tv Smerconish CNN February 22, 2025 1:00pm-2:00pm PST
1:00 pm
xfinity internet customers, cut your mobile bill in half vs. t-mobile, verizon, and at&t for your first year. plus, ask how to get the new samsung galaxy s25+ on us. >> through. our thoughts and. >> prayers are. >> with. >> those whose. >> lives were tragically taken. >> the dots all. >> start to connect together.
1:01 pm
>> somebody did this purposely to these people. >> lockerbie. the bombing of pan am flight 103 tomorrow at nine on cnn. >> don't spend that doge dividend quite yet. michael smerconish in philadelphia, doge. they say they're about to show us the money. the department of government efficiency, led by elon musk, is claiming to have saved taxpayers approximately $55 billion through various cost cutting measures. they're breaking down how they claim they're doing it on the department's website. for example, just yesterday doge published its latest cost cutting measure. they say that it resulted in a value of up to $235 million in savings. it's also pointing out wasteful spending with posts like this showing how taxpayers spent over $20 million on a boarded up building over the course of 20 years. there's also a wall of receipts listing savings on the website detailing canceled contracts and terminated leases as part of the department's. they say transparency initiative. and now there's a new potential layer to these
1:02 pm
doge savings that's gaining steam across social media to give us some of that money back. it's called the doge dividend, and it was explained in a four page plan that was introduced this week on x, breaking down how every taxpayer would get a $5,000 tax refund check, funded exclusively with a portion of the total savings delivered by doge. so long as musk's goal of $2 trillion in federal savings is met, the tweet was from an investor in ceo james fishback, who's been a guest at mar a lago and has ties to both trump and former doge official vivek ramaswamy. well, the idea grabbed elon musk's attention, who replied he'd check with the president. it appears that he did, because one day later, president trump expressed interest in this proposal. >> there's even under consideration a new concept where we give 20% of the doge savings to american citizens, and 20% goes to paying down
1:03 pm
debt, because the numbers are incredible. >> so with attention comes scrutiny. with doge, the accuracy of its reported savings being called into question. for instance, an initial claim of saving 8 billion by canceling a single immigration and customs enforcement ice contract was later revised to 8 million after discovering a clerical error. and that's not all critics are calling musk out for the haphazard way that he's approaching cost cutting. there's the firings, then rehiring across agencies, questions about transparency, conflicts of interest, the true dollar amount of these savings being questioned, and the long term impact of the overhaul. well, who better to answer some of these questions than james fishback, the ceo of azoria, the originator of the doge dividend. james, thank you for being here. how did this all come to pass? >> well, good. >> morning michael. >> to tell you the truth. >> it came to me in. >> a dream. i woke up. >> i called our head of. >> research at azoria. we met at
1:04 pm
capitol grill. we fleshed this thing out in two hours. and i'm honored that the president has endorsed it. this is a real plan to send the savings the doge generates over the next couple of years, right back into the pockets of hard working americans all across this country. they deserve it. it was their money in the first place, and they need a break. >> okay, i'm all for ridding the government of waste, fraud and abuse. but at some level, isn't it all illusory? in other words, if there is a quote, unquote savings made by elon musk and doge, we're still $36 trillion in debt. so there's there's no pie to cut up. there's no slice of the pizza that i can hand back to you unless we continue to borrow those funds. >> well, our plan is really simple. over the next couple of years, doge will save a set amount of money. we're going to take 20% of that and put it right back in the hands of taxpayers. the other 80. as president trump has pointed out, will go back to paying down the debt and narrowing the deficit. here's the truth, michael. for
1:05 pm
every $5 that doge saves, as we believe calculated by the congressional budget office, when this whole project is said and done next summer. for every $5, $1 goes back to the pockets of american taxpayers. here's why. they sent their money to d.c. to be spent in america. not to be abused, not to be disrespected, and not to be defrauded. that $20 million to iraqi sesame street, that money sent for a transgender opera in colombia all at the same time, michael, that we have roads and bridges crumbling. we're losing 900 americans every day to deaths of despair, alcoholism and suicide. eight out of ten black american fourth graders are not even reading at grade level. this is pathetic. the americans sent their money to be spent in america. they were defrauded. they were lied to. they now deserve restitution. and the second point that president trump just one second, michael. the second point that president trump brought up on air force one is that these doge dividends will incentivize americans to report waste, fraud
1:06 pm
and abuse in their own community. why? why? because the more that doge saves, the bigger their doge dividend check will be. remember in economics. show me the incentive and i'll show you the outcome. we're giving every american. >> i'm going to get to the economics. come on. i gave you a chance for a great a great sound bite you got. and those soft power exercises make for great sound bites. but when you drill down, for example, on sesame street in iraq, they often make sense. joseph nye from harvard, who gets credited with the coinage of the word soft power, you know, you'd rather spend on that than bullets. but wait, you want to talk? there was a terrorist. >> attack in iraq last month that killed 40 people. it's clearly not working. soft power and sesame street are not working. if there are terrorists, we need to kill the terrorists. we don't need to fund big bird and elmo. >> maybe the terror. maybe the terrorist would have been better off watching big bird than learning in a madrassa. let me make my point. put on the screen from the peterson foundation.
1:07 pm
this is where the rubber meets the road. we are $36 trillion in debt. i don't know if you can see that, but that's 106,121 for every single person in america. so if elon musk is successful in saving us money from waste, fraud and abuse. and by the way, james, i hope that he is. i don't like the approach, but i like the fact that something is being done. there is no money in the till. we owe 36 trillion. we owe $160,000 each. so whatever the savings ought to be, it's not like president trump is doing us a favor by giving us 20%. everything ought to go to the debt because the peterson people say by 20, 50, 50% of all revenue is going to go to satisfying interest on the debt. we should be paying the debt. your response? >> my response is this we should
1:08 pm
be paying the debt, which is why the doge dividend incentivizes every american to call out waste, fraud and abuse to lower the budget, to narrow the deficit, and to bring down the debt. where was this emergency? over the debt when we sent $350 billion to ukraine to be wasted? where was this emergency, michael, on cnn when you guys were advocating $7,000 to migrants in chicago, $7,000 a month per migrant, and now we want to spend $5,000 one time from president trump to hard working americans. the migrants didn't deserve $7,000 a month. hard working americans deserve a $5,000 check with president trump's name on it. so enough with the double standard. ukraine did not deserve $350 billion. >> listen to me, listen to me. this is made off like this is a ponzi scheme. >> no. ukraine was a ponzi scheme. the migrant funding was a ponzi scheme. hard working americans deserve a break. it was their money, michael. it was their money. >> james. james, give me a chance to speak theoretically. it's my program. we don't have
1:09 pm
the money, is what i'm trying to tell you. it's a ponzi. >> we didn't have the money for ukraine, right? we didn't have the money for ukraine. 350 billion. >> i never do this. i don't i don't want to be that guy. do i have to silence your microphone so that i can respond to what you said? because there's so much fallacy in what you just offered. please give a very simple. i have a very simple premise here. we're $36 trillion in debt. it's a fraud. as much as i want to see us cut waste, fraud and abuse, it is an absolute fraud to say to the american people because of what musk is doing, we have five grand to give each of you. the only way we have five grand is if we're borrowing it, because we're that far in debt. i'm trying to meet you halfway, which is simply to say, what a good thing that finally we're going to look at waste, fraud and abuse. albeit it shouldn't be in this haphazard fashion, but let's at least be honest with the american people that whatever we quote unquote save, we already owe. now i'm going to
1:10 pm
give you 30s to respond, and then i'm going to say, see you later. go ahead. >> michael, let me say this. we're fellow americans. we care about this issue. and i'm grateful for the opportunity to come on this program. but i got to speak truth here. at the end of the day, we have got to send the money back. that is saved just 20% of it. the other 80% going goes down to paying the national debt and narrowing the deficit. to your point, yes, there has been a fraud, a fraud against the american people. the green new scam, ukraine, the migrant crisis. their taxpayer dollars were sent abroad, were not sent at home, were not spent in america, not on health care, not on education. that ends with president trump's leadership. today, he is delivering on his promise of major government reform. michael, the doge dividend plan is bold and americans support it. >> all right, i'm calling i'm calling time on all of that. i appreciate your being here. i think we've each, i hope, made our respective points. thank you. what are you thinking? hit me up on social media. i will read some responses throughout
1:11 pm
the course of the program. from the world of x twitter. i would prefer 100% be applied. oh imagine this. imagine that i would prefer 100% be applied to the debt and deficit. in addition to downsizing the government, eliminating redundancy, failed programs, waste and fraud. absolutely. that is that is the answer. you know, look, everything i know about the markets and finance, i learned from watching trading places, duke and duke, billy ray valentine, capricorn. so maybe i'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer on this, but it seems to me that if i'm bankrupt and you come into my home and you now shed some of the expenses that have led to my bankruptcy, it's not as if i suddenly have a sum of money in my hand. because guess what? i still owe a lot of people. and that's the situation that we find ourselves in. the peterson foundation tracks this where 36 trillion in debt, it's more than 100 grand for each one of us. so you don't give to someone in that
1:12 pm
kind of debt, you know, a $5,000 stipend. that's a political stunt. i'm all for ridding the government of waste, fraud and abuse. this is not the way to do it. is president trump really considering. but i enjoyed having him here. i mean, he's the guy. he wrote the memo. so it's it's it's ideal. and by the way, take take that off the screen for a second. i just i'm like laughing out loud when he wants to make it about cnn and me because there, there couldn't be a more contrarian in the tent than this show. just saying. is president trump really considering the idea of a third term? he raised the topic during a black history month event on thursday. >> did i run again? you tell me. this. there's your controversy right there. there's your country. >> okay, so what's going on here? is he just playing with the crowd? i want to know what you think. go to smerconish.com
1:13 pm
and answer today's poll question. why does president trump tease a third term? is he just needling his opponents, or does he really intend to try to challenge or change the constitution up ahead? trump is using his power to push for a mineral deal with ukraine. will he pull it off? or will his public feud with the ukrainian president get in the way? a former member of zelenskyy's cabinet joins us live from kyiv with the very latest insight. please make sure you're when you're voting, it's .com that you're signing up for the newsletter, which drew the work of rob rogers this week. >> welcome back. >> have i got. >> news for you. new tonight on cnn. >> buying a car is kind of a big deal. you need to see all the options. see, she knows cargurus gives you the most new and used cars right in your hand. so you know your big deal is the best deal. cargurus the number one
1:14 pm
most visited car shopping site. >> waheed butt. >> unnecessary action hero. unnecessary. >> was that necessary? >> no. >> neither is missing your daughter's competition. >> to do payroll. >> with pay. employees do their own payroll. >> so you don't have to miss your daughter's big day. time to shine. >> get paycom and make the unnecessary. >> unnecessary. >> i've always been an active person. biking, running. but yoga, it's really. >> special to me. >> it's definitely a big part of who i. >> am, and. >> i love the way it makes. >> me feel. >> but there was. >> a time not. >> long ago when i felt i had to accept the idea of hanging up this old yoga mat. you see, i have symptomatic obstructive hcm which left me so short of breath i just couldn't get out here. making me feel like a bystander in my own life. so i talked to my cardiologist and he told me
1:15 pm
about cam. he said cam works by targeting what's causing my obstructive hcm. so he prescribed it. and i'm so thankful he did. >> cam is used. >> to. >> treat adults with. >> symptomatic obstructive. hcm may improve your. >> symptoms and. >> your ability. >> to. >> be active. kim ziz may cause serious side effects including heart failure that can lead to death, a risk that's increased if you develop a serious infection or irregular heartbeat, or when taking certain other medicines. so do not stop, start or change medicines or the dose without telling your health care provider. you must have echocardiograms before enduring treatment. seek help if you experience new or worsening symptoms of heart failure. because of this risk, cam is only available through a restricted program. before taking cam, tell your doctor about all of your medical conditions, including current or planned pregnancy. >> with cam reducing my symptoms, i've gone from sitting on the sidelines to being back in the game. my name is stephanie and this is my cam moment. call your cardiologist today and see if a cam moment may be in your future to.
1:16 pm
>> okay, noah's going to make a fire. >> our job. >> is to. let him do it by himself. >> you're going to want a wider base here. >> you just started. >> you progressive. >> can't protect you from becoming your. >> parents. >> can't protect your home and auto when you bundle with us. >> i feel like new sunglasses. like a brand new pair of jeans. i feel a lot. brand new. oh. >> learn more about celebrity cruises. >> latest offers. >> what took you so long? i'm
1:17 pm
sorry. there was a long line at the thai place. >> you get the sauce i like. >> of course. you're the man. >> i wish the future isn't scary. not investing in it is. nasdaq 100 innovators. one etf. before investing, carefully read and consider fund investment objectives, risks, charges, expenses and more in prospectus@invesco.com. >> twitter. that's a great name. >> we invented a. >> whole new thing. >> no one. >> could possibly have understood where it was going. >> twitter breaking the bird march 9th on. cnn. >> closed captioning brought to you. >> by. dot com. >> if you or a loved one. have mesothelioma, we'll. >> send you a free. >> book to answer questions you may have. call now. >> and we'll. >> come to you. >> 821 4000. >> the draft deal between the united states and ukraine over rare earth minerals is at a standstill. the current proposal by the u.s. is not the one president zelenskyy would accept, according to a source
1:18 pm
familiar with the discussions. the deal would give the u.s. access to ukraine's natural resources as reimbursement for the billions of dollars the u.s. already spent in ukraine's war against russia, with potential for future aid. president zelenskyy previously rejected the original offer after it did not guarantee aid, which sparked a war of words between president trump and the ukrainian president this week. zelenskyy accused trump of repeating russian disinformation and is arguing any deal leading to an end to the war would require his involvement. president trump took to truth social called zelenskyy a dictator in response to the social media blast. the new york post used its cover on friday to send a message to the president. it read, actually, i have it right here. this is a dictator. joining me now from kyiv is timothy milovanov. he is president of the kyiv school of economics and previously served in president zelenskyy's cabinet as the minister of economic development of ukraine. timothy, thank you for being here. i know you're no longer in the
1:19 pm
cabinet, but you've maintained that relationship. you see the president on a fairly regular basis. is that accurate? >> well, maybe not not. >> the president, but i talk to people. yes, that's right. >> so what's going on here? why is president trump suddenly targeting zelenskyy and not putin calling him a dictator and saying it's zelenskyy who started the war? >> i've written of this about this publicly just today. i think there are three theories that have been circulated among ukrainians. one is it's just hard bargaining, like really ugly bargaining, trying to get the best deal possible out of ukraine. and frankly, ukraine will benefit from even the worst deal, in my view. uh, so that's bargaining. and there are a couple of other ideas. and some of them there's something behind the doors. maybe there's a semi russian conditions or something else is going on. >> okay. when you say bargaining, do you mean bargaining relative to the minerals or bargaining relative
1:20 pm
to and or or the end of the war? >> relative to the minerals, relative to the conditions of the deal? >> okay. why is it necessary by that theory? the negotiation theory. why is it necessary for trump to to denigrate, to to dis, to emasculate your president? >> well, i think there's also something going on on the personal level or maybe on communication level. um, over the last two days, the administration, different officials from the of the united states, from the president himself to the secretary of state to everyone else spoke about how upset they are, how insulted they are, how the munich conference talk was not well received, how this remark about the disinformation bubble. so i think there is a little bit of that. um, there's posturing. uh, and there is, uh, frankly,
1:21 pm
some emotional, uh, negativity right now. but i think we can move past that real soon. >> okay. um, i'm just wondering why that negativity is not expressed toward the man who initiated the invasion, meaning vladimir putin. let me let me raise this possibility with you. uh, we have a political figure here in the united states. his name is karl rove. he served in the bush administration. i'm going to put on the screen and read something to the audience that he wrote. he said. still, it's possible the author of the art of the deal, meaning trump is lulling mr. putin while setting him up for a great fall. maybe mr. trump has thought a dozen moves ahead and has putin right where he wants him. i don't understand how that could be the case, but maybe you do. is it possible this is a trump strategy to try and get putin to come around? >> so first of all, i don't think, uh, president trump cares either way about russia or maybe about ukraine. uh, wants to get the best deal possible for the
1:22 pm
united states. uh, in his understanding what it means. okay, we might disagree about this strategy. long term interests. but basically, i think there is no idea of getting the best deal for russia. so that's off the table. now, i am not sure i personally believe that president putin is not interested in negotiations. so the only way to get him to the deal is to be nice to him, because what he needs back home to sell to his domestic audience is some kind of legitimacy. look, i'm sitting down with the american team. european. even europeans are not involved. even europeans don't have a seat. i'm the big man now. i think that goes well domestically. and that's exactly what this administration is paying in. >> okay. but timothy putin doesn't have a constituency. he is a dictator. who does he need to keep happy? he can do whatever he wants to do. >> well, that's assuming that he continues to stay in power. and that means giving rents to people who he supports. yes, he
1:23 pm
is an absolute dictator. and if you speak against him or move against him, you get, you disappear or you get poisoned. uh, but still, this system is run on money. it's run on corruption. it's run on force on enforcers. >> i want to show a headline to the audience. from here in the united states, it's the associated press. and it has to do with the way in which this is all being perceived in ukraine. it says trump's attempts to denigrate zelenskyy have led to a surge in ukrainian unity. is that accurate? tell me more. >> yes, absolutely. there have been 2 or 3 recent polls just this week after the attacks, the latest attacks by the president of the united states, and they show 5 to 7% bump in approval ratings, in trust ratings. and in fact, for the first time in the last, maybe half a year or a year, if there were an election held today, uh, zelenskyy would be number one. before that, he was number two. so there is rally around the flag effect in
1:24 pm
ukraine. >> so just one final observation. i, i sense that i'm more offended by trump, our president, his treatment of your president than you are. i even wore my my ukraine tie today in solidarity. like, it sounds as if you're just accepting all of this as business. they're doing business. this is the way that trump is. >> we don't have a choice now, personally. and i don't want to make things worse. of course we are offended. every single ukrainian is offended. but it's important when you are under siege to sort of fight your panic reflex or fight or flight reflex and be strategic. >> okay, that makes sense. thank you sir. i wish you good things. what are you saying? via social media? via the world of x? what do we have? can someone please state the obvious here? this is trump's revenge for zelenskyy not doing the fake biden investigation. yeah, i mean, florida philly fan, i get it.
1:25 pm
you're saying the perfect phone call, right? alexander vindman everybody remember that was impeachment number one. um, i don't get it. i don't get it. i don't understand why. why all of the vitriol has been directed toward to my way of thinking, the one guy who has kept ukraine afloat, and he becomes the focus of all the ire. it it's nonsensical to me. karl rove is a smart guy. when i read rove's column, i say, maybe i'm missing something. i missed plenty of things. and then, you know, i hear my guest, who's totally wired in kyiv on the inside. and to him, it's a certain extent of this. it's it's business. it's trump trying to get zelenskyy in a position that he needs to accept the mineral deal. and by the way, the wall street journal has been on the vanguard of a lot of the reporting on the mineral deal. and yeah, i printed it out this morning and i went and read the comments. and you've got a lot of comments from people on the journal who are saying
1:26 pm
another example of where trump is perceived as as being extreme or, you know, bat crazy. and then all of a sudden, look, he cuts a deal and the united states is going to be reimbursed from, from minerals in a way that iraq should have reimbursed with oil reserves. i get it, it's complicated stuff. speaking of president trump, he keeps talking about a third term, even though the u.s. constitution is real clear and prevents him from running, it has not stopped his supporters. this week, during a cpac event, they touted a proposed third term project and former white house senior advisor steve bannon had this to say. >> we want. >> trump in 28. >> that's what they can't stand. a man. >> like trump. >> comes along only once or. >> twice. >> in the country's history, right? >> we want trump. we want trump. we want trump. we want. >> all right. i love today's poll question. it's cnn.com what is going on here? why does
1:27 pm
president trump tease a third term? is he just needling his opponents? he's just a burr in everybody's saddle. or is it because he intends to try to challenge or change the constitution? go to smerconish.com and cast your ballot. i'll have results later in the hour. still to come, your social media reaction to today's program. and later, the fear of flying appears to be at an all time high after a series of deadly crashes. but what does the data say when you're voting on the poll question? sign up for the free daily newsletter. check out. i love what steve green just drew for us. the gadsden flag, as seen by the far right and the far left. >> this is cnn, the world's news network. >> i'm sure you're wondering why your. >> mother and i. >> asked you here tonight. >> it's because.
1:28 pm
>> it's a buffet of all you can eat. >> butterfly shrimp and sirloin steak. >> yeah. >> that's the. >> reason i don't get it. >> do you have any idea how much this will cost at other restaurants? >> not really. i'm only six. >> a lot, honey. a lot, kiddo. >> oh, okay. >> yeah. >> cardiovascular death. >> two serious side effects include increased ketones in blood or you're in, which can be fatal. stop jardiance and call your doctor right away if you have nausea, vomiting, stomach pain, tiredness, trouble breathing, or increased ketones. jardiance may cause dehydration that can suddenly worsen kidney function and make you feel dizzy, lightheaded, or weak upon standing. genital yeast infections in men and women. urinary tract infections, low blood sugar or a rare, life threatening bacterial infection between and around the and genitals can occur. call your doctor right away if you have fever or feel weak or tired and pain, tenderness, swelling or redness in the genital area. don't use if allergic to jardiance stop use if you have a serious allergic reaction, call your doctor. if you have rash, swelling, difficulty breathing, or swallowing, you may have increased risk for lower limb loss. call your doctor right away if you have new pain or tenderness, sores, ulcers, or infection in your legs or feet. >> jardiance is really swell. the lick.
1:29 pm
>> for more information. >> about side effects. >> talk to your doctor. >> these are real women. >> taking ibrance. ask your doctor. >> about ibrance. >> so we. >> really need to. >> see your. >> ldl c come down more. >> to lower your risk of. >> another heart attack. >> i was afraid we. >> had to. >> do more. >> like what? i already exercise, take. >> my. >> statin, eat kale. >> i can tell you're. >> trying, but there's a high chance you'll have another heart attack. >> i don't. >> want to go through. >> that again. >> what else can we do? >> let's add repatha. >> repatha plus a. >> statin dramatically lowers ldl by 63%, and drops. the risk of having a heart attack by 27%. >> do not take repatha if you're allergic to it. serious allergic reactions. can occur. >> get medical help right away if you have trouble. >> breathing or swallowing. swelling of. >> the face. >> lips, tongue, throat, or arms. common side effects include runny nose. sore throat. common cold symptoms. flu or flu like symptoms, back pain, high blood sugar and redness, pain or bruising at the injection site. >> so i have your.
1:30 pm
>> latest blood. >> work here. and we did it. your ldl. >> c came. >> way down. >> listen to your heart. lower your ldl c and your risk with repatha. talk to your doctor. >> i told you i don't need these anymore. i have sling. okay. >> morning. >> i only. >> let sling deliver. >> the news. >> i need to. >> stay informed. >> thank you. >> very much. nice one. >> nope. sling gives us all the news we want in a quick and reliable manner. and at a wonderful price. this critical time calls for the critical news coverage that sling provides. okay. see you tomorrow. >> the most important news at the best price. sling lets you. >> do that. >> empower. >> i got. >> her a little something. >> a little. >> something, that. >> hold up. won't hold his 401 k account into an empower ira. and it's grow dave's been very excited about saving big with the comcast business 5-year price lock guarantee. five years? -five years. and he's not alone. -high five. it's five years of reliable gig speed internet.
1:31 pm
five years of advanced securit. five years of a great rate that won't change. it's back. but only for a limited time. high five. five years? -nope. comcast business 5-year price lock guarantee. powering five years of savings. powering possibilities. comcast business. dude, i really need a new phone. check out my new samsung galaxy s25 ultra. it's got galaxy ai. imagine this thing running on our superfast xfinity mobile network. and i also heard that it can do multiple things with a single command. —with google gemini. let me try it. add recipes with overripe bananas to my “dessert ideas” note. that's what you chose to ask it? i had other things planned. ask how to get up to one thousand dollars off the new samsung galaxy s25 ultra with xfinity mobile. for less than $34. go to dealdash.com and see how much you can save. >> tomorrow morning. >> he speaks for trump on the world stage from meeting with putin to negotiating middle east
1:32 pm
peace. u.s. special envoy steve witkoff joins jake. plus, house democratic leader hakeem jeffries on his party's next steps. state of the union. tomorrow morning at nine. >> a gang. i'm on every social media platform you can think of. so find me during the course of the show, during the course of the week, and react, for example, from x. it came to me in a dream and we hashed it out in two hours. pretty much describes the entire trump administration. okay, i'm laughing with you because you're reacting to my guest, james fishback, who explained to us all, uh, how did they come up with the idea for the doge dividend? and like, fairness, i'm tempted to say, yeah, but lennon and mccartney wrote a couple of great songs, and on a napkin in just a couple of minutes. give me the next one. what's next? a lot of social media reaction, i'm told, raising the issue of a third term takes media attention away from the problems caused by the mass firings. eric, it's the poll question. cut me some slack. we just did an entire segment to open the program all
1:33 pm
about doge. so it's not as if i can't walk and chew gum at the same time. we've done both. next. come on. liberals have been propagandized to support another endless war. afghanistan liberals. liberals have been propagandized to support another endless war. afghanistan 2.0 ferrari. ronald reagan is rolling over in his grave. ronald reagan is rolling over in his grave. this is so far removed from the soviet 79 invasion and the u.s. response in supporting the afghan freedom fighters. do you know, i used to go to cpac in the 80s when i was a reagan republican, and the republicans were still like reagan. i'd still be a republican. but i can remember i have a distinct recollection of being at cpac dinners president reagan used to attend, like all of them. there'd be a black tie dinner at the end. i was in college at the time, or maybe
1:34 pm
law school. and i remember there were a couple of tables of individuals in in arabic garb and turbans, and we were effusive in our praise of them because they were the afghan freedom fighters, and we were funding them privately, publicly, because they were fighting the soviet invasion. and to look now where instead, zelenskyy gets cast as as the bad guy for standing up to putin because his nation was invaded. no. hell no. no no. one more. do i have time for it? i think that i do. go ahead. my take since he still believes he won in 2020, then let's encourage him to think it. that it's his third term. look, i think my view of today's poll question is that that he's he's playing with his opponents, that he loves needling his opponents. you saw the laughter in trump. i mean, trump has a sense of humor, but not often, you know, outwardly
1:35 pm
emotive. he was laughing when he was saying it. and the more that people make it a controversy, the more he's going to continue to tease a third term. but i don't think that's the objective here. i could be wrong. still to come, did the recent crashes in the u.s. highlight legitimate concerns with air travel, or is the media's excessive coverage of these tragedies amplifying unnecessary or excessive fears from the public? and as i referenced earlier this week, trump likened himself to a king as he celebrated his move to kill new york city's congestion pricing program. i want to know what you think. go to smerconish.com vote in the poll question. why does he continue to tease a third term when the constitution is so clear? 22nd amendment precluding it? is he needling his opponents, or does he really intend to try and challenge or change the constitution when you're there voting? sign up for the free and worthy daily newsletter. check out what scott stantis drew for
1:36 pm
us. >> the lead with jake tapper weekdays at 4:00 on cnn. >> i don't. >> play for. >> money. >> before my. >> mom passed, she told me to play big, play. >> for something bigger than. >> myself. >> now my ambition is to play so i can help and inspire. >> others. >> that's why i joined sofi. they help people save, spend, earn, borrow and invest toward financial independence so they can realize their ambitions no matter what they're playing for. sofi, get your money right. >> if you're living with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. >> or active. >> psoriatic arthritis, symptoms can. >> sometimes hold you back. >> but now there's skyrizi so you. >> can be. >> all in with clear skin. >> things are getting clearer. yeah, i feel free in my skin. yeah, that's on me. nothing is
1:37 pm
everything. >> we're skyrizi. you can show up with 90% clear skin. and if you have psoriatic arthritis, skyrizi can help you move with less joint pain, stiffness, swelling, and fatigue. skyrizi is just four doses a year after two starter doses. >> don't use if allergic serious allergic reactions, increased infections, or lower ability to fight them may occur. before treatment, get checked for infections and tb. tell your doctor about any flu like symptoms or vaccines. >> thanks to skyrizi. there's nothing like clear skin and better movement. and that means everything. >> is everything. >> now's the time. ask your doctor about skyrizi. learn how abbvie could help you save. >> i love. >> sometimes it takes a different approach. to see. >> the. >> possibilities all around you. >> how are the girls? >> they're amazing. >> dad. >> as a.
1:38 pm
>> capella university nurse practitioner. >> student. >> you'll learn the advanced skills you need. >> to face the nursing challenges of today and tomorrow. a different future is closer than you think. with capella university. >> tap into etsy for original and affordable home in style pieces like lighting under $150 to brighten your vibe for under $100, put your best look forward with vintage jackets or pick up custom shelving for under 50 to make space without emptying your pockets and get cozy with linen robes for 75 or less. for affordable home and style finds to help you welcome whatever's next. etsy has it. >> in the middle of suburbia, this owl is. hoping to find a lifetime of happiness. that's lifetime of happiness. that's promising. one scorching heatwave will leave me powerless
1:39 pm
to cool my insulin. - when the storm rolls in, my time to find a pet-friendly evacuation center will have run out. - i'm relying on luck, but who knows if it'll be on my side. vo: when it comes to disasters and emergencies, it's not a matter of if, but when. take control. 1. assess your needs 2. make a plan 3. engage your support network let's prepare so we all have a better story to tell. visit us at gofundme.com.
1:40 pm
>> cookbooks. corporate fat cats swindling socialites, doped up cyclists, then yes, more crooked politicians. i have a feeling we won't be running out of those anytime soon. >> a new season of united states of scandal with jake tapper. march 9th on cnn. >> the recent string of horrific plane crashes are making many wonder is it safe to fly? this month, google trends saw a spike in online searches for air travel safety. a similar finding came during the pandemic, when travelers then were worrying might they catch covid in flight? several aviation disasters have dominated national headlines recently. the deadly mid-air collision between two small aircraft at an arizona airport just this week, the delta commercial flight that flipped upside down after crash landing on the runway in toronto on monday. last week, a pilot died after a jet owned by motley crue lead singer vince neil crashed into a parked plane in scottsdale, arizona. here in philadelphia, a medevac jet carrying a pediatric patient plunged into a sidewalk last
1:41 pm
month, causing a fiery explosion and killing seven people. and of course, let's not forget the u.s. army blackhawk helicopter that collided with an american airlines flight and crashed over the potomac river in d.c., killing 67 people on board. but before we rush to judgment about the safety of air travel, let's consider the media frenzy of previous news cycles and their impact on public perception. in 2001, do you remember, after a string of reported shark attacks in the u.s., time magazine splashed a jaw dropping headline across their front page, dubbed 2001 is the summer of the shark. well, a subsequent study from the university of florida found that shark attacks that year worldwide were slightly down from 85 in 2000 to 70 6 in 2001. and in the number of deaths of shark attacks that fell from 12 to 5, many experts agree there was nothing unusual about the frequency of shark attacks in 2001, only the way the media covered them during a slow news
1:42 pm
cycle. similarly, 2018 remember this many americans scared to travel to the dominican republic after nearly a dozen american tourists died there from natural causes, respiratory issues, or heart related condition. officials found no evidence of foul play or violence. but despite over 2 million americans visiting the dominican republic every year, the number of tourists deaths it's declined since 2015. and another story that i put into this mix that sparked nationwide panic last year. the mysterious sightings of drones near a u.s. military bases, airports, new jersey in particular. the pentagon received hundreds of reports of new ufo sightings, and lawmakers speculated that a foreign adversary was involved. but in her first white house briefing, press secretary karoline leavitt debunked many of the conspiracy theories that took from the drone sightings. >> an update on the. >> new jersey drones. after research and study, the drones that were flying over new jersey in large numbers were authorized to be flown by the faa for
1:43 pm
research and various other reasons. many of these drones were also hobbyists. recreational and private individuals that enjoy flying drones. >> i don't think there was any revelation there, right. that that salved fears. the news cycle just moved on. think about it. recently there have been no concerning drone sightings. the heightened fears and anxieties from these stories and the tragedies may explain why more americans were also scared to fly after 9/11. but in that instance, those concerns may have actually increased automobile fatalities. a study published in the national library of medicine found that in the days immediately following the terror attacks of nine over 11, thousands of americans chose to drive rather than to fly. they were thus exposed to the heightened risk of injury and death posed by driving. there were approximately 353 excess fatalities caused by people choosing to drive when they otherwise would have flown. the
1:44 pm
conclusion from that study inspired thursday's poll on my website. smerconish.com. is the declining safety in air travel rooted in actual increased risks, or is it primarily driven by the media and the results? 30 plus thousand or nearly 30,000 voted? the audience was divided. joining me now is cnn senior data reporter harry enten, the author of a recent cnn piece that caught my eye. why i continue to fly, even though it scares me. harry, thank you for crunching the numbers. what did you do and with what conclusion? >> yeah. >> i mean, look. >> i basically just looked at. >> the ntsb data. i looked at the faa data, and there are a few things that sort of stood out. number one, in fact, there were fewer airline accidents. when you combine commercial and private in january than any january on record. and that, of course, is part of a long term trend whereby 2024 was the safest year on record when looking at fatal air crashes. and it's part of a longer term trend where the number of
1:45 pm
commercial airliner fatal fatalities dating back since 2010, it is the smallest on record. we're talking 62, i believe in total, that is way less than we saw in the 1980s. i think from 82 to 89 there were nearly 1000. so the bottom line is, yes, there have been a couple of high profile incidents. yes, it scares some folks. it scares me a little bit. but when you dig down into the data, the fear is a little bit irrational. >> harry, i think your number was 80. private crashes in january of 2024. i'm doing it from memory, but i think that was the number. whatever the number is, when i read it, i said. i said to myself, my god, there were 80 in that month. i don't remember that. why don't i remember that? >> because the media really didn't cover it. because there wasn't a high profile crash. i mean, i think a lot of this has to do with what happened in late january. that unfortunate event down in virginia, washington, d.c. area and then all of a sudden heighten our fears. and then we're just looking for any little instance, right, of
1:46 pm
something that went wrong. and so there are private commercial or there are private crashes every single month, basically every single day, to be perfectly honest with you. but those don't get the outsized media attention that they now have, because i think our focus is all in on it. >> by the way, i don't know that this needs to be said, but but nothing that i'm saying and certainly nothing i know that harry enten is saying is meant to diminish the loss of life associated with any of these catastrophes, but rather just just to hold our reaction in check insofar as we think there's something going on out there akin to the sharks, akin to the dominican republic, akin to the drug, like, have you heard anybody, harry, talk about drones recently? and what the heck happened to that story? >> i don't know what the heck happened to that story. i remember, you know, my girlfriend's family, they live out in jersey. they were taking videos of the drones every single night. i think i even did a segment with our dear friend anderson cooper on, and i was like, there's no real proof
1:47 pm
that there's anything nefarious going on here. and slowly but surely, that story exited the news cycle as we jumped on to other news stories. that fear seemed to be a bit irrational, a little bit like our fear of flying in a plane is a bit irrational, despite, of course, the unfortunate loss of life. >> right before you leave me any other instance that comes to mind where similarly, we've gotten fixated and it's it's had an outsized influence on our fear or anything that harry enten is looking in the future and saying, that could be the next one. >> i don't. look, predicting the future is a little bit difficult. but, you know, i was thinking back to 1973. johnny carson went on national tv and said that there is a toilet paper shortage. there was no toilet paper shortage, but it actually caused one a little bit to a degree because i think harold froehlich, who is a congressman, said that there was one, there wasn't one. and then of course, they were able to replenish the toilet paper supply eventually. but johnny carson actually caused a bit of a toilet paper shortage, a bit irrationally.
1:48 pm
>> see, now i'm going to take my $5,000 doge dividend, and i'm going to put it all in toilet paper because of what you've just it's kind of a joke related to the program. thank you harry, as always. >> i'll see you later, buddy. >> checking in on social media comments from the world of x. what do we have? we've had more aviation mishaps in such a condensed period of time. ever since trump started messing with the faa. the risk is not worth the savings. i know that that's the perception. by the way, florida didn't florida philly fan already get and we get thousands of response. how does how does somebody get 2 in 1 show. um, anyway, put it back up on the screen because i lost my train of thought. oh yeah. laying this off on trump. there are a lot of things you can lay off on trump. i don't think that this is that this is one of them. and i don't think that the data, as harry has evidenced, bears out that there's any it's it's sad. it's sad. each one of these the philly crash was horrible. pediatric patient terrible. but
1:49 pm
there's not something going on out there as suggested by the data. you still have time to vote on the poll. question of the day. it's smerconish.com. why does president trump tease a third term to needle his opponents, or because he intends to try and challenge or change the constitution? don't just vote and run. sign up for the newsletter while you're there and check out our editorial cartoons. jack ohman drew this for us. >> i'm hanako montgomery in. >> tokyo and this is. >> cnn. >> show. >> how do you sleep at night on a mattress from mattress firm? so i. >> sleep all night. >> at the presidents day sale. save up to $700 on sealy. get matched at mattress firm, sleep at night. >> at morgan stanley. >> old school. >> hard work meets bold new thinking.
1:50 pm
>> partnering to. >> unlock new ideas, to create new legacies. to transform a company industry economy generation. because grit and vision working in lockstep puts you on the path to your full potential. old school grit, new world ideas, morgan stanley. >> outback steakhouse has a three course meal. called the aussie. >> aussie. >> aussie with soup. >> or salad. your choice of. >> select entrees. >> and. >> cheesecake for. >> dessert. >> it's three, 3 or 3. >> courses starting. >> at 14.99 at. >> outback for. >> a. >> limited time. >> planning to move? join the 6 million families who discovered a smarter, more flexible way to move with pods. save up to 20% now for a limited time. whether you're moving across town or across the country. save up to 20% at pods.com today at harbor freight, we design and test our own tools and sell them directly
1:51 pm
to you. >> no middlemen, just quality tools you can trust at prices you'll love. whatever you do, do it for less. at harbor freight. >> i have type two diabetes, but i manage it now. it's a little pill with a big story to tell. i take one daily jardiance at each day. start. as time went on, it was easy to see. i'm lowering my a1c's. and for adults with type two diabetes and known heart disease, jardiance can lower the risk of cardiovascular death. >> two serious side effects include increased ketones in blood or you're in, which can be fatal. stop jardiance and call your doctor right away if you have nausea, vomiting, stomach pain, tiredness, trouble breathing, or increased ketones. jardiance may cause dehydration that can suddenly worsen kidney function and make you feel dizzy, lightheaded, or weak upon standing. genital yeast infections in men and women. urinary tract infections, low blood sugar, or a rare, life threatening bacterial infection between and around the and genitals can occur. call your doctor right away if you have
1:52 pm
fever or feel weak or tired and pain, tenderness, swelling or redness in the genital area. don't use if allergic to jardiance stop use if you have a serious allergic reaction, call your doctor. if you have rash, swelling, difficulty breathing, or swallowing, you may have increased risk for lower limb loss. call your doctor right away if you have new pain or tenderness, sores or ulcers, or infection in your will too.
1:53 pm
>> i can feel the winds of change. >> it's the news. >> welcome back. >> but it's also kind of not the news. >> we don't fact check it. we don't care, man. why sell the information on this show so terrible? >> have i got news for you tonight at nine on cnn. >> so the 22nd amendment is very clear that donald trump cannot run for another term. nevertheless, he keeps talking about it. wow. look at that voting. so i'm asking as today's poll question, why? what's he up to? is he doing it because he wants to needle his opponents, or because he really intends to try and challenge or
1:54 pm
change the constitution? 44,867 have voted so far, and it's running like 8020. 79% say no. he's serious about it. he's serious about it. i don't think so. i think i think the more that it gets talked about and the greater the reaction that it draws, the more it guarantees he's going to continue to go back to that. well, just to to sort of, you know, tweak all of his opponents more social media reaction to today's program. what else has come in this clown? smerconish really literally defends sesame street in iraq. what an app, by the way. like what a stupid. and cnn sucks. and joseph nye put that camera back on me for one second. joseph nye is the is the guy who coined, uh, soft power. he ran the kennedy school at harvard. now, i'm sure you're thinking he's an egghead. he's actually a brilliant guy. look him up. and the logic is that we can only do so much with boots on the ground and bullets. and sometimes you've got to win
1:55 pm
hearts and minds of individuals and expenditures like, yes, sesame street have value. i'm not defending everything on that. that doge list. i looked at some of them, and some of them are ridiculous, but a lot of them just don't lend themselves to a soundbite. sesame street does. do you want al qaeda teaching your kids or their kids, or big bird? here's another one. what else came in? he loves seeing the media jump out of the clown car like their pants are on fire. yeah, that's exactly why trump is, uh, is doing what he's doing, i agree. next. what's next? that is the that is the correct answer. as a trump supporter, i 100. whoa. i 100% agree with you, mike. how did that get in there, michael? that any money that is saved should go back to paying down the debt? no one should get any money back since we owe so much right now. if we if we didn't listen. thank you, john, for that vote of confidence. if we didn't have 36 trillion in debt and we decided we were going to
1:56 pm
downsize government, that would be a legitimate savings that could be passed on. but instead, like the banker, you know, is standing here saying you owe me $36 trillion. and we're contemplating going out to dinner nonetheless. makes no sense. remember if you missed any of today's show, you can always listen anywhere you get your podcasts. so thank you for watching. we'll see you next week. >> superman. the christopher reeve story. tonight at ten on cnn. >> your life is pretty smart, but when it's time to eat, suddenly you feel out of sync. refresh your routine with factor. chef prepared meals delivered with a tap ready in two minutes. eat smart with factor, billy.
1:57 pm
>> i need help with the clicker. >> wait one second, grandma. >> this guy's going to buy my car. >> okay. >> you need carvana. what's your. >> plate number? >> boss. >> em. >> vehicle features. >> no accidents. >> right? >> no. >> good. >> generating offer. >> carvana can. >> pick it up tomorrow. >> that's an amazing offer. >> do you still need help with the clicker? >> i'll ask. >> your. >> sister. >> sell your car the easy way. >> with carvana. >> ooh la la. >> nancy. >> beef bourguignon. for 15. bold choice. >> but they're here in ten, and you're. >> not ready. >> that eye shadow. so fire. know what. else is fire? your kitchen. no, seriously. >> fire! >> fire! fire! >> with over 25%. >> faster smoke. >> detection to. >> detect products. >> help protect. >> you from you.
1:58 pm
>> so take. >> out. >> you're seeing skechers famous footwear everywhere. and now that famous design. >> is available in. >> hands free skechers slip ins. get the comfort and style glide step now with the convenience of slip ins, with no bending down or touching your shoes. try glide step skechers slip in spirit. >> nice going lou. >> nothing like a. little confidence boost to. >> help ease you back into the dating scene. of course, that also includes having a. smile you feel good about. >> fortunately. >> aspen dental specializes in dentures and implants made just for you, with. >> affordable options and flexible ways. >> to pay. and now they're $0 down plus zero interest if paid in full in 18 months. helping our patients put their best smile forward. it's one more way. aspen dental is in your corner. >> i'm sure you're wondering. >> why your mother and i asked you here tonight. it's because it's a buffet of all you can eat. butterfly shrimp and sirloin steak. >> yeah, that's the reason. >> i don't get it. >> do you have any idea how much this will cost at other restaurants? >> not really. i'm only six. >> a lot, honey. a lot, kiddo.
1:59 pm
>> okay. >> yeah. >> ontario, canada. your third largest trading partner and number one export destination for 17 states. our economic partnership keeps millions of americans working. we're here right by your side. >> i feel like new sunglasses. like a brand new pair of jeans. oh. brand new. >> learn more. >> about celebrity. >> cruises latest. >> offers. >> action hero. i guess misery. >> was that necessary? >> no. neither is a blown weekend with paycom. employees do their own payroll so you can fix problems before they become problems. get paycom and make the unnecessary. >> unnecessary. >> hey, guys. >> there's a change in. >> the air. >> two changes. >> two changes. >> the three row. luxury tt. because everyone should feel like the center of the universe.
2:00 pm
>> to all those who never give a second thought. >> to being the. >> first ones in. >> thank you servpro. >> proud supporter. >> of our nation's first responders. >> khuza'a. this isn't. >> the. >> way home. >> that's right james. it isn't. >> car. >> where are. >> we going? >> where? here. >> oh. >> the future isn't scary. not investing in it is. >> were you in. >> on this? nothing gets. >> by you, james. nasdaq 100 innovators one etf. before investing, carefully read and consider fund investment objectives, risks, charges, expenses and more in prospectus@invesco.com. >> closed captioning brought to you by dot com. >> if you or a loved. >> one. >> have mesothelioma, we'll. >> send you a free book. >> to answer questions you may have. call now. >> and we'll.
0 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN (San Francisco)Uploaded by TV Archive on
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f81f4/f81f4706eb000f351b9cb25c479944f00d0bec31" alt=""