>> dum dum dum dum dum dum dum. hey hey baby. whoa. >> i remember hearing a house is not a home for the first time. i couldn't believe what i was hearing. i told him, i said baby doll, you have just given me the definitive version of that song. >> a chair is still a chair. even when there's no. one sitting there. >> tune in the all new cnn film luther. never too much premieres new year's day at 8 p.m. eastern and pacific, right here on cnn. and thank you very much

house ethics committee investigation into matt gaetz took years. and now, even though he is no longer a congressman, that report detailing alleged sexual, criminal and ethical wrongdoing is out. also tonight, the alleged killer in court answering to first degree murder charges and the breaking news, former president bill clinton hospitalized tonight. we have details on his condition. good evening. i'm erica hill in for anderson tonight. the man who might have been the country's top law enforcement official tonight is also a man whose former colleagues today, in a stunning break with tradition, chose to publicly accuse him of having sex with a minor of regularly paying women for sex, using or possessing illegal drugs, accepting improper gifts and other acts, including obstructing the investigation into those allegations. and honestly, those are just the bullet points from the introduction to the house ethics committee's report, a

document the committee acknowledged it would not ordinarily release given the gaetz resigned from congress the day he was nominated for ag and then, of course, withdrew from consideration again. that happened just eight days later. quoting from the report. now the committee does not do so lightly, saying in this instance, although several committee members objected, a majority of the members of the committee agreed that the committee's findings should be released to the public. >> it is a it is a horrible allegation and it is a lie. >> that was then gaetz shortly after news of the sex with a minor allegation broke. and now he continues to deny any wrongdoing and actually went to court today to try to block publication of this report. cnn's katelyn polantz is joining me now with more. so what more is in this report? there are certainly some very allegations in here. >> there is erica, and it was impossible for matt gaetz to block the publication of this report. the house put it out there and his lawsuit was

dismissed pretty quickly from court today. but what the house found, not only in the broad brush of what they say were violations of their standards of conduct, substantial evidence of things like prostitution or him engaging in paying women for commercial sex, statutory rape, illicit drug use. they they also get into the details in this house. house ethics committee report weaving together not just the trace of payments that they were able to assemble, showing venmo payments of hundreds of dollars to women from various accounts used or affiliated with gaetz. but also the testimony of women themselves, including a victim, a 17 year old girl at the time in july 2017 who was having sex with matt gaetz at a party. the committee writes about that victim. the committee received testimony. the victim, a and representative gaetz, had sex twice during the party, including at least once in the

presence of other party attendees. victim, a recalled receiving $400 in cash from representative gaetz that evening, which she understood to be payment for sex at the time she had just completed her junior year of high school. the federal government, the federal justice department, did investigate him for federal sex trafficking violations and other possible crimes, did not charge him with anything. so the house ethics committee picked up its investigation, and they found not just this situation with this then underage girl, but they say that many women that gaetz was having sex with were receiving money for drugs or for the sex to the tune of hundreds, if not thousands of dollars. and then on top of that, this violation of standards of conduct in the house, it includes him doing drugs. another quote from the report, another woman said that she brought cocaine to at least one event with representative gaetz, and that she witnessed him taking cocaine or ecstasy

on at least five occasions. mr. greenberg, that's a witness, told the committee that he would typically provide drugs, such as ecstasy, for events he attended, and representative gaetz would pay him back in cash. several other women observed representative gaetz to be under the influence of drugs. now matt gaetz, he obviously didn't want that report out there today, but he also has said repeatedly to the committee directly and then in public that these allegations against him are false. >> as you noted, his last ditch effort to keep this report from being released failed. is there any other legal recourse that he has at this point? >> there is a question out there about what happens next. the committee did raise the possibility that they think he may have made false statements or obstructed congress in trying to delay or defer them from getting information from him. there's also a question of what florida might do, although we have no evidence at this time to believe that florida is investigating matt gaetz for what the committee says they think could be statutory rape. >> and that's for that that

that incident that involved the minor, the 17 year old at the time that you mentioned, caitlin. appreciate it. thank you. joining us now, cnn political commentator brad todd. jasmine wright, political reporter for notice and cnn political commentator van jones. it's good to see you also, jasmine, as we look at this, the fact that the house ethics committee had initially voted along party lines to keep this report sealed. what changed? what convinced some republicans on the ethics committee to instead change their vote and release this report? >> yeah, erica. well, i think you're right. there was always going to be a question of whether they would, whether they not. but ultimately, two republicans sided with democrats to release this report. that's not of course, the chair the chair didn't want that out. he said it within the report. and another democrat on that bipartisan committee. but i think what's really interesting here is that this is a committee of matt gaetz, peers, former peers, and potentially future peers that voted to release that. they said that it was for

transparency sake, making the case that the american public deserved to know what a sitting member of congress was accused of. now, of course, matt gaetz has denied all of these allegations. in fact, it kind of accused this committee of weaponizing this information that he again denies as false against him. but still, this was a group of his peers really pushing this information out into the public zeitgeist, not into the court of law, but of course, the court of public opinion in a really stunning example, because of course, we know that matt gaetz resigned from congress. >> yeah, it's such an important point. the fact that they clearly wanted this information out there, as you say, in the court of public opinion. and when we look at this as recently as yesterday, you had matt gaetz floating the idea of another run for office. knowing this report, right, was likely coming out. today you have trump ally steve bannon saying, quote, gaetz has to come back. don't back down. double down in this world that we live in. let's say matt gaetz does launch a potential bid for office. does any of

this serve as disqualifying in any way for voters? >> well, it used to. it would have it's hard to know in this environment we find ourselves. now, the one thing that's very clear is, um, you know, gaetz has a lot of enemies. um, you have people in his own party that all they had to do was just go with their party chair and go, go with the committee chair and go with precedent. and this would have had to be leaked, but at least it wouldn't have been put out in this way. this lets you know this guy has posed some serious people in serious places that we're talking about this tonight. but but does it make him a martyr or a villain to florida? voters will probably find out pretty soon. >> when we look at this, just because matt gaetz obviously withdrew that nomination for ag, it doesn't mean that there could not be a role in a trump administration. brad, that does not require senate confirmation, where we could

see him as a part of that administration. how do you see this report impacting those chances? to van's point, martyr or villain? does this elevate or lower his state's status with donald trump? >> well, i think first off, his relationship with donald trump is from the campaign where he was a key member of their debate prep team. so there i think donald trump knows what he got with matt gaetz, who donald trump has pulled, pulled him back after he was clear he was not going to get the votes in the senate, and he didn't have a problem of 3 or 4 votes. he had a problem of 23 or 24 votes in the senate that he was not going to get from republicans. i also think you have to look at the makeup of this ethics committee. you know, michael guest, who's the chairman, is a former prosecutor. you have another former prosecutor on there and a former sheriff on there on the just on the republican side, these are serious people who look into these things with all due process, and they're charged with not only upholding the rules of the house, but also the reputation of the house. and there they find in the report, if you read the details of the report, there

are several indications that perhaps matt gaetz was guilty of accepting favors and gifts that violate the house gift ban. well, that's exactly the kind of thing that the ethics committee is charged with enforcing. and so i think he knew he was going to have a problem with the ethics committee. that's why he skated out of congress. that's why he resigned from the next congress when he didn't even have to. he could have gone in the next congress and waited out his nomination chances for attorney general. but instead, he resigned from both congresses. i think that tells you a lot. we also know matt gaetz didn't sit for an interview. they asked him back in july to have him sit for a voluntary interview or respond to a scene of subpoena for the ethics committee. he chose not to do that. those things also tell us things about where he stands regarding the charges. >> and when we look at all of this, what are you hearing from your sources in terms of whether or not we may hear donald trump weigh in publicly? >> yeah. well, what i've heard from my sources, people close to trump, is that some are actually surprised that the that the report actually came out, because matt gaetz is no

longer a sitting member of congress because of the way that he resigned. um, but i think the question on a lot of people's minds in and around mar-a-lago and certainly here in dc, is whether or not trump is going to publicly come out and kind of bless this. i think what we've seen in the reality, getting to van's first point is that some of these republicans live in different realities, which is that if you are a trump loyalist, you kind of have a different playbook and a report like this may not be as damaging as somebody who is not within trump's favor. now, one thing that i heard from somebody is that if he does bless matt gaetz, right hand over him, that will take a lot of political capital for the president elect. so maybe there's a chance that if he doesn't go to own network and that he doesn't go back to congress, that he becomes a member of the administration in a seat that doesn't need to be confirmed. but there is a major question of if trump is kind of getting all of these different guidances and reports from his advisers, which way he'll go. and i think that's kind of a

largely a major question here. >> yeah, we will be watching and waiting. >> i guess there may be 500 and go ahead. well, there's 535 members of congress, and there might be three of them that want matt gaetz in some kind of job in the administration. so the president elect may factor that his unpopularity in congress before he does anything. >> we'll see. or maybe elon musk will win in weigh in. who knows? oh, to be a fly on the wall of brad jasmine van. thank you all. just up here next luigi mangione his arraignment today on state charges, including first degree murder and the kind of cases ahead for him now in both state and federal court. and still to come, everything that we've learned about what is ailing former president bill clinton, he has been hospitalized tonight, of course, two days before christmas. that update and much more when ac360 continues. >> anderson cooper 360 is brought to you by the focus features film. nosferatu succumbed to the darkness. nosferatu rated r only in

theaters this wednesday. special engagements in dolby and imax. >> nosferatu. >> nosferatu rated r only in theaters this wednesday. special engagements in dolby and imax. >> six in. six, four, 36. >> painting up. powered up and you ought to be glad to. good girls are gonna go bad. >> you were made to chase your passions. we were made to put them in a package. >> my moderate to severe crohn's symptoms kept me out of the picture. now i have skyrizi. i've got places to go, and i'm feeling free. >> controlling my crohn's means

everything to me. control is everything to me. >> and now i'm back in the picture. feel significant symptom relief at four weeks with skyrizi, including less abdominal pain and fewer bowel movements. skyrizi helped visibly improve damage of the intestinal lining, and with skyrizi, many were in remission at 12 weeks, at one year, and even at two years. >> don't use if allergic serious allergic reactions, increased infections or lower ability to fight them may occur before treatment. get checked for infections and tb. tell your doctor about any flulike symptoms or vaccines. liver problems leading to hospitalization may occur when treated for crohn's. >> now's the time to take control of your crohn's. control is everything to me. ask your doctor about skyrizi, the number one prescribed biologic in crohn's disease. >> after homoglaea cleaned our place for $19, we fired our old housekeeper. pomerleau tackled everything from our kitchen to our bathroom, all our laundry. you just pick a date, pick a

cleaner, and enjoy a spotless house for $19. >> you make good choices, always planning ahead. like, do not just chase a career, but one day. follow your heart. with ambition like that, you need someone who elevates advice to a craft. at ubs, we match your vision with insight and expertise to shape a unique outcome for z's bakery is looking to add a pizza oven,

arissa's hair salon wants to expand their space, and steve's t-shirt shop wants to bring on more help. with the comcast business 5-year price lock guarantee, they can think more about possibilities for their business and not the cost of their internet. it's five years of gig-speeds and advanced security. all from the company with 99.9% network reliability. get the 5-year price lock guarantee, now back for a limited time. powering five years of savings. powering possibilities™. 1877866 8555. >> you only come across an artist like luther vandross. once in a lifetime. >> he was a boss from the beginning, luther said. i have a sound in my head. i got to get it out. you are my shining star. >> my. >> it was the most exciting time in the world. his life had extremely joyful moments and some really difficult moments. if we were to be able to talk to luther as fans, we would be able to say, i don't want to

stop. we just love you, luther. >> never too much new year's day at eight on cnn. >> when we ended last week, alleged killer luigi mangione had been unexpectedly charged with federal crimes, including a murder count carrying a potential death sentence. so that pushed his arraignment on state charges to this morning. cnn's shimon prokupecz was there. >> the crime of murder in the first degree and other related charges. how do you plead to this indictment, sir? guilty or not guilty? >> or not guilty? >> accused killer luigi mangione back in court. this time for the charges he faces in new york state. wearing khakis and a maroon sweater shackled at the wrists and ankles, the camera in court capturing the 26 year old as he faces 11 state charges that include murder in the first degree and murder in the second degree as a crime of terrorism for the alleged killing of united health care ceo brian thompson. >> he's a young man and he is

being treated like a human ping pong ball. >> his attorneys slamming the way mangione was paraded before cameras when being brought back to new york city from pennsylvania. >> they are literally treating him like he is like like some sort of political fodder, like some sort of spectacle. >> during the arraignment with rare camera access being allowed to record the proceedings, prosecutors disclosing just how much evidence they have. >> i have never seen a case with such volume of evidence, aside from the issue of the quality of the evidence, this is not a usual case in terms of the thousands of hours of video tracking and the like. >> mangione seen smiling at times while talking with his legal team. outside court, a small group of protesters gathered to voice their support for mangione, we said enough to fight. the hearing ended with mangione casually folding some papers before police escorted

him away. >> did you have anything to say? >> mangione also faces federal charges that include murder through the use of a firearm. the state trial is expected to come first. mangione faces a maximum sentence of life in prison for the state. charges, and prosecutors could decide to seek a death penalty in the federal case. and erica mangione will be back in that manhattan court on february 21st. as the legal process gets underway. >> erica shimon, appreciate it. thank you. also with me now, jon miller, our chief law enforcement and intelligence analyst. he's also a former nypd deputy chief and former federal prosecutor, jeffrey toobin and new york city defense and trial attorney misty marris. good to have all of you here. so, jon, as we look at this, there are still actually some questions. and shimon touched on this in his piece about whether the state or the federal trial could go first. the census state is first, but could anything derail that? >> well, it could change. but the federal prosecutors said on friday that they carefully

couched that they expect the state trial to proceed before the federal trial. so the state trial could take a year before it comes around to trial. and the federal trial could come sometime before that. i mean, some some good time after that. >> right. so as we as we look at all of this, i was struck by just some of the moments in court today. so, um, the attorney, the defense attorney for mangione karen friedman agnifilo, she was really drilling down on what's now become this infamous perp walk, right, that we saw, including the involvement of new york city mayor eric adams. she also said she believed it was actually unconstitutional. take a listen. >> your honor knows under laura v charles, the court of appeals for the second circuit has held it to be clearly established that the state perp walks to the media unrelated to a legitimate law enforcement law enforcement objective is unconstitutional. and i submit there is zero law enforcement

objective to do that sort of perp walk. >> she said he was political fodder. she basically was saying this was performative. there was zero law enforcement objective to having what we saw on friday. you spent years as a prosecutor. do you agree? >> no, i don't agree. i mean, the prosecutor, you know, prosecutors and police have to get defendants from point a to point b when there is a lot of police interest, a public, a public interest, there are going to be cameras following them. i don't blame agnifilo for for raising this. this is something defense attorneys often do and should do. and you know, keep try to keep the publicity under control. what they are going to try to do is delay things. get this thing on a slower, you know, timeline so that they can study thousands of hours of of video evidence, lots of forensic evidence, and also allow passions to cool around the case. you know, it is a classic strategy. the prosecution always wants to go

right away. defense wants to delay here, given the magnitude of the evidence. prosecutor even said it in court. the defense is going to have very good reasons to delay this. as john said, for as much as a year, if not longer. >> it is interesting, though, that was it was not just the perp walk right where she was calling out eric adams. there was also another moment that i want to play that i think has stood out to a lot of us. >> your honor, the mayor should know more than anyone about the presumption of innocence that he, too, is afforded when he is dealing with his own issues. and frankly, i submit that he was just trying to detract from those issues by making a spectacle of mr. mangione missy. >> she's saying there that he is trying to distract from his own legal issues as a defense attorney. smart strategy. >> well, and also a little thinly veiled statement about eric adams and his and his own problems. right. but certainly, a defense attorney has an obligation to their client to preserve any defenses that they

may want to raise along the course of the case. and right now, what we see is laying the foundation for these constitutional challenges relating to whether or not mangione can get a fair trial, whether his due process rights have been violated. and jeff made great points about how transport, transporting someone who's such a high profile defendant from point a to point b is obviously going to garner significant media attention. that being said, there's a difference from a defense perspective, and this will be the argument when you have the mayor of new york city at the helm with those cameras and then making a statement after the fact that he, in fact, participated for the very purpose of making a statement to the public regarding these types of things happening in new york city as a deterrent. so that's where we're seeing this argument shaping right at the very beginning of the case. >> we should remind people, just so people out there don't know, eric adams, the mayor, is currently under federal indictment. so he will be going to trial in the same courthouse

as mangione in at at some point. however, you know, he's still the mayor. and this is a major news event in new york city. he should be allowed to comment on it. >> so does a comment like what we heard from karen in court today? does that backfire at some point? >> you know, this is going to go on for so long. i don't think anybody is going to remember a year from now what eric adams did or didn't say about mangione. you know, this is what goes on in these high profile cases, but time takes care of a lot of the wounds you mentioned. >> and we were talking about the sheer volume of evidence there is, john, when there are bits and pieces that we know, obviously. but what is your sense of, um, just how extensive that is and how much that will add to the timeline here? >> excuse me. um, it's going to add a lot. it's hundreds of interviews. it's hundreds of exhibits. it's the dna evidence. it's the ballistic

evidence. it's the microscopic tests. it's all the tips that came into the tip line. it's all the other suspects that they looked at as potentially prime suspects. before mangione was arrested. and it is chiefly. and when you talk about they said, get us aa2 terabyte hard drive to load this evidence onto because it will blow up the the portal that they use on regular cases. it's principally thousands of hours of video, which have relevant snatches of a couple of minutes or seconds here or there, but they're entitled to get all of it. >> as we look at all of that playing out, we're also talking about a very high profile defendant here, right in federal custody right now in a in a prison that is not known for being necessarily a great place to stay while you're awaiting trial, how does the high profile nature of this defendant figure into the way that he's going to be treated behind bars?

>> um, he's in the same federal jail as p diddy right now. there are other high profile defendants in there. um, the question is, will he be segregated because he's in a very notoriety driven case, or will he be in general population? and the other major question is, will he stay there? i mean, they had to borrow him from the feds today to to the purpose of this hearing, and they had to give him back at some point. these judges are going to have to get together, and these prosecutors are going to have to get together and say, while he is being held for a state trial, is he going to be transferred to state custody? at which point he ends up in rikers island, which is equally, if not more so, unpleasant place? >> yeah, there is often a lot of competition between state and federal prosecutors for high profile cases. everybody is being very nice now, but you can be sure there is some serious negotiating going on behind the scenes. and frankly, the feds usually win because

they have more resources here. they're suggesting that the state will go first. right. stay tuned. >> there's a lot of work to do. probably no surprise that that the guilty, the the plea today was not guilty, missy. but really quickly there are questions about what the defense will be. there's also been a lot of talk today about the fact that the defendant and his attorney were essentially in matching outfits as a defense attorney, it was hard to it was hard to miss. is there anything to read into that, or are we all just desperate for something to talk about? it was hard to miss. >> i agree. i don't think they plan to wear matching outfits necessarily, but it's been amazing the way with mangione every single issue regarding his appearance has really been at the forefront of the conversation. but yeah, we don't know how the defense is going to play out. it's largely going to depend on what's admissible in that courtroom. and i think jeff made a great point about the feds and the state push pull on the back end. i'm wondering what happens on jan 20 when we're talking about the department of

justice and a new attorney general, and maybe not so nice between alvin bragg's office and that particular office, so we could see some changes along the way about how that tension plays out. >> yeah, really appreciate it. misty john, thank you very much, mr. toobin. stick around. we are going to get your take on president biden's decision to commute the sentence sentences of all but three of the 40 federal death row inmates. also ahead, the latest on former president clinton and his health. he has been hospitalized tonight and it has been one wild year. >> i know that whole new live stream was crazy. >> what you have been following actual news, right? oh, boy. >> new year's eve live with anderson and andy. live coverage starts at eight on cnn and streaming live on max. >> if you're living with hiv, imagine being good to go without daily hiv pills. good to go binge watch. good to go

out even later with cabenuva, there's no pausing for daily hiv pills for adults who are undetectable. cabenuva is the only complete long acting hiv treatment you can get every other month. it's two injections from a health care provider as few as six times a year. don't take cabenuva if allergic to its ingredients or taking certain medicines that may interact. serious side effects include allergic reactions or rash. post injection reactions, liver problems, and depression. if these occur, get medical help right away. tell your doctor about your medicines or supplements. medical conditions, liver or kidney problems, mental health, pregnancy and breastfeeding. the most common side effect is injection site reaction. with cabenuva, you're good to go without daily hiv pills. talk to your doctor about switching. there's nothing like welcome to the white lotus in thailand. >> this is very exciting.

>> aren't you a brave girl? there's nothing like. >> where's the money? >> you can't heal something unless you say it out loud. it's not the light. >> not the light. there's nothing like it. >> everybody want to walk like me. wanna talk like me. but it's chalk and cheese. y'all. bring your a-game. >> bring it, bring it, bring your a-game. bring. bring your a-game. bring your a-game. bring your a-game, bring your. game. >> it's really been a gift having mom live with us. but as a nurse, my training told me she needed more help than i could provide. so i connected

with a place for mom, my senior living advisor understood our unique situation. she quickly recommended communities and set up tours. a place for mom helped us get to a decision and now mom is so well

your groups with high quality custom apparel and promo products, all backed by our guarantee at custom inc.com. >> i want to be the greatest player that i could possibly become. every holiday. >> former president clinton spending the night in a washington, d.c. hospital. and though his condition is not being described as urgent, let alone dire, it's important to note at 78, he has a history of heart disease, leading to some questions tonight. cnn's kayla tausche. joining us now with more. so kayla, what more do we know about why the former president is in the hospital and what this means for his overall health? >> well, erica, former president bill clinton was admitted to medstar hospital in

georgetown earlier this afternoon out of what his aides call an abundance of caution after he developed a fever. they describe him as awake and alert and say that he's undergoing testing and observation. after developing that fever at his washington area home earlier today. now, they say that he's in good spirits. he's happy. he's receiving good medical care. but certainly, erica, a fever is not normally something that would send you to the hospital. so that is why his history of medical issues is coming into the conversation here. that being said, his aides say that he hopes to be home by christmas, but he will be there at least overnight. >> so he's staying there at least overnight. as you mentioned, there is this history of medical issues. just remind us of some of some of what he has faced health wise since leaving office. >> well, he's been out of office now for nearly a quarter of a century. and in that time, he's undergone multiple surgeries. in 2004, quadruple bypass heart surgery after experiencing chest pain and shortness of breath. the following year, he had surgery for a collapsed lung, and he

later also received two stents that were that were inserted into his heart. so certainly he has had several of these operations. but in just four years ago, he was also hospitalized for a urological infection that led to a blood condition known as sepsis, which can be fatal. medical analysts on our air today have pointed out that one of the symptoms of that is fever. so certainly that is one of the reasons why they want to have him seriously evaluated in this moment. >> erica understandably kayla tausche with the update for us. thank you. turning now to the surprise action today by president biden commuting the sentences of 37 of the 40 federal prisoners currently on death row, commuting those sentences to life without parole. now, this comes, of course, before the president elect, who supports capital punishment, takes office. the trump transition team calling the move a, quote, abhorrent decision, adding that it benefits those, quote, among the worst killers in the world. back with us, jeff toobin, who is the author of the upcoming

book the pardon the politics of presidential mercy. and also with us, former federal judge nancy gertner. good to have both of you. judge gertner, i want to point out you were one of those 38 legal voices who sent a letter to president biden asking him specifically to commute all the sentences of those on federal death row. um, how do you feel about this decision to commute all but three? >> well, i think the decision to commute, even the numbers that he did was terribly important. there are all sorts of challenges to the death penalty that have been growing over the years. the concern that innocent people are being executed. the profound disparities between black and white people who wind up on on death row. uh, even the public support for the death penalty has waned. so i think that what president biden did was was exactly right. it's interesting. he was actually a prime sponsor of the 1994 crime bill, which led to additional

federal death penalties. so what's interesting is that the facts have moved him, and as they should, all of us. >> jeff, i know you made the point, too, that, um, no one has actually been released from prison because of these commutations and these pardons from president biden. those who were pardoned were, you know, had already been released, essentially. do you anticipate, because he can, that he will go farther in the final weeks of his presidency? >> you know, pardons are anomalous or an anomaly in our constitutional system because there are no checks and balances. it's just what the president wants. and you learn a lot about presidents through their through their pardons. with biden, there are very contradictory elements. he is a serious catholic. the catholic church is opposed to the death penalty. one tip off that he was going to issue these commutations is he's going to see the pope next month, and the pope has urged him, has urged him to do that. however, he is also part of a generation

of democrats that really wanted to be tough on crime. he was a sponsor of the crime bill under bill clinton, which expanded the death penalty, made it harder to challenge death penalty. um, convictions. and he is reluctant to let anyone out of prison. he he commuted 1500 sentences last. a couple weeks ago, they were all already out of prison. these 37 are never leaving prison. so he has not actually let anyone out of prison yet. and i don't know as going forward whether he's going to do that. he has hundreds of justice department approved pardon recommendations on his desk. i don't know if he'll sign them now, what he'll choose to do with those. >> um, he in his statement today, he wrote in good conscience, i cannot stand back and let a new administration resume executions that i halted. judge gertner, what are your concerns when it comes to president-elect trump's policy

toward executions? >> well, we know the last time that there were i think it was 13 executions, which his orders had hastened. and we know that among that group were people with intellectual disabilities. we know among that group, one woman in particular, who had been suffered extraordinary abuse. uh, i mean, these were executions that were done with, in my view, unseemly haste to to get them through. and given the kinds of problems with the death penalty, it should give all of us pause. we know that the death penalty is not a meaningful deterrent. uh, the concerns for victims, which are very important, are oftentimes exacerbated by death penalty prosecutions was last years and years and years, uh, in the in the boston bomber case, for example, one of the victims, the family of one of the victims, urged the court to, in fact, allow him to plead guilty

to life without parole. so it could be over. so i would be very troubled by another sort of rush to kill people, which is really what these executions are even luigi mangione that decision about whether they will seek the death penalty is certainly going to be before the trump justice department, not the biden justice department. >> under under biden, there have been, i think, only one request for a death penalty case. there will certainly be more under under trump. >> you talked about how conflicted president biden is in a lot of ways. do you think he is more or less conflicted after making the decision to pardon hunter biden? >> i think he is more attentive to the issue. when he pardoned hunter biden, he had only issued 25 pardons in three. you know, in three plus years as president. that was, frankly, an appallingly low number. there are 158,000 people in federal prison. it is hard for me to

believe they all should be there. the president has the power to let some of their hard luck stories, who, frankly, are a lot more hard luck stories than hunter biden's story. not let them out of prison. and there are those opportunities in front of him. i mean, the justice department, which is not exactly soft on these issues. they said these people should get out. we'll see whether biden actually lets him out. >> we will. jeff toobin, judge nancy gertner, appreciate it. thank you both. just ahead here, anderson's one on one interview with russian prisoner paul whelan, the former marine who was wrongfully detained in russia for more than five years on espionage charges, was freed over the summer in one of the biggest prisoner swaps since the cold war. what he says now about the harsh conditions he faced while in russian captivity, and also why he reached out to cnn from behind bars. to stop luther. >> never too much new year's

day at eight on cnn. >> transform your website into an immersive 3-d experience with infinite reality, you can tap the power of the spatial and social web. unlock valuable data, and take your brand to the next level. it's time for better shopping. bolder entertainment, and bigger sports. it's time to up your web game. infinite reality. >> the online store that was just breached, has my payment info during the holidays. >> think of all the places that can expose your info. lifelock monitors millions of data points for identity theft. if there's a problem, we fix it. guaranteed. >> pomerleau just cleaned my entire house for $19. seriously? $19. they showed up right on time and did my dishes, my laundry. they even cleaned my windows. you just

pick a date, pick a cleaner, and enjoy a spotless house for $19. i love using home glow, and i think you will too. i can feel the winds of change. >> that's monopoly. go! hehe. chris. >> kiki ready tycoons. >> it's go time. cash grab. >> kiki i won again! ah, daddy will be back soon. >> ah! oh, we're swimming in it now. rent's due. >> busted. >> nothing beats playing with friends except bankrupting friends. >> give it to me. >> thanks for calling. >> consumer cellular ranked number one in network coverage and customer satisfaction. >> hi. my friend linda has you guys. it gets way better coverage than i do. sounds like linda has you beat. >> not at bowling. >> you're breaking up a little. >> are you really ranked number

one in coverage? >> yep. and plans start at just $20. oh, we could afford lessons for linda. >> you're embarrassing yourself. >> at least my phone works. >> switched to the carrier. ranked number one in network coverage satisfaction. and right now, get your second month free call consumer cellular today. >> you don't stop being you just because you turn 65. >> but you do face more risk from flu and covid. last year alone, those viruses hospitalized nearly 1 million people 65 and older, 1 million vaccines lower your risk of getting really sick so you can keep doing you. >> i tried everything for my stubborn dandruff, and then i found nizoral. nizoral works differently to get to the root cause of dandruff. in fact, its active ingredient is ten times more effective at fighting fungus, the primary cause of dandruff. say goodbye to stubborn

dandruff with nizoral. >> dear doctor k, i used to think i was never meant to be beautiful. i was teased because of my teeth. i didn't like the person looking back at me in the mirror. i never thought i could afford dental implants. you and your team work within my budget and help me feel confident in the plan we made together. i love my new smile. thank you. >> congratulations! you have a beautiful soul, cynthia. >> finance the smile you want for as low as 148 a month per arch. schedule a free consultation. >> leo, he's there when you wake up. >> he's there when we leave. >> he's there whenever we come back home from school. >> he's just there. always mash it up, doofus. >> ever since we introduced him to the farmer's dog, his quality of life has been forever changed. >> he prefers real human grade food. >> it's like real food. it is. he's a happy dog now. he's a happy, happy dog. >> he's a happy, happy, happy

dog. >> this year is way better for flipping houses. >> bigger budgets. 1.3 what? they went up. bigger stakes. >> things are so unpredictable. is there a crocodile in there? >> the flipping el moussas season premiere thursday at nine on hgtv. >> tonight we're getting new insight into what marine veteran paul whelan faced during more than five years behind bars in russia. and that insight coming from the ex-prisoner himself. six years ago this week, whelan was in russia for a friend's wedding. that is when he was arrested by the fsb intelligence agency in russia and then imprisoned on charges of espionage charges. he has always vehemently denied. in may of 2020, the u.s. state department designated him as being wrongfully detained. the following month, he was convicted in a russian court and sentenced to 16 years in prison, then transferred from moscow to a remote prison camp. and that's where he led a personal campaign for his freedom, even making several phone calls and writing letters to a cnn reporter. this past august, the u.s. government

secured his release in one of the largest prison swaps since the cold war. and last month, whelan sat down with anderson and with cnn's jennifer hansler, the state department reporter whom he reached out to from russian captivity. here's that interview. >> well, first of all, it's it's an honor to meet you. i'm so sorry for what happened. and what is it like being back? >> well, thanks for having me, anderson. it's an honor for me, too. i've been a fan for years. um, being back, it's, uh. it's surreal. um, i'm in a world that used to be familiar, and it isn't. i'm getting used to just simple things. >> you were held in a prison in moscow initially. um, which is a notorious. it's a, like, maximum security prison. i think it's a very notorious prison. >> yeah. lefortovo. it's called the shooting gallery because that's where the russians used to. and probably still do shoot their own people. it's a it's a horrendously old rundown

facility. and, you know, you're in a small cell by yourself. um, basically 23 hours a day. >> how long were you in that facility? >> for a year and a half. >> i cannot imagine suddenly from being in your hotel room, visiting your friend for a wedding to being in this notorious prison. how do you mentally not just panic and freak out? >> i probably did panic and freaked out. um, very quickly i realized that what was happening was real. um, you know, there was some solace in the fact that i knew my my ambassadors would be coming to find out what was happening. i wasn't sure how long it would take to resolve. i knew i hadn't done anything, i hadn't violated the espionage law. i'm not a spy. i never have been. um, they'd either made a mistake or they were making it up. >> once you. after the trial, uh, you were sentenced to, like, 16 years, i think. yeah. you were sent to a labor camp in mordovia, and you're still

for the next 3 or 4 years. you are woken up every two hours at night. >> yeah, i was an escape risk. apparently, mordovia, there's nothing. there's nothing out there. it's woods. it's forests. >> so what, they would come in and wake you up and what? >> they'd shine a light in my eyes and then take a picture with the camera to prove that they had. they had checked me every night, every two hours, every two hours for years. for four years. >> can you sleep normally? now? >> now, um, i'm getting back to a normal sleep pattern. it's difficult. >> how was it that you started to to reach out to to other reporters, one of whom is jennifer hansler, who's here? um, what was the thinking on on reaching out? >> i wanted to make sure that my story was being told, and i wanted to make sure that people weren't forgetting. i didn't want it to be put on the back burner and have other, you know, affairs of state take over people's interest. um, i made some phone calls. i'd written a lot of letters, and i

wanted to speak to the media. so jennifer was was one of the early reporters that i spoke to quite clandestinely. >> how many calls and all jennifer did. >> i think it was about a dozen. but the first one was back in june 2021, and it came as a total surprise because i had known paul's sister elizabeth for quite a few months at that point, and she had asked at one point, can i give paul your address because he enjoys writing letters, and then maybe a month later he said, actually, can we give him your phone number? and i said, sure, of course, and sort of forgot about it. and then i was sitting at my table in june 2021, and a number just popped up that said russia no, no other caller i.d., and i sort of thought maybe it was spam, but i picked it up and then it's someone saying, this is paul whelan. and i was so taken aback, anderson, that i actually sent a clip of it to elizabeth to say, hey, is this actually your brother's voice? and she confirmed it was. >> did you hear the navalny had had been had had died? >> yeah. he he was murdered by the fsb in a secure prison.

that's what happened to him. there's no question in my mind. >> and when you heard that, what did you think about for yourself? i was worried. >> i was worried that maybe the fsb would poison me. or maybe, you know, break a bone or injure me to try to get the u.s. to speed up the negotiations for krasikov being returned. um, that's what russia wanted for me. >> you you followed. you were aware of negotiations going on. obviously, you were in contact with a number of people in the u.s. government. i know you talked to secretary of state anthony blinken and other high level officials, but there was tremendous disappointment as you believed you were going to be part of prisoner swaps, that then you would suddenly see, um, you know, trevor reed, i think was the first sort of high profile one. you learned that that he had been freed and you were certainly happy for him. but it's got to be incredibly difficult to see the

days passing by. i mean, more than 2000 of them. yeah. >> there were there were peaks and valleys, to be sure. i was glad that trevor went home when he did. i was glad that brittney went home when she did. but i was still there, and i was worried because the u.s. had given up their bargaining position when viktor bout went home. the u.s. had nothing the russians wanted. i was stuck there. >> the u.s. traded this guy, viktor bout, who was an arms dealer, a very high profile prisoner, and that was part of the deal for brittney griner. right. there was a phone call that you made to jennifer after the brittney griner release. this is a part of the call that that you made to to jennifer. i have to say, i am greatly disappointed that more has not been done to secure my release. >> especially as the four year anniversary of my arrest is coming up. i was arrested for a crime that never occurred. i'm happy that brittney is going home today and that trevor went home when he did. but i don't

understand why i'm still sitting here. >> was that the lowest moment for you? >> that was one of two. um, you know, the second was when my dog died. um, that was a realization that i wasn't going home to the home that i had left. but when i realized that the u.s. had given up their bargaining position by sending viktor bout back to russia, i was extremely concerned. and yeah, it was a low point. and, you know, luckily i had a friend to call and, you know, we discussed it. >> you know, jennifer, you would get letters from. yeah. >> so i actually brought the four that i actually received. i don't know if this is all the ones that you sent me, but they would be sent to to our bureau in d.c. and then months after the date they were postmarked. so i'm curious, paul, what you make of seeing these now, all these years later? >> this is your handwriting? oh, yeah. very neat. yeah. >> thanks. i sent, you know, i sent more than 2000 letters to my parents. wow. um, we've got a stack of them at home. i sent letters to the congress, uh, to

the house and the senate, the parliaments and canada and england and ireland. and they were all the same sort of thing. um, you know, talking about the restrictions, how the prison was doing things, how i was, um, yeah, it's it's interesting to see because there's some of my usual jocularity in these as well as, you know, some serious things. >> how much were you able to kind of remove yourself from your surroundings through writing letters, through reading, through anything else um, you know, staying in touch with the english language, staying in touch with authors that i was familiar with that was quite important. >> i had books, english books coming in from the consulates through my family. i had a lot of mail that came in when brittney was released. she had people write hundreds of letters to me. that was extremely important. i mean, at one point, jennifer and i were just discussing this. i was writing out ridiculous. do you remember your ridiculous? i

would write out, you know, the ten reasons why i wasn't a spy or the ten reasons why. you know, putin needed to needed to go all of these kind of funny things that that kind of, you know, sprang to mind. i've still got some of them written down. yeah. um, but that that was an important part of, like, staying sane. >> what was that flight like? what was you know, we saw the video of you at the tarmac in, you know, on american soil being greeted by president biden, by the vice president as well. what was that like? >> you know, that was that was incredible. um, and, you know, we see on the monitor the president putting something on my shirt and it's actually this that's the flag. yeah. this is the lapel pin. um, i didn't realize when we got on the plane it was a cia plane flying back that we were going to meet the president and vice president. you know, i had been in solitary confinement for the five days prior. i hadn't had a shower in two weeks. i had clothes on that i'd actually worn when i went to russia. >> so the clothes you're wearing there, those are the clothes you were. those are the

clothes. >> yeah. yeah. so they were dirty. i was dirty on the plane. i had to clean up as well as i could. >> and, you know, it also looked like they don't really fit you anymore. >> no, they don't, because i'd lost so much weight. yeah. um. it, you know, i, you know, you saw me walking off very kind of gingerly coming down those stairs, holding on because i, i didn't have the strength. i didn't have the balance. the malnutrition. it had taken a toll. um, it was interesting to see the president. it was interesting to see the vice president. but there was a lot of media, too, and i was i was glad to see them. those were the people that had supported me. >> well, paula, it's it's really an honor to talk to you. i'm so glad you're home. >> yeah. thanks very much, jennifer. >> thank you. and thanks for all your work. >> thanks. >> and just one final note. the kremlin has denied any role in alexei navalny's death. we'll be right back. >> 2024 was a wild ride. >> it was like the craziest

roller coaster ride i've ever been on in my life. >> that was an whooping. >> tom foreman and special guests look back. all the best. all the worst. 2024. thursday at 11 on cnn. >> emergency crystals pop and fizz when you throw them back. and who doesn't love a good throwback? now, with vitamin d for the dark days of winter, your parents have given you some amazing gifts. >> but what about the inherited ones? celebrate them with ancestry dna. the simple test that shows your deep family roots from your mom's side and your dad's side with some serious detail. trace the journeys and history that shaped who you are today, and see the traits they pass down. your connections to the past are all waiting. see just how gifted you are. for only $39, my moderate to severe crohn's symptoms kept me out of the

picture. >> now i have skyrizi. i've got places to go and i'm feeling free control. >> my crohn's means everything to me. oh, trouble is everything to me. >> and now i'm back in the picture. feels significant symptom relief at four weeks with skyrizi, including less abdominal pain and fewer bowel movements. skyrizi helped visibly improve damage to the intestinal lining, and with skyrizi, many were in remission. at 12 weeks at one year, and even at two years. >> don't use if allergic serious allergic reactions, increased infections, or lower ability to fight them may occur. before treatment, get checked for infections and tb. tell your doctor about any flu like symptoms or vaccines. liver problems leading to hospitalization may occur when treated for crohn's. >> now's the time to take control of your crohn's. control is everything to me. ask your doctor about skyrizi, the number one prescribed biologic in crohn's disease. from tried and true.

>> to try something new. >> so many ways to save life. >> ready? >> wallet. happy. >> that's 365 by whole foods market. >> natural has organic broccoli, blueberries and carrots. >> ours has polyethylene glycol, vitamin e from sunflowers, red 40 lake. >> which is another way of saying artificial coloring. natural whole food multivitamins available on amazon and natural.com. >> how do you sleep at night on a mattress from mattress firm? so i sleep all night at mattress firm. >> 72 hour

what if your mobile network wasn't just built to work out here... ...but was designed differently to also give you blazing fast wifi where you are most of the time? reliable 5g, plus wifi speeds up to a gig where you need it most. xfinity mobile. xfinity internet customers, ask how to get a free 5g phone and a second unlimited line free for a year. placed my order. bring your own team together with custom gear. get started today at customink.com new year's eve live with anderson and andy. >> live coverage starts at eight on cnn. >> closed captioning is brought to you by tablo. watch, pause, and record live tv subscription free. >> watch live tv for free with tablo. >> access over 90 free channels, plus record, pause and replay all with zero monthly fees or contracts.

order a tablo total system today. >> before you ring in the new year, do not miss the cnn special. all the best, all the worst 2024. it airs thursday night at 11 eastern. my good friend tom foreman, along with other cnn anchors and reporters, will recap all the big news of the year, including politics, of course, but also music and movies and even some of the headlines. you just may have forgotten. here's a preview. >> the world population has grown to about 8 billion people. the u.s. population this year tipped above 337 million, and the most popular baby names are returning champions noah and olivia. >> can you imagine what that second grade classroom is going to be like? olivia eight hands go up in the air. >> most common languages spoken by american homes after