cuts. i'm dying to hear how our economy is better today than it was two years ago, how it's better policy today right before this election, given the 42 months of 8% unemployment, 316,000 people have left the job force since the stimulus passed. this is all politics. this is not economics. it's all politics. good for governor romney not buying into this construct. >> well, it is true that since that time when the president agreed to go ahead and let all of the tax cuts stay in place that we have had many, many months of job creation. not enough job creation, the president would say, but nonetheless, the recession has ended. >> no. >> and we're now looking at a huge debt, as you know. >> so the democratic party said our economy is in good shape enough to raise taxes on job creators? there is -- everything is worse since he's taken office. the debt has gone up by 49%. the unemployment rate's gone up by over 6%. gas prices are 50% higher.

your home values have gone down. the stimulus promised a 6% unemployment, now it's at 8.3%. none of its policies are working. obamacare, you are not supposed to lose your health care. millions of people are losing their health care because it costs too much. premiums were supposed to go down. they're going up. so the idea that now the economy is better than two years ago when president obama said don't raise taxes, it would be bad for the economy, is all politics. it's not based on economics. >> so just quickly, yes or no. if the democrats stay where they are, and if the president stays where he is, would you be willing to say, fine, if we can't reach a deal, taxes go up on everyone? >> i'm willing to do the bowles-simpson plan. not one person who's looked at this in a bipartisan way said you need to raise tax rates. bowles-simpson says let's flatten the tax code, take the money to pay down rates. pay off the debt. >> that's sort of a long-term thing? these cuts are going to expire

on the 31st. >> i'm not going to do a short-term thing that's stupid. it would be stupid in an economy this weak to raise tax rates on a million small businesses at a time they can't hire people. now, if you are looking for a job, this election's not about romney's tax returns, it's about your tax returns. look how many millions of people are underemployed or have lost their jobs. the last thing i'm going to do is play politics with their future. what we should all be doing is fixing sequestration in a bipartisan manner. both candidates should pledge if i get to be president of the united states, we're going to do bowles-simpson. that's what america is yearning for, and i want both candidates to step up to the plate and lead and stop this political stuff. >> and neither one of them has, to your satisfaction at this point. >> i think governor romney has said he would embrace bowles-simpson. and the fact he rejected raising taxes is a good sign of leadership. what president obama is doing is 180 degrees out what he did two years ago when they had large democratic majorities. >> let me talk to you about sequestration which basically is

that come the end of this year, automatic tax cut -- i'm sorry, automatic spending cuts will get into place that will cut over ten years more than a trillion dollars out of the economy. >> right. >> you have raised the red flag about that. you have been talking with some democrats. can you tell me if there's any hope out of the group you're talking with that you can keep this from happening? because everyone sort of thinks this would be disastrous, these across-the-boards cuts. >> here's what secretary panetta said. the failing for -- the super committee's failure is to take $600 billion out of the defense budget on top of the 487 we're already cutting. it also hurts special education. it hurts a lot of the nondefense programs like the national cancer institute. here's what it would be for the defense department. the smallest navy since 1914. you'd go from 285 ships to 232, the smallest army since 1940, the smallest air force in history. we're working with carl levin and some other democrats to find a way to avoid this for four months from january to may using

the bowles-simpson formula. no one's talking -- >> bowles-simpson, for those who don't know, was a deficit reduction plan. >> exactly. it rejects raising tax rates. we'd go into the tax code and generate revenue, taking welling deductions away from welling captains, suspend the corporate jet deduction for a time so we could buy fighter jets. we'd have other cuts in the budget, mandatory spending cuts, a balanced approach to offset sequestration for four months. here's what sequestration -- >> are there enough -- can i just ask you, are there enough of those loophole -- whatever you want to call them -- these tax increases or these tax loopholes that you want to -- >> special deals. >> special deals for people, are there enough of those to balance out the cuts that would have to take place to bring democrats on board? >> in four months, there are plenty of them. there's $1.2 trillion a year we give away in deductions and exemptions, but here's the bottom line. the construct of sequestration

is if politicians fail to do their job in the super committee, the plan was to destroy the military. we got this wrong. we should fire the politicians, keep the soldiers. so i believe the american people are going to be outraged when they hear what comes the military's way because we couldn't get our act together in cutting $1.2 trillion over a decade. >> our talking about a four-month deal. >> mm-hmm. >> do you have any reason to believe that the white house would be on board with it? i know you've talked to the vice president recently. >> if they watch cnn, and i'm sure they do, join us, send a representative from the president's office to engage the senators who are trying to find a way forward. i'm willing to put revenue on the table but not by raising tax rates. carl levin is willing to cut mandatory spending in a responsible way to buy us four months. i cannot tell you how important it is for our economy if we let sequestration go forward, we destroy the military. 1.1 million jobs lost in the

defense industrial complex on the civilian side. 4% gdp affected if sequestration goes forward. we do dumb things in congress, this sequestration idea was the dumbest thing. >> what is the totality of tax on the revenue side that you think you could get to get this four-month deal? >> i think in four months you need $22 billion, break it up in three buckets, one-third from revenue, no tax increases, close loopho loopholes, one-third spending cuts. one-third mandatory. get it done. mr. president, we need your help. you're the commander in chief. your secretary of defense has said this is a navy without ships, a brigade without bullets, an air force without trained pilots. don't send a signal to iran and syria and the rest of the world that we're going to disarm. don't use the tax cuts. here's what omb director zai said, republicans won't ask the 2% to give their fair share. this idea of holding the defense department hostage to the tax

debate makes me sick to my stomach. knock it off. find a way to avoid sequestration. let the next congress and the new president fix this, give them a little breathing room. >> i need a two-word answer from you, and that is what vice presidential pick would best help mitt romney? >> you know, i think pawlenty and -- pawlenty and portman are in the hunt. one last thing, you didn't ask me about harry reid. i've been around this town for a while. i actually like harry, but what he did on the floor of the senate is so out of bounds. i think he's lying about his statement, knowing something about romney. this is what's wrong with america. >> that's pretty stiff. you think the leader of the senate is lying if >> i really do. i think he's created an issue here. i think he's making things up at a time when the country is just about to fall apart. cybersecurity, there's a bipartisan desire to do this. there's plenty of blame to go around. but candy, we're running out of time as a nation. let's start talking about the real issues that matter to real

people. and i just can't let that pass. i just cannot believe that the majority leader of the united states senate would take the floor twice, make accusations that are absolutely unfounded, in my view, and quite frankly, making things up to divert the campaign away from the real issues. >> senator lindsey graham, i wish we had more time. we've got to run. thank you so much. mitt romney says president obama's jobs plan is all wrong. >> the idea of doing the same thing again and expecting a different result is famously said the definition of insanity. >> more of the interview with mitt romney. and later, we'll get reaction from obama campaign senior adviser robert gibbs. [ male announcer ] this... is the at&t network.

a living, breathing intelligence teaching data how to do more for business. [ beeping ] in here, data knows what to do. because the network finds it and tailors it across all the right points, automating all the right actions, to bring all the right results. [ whirring and beeping ] it's the at&t network -- doing more with data to help business do more for customers. ♪

to help business do more for customers. by what's getting done. measure commitment the twenty billion dollars bp committed has helped fund economic and environmental recovery. long-term, bp's made a five hundred million dollar commitment to support scientists studying the environment. and the gulf is open for business - the beaches are beautiful, the seafood is delicious. last year, many areas even reported record tourism seasons. the progress continues... but that doesn't mean our job is done. we're still committed to seeing this through. this is the first leg of our world challenge with the cadillac ats. this is actually starting to feel real now. [ ross ] this is the perfect place to test the ats's advanced aerodynamics. [ derek ] we've got crosswinds, tailwinds, headwinds. aerodynamics is all about keeping the car planted on the road. you are going to get hit by stuff, so don't freak out. [ screaming with excitement ] and move out now. ♪

[ male announcer ] the all-new cadillac ats. ♪

more now of our gloria borger's interview with mitt romney, the republican presidential candidate was asked if his promise to create 12 million jobs in his first term, if elected, is realistic. >> i can absolutely make the case that now is the time for something dramatic, and it is not the time to grow government. it's the time to create the incentives and the opportunities for entrepreneurs and businesses big and small to hire more people. and that's going to happen. you're going to see that happen in this country, but not under this president. his answer is always, can't we

grow government some more? and the problem with growing government, among other things, is that it stays long after these little stimulus years, and people have to be paid, and the retirement benefits, and it becomes a burden on the real job creatorshich are small businesses in this country. the burdens on small business in america are crushing small business. we're at a 30-year low in business start-ups in this country. we need to get people back into business, starting various employers and putting people to work. >> so you say that you're going to add 12 million jobs. >> yeah. >> in your first four years. why should voters think that that's realistic? i mean, that's 250,000 jobs a month. >> yeah. >> that's a lot of jobs. >> that's what happens in a normal process, when you come out of a kind of recession we've had, you should see this kind of job creation. we should be seeing 2,000, 3,000, 4,000 jobs per month to regain much of what's been lost. that's what normally happens after a recession. but under this president, we

have not seen that kind of pattern. we've been just sort of bumping along with barely enough jobs just to hold the unemployment rate about the same, above 8%. 42 months like that. the idea of just giving more money to government will not get our economy going. you have to have the steve jo jobses of the world, beginning businesses, making products that want to be purchased around the world. that gets americans back to work. it allows us to create more jobs. more jobs creates demand for workers. that raises wages. good things happen when you have a private sector that's thriving. >> well, polls show that a majority of the public believes right now that you not -- that you should not allow for the extension of the tax cuts for the wealthy. and today's "wall street journal" said that not extending the tax cuts for the wealthy would be reckless in this economy. that -- and they say that the economy is in a desperate state. so therefore you cannot take away the tax cuts for people at the top end of the scale.

do you agree with the characterization that it would be reckless to remove those tax cuts? >> the great majority of small businesses pay taxes at the individual rate. so if he raises taxes on the wealthy, he's raising taxes on small business. that kills jobs. if your priority in this country is to punish success, vote for president obama. if your priority is to create more success and more jobs, vote for me. look, i know the very wealthy are going to do just fine, whosever elected. the middle class is the people i'm most concerned about, and the poor. they need our help. they need our help with good jobs. that's going to only come if we encourage this economy by keeping the burdens on small business down. >> well, but the president said if the republicans in congress had gone along and passed his

jobs bill, that there would be more jobs in the pipeline right now than there are. how do you respond to that? >> well, the republicans in congress watched the democrats in congress four years ago pass the president's jobs bill, his stimulus bill. $787 billion of new borrowing. and they saw the results. they were told unemployment would stay below 8%. it's not been below 8% since. his approach of just spending money on government programs did not create the jobs that america was looking for. so the idea of doing the same thing again and expecting a different result is famously said the definition of insanity. >> should the fed intervene at some point? >> well, i think the fed's first action in quantitative easing was effective to a certain degree. but i believe that the qe2, the second round of easing, i don't

think it had the impact they were hoping for, and i'm sure the fed is watching, will try and encourage the economy, but i don't think a massive new qe3 is going to help this economy. i've laid out what my course is. there are five things you have to do to get this economy going, take advantage of our energy resources, fix our schools and training programs, make sure we open up trade and crack down on china when they cheat. number four, finally get ourselves on track of a balanced budget. and finally, champion small business. we've got to help small business. keep their taxes competitive. get regulators to encourage them. keep health care costs from driving them out of business. >> okay, governor, i know you're not going to tell me who your running mate is, but can you tell me if you've decided or not? >> i have nothing on the vice presidential front. >> nothing? >> i can give you nothing. but i can assure you by the third day of the republican convention we will nominate a republican vp. >> senate majority leader harry

reid's barrage at mitt romney. >> the word's out that he hasn't paid any taxes for ten years. >> team romney says the obama team is behind the attack. obama senior adviser robert gibbs is here when we come back. s with more pain. more pills. triple checking hydraulics. the evening brings more pain. so, back to more pills. almost done, when... hang on. stan's doctor recommended aleve. it can keep pain away all day with fewer pills than tylenol. this is rudy. who switched to aleve. and two pills for a day free of pain. ♪ and get the all day pain relief of aleve in liquid gels. ♪ energy is being produced to power our lives. while energy development comes with some risk, north america's natural gas producers are committed to safely and responsibly providing generations of cleaner-burning energy for our country, drilling thousands of feet below fresh water sources within self-contained well systems. and, using state-of-the-art monitoring technologies,

rigorous practices help ensure our operations are safe and clean for our communities and the environment. we're america's natural gas.

joining me now, robert gibbs. robert, thanks for being here. let us start out with harry reid. you heard senator lindsey graham saying he thinks reid is lying, that he is making this up when he gets on the senate floor and senator reid says, i've been told that mitt romney has not paid taxes for ten years. i spoke to a democrat yesterday who's in touch with the re-elect -- obama re-elect in chicago who said if chicago wanted reid to stop, he would stop, but chicago doesn't want him. are you just as happy to have him out here saying these things? >> look. i think it's important that we know the financial backgrounds of candidates. you saw lindsey graham i think appropriately talk about the role that tax loopholes play in our tax code and how much it costs average taxpayers. we're going to have a pretty big debate about tax reform in the next coming months, and we have to know what's in people's tax returns and what they're getting the benefit for. candy, if mitt romney -- >> mitt romney didn't make the loopholes, and no one's saying he did anything wrong.

>> well, we don't know that, candy. >> we don't know it, but let's go back to just the question first, which is -- >> sure. >> -- do you think harry reid -- >> we do know the one tax return that he did put out, we found out ed a swiss bank account that wasn't on his financial disclosure. we know he's used not releasing his tax returns to hide where his money is, but let's be honest, candy. >> but it wasn't illegal. he wasn't hiding it. he put it out this time. >> again, after the tax return came out, he updated his financial disclosure to let the world know he had a bank account in switzerland. >> you know where i'm going with this because you all want to couch it as he's hiding something, he probably cheated on his taxes. you paid too many taxes. but you have the leader of the democratic party in the senate saying that mitt romney didn't pay any taxes. why do you have romney saying yes, i did? >> it's a time-honored tradition that candidates release thish tax returns, right? and the standard was set by mitt romney's own father who said don't put out one or two years

because those could end up being an anomaly, and he put out i think 12 years. but mitt romney gave john mccain 23 years of tax returns in order to be the tryout for vice president where john mccain picked sarah palin. if 23 years is good enough to show john mccain so mitt romney can be vice president of the united states, how come only two years is appropriate for voters when you want to be the president of the united states? candy, we could put all this stuff to rest tomorrow. mitt romney can go to kinko's, photocopy his tax returns. there's several hundred pages. he could hand them out to people like cnn, to reporters all over the country. and you know what? we wouldn't talk about this tomorrow. we wouldn't say, is he paying taxes? what's he paying? the whole world would know exactly what loopholes he's taking advantage of. >> to the propryty of the leader of the democrats in the senate accusing, based on a source, the republican -- presumed republican nominee of not paying

any taxes for ten years, is that something that chicago has encouraged? do you want him to stop? >> look, let's be clear. i don't think anybody controls harry reid. >> but if you asked him to stop, he would. >> again, put the tax returns out. put this whole thing to rest. candy, have you ever seen anybody go to such great lengths to not put something out? and when you generally don't put something out, isn't it because you're generally hiding something? >> he may think it's private, but mitt romney doing his tax cuts at kinko's is sort of throwing me -- >> i'll send him the nickels. i think it's a nickel a page. >> you will not tell harry reid to stop. >> i will tell mitt romney if he wants all this debate to go away -- and let's be clear, reid isn't the one who's made this debate. romney has brought this to the floor. this has been something that has been talked about well back into the republican primaries. we did an interview on the foreign trip where abc said, have you paid -- what's the tax

rate? have you paid a lower tax rate than what you released? you know what romney's answer was? i'll go back and check. candy, he's not at kinko's making photocopies. he doesn't have any intention of checking. he's gone through -- i've never seen anybody jump through more hoops to say "a," that somebody's lying but also not put out a document that would prove what the real truth is. >> so chicago's not going to tell harry reid to stop. let me take you back four years ago. barack obama, running for president at a rally in leesburg, virginia. >> any time you want to bring about change, it's not enough just to change political parties in the white house. we've got to change how business is done in washington. >> has he changed how business is done in washington? >> i think he has. i think it's been very difficult. i think the interest in this town are decidedly entrenched. it is hard to get special interests to give up their tax breaks.

it is hard to get millionaires and billionaires to get rid of their tax breaks. mitt romney did have one thing right in that interview. he said if he was president, the rich would do just fine. i can assure you that the rich are going to do just fine. the problem is in order to give the rich a tax cut, he's going to raise taxes on the middle class. that's not me saying that, that's the tax policy center saying that just this week. i think this debate is about whether or not we're going to have an economy that is tilted towards special rules and special tax cuts for the wealthy or whether we're going to invest in and support middle-class families. >> do you think president obama has changed the tone of washington? remember he was going to be a different kind of politician. hillary clinton was old style. he was going to come in. he was going to get consensus. he has not gotten consensus. >> well, he's not gotten consensus because it's hard to get consensus when the other side of the aisle has no desire to build consensus. mitch mcconnell famously said that his number one priority as republican leader of the senate was to prevent barack obama from

being a two-term president. that is not exactly engendering the tip of atmosphere that one needs to get political compromise. and your last guest, i probably can't let this pass, i mean, you have a pretty broad discussion about raising taxes on millionaires. and yet bemoaning possible cuts that could have been avoided had we made some tough decisions to the military. let's do this, candy. let's preserve the size of the navy and the air force by giving up tax cuts for millionaires and billionaires. >> in the end, more democrats voted actually for sequestration than republicans did. but i want to move you on to something else the president said during the campaign. again, this was the one from leesburg, virginia, where he was asking that age-old question, are you better off? >> wages are lower than they've been in a decade. at a time when the cost of health care and college have never been higher. it's getting harder and harder to make the mortgage or fill up your gas tank or even keep the

electricity on at the end of the month. and at this rate, the question isn't are you better off than you were four years ago, it's are you better off than you were four weeks ago? >> okay. so we are now at a place where the economy is creating jobs, which he also talked about there. >> a place we've been for 29 months. >> right. >> 4.5 million new jobs, yes. >> but wages are lower than they were when he took office. the cost of health care is higher. the cost of college is higher. we know what's happened to the housing market. the question is why should americans look at this and say to themselves, am i better off than i was four years ago since all of those mile markers that he put up there have gone south? >> well, let's be clear, candy. the president has taken dramatic steps that will help lower our health care costs. the president has a countless number of times passed legislation and ideas to reduce the burden that students have and middle-class families have to borrow money to go to college. >> still up. >> well, i think -- i'm happy

for you to interview some college presidents and universities and ask why we keep raising tuition tax rates. but i think the most important thing is, there's no doubt we are better off than we were four years ago. are we where we need to be? absolutely not. nobody believes that. we have worked hard to move this economy forward. and we can't go backwards and try the ideas that mitt romney wants, which is more tax cuts for rich people and what wall street write its own rules. >> obama senior adviser for the campaign, robert gibbs, thanks. up next, spinning the latest job numbers. plus, has president obama been bad for business? butter or rich dark chocolate flavor. 90 calories. 100% natural. and nature...approves. granola thins. from nature valley. nature at its most delicious. ♪

( whirring and crackling sounds ) man: assembly lines that fix themselves. the most innovative companies are doing things they never could before, by building on the cisco intelligent network. throughout our lives. one a day women's 50+ is a complete multivitamin designed for women's health concerns as we age. it has more of 7 antioxidants to support cell health. one a day 50+. to support cell health. those little things for you, life's about her. but your erectile dysfunction - that could be a question of blood flow. cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be ready anytime the moment's right. you can be more confident in your ability to be ready. and the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently or urgently. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medications,

and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sexual activity. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or if you have any allergic reactions such as rash, hives, swelling of the lips, tongue or throat, or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a 30-tablet free trial. [ feedback ] attention, well, everyone. you can now try snapshot from progressive free for 30 days. just plug this into your car, and your good driving can save you up to 30%. you could even try it without switching your insurance. why not give it a shot? carry on.

now you can test-drive snapshot before you switch. visit progressive.com today. the july jobs report was described variously as mixed, muddled or confusing, which means it was perfect on the campaign trail where both sides found something to be clear about. the labor department reported that employers added 163,000 jobs in july, better than expected, better than last month, yippee at the white house. >> we've now created 4.5 million new jobs over the last 29 months. and 1.1 million new jobs so far this year. >> with a group described as middle-income americans behind him, the president said the newly created jobs are not enough but are good enough to keep going. he didn't say the names bush or

romney, but did he need to? >> we're not going to get to where we need to be if we go back to the policies that helped to create this mess in the first place. >> the republican universe fixated on a different figure from the labor department, 195,000 households reported losing a job last month. as a result, unemployment rose to 8.3%. it was, as mitt romney would point out, the 42nd straight month of unemployment over 8%, a hammer blow, he said, to the struggling middle class. >> look, the president does not understand how the private sector works. he does not understand how small business works. >> romney believes the president's policies have crippled small business employers and made them reluctant to hire. and a recent gallup poll shows just 35% of business owners approve of president obama. up next, who's better for business with b.e.t. founder bob johnson and former hewlett-packard ceo carly fiorina.

what's she up to? [ female announcer ] root touch-up by nice'n easy has the most shade choices, designed to match even salon color in just 10 minutes. with root touch-up, all they see is you.

joining me is b.e.t. founder bob johnson and former hewlett-packard ceo carly fiorina. i want to put up a rendition of this business owners poll. in the first quarter, 41% of business owners approved of president obama, and it fell to 35%. explain to me why that is. >> well, i think the business community is looking for not just what happened in the past and how those problems came to be, the economy in a free-fall and president obama comes in focusing on creating jobs, focusing on ending two wars, focusing on reforming health care, controlling costs and putting some 30 million people

on the health care payrolls. i think they now want to see what his future vision is for the country if he's to be re-elected. >> has he laid that out, do you think? >> well, i think he is beginning to lay out the framework for that, and i would encourage him to do more. i think there is an argument that the business community would like to see the president talk more about simpson-bowles as a sort of a blueprint for where he might go with the economy in the next election. i think the business community is not so much concerned about taxes as they are about a tax reform, progressive tax system. they'll accept that. but also entitlement reforms and a focus on reducing the growing deficit and serving that part of the fiscal problem. >> carly, republicans say, and you are one and are helping to pry to elect a republican senate, among other things, have said this is about uncertainty. businesses are sitting on so

much cash that they don't want to hire because they don't know what's going to happen with health care, and they don't know what's going to happen with regulation. isn't that sort of the price of doing business? isn't business with the government always a bit of a risk? >> actually, no. i think there is more uncertainty right now than there has been in a very long time. and i think that is a big reason you see a lot of businesses sitting on cash. but i think the real question to ask about the economy really focuses on small business because small business has created the net new jobs in this country over the last 40 years. we now have fewer small businesses starting, more failing than at any time in the last 40 years. and that's because if you talk to small business owners, they will talk to you about uncertainty, although now that the health care law has come into more focus, most small business owners are saying this is bad for me. they listen to discussion about tax policy, and they say gee, i don't see my taxes going down. i see them probably going up. they look at the regulatory

thicket that they are trying to get through. all of that puts a depressing blanket of uncertainty on top of them. and then sadly, you have a president of the united states in obama who apparently doesn't understand the critical role that small businesses play in the economy and who says things like you could build your business because there are roads and bridges and teachers. no one denies that roads and bridges and teachers are important to creating an economic climate. but a small business owner creates a business because they're willing to take a risk, a lot of risk. >> do you agree with that summation of what is keeping small businesses and obviously large businesses are sitting on the most money, but small businesses from thriving, hiring more people? >> well, regulation is, assist every as you said, part of a free-market economy where the government has a role in protecting public interest. and i think businesses account for that. i think on the issue of president obama understanding small business, i think he absolutely does. this whole question of you

didn't build it, let somebody else build that, is taken out of context. all the president is saying is someone build a superhighway system, the railroads, and businesses take advantage of that, and good businesses succeed at that, and some businesses don't. and i don't think the president was trying to in any way to demean small businesses who use whatever government infrastructure is there to say you didn't do it. i think he was saying is it's all part of an ecosystem of the government stimulating private sector growth, the government providing the stimulus or the forum for companies to grow. and some of that includes, as carly mentioned, regulatory reform. but i think the fundamental issue, the president does understand small business. you know, i'm in the automobile dealership business. we are the largest minority-owned automobile dealership group in the country. that's a direct result of the president making a determined decision to save the auto manufacturers and creating small business opportunities. >> i want to get you two to halt just for a second. when we come back, more with bob

johnson and carly fiorina. i like to eat a lot of fruits. love them all. the seal i get with the super poligrip free keeps the seeds from getting up underneath. even well-fitting dentures let in food particles. super poligrip is zinc free. with just a few dabs, it's clinically proven to seal out more food particles so you're more comfortable and confident while you eat. a lot of things going on in my life and the last thing i want to be thinking about is my dentures. [ charlie ] try zinc free super poligrip. a living, breathing intelligence helping business, do more business. in here, opportunities are created and protected. gonna need more wool! demand is instantly recognized and securely acted on across the company. around the world. turning a new trend, into a global phenomenon. it's the at&t network -- securing a world of new opportunities. ♪

do you have any idea where you're going ? wherever the wind takes me. this is so off course. nature can surprise you sometimes... next time, you drive. next time, signal your turn. ...that's why we got a subaru. love wherever the road takes you. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 there are atm fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 account service fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 and the most dreaded fees of all, hidden fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 at charles schwab, you won't pay fees on top of fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 no monthly account service fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 no hidden fees. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 and we rebate every atm fee. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 so talk to chuck tdd# 1-800-345-2550 because when it comes to talking, there is no fee.

this is cnn breaking news. >> we are getting word of a shooting at a sikh temple in oak creek, wisconsin, that is just outside of milwaukee. there are reportedly multiple victims. we can tell you, as you look at where exactly we are talking about, that a nursing supervisor at a milwaukee area hospital says they have been told to expect 8 to 20 victims. no word yet on severity of any injuries. cnn, of course, is following the situation, and we will update you more as we get more details. you more as we get more details. stay tuned. jia down by what's getting done. the twenty billion dollars bp committed has helped fund economic and environmental recovery. long-term, bp's made a five hundred million dollar commitment to support scientists studying the environment. and the gulf is open for business - the beaches are beautiful, the seafood is delicious.

last year, many areas even reported record tourism seasons. the progress continues... but that doesn't mean our job is done. we're still committed to seeing this through.

we are back with former hewlett-packard ceo carly f fiorina and b.e.t. founder bob johnson. about a year ago, you were talking about president obama because i want to ask you on the other side about these looming tax breaks. and here's what you told fox news. "the president has to recalibrate his message.

you don't get people to like you by attacking them or demeaning their success. i've earned my success. i've earned my right to fly private if i choose to do so. it doesn't mean that i am a bad guy." do you think the president has recalibrated his message sufficiently enough for business? >> yeah, i think so. i think the business community is prepared to give the president a second chance for -- at re-election. on the basis of that the president focusing more on what he's going to do in the future. he's established his credentials in the past, the job growth, you know, halting the country in a tailsp tailspin, health care and all the things he's done in the war on terrorism. so he's established those credentials. what he needs to do now is talk about the future. and i think what the business community is saying, mr. president, talk about the future based on tax reform, based on restraint and entitlement growth, paying down the debt,

and focusing on creating the environment for job growth. and i think the president is going to start delivering that message. >> but has not, to your satisfaction, at this moment. >> well, to my satisfaction, he has. i just don't think the translation has come through in some of the campaign stops. and i think that's where we're getting a little bit of a disconnect that we need to focus on that a little bit more as part of the overall campaign messaging. >> we did an earlier piece about the jobs figures that came out and, you know, the private sector created over 160,000 jobs, which is pretty good. and then unemployment went up. >> right. 190-something people lost jobs. >> right. so describe for me -- i'll ask both of you this -- describe for me what you think the state of the economic recovery is. >> okay. first may i just say that what bob said the president needs to focus on tax reform and regulatory reform and job creation, all that's right. and the president isn't focusing on those things.

what he's focusing on is punitive tax increases for a lot of small business owners. we have structural problems in our economy that are holding back this recovery. the first structural problem we have surrounds entrepreneurship. too many small businesses are failing. not enough small businesses are starting. we have a structural problem in terms of education. we have a structural problem in terms of the regulatory thicket. those things have to be fixed, and we need tax reform. absolutely. >> so do you think the economy is -- the recovery is moving along but slowly? >> i don't. >> what do you think is the state of the economy? >> i think we are bumping along at a very bad place. and by the way, the level of uncertainty is increasing, and now what we are facing, which we were not facing six months ago, is a simultaneous global economic slowdown. europe is in recession. asia is slowing. our economy is losing steam by every measure. that's a bad place to be. >> mr. johnson, you're out there

with a business you very much want to have keep succeeding. what do you think the business environment is? how would you describe the economy, and what does it need? >> i think president obama has sort of laid the foundation for an economic recovery. now, it's going to be slow because there's, as carly mentioned, there are a lot of headwinds against it. obviously some of the european debt crisis, we're beginning to see housing come back slowly, both in new homes and in the price of existing old homes. and we're seeing manufacturing growth. manufacturing growth has been sort of a star in this whole process. and i think the president has laid that foundation. and so i think the business community is waiting on that second message. so that's where i think we need to start pivoting in the campaign. what is that message about what the world will look like after the inauguration? and when the president starts talking about that, against a governor romney who has yet to articulate a real clear specific

platform of how he would do it, the 12 million jobs or so, i think the president now has an opening to lay out a foundation as look what i've done to stem sort of a government that was in sort of free-fall. now this is what i'm going to do when i'm re-elected. >> let me do a 180 in the time i have left, and that is to ask both of you if you were on mitt romney's team, just imagine here just for a moment, who do you think would most help him on the ticket as vice president? >> you know, here's the truth. i think you can make a strong argument, obviously, for a marco rubio or tim pawlenty or a rob portman. each of them brings something wonderful to the ticket. however, having said all that, i think the most important thing about this election is actually not the veep. i think the most important thing about this election is how people view the state of the economy and the fundamentally different approaches to economic recovery that governor romney and the president have. governor romney has laid out a

very specific five-point plan to get the economy going and growing again. >> i've got 15 seconds. if you were advising him, what would make you take a look at the republican ticket? >> nothing would make me look at the republican ticket, particularly when i'm wearing an obama 44 tie. rubio. >> you think that might help him. >> it's the only thing with one constituency that's totally not supportive of. >> like those one-word answers. thank you so much. bob johnson, carly rerenaso lly thank you for being here. of occasional constipation. thanks. [ phillips' lady ] live the regular life. phillips'. do you have any idea where you're going ? wherever the wind takes me. this is so off course.

nature can surprise you sometimes... next time, you drive. next time, signal your turn. ...that's why we got a subaru. love wherever the road takes you. one is for a clean, wedomestic energy future that puts us in control. our abundant natural gas is already saving us money, producing cleaner electricity, putting us to work here in america and supporting wind and solar. though all energy development comes with some risk, we're committed to safely and responsibly producing natural gas. it's not a dream. america's natural gas... putting us in control of our energy future, now.

this is cnn breaking news. >> we want to go back to a story we've been talking to you about. we are following a shooting at a sikh temple in oak creek, wisconsin. that is just outside of milwaukee. basically suburban milwaukee. we are told there are multiple victims. cnn's deborah feyerick and rob marciano will be in atlanta picking up our coverage. here's what we can tell you right now, and that is the site that you are seeing, we have spoken to a nursing supervisor at a nearby hospital who has said that they were told to expect 8 to 20 victims. but at the time we spoke with

that nursing supervisor, which was several minutes ago, they had yet to see anyone come into the hospital. now, we also know from one of our affiliates that they believe multiple people may have been shot outside the sikh temple. again, you are looking at tape taken previously, but today just after word of this possible shooting took place, again, outside a sikh temple in suburban milwaukee, wisconsin. we want to go down to atlanta to pick up our coverage and our rob marciano. >> we'll continue this coverage of the breaking news just south of milwaukee as candy just mentioned, there has been a shooting at a temple in the community called oak creek. up to four people have been shot. police on the scene there. and our affiliate wtmj has been filling us in as to what's going on. the actual shooting itself took place at 10:40 a.m. central time inside the temple. the gunman at this time is still believed to be on the loose and

potentially inside, potentially having hostages as well, according to affiliate wtmj. you are looking at aerials. most of this is taped. we don't want to give away any sort of police positions as this is still a fluid situation that we're covering just south of milwaukee. i want to bring in deb feyerick out of our new york bureau who's been following this developing story. deb, what can you add? >> reporter: what we do know is we know that nursing supervisors at a local hospital, columbia st. mary's hospital, they are on standby. they're waiting for what they believe are victims to arrive. we're hearing as many as 8 to 20 victims, but there's no word on the severity of the injuries. the police department right now not commenting until they see how this all plays out. we do know that there are a number of cruisers in the area. the s.w.a.t. team there as well. they're redirecting traffic away from that sikh temple which is what appears to be a very main highway in oak creek. the sikh temple is on howell

avenue. it's a large facility. it's a relatively new facility built about five years ago. an affiliate of ours, wtmj who's bringing us those aerials said that at least they had seen one person in the parking lot. others crouched behind police cars. but then as we were listening to the feed coming in, the helicopter did pull back. but you can see there are some armed s.w.a.t. team members there on the ground as this all unfolds. traffic stopped in and around the area. they don't know how many injuries there are, if there are any injuries. but right now we're hearing anywhere to between 4 to perhaps as high as 20. again, rob, this happening at about 10:40 this morning. rob? >> so at this point, do we know for sure if it was one person or more than one person actually in the temple performing this dastardly deed, or are we just relying on police reports at this point? >> reporter: yeah, no, it's really not clear. what they're trying to do is piece everything together. we've got the