that he did those services in exchange for favorable media coverage. and beyond the history. this is also quite an extraordinary moment because of the timing. this is a sitting israeli prime minister testifying during wartime. that's part of the reason why the proceedings today were held in tel aviv instead of jerusalem, because this courthouse has an underground courtroom that effectively served as a bunker for the prime minister's testimony. he will be testifying over the course of several weeks, as many as three times a week, for as long as six hours per day. initially, he will be taking questions from his own attorneys, but then things will quickly turn to the more prime all wrongdoing. this case, though once a verdict is issued, something that could take some time, he does face the possibility of several years in prison and if convicted, he would have to resign as prime minister. >> wolf. all right. jeremy diamond in tel aviv. thanks very much. and to our viewers, thanks very much for watching.

erin burnett outfront starts right now. >> outfront next, the breaking news. a possible motive, investigators looking into whether the ceo murder suspects, back injury was central to the killing. luigi mangione friend says his hurt back led to other major health issues. his friend will be out front, plus a wealthy and powerful mangione family will speak to a reporter who has covered them. did any of them try to contact police when van jones picture was everywhere on national television and an american family holding out hope tonight? u.s. reporter austin tice has been missing in syria for more than 12 years, but his parents believe tonight that he is still alive and well. they are my guests. let's go out front. and good evening. i'm erin burnett. outfront tonight, the breaking news and the ceo assassin case. new york police saying moments ago that investigators are looking at a possible back injury, that ceo murder suspect luigi mangione may have

suffered from in july 2023. >> he was posting an x ray on his social media showing numerous screws being inserted into his spine. >> some of the writings that he had, he was discussing the difficulty of sustaining that injury. >> so we're looking into whether or not the insurance industry either denied a claim from him or didn't help him out to the fullest extent. he knew that this conference was taking place at that time this is the suspect is lashing out in front of the cameras. >> here is 26 year old luigi mangione outside a pennsylvania courtroom today. just looking at that image, you can feel the rage. none of the expressionless gazes that suspects in the center of public firestorm often display. no, look at him. mangione was yelling and struggling with officers. back up and clearly out of dust and insult the intelligence of the american people and claimed experience

you heard it there. mangione was shackled at the hands and feet, wearing an orange prison jumpsuit. now there he was outside, and you can see that yelling, fighting. and then inside the courtroom, our reporter there says the suspect's color was disheveled when he actually got there, and that he was surrounded at that time by half a dozen uniformed officers. mangione his appearance in court, coming as pennsylvania state police have shared this new image of mangione standing, sitting, i'm sorry, inside the mcdonald's in altoona, pennsylvania, where he was captured. the images come from an officer body cam, and they show mangione eating a hash brown. and we're also learning tonight that he was the suspect of a missing person report filed in san francisco by his mother. now, this is according to the new york times. and here's what's really important about the timing on this. that report was filed on november 18th. that's just about two weeks, 16 days before the unitedhealthcare ceo, brian thompson, was shot and killed. the timing could end up being important because mangione had stopped communicating with friends and family six months

ago. but that missing person's report, we understand, came in just 16 days before the shooting. danny freeman is outfront in philadelphia to begin our breaking coverage tonight. and, danny, what is the latest that you're learning there? >> well, erin, first off, what a different tone tonight at the blair county courthouse compared to what we witnessed last evening over there. it was just stunning to see luigi mangione as you played screaming and yelling as he went from that squad car into the courthouse. but cnn also learned in the past hour and a half or so that his new defense attorney, during that all important extradition hearing earlier this afternoon, actually told him to keep quiet during that appearance in front of that judge. but erin, there's just still so many unanswered questions right now about this case. even with mangione in custody. so we went back to try and understand better his roots. we came right here to where he went to college years before, he'd be escorted into a pennsylvania courthouse, luigi mangione spent time more than 200 miles east here at the

university of pennsylvania in philadelphia, the prestigious ivy league university confirming mangione graduated on may 18th, 2020 with a bachelor's and master's degree in engineering. that means he likely spent much of his time here at the school of engineering and applied science. now, while there weren't a lot of people who knew him or willing to speak to us about him on camera, at least one student said that he was a t.a. of computer and information sciences. also, in a since taken down post for the university's penn today, mangione was featured for leading a 60 student club that made video games. quote i wanted to make my own game and so i learned how to code, mangione told a university writer. >> he was a member of the honor society and engineering school, which is only for the, you know, the top students in the class. he was involved in a fraternity on campus, upenn student newspaper editor in chief jared mitovich said his team has been working to see if there were any signs then of what was to come, what was the type of education he received at penn, the type of place where he would have learned how to 3-d print?

>> is it the type of place where he, you know, was exposed to, you know, certain beliefs just in like the groups that he ran into or like the things that he was involved in. >> mangione grew up in a wealthy family from baltimore, according to the baltimore sun. his grandfather, nicholas mangione, built a local real estate empire that included nursing home facilities around maryland and two suburban country clubs. in a statement released by mangione cousin, maryland state delegate nino mangione, his family said they were shocked and devastated by luigi's arrest at his arraignment monday night, mangione told the judge he had been in contact with his family, quote, until recently. >> it's been an incredible journey. >> mangione graduated valedictorian in 2016 from baltimore's prestigious all boys, the gilman school former classmates couldn't believe he was. now this suspect. >> i can tell you that this is one of the last people you'd think would do something like this in recent years, according to a friend and online postings, though, mangione suffered from back pain and underwent surgery to treat it, a reddit user matching his

biographical details writing in july 2023, my back and hips locked up after the accident. >> intermittent numbness has become constant. i'm terrified of the implications, but after maintaining a social media presence for years, mangione went quiet this past summer and appeared to stop communicating with his family. also notable aaron has mangione started to fade from his online presence. people noticed at least one user tweeting at him saying, i haven't heard from you in months. another in late november, just before the shooting posting, thinking of you and prayers every day in your name. know that you are missed and loved. and aaron, i'll note that the university of pennsylvania declined to comment further for this story. aaron. >> danny, thank you very much. so tim clemente is here now, former fbi counterterrorism agent mary ellen o'toole, senior profiler for the fbi. and mark o'mara, a criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor. tim, can i start with you? i just want to play again that outburst because, you know, often when you see a

suspect like this, there's a stone faced would be the way you describe them. this couldn't have been more the opposite of that. luigi mangione right outside court today. here he is. back up, and he's clearly out of touch and insults the intelligence of the american people and experience. tim, it's disturbing to watch that. what he says we had we had it written on the bottom of the screen. but just in case anyone's just listening, it's completely out of touch and an insult to the intelligence of the american people. it's lived experience. you hear him shout and he sounds distressed. he's he's fighting against police as he does that. what do you make of this uh, this is this is him showing himself the showing what he cares about, which is himself, obviously. >> i mean, he's not not distraught, not going in there with his head held low, not going in there like he's embarrassed by this. this is his moment. and apparently in the last 5 or 6 days, he's probably looked at a lot of

social media and seen how many adulating fans he has around the world that are saying he's a hero. he's mistaken, misguided people that are trying to say what he did was good. i mean, he committed a cold blooded murder, obviously planned it for some time, and now he's basking in the limelight. this is this is his moment, his 15 minutes of fame. and he's taking all the advantage he can out of it. >> mary ellen. there was also a photo taken during those moments in the hearing. and as i described this, it's i mean, the rage is palpable. the sneer, the the rage from his eyes, from his expression, the sneer on his face, his mouth. and we also have the mug shot. um, now this is just a straight stare. but when you look at him in these photos and when you see that outburst, that rage in that still photo, what do you see? mary ellen? >> well, there are definitely signs of rage and anger, but

but here's the here's the conundrum. um, you have to really look at what his behavior was like. >> for example, in the car pulling up there before they got him out of the car. was he cool, calm and collected. >> so then he gets out of the car and then he immediately has this outburst. >> so was that brought about by the fact that the cameras are on the media was there and it immediately put him into the the role of of wanting a lot of attention. and you have to consider that before you rule it one way or the other. i've seen a lot of offenders, when they go to court, they will act up because it is their time to get that attention, to get that notoriety. the other thing that i look at with him is this if he was so quick to anger like that there's an absence of of any kind of reports of him getting in fights with people, of him even being arrested by the police for this quick temper. so something is causing this, and it's important that and investigators will they'll

go back to take a look at is there something medically is there something mentally to understand better understand what's going on with him. >> so mark, what's interesting in terms of his if this was him trying to seize the moment and control the narrative and have his moment in front of the cameras when he was in court today with his lawyer. and so he's, you know, just met this lawyer, right? his lawyer has admitted that he told his client at one point to be quiet and not talk, and then also said this about mangione this is not just a small thing. >> the fundamental, uh, concept of american justice is a presumption of innocence. and until you're proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. and i've seen zero evidence at this point what do you think of that, mark? >> first of all, i just the zero evidence, okay. >> because nothing has come out yet. >> i would probably be a bit more circumspect about saying it, because we know some of the evidence is out there. >> this case is going to run two tracks. one track is the

forensic evidence. did he do it from an evidentiary standpoint? it's going to be very strong because our digital evidence is so strong in cases like this, from cameras to the cell phones themselves. but the other part of it is the mental health mitigation. if they can prove he did it, then the question is why? and i see in those outbursts and these actions, i see nuggets of mental health mitigation coming out to the forefront. and everything has been consistent for six months or more from the, you know, coming off social media, stopping conversations with his family and friends, some bizarre behaviors that we've seen. all of that, i think is going to show itself as a beginnings of a mental health defense to not did he do it? but why? >> right. okay. which which could be crucial. so tim, to this point, mangione mother, according to the new york times, reportedly filed a missing persons report for him in san francisco okay, on november 18th. that was just two weeks before the shooting. now, as as mark's pointing

out, we know that mangione stopped communicating with family and friends about six months ago so that timing may make this even more mysterious, right? nobody reports him missing as we understand it at this point. for six months until two weeks before the actual shooting. and it also brings into context this. and does everyone remember this, this, this image right here of him on the phone that's just a few minutes before brian thompson walks down the street. tim. and and is allegedly killed by mangione. he's on his cell phone and he's talking to someone. so now we know he really cut off contact with everyone. um, it makes that call perhaps even more important. who do you think he may have been talking to well, you know, aaron, it's a guess on my part, but i would think that somebody might have been helping him locate thompson and time. >> thompson's arrival to the hotel for the convention. and so it could have been something innocent and inadvertent, like talking to a doorman at the hotel that thompson was staying at, you know, making a plea. hey, i sent my resume to

unitedhealthcare, and i'm really hoping to meet the ceo today at at the investors conference. can you just let me know when he's arriving? maybe i can bump into him in the lobby or something. and, you know, you do something like that and say, hey, here's my number. call me if you find out when he's leaving the hotel. or it could be. i mean, there's there's a possibility of accomplices. he he wrote in his mini manifesto that, you know, to the feds that he acted alone, but that doesn't mean he's telling the truth. but i think there's a possibility that he was gaining intelligence in that phone call. had something to do with that, because the close proximity to the time and place of the killing is very important, and it's a call that i'm sure nypd and the fbi are tracking down in every way they can. >> and, mark, i know you think that call is crucial to now. >> i think it's crucial for companies. i think, look, when you plan on shooting somebody, if that was true, you also probably plan on getting shot yourself. i think that that phone call may have been saying goodbye to somebody, whether it's a mother, a friend, whatever could have been a

coconspirator cohort, i grant you that. but i think it's going to be significant because of who he is possibly saying goodbye to more than anything else. >> yeah. and if and of course, if it was someone, um, that person didn't say anything subsequently to anyone. in fact, as we understand from the nypd, no one did. no one in his family with all these images said that they thought it might be him. thank you all very much. i appreciate your time. and next, the ceo murder suspect was high school valedictorian who said this the people in our lives, especially our parents and teachers, had such huge roles this comes as we learn new details about the wealthy and powerful mangione family. and even as he faces murder charges for killing a man in cold blood, many americans are celebrating mangione. >> this ivy league hottie named luigi is the robin hood that we never knew that we needed. >> plus, inside assad's palace after the dictator fled to

russia. you see her there? clarissa ward will be out front. >> welcome to times square that's not in my life. >> cheers we're so sorry we are joined by john mayer. >> we are at a cat bar out. oh, my gosh, that's perfect. tv new year's eve live with anderson and andy. live coverage starts at eight on cnn. streaming live en masse. >> at harbor freight. we do business differently from the other guys. we design and test our own tools and sell them directly to you. no middlemen, just quality tools you can trust at prices you'll love. customize, and save with liberty mutual customize and save. >> and then i wake up. >> is lemieux with you in all

your dreams? >> oh, yeah. >> only pay for what you need. >> liberty, liberty, liberty, liberty. >> okay, everyone, our mission is to provide complete, balanced nutrition for strength and energy. >> ensure with 27 vitamins and minerals, nutrients for immune health. >> and ensure complete with 30g of protein your parents have given you some amazing gifts. >> celebrate the ones you inherited with ancestry dna. explore the detailed family roots, cultures, and traits that shaped who you are today. for only $39. >> i used to think of holiday one stop shop as a myth until i found michael's. >> oh, i need those. definitely need those i know this place is unbelievable. >> how did you fit in the front door? >> okay, y'all, we got ten orders coming in. starting in business is never easy, but starting at eight months pregnant, that's a different story. i couldn't slow down.

we were starting a business from the ground up. people were showing up left and right. and so did our business needs. the chase e kiara made it easy. when you go for something big like this, your kids see that and they believe they can do the same. >> earn unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase with the chase ink business unlimited card from chase for business. >> make more of what's yours. >> are they really going to spend all day streaming college football on directv? >> can you blame them? >> they've got the biggest rivalries and bowl games. >> speaking of frank, run a slant to the bowl of chips. bobby buttonhook to the salsa. >> what are you going to do, coach prime? >> don't question your coach, man. >> an alternative to pills. >> voltaren is a clinically proven arthritis pain relief gel which penetrates deep to target the source of pain with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory medicine directly at the source. >> voltaren the joy of movement. >> everyone's running to subway for three. all new spicy footlongs. wait, subway did what? that's right. they're bringing the heat with creamy

sriracha, jalapenos and all new ghost pepper bread. but hurry, these subs are only here for a limited time. >> not again. you cold is coming. your cold is coming. thanks, revere. >> we really need to keep xai your business needs a network it can count on... even during the unexpected. power's out! -power's out! power's out! comcast business has got you covered, with wifi backup to help keep you up and running. wifi's up. let's power on!

let's power on! -let's power on! it's from the company with 99.9% network reliability. let's power on! power on with the leader in connectivity. get wifi backup for your business, or get started with comcast business internet. and for a limited time, get an $800 holiday bonus. call today. >> that's one ( 800) 269-9522. >> i'm clarissa ward in damascus, and this is cnn breaking news. >> the lawyer for the alleged killer, luigi mangione won't say if the prominent and wealthy mangione family hired him. mangione family is influential in the baltimore area. they own two country clubs, a nursing home, a radio station, among other things. luigi went to an elite all boys high school where tuition runs about $40,000 a year. he was valedictorian there, and we want to play part of his graduation speech so you can see and hear him before he allegedly gunned down the ceo of america's biggest health care company the class of 2016

inventiveness also stems from its incredible courage to explore the unknown and try new things. >> the people in our lives, especially our parents and teachers, had such huge roles as well the parents here today first off sending us to gilman, was far from a small financial investment. i'd like to personally thank each of you for sending your sons here, as i can't imagine the class of 2016 without any one of these men on stage. father, thank you for all the time and love you've put into our lives. you've instilled values in us, fed and clothed us, and simply been there for us every step of the way i'd also like to thank every gilman teacher and faculty member here today throughout all three divisions of the school. our imagination draws from your inspiration and our courage largely depends on your encouragement in the classroom, on the fields, and on the stage. so parents and faculty, thank you for all you

have done for us. today is as much an achievement for you as it is for us as i conclude my speech, i have to remember that a valedictory by definition is a farewell we seniors have been hiding from it all year, and i've even been avoiding it in my speech. but now it's time to face the truth. our time as gilman students has come to an end. it seems like just yesterday that we were freshmen, having tie wars and playing computer games and ct20. but now we're moving on. just like. just like we've done in these past few years. we'll be exploring the unknown, whether that be attending colleges across the country, traveling the world during gap years, or fulfilling military service in foreign countries. as we embrace the new. however, we won't forget the old. our friendships, values and memories from gilman will always stay with us. so to the class of 2016, a kind of

class that only comes around once every 50 years, it's been an incredible journey and i simply can't imagine the last few years with any other group of guys. thank you. >> great job. very good. >> eight years later, he is now the suspected shooter carrying out an assassination against the ceo of the largest health care company in america. talking there about the time and love of his parents, the values that he was raised with. outfront now, jack kelly, a longtime columnist at the baltimore sun who has interacted with the mangione family over the years. and, jack, i really appreciate your time hearing him there and seeing him there. a valedictorian surrounded by his classmates and elite prominent high school in baltimore. it fits with what we have heard a life of privilege, a high achieving and likable kid. i mean, that's what you see there. it is so jarring to watch this now. but that's really who he is. or was that

family such a powerful and prominent family? right. >> the family is incredible. i've known them for a while. i've written about them over the years. they were totally self-made. >> i've. >> i've written about the luigi's grandparents and they're wonderful people who gave back to baltimore. >> they although they made a lot of money, they also wrote checks to hospitals. >> the walters art museum are educational institutions. >> it just seems unthinkable. so what? what has happened? i mean, the they were so proud of their achievements too, and rightfully so. >> so what was it like, jack, for? you know, for someone of luigi's generation, right? you're talking about the grandparents had made, you know, so much of this business empire had come from them for luigi, a grandson, to grow up in baltimore. i mean, can you just explain to describe to

people a bit how privileged and powerful such an experience would have been? >> well, gilman's a very fine school, and it produces has produced over the years many, many of the leaders of of baltimore city. uh, i'm thinking of mayors and uh, particularly business leaders and the code of ethics. there is very strong, um, and it just it just does not add up. it just seems a complete aberration. >> it is shocking. and i think, you know, playing that, um, you know, it truly is jarring. i mean, i know you obviously have covered for many years because they are an important family in towson and baltimore. towson is a small town in many respects. and i know you spoke with the mangione family in 2023, specifically with luigi's uncle for an obituary on his grandmother and grandfather. luigi's grandmother and

grandfather. and then the two of you became close. >> we did, we did, and we we would talk on the phone. and i mean, when his grandmother died, we took the unusual step in the baltimore sun of running a picture of her surrounded by not all of her grandchildren, but but so many of them. and she was just this happy, smiling lady. and the children's faces just were beaming too. it's it's a very loving family. uh, the family, as i mentioned before, also has given so much back to the community in baltimore. they made the money, but they didn't sit on it. >> mm. well, it is really fascinating as we just try to understand something that, of course, fundamentally, in so many ways will remain incomprehensible. jack, thank you very much. i very much appreciate your time. all right. and next, luigi mangione cult following online i think he'll go down as a hero in history. and the parents of

american reporter austin tice who's been missing in syria for a dozen years. speak out tonight. out front. >> we just want to have enough money for retirement and travel to visit our grandchildren. i understand that's why at fisher investments, we start by getting to know each other so i can learn about your family, lifestyle, goals and needs, allowing us to tailor your portfolio. >> what about commission based products? >> we don't sell those. we're a fiduciary obligated to act in your best interests. so how do your management fees work? we have a transparent fee structure, so we do better. when you do better at fisher investments we're clearly different. >> do you have subscriptions that are forgotten or even hidden see and cancel them all in one place. >> with experian. oh download the app and see how much you could save unnecessary action hero missing punches, unnecessary check reversals, unnecessary time sheet

corrections, unnecessary unanswered sick time. >> unnecessary. go. >> unnecessary. go. unnecessary when you can take this phone, you'll be ready. >> make the unnecessary. unnecessary. let your employees do their own payroll. >> no peeking. okay, okay. open up over 600,000 usps employees working in sync to ensure everything sent on its holiday ride ends with a moment of joy. >> the united states postal service, hey. >> who's beetlejuice? >> don't ever say that name. >> not ever.

>> beetlejuice. beetlejuice. beetlejuice. beetlejuice is shake shake shake shake shake shake shake shake. >> i'm going to make you so happy calfire. >> this one's from the heart. >> beetlejuice. beetlejuice. rated pg 13. now streaming exclusively on max. everyone's running to subway for three. all new spicy footlongs. wait. subway did what? that's right. they're bringing the heat with creamy sriracha, jalapenos and all new ghost pepper bread. but hurry! these subs are only here for a limited time. >> an alternative to pills. >> voltaren is a clinically proven arthritis pain relief gel which penetrates deep to target the source of pain with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory

your phone, install the free keepsake app. we would love a chance to frame it for you. >> cnn this morning with kasie hunt. tomorrow at 5:00 eastern.

>> breaking news. the alleged killer luigi mangione denied bail as many people are sympathizing with him online. tonight. the book delay, deny, defend, which is about the health insurance industry's tactics, jumping to number two on amazon's nonfiction bestsellers list. number two, safe to say that book would never have been anywhere near number two if it were not for luigi mangione those three words, delay, deny, defend were almost identical to the ones found on shell casings near the crime scene and on yelp. the mcdonald's where he was apprehended has been hit with a flood of one star reviews, calling the employees, quote, snitches and rats. jason carroll is out front. >> this ivy league hottie named luigi is the robin hood that we never knew that we needed. >> i listened to luigi's manifesto this morning three times and i cried. >> honestly, it's beautiful and i agree with him. he left a very powerful message and he highlighted how terrible the

health care system is in america. >> i think he'll go down as a hero in history. >> he had been a named suspect for less than 48 hours, and yet within a fraction of that time, many in the world of social media had already made up their minds about luigi mangione. >> i'm just eating it up because this is like. regular, everyday person becoming our hero, our vigilante. >> these types of comments angering law enforcement and public officials. >> i don't care your views about health care companies because i don't think they're great right now either. >> but you do not celebrate the assassination of another human being who was just doing his job. >> but interest in mangione just continues to grow. on x before his arrest announcement, he had just 64 followers. now more than 320,000 and counting. his initial 827 followers on instagram grew exponentially monday as we watched. by 3:00,

more than 32,000 an hour later, 53,000 by 5:00 monday, more than 71,000 followers before that account was suspended. many of the comments calling for his freedom and calling him a hero. >> hear me on this. >> he is no hero. >> the real hero in this story is the person who called 911 at mcdonald's. >> that mcdonald's in altoona, pennsylvania, where a worker spotted the 26 year old eating and called 911 monday, targeted by mangione supporters. >> what am i going to do? i'm going to stop eating mcdonald's. >> it got so bad google had to remove reviews after that location was flooded with negative comments. someone hung a banner above i-83 with the words deny, defend, oppose, health care for all, a reference to bullet casings left at the crime scene. amazon pulled apparel and home goods featuring the phrase online mangione may be a folk hero to

some, but offline and in person, no shortage of those condemning him. >> health care is a mess in this country, but to celebrate somebody's death is sickening. >> the people in these higher positions, like ceos, they need to look at themselves and their company and ask themselves, why are people so ready to condemn us? >> why are they so willing to call someone who supposedly killed another human being a hero? >> while some suspect support for mangione is not all about rage against health care, but instead something far more subjective and superficial. >> it's the halo effect, like manifesting in real society. >> you really like? >> i truly believe so. >> like people treat people who are attractive. like way differently. >> people are like giving him leeway with this because they are fantasizing him a little bit. >> but i don't think violence should ever be the answer. no matter the circumstance. >> erin, this could just end up being one of those cases that just ends up capturing the

attention of the american people for a period of time. i mean, you look at what's happening right now on ebay. at last checks still selling merch related to this case and the hashtag free luigi mangione is something that's still trending even at this hour. >> erin. jason, thank you very much. it was fascinating just to hear from all of those people. rj martin is back with me now. he's the owner of surf break honolulu h and l, a co-living community in honolulu where he lived with and was good friends with luigi mangione, the suspected killer. so, rj, i'm glad to speak with you again. as as things happen here, it's so important to have your input and insight because you know him better than than, well, many. i mean, most people that were close to him. so when you see the video of your friend luigi shouting entering court today to face these charges, you know, and he was basically resisting and he's fighting and he's screaming out, what do you think when you see that? is

that is that in any way the person that you know, i would like to i'd like to comment on the video of him giving his valedictorian speech. yeah. go ahead. >> thoughtful, humble, good listener that that's the luigi i knew. somebody who could lead a conversation, but at the same time, listen more than he spoke. >> um, somebody who, you know, really cared about those around him and had a larger mind that was socially conscious, somebody that was just good to me and the other people that that we live together with at surf break. >> and so, um, you know, and i know you've talked about that's the person that you knew, obviously not not the, the, the sort of anger and the rage that we saw today. and you said you didn't see or hear any anger or rage, even when he was talking about things like capitalism or housing or health care or things that he was, um, had criticism for, but that that was an intellectual sort of criticism, as you described it to me before. um, he had posted a review for the

unabomber manifesto online, and that's been available for a while for people to see. right. and i know as part of the book club that he had started with you at surf break, you know, he had also put the unabomber manifesto as something for that group. what did he say about that at the time? >> um, you know, we had a lively discussion about the manifesto as a group, a collective discussion. um, but nothing about it, i think, stood out more than other conversations that we had. and, you know, frankly, i think after reading and skimming part of it, um, i don't think the ideas in it were that original in terms of, you know, um, you know, how we're destroying our planet and how we need to reevaluate our systems. um, so nothing about that conversation stuck out. he wasn't upset. he wasn't angry. i've never seen him upset or angry even. um, definitely would put him in the chill, like, nonviolent category of people.

>> so, um, last night, we. when when we spoke, you talked about his back and how much that was just weighing on him and the pain, and that even a basic surfing lesson kept him in bed for a week. he had to get a new mattress. and police are now saying they think that that that back pain may be central to what happened here. i'm curious, though, when you talked about his social life a bit, when you and i had that conversation, um, we didn't get to talk about the implications of the pain that he was going through. did he? did he date when you knew him? did he talk at all about his romantic life? >> you know, if you are in severe pain on and off, it's obviously going to affect all aspects of your life. um, you know, out of respect for his privacy and for the surf break, community privacy, i don't want to comment at all on his dating or any of the other members dating while while we live together. >> yeah. no, i don't mean whether they were dating, i

just mean i know that, you know, you've talked a bit about the the you know, how how the back pain that he had could have made it impossible for him to be physically intimate, and that this was something that may have been frustrating for him, um, as they try to understand sort of what he was going through. do you think that this could end up being something important i think that pain is something that can change our brain chemistry. >> you know, i think it's something that changes our thoughts. um, and i don't know, because i don't have firsthand knowledge from him of how much pain he was in or what he was dealing with. but i do know, you know, from personal experience and from other friends and, and family that when somebody is suffering the way they think about themselves and the world, um, gets warped drastically. and a lot of times you, you go to dark places when you're in excruciating pain and, you know, perhaps not receiving the care or the support that you need. >> all right. well, rj, thank

you very much. i appreciate your time good night. all right. good night. and next, as bashar al-assad has yet to surface. in moscow, clarissa ward takes us inside the palace that he left behind. wait till you see it. and i'm going to speak to the parents of austin tice. he's been held in syria for more than 12 years. but tonight they believe that he is alive and well. and they're going to tell us why. >> it's time to feed the dogs real food in the right amount. >> a healthy weight can help dogs live a longer, happier life. >> the farmer's dog makes weight management easy with fresh food. pre-portioned for your dog's needs. it's an idea whose time has come. type two diabetes. >> discover the ozempic tri-zone. >> oh oh oh ozempic. >> i got the power of three. >> i lowered my a-1c cv risk and lost some weight. >> in studies, the majority of people reached an a-1c under seven and maintained it. i'm under seven. >> ozempic lowers the risk of major cardiovascular events

such as stroke, heart attack, or death in adults. >> also with known heart disease. >> i'm lowering my risk and adults lost up to 14 pounds. i lost some weight. >> ozempic isn't for type one diabetes or children. >> don't share needles or pens or reuse needles. don't take. if you or your family had mtc me in two or if allergic to it, stop taking and get medical help right away. if you get a lump or swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, or any of these allergic reactions tell your provider if you plan to have surgery or a procedure, are breastfeeding, pregnant, or plan to be. serious side effects may include inflammation of pancreas, gallbladder problems, or changes in vision. call your prescriber if you have any of these symptoms. taking with the sulfonylurea or insulin may increase low blood sugar risk. common side effects include nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, stomach pain, constipation. some side effects lead to dehydration, which may worsen kidney problems. living with type two diabetes ask about the power of three with ozempic. if you struggle and struggle and

struggle with cpap, you should check out inspire. no mask, no hose. just sleep. learn more and view important safety information at inspire sleep.com. >> finish ultimate engineered for the toughest conditions. dry. burnt on stains. old dishwashers very hard water. finish ultimate with cycle sync technology helps deliver the ultimate clean. >> did i read this? did i get eggs? where are my keys? >> don't wait. while memory and thinking issues pile up. >> these issues may seem like normal aging, but could be due to a buildup of amyloid plaques in the brain. amyloid can build up over time. the sooner you talk to your doctor, the more options you may have. visit amyloid.com for additional information everyone's running to subway for three. >> all new spicy footlongs.

wait, subway did what? that's right. they're bringing the heat with creamy sriracha, jalapenos and all new ghost pepper bread. but hurry! these subs are only here for a limited time sounds like you need to vaporize that sore throat. >> vapor cool drops. it's sore throat relief with a rush of vicks vapors. people who. >> vaporize sore throat pain with vicks vapor. >> cool drops. we're in a limestone cave letting extreme residue build up to put finish jet-dry to the test. dishwashers are designed to use jet drive to defend against tough residues for a practically spotless shine. >> and so, babe, it's done. >> i just sold my car to carvana. >> i just entered my license plate and i answered a few questions. bam! >> i'm dropping it off and getting paid today. >> how convenient is that? >> thanks for choosing carvana. sell your car today and get paid the same day with carvana. >> what would you look at that?

>> jerry, you gotta see this saying that. >> trust me. >> after 15 walks gets a little old. >> yeah, i really should be retired by now i wish i invested when i had the chance to the moon unbelievable stop waiting and start investing. >> e-trade from morgan stanley. >> i'm elizabeth wagmeister in los angeles, and this is cnn. >> breaking news. prisoners liberated from bashar al assad's most notorious and brutal prison, known as the slaughter house. don't know their own names. that's incredible to think about what that implies. and it's according to a syrian humanitarian organization, as there are no signs yet of assad himself after he fled to moscow. clarissa ward is out front from assad's presidential palace tonight. >> outside the palace of bashar

al-assad. syrians gather to pose for photographs and celebrate the removal of its despised former owner. the public is not allowed inside the sprawling compound yet where the courtyard stretched longer than a city block. this is the driveway into bashar al assad's palace. and you can see how enormous it is. there are still casings all over the ground from rebel celebratory gunfire as they swept in here and took control at the entrance, an iranian flag unceremoniously laid out for people to step on. iran, one of the regime's staunchest allies, where once foreign dignitaries roamed the halls. now rebel fighters have the run of the place. you can see blankets on the sofas in here. it looks like this is where the rebels are sleeping. and in fact, over here you can see they've got some kind of a makeshift dining area going.

some of their weapons here. a couple of rifles on this sofa. so this gentleman here who is with the rebels has just asked that i put on my scarf. it's the first time since we've been here that anyone has asked me to cover my hair. nguyen khac giang hermon ayla and arwa min. idlib dick schoof he's says that he's from idlib, and that this is the first time he's seeing the palace. well, keith powers hussam abu saifya a-dna zain asher b we feel that the injustice will break down one day and justice must win. this is the idea of justice in our religion, he says. in islam, it is a must and a promise of allah that islam is victorious after nearly 14 years of a vicious civil war, to stand in

this palace is a proud moment. capping off a seismic victory. so the rebels here want to stress that they tell us that it was not their group that ransacked this office when they first swept in. you can see, actually, some of the graffiti here that those first rebels wrote on the window. it says a law curse hafez's soul hafez al-assad being the father of bashar when you look at these ceilings and these chandeliers, the marble, the detail, this is the kind of opulence, this lavish lifestyle that engendered so much resentment from so many syrians who have been struggling to survive for decades. while the assad family lived like this in a warehouse, rows and rows of luxury cars, ferraris, lamborghinis and classic cadillacs. this was a

dynasty that will be remembered not only for its brutality, but its deep corruption. below the palace in the heart of damascus, crowds gathered in umayyad square under assad's rule, the syrian people were forced to worship him. now they finally have the freedom to celebrate his demise and erin, we definitely noticed a marked shift in the mood on the streets today. the first couple of days that we were here, a lot of people were staying at home. a lot of people were nervous about chaos, about looting, about further violence. but today you just saw those crowds out celebrating jubilant, enjoying this victory. and i think it's important to underscore that regardless of what the rebels might have told me inside the presidential palace, out in that square, there were muslims, there were christians, there were young, there were old. there were women who were covered. there were women who

were uncovered, all of them coming together to start this new chapter. erin. >> clarissa, thank you very much. absolutely incredible to see that. and next, i'm going to speak to the parents of austin tice, the american journalist held in syria for the past 12 years. >> this is not a drill. subway dropped the price on all their subs 20% off any sub, any size. >> subway did what any sub yep. >> for a limited time, you get 20% off when you order in the app. hurry and get this deal before it's gone. >> you give my exams, i give fresh starts. >> better vision, healthy eyes. >> everybody wants that paradox saves vision. well. my beryl howell saves money. >> use your vision insurance for exams, glasses and contacts. >> all at america's best. >> mm. >> kind of needs to be more squiggly perfect. >> so now, do you have a

driver's license? >> oh. what did you get us with a click of a pen? >> you can get a new volkswagen at the sign, then drive event. >> lisa, 2024 tiguan for zero. down zero. deposit, zero first payment and zero due at signing. limited inventory available. >> sophie's helping me get my money right to achieve my ambitions. like saving for a better swing. >> loosen that grip. or with sophie, i earn more money on my money and pay no account fees. >> plus, i'm investing in my game. so if i can help fund all your ambitions no matter how ambitious. bank with sophie to score a higher apy in an epic welcome bonus. sophie, get your money right now! hello, brad. >> dad. the world the boys and girls.

now! >> i didn't sign on for this. >> it's christmas. bah, humbug. christmas is the time to be with the people you love talk to the world. >> talk. wow. >> to you and me. >> to me, harlem is home. >> but home is also your body. >> last one. >> everyone. >> i asked myself, why doesn't pilates exist in harlem? >> so i started my own studio. get in a brick and mortar in new york is not easy. >> chase inc. has supported us from studio one to studio three. >> when you start small, you need some big help. >> and chase inc. was that for me? >> earn up to 5% cash back on business essentials with the chase ink business cash card from chase for business. make more of what's yours. >> berwick every year, millions of noses are ghosted by their plugins. new airwick advanced our groundbreaking plugin that pulses scent for staying power up to 60 days, plus a fragrance boost button. our noses won't

be ignored again. >> are they really going to spend all day streaming college football on directv? >> can you blame them? >> they've got the biggest rivalries and bowl games. >> speaking of frank, run a slant to the bowl of chips. where can nfl fans get a great deal that turns christmas day into game day? x marks the spot. the nfl is streaming christmas day games exclusively on netflix, and you don't want to miss a moment. gather round the game because nothing says holidays like family and football. now xfinity customers can add streamsaver including netflix, peacock, and apple tv+ for just $15 a month. stuff your stockings with tons of entertainment and tons of savings. bring on the good stuff. xfinity.

one for you. download the free keepsake app and start framing today! >> anderson cooper 360 next on cnn tonight, a manhunt for an american in syria. >> the biden administration tonight says finding missing journalist austin tice, who has been held in syria for more than 12 years, is priority number one. >> we want anyone who is operating on the ground in syria to be on the lookout for him. >> the united states is looking into new reports that tice may be in or around damascus. tice is an american journalist, a former marine and eagle scout. he was captured while reporting on the syrian civil war. this

is the last time that marc and deborah saw their son. he was 30 years old. you see him there just days before he turned 31. he is now 43 years old and his parents are out front. now marc and debra tice and deborah, here we are, more than 12 years since those horrifying images, the last that you saw of austin after that, you went to syria. you spent nearly four months there meeting people, trying to find his trail, to find where he was. and you met some people that you became very close with. you've talked to a source that you've referred to as very significant there, telling you that now austin is being cared for and that he is well. what can you share about how certain you are that austin is okay well, i mean, it comes from intel that's been verified by

many different agencies in the united states. >> they just don't want to share it. they don't want it to be public. but it's verified. it's real. and, um, as recent as august of this year, as recent as august of this year. >> marc, what? what makes you feel this confidence? i mean, it's not just that he's alive, but that he's being cared for, that he is. uh, i don't want to use the words in good hands in the context that we're in, but that he is indeed doing well well, that's the information that we've received, you know, based on these reports from from confirmed sources. >> uh, so, you know, we're and it's not just one report, it's it's several times we have heard definitively that he's being taken care of.

>> you know, that he's in good health. >> so we trust that because of the nature of the sources and, you know, right now, of course, we're asking anyone who has the ability or comes in contact with austin to help bring him back home to us safely. >> and and, deborah, your whole family has been gathered together at your home, and austin is one of seven siblings. so, you know all together a a very full, full house and i do you believe that his release is imminent? is that why you feel so important to all be together right now well, um, we certainly hope that his release is imminent. >> it's a bit frustrating that, um, our government isn't urgent about it. they they're willing to think that austin is

going to pop up, but, um, there isn't a sense of urgency about finding him and making sure that he's okay. so i don't, you know, now we're sort of getting the the vibe about, you know, be patient. this could take some time kind of thing. um, but, you know, whatever. whenever he walks out, we're going to put our arms around him and we're going to move on. and the rest of our lives right. um, and but, you know, every minute is, is about a week long right now as we wait for him to walk free. >> it's truly impossible for anyone to imagine. but the waiting, the agony as parents to wait for so long for a child. marc, when you say you understand he's he's doing well. do you know anything about the circumstances under which he's been held or the duress of his situation or anything like that uh,

no, not in any kind of detail. >> uh, again, you know, the word that we've gotten is that his needs are being met and he's in reasonable health. and, uh, you know, being treated humanely. >> i mean, marc, the last time you saw him, he was 30. he was, you know, it was his. and, you know, that's the last time you hugged him. and, you know, turns 31 and then you have those those horrible images. um, you know, you all have described your son as that. he talked faster, walked smarter, was stronger, smarter than any child in the history of the world um, i know his siblings are around you right now, but nonetheless, do you think that that strength, the person that you knew, the marine, the eagle scout, all the wonderful things about your child will have sustained him through 12 years?

>> well, he has a really, really strong will. he was always a strong willed person. he has a love of life. i mean, a just a beam of life and, uh, also, he's just very. there are things in his past and in the, in the literature that he was reading when he was in fourth grade and so forth. this has always been on his path. you know, uh, he's on his path now. and it's kind of an odd thing to say, but it but it comes from a life of faith. and austin also has that deep faith. and so he knows that his time will come and he will walk free. and what i pray for him is about mandela and what mandela said, which is not only do i need to come out of prison, but i must also be free

by being fully forgiving. and so i pray that for austin all the time. >> i would just just add that, uh, he's a tremendously disciplined person. uh, and so, you know, my image of him is getting up in the morning, uh, doing his workout with whatever means he can. and, and then, you know, depending on what kind of material he has at hand, doing some kind of studying, you know, whether it's language or something else. i just think of him as, as, you know, having a disciplined life even though he's in captivity. >> well, thank you both so very much. we all can only hope that that you and your children will have the incredible joy of seeing him again very soon. thank you so much for talking to me. >> a very happy christmas. yes, that's what we're waiting for. aaron, thank you so