with the nba to inspire mental fitness in everyone laura coates live next on cnn closed captioning brought to you by book.com if you or a loved one have mesothelioma we'll send you a free book to answer questions you may have. call now and we'll come to you. >> 808 two one 4000. >> breaking tonight. unfortunate development for one of the world's legendary pop stars. elton john has announced that he can no longer see i haven't been able to come to many of the previews because, as you know i've lost my eyesight so it's hard for me to see it but i'd love to hear it and it

laura coates live starts right now president biden getting plenty of criticism over his decision to pardon a son from his own party. >> well, one democrat who's congratulating his decision is my guest tonight. plus, he's donald trump's pick to run the fbi, and he wants to turn the agency's headquarters into what he's calling a deep state museum. so who is kash patel and what would the fbi look like if he were in charge? and the defense in daniel penny subway chokehold trial makes their final case to the jurors. the one key question that they want them to hear before they start their deliberations tonight. on laura coates live so democrats are finding

themselves once again in a bind over a decision or a choice from president joe biden. now, first, it was his choice to run it all, frankly, in 2024, only to leave the party scrambling in the wake of his well disastrous debate performance. well, now it's the pardoning of his son hunter, after publicly insisting personally and through the white house press secretary that he would not. look many democrats say that they are totally sympathetic to the idea of a father who is protecting his son. but what they're not sympathetic to is biden saying one thing and doing another. later on. i mean, imagine a politician doing that. here are some of the words being thrown around by democrats. wrong decision. a mistake. unwise. wrong. wrong. now they say it sets a very bad standard. the president should not choose his family ahead of the country. senator michael bennet says it's erodes americans faith in the justice system it just gives the

american people a sense that there's one system for the rich and powerful, and another system for everybody else, which is what one of the reasons why we haven't been able to keep donald trump from coming back here again for a second term. well congressman glenn ivey predicts it's going to give trump some fuel for his attacks against his enemies this is going to be used against us when we're fighting the misuses that are coming from the trump administration. i mean, he's not wrong about how it's going to be used. i mean, trump is already on the offensive. he's calling the pardon a quote, miscarriage of justice. that's pretty interesting because that's the same language joe biden used in his statement announcing the pardon. he says that hunter was unfairly prosecuted and that type of federal tax and gun charges that he was always facing are almost never brought to trial. now, trump himself has given his own controversial pardons. he's also made it clear he wants to

take a sledgehammer to the justice department, and has suggested pardoning january 6th. defendants all by the way, long before this, hunter biden pardon. so is it really the precedent? democrats are worried about? i mean, cnn is hearing from multiple sources tonight and officials who worked for joe biden that they never actually believed a pardon was off the table. i mean, you'd be naive to think that it wouldn't be good to be the king, right? but one ex-official says it was, quote extremely, painfully obvious that this was where things were indeed going to end up. sources telling cnn that hunter biden would not have ever agreed to plead guilty without the expectation of clemency from his father. now, the white house claims the final decision was reached. only this weekend, but saying one thing and doing another is why a lot of americans say they're fed up with washington, d.c., period. democratic senator tim kaine was quick to point out he didn't need to tell the american public, i will not do

this. >> and he did. and when you made a promise, you got to keep it i wonder if the senate is holding for both democrats and republicans. >> i want to bring in democratic congresswoman jasmine crockett from texas. she serves on the house oversight committee. glad to have you here. congresswoman, i'm eager to get your take on this, because, look, i mean, you have actually congratulated president biden. you seem to be at least publicly, in the minority among democrats in the house. why do you think you are in the minority here? and is it sincere? >> um first of all, it is sincere and you know, i can't say why my colleagues are acting the way that they are. i can say that the american people are tired of us bringing a butter knife to a real fight, a real war. and the reality is that you know, a lot of my colleagues, even if they are lawyers, they've never practiced law they've never actually been in a courtroom, something that you've done before. and laura, you and i haven't rehearsed this, and i'm not supposed to do this

because, you know, we're never supposed to ask a question you don't know the answer to. but chances are i'm going to go out on a limb and say you've never prosecuted anyone who was a drug addict, and they filled out an application to get a gun before. correct. okay. all right. so in my experience, because i did practice criminal defense for almost 20 years, both in state courts as well as federal courts. i've never seen a case like this before. so, you know, when we look at this and as somebody who serves on oversight, i saw it up close and personal. listen, this was gamesmanship. they were going after his only son so that they could try to get at him. this was all about politics. and at the end of the day when the president said that he had no intentions of pardoning his son, i absolutely believe that he believed that in that moment. >> also, why would he have done that, congresswoman? i mean, in the grand scheme of things, as he wrote out in that statement, for the reasons you've suggested these charges alone, the accusations

alone normally would not have given way to a trial. but biden surely would have known. he himself, by the way, was a defense attorney for a time in his earlier career. he himself would have known how this all worked, so to speak. why wouldn't he have given himself some room to even equivocate? why would he have said so definitively if that might have been in the future? >> i can't tell you why he did it. i can tell you that at the time that he said it, though, he was number one, the democratic nominee to go after a second term and circumstances have changed. not only did he not end up becoming the democratic nominee to go into a second term, we know that trump and his administration, you were just talking about in your lead in about kash patel. and so not only is it that we lost but we now know that we have someone who is a convicted criminal that is going into the white house and seemingly is surrounding himself with questionable figures and the retribution that he's talked about seeking on the trail. you know, i think that the president is taking him at his

word and he's decided that he is going to protect his only son. and honestly, i think that it was the right move. listen, anybody that has a problem with a pardon, let me be clear about this the only way you get a pardon is if you've been in trouble in some way, and so, you know, at the end of the day there are really bad folk that trump decided that he would pardon when he was going through his first presidential. um, you know, when he served in his first presidency. listen at the end of the day, i need people to really recognize that we are living in some different times. and i applaud the president because the american people have been so upset with democrats not fighting back and not fighting with the same tools that the republicans have been fighting with. and we know that the supreme court has done what given immunity. his own lawyers argued to the supreme court that he should be allowed to have seal team six go out and kill somebody so people have given some. >> they have said that there is some form for official conduct

and acts really quickly, though democrats have been accused of seeking the moral high ground even at their own expense. are we seeing a shift now where democrats are no longer bringing that sort of butter knife and are just going to say, listen, we're going to fight in the way that perhaps they expect republicans to. >> i don't see the shift. you just said i'm in the minority but my question was about you being sincere. >> it wasn't whether you were sincere. but are there others behind closed doors who actually feel just like you do and are saying in front of cameras, this is unbelievable. i can't imagine it's ever happening. >> no, i think that others that feel the way that i feel they're actually quiet. i think the ones that are out front saying what they're saying they really believe what they're saying. >> why are they quiet? >> um, you know, everybody comes from different districts so a lot of people are always concerned about how will my district take this. but for me, listen, i'm fearless at the end of the day, i do believe in democracy. if my district ever feels as if i'm not

representing an authentic voice for them, then they will vote me out but one thing i can't do is not be myself. >> i see congresswoman jasmine crockett, always a pleasure to see yourself in this studio. good to see you. well, the white house says president biden will issue more pardons before he leaves office. but the question tonight is whether biden would entertain the pardon idea that's being floated today by senator joe manchin all in the name of balance i want to get your reaction to this news involving the president giving his son a pardon. >> he had said for months that he would not do that. and now he is. what's your reaction to that? >> i just as a father, i don't know if a father that wouldn't have done the same thing. it was not a criminal. i mean, it wasn't violent crime. it wasn't sexual crime. now, with that, he'll have to pay. i guess restitution, whatever he owes or this or that and things of that sort. but i wasn't surprised from that standpoint, what i would have done differently and my recommendations to counsel would have been, why don't you go ahead and pardon donald trump for all his charges and

make it, you know, it had been it had gone down a lot, a lot more balanced. if you will. >> so pardon him for the everything. well, i mean, he has he's been charged he hasn't been convicted on the federal on the federal cases. >> but i'm just saying wipe them out rather than going through all these court cases and getting, you know, the president has to be the president for the next four years fighting all these criminal and all this other stuff coming after him just clean that slate up. let's get this behind us and move forward. that's what i that's been my recommendation mhm. >> well joining me now cnn political commentator and republican strategist brad todd and democratic strategist chuck rocha. glad to have you both here brad. let's start there. should biden clean the slate and extend a pardon to donald trump? >> he should have already done it. he should have done it before the election. and and i think donald trump should have said he'd pardon hunter before the election. to tell you the truth, i think both of these men this is the one way they could have actually grown outside the caricature they've become of each other. it's one of the few ways they made up.

some people take a second look at them. >> well, interesting. you say that because trump intimated or suggested at one point that, you know, he wouldn't rule out the possibility of pardoning hunter because he felt as though he was treated badly by the justice department, which is odd, given his response to now the pardon issued by biden. they seem to be on similar page should he have done that, should he have issued or should he now, if you're biden, say, i'm going to pardon trump, i wouldn't have. >> but i'm one of those lefty democrats who don't think he should pardon anybody. if nobody's going to do any pardoning, we'd know who've done the most pardoning. and that is donald trump. just just like this decision with biden. i'm kind of like the congresswoman. i'm glad that he did it he should lean into it. i don't like the fact that he lied about it. like that's something that as a political consultant, i'll have to deal with for a year or two as people. yeah, yeah. and about that. but it's his son. he should have handlers around him. and i've run a presidential campaign. you tell them when they're going to answer that question, you can pivot away from that. i'm not going to put my hand on the scale. i'm going to wait till justice. that's the piece that aggravates me and kind of the sanctimonious letter. i didn't like that as much either, but i have no problem with the way some people are saying he

didn't lie. >> i think it was jamaal bowman earlier today with abby on her show. he was saying it didn't lie. and i'm paraphrasing that congressman, he didn't lie circumstances changed such that it was now appropriate to make a different decision. >> now that's complete bunk. and of course, jamaal bowman, we wouldn't expect anything but that from him. i mean they said it ten different, ten different times. he's a noted herbalist. he's a fabulous ten different times. the white house categorically denied he was going to pardon him now he's his son. everyone gets that. i mean, if he wouldn't do everything you could for your own son, then i would question it. but joe biden should have said i'm going to pardon him. and yes, he thinks the justice department is out of control. i think that's something everybody should be able to agree on. the doj politicized this too many prosecutions and it's time for reform. >> well, this is the question i have. what is more important, it seems, for the critics. is it the fact that he pardoned his son or the fact that he first said that he wouldn't pardon his son and then did? so when you look at the balancing

of these two, quote, unquote offenses, which is more problematic for you as a strategist it's the part that you brought up a while ago with the congresswoman when a lot of democrats not me, have said that we are better than republicans, we're better than republicans because they do. >> this thing makes us more democratic. we are better than them. kind of talking down to them. i can have a whole ted talk about the democratic party talking down to folks with cowboy hats. i'm just saying that that's the part that gets me. that's the part that bothers me the most. like i just said, i gave you my opinion on the pardon. it's the part about when we say that we're better than them, and then we do what he did. and i'm glad that he did it. i'm going to say it again. >> that's the part that bothers charlamagne tha god had a statement about this very notion of moral high ground today, and the democrats need to get off it. listen i just want democrats to stop acting like they are on this moral high ground politically when they have shown us they're not, you know, whether it's skipping the primary process. >> when biden stepped down and things like biden pardoning his, pardoning his son stop acting like you are the pure party and republicans aren't. and it also shows me elected officials can do whatever they

want, as long as they have the political will and courage to do it. >> does he have a point? >> i think he does and i think one thing we're not talking about is yet is that this is not just a pardon for two crimes. this is a pardon for everything he did in ten years. i think it's going to open the door to a lot more investigation into hunter biden, because joe biden knows there's something else he needs to pardon hunter for. besides the two things that he's been charged with that's going to hunter no longer needs the fifth amendment to protect him from future prosecution. he's now pardoned. he can be compelled to cooperate. he can tell us his coconspirators. he can tell us other people. he did business with. he tells people he bought drugs from. there's now a window for hunter to open up about everything that was on that laptop. who helped him? did joe biden help him? did he ask for any favors that's where we are now, because biden chose to overreach with a ten year pardon. >> is there an appetite for it? that's the question for the american people. and whether, in fact it is if they believe biden's statements about this being a miscarriage of justice, i wonder if they'll think about that surely i doubt it's the end of the story. please stand

by, though, up next will christopher wray wait to be fired or will he step down to make room for trump's new and controversial choice to lead the fbi? plus, we've got new reporting about pete hegseth alleged past surfaces and the allegations, and it includes claims that questioned his ability to lead an organization like the pentagon. so why aren't some senators interested in even asking him about it? that's next you only come across an artist like luther vandross once in a lifetime. >> he was a boss from the beginning. luther said, i have a sound in my head. i got to get it out. you are my shining star. >> my. >> it was the most exciting time in the world. >> his life had extremely joyful moments and some really difficult moments. >> if we were to be able to talk to luther as fans, we would be able to say we just

love you, luther. >> never too much new years day at eight on cnn. >> it's the most wonderful time with verizon trade in any phone, any condition. >> this black friday, get iphone 16 pro on us and ipad and apple watch series ten. all three on us. only on verizon. >> bent finger appointment in 30 minutes. >> you got this one. remember, i don't want surgery for my dupuytren's contracture. two i don't want to wait for my contracture to get worse. three i want a treatment with minimal downtime. four i want a nonsurgical treatment. and five. >> and if nonsurgical treatment isn't offered i'll get a second opinion. >> let's go take charge of your treatment. >> if you can't lay your hand flat, visit. find a hand specialist.com to get started this is the sound of the season's favorite gift for a limited time. >> omaha steaks is offering the favorite gift package that includes our famous bacon wrapped filet mignon, our delicious air chilled chicken

breast burgers, franks sides and desserts, all for just 89.99. that's 64% off. order now to include four more burgers free. this exclusive tv offer is our best of the season and won't last. order today at omaha steaks. dot com slash tv. >> i love this whoa! >> how'd you get your teeth so white? >> well, you got to use the right toothpaste, doctor. >> see not all toothpaste whiten the same crest. >> 3-d white removes 100% more stains for a noticeably whiter smile. >> new personal best crest. >> take advantage of everything aarp has to offer right now. join aarp for $9 per year with a five year term, and your second membership is free. get access to discounts on everyday purchases eye care and prescriptions, and tools and tips to help manage your money and maximize your health. plus, aarp fights to protect your social security, medicare, and more. join and get an insulated trunk organizer free. plus aarp

the magazine. call or go to join aarp dot org now. >> what's up? you seem kind of sluggish today. >> things aren't really moving. >> you could use some metamucil metamucil. >> psyllium fiber helps keep your digestive system moving so you can feel lighter and more energetic. metamucil keeps you moving and try fizzing fiber plus vitamins. >> class dismissed. >> don't sit in courses you've already taken class at university of phoenix. you can save time by transferring prior eligible college credits plus, there's a transfer scholarship that can help you save money, earn your degree at university of phoenix oh, what a good time we will have you can make it happen again your business needs a network it can count on... even during the unexpected. power's out! -power's out! power's out! comcast business has got you covered, with wifi backup to help keep you up and running. wifi's up. let's power on! let's power on! -let's power on! it's from the company with 99.9% network reliability.

let's power on! power on with the leader in connectivity. get wifi backup for your business, or get started with comcast business internet. and for a limited time, get an $800 holiday bonus. call today. in more than 80 stores worldwide i'd shut down the fbi hoover building on day one and

reopening the next day as a museum of the deep state and i take the 7000 employees that work in that building and send them across america to chase down criminals. >> go be cops donald trump's pick to lead the fbi kash patel and his own words describing his dream plan to remake the law enforcement agency. >> joining me now someone who's been singled out by patel as a member of what he calls the deep state. cnn senior law enforcement analyst and former deputy director of the fbi andrew mccabe. i wonder what wing of the deep state museum they would put you in, andrew. at this point, if he actually is the fbi head. let me ask you, though, just you know, look, the former ag bill barr wrote in his memoir that patel would be would become the fbi's number two over his dead body. his words not mine. now, there's a real possibility that he could actually lead the fbi. so what would that really look like well, that's a great question

laura. >> and we don't have a really precise answer to that question because kash patel beyond the absurd hyperbolic comments he's made on a few podcasts has yet to articulate any distinctive vision for the fbi, how he thinks he would make it more productive or better. you know more accessible to the american public and more responsive to the demands of national security if we just if we just go by those podcast claims, he seems to be quite focused on eliminating fbi headquarters and greatly reducing the number of people who work there. i think it's really important that people should think about that in the context of how we got to where we are and the evolution of the fbi and the post. 911 era. responding to the realization that we failed to connect the dots on the intelligence that could have prevented the attack

on nine over 11, partially because we didn't disseminate intelligence. well, we had 56 field offices all working independently, not sharing information in the way that we needed to to protect the country. and so a lot of that consolidation at headquarters took place in the years after nine over 11, in an effort to work terrorism threats, more effectively and to protect the american people so if his proposal is to eliminate headquarters and to push 7000 people to work as cops, he should explain how he thinks that's going to impact how he thinks. that's going to make americans more safe. my argument would be it would not. >> that's got to be one of the first questions. if he were to go through a confirmation process about continuing that particular threat on that issue, but just taking a step back for a second, you know, trump is the one to have appointed christopher wray, by the way, he once called him a man of impeccable credentials. now he wants to fire him. remember, directors, they have a ten year term. they're supposed to outlast

presidential administrations. should wray stay put, knowing that he has someone in mind to replace him and wait to be fired a la jim comey? or should he step down you know, that's a tough one, and i can't profess to know how chris wray thinks about that. >> um my personal opinion is that there is an important, um there is an important point to make here, by the way. he handles this decision. and i think not letting the president elect off the hook. so to speak, remaining in your position, forcing him to take that unconventional action of firing a a director for some manufactured reason, i think that's an important step. it's an important marker for the record of history. i think it would be important to the men and women of the fbi. now, that said, i don't you know, from my short time working with director wray, i don't see him

as someone who's really inclined to those sort of, um bold, very public um moves but, you know, it's a matter of personal style. and what he thinks is important. and i suppose in the next few months, we'll find out. >> well, weeks at this point. andrew mccabe, thank you so much. i'm curious about what the morale must be like right now, thinking about who might lead. thank you so much for joining brad todd and chuck rocha. they are back with me, brad, i mean morale aside for a second, let's talk about the nomination process. there are some republicans who have ultimately praised this nomination of kash patel there are others who are a bit more equivocal about the entire thing. do you think that hunter biden's pardon might grease the wheel here in any way? >> well, yeah three camps, i think of republicans. there are some republicans who enthusiastically like kash patel and know him. there are some other republicans who

think a president ought to be able to have the ability to staff his administration. should some of those republicans voted for a lot of joe biden's nominees by the way, lindsey graham being one of them, who sits on the judiciary committee. so then there's another group that i think the jury's still out on. i think susan collins and lisa murkowski. everyone expects that they could be a no on kash patel. i'm watching chuck grassley and john cornyn. they both sit on the judiciary committee. it's possible they're both serving their last term in washington. chuck grassley came out with a tweet yesterday and said, i'm interested to hear kash patel plan to reform the department of justice, and he's got to make that case to the senate judiciary committee. i thought that was an interesting comment because he's he's looking for not just a rhetoric, but he's looking for a plan and i think that that would also imply that he's reserving judgment on how he might vote on the nomination so if you can't get every all but one republican senator on the judiciary committee, then you won't make it out to the floor. and if you can't get those on the judiciary committee, you probably can't pass on the floor so i think this nomination still has a way to go. but one thing is certain is whoever heads the fbi,

whether they're confirmed or whether they're acting directors, they're going to be reform head of the fbi. >> well, one of the things that and in that same vein, when patel has been talking about some of his plans and again, these are not things he has said now in front of the committee for confirmation but listen, chuck, to some of the things he's also saying about what these plans might look like we will go out and find the conspirators, not just in government, but in the media. >> yes we're going to come after the people in the media who lied about american citizens who helped joe biden rig presidential elections. we're going to come after you. whether it's criminal or civil. we'll figure that out now, of course, the fbi has directed not to go after purely first amendment concerns, but let me just ask you trump has also promised to go after in some vein, political enemies and adversaries. >> is kash patel the vehicle? >> look, it's just as he talks. it sounds crazy to me, and i think the american people will see that. speaking of the media, i don't reckon he's going to be in line for any of these cnn hero awards here at cnn this weekend.

congratulations on hosting that on sunday. that's right. and i was thinking about that outside because it was the same thing. i saw that commercial, i saw him, i was like, look, we are having these inspirational stories that you'll be talking about and others at the same time. we're talking about a guy saying we're going to punish the media or we're going to go in reform. reform. i understand that and probably anything and everything could take some reform at some level. but as a voter and folks who run elections, i think that this is going to be great for democrats because you can contrast. but i just don't think it's good for the country as we go through this process in any shape, form or fashion. >> i guess i think about what the role of the fbi is. and, you know, i know he will focus a lot on the so-called deep state but there's a lot of important things the fbi does as a supplement to local law enforcement and beyond to do a lot of things. i just i shudder to think about it being falling to the wayside. let me just turn for a second, brad, to the idea of the defense secretary nominee, pete hegseth because the new yorker has now obtained a whistleblower report that details misconduct allegations. they are allegations during his time leading

the concerned veterans for america nonprofit. some of them include being repeatedly drunk at events, taking staff to a strip club, sexually pursuing female staffers and on senators rick scott, brad mike lee, ted cruz and cynthia lummis have all said that they didn't discuss any of this in their meetings with pete hegseth and they they support him. does that strike you as concerning that they haven't asked questions about what these allegations say. >> no. i think the new yorker and this particular journalist in particular, has a long reputation of running hit pieces on republicans. this is the same reporter who said that the russians stole the 2016 election and swung the 2016 election for donald trump. i don't think this this report has any credibility with republicans. it's not. and it's all it's all people who are anonymous people who most of these republicans know personally, who worked with pete hegseth say it's not true. >> well, if that's true, i don't have any confirmation of that reputation you talk about. but if that's true, simply a question of look let's just talk about it. let me get it out of the way. they're saying

this, this and this about you what's your response? i'm not saying anything at all i'm sure that those questions will be asked. >> i'm sure there will be senators who ask it but the job of reforming the pentagon is a pretty big job, too. and there's only so much time in a meeting. and i would say that if i were a u.s. senator, the first question i would notice is, how are you going to handle this job? >> is this the same reporter that came up with finding the letter from his mama, saying that he was no good? or is this a different reporter? >> i see what you're doing there. see that different reporter i do, i'm just saying, when i read up on the stuff tonight, i don't do a lot of reading. >> i ain't going to surprise nobody at home. but i read the stuff you told me to read. we were going to talk about tonight. when i read that i was like, when you lose your mama like my mama has looked past a lot of things chuck roach has done. your mama going to love you forever when your mama comes out, you got a problem. so i think if your mama's not with you, the senate should have an easy confirmation. >> well, she has come back. >> she shouldn't have she shouldn't have written it. and she wishes she hadn't but she did write it at the time. >> but now she said, i do want to read for you, though. what hegseth adviser told cnn saying we're not going to comment on outlandish claims laundered through the new yorker by a petty and jealous, disgruntled

former associate of mr. hegseth. get back to us when you try your first attempt at actual journalism that clearly wasn't meant for me. let me ask you though, on this point, the new york times also obtained that, as you mentioned, that email from his mother. but more broadly, i still go back to this. these are claims that are going to come up. you would expect senators who are going to be a part of the entire process to ask about the things, at least to take the wind out of the sails, to have some response that can be complete and fulsome. why not just ask the questions? why not just get the lay of the land? why decide to ignore it? it's ultimately going to come up. >> it makes no sense to me because as a strategist, if i'm the republican, if it was a democrat in the same way, i'd want to know how the answer, because i know the other side is going to ask the question. so if i'm really with him ride or die. as bowman said tonight, i would want to know what the opposition is so i could try to give him other questions to help soften the blow, because i

know that the opposite party is going to send these questions. this is a lot of red meat. >> he's going to be asked, and he'll be asked by the staff and the prep for the hearing. there will be more than a bunch of anonymous quotes in the new yorker by the time this is over with, and we'll get to the bottom of it. >> well, we certainly will. we'll have to see how doge and the defense department might be looked at in tandem for a number of reasons. brad chuck, thank you both so much look, elon musk is now just days away from talking doge up on capitol hill. and already he has names of government workers that he wants to cut a former federal employee who says she once faced musk's public wrath joins me on that next and later. it could be the one question that decides daniel penny fate in his manslaughter trial. hear the defense team's final plea to jurors as they get ready to take the case cnn heroes on all star tribute meet and celebrate the honorees then find out who will be hero of the year, plus a special tribute to michael j.

>> fox, cnn heroes, an all star tribute sunday at eight on cnn shop. >> etsy cyber spectacular until december 3rd for up to 60% off all kinds of gifts carefully crafted by small businesses save big on the perfect presents for practical parents cute and cuddly creations for kids and other fetching finds made to make the holidays for any hard to shop for person on your list when you want up to 60% off gifts that say i get you. etsy has it. >> this thing gave me my life back 110 pounds in a year. >> woman is a little device that you breathe into that gives you a real time reading on your metabolism and create a customized nutritional plan for the day. >> i lost 45 pounds. >> it's been 25 years since i weighed what i weigh right now. >> if you're struggling, try this you're worth it. i was

holiday special $100 off, plus an additional 15% off with code lumen tv black and yellow friday sale now at lumber liquidators, 267 floors at up to 61% off. >> our already low prices. hurry in for these incredible deals now until december third. see lumber liquidators dot com with dexcom g7 managing your diabetes. >> just got easier. so what's your glucose number right now? good thing you don't need a fingerstick. how's all that food affect your glucose? oh, the answer is on your phone. what if you're heading low at night wow, it can alert you and you can even track your goals, manage your diabetes with confidence. with dexcom g7, the most accurate cgm. learn more at dexcom.com. >> does your wife know you spent over $600 on takeout? we're busy. >> we don't have time to cook. >> okay, but do you know you're also paying for a meal kit on top of that? wait really? look, just get rocket money. it shows

you all your expenses in one place, and it even tracks your subscriptions and any subscriptions you don't want. which for you, there's a lot you don't need. you can cancel right from the app. so you mean i don't have to call customer service to cancel? nope. no. hold times or anything. and we'll even try to get you a refund for the money you spent, which i'm sure your wife will be very grateful for. i'm a downloader right now thanks for calling consumer cellular ranked number one in network coverage and customer satisfaction. >> hi my friend linda has you guys. it gets way better coverage than i do. sounds like linda has you beat. not at bowling. you're breaking up a little. are you really ranked number one in coverage? yep. and plans start at just $20. oh, we could afford lessons for linda. you're embarrassing yourself. >> at least my phone works. >> switched to the carrier ranked number one in network coverage satisfaction and right now, get your second month free. call consumer cellular today. >> i know how hard this is. hard versus duty. but you signed up for this. we all did. >> this is national security. >> it's personali'm bill we're

california coast and this is cnn the department of government ethics, also known as doge, will execute their first piece of business. >> this coming thursday. it's a trip to washington, d.c., and once there, elon musk and the vivek ramaswamy will meet with congressional republican leaders to lay out their vision. but already musk is previewing some of his ideas on x. what's he saying? well, he is retweeting some supporters who are doxxing federal employees, exposing their full names, their positions where they work. it's a familiar tactic that musk and his fans have used before it's actually happened before in 2021, after the appointment of a new senior safety advisor at the national highway traffic safety administration, musk took to twitter, responding to a tweet critical of the new hire

saying, quote, objectively her track record is extremely biased against tesla unquote now, this employee was critical of tesla's self-driving software but after the musk tweet that employee received death threats and they eventually deleted all social media and even had to physically move from where they lived her name is missy cummings. she's a former senior advisor at the national highway traffic safety administration. she's now a professor at george mason university and she was also one of the navy's first female fighter pilots. missy, good to have you here. this evening. i want to ask you because your life was upended after musk tweeted about you personally accusing you of harboring bias against him. bring me into that experience what happened after musk tweeted that well when people say their phone exploded, i didn't really

know what that term meant until that happened so, you know, my phone explodes emails. >> people are calling me to tell me what's happening. you know i really didn't foresee this coming i had written a very actually boring academic paper that enraged the elon and his minions and, um but, you know, you just don't realize how fast somebody can go out of control uh, when there's an agenda of squashing any dissent whatsoever, it must have been unbelievably startling, but also daunting to figure out how you come from underneath the weight of that particular moment and all the attention you never wanted to get. >> i do wonder, in the times that we're in right now, when musk has engaged in behavior

that is similar identifying particular federal employees, what are you hearing from federal workers about his role prospectively well, since i work in dc now, even though i'm not working directly for the government anymore, i'm here. >> i have a lot of my friends are in various agencies and people are afraid people are. there have been a few people i know that have resigned from their jobs. they're like, you know that's it. i'm out. uh and the rest are just waiting to see. am i going to have to sell my house? am i going to have a job? is my agency going to be moved out of dc and you know, i think there's some uncertainty every time an administration changes but i've never seen anything like i see the fear now. and certainly my experience you know, people know that people know what he did to me and, you know, the good news is, is that i had fighter pilot training. so i

was like, bring it. but you know, not everybody has that kind of training. not everybody's been to prisoner of war school, you know? and i feel bad for other people who don't have the the training and just the resilience to pull from. so it's a pretty bad situation. >> well, what's your advice to those federal workers who are afraid, who don't have the same experience that you have had get a good lawyer. >> you would be amazed at what happens when you start throwing a lawyer around. you know, it's not clear that what elon says he's going to do as co-president is going to actually work and so, you know, i think arming yourself with a good lawyer and also get out of your house, i mean, that that when when they started coming after me, the death threat, you know, the police were involved and, you know, it's a terrible situation when you have to leave your house but i do this environment, especially after january 6th, we're just not

it's just not clear what people are willing to do and how far they're willing to go. and so the police told me that, you know, let this calm down. once he puts your information out there, you know, if you'll give it some period of time, things will calm down. but still, in that period of time, you just don't know what people are capable of. >> seems like a luxury for some to be able to pick up and go. i wonder, you know, how long people have to wait and can wait for things to calm down and yet, you know, one of the things that this all happened of course, before he owned x and now he's got an even bigger platform, so to speak bernie sanders, though, um he tweeted about some level of interest about certain parts of doge. and i wonder from your experience and your viewpoint is your critique with musk? um about him as a person or what he might be trying to do with the government

i have never criticized him as an individual, except for what he did to me personally and nor do i have any. >> i haven't had any major opinion about what he wants to do in the government, because i haven't seen any formal proposals. i'm a researcher who researches artificial intelligence safety, and that is my job to look at technologies that are in the marketplace and assess whether or not they're safe. i assessed his teslas. they are not safe when they are being driven on autopilot and full self-driving. that is my professional opinion i love spacex that is one company of his that i can't get enough of. but in this very divisive culture that we live in right now, you can't hold those thoughts and not be a bad girl. you know, i can't like spacex but, you know, i actually like the tesla vehicle itself but i

just don't like this one feature. but that's not enough for people. they feel like you have to be all in to support musk or somehow you're evil missy cummings. >> thank you so much for joining thank you. well daniel penny is high profile manslaughter trial nearing an end now as a new york jury gets ready to get the case. maybe as early as tomorrow. up next, the closing arguments from the defense and the one key question they want the jurors to now consider this holiday season, find the perfect gift at cnn underscored from the latest fashion to expert approved tech to the best beauty finds. >> discover it all at underscore com. >> this black friday, verizon will turn your old or broken phone into a gift anyone can trade in any phone in any condition and get samsung

galaxy s24 plus and watch and tab all three on us only on verizon. >> hey folks, chris coonan here with lee filter america's largest gutter and gutter protection company. lee filter has over 150 locations and has been installed on over a million homes. we've been protecting homes now for over 20 years. our patented technology offers total protection for your home and comes with a lifetime transferable warranty. the process is simple. give us a call to schedule your free gutter inspection if you decide to move forward with the project, you put nothing down at all. 833 lee filter or visit lee filter.com today. >> new projects means new project managers. you need to hire i need indeed. indeed you do. when you sponsor a job on indeed, it's easier for talented candidates to find it, which makes it easier for you to hire them. visit indeed.com slash hire. >> i tend to deal with things in life with a sense of humor. my therapist on betterhelp and i, we share this trait, and so we connect on a deeper level. and i'm more comfortable

sharing things with him the future is not just going to happen. >> you have to make it. and if you want a successful business, all it takes is an idea and now becomes a future where you grew a dream into a reality. the all new godaddy arrow put your business online in minutes with the power of ai. >> my hair was thinning all around my hairline. >> my dermatologist recommended nutrafol. >> it's 100% drug free and clinically tested. >> my hair is longer, thicker. >> nutrafol is life changing for me. >> get growing at nutrafol. com. if you know luxury it's not just award winning it's rewarding saatva mattresses, supports all types of sleepers luxury is handcrafted and assembled in american factories and brought directly to you with our complimentary in-home delivery and setup service, which is why over 90% of customers would recommend saatva to friends and family.

saatva luxury mattresses made affordable. >> what if you could tackle your dog's itching, soft stools and low energy? millions of pet parents are raving about doctor marty nature's blend, such a huge difference in your health. more energy more playful. no more pooping issues. >> i'm doctor marty. i've been a veterinarian for more than 50 years. the dangerous ingredients added to many pet foods could be impacting your dog's lifespan. that's why i formulated nature's blend. >> now you can feed your dog wholesome cuts of real meat, vegetables, and fruit with no artificial preservatives or fillers. try doctor marty risk free go to doctor marty pets.com slash tv, would you? >> yeah, you know bluechew. >> yeah. so it's like chewable tablets, things like. >> oh, girl, how do you know her, man? >> come on. and it made you like him more, right? >> absolutely. >> are you kidding? >> where do i get bluechew? well, you can go online and get your first month free. actually so when i move you move just like that. >> when i move, you move just like that. when i move, you move just like that hell, yeah. hey, dj, bring that back. when

i move, you move. >> just like that. when i move, you move the online store that was just breached has my payment info. >> during the holidays think of all the places that can expose your info lifelock monitors millions of data points for identity theft. >> if there's a problem, we fix it guaranteed rise up. >> this morning smile with the rising sun saying this is my message to the black friday sale is now on. >> visit sandals.com or call one 800 sandals. santa is coming to town. >> santa joy to the world all the boys and girls now we are. >> i'm enchanted. joy to you and me. >> i'm elizabeth wagmeister in los angeles and this is cnn who would you want on the next

train ride with you? >> that's the key question that daniel penny attorneys put to new york jurors today during closing arguments in his fatal chokehold trial. now penny's team hoping that very question will resonate with the 12 men and women who will ultimately decide whether penny is guilty of second degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide in the death of jordan neely. the defense framing the question as kind of a choice, saying, quote, the guy on the train with the earbuds minding his own business, who you know will be there for you if something happens or you just hope someone like neeley never enters, especially when you're all alone, unquote. well joining me now, criminal defense attorney arthur aidala. i'm so glad that you're here to help unpack this from the defense perspective. that question that was asked, who would you rather have on the subway with you? tell me, was that the right tactic to take with the jury like this? >> well, besides being a lawyer in new york city, i am a very frequent subway rider and

especially this time of year, it's really the only way to get around new york city, because of all the traffic. and i think that's a great question to ask because you know, we've many people who ride the subway. luckily, it's never gotten to this point. most of the time. but there are people who are yelling and screaming and just intimidating you. and, you know, there i am in my suit and my tie and my my fedora hat and i'm like, okay, i'm 57 years old. like, i'm going to start tussling with some guy. but then you see them like going after older people or on this particular case, there was a woman with a child. so i think jurors, those jurors who not necessarily ride the train every day, but who are on the subway and have encountered someone who has been as disruptive as mr. neely, is i know how they would answer that question. i would rather have daniel penny who's sitting there listening to his earbuds, not having someone who's yelling and screaming and throwing down their jacket and saying i'm i'm ready to rob. i'm ready to kill people. >> but that's not really going to be the ultimate question for the jury. and that could be

true that many will say yes, i prefer to have somebody who's not offending me in any way, but the prosecution is going to come back pretty strong and suggest, okay maybe you even want this person to actually stop the person from acting erratically. but at some point they had to stop before the person died. can the defense adequately defend against that prosecution strategy? well, the prosecution, even today in her summation, she was like it's very hard when a prosecutor goes up there and kind of says what the defendant here did was like the right thing until it became the wrong thing. >> she said he was doing the right thing. she said he was trying to help, except he went too far. and under those those circumstances where human beings they always tell you, use your common sense, use your common sense, can really relate to the anxiety and the adrenaline of the moment. and look, you know, they're all about how long did he hold him? as soon as the police came, he let go. but until the police came, he doesn't know if this

guy's got a gun. he's got a knife. what he's going to do if he releases him. so it's they're really talking about, i think 51 seconds or seconds so it's rare to have a prosecutor agree with the defense for a big hunk of what took place, except for a couple of seconds and new york jurors are going to do what new jurors want to do, and they're probably going to be 12 jurors fighting in that courtroom over the next couple of days. >> i mean, they're going to start to deliberate soon and they've got to unpack those different aspects of it. you can you can bet the jury instructions are going to come into play. i would bet there's going to be more than one question about how to interpret them you are friends with some of the members and personally know members of the daniel penny defense team. are you hearing anything about how they feel about his chances of an acquittal? >> no, i would never ask that to a lawyer on trial. knowing myself that i don't know what what's going to happen, because you get so emotionally involved. but you know jurors get emotionally involved as well. and i'm not saying they're not going to follow the law, but they are going to bring their own personal experiences into that jury

room. those interactions they've had on the subway or on the streets of new york with mentally ill people and look, there's a possibility here of a compromised verdict where you're charged. he's charged with murder in the second degree. i'm sorry manslaughter in the second degree, which is a most you can get is 15 years in jail. and then he's charged with criminally negligent homicide. which the most you get is four years in jail. so there is a possibility that some people say i'll never convict him other people say i'll never acquit him. and they meet in the middle at the criminally negligent homicide and then it's up to judge max wiley to determine a sentence. >> well, speaking of the judge, i mean, there is a world and a universe where somebody without a criminal record could possibly not go to jail. maybe not in the circumstance, but do you think the judge, if he is convicted, would sentence him to jail time? >> i know max wiley, since the summer of 1990, when i interned in the manhattan district attorney's office, i've appeared before him. if i had to make a small wager, i could definitely see myself making a wager that judge maxwell does not sentence him to prison. but

nobody knows because it would have such a chilling effect. i think, to good samaritans and the good samaritan statue of people saying, look, i'm not going to get involved anymore. i'll just take out my phone stay afar, i'll take a video of it and then after that person gets hit stabbed, that kid on the train gets attacked. well, at least i'll have it on my phone and i can show it to the police and the detectives and let them deal with it so i don't have to worry about going to jail. and that's kind of a rough way for citizens in any community to live. >> arthur aidala, we'll see what the jury thinks of all of it. thanks for joining us tonight. >> always a pleasure. >> well up next, an emotional moment for a music icon and his fans cnn heroes, an all star tribute meet and celebrate the honorees then find out who will be hero of the year. >> plus, a special tribute to michael j. fox, cnn heroes, an all star tribute sunday on cnn. this is not a drill.

>> subway dropped the price on all their subs. 20% off any sub, any size. >> subway did what any sub. yep. >> for a limited time, you get 20% off when you order in the app. hurry and get this deal before it's gone sounds like you need to vaporize that cold nyquil vapor. >> cool it's nyquil plus vicks vapors. people who nyquil vapocool the vaporizing nighttime sniffling, sneezing, coughing. >> best sleep of the cold medicine. >> take advantage of everything aarp has to offer right now. join aarp for $9 per year with a five year term, and your second membership is free. get access to discounts on everyday purchases, eye care, and prescriptions, and tools and tips to help manage your money and maximize your health. plus aarp fights to protect your social security, medicare, and more. join and get an insulated trunk organizer free. plus aarp the magazine. call or go to join aarp dot org now

believe it or not baby at university of phoenix you you you you could earn your masters for under 11,011. >> yes 11 master's degree for under 11 k in less than a year. some things are too obvious to be a coincidence. earn your competency based masters at university of phoenix did you know how you feel can be affected by the bacteria in your gut? >> try new align yogurt coated probiotic fruit bites with a delicious apple and blueberry flavored fruit center and yogurt coating. each bite is infused with added probiotics to help promote a healthy digestive system. every day. plus, they're packaged in individually wrapped pouches for daily digestive support. on the go. look for new line yogurt coated probiotic fruit bites online and in the digestive care aisle of your local retailer. bran power helping you buy better i'm a

forgotten subscription. >> poor guy. signed up for my free trial a year ago. i forgot to cancel. now he pays me $18 every month. it's awesome. >> don't let this happen to you. >> download rocket money today. >> your best defense against erosion and cavities is strong enamel. >> nothing beats it. >> i recommend pronamel active shield because it actively shields the enamel to defend against erosion and cavities. >> i think that this product is a game changer for my patients. it really works from tried and true to try something new so many ways to save life. get

started today at forbes.com luther. >> never too much new year's day at eight on cnn closed captioning brought to you by book.com if you or a loved one have mesothelioma, we'll send you a free book to answer questions you may have.

>> call now and we'll come to you 808 two one 4000. >> it's not personal. it's just competition. these are the words of houston texans linebacker aziz al-qahir posting an apology on x for his controversial hit on jacksonville jaguars quarterback trevor lawrence this past sunday. the hit forced lawrence out of the game with a concussion. his team visibly angry as you see there right after the play. al-qahir saying quote, my goal is to hit you as hard as i can. then i pray you're able to get up and play the next play. al-qahir, though, has been fined multiple times this season alone for on field incidents. lawrence, for his part, says he's home and feeling better glad to hear it. and our best wishes continue with elton john my husband who's been my rock because i haven't been able to come to many of the previews because, as you know i've lost my

eyesight so it's hard for me to see it. >> but i love to hear it. and it sounded good tonight. >> that's the legend. at opening night of his new west end musical, the devil wears prada. the update to his health comes after john disclosed a severe eye infection this summer, which he says is still keeping him from creating new work in the studio. and speaking of legends, well, moana two breaking box office records, grossing $389 million worldwide in its massive opening weekend. so of course, disney is not done with the franchise. in just two years, we'll be able to watch a live action remake. and yeah, the rock is in it. so with all that i leave you with a song from moana two sung by the rock himself, anita, can i get a who? >> who are you? >> who are you? >> what can i >> thanks for watching. anderson cooper 360 starts