tv Fareed Zakaria GPS CNN November 14, 2010 10:00am-11:00am EST
10:00 am
heart." and she's stopping in iowa and south carolina, two states critical to picking up her party's nomination. and where, according to our cnn exit polls, presidential prospects are already very high. maybe, maybe, that means more than this. >> on a really clear day, you can see russia from here -- almost. >> thanks for watching "state of the union." i'm joe johns in washington. don't forget to tune in tonight for candy's interview with president george w. bush and his brother, former florida governor, jeb bush. "bush 2 years later" airs at 8:00 p.m. and 11:00 p.m. eastern only here on cnn. but up next for our viewers here in the united states, "fareed zakaria: gps." this is "gps," the global public square. welcome to all of you in the united states and around the world. i'm fareed zakaria. this is a special edition of "gps" coming to you from the cnn
10:01 am
studios in hong kong. you see, while president obama has been traveling in asia, so have i, and i've actually been struck by the change of mood in asia last year. one year ago if you were traveling around here, the talk was all about the irrelevance of the united states and the dawn of chinese power. experts would point out that china had massively expanded its aid to southeast asia, dwarfing that from washington. when china would stand up to the united states on climate change or currency, well, people in asia would say that's the new world order. but over the past year, china's behavior in asia is causing something of a rethink on that vast continent. [ sirens ] the signal event was probably the scuffle on september 8th in the waters around the senkaku islands, which are claimed both by japan and china. it wasn't the details of this incident which involved a chinese fishing boat that worried people. rather, it was china's response -- tough, unyielding, up the ante in many cases.
10:02 am
so the japanese, the indians, the south koreans all looked at that and wondered, is this our future in an asia that's going to be dominated by china economically cli? the sharpest rethinking appears to be taking place in tokyo. you see, japan had long believed it could play a kind of quiet and nonconfrontational role position between china and the united states. but listen tho this -- "japan and china now stand at ground zero and the landscape is a bleak, vast nothingness." so writes japan's most important foreign affairs commentator in a letter that he sent to dozens of high-ranking friends in china. if china continued to undermine its own peaceful rise doctrine, he wrote, then japan would discard its naivete, lower its expectations, aqueer needed insurance and in some cases cut its losses. china has managed its rise with great care so far, making sure not to give the impression that
10:03 am
it was an aggressive rising power. it remains unclear whether this recent bethaifr's been over the last six months in a variety of different areas is a misjudgment which will be corrected or whether this is the new normal that asian countries and perhaps the world will have to get used to as china ascends economically. in any event, one thing is clear. it was easy to accept, even welcome the rise of china when it was an abstraction. now that it is a hard reality, the geopolitics of asia will get interesting. we have a great show for you today. we'll go more in depth on the president's trip to asia with a panel that includes someone who can comment on each of the president's stops -- india, indonesia, south korea, and japan. what did and didn't obama accomplish here in asia? but first the main event from back in the united states. america's eldest statesman,
10:04 am
george schulz, on foreign affairs, of course. but before schulz was secretary of state, he was secretary of treasury and secretary of labor and director of the budget. he's going to tell us what's wrong with the economy and what he thinks the obama administration needs to do to fix it. then what in the world? some say it's the most innovative place on the globe. i'll show you some of its fascinating inventions and tell you what lessons tiny singapore could possibly teach the united states. and finally, what does the president really miss about his childhood home in indonesia? you'll be surprised. let's get started. >> u.s. unemployment is at 10%, the budget deficit is at 10%, and growth is under 2%. what's to be done? i wanted to ask george schulz, most remember him as secretary of state who helped end the cold war, but he's also a great
10:05 am
economic mind. he has a ph.d. in economics from m.i.t., was dean of the chicago business school, ran the country's biggest engineering firm, and, of course, held three other cabinet positions all related to the economy -- budget director, secretary of labor, seasoned secretary of the treasury, as i mentioned. he is now a distinguished fellow at the hoover institution at stanford. he's just published "ideas and action," which includes his ten commandments for action. he was a supporter of george w. bush and has been critical of president obama's economic polici policies. so let's listen to him and find out what his solutions are. george schulz joined me from stanford university. thank you for being with us, mr. secretary. >> my pleasure, fareed. >> let's start with the short-term economic crisis, because you've written some things about the longer-term issues, and i want to get to them, as well. but right now you have a situation where unemployment
10:06 am
remains stubbornly high, the consumer is still not spending, perhaps shell-shocked from the bursting of the credit bubble, businesses are still not spending, they still have a lot of capacity and don't see the need to add capacity. in that circumstance, many people say, look, the government is the only player who has the capacity to do something. what do you say to those who believe that the government -- if the government doesn't spend, in fact, if it starts cutting, you are going to put an already fragile economy in a downward spiral? >> i think what we have had, in effect, is an anti-growth policy. the name of the game is economic growth. and we've had a policy, set of policies, that maximize uncertainty, that threaten to reduce incentives, where you don't -- you have little quick fixes that aren't permanent and
10:07 am
all the evidence shows that if you have something that's temporary, it doesn't really change behavior very much. also a sense that the playing field can change, nothing distinct from rules of administrative actions. tell us what playing field looks like. if we know the rules and we're confident you're not going to change them in the middle of the game, thenwe'll play the game. but if you keep saying to us we don't know what the rules are and to the extent there are some we're going to change them in the middle of the game, i say well, i don't want to play that game. that's why i say we've got to create some certainty and we've got to get back to paying attention to incentives, and we've got to get back to having people have skin in the game. all these things add up to an anti-growth policy. and what we should do is change it to a growth policy. that's what we need to do. >> so let's talk about that. what would a pro-growth agenda
10:08 am
that george shultz would write look like? what are the four or five key elements that are going to get businesses to start spending again? >> number one, i would enact a very short bill that says the income and inheritance tax rates that are in effect in 2009 will remain in effect until congress changes them, period. very short. one-sentence bill. be so refreshing instead of these thousands of pages of bills. so that would create some sense of where the tax rates are going to be. then i would rein in this excessive government spending. it's just totally out of control. and i would tackle the entitlement programs. let me come first to social security. somehow people are afraid to touch it because they're afraid of reactions from older people.
10:09 am
i've examined this issue with some care. i have yet to see any proposal that changes anything as far as older people are concerned. this is not about older people. it's about younger people and preserving the system for them. then you've got to look at the health care system. its costs are rising. everybody understands that, sees that. the recent health care bill, if anything, makes that cost problem worse. and so we've got to start doing things that get the costs under control. and we know how to do it. >> how? what would -- >> the same way we -- you do it the way we do it in every other industry. why is it that in computers the quality goes up and the price goes down all the time? why is it in other industries the same thing happens? it's because you have an empowered consumer. when you have an empowered consumer, when the consumer has
10:10 am
resources and there's a reasonably competitive market and reasonable information, costs come down and quality goes up. we've got to get back to the consumer in the game. >> but, mr. secretary, even if you got all the things you're describing, david stockman, who was the budget director for ronald reagan, says you need to do all the things you described, but he says still, if you look at the budget deficits and you look at the projected budget defic deficits, particularly once the baby boomers really start retiring, you're going to have to raise revenue. there is simply no way -- the math doesn't work without raising revenue. and your proposal number one effectively locks in the bush tax cults, which means that you lose about $700 billion to $800 billion of revenue over the next ten years. how would you make the math add up? >> well, i don't agree with your math. that is, i think the way to produce revenue right now is to create some certainty about tax
10:11 am
rates and leave the incentives there and have the economy expand. an expanding economy will -- is the best way there is to generate revenue. so that's the way to start. then i think you need to look at the tax system. and everybody agrees that it badly needs reform. the corporate tax rate is punitive, much too high. there are all kinds of gimmicks in the tax code that needs to be taken out. and lots of other things can be done. there are many proposals for it. and so a serious effort needs to be made to do a kind of revision sort of like we did in 1986 in the reagan administration. incidentally, that massive tax reform was passed on a bipartisan basis. lots of democrats as well as republicans voted for it. >> well, let's talk about that, because any kind of massive
10:12 am
overhaul of any of these systems -- social security, health care, particularly the tax structure, which, of course, is 16,000 pages, which is mostly 16,000 pages of giveaways to various special interests -- is going to have to be done on a bipartisan basis. you give up your special interest in return for mine. it seems as though anyone who tries to come forward with a compromise is immediately attacked on -- by each flank of his or her party. how do you change that? >> i don't know. i've been away from washington for 20 years now, and what i read is not comforting. but i remember when we came into office in the reagan administration. we had a terrible situation on our hands. inflation in the double digits and the soviet union running wild and so on and so on. and jimmy carter had called the situation "malaise." people talked about how it was ungovernable. it didn't turn out that way.
10:13 am
and we can change things around and i think people can be appealed to. people are saying what's the message of the election, and i'm sure there are lots of messages. but i think one of the messages must be washington isn't working, and for goodness' sakes, will you guys pleads get together and try to accomplish something sensible. so maybe that message can be brought to bear and something sensible can come out here. >> but, again, let me ask you, in your "wall street journal" op-ed, i think you mentioned that there was a period of spending restraint in american government which was, roughly speaking, the mid-1980s through 2001. and you attributed it to stronger growth, which is absolutely true. but the deficits came down after having doubled initially under reagan because george bush sr. and then bill clinton also raised taxes. and what i'm wondering is if you take taxes off the table, will
10:14 am
you ever be able to get the deficits down? >> i don't say take taxes off the table forever. i said first have a tax regime that people know is there for a while, and have it be one that creates incentives, and get the economy moving. in the cases that you mentioned, the economy was moving, and so these were changes that had to do with expanding economy, a healthy economy. so the first task is to get economic growth going. and you don't do that by raising taxes. >> we're going to come back, and when we come back, we are going to talk to george shultz about the world, about china, about what's going on in asia, about the challenges of nuclear proliferation, terrorism, iran, all when we come back with george shultz. ealth. plus now it supports my heart health and helps maintain healthy blood pressure.
10:17 am
try capzasin-hp. it penetrates deep to block pain signals for hours of relief. capzasin-hp. take the pain out of arthritis. and we are back with george shultz, the former budget director, secretary of labor, secretary of treasury, secretary of state. and we're now going to focus a little bit more on his last job as secretary of state for president reagan and his insights that draw from that.
10:18 am
secretary shultz, how would you advise the obama administration to handle this rise of asia? obviously, he's going there, he's paying a lot of attention to it. but beyond that, what would be the kind of advice you would give? >> well, first of all, i think there is a thing that you do in diplomacy that's not really recognized. and i do think the obama administration is trying to do it. namely, it's what i call gardening. if you plant a garden and you go away for six months and you come back, what have you got? weeds. and you can't get them out without getting all the flowers and the vegetables or whatever you planted there out. same thing is true in diplomacy. if all you do is go to people when there's some sort of a crisis, well, your garden is full of weeds.
10:19 am
so you've got to have, particularly with major country, some sort of process of gardening, of going there, talking, sorting out issues, having -- setting up some kind of an agenda, working through the agenda, doing staff work, and then when something comes up that's a big problem you've laid the groundwork of understanding and some ability to talk in reasonably candid terms. >> would you talk to iran even though you would naturally present a very tough series of demands? would you try to initiate some kind of dialogue? >> i certainly would be willing to talk to iran, but i'd want to do it more on my agenda, not their agenda. and i would be making no bones about my opinion of what they're doing. it isn't just their nuclear program, but look at how they are governing their people. here they have all these riches. they have talented people. and their most talented scientists and engineers are working on nuclear weapons
10:20 am
instead of doing things that can be helpful to people. and i'd be drumming that in on them and saying that visibly and hard so they know exactly where we stand, and we'd be trying to let the people of iran know where we stand, just as when we were dealing with the soviet union you remember ronald reagan called it an evil empire. >> evil empire. >> when i went to moscow, i always met with dissidence. we sad a sadr in our embassy and we made a point of recognizing their problems and saying what we want, so -- and we had an agenda, which we wrougbrought t fore. that's the way to go about it, but certainly talk. >> what would you do about the israeli/palestinian peace process? one of the things when president reagan was in office, you guys were pretty tough on the israelis over the invasion of lebanon. do you think that we should be pressing israel more on
10:21 am
settlements? do you think we should be trying to present a settlement plan that, you know, a version of camp david, the clinton plan? >> well, it's one of those situations where the nature of the settlement is fairly well-known but you can't get there. so how do you do it? i think it's a mistake to precipitate negotiations in saying we're going to get this job done by the end of the year or something like that. it's not that kind of a problem. this is something to nourish and let it take hold more and more. and then -- so you're building something from the bottom up rather than negotiating something and trying to impose it from the top down. so i'd be putting a lot of my emphasis on seeing to it that that process continues. >> how would you handle the rise of china? probably the signal geopolitical fact of the world we live in has been the dramatic rise of china economically and now increasingly politically.
10:22 am
what would you tell obama about how to handle this rise? >> the first thing that i would do is get our own horse in order. we're out of control. and our spending, this most recent move by the federal reserve has set off alarm bells all over the world, and people feel we're a country that doesn't have our house in order. so the first thing we need to do in negotiating with china or anybody else is get our own house in order. get ourselves under control. where we're financing our own investment and we have reasonable balance in trade and we're getting control of our deficits and so forth. then we have a base from which to move. i think the way to proceed is to engage the chinese leadership and, as secretary of state, say to my counterpart, you put on the agenda anything you want to
10:23 am
put. and i'll p put anything i want to put. and let's organize it into some sort of a reasonable set of things that we're going to work on, have our staffs engage, and work through this agenda carefully, thoroughly, continuously. it's a special kind of gardening. and of course we need to encourage heads of state meetings, the meeting of hu jintao coming to washington i think in late january is a very important meeting. it needs to be set up carefully. it needs to be treated with great respect, courteously, and that's the way you make progress. >> all right. and finally, mr. secretary, i have to say i'm going to find out whatever it is you heat ooet because i'd like to be as alert and as engaged as you are at 90. >> well, tell people to read this book because it's -- the theme of the book is ideas matter. and if you have ideas and you
10:24 am
act on the basis of them, you have a compass. and if you don't have ideas, you're going to just flounder around. so start with ideas. that's why i've always been so lucky to be affiliated with strong universities throughout my adult life. >> secretary shultz, thank you very much. it's been a pleasure and an honor. coming up, a model for innovation that the united states can follow, and it comes out of a city of 5 million people, a city state of 5 million leading the way, when we come back. than tylenol 8 hour. so why am i still thinking about this? how are you? good, how are you? [ male announcer ] aleve. proven better on pain.
10:25 am
10:26 am
10:27 am
we're back with a special edition of "gps" coming to you from hong kong this week. and now for our "what in the world" segment. america is the innovation capital of the world, the home of the best new research technology, scientists and companies, and the only way it will stay vibrant as an economy and a society is if it continues to lead the world in innovation.
10:28 am
unfortunately, it is increasingly evident that we're not as securely at the top as we once were. it's partly that we're not as focused as we should be on science and technology, but it's also that others are joining in the game, learning our tricks, and catching up. a study last year from the boston consuling group and the national association of manufacturers found that the united states ranked eighth in the world in innovation. the top-ranked country is actually a city, city-state, one with a population of just 50e6r million people. it's singapore. and i stopped there this week to find out the secrets of their success. hi there. >> hi. welcome to my house. i hope you're enjoying your visit so far. >> that's a computer-generated "avata greeting me at a place called fusion world. it's where singapore's agency for science, technology, and research shows off its latest
10:29 am
innovations. 2,400 scientists in a variety of fields, all working on research projects with massive government funding. take a look at this tv of the future that you can control with hand gestures, no remote. look at this smart billboard that can figure out your gender and can target advertisements accordingly. when a woman walks in front of it, she's shown a watch for women. but when i walk in front of it, the sensors read my face and throw up an ad for a man's watch. from modern mad men to medicine, this next one could save your life. one scientist helped me understand it. >> so here we have the hospital bed of the future. this is called a smart bed. >> right. >> why? >> well, it has sensors. one detechs the sleeping pattern, the pressure of the body, and the other detects breathing rate. >> if the patient's body stops moving or the patient stops
10:30 am
breathing, an alarm goes off to alert doctors and nurses. >> but you don't have to be hooked up to anything? >> no. it's totally noninvasive. >> for this next one, the patient did have to be hooked up, and the patient was me. so what do we have here? this looks like a video game. >> this is our award-winning brain technology. >> well, it is all that, but it is also a video game. this is tough. i am controlling the blue car, guiding it around the track with my brain. >> the game is a way of encouraging the patient to concentrate more. the harder he concentrate, the faster the car will move. >> i had to train myself to concentrate really hard. but when i did, it worked. i was zooming around the track like mario andretti. well, maybe like super mario. now, what i was doing was just fun and games, but this invention has many very serious real-world applications -- helping rehabilitate stroke victim, helping the severely paralyzed commune kite kayte with the outside world, and
10:31 am
helping kids with attention deficit disorder. rather than using drugs to deal with the symptoms of a.d.d., this game tries to get at the root cause and train children to focus and concentrate. so what is it that makes singapore so good at innovation? well, it needed to do something to move up the value chain. around 2000, sping pore looked around and realized that it had to do something different to get ahead in the new world. its wages were high. it couldn't compete with china and basic manufacturing anymore, so the government decided to pour money into innovation and r&d. between 2000 and 2016, $30 billion of government money will have gone to innovation. remember, singapore has just over 5 million recipes. so how much should the united states spend to stay ahead in this race? well i've argued much more than in the past. it's a new world with many new nations competing. my own number is about $700
10:32 am
billion, which is about what we spend on the defense department every year. and we will be right back. >> gotten very heated in the newsrooms, very heated in the studio discussions as well as to people i spoke to on the street who said, you know, he may be the president of the united states but we are expecting a little more from him here. [ technician ] are you busy? management just sent over these new technical manuals. they need you to translate them into portuguese. by tomorrow. [ male announcer ] ducati knows it's better for xerox to manage their global publications. so they can focus on building amazing bikes. with xerox, you're ready for real business. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 are still talking about retirement tdd# 1-800-345-2550 like it's some kind of dream. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 it's either this magic number i'm supposed to reach, or... tdd# 1-800-345-2550 it's beach homes or it's starting a vineyard. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 come on! tdd# 1-800-345-2550 just help me figure it out in a practical, tdd# 1-800-345-2550 let's-make-this-happen kind of way. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 a vineyard? give me a break.
10:33 am
10:34 am
but there's one that's so clever, it makes your skin look better even after you take it off. neutrogena healthy skin liquid makeup. 98% of women saw improvement in their skin's natural texture, tone, or clarity. does your makeup do that? neutrogena® cosmetics recommended most by dermatologists. ♪ but i really love my bank ♪ i hate-- didn't quite catch that last bit. i said i really love my bank. right... is there a problem ? it's not really raging, man.
10:35 am
uh, we were hoping for more raging ? well, you said write from the heart. yeah... don't do that. at ally, you'll love our online savings account. named the best of 2010 by money magazine. ally. do you love your bank ? president obama has spent the last week in asia. it's an important trip to the emerging center of global economics and politics. where once the crucial summits and global affairs were held in europe or between washington and moscow, now they're all in asia. the debates within asia between the u.s. and china on currency, between china and japan on the senkaku islands, and increasingly between china and the rest of asia will spill over and affect the whole world. we wanted to take the pulse of the nations that mr. obama visited. so we brought together a key observer from each of the president's destinations.
10:36 am
the deputy foreign editor and a prime-time anchor for cnn ibm in delhi. victor cha is the korea chair for the center for international and strategic studies and a professor at georgetown university. jason is based in jakarta, indonesia, for "time" magazine. and the washington-based editor at large at one of japan's largest daily newspapers. so, hosni, let me start with you, because obama began with india. there were great expectations. obama in a sense had an almost unmanageable task. he was following the president who had given india everything it had wanted. it had ended what was called the nuclear apartheid of india by bringing india effectively into the nuclear club. was obama able to deliver? >> i think, fareed, what
10:37 am
president obama was able to do was to keep the expectations really low before he landed in india. he gave an interview, in fact, to a news agency where he really said everything that he had wanted, whether it was sort of support at the u.n. security council for a permanent seat, whether it was the lifting of curbs on entities for high-tech exports. he said everything was very complicated. those were the words he used. and those were what he delivered on by the end of his visit in new delhi. and as a result, as a result of keeping those expectations low and then delivering high, i think he was able to go away with a very, very strong impact made in those three days, also going away with a real feel-good factor. >> did people react very strongly to obama's decision to publicly for the first time have the united states support
10:38 am
india's request to be a part of the u.n. security council? >> that report on the security council was certainly hitting on the right notes, but remember it came at the end of his trip and there was a lot of public disappointment. why is he not pushing harder on pakistan? why isn't he talking about terror that comes from pakistan? that's a hot-button issue. that's not going away. it got very heated in the newsrooms and discussions as well as with people on the street who said, well, you know, he may be the president of the united states but we are expecting a lit millitle more fm here. >> jason, the symbolism of his trip to indonesia couldn't be matched. i mean, there's no other country where he'll ever be able to have that kind of connection. he spent four years there. the reports we get are that it was a huge success. did it feel like that on the ground? >> oh, completely. i mean, it was definitely a home run. the welcome he got here was quite surprising. i was impressed myself because
10:39 am
you didn't see too many demonstrations on the streets. there were groups that were intent on causing disturbances but they were pretty small. the minute he touched down it was almost like a rock star arriving to play a huge gig in town. i think just the fact of him arriving after having canceled three times before was just enough. that in itself was a victory for the president. after that, it was all good. he won over everybody, even certain ministers who probably have mixed feelings about the indonesians' relationship with the u.s. were falling over themselves to greet the president and the first lady. it was amazing. but overall the fact that so many groups and muslim students primarily who went to see him speak at his big speech at the university of indonesia were thrilled to see him, there was, you know, a type of excitement that you would only see maybe if u2 came over here.
10:40 am
and it's increasing everyone's awareness of the potential of america. >> okay. we will be right back with our guests from all four countries that president obama just visited. we're going to do south korea, japan, but we're also going to talk about how the rise of china may have rattled all four of these asian countries. ice 1) we've detected an anomaly... (voice 2) how bad is it? (voice 1) traffic's off the chart... (voice 2) they're pinging more targets... (voice 3) isolate... prevent damage... (voice 2) got 'em. (voice 3) great exercise guys. let's run it again.
10:41 am
of some of the annoying symptoms menopause brings. go introducing one a day menopause formula. the only complete multivitamin with soy isoflavones to help address hot flashes and mild mood changes. new one a day menopause formula. down the hill? man: all right. we were actually thinking, maybe... we're going to hike up here, so we'll catch up with you guys.
10:42 am
10:43 am
10:44 am
pacific economic conference. myanm myanmar's newly freed democracy activist aung san suu kyi addressed supporters today. the nobel peace prize winner said she is for national reconciliation and the rule of law. myanmar freed her after a years of house arrest yesterday. israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu met with cabinet members today about the u.s. proposal to free settlement construction in the west bank for 90 days. the proposal could be a difficult sell for conservative members of israel's coalition government. those are your top stories. up next, much more "fareed zakaria: gps," then "reliable sources at the top of the hour. copd makes it hard for me to breathe.
10:45 am
but with advair, i'm breathing better. so now, i can join the fun and games with my grandchildren. great news! for people with copd, including chronic bronchitis, emphysema, or both, advair helps significantly improve lung function. while nothing can reverse copd, advair is different from most other copd medications because it contains both an anti-inflammatory and a long-acting bronchodilator, working together to help you breathe better. advair won't replace fast-acting inhalers for sudden symptoms and should not be used more than twice a day. people with copd taking advair may have a higher chance of pneumonia. advair may increase your risk of osteoporosis and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking advair. i had fun today, grandpa. you and me both. if copd is still making it hard to breathe, ask your doctor if including advair
10:46 am
will help improve your lung function for better breathing. get your first full prescription free and save on refills. what's the big news in priority mail flat rate boxes and envelopes from the postal service? over a billion used. with envelopes starting at just $4.90, flat rate shipping is the hassle-free way to ship. pass it on. with flat rate boxes, there's no need to weigh anything up to 70 pounds. if it fits, it ships. you ship all different sizes? distributor caps to brake shoes.
10:47 am
so 4 box sizes come in handy. if it fits, it ships. documents to different states? coast to coast. with flat rate envelopes, i ship anywhere in the country international too, for a low flat rate. now, we'd like to pass on this offer to you. call or go online to order your free flat rate shipping kit. you get free boxes, envelopes and our helpful shipping guide. i'll even deliver them to your door for free. it's an offer too good to pass up. call or go online now to order your free priority mail flat rate shipping kit, only from the postal service. a simpler way to ship.
10:48 am
and we are back with suhasini haida in new delhi, victor cha in washington, jason tedjasukmana in jakarta, and yoesh hee is a coe moret in washington. victor, let me ask you about south korea. i was there two weeks ago and i noticed that for the first time i could not find a south korean politician who was anti-american. the left in south korea, as you well know, has tended to be quite anti-american for historical reasons, you know, dissidents against a right-wing dictatorship that the united states supported. no more. there is a rising sense that china is -- you know, that china is rising in asia and that it's very important that south korea stay connected to america. that was my impression, you know, on the basis of a very brief trip. tell me whether you agree, disagree. what's going on? >> i think that on the one hand
10:49 am
koreans know they have a big neighbor in china that they need to live with. on the other hand, they understand in terms of political values they're connected with the united states. in terms of the alliance they're connected with the united states. and also in terps of the friendship that was -- that has been developed between the two presidents, president lee and president obama, it's something special in the history of the u.s./korea relationship. we haven't seen this sort of personal chemistry between the two leaders. these things have really sort of changed the political discussion about the united states in korea. in addition to this, there was a very specific incident that took place, the sinking of a south korean naval vessel by a north korean submarine last march, in which the chinese from a south korean perspective behaved in a way that was way too one-sided, way too supportive of the north koreans rather than the south koreans. and for this reason i think there's also been a change in the spectrum in terms of the way south koreans, both conservative and progressive, view china.
10:50 am
>> komare sandi, the big incident, of course that has taken place in the seas in asia recently was the conflict over the senkaku islands. very briefly, a chinese trawler went fishing in waters that are disputed. it appears that the chinese boat may have rammed into a japanese coast guard vessel. the captain was arrested. from that spiraled a diplomatic incident in which the chinese were very tough and seemed to have startled the entire japanese establishment. is it your sense that japan is rethinking its basic security policy in asia now? >> i think it's really fair and accurate to say that japan started rethinking its own foreign policy, in the wake of
10:51 am
the incident at senkaku islands. it was released by the leak of videotape that was clearly taken by some members of the japanese coast guard on board, showing that -- showing the actual scene, the chinese fishing boat, coming straight ahead into the direction of the japanese coast guard ship and ramming it twice. it's a number-one news for the past two, three days, overshadowing the upcoming the visit of this president obama and opening of the epic meeting which will be held in yokohama city in tokyo. so to answer your question, yes, japanese public is very uneasy, upset about what they see as an unreasonable chinese behavior, and the japanese resulting in the government's rethinking of its own stand towards china. >> so suhasini, how did the
10:52 am
senkaku islands business play in india? did obama's trip play out in any sense as an insurance policy against a rising china? >> there's no question that china was the elephant in the room when the presidents spoke to each other. the two of them significantly came out amongst other agreements a decision to continue a consult tative process on the nichive in east asia, that the two countries would continue to meet on east asia affairs. that is something certainly directed in a sense at china. the two countries also coming together on projects like africa. obviously another way of countering chinese influence. >> victor, sum this all up for us. you are a student of strategy, a student of geopolitics. you were george bush's adviser in the white house on east asian affairs, particularly korean affairs. how is this going to play out? you have this new dynamic where asian countries are concerned about china, and yet china is
10:53 am
the biggest economy in the region. how will they play the united states and china simultaneously? >> well, a couple of things, fareed. i think in terms of the united states, as many of the commentators said, these trips are trips in which there's a lot of optics and there's a lot of messaging that takes place. but in the end every country wants a deliverable. and if the united states does not provide the deliverables, there will be continued concerns about how present the united states will remain in asia as a major power. but i think the broader message here for the region is, you know, there is constant concern that the united states always at some point will disengage from asia, but if it's domestic issues, because of two wars that are taking place in other parts of the world, the united states is as a security partner is always present. but as you know, being a great power is not just about one thing that a great power can do. it's about security, but it's also about economics and it's about providing collective
10:54 am
goods. and right now i think there's some concern as a result of this trip, although i think it was a great trip in terms of optics, i think there's some concern about whether the united states is still going to play in asia. >> and whether it has the capacity and the domestic constituency to fulfill the role that increasingly asian countries are looking to it to fulfill. we're going to have to close on that. thank you very much. suhasini haida in new delhi, victor cha, jason tedjasukmana, and yoshihisa komori. back in a moment. [ female announcer ] there's a new way to let go
10:55 am
of some of the annoying symptoms menopause brings. introducing one a day menopause formula. the only complete multivitamin with soy isoflavones to help address hot flashes and mild mood changes. new one a day menopause formula. hi. wwhere we build eachit all stof our customers a better banking experience. hey, let's talk small business. there is some very sophisticated stuff in here. we have everything from business checking, to loans for expansion. there's even a regions cashcor analysis. but one of the best things is the personalized advice you'll get from a regions business expert. hey, mary. hi, mike. thanks. she really understands business. is your small business ready for something better? switch to regions.
10:58 am
and our "gps" challenge question this week is -- how many nations are members of the g-20? -- captions by vitac -- www.vitac.com >> stay tuned. we'll tell you the correct answer. go to cnn.com gps for ten more challenging questions. while you're there, don't forget to check out our podcast. you can sub can you describe to it at itunes. you'll never miss a show and it is free. our book of the week is "super power," the amazing race between china's hare and india's tortoise. he's written a fascinating study of the rising asian giants. what has the potential to bring each of them to greatness, what could hold each of them back from reaching that potential. it's a fascinating look by an
10:59 am
asian. most of what we read about asia tends to be written by westerners, but this was written within asia. now a last look at the president's trip. he went to indonesia, his childhood home, where he hadn't set foot in 20 years. he reminisced in a press conference. >> when i first came here it was in 1967, and people were on bicycle rickshaw things. and, you know, now as president i can't even see any traffic because they block off all the streets. >> mr. obama, don't get nostalgic about traffic. here's president obama zooming through the cleared streets of jakarta this week, and here's what everyday traffic looks like if you're not the president. it's been said that jakarta has the worse traffic in asia, and on a continent that had an 11-day traffic jam earlier this year, that is
180 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CNN Television Archive TV News Test Collection Television Archive News Search Service The Chin Grimes TV News ArchiveUploaded by TV Archive on