tv Impeachment Hearing Reaction CSPAN November 15, 2019 3:43pm-4:19pm EST
3:43 pm
aid. this president provided an he is getting impeached. what about the previous president who denied the interagency anti- not congress. you. >> is there anyway you can look at this that this is a good day for republicans. [background sounds] >> members of the house intelligence committee including congressman jim jordan about the way those appointed to the committee last week aft asked questions and their fleet reaction to today's testimony.
3:44 pm
detail of the hearing with maria yoon of began at 9:00 o'clock this morning and broke about midmorning and wrapping up here will be a close door session with david holmes, and he of course is the official who overheard that come phone conversation. it got so much attention with a testimony of bill taylor. that testimony in all of our coverage by the way is available at her website at cspan.org. we will use this opportunity to hear from you to get your reaction. and what you heard and we saw today, our phone lines are open at 202, 748 - 8924 democrats and 202 - 748 - 891 republicans and he also took two - 748 - 892. a lot of attention on the tweet that came just as the hearing was getting underway at 10:00 o'clock eastern time this morning. from the president tweeting and real donald trump, the president writing the following quote everywhere marie yvonne news bench wet, turn red. she started off in somalia, how
3:45 pm
did that go. then fast forward to ukraine where the nuclear ukrainian spoke unfavorably about her and i see a phone call with him. it is a u.s. president absolute right to avoid ambassadors. president trump, will that happen as they hearing was underway in the opening statement by chairman adam schiff in the ranking republican member and then mary jovanovich is open state statement. this question to the ukrainian investor. the former investor to ukraine. mary jovanovich. [background sounds] >> up talk about transparency. i am the most transparent president in history. i tell you about what tempering is. it's when a guy like 50 shift, doesn't let us have lawyers tampering is when schiff doesn't
3:46 pm
let us have witnesses and doesn't let us speak. i've been watching today for the first time. i started watching and it is really sad we do see people not allowed to ask questions and it is totally nobody has ever had such horrible due process. there was no due process. and i say it is considered a joke, off of washington and all of the world, the republicans are given no due process whatsoever. are not allowed to do anything. if it's a disgrace what is happening but you know what the american public understands it and that's why the poll numbers are so good. and that's why other things are so good. what they are doing and washington, or that hearing and by the way it is a political process. as a legal process. so 570 staying, i'm allowed to speak up, somebody says about me, were not allowed to have any kind of representation, were not allowed to have almost anything. and nobody seen anything like it in the history of our country there has never been a disgrace live what is going on right now. see you know what, i have the right to speak. i have freedom of speech just as
3:47 pm
other people do. but they've taken away the republicans rights and i've watched today in certain very talented wanted to ask questions. and they were even allowed to ask questions. republicans. they weren't allowed to ask questions. it is a very sad thing. go ahead. [inaudible conversation] cima i just want to have, freedom of speech, as a political process, the republicans have been treated very badly and watched a little bit of it today. it was able to yesterday because we had the president of turkey here and i was able to watch much. i watched some it this morning. that it was a disgrace. when we have a great republican representatives, people elected by the people, and they are not allowed to even ask a question. not allowed to make a statement. we are not allowed to have witnesses. wherein i love to have legal counsel pride white house counsel. it is a disgrace and an embarrassment to our nation. a. [inaudible conversation] reporter. [inaudible conversation]
3:48 pm
>> i don't say so at all. >> do you say you will be impressed at impeached. >> washing b, why thought last night, last night i was in louisiana where we will hopefully elect a great republican governor. and i was getting off the plane and they handed me a statement that is just made by the foreign minister and president of the ukraine. in ukraine, they came out loud and clear that there was no linkage whatsoever, not even a little bit. you saw it, you also. i said will, that is the impeachment. and you people don't even report it. look, the press is unbelievably dishonest. it was a major statement put out last night by the foreign minister of ukraine and also by the president of ukraine. and you don't even report it. it is a disgrace.
3:49 pm
because it said that there was absolutely no linkage. when a perfect conversation and i also because of transparency whether it is medical transparency or just transparency generally, i also put out today the statement. in the statement we released and then congressman nunez, red a call that i had with the president of ukraine and it was a great call. it was a very nice call. everybody said it was perfect. i always see, it was equally as good as the other call. and i put it out today and nobody even wants to record it. because look, if we had an honest press in this country, we would be so woa served. and what, when i look at your approval numbers, the worst they've ever been in the history of our country. the media. the approval numbers. they are horrible. you want to get yourself back and you want to put yourself back in a position where people
3:50 pm
respect the media again. i know some great journalist. an innocent great people in the media. but there aren't enough of them. there's a lot of dishonesty and many of you i just consider members of the democrats. and it is a shame. select the president and roosevelt room and emit focusing on healthcare issues taking reporters questions and again he responded to the suite they came from the president at ten oh one this morning in which he criticized me jovanovich as she was about to begin questioning from democrats and republicans primarily passed committee. the presence of an afternoon responded to the tweet. taking reporters questions and discussing the media. will get your calls this moment but mary was then asked about the tweet and again going back to the hearing this morning with questioning from the chair. congressman adam shift less watch. a. >> now you testified in your opening statement that you had lift to ukraine by the time of the july 25th all.
3:51 pm
between president trump and zielinski. when was the first time that you saw the call record for this phone call. spinning when it was released publicly at the end of september i believe. >> prior to reading a call record, were you aware that president trump had specifically made reference to you in the call. >> no. >> what was your reaction to learning that. >> i was shocked. absolutely shocked and devastated frankly. >> we mean by devastated. >> i was shocked and devastated that i was featured in a phone call between two heads of states in such a manner. where president trump said that it was bad news to another world leader. nobody going through something.
3:52 pm
so it was a terrible moment. a person who saw me actually reading the transcript said that the color drained from my face. i say it even had a physical reaction. i say even now, but whoever's. >> that went out upsetting you is it too much for my like to show you the excerpts from the call in the first one president trump says the former ambassador from the united states the woman, was bad news. and the people she was dealing with in the ukraine were bad news. so just want to let you know. what was your reaction we do heard the president of the united states referred you as bad news. >> i couldn't believe it. again, shocked and appalled, devastated that the president of the united states we talk about any ambassador like that.
3:53 pm
to a foreign and state. and as me. i cannot believe it. >> the next expert was when the present references you is the short one. but he said woa she is going to go through some things. what did you say would president trump told president zielinski you read in the going to go through some things. >> i didn't know what to say but i was very concerned. his tunic were you concerned about. >> she's going to go through some things. it didn't sound good. sounded like a threat. >> did you feel threatened. >> ended. >> also prayed. >> i didn't know exactly.
3:54 pm
it's not a very precise phrase but i say it didn't feel like, i really don't know how to answered the question further except to see that it kind of felt like a big threat of a threat and so i wondered what that meant. it concerns me. >> she came to this country at the edge of three and she was born in canada and became a u.s. citizen at the edge of 18 and 33 year veteran of the foreign service. served as the u.s. ambassador from ukraine from august of 2016 to may of this year. in her testimony, now available the c-span video library. the hearing will continue next week and will have life coverage tuesday and wednesday and thursday. beginning at 9:00 a.m. eastern time of the c-span networks and you can listen to it on the free c-span radio app and all of it streamed on the web in our youtube page. traffic not independence avenue
3:55 pm
where the rotunda, and how side of the capital. we are hearing wrapping up though there is a closed door session going on right now later this afternoon with dave holmes was a state department official who overheard one of the phone conversation with sutherland, whwho is the master of the european union appointed by president trump and that phone conversation getting a lot of attention on wednesday my master bill taylor expect to get a read out i was having from democrats and republicans from that closed-door session. over a no one hear from you. joining us from michigan, democrat line, what are you seeing today, we do heard. >> wife and i have been watching the entire show here today and my feelings are she's allowed to have feelings and they asked for facts but after our president who talks about disgraced, ganymede call her by her own name. said to me is the disgrace.
3:56 pm
she is allowed to have feelings. >> thank you for the call. republican vine virginia. good afternoon sharon. >> thank ship is orchestrating a bone hearing. he's been flying through missions and restrictions so basically due process and the use of allowing hearsay evidence which is also worried about any and every associative president who included his lawyers being taken down by corrupt at the idea. dangerous and setting a precedent that we've never seen in this country. everybody both parties should be shouting from the rooftops. they should see justice. if it happens to one person can happen to anyone. shouldn't be going on this country. we are republican the bottom line is the president of foreign policies, not in the deep state unelected bureaucrats as she does that. using her there. realizing this. and she also stopped the
3:57 pm
investigation of the biden situation. that was the reason she was removed. >> thanks for the call. congressman and more meadows, this is an area in the capital known as the secure area. as for mary jovanovich for approximately 12 hours behind closed doors and the intelligence committee releasing all of the testimony of all of those who testified in a closed-door session and now there is yet another one with david holmes who will be testimony about what he may have heard in a phone conversation from a restaurant with gordon sutherland the investor, was a donor to the top trumpet inaugural committee in the phone conversation with trump) layer alleged took place on the july 26 and here is the possibility of that hearing going into tomorrow again and there's closed-door sessions in the open
3:58 pm
hearings is coming on morning which will live. next is tony from elgin south carolina independent line. good afternoon. >> as independent, looking at the sink on both sides. got to sympathize with the republicans in the way this thing is being run. adam schiff, is the dictator on this bench. he is allowed not allowed when unanimous these not allowed them to manage her time. he is absolutely squash symphonic has been brilliant. the president can hire and fire any diplomat he wants. the reason he was say the evidence against jovanovich for going to squelch this investigation is pretty substantial. sven rick if you know question giving military aid that went out investigation, you are not doing the public service. >> thanks for the call. on read to you what the washington post is reporting
3:59 pm
about david holmes. the headline is stated who overheard the call and ukraine testimony behind closed doors. background washington post. before david holmes came to unintentional fame to the diplomat who alleged overheard present from seeking an update on the politically motivated investigation on your pain comes one and were back in toy 14 part raising concerns about then president barack obama news on afghanistan where holmes was served on a constructed dissent honor recognizing this mid-level state department levels who use the internal process to raise concerns about policies and the administration. so just some background. you can read full story available online at washington post .com. is joining us from webster, texas. your reaction to today's testimony. day two of the house intelligence committee. >> thanks for taking my call. first i'll begin by staying i'm a veteran who stood by and watch
4:00 pm
4:01 pm
one after another, they could have simply said i'd like for these articles and ask for unanimous consent and lastly, the fact that they complained that the whistleblower doesn't come forward or that there denied this or that witness or that these witnesses don't have firsthand knowledge, all those people who do have firsthand knowledge, doj and the white house refused to let them testify so i'm not sure what they're complaining about >> you for the call. by the way the house and senate will be in session next week, the house intelligence committee and then the thanksgiving break but we mention that because we learned earlier on the democratic leader steny hoyer that they should be plan to
4:02 pm
be here december 16, that was scheduled to be an off week but presumably that means further action and possibly a houseboat on articles of impeachment. once the house intelligence committee as wrapped up its business it will send a letter to the house judiciary which willproceed with any potential articles of impeachment . if the house does impeach the president you can look for a trial beginning some point in january and potentially into early february. della is joining us from roanoketexas, republican line . >> how are you. >> guest: how are you. >> caller: thank you. watching this impeachment i want to say i'm absolutely disgusted in adam schiff and the way he sits up there like some sort of king of our country just completely biased and cuts off every republican that tries to talk every time they do. it's completely unethical and i think it's a full disgrace to our democracy byhim doing that . >> host: if you had the chance to question marie yovanovitch or any of those
4:03 pm
testifying, what is your looming question, what do you want to know? >> caller: what does shethink about president personally ? >> host: thank you for the call, we will go to tom in pennsylvania, independent, good afternoon. >> caller: thanks fortaking my call . >> host: you're on the air, go ahead with your comments. >> caller: i am totally disgusted with this whole thing. it feels like the old-fashioned put on a rail run him out of town. never sensed day one given trump a chance to prove his genius. i know that in the past 30 years i had high respect for the man because businessman and i don't understand i finance but thank goodness he
4:04 pm
does because now he's the master of our government and our finances. >> host: thank you for the call. we should point out paul manafort in jail in large part because of his dealings with the ukraine and roger stone convicted on perjury charges, found guiltyon all charges of obstruction and assault cases, that conviction today in a dc courtroom potentially facing up to 51 years in jail , his sentencing is scheduled for early february . a president with this tweet at 12:15 . so now they convict roger stone of lying and what to jail him for many years to come, what about crooked hillary, c-span.org, shifting schiff and all the others including mueller himself. since they live?
4:05 pm
that's the president in response to the conviction of his longtime friend and political advisor roger stone . our line for democrats 20274889214 republicans, our listeners on c-span radio and the free c-span radio app. from georgia, good afternoon. >> caller: am i supposed to put the phone on mute, can you hear me? >> host: yes we can, what's your reaction. >> caller: why did trump send a transcript of a telephone call he had gotten back in march? we want this not the summary, the transcript of the july 25 call, what was that allabout? that makes no sense .>> host: if you're talking about the transcript of the call from april, the president was on air force one and he had a
4:06 pm
conversation with president zelensky before get the transcript of july 25 and let us see that, the american people want to see. >> host: thank you for the call. on the other side ofthe screen area known at this and there's a closed-door session getting underway momentarily . this is a secure area of the us capital and we expect the transcript to be released as we've seen the transcript from others who have testified. david holds the state department official overheard a phoneconversation between the president, president trump and the eu ambassador gordon sondland who will testify himself next wednesday on capitol hill . hearing gets underway on c-span3 at 9 am eastern. let's go to dale inflorida, republican line . >> caller: thank you for you and c-span. my major concern since the
4:07 pm
election is the fact that it seems that the media in general and the entrenched powers in washington refused to let the people's choice do his job . looking at this i would think a lot of civil libertarians would be appalled by the fisa court abuse, by higher ups in the cia and also the ex-cia. it's really to me looks like a lot of our intelligence community and the entrenched powers are trying to do a black op on our own country. >> host: let me bring it to the testimony today and marie yovanovitch. did anything in her testimony change yourmind or questions
4:08 pm
from the democratic or republican house members or the council asked the questions ? >> caller: it's kind of reinforced the idea that since day one, once we found out from one that they were going to doeverything and anything to stop him . she, weather, she's a diplomat which is fine, we need the diplomats that they serve as the pleasure of the president. they're there to put in policy. we're not looking for a policy set 30 years ago and we keep the same policy . continuity has its benefits but when you change direction , as a servant in the state department you have to change direction. the other thing when the council was asking her about what they were saying trump was badmouthing her, she's a bad person , he didn't say bad person. he said she was bad news. they left out the fact that thepresident of the ukraine had brought her up .
4:09 pm
he had concerns that she had loyalties to the old regimein the ukraine. the other thing look at what ukraine's president is up to. we took a serious issue , took an ally or at least a probable ally and we turned him into some kind of right in the middle of some kind of circus that pretty much every fair-minded person can see that they've figured out a suspect on november 9, 2016 and now they've been looking for a crime ever since. that's not the way it's supposed to work in america. sounds like the red revolution. >> host: we will go to greenfield tennessee, ray, you are next, independent line . >> caller: i'm in a lifetime independent and at this, this blows my mind that it seems clear that president trump received assistance from russia in 2016.
4:10 pm
it looks like the democrats were prepared to grant, grin and bear it and wait out his first term but then he starts soliciting assistant in the 20/20 election and that was the last straw for them and i don't blame them at all. donald trump can do a lot of damage to this country and another five years. thank you for listening. >> host: in addition to our coverage on capitol hill we are also providing reaction from officials including the president. it's all archived on our website at c-span.org/impeachment. and scroll through and everything that's been happening here on capital hill on the floor of the house, reaction from leaders, lucy and kevin mccarthy and of course the president and administration officials. line pennsylvania, bill. >> caller: i want to say to
4:11 pm
all these trumpalini's, it's not the economy, it's the constitution. if you break the constitution you're not able to do any business without total governmentinvolvement and here we go with the impeachment . trump has nine people found guilty on his team. they were already found guilty, rogerstone the last one . he's basically he's got his republican buddies trying to give him an excuse, not question the witness but give him an excuse on what to do and their patriots. they are true patriots. donald trump and his family never had one person served in the military. all he's done is taken his whole life and it's sincerely pathetic and the last thing i got to say is trump, impeached the leech, that's how you drain the swamp. >> host: are you still with us? so did anything today move
4:12 pm
the needle in any way from your standpoint with the testimony of ambassador yovanovitch? >> caller: it just made it more convincing that he's guilty. he's a bad man for this country. i don't care what the man does in his own business but when it comes to running people and he supposed to be subject to them, he's got to go. is not a king, he is not a monarch, he's nothing. actually is nothing, his father gave him everything. it's disgusting the way this man is treating our constitution and our country . >> host: we go to ohio, brian is on the phone, republican line . >> caller: good afternoon. i used to be a democrat but switched to republican and i think this all started at the beginning when theelection came .
4:13 pm
>> host: we're losing you, are you on a cell phone for mark. >> i'm trying to figure out the one on the post. >> when pelosi set up a podium and stated the fact that he was not going to do anything to support the republicans and the president no matter whether it was good or badfor the nation , that just tells me right there that he's not going to do it from the beginning. and from that point on, he has done nothing but try and discredit our president, duly elected. and now we're into an impeachment hearing. and we have to your fun of it, they're asking questions that have nothing to do with an impeachment. >> in question,did you find her a credible witness ? >> know, an opinion about a person is not, it has nothing
4:14 pm
to do with testimony. >> host: thank you for the call denise is joining us from nebraska, democrats line . good afternoon. >> caller: can you hear me? i'm hanging in there. i have to say since this whole, since trump allegedly won the election, i have seen this country turned around so fast. i can't even tell certain family members that i'm a democrat because iget . even church members for being a democrat. when i see all of this and i know somebody in my family that did work for mister trump. and he was crooked then. the found a way for the economyto get out of trouble to file bankruptcy . and the fact that he calls the people in the news fake
4:15 pm
news and all that, with every word he puts out there contradicts himself. and it just boggles. it just breaks my heart seeing what it's done to this country. and the witnesses, i just have to say that you can tell they are scared. there's a reason that. >>. >> we will go to richard next. independentline. schenectady new york, good afternoon. what did you see and hear today, what stood out ? >> let me start off with i thought the ambassador testimony was extremely compelling. i thought she was genuine. for her to get a call to get on the next plane to come back to washington at 1:00 in the morning, i just think they railroaded her out of her post.
4:16 pm
i got a quote what governor cuomo had to say about president trump when he decided to change his residency from new york to florida. good riddance. i think he's divided this country. i think he is a president who has our children are watching things like this and this is not the way office of the presidency should be run. i thought the ambassador was extremely sincere in her testimony. i thought the republicans were able to make their point . i thought adam schiff gave them many opportunities to make their point but i just think this woman, for him to tweet during the testimony
4:17 pm
was just another thing that the president does. he had to get off twitter. >> you for the call from schenectady. a reminder there are a lot of ways you can continue to follow the hearing including on the free radio. today's procedures will be reairing tonight inprimetime . and all of its available on the web at c-span.org. >> next the house intelligence committee and chair adam schiff continue impeachment inquiry hearings beginning tuesday morning at nine eastern on c-span3. watch live testimony from jennifer williams, aide to vice president mike pence and rector for european affairs at the national security council alexander vindman and ambassador called folder, special envoy to ukraine and national security council white house aide tim morrison
4:18 pm
on wednesday at 9 am eastern, testimony continues with us ambassador to the european union gordon sondland and 2:30, secretary of defense for russian ukrainian and eurasian affairs laura cooper and david hale under secretary of state for political affairs and on thursday at 9 am eastern the committee will hear testimony from fiona hill, former national securitycouncil senior director for europe and russia . what's the first to public hearings in their entirety on our website c-span.org/impeachment and there you will find transcript of witness testimony and procedures for the hearing plus the points of interest feature that identifies key moments during the hearing indicated by a star in the timeline next week watch live coverage of the house impeachment inquiry c-span3 or listen live wherever you are with the free c-span radio app.
50 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CSPAN2 Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on