Skip to main content

tv   Anderson Cooper 360  CNN  December 3, 2024 5:00pm-6:00pm PST

5:00 pm
picked up her luggage from lax, took a metro to union station. >> she used her passport and cash to purchase a ticket to get to the border. >> police say she crossed into mexico november 12th at 12:13 p.m. at san ysidro south of san diego. we basically done everything we can do at this point. >> she's left the nation left the country, and in another nation now. >> so now there are still a lot of questions and hannah kobayashi family is still looking for answers. >> they released a statement that reads in part, our family remains hopeful that hannah is safe and urges everyone to continue the search. the search is far from over and we are committed to doing everything possible to bring her home safely. they also say don't fall for speculative conclusions. i
5:01 pm
tonight on 360. >> breaking news on the president elect's pick for defense secretary. now facing growing republican skepticism and growing allegations of a drinking problem also tonight, what just happened in south korea is the country's president declares martial law. then un declares martial law, leaving a bulwark of democracy looking like anything but. plus, with all the security at airports, the latest on how one woman stowed away on a u.s. flight and made it to paris without a ticket including video of the very moment the stowaways ruse was uncovered mid-air. good evening. thanks for joining us. before we even getting to the new difficulties facing defense secretary or defense secretary designate, i should say pete hegseth nomination, there is breaking news on the end for another top pick, chad chronister named to head the drug enforcement administration, said late today he is bowing out. the hillsborough county florida, sheriff said on social media quote, as the gravity of this
5:02 pm
very important responsibility set in, i've concluded that i must respectfully withdraw from consideration. just last week, he called it, quote, the honor of a lifetime to be nominated. just a week and a half ago, another floridian, obviously matt gaetz, backed out of the running to be attorney general. and now, after several damaging reports on his alleged drinking problem, alleged sexist behavior and alleged financial mismanagement in a job related to veterans, pete hegseth pentagon nomination is drawing more doubts from the very same republican senators who support a republican nominee would ordinarily take for granted some of these articles are very disturbing. >> he you know, obviously has a chance to defend himself here. but, you know some of this stuff is going to be difficult. you know, time will tell. i like pete, i've known him for a very, very long time senator joni ernst, a republican who serves on the armed services committee, says she'll have what she called a frank and thorough discussion with hegseth when she meets with him republican kevin cramer of north dakota called the drinking allegations, quote, concerning. >> but said he was leaning yes on the nomination, telling
5:03 pm
cnn's manu raju quote, i'm interested in who pete hegseth is today and who he is going forward. susan collins of maine had this to say as a i've repeatedly said to you, i believe that we need an fbi background check to evaluate the allegations. well, to that point, late today, we learned that the transition team has signed a memorandum of understanding with the department of justice, permitting just that which in turn was followed by word that hegseth will be appearing tomorrow in defense of his nomination on fox. cnn's kaitlan collins starts us off tonight with that. not far from mar-a-lago. so what more can you tell us about the fate of his nomination it seems to be getting more difficult by the day. >> anderson now, that doesn't mean that he's going to be pulled. and we haven't heard anything like that yet. but when you're hearing from people who are trump's closest allies on capitol hill like lindsey graham, as you were there talking about the difficulties that they believe that pete hegseth is going to be facing when that confirmation hearing
5:04 pm
does happen. if it happens, that's a sign of really just the trouble. and it's certainly not lost on people at mar-a-lago. i've been speaking to them about this nomination, anderson, and how they're feeling about it. and even they have raised concerns as moore has continued to come out necessarily because of the pile up and the questions of what this means for republican senators given they can only afford to lose three of them and plenty of them are sounding skeptical on capitol hill today, more so even than they were about two weeks ago when when all of this first started and there were questions about what this was going to look like. and so i think that's the thing to watch a sign that the trump team is taking seriously the concerns that you heard from those republican senators is that they are sending pete hegseth out to do media tomorrow. i'm told that he's expected to do a fox news interview likely tomorrow is what i'm hearing. and that's notable. not because obviously, you know, one he did used to work there, but two, none of the other cabinet picks are out doing interviews. they have been all told to hold off from doing any media focus on their confirmation hearings. and then
5:05 pm
once those happen, then they can go out on television. and so it's notable that they're sending him out to try to alleviate some of the concerns that you're hearing from those officials. and, anderson i will say, obviously, there have been the questions of sexual assault allegations that pete hegseth has denied but also the other reports that are coming out regarding pete hegseth drinking have covered trump for a long time. he abstains from drinking, never has, and he looks critically at people who do drink heavily. that has always been a factor of his. and so that is something that i heard from several people inside trump's orbit today, is how he's going to receive those reports. >> the president elect's transition team, as we mentioned signed an agreement with the justice department to allow background checks for his nominees have you heard anything from the trump team about whether they think hegseth could actually pass a traditional fbi background check? >> i've heard from some people that they think, actually, this could potentially be helpful to pete hegseth. maybe it could help clear up the concerns from some of those republican senators. but also, there's a
5:06 pm
question of whether or not his name is actually one of the ones submitted by the trump team to the fbi to conduct that background check, because what this means by signing this agreement that typically incoming president sign when they when they win the election to to have the doj go ahead and start carrying out these background checks, is that they'll they'll have them submit these names that they are going to nominate to capitol hill to the fbi. now, that does not mean they have to submit all of them. there's no legal requirement actually for for trump to do so. and i also think, anderson, one other question that is still raised tonight is whether trump trusts those background checks. he obviously has a very hostile attitude toward the fbi. that's part of why it's been nearly a month since he won the election. and they're just now signing this memorandum. memorandum of understanding. and so even if an fbi background check came back, it doesn't necessarily imperil someone's nomination in trump's eyes because he doesn't trust that he's overridden concerns for before for security clearances. he did so with jared kushner, his son in law, the first time around. and so i think that's really the question here of what that
5:07 pm
looks like now that they have signed this agreement, they will move forward. but whether or not they submit all the names is something that still remains to be seen. >> and trump also announced his choice for deputy defense secretary today as we mentioned, his choice for dea administrator withdrew from consideration. what more about this number two at the pentagon anderson, i'm sorry, i think i lost your audio. >> i'm not sure what your question was there. >> as we're hearing it. sorry. we're we're we're short on time. we'll move on. caitlin. we'll see you at the top of the hour. >> at the source at 9 p.m.. joining us right now is cnn senior political commentator david gergen we should mention that david serves on the board. and as an advisor to two companies that trump deputy defense pick, stephen feinberg's, cerebral cerberus capital management. his investments in feinberg was named for the job late today. also with us, cnn political commentator van jones and journalist and lift our voices co-founder gretchen carlson. gretchen, at this point, i mean, does it seem like pete hegseth will survive this process? >> look, i think the pivotal moment today was senator lindsey graham coming out and
5:08 pm
questioning this aside from what you played, he also said that he wants to make sure that every young woman who joins the military feels respected. and the reason that jumped out at me is because i've worked with senator lindsey graham on three bipartisan bills two of which passed into law and they were both about sexual misconduct. so the idea that senator graham would not be taking pause right now is not surprising to me at all. >> i mean, you heard what graham said do you think this will survive? >> yeah. it's hard to know. but i mean, you got to think about what is this job if you're running one of the biggest departments, the biggest bureaucracies, the most powerful in the world, the department of defense, you've either got to be able to be excellent on the inside an unbelievable administrator, able to deal with moving chess pieces all around the world, around the world. or you've got to be a great public face. you've got to be able to go out there and recruit people and stand up. he's got two black eyes on that public face, and he can't run anything but his
5:09 pm
mouth so right there is a very damaging article in in the new yorker, very well-researched about allegations made at two veterans organizations nonprofits very small, one of them was a very small organization that he essentially, according to the reporting, was essentially forced out of. exactly. >> so financial mismanagement so he's not a great public face at this point, and he can't run anything but his mouth and the small things he had to run, he ran badly. >> so you start wondering why is this guy in charge david? >> i mean, how much longer do you think the president elect will be okay with this kind of drip drip, drip of bad headlines about this pete hegseth. >> yeah listen, anderson, i don't suspect that president trump will ever cut peat free. i think it's going to be up to pete to determine at one point if and when he decides to, that he doesn't have the votes. and i think, look, i think it's very smart for him to go on on fox tomorrow and explain himself. he is kind of fighting this one hand tied behind his back a lot of these reports are, you know, not sourced they
5:10 pm
have no they're, you know, anonymous sources and, and kind of whispers down, down the lane. and so i think that it's smart for him to go out and go out and give his side of the story and try to try to win some of these senators back. he's doing it. you know, senator, by senator, he needs to get a good whip count and know what his what it looks like there in the senate. and he's going to have to answer a lot of tough questions when he gets to the to, you know, the armed services committee. i think that, you know caitlyn was talking about the the fbi background checks. they may not mean much to the folks at mar-a-lago, but they do mean a lot to to the senators. and i think they paid a great deal of attention to that. and i think that that will provide a great deal of weight. so i think that if he does get fbi background check and vetted, it's not there's no pass or fail. they just present a bunch of they bring a big file up and give it to each senator to read, and they take it with you when they leave. i think that's important. and i think it's important for pete to get a hearing, to be able to stand on his own two feet and answer those questions you know, to van's point, we had a current the current secretary of defense was missing. he wasn't
5:11 pm
at work for seven days, and the entire department of defense didn't even know it. the president didn't know it. the current secretary of defense oversaw the the most uh, one of the most regrettable military withdrawals from afghanistan, from any, any country, but from afghanistan. and so, you know, i don't know that the you know, what what people say, what are his requirements he's got the faith of the president. he's got the ear of the president. he's got the confidence of the president. i think that's that's that's that's a lot. >> david, it doesn't concern you. i mean, as somebody who obviously you have a military background, you know, very big on veterans causes and organizations that two of the organizations he worked with that he according to the reporting was essentially pushed out of yeah. >> so so anderson i think he needs to answer those questions. i would like to hear the answers, but i'm not just going to i'm not just going to take, you know, at faith from a report in the new yorker and say, well, that's it. that's the like the tablets that were handed down by god to moses. right? i want to hear pete's side of the
5:12 pm
story. let him explain it. >> right. margaret hoover was margaret hoover was on the air with she was on worked at one of these organizations and spoke publicly. >> there's so many allegations. i mean it's not just about financial mismanagement at these two organizations. it's the sexual misconduct claims. it's the alcohol alleged problems. i mean it just keeps coming out. i just can't believe that this would ever go to a hearing. and the thing i've been thinking about today, aside from why we even teach our kids to have morals and values, is is that i mean, why would pete hegseth put himself in this situation? and the only answer that i can come up with is that when you work at fox, it's kind of like a bubble. and maybe he just felt like none of this would ever come out and that trump really didn't have any repercussions for some of the alleged sexual misconduct things that he had in his past as well. yeah. >> i mean, the reporting by jane mayer van, you know, a whistleblower report that claims when hegseth was president of concerned veterans for america, he was, quote, repeatedly intoxicated while
5:13 pm
acting in his official capacity to the point of needing to be carried out of the organization's events. um, as gretchen was saying, there are other accusations of sexual impropriety, misconduct of and also treatment of women at these organizations. you know, being drunk in a bar chanting about killing muslims the the list is a long one. >> yeah. i just don't get it. i mean, the republican party is supposedly a party that wants america to be strong, wants america to be great, wants to put america first. i don't think any of the people who voted for donald trump, who run small businesses, would hire this guy to be a floor room manager. he's just not coming across as the type of person that you would want in any position of authority and and we'll just have to see i do think that maybe we're in an age where a personal valor doesn't matter in the military anymore, but i don't think we're there yet. >> i'm going to tell you who should be the pick. and that is senator joni ernst. and she's
5:14 pm
having reservations. right now. and here's why. she's a veteran. she's a sexual assault survivor, and she has a history of voting against people who have sexual misconduct allegations against them she would be a slam dunk victory for president trump. and i've heard through the grapevine that she's number two on the list. >> david, what does it take to run the department of defense? i mean, what is it? it's obviously a huge bureaucratic organization. um, i mean, is it traditionally somebody who has management experience what do you think it takes? >> yeah. look so so, anderson, it's up to the united states senate to determine what it takes. right. that's that's the advice and consent role, like the secretary has to provide sound judgment, has to provide the president with with good advice the secretary has the deputy secretary has lots of undersecretaries. deputy assistant secretaries. so it is it's running a huge organization. but you manage, you know, small people who end up running a huge organization. look, pete's going to have to
5:15 pm
explain a lot of things. and president trump's going to have to determine how much political capital he wants to expend here. you know, as any politician, the this president has a limited amount of political capital to burn. and you've got a lot of nominees, you've got a lot of nominees you want to get through. and at some point you're going to make a judgment, and pete hegseth is going to count heads, and you're going to see whether or not the votes are there, whether to get to even a hearing so, um, i think that, you know, the senate will ultimately decide as they always do. i think the fbi background checks are important here to give the senators a lot of confidence. i think, pete hegseth we're going to hear from him tomorrow. let's see what he has to say. >> but you know, but even the proposed deputy secretary is worrisome. i mean, it's not like a like a billion like a, like a billionaire war profiteer. that's kind of like a party guy as well. so, i mean, i don't understand who's going to be running the department. >> yeah, but that's petty compared to the other stuff that we're facing. >> van jones gretchen carlson, david urban, thank you. coming up next, a live report on new developments within the last few minutes from south korea, where the sudden declaration of martial law shocked the world. the sudden end to it leaves
5:16 pm
more questions than answers about one of america's leading allies. and later, how a stowaway from new york to paris got on board, got caught in. why she couldn't stay on the flight that was supposed to take her back. we'll be right back they're everyday people doing extraordinary things in their communities and in our world who should be the 2024 cnn hero of the year? >> it's your chance to weigh in. meet this year's honorees and discover the life changing work they're doing then cast up to ten votes a day, every day visit cnn heroes dot com kind of needs to be more squiggly perfect. >> so now do you have a driver's license? >> oh what did you get us with
5:17 pm
a click of a pen, you can get a new volkswagen at the sign, then drive event, lease a 2024 taos for zero down zero deposit zero first month's payment and zero due at signing. >> limited inventory available. >> shop etsy cyber spectacular until december 3rd for up to 60% off gifts crafted by small businesses get fetching finds for friends with fur friends and everyone else on your list for up to 60% off gifts that say, i get you. >> etsy has it today is giving tuesday, and at this very moment, children at saint jude are fighting to survive with a gift. right now, you can help save lives these kids, they've done nothing wrong in the world and they end up having to go through all of this to survive your donation. >> it means everything this giving tuesday, make a difference by supporting the children of saint jude. >> please donate now i tripped
5:18 pm
something awful is coming nosferatu is more powerful than evil. >> is death itself i am ready for r2 rated r only in theaters christmas day. >> special engagements in dolby and imax hello brad. >> dan singh with the world of boys and girls now, i didn't sign on for this. >> it's christmas. bah humbug. >> christmas is the time to be with the people you love talk to the world go wow to you and me for more than a decade pozega has been
5:19 pm
trusted again and again. >> and again. pozega ask your doctor about pozega i used to think a holiday one stop shop was a myth until i found michael's. >> oh, i need those. definitely need those drop everything and get some magic of your own during the xfinity black friday sale. xfinity internet customers, our best deals of the year are back! switch to xfinity mobile and get your choice of a free 5g phone, plus your next unlimited line free for a year. get amazing savings and connect to wifi speeds up to a gig on the go with xfinity mobile. fly don't walk to get our best deals of the year. connect to the world of wicked this holiday, in theaters now.
5:20 pm
south korea and this is cnn the south korean president and chief of staff and more than ten of his senior secretaries have just submitted their resignations, according to his office, the president himself has not yet resigned. >> the breaking news again, just moments old, follows hard on the heels of a remarkable and remarkably brief flirtation with martial law. today it ended six hours after it began, the president, bowing to pressure from lawmakers and mass protests in the streets of south korea, as you may know, became a democracy in the late 1980s after decades under
5:21 pm
military rule. cnn's mike valerio is in seoul. for us tonight. what is going on there right now? and is there any more clarity about why the president did this well, anderson, right now we're in the middle of a protest with a couple hundred people steps away from the national assembly. >> one of the main centers of the drama that unfolded over the past couple of hours. we have one of the new late edition newspapers that's come out with a headline that encapsulates the feeling that so many people have right now. it says in korean president yun's martial law, a betrayal of the people and that's exactly what so many people here, myriad citizens of south of seoul and surrounding area, are saying, right now in terms of the why question, anderson, why this happened and why we got here, the best guess and best analysis that we can. marshall right now is that the president of south korea felt as though he was backed into a corner facing myriad scandals, many scandals here domestically
5:22 pm
with a popularity of favorability rating under, i repeat under 20%. and in his words, a parliament, you know, a couple of yards behind me that wasn't able to play a part in furthering his domestic agenda. so a huge miscalculation on his part to take control, to take power, take control of the situation in everybody would agree here a terrible way, anderson. >> no fascinating mike valerio appreciate it. joining us stay with us. also, mike, cnn's national security analyst and former deputy director of national intelligence beth sanner joins us also, william cohen, who served as defense secretary during the clinton administration. secretary cohen, i'm just trying to put this in a global perspective for us. how dangerous is political instability in south korea at a time when north korea is testing new missiles with longer range? and obviously, china getting increasingly more aggressive against taiwan? >> well it's pretty serious, anderson as you pointed out, just the threat of the north koreans over the years. but
5:23 pm
especially in recent times when they're firing off more and more missiles and getting greater and greater range of those missiles. so with the possibility of striking the united states with a nuclear weapon so that's dangerous enough but it poses a danger to the entire region. japan is certainly going to be concerned about this, as other um, countries in the region so instability is not good and i think this reflects an act of impulsiveness. i think he acted impulsively. and you're supposed to have a plan. if you had plan a to impose martial law, what's plan b? there's no plan b, and that's why it's, um, president biden was not called on on it his own parliament wasn't called to let them know what was going to take place. his own party didn't know about it so it had to be an act on his part. coming late at night impulsively, not thinking it through. and he's paying a consequence for it now. >> yeah, beth, i mean, to that point the announcement clearly appears to have called the biden administration the
5:24 pm
intelligence community, by surprise um, if this was just an impromptu decision, it's a pretty crazy impromptu decision to make. if you don't haven't really planned out the institution of martial law in a country that, you know, has not had martial law in decades yeah, yeah. >> note to self don't text after 11 p.m.. >> i mean, it's like a late night decision of all the late night bad late night decisions people have made this seems like a huge one. >> it seems like a huge one, and it absolutely will be. there is no way in the world that he is going to get out of this politically alive you know, his chief of staff resigned. all senior staff has resigned. his party has demanded his resignation. so now it's just a matter of how long does this take? and then we're going to see this period of 60 days from when he declares, because i don't think we're going to have to go through the impeachment process. so he's going to resign, and then there'll be elections within 60 days of that. and so that's going to put us at, you know elections
5:25 pm
in south korea. one of our most important allies. what has been an absolute bulwark for us working with japan. and this trilateral arrangement on that peninsula and in the region and that, you know, we don't know how that's going to turn out. the reason that yoon was so important to us is because he was a willing player in that, and the next person may or may not be so there's a lot at stake. >> yeah mike, i mean, the entire south korean parliament voted unanimously to undo this martial law declaration. what are the consequences for south korea's president well, you know, he's lost so many of his allies. >> and there is a fear i you know, i think it's fair to say anderson, just talking to all of these people, south korea is so proud of how far the country has come since 1980, since the last time there was martial law spread throughout the country. we now have k-pop k cinema, you know, soft power is so strong
5:26 pm
that south korea exerts. and i can tell you there are people from grandmothers and students and everyone in between who's gathered here. they're really afraid and concerned that this is a blemish on south korea's reputation. the world now knows that things are incredibly unstable here and there are allies of president yoon suk yeol who are concerned, and people in the opposing party who are concerned that north korea, perhaps could see this moment as a moment of weakness and do something that, you know, we don't even want to go into that realm of possibility. but so there is serious concern about what this has done to the reputation of south korea and the ripple effects that this means going forward. >> secretary cohen i mean, obviously, there are tens of thousands of u.s. troops stationed in south korea. i know a spokesman for the pentagon has said that quote, and i'm quoting right now, there has been essentially no impact on u.s. forces. what impact do you think continued instability there could have on u.s. forces in the region or to to the as you know, we talked
5:27 pm
about this, this kind of trilateral alliance. >> yeah, i assume the korean forces will be enhancing their security alert and go on to a higher level of status of warning. i think the american troops will remain calm but very vigilant, watching as things unfold. so i think we'll keep an eye on north korea we'll keep an eye on what is taking place in the region. but i want to add just one comment of optimism here this is democracy that worked these the korean people have said we like freedom. we like democracy. we don't want anyone to take that away from us. and so what the president tried to do is imposing martial law, become a dictator as such, because he was frustrated that he couldn't get his budget through. he couldn't get his cabinet approved or not impeached. so democracy in that sense, worked with the people, spoke out and said, no, no you'll work with a system democracy can be messy
5:28 pm
but dictatorships are a menace. and that's the choice they have made here so i think that sends a signal to all of our allies in the region that, yeah, we have a problem here for the time being. i think it will be corrected. in the meantime, we'll be on alert and i think the region will be relatively safe if the north koreans start to do something and move in an adversarial way, we'll be ready for that. so i think it will calm down over time. and as beth has said 60 days will pass. they'll have a new election and democracy will be in action again. >> beth, what do you think about north korea? i mean, kim jong un often employs hostile rhetoric, obviously against south korea and the u.s. do you think they will try to do something using this as an opportunity? >> i do. i think that they see you know, korea watchers have been worried, you know, for some months that that kim would take advantage of the u.s. transition and to do something, you know actually kinetic actually an attack on something
5:29 pm
like an island or something like that in, in, you know, around the transition to put a real dilemma on trump's plate at the beginning of his administration. now, i think that there actually is even more likelihood that that will happen but i'm not sure it will happen before the south korean elections because in a way the north koreans aren't dumb if they do something before the election, it actually could encourage south korean voters to gravitate more to the conservative party rather than to the the progressives who are more accommodating to the north koreans but so we're looking at a window. i think, in early in the trump administration, where we really have to be on our toes and in alert because kim is is definitely gunning to make things difficult. >> beth sanner mike valerio william cohen, thanks so much. coming up next, an update on the woman who allegedly stowed away in a delta airlines flight to paris out of new york. how she got on this is hard to
5:30 pm
believe, and the airline removed her from a scheduled return flight earlier today. we'll have the details on when she might get sent back to the u.s. united states can't fool myself. >> it was the most exciting time in the world his life had extremely joyful moments and some really difficult moments you only come across an artist like luther vandross once in a lifetime. >> luther never too much new year's day on from dress the bird to deck the halls so many ways to save life. >> ready? wallet. happy that's 365 by whole foods market. >> you'll love this. centrum silver is clinically proven to support memory and older adults, so you can keep saying you mastered it, you fixed it. you nailed it. you did it with centrum silver, clinically proven to support memory in older adults. >> it's closed. >> what about my letter? >> call uncle brian to the
5:31 pm
north pole never the december to remember sales event. >> get offers on select models oh, what a good time we will have you can make it happen again voltaren for long lasting arthritis pain relief now's the time to go back in time and shine a light on the family journey that led to you. >> detailed dna results, inspiring family history. memberships. now's the time to save at ancestry your best defense against erosion and cavities is strong enamel. >> nothing beats it. i recommend pronamel active shield because it actively shields the enamel to defend against erosion and cavities. i think that this product is a game changer for my patients. it really works liberty mutual customizes my car insurance, so i saved hundreds with the money
5:32 pm
i saved, i thought i'd get a wax figure of myself oh, right. >> in the temporal lobe. beat it. punks only pay for what you need. >> liberty, liberty liberty liberty for more than a decade, pozega has been trusted again and again and again s. >> e. cupp pozega ask your doctor about pozega surprise! >> there's still time to save. wayfair's cyber week sale is back for an encore. it's your last chance to save up to 70% off on furniture and cookware. holiday decor and more at wayfair's lowest prices of the year. plus, score new deals of the day every day. wow. and get free shipping on everything. don't miss your last chance to save up to 70% on everything. home, shop, cyber week now! wayfair every style, every home. >> if your family is anything like mine, every day brings in
5:33 pm
dirt and messes touchdown. just sit back
5:34 pm
>> having a plan in place, it was a huge relief. >> create your estate plan at trust and wilcom. >> while your harkonnen you are the strongest among us with our spice, the great houses would feed me to the worm. your troubles are far greater than just arrakis. stop dune. >> prophecy. streaming exclusively on max the russian national accused of stowing away on a delta airlines flight to paris out of new york last week, remains in france. >> she is believed to have evaded multiple security checkpoints and boarded the plane with no valid travel documents or even a ticket. the 57 year old woman was expected to be returned to the u.s. earlier today. an airport official tells cnn she boarded a flight but was removed by delta and that was not the first attempt to send her back. polo sandoval has more than please help this is video taken on saturday. >> the first time authorities tried returning the 57 year old
5:35 pm
russian national to the united states. a passenger's cell phone video captured the woman causing a disturbance before the flight took off from paris i don't want to go to united states. she was removed from the new york bound flight, recalls gary treichler, who was sitting right across the aisle. >> what i saw was basically this lady that was progressively getting more and more irate and raising her voice louder and louder, and was ultimately restrained with handcuffs and yellow twist ties and held down by three individuals. a stewardess and a lady that represented delta security delta airlines not commenting about its decision to kick her off today's flight or elaborating on the initial security breach in a previous statement. >> a spokesperson for the airline wrote in part delta is conducting an exhaustive investigation of what may have occurred. tsa says before stowing away on this flight last week, the woman slipped past tsa officers at jfk checking boarding passes. they added she and her carry on
5:36 pm
bags were screened but that she somehow bypassed id verification at the gate. a source familiar with the incident said she evaded detection in flight because the plane wasn't full, though passengers previously told cnn she hid by moving between lavatories. the next attempt to fly her to new york is planned for tomorrow, according to that paris airport official, who adds french security personnel will be escorting her. >> polo sandoval joins me now. so where has the woman been held? in paris and what do we know about her well anderson, until she is brought back here to new york she will continue to be held where she's been for the last week, really, which is a specially designated section there at paris's charles de gaulle airport specifically reserved for people who do not meet requirements to enter france. >> in fact, by at least one account, this woman does not meet the entrance requirements to enter europe altogether. in fact, we have learned recently that she had recently petitioned for asylum in france but had been denied. anderson. so clearly there is either
5:37 pm
something or someone that's essentially drawing her to france. now what that is, that's still unclear tonight polo sandoval, thanks so much. >> among the outstanding questions in this bizarre saga is how the stowaway managed to sneak past multiple security checkpoints at jfk and board a flight without a ticket in the first place. we'll get some perspective now from john miller, cnn chief law enforcement and intelligence analyst um, do you have any idea how she was able to get. i mean, there's so many layers of getting through security. >> so investigators have gone through the video and, you know, if there's next to an next to a casino, the place with the most video cameras is going to be an airport especially at the security checkpoint. so what they what they see is they pick her up trailing a flight crew down that special lane, that flight crews go through their screening in. but as she approaches the place where she has to show her airline identification, which of course she doesn't have, she breaks off from the flight crew, not a delta crew from another airline. and there's a gap there where there's a stanchion
5:38 pm
that divides their area from the regular screening area and she she goes through that gap or under a stanchion. and then goes through the regular airport security screening. so she hasn't presented a ticket at the normal passenger entrance. she hasn't presented one at the airline one, but she's gone through the security when she gets to the plane now. now she's in delta's territory. she seems to be looking at the video. get in the middle of a group. it looks like a family. according to investigators who have seen it and then they're presenting their tickets and passports in a pile to the gate agent who is then going through them and as they sweep onto the plane, she does too. so it sounds like she had a plan. it looks like she executed it very well, and that she took advantage of the massive crowds. >> so how do you fix that problem? i mean, who does the buck stop with? who's responsible for that? >> well, it's the buck stops in two places. one on the tsa. they've got to look at that gap. they've got to look at
5:39 pm
who's watching those spaces um, important to remember, she did go through security screening but she didn't go through an id check on the on the getting on the plane. and that's on delta right that's where that gate agent has to check those passports, visas plane tickets. >> and would she face charges for boarding a stowing away on a flight so she could that's a $4,500 ticket. >> by most estimates so that could be grand larceny there's civil penalties from tsa, which they could assess her. so tomorrow when she comes back, she'll be interviewed by the fbi. other law enforcement agencies, and they'll confer with delta. how did they even get her back? >> if she's going to keep causing a problem on a plane? i mean, so she'll be with four u.s., tsa, air marshals and a delta corporate security person and i think they're going to try again. >> huh? >> sounds like a great flight to be on that one. john miller. thank you very much. appreciate it. coming up, the cdc considers the initiative to put fluoride in public drinking
5:40 pm
water. one of the greatest public health achievements of the 20th century. we'll take you to one community in new york that recently opted to remove it. that's ahead on cnn heroes, an all star tribute meet and celebrate the honorees then find out who will be hero of the year. >> plus, a special tribute to michael j. fox, cnn heroes, an all star tribute sunday at eight on cnn. >> still congested? nope. uh oh. >> new mucinex 2 in 1 saline nasal spray spray goodbye. new mucinex 2 in 1 saline nasal spray with a gentle mist and innovative power jet spray. goodbye to congestion its comeback season. my life is full of questions. >> mom. is yellow a light or a dark? >> how do i clean an aioli stain thankfully, tide is the answer to almost all of them. >> why do we even buy napkins in cold water? >> clean white socks you can with tide. >> do i need to pre-treat guacamole? >> no. italian. this is chocolate, right? >> just use tide yeah.
5:41 pm
>> no matter who's doing it on what cycle or in what temperature? tide works. so i can focus on all the other questions your crabs have eyebrows? >> uh, for all of life's laundry questions, it's got to be tide whether you're a professional driver or just a fan. >> vehicle breakdowns are costly. >> it started tugging. >> it started making some really weird noises. >> the last thing i remember is just the engine cut out. >> if your check engine light comes on tomorrow, the repair could easily cost thousands. >> is that transmission? >> it's an exhaust leak broken axle. >> but with endurance, you could never pay out of pocket for a costly repair again. >> they covered a $14,000 engine replacement. >> i had a seat sensor that went out $1,400. endurance paid it. >> got a brand new transmission, and we never seen the repair bill. >> use any certified mechanic you want, just bring your car in and endurance will pay them direct. all major parts are covered. >> what i like about endurance,
5:42 pm
they don't play games. there's no middleman. they're a solid company. >> if i didn't have endurance, i would have paid over $7,000 out of pocket to repair my vehicle. >> something is going to break down, make endurance pay for it with endurance. >> your car repair costs go way down while your car's life expectancy goes way up, allowing you to drive more and pay less. >> one claim alone saved me more than $4,000. >> i've had five claims and that is $3,500 that i've kept in my pocket. >> so who's going to pay for your next car repair? you or endurance? >> whether you put 10,000 or 100,000 miles a year on your car. if it's less than 20 years old, endurance has you covered with unlimited miles. plus, your plan covers 24 over seven roadside assistance anywhere in the country. call right now to get $300 off any plan, plus a full year of our top tier elite benefits. a $200 value free an
5:43 pm
all endurance plans come with a 30 day money back guarantee, but you have to act now. call 1-855-237-0489. that's 1-855-237-0489. >> i won't let my moderate to severe plaque psoriasis symptoms define me. emerge as you with clearer skin with tremfya. >> most people saw 100% clear skin that stayed clear even at five years. >> serious allergic reactions and increased risk of infections may occur. before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tb. tell your doctor if you have an infection. flu-like symptoms, or if you need a vaccine. >> emerge with clear skin. ask your doctor about tremfya disability is not a dirty word. >> it takes a lot to be able to get to the pride part of disability, because we live in an ableist society. >> there are millions of people like me. >> they are overlooked and underestimated. >> i have a mind. >> i have a heart. i have a passion
5:44 pm
it's who i am, whether i'm sitting or standing. >> if i didn't have the disability, i wouldn't be the person that i am today. say disability with pride let it rain randy. >> woohoo! hahahahaha! yes that's how you make like it never even happened. happened? >> servpro i'm rafael romo at the georgia state capitol in atlanta. this is cnn more breaking news tonight in the president elect's office picks this time. >> kash patel his choice to head the fbi. cnn's kristen holmes is in west palm beach for more. what have you learned yeah, anderson we are told that kash patel was told by the fbi that he had been targeted in an iranian hack. >> now, this comes from two sources. one of the sources telling us that they believe that at least some of patel's communications were compromised. unclear how much.
5:45 pm
unclear how big this hack was, but this is just the latest in a series of complications and a series of hackings that we have seen from foreign governments, whether it be the chinese hackers who targeted some of trump's inner circles on their phone, as well as the iranian hackers who have targeted many of trump's lawyers for example, as well as his inner circle don junior, saying he was informed by the fbi that he was one of the biggest targets for iran. i will quickly read you the statement that we got from kash patel spokesperson at the transition, alex pfeiffer. he said kash patel was a key part of the first trump administration's efforts against the terrorist iranian regime and will implement president trump's policies and protect america from the adversaries as the fbi director. anderson. >> kristen holmes, thanks very much. more to learn on that another controversial cabinet pick also taking the spotlight, robert f. kennedy jr. is the president elect's choice for hhs secretary. his support for removing fluoride from public drinking water has been a boon to anti-fluoride fluoride activists. days before the election, kennedy tweeted on january 20th, the trump white house will advise all u.s.
5:46 pm
water systems to remove fluoride from public water. the next day, trump told nbc news the plan sounded okay to him. whether that will actually become policy is unclear. our jason carroll spoke with residents of one new york city suburb, wrestling with the fluoride question after a decision to remove it from the water supply the anti-fluoride people are very outspoken. >> i just don't want it in my body. >> the science shows that we do need fluoride in the water. >> public health is not adding something to the water and going, okay we did our job. >> you've just heard some pointed opinions about fluoride in drinking water. no shortage of those here in yorktown, new york. it's a suburb of new york city population about 36,000. and it's a town really divided over the issue. hi. these women call themselves the poison squad. >> nice and cozy. >> they say they want their water the way it is now without added fluoride. all of your drinking water. how are you feeling about that? >> you mean the fluoride free water? feel amazing. feel like
5:47 pm
it's one less toxin that i have to worry about. >> cheers to that. because that's how i feel. >> let's cheers. >> if you want fluoride, you can have it. it's in your toothpaste. you can go to your dentist. you can have it put on your teeth as many times a year as you want. >> i really truly think it should be a freedom of choice. >> if you were able to have a conversation with someone who disagrees with you on the subject matter, and they were to say to you, well, look, i hear what you're saying, but i want to have a choice. >> what i would say to that person is, that's not how public health works public health works because it is directed toward the public for the public good. >> since the 70s, the town has been adding fluoride into its water supply. but in 2012, the system that does that here at this water treatment facility failed. and it needed to be upgraded. well, it took 12 years to do that. so for 12 years the town had no fluoride in its water. but then they got it up and running again. and in fact, this is the pipe that
5:48 pm
does it that sends the fluoride through this pipe out into the water supply. and in august it was up and running again. they turned it back on. but a month later it was turned off that responsibility fell to ed lichterman. i would have lost sleep if i didn't do it. he's yorktown's town supervisor and he was one of four town board members who voted to stop adding fluoride to the water supply. >> if we can't believe epa or the nih or the cdc, i don't know who i'm supposed to believe. >> so the board voted 4 to 1 against you. you were the only one who said yes, i am in support of fluoride. >> the board did not listen to science. >> the decision to stop fluoridating the water was a controversial one. >> you unilaterally stopped fluoridation. >> on what grounds? >> there is now no question that fluoride is a neurotoxic. >> i think it's generational, to be honest with you like the younger generation wants
5:49 pm
purity. some of it may be fueled by a federal judge's order for the epa to review possible risks of fluoride and its impact on iq in children, but that ruling was based on studies looking at fluoride levels nearly double what's found in u.s. drinking water. double the amount found in your town's water, which was 0.7mg/l. the national standard. and while scientists agree on the adverse health effects of high levels of fluoride, there's also strong evidence showing low levels of fluoride is safe. but science shows more research may be needed, and it should be noted the cdc and the american dental association point to numerous studies showing low level fluoridation in water reduces tooth decay by at least 25%, calling it one of the greatest public health achievements of the 20th century. >> it's the dosage that is important. it's the dosage that counts. >> would there be any acceptable level? low level of fluoride that would be okay
5:50 pm
with any of you in the water or. no. no, no. and then there are questions about rfk jr.. s influence over the debate. president-elect donald trump's controversial pick to head health and human services, says he plans to end fluoridating water in his first 90 days in office. >> oh, i think certainly the rfk has magnified the issue and made it more of a national issue. >> was the discussion given a boost by rfk for any of you? >> no no, this came before rfk was given his platform. i didn't really notice rfk or anybody. i was just focused and tuned in on my children and what was best for them. >> i wonder if this isn't a reflection of things that are happening in the country in general. this increasing distrust of science that we're seeing. >> do you feel like at this point, sort of the battle is over for for you? >> i haven't given up and jason carroll joins me now. >> it's an interesting debate. where do things stand right now with that? >> well, look again, 12 years in yorktown without any
5:51 pm
fluoride in the water there. and one of the leading dentists there in the town who we spoke to, who did not want to go on camera because, you know, it's become a divisive issue. but he made it very clear. no fluoride in the water there means that these children are going to have more tooth decay, more cavities more root canals. and the worry is that it's not going to stop with fluoride that today it's fluoride tomorrow it's going to be something else like vaccines. the next day who knows. >> all right, jason carroll, thanks very much. coming up, the latest episode of all there is my podcast about loss and grief just got posted wherever you get your podcasts. i talk in this episode with alex van halen about his brother, eddie van halen with whom he formed one of the most successful rock bands in history. he talks about eddie's life and death, and he still feels he communicates with his brother, who died four years ago. we'll play part of that interview in a moment you only come across an artist like luther vandross once in a lifetime.
5:52 pm
>> he was a boss from the beginning. >> luther said, i have a sound in my head. i got to get it out you are my shining star. >> my it was the most exciting time in the world. >> his life had extremely joyful moments and some really difficult moments. >> if we were to be able to talk to luther as fans, we'd be able to say we just love you, luther. >> never too much. >> new years day at eight on cnn i'm kind of needs to be more squiggly perfect so now do you have a driver's license? >> oh, what did you get us with a click of a pen? >> you can get a new volkswagen at the sign, then drive event. lisa 2024 tiguan for zero. down zero deposit, zero first month's payment and zero due at signing. limited inventory available heartburn makes you queasy.
5:53 pm
>> get fast relief with new tums plus upset stomach and nausea. support and love food back. >> dum da dum dum tums come to me he is coming. >> he is coming he is coming to us. >> he is coming. >> who is coming to you? my child oh nosferatu we are only in theaters christmas day. >> special engagements in dolby and imax for more than a decade, pozega has been trusted again and again and again. >> pozega ask your doctor about pozega today is giving tuesday, and you can give a gift like no other. a gift that can help. saint jude children's research
5:54 pm
hospital save lives. >> cancer doesn't care how old you are, and it's devastatingly scary if you're donating to saint jude, you're supporting finding a cure because the fight never stops. >> every gift counts and whatever you can give will make a difference for children like gideon. make your donation today to help saint jude save lives. >> doctor box. >> there were many failed attempts to fix my teeth i retouched all my wedding photos and it was even affecting my health. i trusted you because you specialize in dental implants. you created a permanent solution and customized my teeth so it still felt like me. my new teeth have improved my life and change my future. thank you. you're so welcome. >> get the smile. you want from the number one provider of fixed full arch dental implants in the u.s.. schedule a free consultation. >> shop etsy cyber spectacular until december 3rd for up to 60% off all kinds of gifts.
5:55 pm
carefully crafted by small businesses save big on the perfect presents for practical parents cute and cuddly creations for kids and other fetching finds made to make the holidays for any hard to shop for person on your list when you want u download the app
5:56 pm
and play $5 to get $50 instantly with code tv. >> the source with kaitlan collins next an all new episode of my podcast about grief and loss all there is has just been released. >> it's available now wherever you get your podcasts. right now, you can point your phone's camera at the qr code at the bottom of your screen and follow the link that pops up. this week is about the life and death in 2020 of one of the greatest guitar players ever, eddie van halen. on the podcast, i talked with his brother alex, who was with him at the end and at the beginning of his life. they created van halen together. they co-founded the band eddie as alex called him on guitar, alex on drums. here's part of our conversation how has grief been
5:57 pm
for you? >> uh, you know, i always thought of myself as kind of a stoic kind of guy. you know, tough you know, i was the elder in the family, so i had a certain role. you were the protector. yeah. >> do you feel like you are grieving, or do you feel like i'm grieving all the time? >> you're trying to put it aside. i'm not running from it. because that doesn't solve the problem. it's there. you feel it oh, yeah. absolutely absolutely. it's just it's a times can be overwhelming. and the more the more i dwell on it. the more complicated it becomes when i'm alone and not put on a piece of music and i hear him play, i just break, i break down, that's it. you know uncontrollably. but knowing what i know about the human body, you just let it happen. otherwise it will happen in the line at the grocery store, you were able to be with your brother at the end, he had a stroke and is that. yes. at the end he had a massive stroke. um, we were in the room with
5:58 pm
him when he actually took his last breath. we just sat there everybody was in their own headspace all i know is that when he stopped breathing, i didn't hear anything. i didn't see anything there were no bells. there were no angels. it was just. it stopped. and then the room was empty. and then they pulled the plug because he was on a ventilator and because of covid and the restrictions of the rules, they immediately carved the body off. and that was it. then we didn't see him anymore. it was very uneventful ending to an eventful life this is going to sound a little out to left field, so to speak, but he communicates in different ways with me um, and i can't really go into that because the moment you mention it, it breaks that bond. it's kind of a really thin thread of, uh signs. >> there's a lot of people who feel signs and see signs, and it gives great comfort. and it's only recently that i've
5:59 pm
begun to um. excuse me if i. my voice cracks. it's uncontrollable uh, i've recently begun to actually feel my brother and my dad, who died long ago, but i've actually started to sort of feel them inside me in a way that i never have before. and it's it's an extraordinary feeling. >> the first real direct if you will communication, if you will, was more of a smell. his unique fragrance was everywhere, and i couldn't figure it out rationally. where is this coming from? is it the closet? is it the clothes? is it the stuff that he washed with? but it's just and it shows up everywhere. or maybe it's just my mind wants to smell that. i don't know, but it was there and lately it's been fading a little bit. >> but the feeling it leaves you with is positive.
6:00 pm
>> oh yeah yeah. you know, in a lot of different cultures, death um, and i prefer to believe that about your podcast, you can also point your camera at the qr code on the screen right now click on the link. >> another way to access it this season is to go to our online grief community that we just started on cnn.com/vote forward slash all there is online. you can connect with me there and others living with grief. you can leave comments and share your own experiences as well. watch a video version of this podcast and listen to all the podcasts there. the videos are also available on the cnn channel on youtube. i hope all of it makes you feel a little less lonely in your grief. the news continues. the source with kaitlan collins starts now. i'll see you tomorrow