>> the court is failing to recognize -- to talk about the impact it would have on the economy. two billion pounds costing 24,000 jobs. that's a step we cannot afford to pay. >> back to you mr. speaker, is it the case that the special advisors had a meeting with representative of the europe campaign and if so what did they discuss? >> well, we will, of course, discuss a range of issues that affect the economy and, in fact, it will affect the welsh economy two billion times to the welsh

economy. 24,000 jobs we're seeing some spectacular employment data as we speak. but that is on strong economic foundation and access to 500 million customers across europe. >> given it is unfolded in the u.k. government, what detail guarantees to the secretary of state to the 244 million who actually reach wales? >> i don't necessarily recognize the basis of the question. and honorable lady forget the historic funding floor that is to have chancellor interview to the 1500% with the commitment that government is showing to wales. >> mr. speaker, will secretary of state join me in welcoming the fight that toyota has made it clear that they will continue to manufacture in the united kingdom including their agent in

wales regardless of the fight as to whether british people vote to leave the e.u. on the 23rd of june? >> and mrs. speaker i will recognize the comments that are made by them because they said specifically and i, quote, that british memory of the european union is the best collateral operation and long-term competitiveness and that 150 component industries in the owner of automotive sector that depend on companies like toyota, ford, for repart of the european market. >> order. questions to the prime minister. maria colefield. >> wait a minute. >> duetting ahead had of himself. a process to be followed.

ladies turn. >> thank you very much mr. speaker, prime minister is defending japan i ask on his behalf meetings to addition i'll have further such meetings today. >> maria colefield. >> members would agree would the first priority of government to have the security of our country. that's also the chancellor outlying to me that this government is taking to a place -- [inaudible] >> absolutely right. the duty of government is to defend country an for almost 70 years independent has provided ultimate insurance of our freedoms. we will review our bringing forward votes in our house and from all sides was house to

support this vital commitment to national security and when she stands u indicate that support today. >> aye. >> thank you mr. speaker we look forward to the vote and he should get on with it. mr. speaker, given the open news of the french authority on google, investigating allegations of aggravated financial fraud and money landering just a chance in that regret calling his cozy tax skill with the same company good news for the british. >> well it is good news that we're collecting money and tax from companies that pay no tax

when the labor party was -- >> and seems to forget that she will be a secretary in the large government when she stands up she can tell us whether she has a raise at the time. the tax affairs of google. >> mr. speaker, mr. speaker, mr. speaker, i think, obviously, the chancellor has done a bit more research this time. and regard that as a -- mr. speaker, i think, i think from that answer that the chancellor is far too easily satisfied. and i know, i know mr. speaker that even member laicialed his

cozy deal and the british public think it is worse despite all of the rhetoric on his watch that tax gap has gone up, tax deal with the swiss weighs a fraction of the revenue he boasted and blames lack of resources in rev u revenue and sat 11,000 tax staff since 2010, and when is he going to give them the resources they need to do a proper job? >> well reincreased resources and we introduced a diversity of profit taxes so google can't shift their profits upshore anymore. we've had made sure banks pay a higher tax charge than the labor government.

but she was a treasury minister and stood at the stump. she's asking me while we've done to household tax -- did she ever raise as the executive secretary of google we should notice before she asked questions of this government. >> mr. speaker -- mr. speaker. >> members must calm themselves and remain calm. they should taked order on both sides take the lead and gentleman, the member but always sitting calm in are a statemente manner -- >> mr. speaker, mr. speaker, we all have a great deal of respect for the right member.

now, chancellor will know that the secretary builds taxes on vice not google and i did my job when i was in the treasury. now he will be judged on results -- on results he's been in office for six years are. and what demanding ten times more than google than he is, the public will make their own judgment. mr. speaker, well labor is campaigning to ensure that u.k. remains in european union because it's the best way to defend as well as jobs and prosperity. the part of the office is split right down the middle. and, and mr. speaker, it is

descending. so last week the employment minister, next week -- mr. speaker, last week the employment minister called to correct it so they could be workers right it is. does chancellor agree with her or does he agree to sustain in the european union is best deal for britain's work. >> first of all l, she confirmed that way she was in the treasury she asked absolutely no questions. about the tax affairs of google. when it comes to the european union, as she knows that we agree on this. i think it's better that britain remains in the european union why don't question of some consensus now on other issues such as independent nuclear and consensus on that . let's have a consensus on supporting businesses rather than disparaging businesses pep

and let's have a consensus about piling debt on the next generation and dealing with our deficit. let's have a con sen sis to the the parties in this house who have a credible economic policy. >> thank you, thank you mr. speaker. i think you just agreed with mccluskey so former work and secretary -- that the chance report should not be believed by anyone and branded chancellor pinocchio nose getting longer and longer with everything. now the manager director says that treasury get this half a million good reasons to stay in the european union who does the chancellor think that public should listen to? his former colleague or the league of britain's union --

>> i don't think it's any -- i don't think it's any great revelation that is conservative that different views on the european union. that's why we're having a referendum because if he does divide parties and families and friends, and we made a commitment in our manifesto the british people will decide this. and i might just observe that if she wants to talk about vision and parties while she's sitting here, the leader of the labor party is sitting at home wondering whether to impeach for war cry. >> mr. speaker, i'm glad that he agrees to the pity that he can't get off his back and defend party to agree with him.

and given that the former work and secretary is just called the prime minister disingenuous and mayor of london call him demented i wouldn't talk about that if i were him. but house in order before it talks about us. now mr. speaker following in second the budget earlier this year, i say the chancellor approval rating has collapsed by 82 points among his own party. now given that he's following a similar career -- given that he seems to be following a similar career path isn't it time he turns for advice. last week former would be leader said that the queen speech after 23 years of careful thought about about what had they would like to do in power -- >> order, order. this question will be heard. those prating away should do so

and stupid and counterproductive. j mr. speaker after 23er yews of careful thought about what they would like to do in power mike said the answer is nothing. nothing to do with nothing to do and nothing to say and think nothing as you said. but even this nothing has called a revolt on back bench and forced yet another u-turn to avoid first defeat of a government on this legislative program that is 92 years. mr. speaker -- mr. speaker, this is not how you need to know about this prime minister and chancellor it seems they can't get even vote for nothing without a fight. >> i till you what we've done in recent weeks we've taken another million people out of tax

altogether. >> and cut business rates for small businesses. we've seen the deficit fall by another 16 billion and dliferred record number of jobs and have a national living wage. that's what we've been up to. what has labor party talked about? u-turn it gave to a party that wants to scrap it. so a party that created the economy program and now wants to abolish all aft economies so the party that wants courted businesses to now disparage it. it is plain offensive these days. and as a result the labor party that want elections to go on losing those elections. >> mr. speaker with 29 days until the most important

decision this country has facedd in a generation we have to forward the government in utter chaos at war with itself, the state should not be higher, yet this is a government that has the benches unable to get their agenda through parliament instead of that fighting a war over the leadership of their own party. and i notice that no outer -- have been banished dcial. [inaudible] mr. speaker -- while mr. speaker it's nice to see that justice secretary here. ting that justice for rest

colleague in detention. [laughter] instead of providing the leadership that country needs they're fighting a approximatey are war over the leadership of their own o party instead of focusing on the insight they're focuses on their narrow self. what we need mr. speaker, is a government which will do the best for britain what we've got is a conservative party focused only on themselves. >> she told us about our parliament party. let's look at her parliamentary party they are rats with a sinking ship because they want to be the mayor for liverpool you have the shadow wants to be mayor for both cities. when we've said -- [laughter] we were creating job opportunities, we didn't mean job opportunities for the whole

shatd doe capita. and they're like a policy on day relief aren't they? they'll be back and four more years of hard labor. today we are voting on a queen speech that delivers economic security for tax our national security enhance life chances for the most disadvantage and it doesn't matter who stands at that dispatch to the labor party these days. they're dismantling our defenses they're wrecking our economy. they will burden people with debt, and in their own report, publish this week told labor futures surprisingly long, they say -- [laughter] say this in their own revolt they're becoming increasingly irrelevant to the working people of britain.

>> britain -- thank you mr. speaker, what a privilege it is to be called by you if the remaining team have the say on the 24th of june i should apply to ask a question. mr. speaker -- a wonderful example of european corporation not e.u. fuselage is in france and germany and wings in this country. and cannot fly without wings, mr. speaker. would remain inside or outside the e.u. will have no effect the on this. chancellor knows it is trade and hardwork o of businessmen and overwhelm create job and prosperity not politicians and bureaucrat ares. it is their job to about --

have an enterprise -- >> order -- i was looking for a question. >> does agree with me? and not to make threats to business enterprise job deliberation. >> i completely agree my friends the job enterprise created through ingenuity of private businesses we should support this house. [inaudible] >> thank you, thank you very much mr. speaker. last one -- is 7 years old. and he attends the private school in the scottish -- next week as home secretary is

currently briefing him, the whole department plans to deport him and he has family despite the fact that he arrived as rt pat of a scottish government initiative backed by the home office to attract people live and work in the region are. this case has front page news in scotland and repeatedly used in the house. what does chancellor have to say to the brain family and community who want them to stay? >> family don't meet the criteria but home secretary say he's happy to write to the gentleman on details of the specific. the anger of robertson. >> going on for weeks and that frankly is not good enough. appeals have been made to the home secretary by the minister, local mp and local sp and by the community.

it is wall to wall across media of scotland as chancellor clearly knew nothing -- >> the problem in the highland of scotland is not immigration, it has been immigration. so even at this late stodge knowing nothing about it will attract to speak to home secretary, prime minister and get this sorted out. >> as i say home security will write to details of the case. again -- i make a suggestion they have substantial tax and if they want to attract people to the scotland why not have a scotland that people want to meet and the rest of the united kingdom where they can grow that business and have a successful life?

>> thank you very much, mr. speaker. >> will be heard. >> why is the chill report not published before the e.u. referendum because the chancellor don't want the public to be reminded how the government and the day and publish the have prepared to produce, make things up and have is the factses that they support something they otherwise o wouldn't ahead of the e.u. referendum? >> no because they produce that report. steven -- found in spirit of consensus, mr. speaker. may i say that the last few things that unite the house more than a concentration on the periodic review and of the boundary are commission which is started with a fierce intensity

occasionally cost on constituents, however, we note that the electorate chelsea has declined precipitously against all logic. does the chancellor believe that the prime minister should be concerned about this and if so, what should he be doing? [laughter] >> well i thoughts he was member of parliament for healing but sir, boundary that you were doing their work. drawing up in independent way a good thing about our country. boundary and see that proposal but initial proposals -- [inaudible] >> will chancellor join me in congratulating the u.k. charity which this year celebrating 150 years of reporting, protecting wonderful children. don't you agree that young people need support beyond age

of 18 to maximize their life chances and that the government extend duty of the carry to therefore a fitting way to build on artist proud history of giving young people the best tnts in life. >> i certainly agree with my little friend a brilliant chair hadty and we should all congratulate them ojt the work they do and huge responsibility to the people in the care of the state and that does not end when they're 18 years that means in the queen speech we're announcing new measures to include for example, support from a personal advisor until they're 25 and make sure that other bodies like local authorities have a care for people and make sure all of the opportunities are brought to their attention is is part of the life chance distraction that lives to the heart it have this queen speech. >> yeah. yeah. >> chancellor wants to -- hundred it is of steel workers are marching for parliament for

their future in their community. why does this china bid to market fierce against the interest of british work? why is this chancellor block changes to the duty against the interest of british workers and will set down industrial strategy to put interest ahead of his own? first thing our thoughts are with the steel make ergs at this time. but a step back we should all acknowledge there's a global crisis in the steel industry. tens of thousands of jobs have been lost just across yiewrm alone and many tens of thousands beyond that. thousand we're taking specific action today to help the portal that works in related works across the country and secretary have been there in india with cross party effort.

and then nationally we have taken action to reduce energy charges on energy, industry, we have taken action to make sure there's more flexibility with emissions doing everything we can to help this industry in a very difficult time including making u sure there is chinese dumping and introduced on the bill those imported down over o 90%. >> thank you mr. speaker. could the chancellor confirm to this house reports in the press today that former labor minister though sugar has joined the government as our new enterprise? does she agree with me that this is a sign of people abandoning labor for the prosperity security and jobs offered by this government in but will you finally confirm to me that he has no plans for a attack.

i can confirm that we have on enterprise and sold the labor party, you're fired. >> thank you mr. speaker. i have a 14-year-old awe autistc one size fits all approach and left him with a special in his only option. what will chancellor do to make sure when the independent looking at initial teacher training reports back that specific training from past. >> well i think that honorable lady does raise an important issue and i have a lot of sympathy from colleagues around the house. i can tell you that the education secretary has raised their concern, and hated has

shared that concern and personally raised, the chair had of the initial trading issue an my other friend stress importance of prorely train to support young people with special education needs and specifically ordered them. and as a result he will be including recommendations as to how core teacher training should cover special educational needs in this report. and this revolt will be published very shortly. >> my local commissioning group currently consulting a plan to downgrade a.n.e. will meet chancellor agree with me an thousands campaigners led by karl that all option it is should remain on the table that's a plan b must come forward to keep good quality local health services. >> my friend is a strong friend of his local area and we know that they have been struggling

with a pfi contract signed under last labor government. now, any service changes that needs to be made by the local and needs to be based on clear evidence that they'll deliver better outcome for patients. it's right that decisions are made by local rather than politicians. but they do need to meet the four key tests that have been set up to demonstrate an have support from commissioners and bees based on clinical evidence and consider patient choice and i would suggest to consider options in any decision they reach. >> thank you. thank you mr. speaker. common library sthaiments 4.9 million u.k. citizens led or worked in other countries yet week in and week out that will constituents from overseas who can't get visas raised it in citizenship here and scotland is outraged for deportation of the family. is the chancellor tell us and