help you lose fat get lean, absolutely free, rugged 321321. i'm melanie is known in washington. and this is cnn. closed captioning is brought to you by skechers max cushioning. do you struggle to put on your shoes when you leave the house call inaudible with new max cushioning. hands free skechers slipping. it's easy. just step in and go try new max cushioning handsfree sketches, clippings. can we come back? police in

nashville, releasing dramatic body cam video of officers arriving at the scene, searching for and confronting that killing the shooter. this was after the shooter opened fire at a private christian elementary school, killing three children and three adults. police say they don't know the motive, but they also say the attack was quote calculated and planned. i want to bring in cnn's tom foreman. he's at the magic wall for us to explain what we'll see in this body cam video. which many of you we want to warn, you may find disturbing. also we're joined by ed davis, the former boston police commissioner, and cnn law enforcement analyst, michael finnegan of former d c. metropolitan police officer. gentlemen thank you very much for being here, tom. let me start with you. you've been covering school shootings since before columbine. so tell us what you see. in this video. you see, most of all is what looks like a textbook handling of things here and that they start off from the very beginning. calm and focused and purposeful and everything they do. we see

officer rex engelberg show up here is getting information from people. he has his weapon ready. he's approaching the building, and, as he called out to other officers conference, joined him and get ready. it is clear he's not going to wait around about 20 seconds from the time he reaches the doors until he goes in. listen to what he does here. all the way down the hall fellowship, all the end of this fellowship all there. they just said they heard gunshots down there and then upstairs for a bunch of fish. let's go. i need . three. more let's go. just incredible. i mean, michael, i just want to bring you in. when you hear that, just to me. it's so viscerally powerful to hear that they know that this is a life and death situation and they're just gonna they're just, you know, storming in. yeah i mean, i think these officers

demonstrated what the american police officers capable of when he or she is given the right equipment. the right training, uh and has the appropriate mindset. it's clear that these officers, um they acted methodically and deliberately in everything they did from the time they arrived all the way up until they identified and neutralized the threat. and so bravely also, commissioner, do you agree? this is a textbook example of what should be done. i do, and courage, i think is the one thing that we haven't heard until you just mentioned it. alison i it's just incredibly amount of fortitude. it takes to literally charge a position with military style weapons involved. these officers are walking into hell, and they're doing it calmly and methodically, and exactly why they're training. so i can't say

enough about how well this was executed. um they communicated well. they move from place to place clearing rooms, as is the plan and then, when they heard gunfire, they moved immediately to the sound of gunfire and took immediate action. it saved lives, and, uh, this is textbook. so let's hear that next part of it, tom, let's talk. let's show us the part where they're going, methodically classroom to classroom if you look at them when they first get inside here, and they're going through the bottom floor. that is the description exactly right there. they're methodical. they're calm . you would think that they were performing some kind of a drill because they show none of that unease when they're encountering exactly what ed made reference to their there are mortal threat in this building, but they're going about it quickly and smoothly. listen now. door door with me with me. hold the door.

next michael, i don't think i've ever seen that before. i've always heard that they go classroom to classroom and have to clear each classroom, but i've never seen them say here's a bathroom looking bathroom clear and then move on to the next one. just seeing it again is very powerful. and i can't help but think about how they didn't do that. and you, baldy. yeah i mean, it's the complete opposite end of the spectrum. but these officers did what they were trained to do. the training is to immediately enter the structure. identify locate the threat and neutralize the threat. you can see that. prior to them hearing gunshots. they're going in room two room trying to find the suspect. once they hear gunshots, they begin bypassing rooms responding directly to the threat and then

neutralizing that threat. um again, that is the training and that is what's expected of police officers here in america commissioner again. as i've said, i find this so satisfying , i guess to see because they're doing, you know god's work. i mean, there is trying to save these children, and it's such a great example of police work, and i think that all americans should see what our local police and obviously our fbi etcetera have to do every single day. but at the same time does it make you at all anxious that we're showing? this does that? does this giveaway kind of a handbook ? does it give away clues or do you think it's a deterrent? right i think it's a deterrent. i think that this type of professional response is something that needs to be seen . police were initially hesitant to have party cameras and they've been terrible things shown on police body cameras, but this is an example of

getting the word out as to exactly what police officers are facing. when they get a call like this, and i think that over the course of a year, the police in the united states do a much better and press it job if we can document that on video and get that out to the community, people will see exactly what they're getting from the from the police department, so i think this is a positive step and kudos to the chief for getting this out so quickly. you know a lot of places. uh lawyers get involved in it, and they want to hide everything. and this is one of these things that we really need to be transparent to vote to regain the trust of the american people. this goes a long way towards that happening . okay, tom, so this next part is, is arguably even the more intense the most intense part. so show us what we're about to say. absolutely. and what you see here? is the lesson of school. i was outside columbine when what was happening inside was happening after columbine.

the lesson was. don't sit around moved to the gunfire. take action. listen to what happens here is a charge of the stairs and you hear gunfire and there is no hesitation there moving directly toward the shooter. right? bbo. hmm. mike obviously not all of us are built of that stock. not all of us can run towards the danger. you are built like that. what is that moment like? i mean, i said many times, uh, especially with regard to my own experiences. uh you never rise to the occasion. so to speak. you fall back on your training. it's apparent that these officers were well

trained, but that they also possessed what you called courage. the commissioner called bravery. uh i would refer to as the warriors mindset. um they knew that they had a job to do, and they completed that task. and to touch on what you were saying with the commissioner earlier, uh i couldn't agree more. it is. more than just appropriate. it's what you needed right now. people need to understand what police officers do on a daily basis so that we can sleep safely and securely in our beds each night. this is part of the drop. it's brutal, and it's gruesome at times, but people need to understand what officers do. uh and they need to be commended when they perform exceptionally like these officers. absolutely commissioner. how much training goes into what? we just saw the orchestration of that the choreography. how much did they train for that moment? the

training goes on every year, year after year, and i had a policy of bringing officers in who were involved in combat situations and interviewing each one of them in the two police departments, where i was the police chief, and, uh um, and every one of them said to me at some point the threat happened, and then we just respond to the way we were trained to, and it saved lives. and so the training whether it's on the range or whether it's tactical training, uh, of room, clearing the techniques that you saw here, communicating, shoot and move, um going to the sound of the gunfire and neutralizing the threat. those are things that have to be done over and over and over again, so it becomes part of your physical reaction to these terrible threats. but you know the sights. the sounds the smells of incidents like this. don't get translated completely in a video. it's much worse when the adrenaline's pumping, and i think that that

that this training is necessary and you see it happening over and over again. i'm so glad you point that out, because obviously, they're seeing on thinkable things that were not showing but that they are forced to have to, um metabolize somehow while they're doing all this, tom, go ahead. your final thoughts. the last thing i want to point out is when you watch all this video continuously from the time they come in the door until the time the shooter is down. is about two minutes and 15 seconds. that's a pretty amazing response time in situations like this, because we've seen many where it hasn't been anywhere near that. we applaud them such an amazing bit of video that they've shared with us. michael commissioner tom thank you all very much. thank you. poll suggested americans are backing away from the values that wants to find us things like patriotism, religion , community involvement and having children. so what defines us now? you're doing business in

an app driven multi clcloud wor. that's why you choose e vm ware with flexible multi cloud services that enable digital innovation and enterprise control helps you keep your cloud options open. you're finally mastering grama's 12 hour sauce. u're still talking about the 11th hour. american home shield is there to fix or replace covered appliances and systems protect you don't expect . visit hhs .com for 50% off sometimes, one thing leads to another thing. then all of a sudden it's on with roman. you can take care of erectile dysfunction discreetly. so whenever the moment happens, you're ready. roman ready? i didn't even realize that i was living in constant fear walked, i put my keys between my finger and just in case but you don't have to protect me anymore. i

feel 100 times stronger. £100 lighter. because i have this thing in i can imagine that kind of freedom. or series march 31st on prime video. these that's more like it. i see how pro starts working insulin. with two extra pain relievers. you can rise from pain like a pro. icy hot pro. hey, man. you could save hundreds for safe driving with liberty mutual because demise your car insurance. so you only pay for what you need. who we gotta go again for what you need. liberty

liberty liberty. welcome to stormy heights. where the windows are always paella. because the weather is always changing. glass is the strongest material for windows and patio doors. tested from minus 40 f up to 160. fiberglass frame is even scratch and dent resistance. hello, windows, even replacement windows by pellet now. i've always been prone to hair thinning, genetically predisposed gave birth is under a lot of stress. older i started taking neutral, natural. clinically effective, neutral fall is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplements. within months, i noticed it becoming stronger and thicker. neutral has taken me back to the hair i was meant to have. i am back to

me. start your hair growth journey at neutrophils .com. you got me, you're it. imagine a world with no drama for the guarantee of high quality promotional items delivered on time, go to four imprint dot com imprint for certain care were easy. everyone would do it as well as true green. does it true greens online tools, help ensure your custom treatment works to deliver a greener, healthier lawn guaranteed. it's time to trust your experts at true green go online today. when you're the leader, disaster cleanup and restoration. how do you make like it never even happened happened. fire it up, randy. being prepared for anything. whatever comes your way. there's

a program that serve pro like it never even happened. with each other. yep. a new poll shows americans are shifting away from values that wants to find us. let's bring in pollster frank luntz awesome community in princeton fellow may soon zion he always interesting. evan siegfried, our favorite former tennis pro patrick mcenroe and gideon lichfield of wired guys stand by because i want to talk to frank pollster first, about what this means, frank. what do you mean that we're shifting away from our treasured values? well this is a wake up call that the anger and frustration, anxiety every negative connotation you can imagine now exists and it's affecting our attitudes towards patriotism, our attitudes towards faith towards family towards freedom. and i thought this was impossible. but alison what? we've been what we've been hearing. for the last 34 years

in our focus groups is really intensity, and it's not just anger. it's a lack of civility. it's a lack of decency. we don't focus on communication. we need to focus on comprehension. we need to focus on what we all need to learn rather than what we need to say. i think that that's one of the problems that we have in politics right now, and i blame the republicans. i blame the democrats. frankly i blame the media as well. i blame all of us. i'll take responsibility for what we have lost the ability to listen. we've lost the ability to learn and what this poll shows. is that we are not facing a critical point or a crisis point . it is upon us right now and unless we get our act together, and i'm cleaning up my language for cnn, unless we get our act together, we are we are headed down a path. that we may not be able to recover from politically economically socially culturally as a country. we are so divided, please those people watching us right now, listen up. our

country is changing and not in a good way. it's not our viewers because they're also wonderful. but anyway, um i just want to dive into it a little bit more. so this is the wall street journal poll, frank and you? we put up the one that in 1998, patriotism and religion were two values that were very important to the respondents. 70% for patriotism. now it's 38% 62% for religion. now it's 39% then values that were very important to people in 1998 having children. was it 59% now it's 30% community involvement 47% down to 27% and so here's one that has gone in the opposite direction, frank values that are very important to you money. in 1998 31% said. that was very important. now it's 43% so what's caused this shift, frank? well it's part of it is the politicians. i do want to do something right here. this

doesn't matter if you're unhappy . this doesn't matter if your family is broken if your faith in the future if your faith and faith doesn't matter, so i wasn't thinking about this. until now, this is irrelevant and we need to stop focusing on this and so focusing on the things that really matter. i'm teaching right now and verbund am teaching right now at radley college, and it really truly matters to these students, the environment that's around them. climate immigration fairness, justice doesn't matter whether you're republican or democrat. the problem is too many of their parents and grandparents judge people based on their politics based on their attitudes towards issues. and there were not paying attention. to what really matters. love. respect. decency civility and alison and i'm interested in your with your panel says about this. i don't

see any candidate right now. who's speaking up for this? in fact, i see partisanship. i see . uh ideological warfare. i see people still trying to get the advantage over each other. there's an app right now. it's called facts, and it doesn't engage in this kind of communication. it focuses on the truth, and i say to everyone on the panel if we don't reassert our passionate, relentless pursuit of the truth. they were not going to make it as a country. we're not going to make it as a society and all i don't want to repeat myself, but we see these things in our focus groups every time people just light into each other, and we gotta stop. we've got to stop right now. frank. stand by if you would let me bring in the panel now, so patrick disheartening, but i mean, i think that i don't know. i think that maybe it's not as bleak as the wall street journal is, is, um, you know, spelling it out as

but here's one that is bleak tolerance for others in 2019, they said 80. is that possible in 2019? that's how we felt. and now in just a few short years later, 58% your thoughts. well, first of all, i'm glad frank didn't tear up 100. it was just a single, so that was a good feel better. i mean, he's spot on with so many of his comments, but, you know, i think back to when we are all similar age when we were kids, you know, we used to watch certain you know, the one show that we watch. we do things together. and i think the splintered nature of not only the politicians, which is certainly a huge part of this, but what's available to me think of our kids now and all the options they have. i mean, there's so many different things they can do. there's so many different shows, so i feel like people are trying to just put you in your little box. you know, the box has gotten smaller for all these different things. whether it's politics, whether it's television entertainment, and so it's just it's kind of like becoming just what it is. it's hard to get away from it because everyone's like these focus groups, frank talks about

all this. both he does focus groups on certain groups of people and this is what it's sort of become, but i think i'm not as as pessimistic as this. i still think there's a lot of good things, and i think the biggest thing that frank said is to listen. listen to other people. so i'm ready to listen. now people need to stop listening with their mouths, which is what people do get in with their mouth. so, speaking of listening with one's mouth, i want to. i'm not. i don't want to second guess frank lunch, the master the master of public opinion. but i've seen opinion polls misused a lot in many different countries, and it's very easy to tell a story with a poll by picking certain questions. and these questions tell a pretty dispiriting story to be sure. but i want to point out, you know, first of all, i think you could ask questions about other things. what do people are important as friendship to people has that gone up? curious to know. i don't know the answer. how important is caring for the environment to people that might show a shift in a different

direction again? i don't know the answer. but when you pick questions like this, that you almost designed to show the country falling apart. and also to show certain values which are more associated with the right and the left, and many of these cases declining then should you be surprised. i also want to say one more thing, frank said. money is not important. when you look at that poll before the question about which of these values are less important to people are more important. there is a whole series of questions on the pole about economics about how optimistic people feel about the future and they are a litany. of concern of anxiety. people are saying they're not confident that they will be better off. they're not confident their finances are improving. i think, 21% said that they feel their kids will be better off than they are, 78% said. they won't be that and that's been part of the narrative of economic insecurity . this country has been in for a long time. and so i think it's not money is of course, money is important. it is important to say it to tear up the great move, frank on the flag, do what

you want, but i'm not entirely convinced. help, frank way on this in a second. but let me go to mason mason. so your thoughts so my thoughts are you can't have religion and you can't have kids. without money. you can have faith. faith is free. organized religion is extremely expensive and having children is extremely expensive. so the idea that we can be close to these things and ignore money? i hope he tapes that dollar back and sends it to me because a better being disabled in americans expensive having kids i tried to adopt. it was so expensive i could afford was a cat. that's it, beyonce. that's all i have. so i think that we need to look at this and first go. people like me aren't cold. i'm closer to religion than ever. it's ramadan. i'm hungry. i remember . i know what's happening. but also i think that these things getting away from them isn't necessarily bad, and i think community has completely been redefined community is now

online. when i'm hanging out with my community. it's not cliffside park, new jersey, which i love and jersey girl jersey ruled by my community is, you know disabled people worldwide. side palestinians worldwide. people who were way too much makeup for a new show, and so is community disappearing . or is it defined differently? great point to get to gideon's point on economics, when if we go back to the nineties, the dollar went a lot longer further for everybody. and now more and more americans are living paycheck to paycheck and cost of living is skyrocketing. and that's a huge problem. and at the same time we've seen both political and cultural shifts. where in culture the tvs dad in the nineties was bob saget. now it's low. logan roy now in and we also have the kardashians. what are they chasing after money, so those are the values were imparting too many in our generations, the younger millennials and gen. z and then on the political side we've seen since the 19 nineties, the left and the right elect further and

further more extreme bomb throwers who refused to compromise and think it's the dirtiest word. last month, we had marjorie taylor green calling to have a great national divorce. and you know, biden is hardly a left wing. no, he's not when i think enough of the country was so sick and tired of it. donald trump and just literally tired of the drama. that they voted for joe biden. and at the same time tonight we had a fox news host come out and say that trans people are the natural enemy of christianity and tried to paint the brush that because of the shooter in nashville was being trans that all trans people are responsible , and that is violent and dangerous rhetoric that does divide us. it's wrong because the shooter and, uh, in sandy hook had was on the autism spectrum. not that doesn't mean everybody with autism is all of a sudden a threat. it's wrong. it divides us. but also those online communities who talk about there are plenty of online communities where they get together and they echo chamber. these horrible, divisive ideas, frank, can you tape that dollar bill together and send it to me,

please? thank you want to take it together? but i want to emphasize one point that when you do your panelists made which is that so many parents now think their kids are going to have a worse quality of life. that's been a problem now for about 10 years, but it's never been this bad. we've never had a situation when so many people think that the next generation is going to have it worse than this generation. that is a major definition of the american dream . that is a major component in the anxiety that people have right now that the genuine fear and unless we address that i will tell you that people were making more money over the past couple of years, but everything in life is costing them even more, and they started to come to realize that money itself doesn't buy happiness. it doesn't buy success that in the end, a happy family and a community that works together and actually, however you define it. if you feel part of a community and you're satisfied with your family, then all these

other issues don't matter as much. but if you're making more money, and you have less of that soul less of that ethos about america, that's what matters most. so yeah, this is a wake up call to everyone that things are still getting worse in this country. and god forbid, if we have the same 2024 that we had in 2020 politicians need to listen not just listen to each other. listen to the american people learn from the american people and then lead in the end. that's what matters. and love is the answer professionally. i think we can all agree with dollar bills. very good, frank. thank you very much. great to see you. thank you, acting head of the federal aviation administration has an interesting theory on what might be causing that string of near collisions of commercial flights . he links it to the pandemic, but something else also, we'll talk about that next. at the end

of the age, i'm a afraid i feels right upon us. this is considered a mass suicide investigation. never mind. t ando were the second coming. killing themselves. they ensured their immortality. to live easter. very. cnn presents a max original heaven's gate sunday at 10 on cnn. from ear birds tonight hours. so many ways to save life ready wallet happy that's 3 65 by whole foods market, introducing fast protect technology exclusively from simply advanced technology that allows our professional monitoring agents to capture evidence and verify the threat is real. for faster police response. there's no safe like safe. i'm livy done all american

gymnast and view every athlete. when you travel and train as much as i do you find happiness where you are. on the mat or on the sand movement and comfort are essential. that's why i live and performance joggers by the jury made from dream net fabric that's made of 89% recycled materials effortlessly soft and made to move as much as i do. my happiness starts here in the softest joggers on the planet. politicians never agree. we don't always agree like you like sleeping in luxury. i like affordability. mattress brought us together. i wonder if i could do that for politicians. anything is possible luxury mattresses made affordable. we know you care. but if this is all too real for you and your loved ones make the call because we care, too. home instead to us, it's personal. when i was

young, my father said, always be excellent. no one may take down excellent fringe meat. quite a remarkable man. antoinette queen of france point you, shivani, forget your place. the choice to fight is yours. one day whole world. chevallier told true story 13 looking great parasol. now, now you're fungus damage. carousel starts working in just two days, improving the appearance of fungus damage toenails and just two days your new movie story carousel two days, one solution. these must have cost a fortune. nope it was actually less than we expected old floors at home. it's time to love your floors. number liquidators is now flooring up to $500 cash back on hardwood

get into the stanley cup playoffs. there was nothing like it atmosphere to explode. hard grind. let's go. off scan this r

code. don't wait the code now and get the permanent solution protected by the bosley guarantee. good morning, everyone we do begin with breaking news this morning. what did you miss them? i like that. mason is cracking you up. that is fantastic. all right now to this close calls on runways, putting airplane passengers at risk. today the faa is acting administrator had an interesting explanation. no one says quote. air travel is coming back in a big way since the pandemic, but the long layoff coupled with the increased technical nature of our systems might have caused some professionals to lose some of that muscle memory. on top of that were contending with the loss of experience as the pandemic forced many seasoned professionals into retirement. data from the bureau of

transportation shows that after dipping at the beginning of covid, the pandemic airline passengers bounced back by mid 2021. but despite the return of passengers, the data shows a different story for airline jobs . airline employment is still struggling to get back to pre pandemic levels. my panel is back with me may soon is the faa basically throwing pilots under the plane here by saying like they just don't know how to operate. the new systems have gotten rusty. their muscle memory has gone. not only are they throwing pilots under the plane, they are terrifying. touring people like me like i don't need their muscle memory gone. i need them to be sharp and like everybody's wilding out on planes right now, but also nobody's talking about the fact that there's no such thing as a scheduled flight anymore. like i know i'm supposed to feel bad for the pilots. they're tired. my life is in their hands. but what i really feel bad about is going to newark airport and just living their flight schedules on just suggested they're not real

and this pandemic excuse my god , that's what i tell my mom. when i don't want to do stuff i'm so behind. it's the pandemic up from the pandemic. you're not catching up from the pandemic. you're not gonna take that from pilots. i'll take anything in private wants me to take. i said very quietly on airplanes and i am not disruptive. that's good. excellent me too, because i'm scared some of the time, so i don't like i like mason. i don't like the idea that are pilots have forgotten how to fly. some of these systems. the pandemic excuse now doesn't hold water because we've had vaccines for two years, and that has enabled us to get back to pretty much more normal life, but at the same time, let's look at the infrastructure, which the acting a for the f, a, a kind of hinted at but did not go there. which is we have an aging infrastructure. we aren't having advanced supercomputers and airport traffic control and air traffic control and in playing themselves that can coordinate and say, oh, there's another plane there. they actually have to take little tiles and move

them around. and some no, no, no, no, no, that's still there are on terrifying that they're doing it with legos. traffic controllers battleship. it's literally a little battleship. that was an airplane. they don't do that. my god, that is we do need to upgrade the infrastructure that can better deal with stuff in the 21st century. we heard that we definitely learned that after the southwest meltdown. well as as you know, alison i my homework for this show is positive. okay, so but i went through. there's some of the numbers on this one. they said it was 20 to 25% of the airline employees, pilots, air traffic control people flight attendants had left during the pandemic. but why haven't they all come back? i'll give it three guesses. the first two don't count. what frank lunch was talking about. it's about the money. i'm on a flight a couple of weeks ago when i had to miss the show, which was devastating to me and california, and i'm gonna flight to palm springs, which is only one nonstop

flight. today we got off the flight. a small plane. people are packed in the flight attendants say. well, if could you please leave quickly because we're turning around. we're going right back. i said, you guys are going right back to new york, the same crew and that used to be you take a long cross country flight. you'd be off for a day or two. you get to relax because they turn right around and came back and this is what they're trying to squeeze everything. the employees us talking about the dollars and more flights and these people got to get their act together and not make it all about. the green. get in. i mean, hearing everything that you're saying, i think these numbers are actually a good thing, a sign that things are going remarkably well, considering all of the you know the losses of jobs, the stresses the angry passengers, everything else. the fact that we're anything that's actually relatively small uptick in the number of serious near misses. i mean, we don't want one of those areas named the sister turn into an actual collision. obviously. but if i was looking at the fda data, and i think the numbers

that they're talking about is seeing this uptick recently is the most serious incidents. but if you look at the data on all incidents that that counters incidents which you know amount to a good few dozen a month, the numbers have actually slightly declined in the last six months, bad the ones that we have the ones that more attention that, of course, and it's true, like one bad incident like that, and you look but all i'm saying is, i'm very glad that nolan is, you know, calling attention to this and having summit about it, and i think that's responsible, but i don't think we should all freak out. it's certainly not good from here, missing a plane if they don't miss, don't want to be sitting in a plane freaking out. that's why they have bourbon on the plane. that's right. you have to pay but also like quickly. just really quickly. why are we not better at this? it's american exceptionalism. a year later, we didn't know everyone was getting wind fly after being trapped in their houses. should be ahead of this curb. we should not be behind it and no near misses

when i'm flying. please agreed with all of that. thank you very much. panel. stay with me when we come back. does chat gpt have a political bias. and how much of what it gives you is flat out wrong. that's next. packing and shipping store. two sided printing store where everything your small business needs to make it everything. it should be the one stop secret weapon to make a lot of noise and be unstoppable store. the ups store always been prone to hair thinning. it was getting older was under a lot of stress . i started taking neutral fall fall is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplements. i am back to

me. start your hair growth journey at neutrophils .com. i need a volunteer go promotional products. i'm on it. print makes promotional products success easy for high quality items, go to four imprint .com imprint for certain care were easy. everyone would do it as well as true green. does it true greens online tools, help ensure your custom treatment works to deliver a greener, healthier long guaranteed. it's time to trust your experts at true green go online today. sometimes you're so busy taking care of everyone else. you don't do enough for yourself or your mouth, but eventually it will remind you when it does. aspen dental is here for you. we offer the custom dental treatments. you need all under one roof right nearby so we can bring more life to your smile and more smile to your life affordably. new patients without insurance can get a free, complete, examine x rays and 20% off treatment plans and dental

anything to make you smile. schedule your appointment today. if you're ready to update the style of your kitchen remodel with all new cabinets over your existing cabinets with a new color, new style in new functionality can install a new style of doors on your existing boxes and refinished everything to a new color, giving you a completely different style as well as improving functionality with pull out trash and other organizational accessories. cabinet makeover in less time for less money than traditional cabinet remodels enhance would re finishing done right? get refunds dot com powered by innovation, refunds can help your business. get a payroll tax refund, even if you've got p p p n no, it takes eight minutes to call if i went on their website uploaded everything, and i was blown away by what they could do get refunds .com has helped businesses get over a billion dollars and we can help your business to qualify your business for a big refund in eight minutes. go to get refunds

.com to get started powered by innovation refunds. good morning, everyone we do begin with breaking news this morning . i want to give you a sense of what it looks like to you and your team on the ground pressing for answers. it's really important. joining us now are two lawmakers from different sides of the aisle live in ukraine. this is what climate scientists have been warning us about these volunteers. they say we couldn't have just sat at home. i'm doctor sanjay gupta home. i'm doctor sanjay gupta award palestinian ♪♪ alex! mateo, hey how's business? great. you know that loan has really worked wonders. that's what u.s. bank is for. and you're growing in california? -yup, socal, norcal... -monterey? -all day. -a branch in ventura? that's for sure-ah. atms in fresno? fres-yes. encinitas? yes, indeed-us. anaheim? big time. more guacamole? i'm on a roll-ay. how about you? i'm just visiting. u.s. bank. ranked #1 in customer satisfaction with retail banking in california by j.d. power.

ever ingredients to help you lose fat get lean, absolutely free, rugged 321321. i'm david culver in los angeles. and this is cnn. chat gpt has only been around for a few months, and already both the left and the right are angry with it and calling it biased. we need to examine how this new technology blurs the line between truth and fiction. my panel and i are joined now by cheryl cash in the carmack waterhouse, professor of

law, civil rights and social justice at georgetown law school professor. thanks so much for being here, tell us about this experiment that you did with chat gpt involving the history of slavery. right so 35 states in the country have adopted or introduced legislation to ban the teaching of race race history about race, right? and so i wanted to my fear was that students who denied, uh, truth and that kind of creep will probably fall back on the internet. so i just asked you to chat gpt a simple question. simple to me. um which of the delegates at the constitutional convention? um post slavery and chat gp teak, um busy made up an answer right? they. they said that several delegates, many

delegates spoke out against slavery. um but they weren't able to abolish it. and in fact that's was so far from the truth. the debate at the convention was really about how much we're going to accommodate slavery, not one delegate, their proposed that it be abolished. and so what chat? gpt did. was it mouth? um something very similar to the things that ron desantis and others have said about the framers suggesting that they favored freedom for all and that they set the stage for abolition when in fact it took 80 years in a civil war. um before we were able to accomplish that, professor, where is chad gpt getting its information? so it it as i understand it from reading about it in the newspapers, it minds data that's given to it. it looked at thousands and thousands and thousands of patterns, um, words

that are out there, and it predicts the kinds of words that the prompt the person who wrote the prompt would want to hear right. so i asked who at the founding spoke against slavery. it mounts back to me. we, uh this very tale about the delegates actually wanting abolition, um, but not being able to accomplish it. uh and this is this. i think it's pretty dangerous. um because chad gpt can't tell truth from fiction. it's not intelligent in this sense. it just gathers information and spits out what it thinks. frankly um, i may want to hear and the thing that's particularly dangerous because it's written and nice pros and it's written with confidence. it seems as if it knows what it's talking about, right. the person who reads it might think it's true. i happen to be a scholar and read two books and knew that it didn't

know what it was talking about, but it also could be manipulated pretty well to put out untruth. yahoo this is a yeah, this is an excellent cautionary tale. this experiment, professor stand by. if you would, i wouldn't bring in my panel. so get in. maybe humans are better than robots. after all. i mean, this is what she is described. as she says she knows better. most of us don't and so we can't really rely on chatterjee beauty. we see it time and again. i want to say one sentence that i want everybody to remember. that would really help if people remembered it. chat gpt is not trained on the truth. it is trained on the internet. the internet is full of stuff. that people that some of which is true, some of which is stuff that people want to be true. it contains all of the biases and the anger and all of the stuff that we have humans have put onto it. um and so that's that's one point. the second point is someone used in what i thought was a really good metaphor to

understand what a model like chat g p. t s. it's like, you know, when you take an image a picture of something and then you compress the image. you make a jpeg, but you keep on compressing it and compressing. it gets green here and green here and messier and messier and last year and last year gp to gpt is like this incredibly compressed image of the internet. so even whatever information or it's not even really information that it's taken. what it takes from the internet is sequences of words. and it says, what is the word that is most statistically likely to follow the preceding word, and that's how it creates patterns and then it takes those patterns and compresses them and it produces this very grainy picture of what is there. so to go and then ask it who was against slavery in the constitutional convention? you shouldn't really expect it. to produce a good answer. the problem is, of course, as the professor says, a lot of people expected to, but we really need to understand just how limited it is in being able to translate anything into into anything that might be called revival. sounds like some political operatives. i mean, it's just you put the you get any information from

human beings are putting the information in the internet. i mean, my twitter feed. let's see . i've got tennis on it. what a surprise. i've got news. i've got music like my instagram feed figures out. i like music. i like the beatles. so that guess what comes up? the beatles comes up again. i mean, this is what it is, and so human beings are going to affect what chat gpt is right, based on exactly what they're putting. they're giving them the information and i understand that they're starting to write all the they're they're going to use them in the political world now to just write their media reports and just put it out there that this is what's happening a bad idea. the text in the emails that we get already i spend like half the day trying to unsubscribe and now they're going to let a robot do it like they're already robots. robots will kill us. i'm not even convinced that gideon's not one, but like the idea of introducing i do. there's not he's not. he's real. he's real perfect. you want you to think, and that's what chad gt one, but i want nothing to do with any of

that. i'm not laying it. predict what i'm going to say. i'm not going to play with it, but the idea that politicians would use it to court us. we'll see may soon. i mean, i feel like i'm gonna ask you back in a year and we'll see if you can avoid chat gpt because it seems so ubiquitous and i owe you one. we have to get to penguin penmanship, okay? so we're going to talk about penmanship porn. and i'm serious when we come back. to finanally lose £80 and keep it off f with gullo is amazing. i've been maintaining the weight is gone and it's never coming back with solo. i'm not only kept off the weight, but i'm happier, healthier and i have a new lease on life is the only thing that will let you lose weight and keep it off, loses £138 in nine months. i did. goal is a lifestyle change and you make the change and it stays off. if you're 50 or over

, youan be taking advantage of erything aarp has to offer ght now join aarp for $12 for one year and your second membership is free, get instant access to discounts on everyday purchases. i care and prescriptions and tools and tips to help manage your money and maximize your health. plus aarp fights to protect your social security, medicare and more, join and get an insulated trunk organizer free plus aarp the magazine call or go to yes. aarp .org now sometimes, one thing leads to another thing. then all of a sudden, it's on with roman . you can take care of erectile dysfunction discreetly. so whenever the moment happens, you're ready. roman ready? i'm living done all american gymnast and fiori athlete when you're in the gym every single day like me, you need leggings that can keep up. that's my viewers. daily leggings are my favorite fit with the drawstring high waist and buttery soft fabric

that moves with these you'll want to wear these every single day. from the toughest workout to running areas or just lounging. there's no mistake in the name i wear these on the daily. you need to deliver new apps fast using the services you want in the clouds of your choice with flexible multi cloud services that enable digital innovation and enterprise control. vm ware helps you innovate and grow. the earth is full of color. now going green is to threaten it from 100% recycled plastic bottles, comfortable, washable, stylishly sustainable brother these green in every color. spot, does it? obediently. boy. wonderful pistachios, get cracking it simply safe. we build advanced

security sensors and cameras for your whole home. 24 7, professional monitoring and fast protect technology exclusively from simply safe for faster police response. there's no safe , like simply safe when it comes to reducing sugar in your family's diet choices, the better that's why america's beverage companies are working together to deliver more great tasting options with less sugar or no sugar at all. today nearly 60% of beverages sold contains zero sugar. different sizes. check clear calorie labels. just check with so many options. it's easier than ever to find the balance. that's right for you. more choices. less sugar. balance us .org people remember ads with the catchy song to help you remember that liberty mutual customizes your home insurance. here's a little number. you'll never forget customized. only pay for what you need. liberty liberty, liberty carousel

nighttime patches. she's improving the look of her fungus damage nail while she sleeps. only carousel patches work for up to eight hours to reduce discoloration and thickness. that's what i called beauty. sleep. nighttime patches. we've got you covered. i hear you're more than just a landowner. you're a gardener. landscape er hunter. because you didn't settle for ordinary same goes for your equipment. versatile powerful durable taboada equipment more goes into it, so you get more out of it. okay let's talk penmanship. porn penmanship. porn is a community on reddit where people can fawn over beautiful examples of penmanship and watch other people's writing. i'm back with my panel. okay, so first, let's put up one of our panelists,

penmanship and let's all judge it and then look at okay, let's so this is okay. so this is clearly a psychopath who has written this. this right here is evans. yes it's totally legible. i can read it. it looks great. okay now, let's look at the next example. the next example. okay okay, that's pretty. that's pretty amazing. first of all, you signed it, so we've seen that that's here. okay nice. this is me and i just want to say this is proof that i'm better than mediocre white men because i have cerebral palsy. resting position of my hands is like a kangaroo. i still wrote better. how did you do that? with several policy? how did you is it hard to write inside? it's hard, but the thing is, i knew about penmanship porn, and i wanted my riding to reflect the fact that i vibrate. because i thought it would help me do better and thank you avenue eight seconds. my penmanship. i was just trying to promote abstinence and but proof that is my therapist is going to get a

lot of flowers up on their real isn't to follow up on that. yeah okay, well, one more thing. i just have to show one more thing. patrick yours is on a cocktail napkin. well i mean, what does that tell us? the hotel room. you can't even get stationary. use my napkin. that's all i could get. that doesn't say parents ship porn? i don't know. what does thank you all okay? get in very quickly. let's get in gideon's right there. it was clean cocktail napkin, okay? but wow. you are a robot getting he's a robot. alright, guys. thank you very much. great to have you all here tonight before we go tomorrow on cnn this morning, republican senator mike rounds, joins to talk about today's big banking hearing. in the senate, and if there's any possibility of gun reform in the wake of the nashville shooting tune in for cnn this morning, starting at six a.m. eastern, right here on cnn, thanks so much for watching our coverage continues now. from friends coming over. mom's coming over. so many ways to

save life ready, happy 3 65 by whole foods market prone to hair thinning genetically predisposed just gave birth is under a lot of stress. older i started taking nutritional natural and it's clinically effective. neutral fall is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplements with in like months i noticed becoming stronger and thicker. neutral has taken me back to the hair i was meant to have i am back to me. start your hair growth journey at neutrophils .com. well changing question. is your investment portfolio really customized? some advisers say they customize them. but all they really do is ask you a few questions, then put all your money in a model portfolio. creative planning each of our private wealth management clients. portfolios is unique. your investment mix will be based on your custom financial plan. if that's not how your money is managed. you're not

getting the customization. you deserve. book your free meeting today at creative planning .com. creative planning. a richer way to wealth. here's your parachute certain it's okay. are you foreign prints certain. certainty matters, so congratulate coworkers or say thank you with promotional products from four imprint dot com. print for certain long care were easy. everyone would do it as well as true green. does it true greens online tools, help ensure your custom treatment works to deliver a greener, healthier lawn guaranteed. it's time to trust your experts at true green go online today. i am chevalier one day world. an outsider who rose to fame. he is the master of the sword maestro of the boat. risk everything is changing. i'm putting on a concept that is fun. the revolution to defy an empire. forget the old place. new front

you cannot topple, but it's been ordained by god revolution begin failure until true story 13. when you're the leader in disaster, cleanup and restoration. how do you make like it? never even happened happened. let it rain, randi. ah! being prepared for anything. whatever comes your way. there's a pro for that probe like it never even happened. what's it like to hear from the people actually living the headlines? cornish my new cnn podcast talks to the people behind the off scs

qr code don't wait code now and get the permanent solution protected by the bosley guarantee. this is cnn. the world's news network.