>> before you ring in the new year, do not miss the cnn special. all the best, all the worst 2024. it airs thursday night at 11 eastern. my good friend tom foreman, along with other cnn anchors and reporters, will recap all the big news of the year, including politics, of course, but also music and movies and even some of the headlines. you just may have forgotten. here's a preview. >> the world population has grown to about 8 billion people. the u.s. population this year tipped above 337 million, and the most popular baby names are returning champions noah and olivia. >> can you imagine what that second grade classroom is going to be like? olivia eight hands go up in the air. >> most common languages spoken by american homes after

>> i honestly, i have no clue. >> tagalog, a language of the philippines. >> i never would have guessed that. ever. >> all the best. all the worst of 2024 airs thursday 11 p.m. eastern right here on cnn. thanks for joining. the news continues right here on cnn. >> outfront next, the sordid text messages the house ethics committee releases its long awaited report on matt gaetz. the evidence they reveal. and a member of the committee is our guest. plus, luigi mangione accused of assassinating a ceo back in court to enter a plea today, with his attorney blasting the police and new york city's mayor for using her client as, quote, political fodder and the breaking news. former president bill clinton in the hospital tonight. we're just getting new information about his health. let's go out front. good evening everyone. i'm kate bolduan in for erin burnett outfront tonight. sex, drugs and a minor. a bombshell report released by the house

ethics committee. reams of evidence released, including text messages that reveal the first for the first time, the full scope of former congressman matt gaetz's sex scandal. according to the report put out just this morning, gaetz, who was trump's nominee for attorney general before stepping aside, allegedly paid multiple women for sex, including a 17 year old while he was a sitting member of congress and also did illegal drugs while in office. well, tonight, a slew of text messages that suggest gaetz wasn't always so willing to pay up. there's a lot here. here's one exchange. a woman writing. so i'm not going to be taking care of this. i'm not going to be taking care of for. last week, gaetz allegedly responds, i gave you 250 today. i figured redacted would pay for your uber. last week you gave me a drive by. in another exchange between women who say they met with gaetz, a woman starts complaining in a message this quote, matt never paid me. how much did he pay

you? the other woman responds wtf? he gave me 400 and gaetz then girlfriend also messaging with some of the women who were typically paid for sex. according to this report. quote, the guy's representative gaetz and mr. greenberg, his associate, wanted me to share that they are a little limited in their cash flow. this weekend, matt was like, if it can be more of a customer appreciation week. dot dot dot. now again, this is all said to have taken place while matt gaetz was a sitting member of congress, the house ethics committee concluding it found substantial evidence that, quote, in 2017, representative gaetz engaged in sexual activity with a 17 year old girl. it goes on to say that during the period 2017 to 2019, representative gaetz used or possessed illegal drugs, including cocaine and ecstasy, on multiple occasions. we'll note that gaetz has never been charged, and he denies all the allegations, and the committee found that the 17 year old did

not tell gaetz she was a minor, nor did gaetz ask her age. with all of this coming out, matt gaetz tried today to block the report from being released, unsuccessfully filing a lawsuit this morning and acknowledging this evening that the point is moot since the report is now out tonight. gaetz is responding, though, posting online in part this. there is a reason they did this to me in a christmas eve eve report and not in a courtroom of any kind where i could present evidence and challenge witnesses. katelyn polantz is out front, live in washington all over. as this was released this morning. caitlin, there's a lot of detailed evidence in this report. what more are you learning, kate. >> not just detailed evidence. what the committee says is substantial evidence that backs up what they believe are violations of the ethics of congress, of the ethics of the conduct of somebody who would be a sitting representative. and it is a laundry list that the committee puts right at the top of their report, saying

that they believe that some of this conduct included engaging in prostitution, statutory rape, illicit drug use, impermissible gifts, and then obstruction of congress. the committee goes on not just to show their work, showing 11 pages of ledgers of payments that they were able to track down. also, text messages, as you were mentioning, but they highlight what women told them in testimony. women coming in to speak to the committee, including that woman who was 17 at the time she was having sex with gaetz, she testified. and they say that many of the women interviewed by the committee, they knew that there was a clear expectation, a general expectation for sex. one of the women who spoke to the committee said she was paid more than $5,000 by gaetz in two years while he was sitting in congress. so the committee is putting this all together and saying he may not have been charged with a federal crime. he may not have evidence. there is no evidence that we're

seeing of federal sex trafficking violations, but there surely is something to be seen here. some violations of ethics. for someone who was a sitting member of congress and still a prominent voice in the conservative movement behind donald trump, and as i was mentioning, caitlin gaetz tried to put up a fight this morning. >> there was like a flurry of activity of him trying to fight the release of this as it was being leaked out. and then what? >> well, the committee says that it's possible he implicated federal criminal laws of false statements and obstruction for congress. they believe that they were obstructing, that he was obstructing them. it might not be a criminal violation, they say, but over the course of this 19 month investigation that the committee was doing that culminated in the release of this report today, that he was deflecting, deterring, misleading them, essentially just not responding to the request, trying to push them off, saying they're too burdensome and barely giving them any information as they were seeking it. kate. >> caitlin, thanks so much for

the reporting, putting it all together for us. i really appreciate it. now out front with us now is democratic congressman glenn ivey of maryland. he is a member of the house ethics committee. congressman, thank you very much for your time tonight. the contents of this report are very serious. i'm hearing that from republicans and democrats alike today. what is the most thing in this report, in your opinion? >> well, i think you covered a lot of it. you know, certainly the allegations or the findings with respect to the sex with the 17 year old are very powerful. and, you know, the prostitution issues and the like. i mean, there's there's a lot there. so it's. kind of overwhelming. i think in some ways when you read it all and put it all together, and our staff did a great job of doing a very thorough investigation and bringing us the information so we could do that, put it in the report and allow the public to see it. >> now, gaetz has responded to all of this, saying he did nothing wrong. he denies the

allegations. he filed this lawsuit that i mentioned this morning, essentially trying to block its release, accusing the committee essentially of defaming him and engaging the way he put it was an unprecedented overreach that threatens fundamental constitutional rights. in releasing the report. how do you respond to him tonight? >> well, i think the point is that, you know, the report is out there now and the public can see it and review it and decide for themselves what they think. and, you know, your lead in report mentioned, you know, other possibilities as far as, you know, where the department of justice or local law enforcement taking a look at these things, too, it's available for them as well. so, you know, mr. gaetz has the right he's he's got a first amendment rights just like anybody else. he's got a very big platform as well. he's got the right to say his, you know, his position and give his points of view. and the public can take a listen to all of it and, you know, draw their own conclusions. >> i mean, i'm sure people know your background, but before

being in public office, i mean, you were a state's attorney. you have a long, long career in law. do you think that local law enforcement, do you think that people should look further into potentially. charging him? >> well, you're right, i do have a background as a federal prosecutor, state prosecutor and the like. and, you know, one thing that i always tried to do and do now is to leave it to the people who are in those positions to draw their own conclusions. and sometimes they have to take a look at the evidence and decide what they have to prove. as far as the elements for the statutes in their particular state, or with the department of justice for the federal offenses. but there's a lot there. and you know, how they how they decide to move forward with it is up to them. but again, i think it was important for the public to see it and also for our colleagues to see it so they understand, you know, what the committee was doing, why it took so long, and how to conform their conduct as they

go through this. one of the important parts about releasing reports is it gives guidance to our colleagues about what's over the line and what's not. and i think we tried to do that here real quick. >> i mean, as i said, he denies the allegations. he also attacked the credibility of the witnesses that spoke to the committee, just to put it out there. how confident are you, congressman, in the fidelity of this report, the conclusions, the evidence you gathered? >> i mean, i think the evidence is strong and, you know, the substantial evidence finding that we reached, i think is certainly very well supported by the evidence and the testimony of the the people that you mentioned, backed up by the text messages, backed up by the financial records. and we put it all together and put it out there. so, you know, that's my take. the bottom line, though, is, you know, what is the public decide? you know, i always thought that sunlight is the best disinfectant. this is important for us to put that out there and give the public a chance to to take a look at congress as a

whole. you know, the ethics committee is charged with making sure that we're doing the right thing and staying on the right track. but ultimately, we all know that the public has the final word on who comes back and who doesn't. and it's important for for them to know that there's stuff like this going on in washington. >> on that note, i mean, some members of the ethics panel did not want to put out this report. it's as gaetz is no longer a member of congress. it was only described as dissenting members in the final page of the report. but here's what it said in part. the decision to publish a report after his resignation breaks from the committee's long standing practice opens the committee to undue criticism and will be viewed by some as an attempt to weaponize the committee's process. did you struggle with that? >> not so much. i mean, actually, there have been four instances in recent history, you know, one per decade, actually, over the past 40 years, where the committee decided to release a report

even after a member had left his service in congress. so i think it's appropriate here, especially given the nature of the the findings that we we published here. and i think, as i said, it's important for the public to see it and draw their own conclusions. so i know there were certainly colleagues that dissented, and they cited one instance that they tried to distinguish, but really didn't say anything about the other three. and i would note, too, that the senate's done this as well in certain cases. so i think we're we're on pretty firm ground here. and i trust that, you know, our colleagues, we've been able to work together in a very bipartisan way on this committee dating back to, you know, the santos findings and that investigation. and there's a bunch of other ones that have taken place between now and then, and we've always managed to work well together in a very good and bipartisan way. and i trust we'll be able to do that moving forward. >> congressman glenn ivey, thank you for coming on. >> thanks for having me. >> outfront for us next, the

alleged ceo assassin, luigi mangione making a first court appearance on state charges in new york. the man seen smiling at times as his attorney slams the mayor and the police for how she says he's being treated. plus, donald trump wants to take back a canal. >> we will demand that the panama canal be returned to the united states of america in full. >> and tonight, a key ally says the president elect is serious. and breaking news. former president bill clinton in the hospital tonight. and we have new information on his health erin burnett out front is brought to you by the focus features film. >> nosferatu succumbed to the darkness. nosferatu. rated r only in theaters this wednesday. special engagements in dolby and imax. >> he is coming. >> he is coming to us.

>> nosferatu. >> rated r only in theaters this wednesday. special engagements in doge and imax. >> this holiday season. kevin. catherine. all aboard the freedom unlimited. >> kevin. kevin. >> kevin. kevin and kevin. i mean macaulay. take a very special trip to the mall where anything can get your little kid is. jasmine el-gamal. really? yeah. >> anything. is cash mark schamel. >> jim sciutto. >> tis the season to cash back with chase freedom unlimited. >> how do you cash back? chase, make more of what's yours. >> you make good choices. they've shaped your journey to leave all that your life built. rock solid for generations. with ambition like that, you need someone who elevates advice to a craft. at ubs, we match your vision with insight and expertise to shape a

unique outcome for you. advice is our craft. >> as the people you love get older, their risk of severe flu and covid goes up. last year alone, those viruses hospitalized nearly 1 million people 65 and older. that's nearly 1 million moms, dads, favorite uncles and grandmas. if someone you love is 65 or older, talk with them about vaccines because to you, they're not just another number. >> liberty mutual customized my car insurance, so i saved hundreds, but the money i saved thought i'd get a wax figure of myself oh, right in the temporal lobe. beat it. punks only pay for what you need. >> liberty, liberty, liberty, liberty. >> the tempur-pedic adapt mattress was designed to help make aches and pains a thing of the past. because only tempur material eases your pressure

points in a way no other mattress can. save up to $500 now on select adjustable mattress sets. >> when a tough cough finds you on the go, a sirup would be silly. hey, try robitussin sauer juice pack with the power of robitussin and every bite z's bakery is looking to add a pizza oven, arissa's hair salon wants to expand their space, and steve's t-shirt shop wants to bring on more help. with the comcast business 5-year price lock guarantee, they can think more about possibilities for their business and not the cost of their internet. it's five years of gig-speeds and advanced security. all from the company with 99.9% network reliability. get the 5-year price lock guarantee, now back for a limited time. powering five years of savings. powering possibilities™.

>> call one ( 800) 355-8999 or visit homeserve. com. can't fool myself. >> it was the most exciting time in the world. >> his life has truly joyful moments and some really difficult moments. >> you only come across an artist like luther vandross once in a lifetime. >> luther. never too much new year's day on cnn. >> closed captioning is brought to you by tableau. watch, pause and record live tv subscription free. >> watch live tv for free with tableau. access over 93 channels, plus record, pause and replay, all with zero monthly fees or contracts. order a tableau total system today. >> tonight ceo shooting suspect luigi mangione pleading not guilty to state terror and murder charges in new york.

appearing in court today wearing street clothes and in shackles. outside the court, he had supporters show up for him, waving protest signs that said people over profit. it comes days after mangione appeared in federal court. kara scannell was in the courtroom today. she's out front. >> luigi mangione accused of shooting and killing united health care ceo brian thompson. arriving to a new york city courtroom today escorted by police officers, his wrists and ankle shackled. >> not guilty. >> mangione entering a plea of not guilty to the 11 new york state counts he is facing, which include murder in the first degree and murder in the second degree as a crime of terrorism. >> i'm very concerned about my client's right to a fair trial like every other defendant, he is entitled to a presumption of innocence. but unfortunately, the way this has been handled so far, his rights are being violated. >> his attorney, karen friedman

agnifilo, telling judge gregory carro that mangione was being used like, quote, political fodder. >> he's a young man and he is being treated like a human ping pong ball between two warring jurisdictions. >> here saying last week's now infamous perp walk with mangione stepping off a helicopter surrounded by heavily armed law enforcement officers and new york city mayor eric adams. trailing behind was inappropriate. >> frankly, your honor, the mayor should know more than anyone about the presumption of innocence. >> noting adams own legal problems over federal charges, including bribery, to which he has pled not guilty. >> i submit that he was just trying to detract from those issues by making a spectacle of mr. mangione agnifilo also asking for expedited discovery, but prosecutors warning that may not be so easy. >> i have never seen a case with such volume of evidence saying there are thousands of hours of video tracking, mangione mangione is also facing four

federal charges, including murder through use of a firearm. as we understand that we have primary jurisdiction and we have been informed by the u.s. attorney that they intend on allowing us to try our case first. we will comply with our ethical obligations with respect to trying this defendant's guilt in this courtroom, in this courtroom alone. >> mangione has not entered a plea yet on the federal charges. prosecutors could decide to seek the death penalty in that case. members of the public filling four rows of the courtroom to watch the hearing. unfold. >> you want to say something? >> while outside, protesters rallied in support of mangione and against insurance companies like unitedhealthcare. we said enough to fight. >> he should enough. the fight. >> and kara is here with me and kara. you were in the courtroom today. you could see mangione up close as he entered this plea. tell us what stood out to you. >> i mean, if you look at the contrast, you know, he's covered by security. there were

security officers from the court surrounding him. at one point, when the lawyers went up to the bench to talk to the judge. just a real strong presence walking him into the courtroom, arm in arm. and then, by contrast, he's very calm. you see his lawyer there putting her hand on his shoulder, emphasizing he's a young man trying to draw that contrast, that he's not the shooter, the killer that he's been charged with being. and also interesting in court, there were four rows for the public and they were filled. they were waiting on line, just like the reporters, to get into the courtroom. the majority of them were women and young women, which is just interesting. you don't really know what to draw from that, although clearly there's this sensation about him. you see the people outside court protesting in favor of him in a sense, which you don't usually see when someone is facing such serious charges. also, even the fact that we saw these images and the video of him, that is something that hasn't happened in the new york state court system in at least a decade, going back to when dominique strauss-kahn, the former head

of the imf, was charged with sexual assault. this charge was ultimately dropped. but that was the last time that people i've talked to can remember there being cameras and broadcasts from the courtroom in new york. so a real rare glimpse into this, which is fascinating given the public fascination around him. and obviously, the high profile nature of this alleged assault. yeah. >> and will it continue? i think is going to will we will see. but know when it popped up this morning and we saw it, i was really surprised to see inside the courtroom for sure. and so great that you were able to be there. thank you so much. great reporting as always. outfront with us now, criminal defense attorney mark o'mara and casey jordan, criminologist, attorney and behavioral analyst. guys, it's good to see you. mark mangione enters a not guilty plea. not unexpected. what kind of work does his defense team now had ahead of have ahead of them. and what do you see as their options? >> well, a lot of options are coming up. first, of course we had that first track, which is the forensic or evidence focused track, which is can they prove he did it? it seems that what we have seen so far,

the strong case is there for the state because we have the forensic evidence. we have some dna evidence, we have fingerprint evidence, video evidence. and it looks as though they'veof course, the defense team the track that they really have to focus on is the mental health mitigation. if in fact he did it, which seems as though it's a strong case, then the question is why? because of potentially some mental health concerns. but an interesting third track that may be here that they're going to weave into it is can they carefully start blaming big industry not for the shooting itself, but for maybe their client's obsession with what happened, and maybe start looking and feeling into people's, you know, disdain for big industry, big insurance in this case. and that may buy them a little bit of that mental health mitigation dynamic to it. it's going to be very interesting to see how the defense team weaves all that together.

>> yeah. no kidding i mean, yes, absolutely. and hearing you describe it that way for sure, mark casey, we've got all this video as kara scannell was talking about of of mangione. we've got him in the hallway on his way into the courtroom. and when he's walking in, we're playing it now for viewers. he's in shackles. there's very little emotion shown on his face. i was watching it very closely. it was happening during my show this morning. and then he's in the courtroom cameras again, talking to his attorney. you see him smiling at at least one point, then on his way out of court, if you're continuing to look at his demeanor, reporters ask him if he had anything to say. he shakes his head no. what do you make of all of that? >> gosh, i see confidence to the point of being smug or even indignant. but at the very least, he is unperturbed now that confidence can stem from a lot of things. it could, you know, as mark just pointed out, i anticipate a mental health defense down the line. but is it that he is delusional and

doesn't really understand, you know, how much serious trouble he is in, or is he just confident because he is a child of wealth and privilege, and he's pretty sure that, you know, the attorneys that have been hired are going to do their best to get him out of this some way or the other. but even more interesting to me is the twinning is winning approach. i have to say that it was just kind of fascinating from from a visual standpoint, to see the matching outfits like his defense attorney in here, going to a mother son dance or something. >> it was it was something. it was one of those things you add into, you don't know what to make of it. from the outside looking in. mark, there has been this. i describe it as just scary lionizing of mangione since he was caught. i mean, you saw it outside the court today. we've seen it in the days weeks since he was caught. there's even an audience outburst during saturday night live this weekend. let me play this. >> luigi mangione dropped.

yeah, yeah, definitely. >> woo! >> you're wooing for justice, right? >> colin jost was just trying to set up a joke. and that's just the mention of his name. the. there's an audience outburst of applause and cheers for mangione. mark, what do you see is going on here we now are a celebrity focused society. >> and unfortunately, this case is going to be one where all of his fans are going to be very, very, um, vocal. and of course, if it gets to a trial, this should not this should be figured out ahead of time. but we know sometimes they do, particularly high profile cases. those same people are going to be in the jury pool, um, that they've had to select from. so it's going to be a very interesting dynamic. you know, going back real quickly. a year ago, we had that same thing a decade ago, the same thing with the zimmerman case, where there was a split of a lot of people in favor of him,

a lot of people opposed to him. and now we're seeing it that real celebrity, and it's going to play out in some strange ways over the next several months. >> strange is definitely one word for it. casey, what's your final thought on this? >> i think his attorney is already strategizing. she is taking her. leslie abramson playbook from the menendez brothers, making him look innocent. and she is going to be there for voir dire, hoping and praying to get a stealth juror that will find him innocent on principle, and not because it's the legal finding. i mean, that's how i think this is going to go a long road ahead. >> thank you both. it's very good to see you out front for us next. donald trump making it clear there is only one president elect at a time, or really just one. and it's not elon musk. our cracks now forming in their newfound friendship. and we have breaking news. former president bill clinton hospitalized, and we're just getting new information about his health this evening. >> welcome to times square. >> it's the biggest party of

the year. happy new year with the biggest guests. we have even more amazing guests lined up for you with performances by music's biggest stars and appearances by comedians, celebrities and more. yes, anything can happen on new year's eve oh! oh my gosh. >> wow. >> new year's eve live with anderson and andy. live coverage starts at eight on cnn and streaming live on max. >> it's time. yes, the time has come for a fresh approach to dog food. every day, more dog people are deciding it's time to quit the kibble and feed their dogs fresh food from the farmers dog made by vets and delivered right to your door. precisely portioned for your dog's needs. it's an idea whose time has come. the time has come. >> hi, susan, honey. yeah, i

respect that, but that cough looks pretty bad. try this. robitussin, honey. >> the real honey you love. plus the powerful cough relief you need. >> mind if i root through your trash? >> robitussin with real honey and elderberry. >> this is kavana. and this is how you can sell us your car. visit carvana, answer a few questions. we'll give you a real offer. then set a time for us to pick it up and pay you on the spot. sell your car the easy way with carvana. >> not again. the cold is coming. >> your cold is coming. >> thanks, revere. we really need to keep zicam in the house. >> only if you want to shorten your cold. when you feel a cold coming, shorten it with zicam. mm. >> kind of needs to be more squiggly. perfect. >> so now, do you have a driver's license? oh. what did you get us with the click of a

pen? >> you can get a new volkswagen at the sign, then drive event. lisa, 2024 tiguan for zero. down zero deposit, zero first month's payment and zero due at signing. limited inventory available. >> like a relentless weed. moderate to severe ulcerative colitis symptoms can keep coming back. start to break away from uc with tremfya with rapid relief at four weeks. tremfya blocks a key source of inflammation at one year. many people experienced remission and some saw 100% visible healing of their intestinal lining. serious allergic reactions and increased risk of infections may occur. before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tb. tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu like symptoms, or if you need a vaccine. healing is possible with tremfya.

checks, no mandatory fees, and that's why i chime. join me at chow.com and get paid. when you say.

party new tonight a trump ally in congress saying when donald trump says he wants to take back the panama canal, he takes him seriously. >> i always take him seriously. even though they may sound a little bit, you know, out there. i always take the president seriously, and it's and it's legitimate threat to panama. he wants a better deal. and i think we need to get a better deal from from panama. >> this after donald trump has repeatedly brought up control of the panama canal of late, including during a speech yesterday at a conservative conference to activists. >> it was given to panama and to the people of panama. but it has provisions. you got to treat us fairly and they haven't treated us fairly. if the principles, both moral and legal of this magnanimous gesture of giving are not followed, then we will demand that the panama canal be returned to the

united states of america in full, quickly and without question. i'm not going to stand for it. >> steve contorno is out front with us now, steve. why all of a sudden interest for donald trump in the panama canal? >> kate, that is a question that i've been trying to get to the bottom of for the past 48 hours. i asked the trump transition team and they declined to elaborate. but i did talk to several people in trump's inner circle. and look, they said that this came out of left field for them as well, and they were caught off guard. it's not something that he campaigned on over the past year and a half. it's also not something that they have understood, have saw him talk about recently behind the scenes as well, and they don't really know where the origins of this come from. the one person did tell me, look, trump dines regularly with friends and new acquaintances, and he's been entertaining business leaders and and world leaders, and he gets ideas in his head. and then he quickly decides whether or not to act

on that. so that could certainly be the case here. and another person told me he has been infatuated with taking steps to improve u.s. standing with trade, and this would certainly fall into that category. now, there are a lot of specifics that are lacking here. how would donald trump go about seizing the panama canal through pressure through the military? this is a piece of land and a port that has been operated and controlled by the country of panama since 1999, based on a treaty that the u.s. signed almost half a century ago. and unraveling that at this stage would be difficult, to say the least. >> or maybe not. stand by. to stand by. i think that's maybe where we. where we let it land yet again. it's good to see you, steve. let us know if you get any more answers to the question to the query on the panama canal. thank you so much. outfront with us now to talk more about this former democratic congressman max rose, david urban, and kristen soltis anderson. good to see you guys. david, smile. it's me. jeez, louise, look at that.

just give me a smile. max. >> i'm smiling. i'm smiling for max rose. >> congressman. max rose makes me smile. >> always, always. uh, do you agree? i know i saw you smiling off camera as this as steve was describing it, but do you see what congressman jimenez is saying? like, take him seriously? no. >> sure. >> look, you should take what donald trump says seriously. and to my friend david, obviously, congrats on your on your victory. and what i particularly enjoyed about donald trump's campaign was all of the panama canal commercials. and you saw how much that spiked in the exit polls. it was such a pivotal issue in the campaign, so obviously he'd be acting on it now. of course not. the guy never mentioned it once. so we all know how this business works. okay, someone wrote him a check or someone had a pivotal meeting with him and made a promise for a future check if he acted on this issue. so it's going to be panama canal this week or next. and then the weeks thereafter

it will be another pet project of the billionaire class. this speaks to what the actual truth of this second iteration of the trump presidency will be, not the populist, hard core issues that he actually ran on. and that's what's so sad about all of this. >> here's david respond, respond. but can i came up with a funny one for you? i came up with a funny one for you, though. >> come on up. >> he's he's so he's so jaded. listen to the jaded, bitter guy from staten island there. i used to like him until a couple minutes ago. listen, kate, it's important. here's why it's important. um, there there is a a major player in in the panama canal that's not panama. it's china. right. so the chinese control the two biggest ports at either end of the canal in 2017, the panamanians rejected the notion that they rejected taiwan as a country. they sided with china. they recognized china. they signed the belt and road initiative with the

chinese in 2018, expanding their sphere of influence in an area which 70% of all traffic is u.s. traffic going through from one port to another through the panama canal. the treaty, which was signed, leaves an out for the united states that says if the neutrality of the canal is threatened, that we could take it back. you know how we do it with the u.s. military. i don't know if anybody remembers operation just cause, but we sent the u.s. military down there to kick some and oust the president and put a new president in. we did it within about like 24 hours so we could do it. if i was the panamanians, i wouldn't cozy up to the chinese too much. if i was the chinese, i wouldn't get too cute. >> so, wait, is this do i do i sum this up to it's like option all of it's like choose your own adventure on on on the land grab of the day. and this is the negotiating position. do you take him seriously or it's not a land grab? >> this is u.s. national security. u.s. national security is at interest here. there's a neutrality provision that was put in that treaty for a reason. if that neutrality is

threatened by the chinese, their belt and road initiative continues to expand and threatens the u.s. in terms of whether it's allowing passage of u.s. military ships or hindering trade. that was that was obviously put in there for a reason. we can exercise that clause. if i were the panamanians, i would not get too cozy with the chinese christian i when i was thinking about this today, this feels a little bit like trump's play in saying he wanted to make canada the 51st state or, you know, he's been trolling canada about repeatedly that i image that was generated where he posted it with the caption, oh, canada. >> the trump calling prime minister justin trudeau governor. how does this fit into what people care about and why they voted for donald trump? or does this not? so i view a lot of this as related to his promise to try to either place tariffs around the world, or at least renegotiate the deals we have with lots of countries. >> the idea of donald trump

coming in, blowing up a deal, saying, i'm going to renegotiate it and get a better deal is pretty much at the core of what donald trump's brand has been since i have been alive on this planet. so in that sense, it's not totally surprising where i do think he might run into trouble is that the republican coalition now contains a lot of folks who have been republican for a long time. they love fighting communists. they love going and fighting around the world. and a lot of new people who say, i don't really want to send american troops down to panama, for instance. david. and so i do wonder, you know, how far can he push these negotiating tactics, knowing that when it comes to projecting american strength, there are pieces of the republican coalition these days that say, no, no, no, no, no, i'm not interested in doing that. i would like us to focus here at home first and don't necessarily see a connection between going off and doing stuff elsewhere and what happens here at home. >> yeah, great point kristen. david, now question for you over the weekend, donald trump weighed in on elon musk's growing influence in the trump world. the refrain from

democrats that they have definitely been pushing, especially in the last couple of weeks, especially since the shutdown fight, was this co-presidency or president musk? we've heard it over and over again. clearly they are trying to get under his skin. i want to play for everyone. what donald trump said about it yesterday. >> they're on a new kick. russia, russia, russia, ukraine, ukraine, ukraine, all the different hoaxes and the new one is president trump has ceded the presidency to elon musk. no, no, that's not happening. no, he's not going to be president. that i can tell you. and i'm safe. you know why he can't be? he wasn't born in this country. >> i actually really think the other that was really funny. um, david, do you think. yeah. how much do you think this gets under his skin? >> all right, listen, i don't think it gets under his skin at

all. i think he enjoys the banter. if it got under donald trump's skin, he wouldn't talk about it. okay, i disagree. this is how he projects. uh, no. listen, kate, there is no doubt that donald trump is the president. elon musk, he can huff and puff all he wants. he's he's listen, people have known you can go look it up in the on the google machine. you can see elon musk wanted certain people for cabinet positions. they've lost out. right. so he's not getting his way on everything. elon musk is an influential in the sphere of donald trump. but there are lots of other people as well. >> kristen, what do you see? do voters have issues with musk having growing influence? >> elon musk's job approval rating overall, or i should say favorability is pretty good. it's not too bad. it's about where donald trump's is. people know him first and foremost as being someone who's good when it comes to electric cars and putting rockets into space. i think if he can deliver for the american people through this doge department of government efficiency, if it actually can produce something,

i don't think people will mind it that much. and donald trump is also had people in his orbit in the past, like jared kushner, with whom he has shared important responsibilities making calls to foreign leaders, et cetera.. so there's a way elon musk could handle this that might not put him on trump's bad side at the end of the day, left turn. >> but i really want to ask you about it. joe manchin, former democrat now independent, heading out, talks to manu raju. and he says of the democratic brand it is toxic. what do you think? >> he's wrong. so if you were right, we wouldn't have seen democratic senatorial candidates win in wisconsin, michigan, nevada and arizona, despite donald trump winning those states with the democratic party. has to stop doing, though. is elevating really bad candidates with even worse staffs and campaign consultants who produce this weird gobbledygook that no one understands. and also, they're constantly tilting towards far left advocacy groups that don't allow them to tackle really important issues that are hurting them in negative polls. when we do that, we win.

we just show that, and that's why we're going to win in elections to come stand by, to stand by friends. >> no way, no way. by the way, max. >> max! listen, max. rose is a normal democrat. he's a normal guy. he's a good guy from staten island. i'm to do that. >> i'm going to do that thing where i go like this with my papers to make to shut this guy, have to chatgpt greenland next week. >> when donald trump says he wants to acquire his telling you the answer for greenland. >> that was last, last democratic greenland democrat. this guy couldn't even find panama canal on a map. two days ago, david irving can't. david irving has. unbelievable. >> okay, okay, gentlemen. zip it. kristin, i agree with you. thank you both very, very much. coming up for us, former president bill clinton, now in the hospital, we have new details on how he is doing this evening. plus, i'm going to talk to the father of an american still being held hostage by hamas. why? they say the situation surrounding their son's captivity suddenly feels different. >> this holiday season find the

perfect gift at cnn, underscored from the latest fashion to expert approved tech to the best beauty finds. discover it all at underscore. com. >> no more gross cough sirup. >> i want you to feel better. i want extra tv time or i'll walk. how about this? introducing the only kids soft shoe for medicated cough relief. new mucinex children's mighty chews are mighty clever this way. >> i hope you brought coffee. >> the december to remember sales event. get offers on select models. if you have heart failure or chronic kidney disease, vasica can help you keep living life because there are places you'd like to be. serious. side effects include increased ketones in blood or you're in and bacterial infection between the and

genitals, both which may be fatal. severe allergic reactions, dehydration, urinary tract or genital yeast infections, and low blood sugar. stop taking and tell your doctor right away if you have nausea, vomiting, stomach pain, tiredness, rash, swelling, trouble breathing or swallowing. tell your doctor about lightheadedness, weakness, fever, pain, tenderness, redness or swelling between the and genitals. ask your doctor about vasica today. >> weight noom has gop one meds now. >> noom, the psychology based weight loss company. >> yes, noom combines medication and behavior change so you can lose the weight and keep it off. >> and it starts at just $149. >> noom the smart way to lose weight. every parent knows when it's time to go into protect mode. adding lysol disinfectant spray to your cleaning routine is three times more effective at stopping the spread of germs. daughter, i know that when i

need you, you'll be there, but it's okay to accept a little help so you can be my daughter, not my caretaker. >> just you home instead for a better. what's next? >> my moderate to severe crohn's symptoms kept me out of the picture with skyrizi. feels symptom relief. at four weeks, many people were in remission. at 12 weeks, at one year, and even at two years. >> don't use if allergic serious allergic reactions, increased infections, or lower ability to fight them may occur before treatment. get checked for infections and tb. tell your doctor about any flulike symptoms or vaccines. liver problems leading to hospitalization may occur when treated for crohn's. control is everything. >> ask your gastroenterologist about skyrizi. >> what took you so long? >> i'm sorry. there was a long line at the thai place. >> you get the sauce i like.

>> of course. you're the man i wish. >> the future isn't scary. not investing in it is nasdaq 100 innovators one etf. before investing, carefully read and consider fund investment objectives, risks, charges, expenses and more in prospectus at invesco. >> com i wish my tv provider let me choose what i pay for. >> sling let you do that. hey, where are you going? >> i wish my tv provider let me choose what i pay for and let me pause my subscription when i want. >> sling lets you do that to sling. >> i wish my tv provider let me choose what i pay for and let me pause my subscription when i want and have hundreds of free channels let you do that too. >> mr. fish. >> choose and customize your channel lineup or watch for free. sling lets you do that. >> how do you sleep at night on a mattress from mattress firm? >> they have the nicest beds and i wanted to upgrade. i sleep all night long, get matched at mattress firm, sleep at night, new year's eve, live with anderson

and andy. >> live coverage starts at eight on cnn. >> breaking news former president bill clinton hospitalized tonight in washington. a spokesman telling cnn he is undergoing testing and observation after developing a fever. kayla tausche is out front. kayla, what are you learning? >> well, kate, we're learning that the president was taken from his home in the washington area to medstar georgetown university hospital earlier this evening out of what an aide describes as an abundance of caution after he developed a fever. the aide describes clinton as awake and alert and receiving good medical care, but says that he will remain there at least overnight, though it is the family's hope that he can return home by christmas. now, president clinton is 78 years old. he's had several health issues since leaving office, including just a few years ago, a urological infection that led to a blood infection known as sepsis, which sepsis, which can be fatal. of course, we don't know the exact nature of what caused the fever that he spiked that led to his hospital visit. but

we will, of course, bring you back any additional news as we are getting it. kate? >> yeah, we are wishing him well. of course. kayla. another major story from there tonight. president biden commuting the death sentences of almost all inmates on federal death row. take us inside the white house. calculation here. >> there are two real reasons behind biden's decision to commute the sentence. of these 37 individuals, all the inmates on federal death row, except for three. those three responsible for mass murder and terrorism, according to president biden, they are dzhokhar tsarnaev, who is behind the boston marathon bombing. dylann roof, of course, the shooter at the historically black church in charleston in 2015, as well as robert bowers, who is the tree of life synagogue shooter. but for the 37 individuals who will now be serving life sentences instead of sitting on death row. the consideration was really twofold. first, president biden had suspended federal executions when he came into office. there was a worry that with president-elect trump coming back into office, that

that could be reversed. and some advocacy groups had warned about executions en masse. when that happened. and second, this is really biden delivering on a campaign pledge. while he was a staunch supporter of the death penalty earlier in his political career, when he ran for president in 2020, he said that he was going to abolish it, in his words, because we cannot ensure we get death penalty cases right every single time. >> kate. kayla, thanks for the reporting as always. coming up next for us, the father of an israeli hostage joins us here. why? he's more optimistic now than ever before. >> they say things take time and effort, but it's worth the wait. >> i can tell some stories. i'm so excited. >> twitter brought the world together and the world was not ready to see itself. >> you read the comments? yeah. i might recommend that you don't. yeah, that's how i get by. >> we never backed away. >> he never stepped down. oh, that's how i get by. >> i feel at home

here. >> lord. >> that's how i get by. >> now's the time to go back in time. >> and shine a light on the family journey that led to you. detailed dna results, inspiring family history, memberships. now's the time to save at ancestry. >> go, friends, gather. kiki. chris. jason. >> friends. let's go, let's go! friends. >> hold on to your dice. >> nice frosting. fran. >> thank you. how are we doing, kiki? >> tastes like money to me. i can't go back to jail. >> wait. did you rob my bank? are we winning? ha! oh, money, power. friendship. let's go now i lay me down to sleep. >> i pray the lord my soul to keep. if i should die before i wake i pray the lord my soul to

take. >> nosferatu. rated r only in theaters this wednesday. special engagements in dolby and imax. >> this holiday season. kevin. catherine. all aboard! >> the freedom unlimited. kevin. kevin. kevin. >> kevin and kevin. i mean macaulay. take a very special trip to the mall where anything can get your little kid. is cash. basketball? really? >> yeah. anything is cash. >> basketball. i'm sorry. >> tis the season to cash back. >> with chase freedom unlimited. how do you cash back? chase, make more of what's yours. >> every parent knows when it's time to go into. protect mode. kill 99.9% of bacteria when you add lysol laundry sanitizer to your laundry routine. >> mark schamel. >> she. going to. it's.

time for. >> paint it up, powder it up and you ought to be glad you good girl's go bad. >> you were made to chase your passions. >> we were made to put them in a package. >> from dress the bird. >> to deck the halls. so many ways to save life. ready? wallet. happy. that's 365 by whole foods market. >> no more gross cough sirup. we all want you to feel better. >> i want extra tv time or i'll walk. >> how about this? introducing the only kids soft shoe for th

less than $34. go to deal dash dot com and see how much you can save kelli stump luther. >> never too much new year's day at eight on cnn. >> and tonight, families of several israeli hostages have

received signs of life from their loved ones held captive by hamas for 443 days. now, this is according to the hostages and missing families forum. it also comes as israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu says there's, quote, certain progress being made in the ongoing hostage negotiations, while adding he still doesn't know how long it will take to get the hostages home once and for all. out front with me now, jonathan declan, father of israeli-american hostage sagi. declan sagi is a husband and father to three young daughters. we cannot forget about this family, including a baby girl born after sagi was taken by hamas. jonathan, thank you for being here once again. i know that you were not one of the families who received this sign of life that we have heard of about sagi, but does this situation does this time, if you will, does it feel different this time?

>> well, it's a good question. okay. um, yeah. unfortunately, no, we were not one of the families who were fortunate enough to get some sign of life. uh, for us this time. i mean, the proof is in the pudding, of course, and getting everybody home. but clearly, over the course of the last three weeks since president-elect trump came out with a very strong statement with a deadline of january 20th, his inauguration, clearly, all of the sides and the intermediaries egypt, qatar, hamas and israel have put into motion a negotiation process that had been stalled for months until that statement. and there seems to be an urgency on all sides that's been missing for a very long time to get this done. it remains to be seen whether or not the intermediaries, the people of gaza and other forces can get hamas leadership to. yes. and that is that is

the key. and the only way that this can move forward, that is the key, of course. >> but interesting that there does seem to be something of a shift, even if it's just for now. i mean, because as you talked about, the president elect, he did. his warning was definitely a change from what we have heard before, which is saying that all hell would break loose. all hell, there would be all hell to pay if hamas doesn't release the hostages before his inauguration. you've spoken with some members of donald trump's team amid this transition. what have those conversations been like? >> well, they've been open and honest and embracing really, in a way, a continuation of the many dozens of conversations that we've had. the u.s. citizens with biden, biden administration officials and, you know, we're only very, you know, at the beginning, of course, with getting to know the trump administration officials, you know, they still are, you know, not not in

office. but that being said, we made a request to both sides, the outgoing and the incoming administration several weeks ago that, you know, begging them in a in a really to put aside whatever differences they have. and at least on this issue, getting the hostages on all the hostages, of course, the seven americans among them to work together. and it's really we are thankful, truly, not just the hostage families, but but almost all israelis that, in fact, that trump and the biden administration officials that are connected to the hostage negotiations have been an absolute lockstep for weeks now. and the results seem to be suggesting that that we are close to getting this done. >> the president's the president elect's incoming national security adviser also just issued a new threat, another threat to hamas, kind of echoing how president the president elect has spoken. i want to play for you what he said

there has never been enough consequences. >> and that's what we need to be talking about with these people. >> you take an american, you illegally detain them if you're a nation state or if you're a terrorist, you hold them hostage. there is going to be all hell to pay. there are going to be nothing but consequences for you financially, and maybe even a bullet in your forehead. if you take an american period. >> and that is the incoming national security adviser coming in from the white house. i mean, do you think this more aggressive approach is making a difference well, i we all hope and pray those of us who are concerned for the israeli hostages and no less those who are concerned for for the people of gaza, that that it will have the desired effect, that it will push hamas and hamas supporters to. >> yes, in order to end this madness. um, you know, it's a change in tone, the results, whether it's the biden

administration or the incoming trump administration, everyone wants the same results, which is to get all the hostages home. and so if this tone, with its intent, clearly, i mean, we heard the same words from from mike wallace about a week and a half ago. we met with him in dc, and those were the same words. so there's clearly an intent here to make a point. and perhaps most importantly, there's also a deadline of january 20th. so in that sense, it has been a game changer. what president trump has done. the results are the results. and we we await because we know the fate of our loved ones. it's it's a daily challenge and we need them home. and they, you know, just speaking for ourselves. i need my son to be reunited with his three little girls and his beautiful wife. >> jonathan coulton, thank you so much. >> thank you for having me. >> thanks for joining us. the source