states. do you have the same level of concern that you expressed to president biden about democracy overseas? >> absolutely.
6:24 am
i think it's systemic. it's throughout the western democracies. there's this problem, series of problems. but, yes, if you take it down to the level of what's going on, it's ironic that indeed the queen should die right at the moment when there's a great transition to a new prime minister in britain and that new prime minister is a very polarizing figure. where british democracy is going post brexit is just as -- chancy a question as where the united states is going post trump. >> i watched i think it's called council of ascension this morning in all of these on going pomp and circumstances surrounding her death and his upcoming core nation. the point i wanted to make, professor is this, standing in the front row, my gosh, there were six or seven former prime ministers which was a reminder to me of the tumult and turnover that they experienced. >> yeah. she reigned for a very, very long time. it's unusual. i suppose victoria we could say something of the same thing.
6:25 am
a lot of prime ministers had come and gone. and that's what the monarchy is all about. to serve as a stabilizing force. the united states is more of an idea, you know. we have an idea of democracy. that's what holds us together, not a figure head, not a person age, not a monarch but an idea of democracy. the problem in the united states, i think, is that idea has come under assault. the idea of truth has come under assault but certainly the idea that we all share certain democratic ideals that has been battered over the last 10, 15 years, certainly over the last 5 years and makes is situation in america so dangerous. as long as we have that idea, then we can get through a great deal, we always have. when that idea is being challenged as it was in the 1850s and 60s and 1930s, then i think we're in real trouble. >> final question, the president spoke in front of independence hall in philadelphia about ten days ago. do you think that speech
6:26 am
obviously you would have paid attention to it. was that an outgrowth of the warning that you and colleagues delivered to president biden? >> i don't know. i don't want to talk about that meeting in particular. i can't do so. but i think the president has been talking along these lines for a while. goes back to his inauguration actually after january 6th. so i think it's been a theme that's been present throughout his presidency. but at the moment, i think it's come to the fore in part because he managed to get his program through. it's a moment now to reflect on the larger issues and also an election year leading into the midterms. so i think that, you know, and things certainly changed since he took office. but i think this has been a theme throughout. whatever we had to say to him, i think, was just re-enforcing or just reflecting on things that have been happening all along. >> do not let the nature of my trick question stop you from voting today, professor. thank you for coming back. >> very good. thanks. good to see you. bye. >> thank you. let's see what you're saying via social media, twitter,
6:27 am
youtube, facebook. tall outlets. democracy i guess is the answer to which is more secure. despite its potential for modern day good and symbolism for stability, cancel culture will ultimately subsume the monarchy. interesting observation. don't believe me, check the twitter bashing within hours of the queen passing away. some of that was horrible. we lost our humanity we can't have one day to mourn. well, beta testing, let me say this don't go believing that a snapshot of the twitter mob and yet, of course, i'm responding to the twitter mob each and every saturday, aren't i, is reflection of society at large, because god help us if the people who were in such poor taste saying things about the queen upon passing are representative of the whole lot. i don't think they are. i want to remind you, go to smerconish.com. my website right now and answer this week's poll question, can't wait to see the result of this. i have no idea how it's going to turn out. which is more secure, you heard professor say he thinks there's more volatility in american
6:28 am
democracy than the british monarchy. i'm asking you which one is more secure. up ahead, king charles is finally in charge at age 73, but what does the future hold for his heir william who is now prince of wales? i'm about to ask princess diana's chief of staff and private secretary patrick jeffson. in her 70 years on the throne, queen elizabeth had a wide variety of meetings with 13 u.s. presidents, dancing, attending church and a baseball game and rode horses with president reagan. did she ever let on who her favorites were? when you take it again the next day. so betty can be the barcode beat conductor. ♪ go betty!! let's be more than our allergies! zeize the day. zyrtec. ♪ age before beauty? why not both? visibly diminish wrinkled skin in just two days. new crepe corrtor lotion only from gold bond. champion your in.
6:29 am
my asthma felt anything but normal. ♪ ♪ it was time for a nunormal with nucala. nucala is a once-monthly add-on treatment for severe eosinophilic asthma that can mean less oral steroids. not for sudden breathing problems. allergic reactions can occur. get help right away for swelling of face, mouth, tongue, or trouble breathing. infections that can cause shingles have occurred. don't stop steroids unless told by your doctor. tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. may cause headache, injection site reactions, back pain, and fatigue. ask your asthma specialist about a nunormal with nucala. age comes with wisdom. and wisdom comes with benefits. dryer's broken okay... you want a socket.... that's especially true when it comes to medicare. so make the wise call and learn more about cigna medicare plans in your area. their tools and resources make it simple and easy. bears can smell wifi. visit cignawisecall.com today. you want to flip it.
6:32 am
6:33 am
grieving over the loss of queen elizabeth. we're back with cnn's special coverage, soon king charles iii will hold audiences with religious and political leaders including the new british prime minister liz truss. we'll bring that when it happens. but first, what's the future of the british crown? earlier charles iii was proclaimed the new monarch of the united kingdom, first new leader since the second elizabethian age began in 1952. this week he addressed great britain and the world the first time since his mother's passing. he conferred new titles on prince william and kate middleton and expressing love for his son prince harry and daughter-in-law meghan. >> as my heir, william, now assumes the scottish titles which have meant so much to me. i am proud to create him prince of wales. with katherine beside him, our
6:34 am
new prince and princess of wales will, i know, continue to inspire and lead our national conversations, helping to bring the marginal to the center ground, where vital help can be given. i want also to express my love for harry and meghan as they continue to build their lives overseas. >> now that charles is king, what does this mean for prince william and where does the future of the monarchy go from here. joining me now to talk about all the above is patrick jeffson. you'll remember he was princess deanna's private secretary and chief of staff and served the princess for eight years. he's also the author of the books shadows of a princess and the meghan factor and the recent piece just published in the daily mail, mystique, aura and majesty radiated from her majesty like an electric force field. actually patrick, let's begin with that. the piece that you wrote talks about you being summoned to meet
6:35 am
with her majesty. can you quickly tell that story? >> yes, michael. the first experience i had of walking across that daunting fore court behind me here was while i was going for an interview to be military aide to princess diana. i had been summoned from my service in the royal navy in the north atlantic, suddenly finding myself in front of the most famous landmark in the country, one of the most famous in the world. i was about to be admitted to this chance circle, i suppose, of people who had the honor and the privilege to serve her majesty really closely. >> i'm wondering how the passing of the queen might impact the relationship of the boys. what thoughts do you have on that? >> it changes their lives, certainly william's life very significantly. as you heard, the new king has
6:36 am
created william, his heir, prince of wales. that means in simple terms that he is next up. god forbid if anything happened to the new king, william would become king as quickly as charles did when his mother passed. so, this is a shifting of the perspective. the british constitutional system has delivered a replacement head of state in william and his work now is to prepare for that day may it be far off when he in turn assumes the throne. in a sense, it underlines the die verging paths between william and his younger brother harry. they used to be so close. i knew them when they were still small boys. now it seems they're set on further and further distant paths ahead. it's significant that prince charles said -- sorry, the king said, that william is heir. harry is building his life
6:37 am
overseas. the shift of state is sailing on and harry and meghan seems gotten their own boat and gone off to their own desert island. >> you know, patrick, we have all grieved. we have all grieved loss. sometimes it's a unifier. maybe it's an opportunity for the brothers to the extent there's a schism between them to put it back together? >> we would hope so, michael. certainly grief can have a unifying effect, even on the most fractured family, but the signs are not good. harry arrived after everybody else at balmoral, when the queen passed. and he left first. so, we read he also had to make his own way there. made his own arrangements for travel. the signs are that the distance between harry and the rest of his family at the moment is about as far as it could be. and it doesn't look like it's going to get any better in the near term with we're promised his own memoirs due to come out in a book before the end of the
6:38 am
year. >> is there a lot of pressure now brought to bear on meghan, beyond that which already existed because the eyes of the world will be scrutinizing every step that she takes during the course of the next ten days? >> well, it's a wonderful piece of good fortune, probably, that harry and meghan were already in england when the queen entered her final illness. they had a successful visit to manchester and their last engagement in london was overshadowed by the queen's death. there will be many question marks, i think, about her participation in the events that loi lie ahead, particularly the state fun yal. we'll remember the queen's platinum jubilee, service of thanksgiving, harry and meghan were consigned to the pews along with the junior members of the royal family.
6:39 am
they weren't with the royal "a" team. interested to see where they're seated for the funeral. it's a shame we're concerned with such details at a time of such momentous constitutional importance. it is if you asked any of the people behind me, these crowds around the palace, yes, they're here for the new king and to give gratitude for the queen who is no longer with us. but above all, their presence signals the strength of the british system in which continuity meant that one head of state has been replaced by another without even a ripple. >> i hope you're right. patrick jephson, thank you as always. >> thank you. still to come, queen elizabeth met with 13 of the 14 sitting u.s. presidents during her reign. so what were their relationships like with this -- what were her relationships like with this diverse array of leaders in a country that revolted against
6:40 am
her monarchy? did she have a favorite? final reminder, go to smerconish.com and make sure you're voting on this week's poll question. register for the newsletter while you're there. which do you think is more secure, american democracy or the british monarchy? if your moderate to severe crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms are stopping you in your tracks... choose stelara® from the start... and move toward relief aftethe first dose... with injections every two months. stelara® may increase your risk of infections, some serious, and cancer. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, sores, new skin growths, have had cancer, or if you need a vaccine. pres, a rare, potentially fatal brain condition, may be possible. some serious allergic reactions
6:41 am
6:44 am
over the course of her 70-year reign, queen elizabeth met with 13 sitting american presidents. that's not only a record that will likely never be broken, but as peter baker put it "the new york times" it was surely a test of diplomatic fortitude. from harry truman, who she met before she was crowned, to joe biden who visited her last year, think of the different personalities of leaders that she encountered from the up start nation that had broken free of her's. she went to church with dwight d. eisenhower, later sent him a recipe. danced with gerald ford. rode horses with ronald reagan. went to a baltimore orioles game with george herbert walker bush. after she stopped traveling, the
6:45 am
presidents went to visit her. obamas gave her an ipod. also had some show tunes. she had tea with donald and melania trump. the only president she never met was lbj because of tensions over the war in vietnam. so, how did she navigate all of that? joining me now is alvin, a presidential historian and former lecturer at the university of pennsylvania school of communication, his books include "the leaders we deserved and a few we didn't" rethinking the presidential rating game. al, it occurs to me the school where you taught at penn, named for a united states ambassador to the court at saint james. >> yes. very hard-working one and very respected one in the uk. and i point out that when he retired, came back to the united states, he had the pleasure and the honor of welcoming the queen california estate and people tell me at least one of the
6:46 am
california presidents that she knew was at some of those receptions. ford, reagan and nixon were all in california at the same time. so love to have been a fly on the wall if that was true. >> you think she had a favorite? >> very revered -- well, she never said. but we can tell by the body language. we can tell by how she related to them. her first sitting president was dwight eisenhower. in the photographs we can tell a lot. she knew him as an adolescent growing up. he was in the england for the latter years of war. when he came to the white house, there's a wonderful photograph of the two of them at a dinner where she is bejewelled and beautiful and new queen, great curiosity about her. he's looking at her with great pride, grandfather would take, when a young granddaughter was beginning to blossom. and you can see that he's just beaming with pride.
6:47 am
on his attire, is a sash carrying the medal of the order of merit, which is the highest honor an american can retain. she remembered that. her father had given it to him. they went to a picnic together at balmoral. she sent him a recipe how to make the scones he such praised and asked for. >> i remember -- >> moving along -- >> i remember some controversy surrounding nancy reagan going to charles and diana's wedding. and i also remember the perception of there being a real bond between reagan and her majesty, perhaps over horses. you know, they had that in common. >> yes. yes. i want to talk about the reagans and both the queen and the current king. you mentioned this. when the current king was prince of wales, he took a tour of the united states and several of the commonwealth countries. and he stopped at the white house, richard nixon honored him. some great photographs of the
6:48 am
nixons and the queen. not at that visit, but he went to buckingham palace with the first lady, pat nixon, later on. nixon was supposed to be a man of great awkwardness and unease in public and sometimes retiring in shy. this is most relaxed photograph you'll ever see of richard nixon. the only rivals -- >> yeah, we're showing it. >> when he danced with pat at the daughter's wedding. but you see nixon just beaming. why? it was a reunion. i mean, eisenhower was president, first sitting president she met. but nixon was her guide. he was more of a contemporary to her. and photograph of the two of them in an open cadillac going down connecticut avenue with crowds and crowds of well wishers. well, the prince at that time went out to california. he met several of the people in hollywood whose movies he had seen as a teenager and met the reagans. and somehow he bonded with nancy reagan, sat with her at a dinner. they began quite a long
6:49 am
friendship. he wrote her kind of letters from the palace and elsewhere that an american teenager or american young man would write to a favorite aunt. not always things you would tell your parents, but things he wanted to get off his chest and tell her. and so when she went to the wedding, she did not have a very good press unfortunately. and we had just been through the period of the controversies about designer clothes in china and all the other nonsense. people were saying, why is she going to these events? is she thinking she's a monarch herself? pretentious? the answer is she was invited to all the groom's receptions, all the parties with his friends, all the parties are just in current relations. she was with relatives. she was with the family. she was with the friends. she wasn't pushing herself on anyone. she wasn't running for monarch. well -- you mentioned ronald reagan. >> al, it's a book. you got to write the book. i'm out of time, but you have to
6:50 am
write another book exploring this whole subject and covering the relationships that she had with all of them. i really appreciate your time and expertise. >> one line ronald reagan said he never saw a person master of a horse the way the queen took hold of that animal. one of his great lines. >> wow. it is a great line. thank you, al. appreciate it. still to come, more of your best and worst tweets. have you voted yet? go to smerconish.com, tell me which is more secure, american democracy or the british monarchy? and some you'd never. it's going to take funding innovationon in renewable energy, helping reduce carbon footprints, and big bets on environmentallly conscious construction. citi has committed 1 trillion dollars in sustainable financing to help build a better future. because to reach net zero, it's going to take everything. ♪ ♪
6:51 am
♪ today, my friend, you did it... ♪ today you took delicious centrum multigummies and took one more step towards taking charge of your health. they're packed with essential nutrients so every day, you can say, withentrum multigummies. moving forward with node- positive breast cancer is overwhelming. but i never just found my way; i made it. and did all i could to prevent recurrence. verzenio reduces the risk of recurrence of hr-positive, her2-negative, node-positive, early breast cancer
6:52 am
with a high chance of returning,... as determined by your doctor when added to hormone therapy. hormone therapy works outside the cell... ...while verzenio works inside to help stop the growth of cancer cells. diarrhea is common, may be severe, or cause dehydration or infection. at the first sign, call your doctor, start an antidiarrheal, and drink fluids. before taking verzenio, tell your doctor about any fever, chills, or other signs of infection. verzenio may cause low white blood cell counts, which may cause serious infection that can lead to death. life-threatening lung inflammation can occur. tell your doctor about any new or worsening trouble breathing, cough, or chest pain. serious liver problems can happen. symptoms include fatigue, appetite loss, stomach pain, and bleeding or bruising. blood clots that can lead to death have occurred. tell your doctor if you have pain or swelling in your arms or legs, shortness of breath, chest pain, and rapid breathing or heart rate, or if you are nursing, pregnant, or plan to be. i'm making my own way forward. ask your doctor about everyday verzenio.
6:53 am
medium latte, half-caff, no foam. quite the personalized order. i know what i like. i've been meaning to ask you, carl. does your firm offer personalized index investing? hmm? so i can remove a stock that doesn't align with my goals. i'm a broker, not a barista. what about managing gains and losses to be more tax efficient? not a wizard either. looks like schwab personalized indexing can. schwaaab! learn more about personalized indexing at schwab today. you might already know that prop 27 taxes and regulates online sports betting to fund real solutions to the homelessness crisis. so how will that new revenue be spent? new housing units in all 58 counties, including: permanent supportive housing,
6:54 am
6:55 am
okay. time to see how you responded to the poll question this week at smerconish.com. which is more secure, american democracy or the british monarchy. here it is. wow, pretty decisive. the monarchy with more than 20,000 votes cast, call it 70/30. i read that as a tribute to queen elizabeth ii, a 70 year reign and the stability she brought to the picture. i hope it's another 70 and secure. social media reaction, what do we have? >> amazing and thought provoking poll question today. thank you. i am saddened by the results, though. ask it again in six months and compare. i'd be curious. fyi i answered democracy. i feel better about democracy. wishful thinking maybe. i see the polling data i shared with all of you and it frightens me but i'd like to think there's
6:56 am
still more that unites us than divides us, despite the headlines. i think we give attention to the divisiveness without recognizing on fundamental issues there's still large agreement among us. thank you for watching. i'll see y you next week. . hurry in and enjoy this deal for a limited d time. download the app and earnn free food with every order. age comes with wisdom. and wisdom comes with benefits.
6:57 am
dryer's broken okay... you want a socket.... that's especially true when it comes to medicare. so make the wise call and learn more about cigna medicare plans in your area. their tools and resources make it simple and easy. bears can smell wifi. visit cignawisecall.com today. you want to flip it. if you have type 2 diabetes or high blood pressure... ...you're a target for chronic kidney disease. they're the top two causes of ckd. ckd usually starts with no symptoms. so you can have it and not know it. to find out, check the kidney numbers from your lab tests. ♪far-xi-ga♪ if you have chronic kidney disease, farxiga can help slow its progression. farxiga can cause serious side effects including dehydration, urinary tract or genital yeast infections in women and men, and low blood sugar. ketoacidosis is a serious side effect that may lead to death.
6:58 am
a rare, life-threatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. stop taking farxiga and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of this bacterial infection, an allergic reaction, or ketoacidosis. and don't take it if you are on dialysis. take aim at ckd by asking your doctor for your kidney numbers and how farxiga can help. if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. ♪far-xi-ga♪ nurse mariyam sabo knows a moment this pure
6:59 am
7:00 am
121 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco) Television Archive Television Archive News Search Service The Chin Grimes TV News ArchiveUploaded by TV Archive on