Skip to main content

tv   Fareed Zakaria GPS  CNN  January 14, 2024 7:00am-8:01am PST

7:00 am
have put their own personal ambitious ahead of what's right, they will ultimately have to answer the same questions that i had to answer after my decision in 2016. those questions don't ever leave. facts are really stubborn. they stay. >> former new jersey governor christie looked out at capitol hill on january 7th, 2021, and he hated what he saw. and he hated the role he felt he had played in it. and he feared that what might come next would be worse. >> i remember what benjamin franklin said when he was walking down the street in philadelphia after the constitutional convention and a woman approached him on the street and said, mr. franklin rngs what kind of government did you give us? he said to the woman, a republic, if you can keep it. >> can we?
7:01 am
thanks for spending your spunda morning with us. "fareed zakaria gps" starts now. this is gps, the global public square. welcome to you in the united states and around the world. i'm fareed zakari coming to you from new york. on today's program, the u.s. and britain strike the houthis in yemen. and the strife between hezbollah and islamrael heats up. is this turning into a war in the west? then, china's eagle eyes were watching across the strait as taiwan voted yesterday. what did they see? will the results bring us closer to conflict or further away? i'll ask an expert. also, escaping from north
7:02 am
korea. it's an incredibly dangerous prospect. would be defectors are likely to be tortured or killed if caught. we will bring you an extraordinary inside look at the journey out of the hermit kingdom with the people behind the new film, beyond utopia. it's almost three months since the ground invasion of gaza began. has it been proportional to the damage hamas inflicted on israel? has the israel government been careful to avoid civilian casualties? was there another path? i asked this as a supporter of israel. a country that i believe has been a remarkable success in an environment that was for decades
7:03 am
deeply hostile. i'm also dismayed and appalled by the rise of antisemitism across the world which is a powerful reminder as to why israel was founded in the first place. the international court of justice began to determine if israel's government is committing genocide against the palestinian in gaza. i think the charge is invalid. there's no systemic effort to exterminate gaza's population. if there were, given the vast disparity in power, israel would surely have killed more than 23,000 people. of course, that number is still staggeringly high. the death toll comes from the hamas-run health ministry in gaza. genocide is an incendiary accu accusation that should not be used loosely. never the less, some deeply troubling facts may emerge about israel's bombing campaign. israel suffered a brutal terror attack on october 7th and had the right to respond forcefully,
7:04 am
but consider what it has done in a small territory housing 2.2 million people, half of whom are children and by which of israel's estimate, only 30,000 are hamas fighters. a "wall street journal" analysis of israel's bombing campaign notes that by mid december, nearly 70% of gaza's 439,000 homes and half its buildings have been damaged or destroyed. much of the water, communications and healthcare infrastructure that made gaza function is beyond repair. of gaza's 36 hospitals, only eight can still accept patients. u.n. monitor's reports that more than two-thirds of all schools have been damaged as have several churches and over 100 mosques. in roughly two months, israel caused more than destruction in gaza than the battle of aleppo and syria or the raising of
7:05 am
mariupol in ukraine and killed more than civilians than a three-year campaign against isis. israel's campaign has exceeded the destruction of the allied bombings of germany in world war ii and as the university of chicago notes, is one of the most intense civilian punishment campaigns in history. cnn reported in mid december that u.s. intelligence estimated that 40 to 45% of the 29,000 bombs israel had dropped were unguided. indeed, a top israeli admiral acknowledged before the ground invasion began that while the idf was balancing accuracy, right now, we are focused on what causes maximum damage. prime minister netanyahu has evoked the biblical story in which god tells the israelites to kill every man, woman, and child, destroy all property,
7:06 am
even kill every animal in retaliation for a surprise attack. the committee to protect journalists reports that more journalists have been killed in the first ten weeks of the israel gaza war than have ever been killed in a single country. the united nations reports that more u.n. aid workers have been killed in gaza than in my other conflict over the 78 years of the organization. it's possible that some of these numbers are misleading. but are all of them coming from various sources wrong? this military campaign is being perpetrated by a deeply unpopular government in jerusalem that is trying to salvage its reputation. polls sense the start of this conflict have shown that most of the israeli public has lost faith in netanyahu. a poll last week found only 15% of those surveyed wanted netanyahu to keep his job after the war.
7:07 am
69% wanted elections as soon as the war ends. it is awkward to note this, but prime minister netanyahu has every incentive to keep the military campaign going in the hope his day of reckoning can be postponed or put off. having bungled the strategy toward hamas before the war, he is trying to use maximum force now for political compensation. israel is a democracy and open society. and precisely because of that, it will one day have to ask itself whether it acted appropriately in the heat of its anger and sorrow after october 7th. friends of israel should help it ask those questions now so that it does not look back on this episode with shame and regret. go to cnn.com/fareed for a link to my "washington post" column this week. and let's get started.
7:08 am
sunday marks 100 days since hamas' terrible attacks of october 7th and today, the wider war in the middle east that many feared may be upon us. on thursday, the united states and the united kingdom conducted strikes against the houthis. the iran-backed yemeni rebel group that has attacked commercial vessels in the red sea in recent weeks disrupting commerce. hezbollah is heating up in lebanon. joining me now is professor of international relations of the london school of economics. welcome. it's so good to have you here as a deep scholar of this area. let me start with the most urgent issue, which is these american and british attacks on the houthis. it feels like the united states is getting drawn into a conflict
7:09 am
that is going to be very difficult to declare victory over. the houthis have withstood ten years of saudi air strikes, bombardment, war, and what they're doing is launching cheap drones that are causing all this damage. is there a possibility that these american and british strikes will work? >> probably 10% out of 100. i think the big question, fareed, is that the biden administration is getting sucked into the shifting sands of the middle east with really eyes wide open. and we have been there before. but let's unpack biden's position for a minute. from day one after hamas' bloody attack on israel on the 7th of october, the key objective of the biden administration has been to prevent the escalation, the spread of the conflict from gaza.
7:10 am
what does it mean? it means giving israel time and space to accomplish its mission while preventing and deterring any group or nation from really lending help to the palestinians. this strategy has failed. the war in gaza has spread near and wide. it's escalating. it's escalating that my fear is that the longer the war goes on in gaza, the greater risk of a region wide conflict. and the biden administration is partly responsible for this because it has really the key to resolve this particular crisis by agreeing to a humanitarian cease fire, which most of the world had been calling for in the past three months or so. >> so let me ask you about the other piece you mentioned, which is hezbollah. what is likely to happen when the conflict started, the head
7:11 am
of hezbollah made a kind of remarkable statement where he seemed to say i wish you well to hamas. we did not know about this in advance. but we're not joining in. so there was a question, a pragmatism. do you think hezbollah could get more drawn in? because it seems lieke things ae changing. >> you're talking about the leader of hezbollah. he has made very clear in multiple speeches that he does not really want all out war with israel. he has made it very clear there is no really, i mean, centralized command for the various resistance groups in the region. maybe he said clearly look, we support each other. we coordinate with each other, but there's really no central command and control. each one of us, he says, quote, unquote, basically acts according to their own national interest.
7:12 am
and in fact, the united states itself has made it very clear that hezbollah has been acting with restraint. hezbollah has not targeted islamabad's population centers but if you look at what's happening in the past few weeks, it really is israel that has been pushing hezbollah to the limits. it's provoking hezbollah. it has been killing its, i mean top commanders in the field. it's had attacks hezbollah in the very heart of its social base in beirut and the south. it has killed scores of hezbollah members in syria. more in the path three months. 19 hezbollah fighters, than in the past year. and the united states is terrified. is terrified and is really trying to basically pressure israel not to provoke hezbollah. israel also, fareed, and the defense department, the u.s. defense department, has been
7:13 am
furious. it targeted the lebanese army 34 times in the last three months and if you ask me what's happening here and i mite come across as too cynical, but i think netanyahu's political future depends on the continuation of the war in gaza and probably its expansion. because when the guns fall silent in gaza, he knows that there will be reckoning, public reckoning. public reckoning for his strategic failure on the 7th of october and his failure to deliver on his promises. >> let me just ask you before we go, i want to ask you about this one other piece of news which is the saudis reaffirmed that they wanted to normalize relations with israel. that strikes me as unusual given everything that's going on. what do you think, what do you read into that? they really don't care about the palestinian issue? how would you read it?
7:14 am
>> well, the other part which you did not mention is that they will not, they will normalize only when isaac accepts to allow the palestinians a state of their own. at the end of the day, top down normalization was autocrats will not give israel security. the only security that israel can have the genuine reconciliation with the palestinians. fareed, genuine reconciliation with the palestinians. means ending israel's military occupation. it means allowing palestinian determination. it means being a good citizen its neighborhood and being at peace with itself. this is the only way that israel can really live in peace in the region. not with this fake normalization with autocrats that will never deliver security for israel. >> always a pleasure to have you on. thank you, sir. next on gps, concerns about
7:15 am
a future conflict in asia. did yesterday's election in taiwan put the self-governing island on a path toward ever greater problems with mainland china? when we come back.
7:16 am
7:17 am
7:18 am
7:19 am
yesterday's election in taiwan might push the self-governing island closer to conflict with china. at least that is the fear. taiwanese voters chose lai as their new president. the current vice president and a member of the ruling democratic progressive party which wants closer ties with washington and other democracies. he won against two rivals who both in various ways favored a warmer relationship with beijing. in response to the election, a chinese government spokesman said the basic fact that taiwan is a part of china will not change. joining me now is bonnie lynn,
7:20 am
the director of the china power project at the center for strategic and international studies. bonnie, welcome. give us a sense, who is this guy who's just become president? >> thank you, fareed. it's great to join you. he has been in taiwan politics for quite some time. he has currently serves as the vice president of taiwan, but he's also held other national positions including premier of taiwan. he's also had positions at the local level. so in many ways, he is very much a seasoned politician as well as a supporter for some time. one thing we know is that part of what you alluded to is that prior to his, the recent years, he has taken positions that china used as pro independent. from a chinese perspective, they view him as a die hard worker.
7:21 am
that does raise tensions for china were to operate on this very ill-conceived notion of lai. >> what i'm struck by is help us understand the politics of taiwan. i think there's a general impression that everybody in taiwan wants independence but when you look at the polls, that's not the case. most people in taiwan just want the status quo. they're not independent, but they are basically in de facto indep independent. he wins 40% of the vote and the other two candidates together take 60%. does that tell you there's sort of a majority of taiwan is uncomfortable with this more assertive, anti beijing, pro washington position? >> i think you raise a really good point. if we look at polling, we don't see most in taiwan advocating for independence. most want to maintain the status quo and if you look at the
7:22 am
polling results, as you mentioned, he did not receive more than 50% of the votes at the presidential election. which is different from thai, where both in the 2016 and 2020 election, she received more than 50% of the votes. it's also important to note that not only did lai not receive 50% of the votes for the presidential election, when you look at the legislative u.n. elections, the dpp did not hold on to their majority. so one way to look at this and this is how china looks at it. is that lai does not have the popular vote in taiwan and nor does his party have control of congress. hopefully china has that perspective. it will put some moderation in terms of how china views lai as well as his ability to influence taiwan's policies. >> now for the chinese, as important as what taiwan does is what washington does.
7:23 am
i'm wondering if you step back from all of this, where do you think u.s. china relations are? because that's going to determine whether this particular hot spot explodes. it started off badly with the summit and such seemed to have gotten better since the last biden xi summit. has there been genuine progress on building a keenind of workin relationship or was that just show and no substance? >> if you look at u.s. china relations, it's probably a more important factor for how china thinks about taiwan. in the last couple of months, particularly since the biden xi meeting outside of san francisco, we've seen u.s. china relations stabilize to some extent. i would still say competition still defines u.s. china relations but it is interesting to watch what has happened the last week in u.s. china
7:24 am
relations. almost every day of the past week, we've seen some form of critical u.s. china engagement. monday and tuesday, we saw military to military talks between u.s. and chinese militaries. on wednesday and friday, we saw ministry from china's international liaison department engage with national security adviser as well as meet with secretary blinken. on thursday, we saw a call between secretary mondo and her counterparts. and i think that provides some counterway to however china may perceive election results. >> okay, we've got about 30 or 40 seconds left so i ask you to make this short. jim steinberg and steve hadley, two very senior, very seasoned offi officials are going to taipei to meet the new president. what do you think the message that joe biden is sending through these people is going to
7:25 am
be? >> i think one critical message is that the united states supports the democratically elected president of taiwan and we hope to maintain u.s. policy towards taiwan. it will be consistent regardless of who is the president and i believe both of those former leaders will be meeting not only with lai and the dpp, but also those of other parties including the kpp within taiwan. >> those are the two other parties that fielded presidential candidates. that was wonderful primer for us about the election. thank you. >> thank you. next on gps, we have something really special. an eye opening new documentary. it's a real life thriller about people trying to escape from what i call the worst country in the world. north korea. you don't want to miss this.
7:26 am
7:27 am
7:28 am
7:29 am
i think he's having a midlife crisis i'm not. you got us t-mobile home internet lite. after a week of streaming they knocked us down... ...to dial up speeds. like from the 90s. great times. all i can do say is that my life is pre-- i like watching the puddles gather rain. -hey, your mom and i procreated to that song. oh, ew! i think you've said enough. why don't we just switch to xfinity like everyone else? then you would know what year it was. i know what year it is.
7:30 am
academy award nominations will be released later this month and on the short list for the best documentary is a film called beyond utopia. it tells a powerful story about people trying to defect from north korea. but also a sprawling network of people risking their own lives to help. the film makers got extraordinary up close footage of one family's harrowing journey. to talk about that story and what it tells us about north korea, i spoke to the film's director and one of the film's producers, former cia analyst. welcome. both of you. let me start with you. you know, when i was at news week, we once did a kind of, the worst countries in the world list. you talk to experts and correspondents and we decided
7:31 am
the north korea ranked number one. i think the taliban afghanistan ranked number two because they were evil, but not that competent. north korea has this combination of pure evil with extraordinary brutal competence. so given that backdrop, which i'm guessing you agree with, explain what the stakes are for somebody trying to escape from north korea. what happens? how difficult is it? >> well, it's life and death situation. as you said, north korea is a failed state. but they are very competent about the security apparatus, their fear tactics, ability to control the population. so it's literally you're risking your life to flee north korea. >> of course you can't. the easiest thing to do geographically would be to go to south korea but that is a heavily armed, mined border. what's the path out? it's pretty complicated. >> it's complicated. you have to cross the river and
7:32 am
go to the china north korea border and cross the river and go through the mountain. all of that to flee north korea. as you said, you can go across the dmz and there are instances in the past, a few years ago, a north korean soldier tried to escape, got shot in the back. it's heavily fortified. soldiers. land mines. that's very risky. the real way to escape is really just the border. go through the border. >> when you go to north into china, you're not free as i discovered in the movie because if the chinese get you, they'll just send you back to north korea. >> i think that's one of the most important things about this film. you realize you think that most people might think okay, fleeing north korea is the hardest part. no, that's just the first step and the real danger begins when you're in china because china's policy is to not recognize them as refugees. they call them economic migrants
7:33 am
and they have this long standing policy of repate rating them forcefully back to north korea knowing exactly what fate awaits them. >> but it's not even just china. then you get past china. you've got to go into laos. >> it's very treacherous journey until they make it to thailand. >> you've got to cross through three countries usually before you get to freedom. >> it's a long trek. >> madeleine, to me, the most extraordinary thing is you are watching this family escape from north korea. in the most dangerous circumstances and we're seeing it all. you couldn't have had camera men. it feels like it's being shot on iphones. how did you manage that? >> i have to give so much credit to pastor kim, south koreafoll .
7:34 am
he is the reason we were able to shoot in places where nobody goes. nobody wants to to go. the border of north korea and china, it's a more than 800 mile river border and the underground railroad and pastor kim's network keeps flip phones and cameras hidden along that border and that is how we were able to do this. >> how many people helped this one family? >> in this one escape, there were more than 50 people from the underground railroad involved in that escape. >> describe the journey because we see some of it and it feels like they're going through forests. going through jungles. and they just have the keep moving. the little kid gets hurt. the mother just says you've got to keep moving. >> yeah. >> yes. so, the journey begins in china, which is a huge country. in this particular case, they went through china into vietnam and then into laos.
7:35 am
then over the mekong river into thailand. yeah, we had different -- every single thing had to be vetted in such a delicate fashion. in china, none of us were in china, obviously. that was only the underground railroad shooting and one family member of the family who we followed. we were able to be in southeast asia, but there were areas where someone could be but not someone else. this camera could be used, not that camera. it was -- >> how did they trust you as an american? the grandma says i was suspicious of these americans, but how did you work on it? >> for grandma, you could feel the sort of dialectic inside her. on one hand, every time she looked at me, she would kind of tear up. there was this kind of, she was grappling with what she has known to be true her whole life in north korea, which is that we are her enemy, and what she was experiencing in the moment, in
7:36 am
the present. and it was this unfolding that was extraordinary. >> when we come back, we'll find out what happened to the row family. did they make it to freedom? stay with us.
7:37 am
7:38 am
7:39 am
7:40 am
more now on the film about north korean defectors. we're going to unfortunately d a bit of a spoiler alert, but the row family does make it. there's this extraordinary moment, the last stage of it is crossing over to thailand. crossing the river. and that is also very fraught and the pastor says something i thought was so good. he says until now, you have been
7:41 am
running away from the the police. now i want you to run to the police. i want the thai police to arrest you because they will send you to south korea, not north korea. that must have been i mean just amazing moment to capture on camera. >> yeah, and for the row family, who because kbrgrowing up in no korea, you learn essentially nothing about the outside world. so you know, like you said, they were running from the police. hiding from the police. in china. in vietnam. in laos. even to be told that is such a, even to grapple with that and run toward the police as you say, yeah, it was an extraordinary moment and then you know, to see them when they get to thailand and they actually are safe. >> you know, to me, the watching the grandma kind of get
7:42 am
unbrainwashed is fascinating, right? because she begins when they talk to her and she starts saying, you know, i don't understand why kim jong-un doesn't do a better job. he's badly advised. then his daughter, the daughter says to her mother, you don't have to lie anymore. but she's not lying. she's slowly getting unbrainwashed. and then she says to you what i don't understand is i was told americans are monsters but you are so nice. that must have felt good. >> it was amazing. then she goes on to say but sometimes i think well maybe they're pretending to be nice and they're actually going to kill us because we're north korean. so it was this real back and forth in her own mind. that was so fascinating to watch. >> well, i talk a lot about ideological indoctrination that goes on in north korea, but that scene when the grandmother just
7:43 am
says, she's in vietnam and she sees how prosperous it is and she says but this cannot be our dear leader's fault. this must be our fault. that just says volumes. that speaks volumes about the id logical indoctrination she went through her whole life. >> how do they maintain in north korea that level of indoctrination, that level of repression? it does feel unreal. >> it is the most closed off society in the world. i think they have perfected totalitarian control more than any state in the world. this is how the region survives. through monopoly on information. by isolating its population from the rest of the world. field tactics. south of the border, there's south korea. tenth largest economy in the world with all the increasing
7:44 am
self-power. how does the north korean region survive? they have to have this unparalleled control of its population. >> give us an update since we have you. you were the lead cia analyst on north korea. what's going on? is there anything new that we're worried about gaza and iran and russia. we forget this nuclear armed, rogue, failed state. >> yeah, i think there's a continuing danger because geopolitical environment is actually favorable for north korea. the whole world is distracted. meanwhile, they are diversifying, expanding, modernizing, perfecting their arsonal. they just had a successful satellite launch after two failed attempts only two months after kim pemeeting putin, thers a new closeness between russia and north korea. north korea just sent artilleries and rockets. the russia use in ukraine cities. so there's a lot going on and of
7:45 am
course in the humanitarian situation is not getting better. k kim jong-un regime is cracking down on its public, the population, because he's very worry about information coming into north korea. so situation is worsening, but the world is you know, so much going on. and united nations security council completely paralyzed. china, russia, working with north korea. >> there's a lot of heartbreak in this movie. there's another family, one of the characters in the movie says in the film says we were just born in the wrong country. that seemed to me the most heartbreaking moment. >> yeah. it was so important to me to put in the film. and also something that lee, another person in the film says. she said people always say why don't the north korea people revolt? why don't they just sand up to their leader? she says i believe that everyone else would be exactly like us if
7:46 am
they were brought where we we were brought up because we didn't know what existed outside. we lived in a virtual prison. so it's like those two things. i mean, born in the wrong country. it's the luck of the draw that we were not born there. that's why i wanted to make this film. 26 million people who we have not really acknowledged in our media for more than 70 years, they were born in the wrong country and that line was so important to me. it's heartbreaking. >> well. you made an extraordinary movie, both of you. you should be very proud. thank you for sharing it with us. >> thank you. the film is beyond utopia. it's available to watch on pbs and other streaming services. next, as everyone is worried about ukraine's prospects, we bring you an inspiring story about ukraine's attempt to turn its democracy digital and strengthen its liberal democratic credentials.
7:47 am
that story when we come back.
7:48 am
7:49 am
7:50 am
this election is a choice between results or just rhetoric. californians deserve a senator who is going to deliver for them every day and not just talk a good game. adam schiff. he held a dangerous president accountable. he also helped lower drug costs, bring good jobs back home, and build affordable housing. now he's running for the senate. our economy, our democracy, our planet. this is why we fight. i'm adam schiff, and i approve this message.
7:51 am
when i was in ukraine, i had the opportunity to sit down with the deputy prime minister for innovation, education, science and technology. he is the man behind ukraine's drone fleet and we aired an interview about that, but he also serves as minister for dinl tall transformation and what a transformation it is. in this war ravaged country, the citizens can now pay taxes, receive benefits, get a driver's license and more all via an app. as it fights for its own survival, ukraine is showing the world how to make government tech savvy and nimble. i talked to him about these efforts and i wanted to bring you that conversation now. i'm amazed when i have been
7:52 am
dealing with ukrainians and talking to them. everybody has these digital apps. they have the passport on there. their driving license on there. they have a national id. they have the equivalent of our social security card on there, but many, many apps. is this now, is it a kind of digital first strategy where the primary documentation is now all digital? >> translator: yes. we have special laws. we have become the first country in the world to adopt laws making electronic passports comparable to physical passports. we even have an option to get electronic driver's licenses without getting plastic licenses. this is our country's strategy and we are implementing it actively. and today, our core app dia is used by more than 70% of all ukrainians. it is very popular. in all the services are launched
7:53 am
first online then offline. so this is our strategy. launching digital first. >> and with this app, dia, what can an average ukrainian do on that app? that we would not think you can do digitally? >> translator: your electronic passport is there. you can get any kind of services using this passport. you can pay taxes. you can receive fines for parking illegally or traffic violations. you can donate to the armed forces. you can get any certificate you may need to submit to government agencies. and during the full scale war, you can get social security payments and benefits if you live for example in the area of hostilities. the government understands that and makes targeted payments. and if you are in the occupied territory, you can use it to pro provide information about the
7:54 am
equipment and provide information to the armed forces about the enemy's location and more than 5,000 ukrainians have provided information about the enemy in the territories. >> and you can file for damage payment, right? if your biluilding is bombed by the russian, you can just go on our app and say by building is bombed, i'm putting in a claim. >> translator: right. right. today, this is the most relevant service for people whose real estate has been damaged or destroyed. they can use dia to file such a claim then the claim gets to a special register. everything is checked automatically. very few bureaucrats participate in it. everything is transparent, documented. therefore the service is rather transparent. and the world bank sees that. they see how all of it is built. and donors are helping us to rebuild the country because the process is quite convenient on the one hand and very
7:55 am
transparent on the other. >> so when the war began, you tweeted out saying, hey, if people want to contribute, donate to ukraine, here's how you can do it and i think you opened a kind of crypto wallet like thing and you created a portal called 24. how many people, how much money have you raised this way? >> translator: right. we have supported foundations engaged in raising money we launched the united 24 platform and through the platform, we've raised about $500 million from all over the world. people would donate for drones, for boats. here for example, there is a boat for which people also donated money from all over the world. we were able to do it thanks to the united 24 platform. in fact, we took our digital expertise and made it convenient
7:56 am
nrd in order to get donations with weekly reports and involvement from stars all over the world who use the platform. >> what's the future? what are the next steps you dream about for the digital transformation of ukraine? >> reporter: we want the gdp to grow in ukraine. we want to have our own google, apple, and other big tech companies. to do that, we need to transform our education system. we want to build the most convenient, comfortable country in the world in terms of government services. >> thanks to minister fed rof and for all of you for being a part of my program this week. i will see you next week.
7:57 am
7:58 am
7:59 am
8:00 am