Skip to main content

tv   Hearing on Concussions  CSPAN  March 29, 2016 9:14am-11:31am EDT

9:14 am
sure crta tey sul ma t cion >>ndonht o.safo onhtt0:asrnn c-an ad paor > nihton eran hto tvn-sn3 cngssndhe potil ysm. giinat:0 stnt' oo a teisry o pital rts. tigt:1he lte a ngssefeth cilar dh t sry o bane. bre,irltela nar er a fll er prend msiip fom 75o 18 a teth sryofhe jnt mmt ontatn, icw esblhein92 > tatn ftbleae seoricpridntoreth a set cely aknleed fo cgrshahes li btwnooalnjy sw con draat
9:15 am
cealay o e. somnt methose enrg ad mmceomtt scsi autesrcan tratnt aooafrnn. wa t wlcelofur anis he. iis fumnoa rng -ean wwi he mbs rin roho ts,hifom he.
9:16 am
h aifre aroh o'soi tbeitngn e ne rsi tirig nanswri tte t ho tth werecitis wasme th'slloul y yws. in bmyolag, nkg mb, y hemeerhee t? lemeta o wh lile brf eng atentoet thtoe. i nto anyoalfo ei he r das utae ll eluin ta ccuiorercsis. the aewndrocave v se y m he en cale"ccuio" ttg loofttti. th h lp bnghiin e bl e. e vmoti edee gainthpralcef nssnsn or a mity d heroer pulio a wkn mt ccsinson en cc sptsn lir
9:17 am
ropant a titso atet a svi mbe, oe e rrd. hehe me d rebot thdaer penalonte fes. thy nto owf eyr thr mi mbe a a rik. f ur tt'noalysee t ce. le than o cas o onssnserbaly bp t niol dasce whheyofe o aadr tity pih,t s bu othsa oth jt idouotoube rg,aw so srsnd nbidl pef ju. remb wn pled ftbl arag y g oedutth wedmmi deyo ne,ndouotp anwaedwa n t pliisonrn a okg r sws. chdr bp eihes l heim whreo u awhein bewe tt o-o d in tothernds se py nctpos. mmeryosdutoix yes hh ho a cle ooaloromhi ee? th sn me iidt ay coegfoba. ar oo sin a rsu omraat sre fm coplof urohi torainpeap atarccenth tk a t yrsgo
9:18 am
its go tnge e ki tseueio. ftute w s he toaye n y he l he aneranthre lesh alng th pliwas sws at scncisotea tprid wde wh e alng mapehsi a fr wh wdot deta. heeetoetreerlaty gainth sene nssnsndraat bin ju ioftmt poan. 20 ctrut tth eas 500pelend acund r 5 lln een rm ists eay % a dumte binnjy juesreueo fas. %o sat os65ndld h t laesra otbrete ea. toaye gia w apr e aluen ncsis,ot o lipa aio. werabto eg a coerti fus o
9:19 am
luon nt obm a jnetoy se f thmt omeneer i ts el iss woerl pouny oremrso t cknd lienndea fm es didl d eidedeo coecvexpiee. eye reo lpdut meeranthpuicbo t stef e iee onssns wh dweno wt e e gs,owo are tse ptoaceva angf oranlo-tm luon wearal he datoak onthg ea iisotusa or o mita iue hiis plihethse. evryeamiio oamicns t ayg or a nt rvg t mity ffr ncsis. ty n pp tannean tie,nyer omwi rov wh teae fes,ths ll veebitinsyto. y e ffen? weantono tht'whwereertoy d o su waronheig
9:20 am
pah,o ove e ubche anerth der. e lleg wh brf pseatn omr.alin omhedchoilprida prio iroctn f ccuio a ger orvw ouwh wkn authee inri a tirrelee ciy d foatn rode bele r is inrmio epufoar abrd ris scsi qstnso r rtiptsoc o o, print scceio o unerpriad ctabt ncsis. tw kwlgeaponur dstdi ocouson re scic jeiv tt wil ado angf pgrs an miminthri f coluon a otaeso chvi tse he qstnsrentdeto gue rtipioanprid aoprtittoisn d ean. mebe a wco tas qston inogog bfoa lie heinbuju l u kn iyoha aueio e' etrckf at asumg he mewel ha me esonndnsr
9:21 am
thheanis athento cernyutanngre o test d keo anitheanng meeroreruprtn is tnka t,r.hama orhirodtle mim ises keh rt aite widyb cirn towi tl u, d aotofthe ene rk oou21 ctuy kersiniavendt s watoet l oinrmio cd toneftno. i'al le tnkhean exer w he meod t ta uautthimrtce ofeatrma dstd inthimctto thhe a h tdino a e iurth rul fm uctrmas italo ris gmtsf r ciy, omilartopos ags,
9:22 am
toartsf unatet a aunthcotr gin e aly t nesttoy d e vsi oopio, bee wha t oorni f ve dcuio i peod'sve, h ecounat tust e sffev, t binngf seesf scsis d ang o tsoc. i intaet a sucre diusononhimaerou besuls srto in abt atoness les. me rwd e arg rossilpridusit imrtt gazaon aoo dtrtu. i n tnth mstmpta inishapelee de thbui initoehep toha ttinyn e cod. teyes o,otuc ttti w pd ncsis,s u id aweeaedoranmo abt e teiasht d ngerefctofonsse dubncsi hs,ur csttutsavma qstns a cces,arcurlabt
9:23 am
thr ilen iolme i ntt or. u ales y rcurlatisofasn aidagdutoepite hs,vewh tseitdot seo e veofa onssn. stieha swnhayog htewhdootusin ncsis t d peen retivhi tthhe eibedeuloca iaienov t crsof ng alec as. aditnay,ccdi ta ectlreas sdyy e yolic demr lt ea autnehi omewh pledmauronctpos eiyoh spyeeven f e thog e-ir atumr sprinanit idelyonrng. t owth y d'tavto velad ofsial foba ohoeyo ff log-rmra dagfr onctpos. whe sllavno tlied pvancra
9:24 am
r e,hetu sony sues atthdiasis me eventh w rinay out,ndraly noju wh osdias b alo thir' cc ad th deas feinboh r a bs. w unranth ainn chcitic deorthe y dagemt d unerin rarnghawe knw wt li aio w shldakagnsthbadr atnoed. buunrtntdo n eus acio mntesd hr omu peltsod ites wt tis sulta rht no, d enowe edo mo fwa ioucoinng nvtitin. noi'gog s, t ngeswon r e rl chpi nvr ons,ou noi d s i ad sobo wseamy s e le-ngean ck oer ndlssobo w gdued fm disi hke1 ho
9:25 am
d w pren o, e uneit odeerweov ayg d tcngonct spts areatthfiesan thotr netsf e titi. tt e meim t hd juesssiad thomof tsectitesaparo v coseens atreontem, rersler eneay. hefo, trereayto ma tesacviiesern ju f o ks,utlsfo pfeiol hlesweee bsu ty' bng imlent. inth wdsmrchrm, nitll e nto joththll ina n ptipas t wh mh foatn psie fo t pye o e al rksndiniz t hltris soat wh ntt ors. thk u ryuc fr coizg e. i noweava t dcus ndanvoeso arro m adhawee ckg f iefr yldac >>soo ea tt'rit.
9:26 am
ioceheicffins emod ck fd to cirn t fl mtt, u e coiz. anyo i ve lg aten b i n gngo adt beau iantoeto e usesofheay i pria eeronbn here. i think that we've learned a lot. we have a lot more to learn. but primarily this is to listen. this is why the format isa ttle bit ffenhe tn y ie mr. ponhaa eran erore. ise rssp owhawee l ulve test ith. pps.o keurth tt i anuiayhai sid myraae lazo mcole weinar a hpil. nee ot tt twnashaweavhi is- ate vedeifd cousonarnoque haunrsor at acg.
9:27 am
o st, d yid ck >>ha >>u. tipas r ing toy. cousonar puiceaafctg ilonofeoe tht e fera a eth ourd ou c b lger lini. thseonquceanst fom njieonas ubnsce ct udowthte re vincof igfintraof orxalehero oo reahe o opu uitfod gnict ucrachgetohe ofscolooalpler g oswhdootavccuiodino wh'sarcublg thhaeserst ev nt leugst domeedn soav
9:28 am
tenubncsi hs ifanchgeinran hecrsebrn futihioalhage anthasofioemal maerliedo aida reeahee soeptely fod idcee nke twn mptsndhe egerivbrn see ow as ctis dasti morlo ascitewi dreio a evtulyemti d meys reod fm sn si. s a h cleuefr t rsy veeecoucn grndeangesrcino se denofecsen. rr l ays wl e didus ayg otll chl ves.tendvehih th'vdiovedherenc n hlesunas5 d my ul w pye fotbl ncth we ds nie see th uquia ulnad aro senfi
9:29 am
cseushafiinth chriicoft unrtatth t cr'wo h bn ueiod tsehoava st iert mntni thstusuo i ndstd e wiines knlee e nke n ntt or a bin mae. iwh wca a innvie tthhaso o ou gatatnapa tes or tt le d at childr py erda m siifananlain brn ma. tt te aepth ouinev tt eris a nke twn admpts dran mae dts me o setngbo i de oero sw a t eio,hi sulnobean cu f ictn. wexaneotnlthste heciceutlslo io hoanpp wt kw rit w pte or seicenndom, r athteou. wexorthste t au cfuonr rv iho o dcuiodon'
9:30 am
scntficoseuarn pite adraa e ngs ios. lia ha ihe. no oy reorofal retis ccuio lecyoun icdos u citorindvce ei t sen ouson oforr mpbabuanfe m ke w d e vuae hr ou 'sxpiee tht heexricendths ke he c irear a t pah rwd are ts soete y,hamaupn, te concdey mas sugeinreecul meiod arey wle ths unab ia lule stt o wk,e ou s ath -a ar weeetool oth
9:31 am
bjt vethofisop a t nbe lest fes d iorl suicntt inis mtiedchrm, at m ndg u leerefe imeiod . g atweotlexn thcoexorioo thcs, fes,retmt anprenonssns ienon ithlee pros f aers fr mmtehein tt ge ncansprt retehe tumth icapuiceah anho wcawo tetr g rwd d ann furhein. thk aitollf r rcintanthk u, aianpt cirn muhyanag f pti ts geer isor ioninngan ihi wcawoetr ts gnict bl h sse. thksga. anyo i nto ntn mef e
9:32 am
mrshaarhe tn. j ptsnnlvias sohirn t hlt bcmiee r.icelursss son otubmmteon d chd ds ono cola. tnk o n rk geen ra nolemerynd- wot ado fllio iclr d fo mtollriceinh heenris.t auay thngnhug se tse the n'ben y rt caaiandrmi cso phsindirtoof ce f sen ad ecoly alh. drgrd nienon inrentn t atnaceerornjy prenonnddc iaheei inalross oneoly
9:33 am
atndnanieritos unertyscolfedin go lk t mchadss ia. yoren e enal brpi. c ie' eh he bu wllee >>e owheamin thbu rgshieay. > . ffan, ofof nerorg uveit cifnisafrcio. r.elccy,lica neopogt,ross o eusuerdict o a iurar ath dil lle wcoin ana sechsyt
9:34 am
a dil nt imie, isns. elisns pyepi fstoud. jukn. ' s hgo. did- . viserts vigia mmweth irs ieofhycameci a reabitioseic f bu. . ck uvy pitsrgmecace dict ouprtmeci usonroagerdio, ilens niol vionhi pschogandict heafcousonutme ceranedatn or ogm cldnaon eah stm. lelens ch
9:35 am
csuanrent rir f ryhe hdict hecbacousiv ce sechamro20 t 01 crelyltg e nc a o md aan sechn aiheth iro cnil act n ke wco. ofsoofeulo ad og azhmes see er thnkoull het gngo a dcuio te s. regne atanofou he anttsaynoea ybso oyoha m ad sss tngbere wt iso aop sssn. si'gog towutn itesonerju tbe to-u ift snghayo kn. ntoomn,lee . ve hd oplar ortoadmoe.
9:36 am
ift'sothg u saee wih bau pt t a dfenc ith iee. aay wwa ther hi s mbs veomntan eiollryo ep mbs'ue jt kp e scsi gngorrdwe wo'te viecs da rerhathlemeo e rsto baicly- rswee in toavthcdspk. ldn llethiupo op hasi inrm >>re, yo mh. wa tthk aianptn a rrent mphanotr mbs ts te roucoitnto s sis a preinpuic al iue iktoha a reiol aiinryas r w he enhaio o i r othbueno erana
9:37 am
isoutae,hamag weacal d'tnoa eatrma hoitffifre sse e puti, e oran hisig.eec a oercric dai. tht'whi soanto hhlhtherosecd cousonurilnc ffsyea or fos toelfi tseatga. 'inurin o oth t fwa. nonev wtso arr ev agnehaa amy inri wchreaua um bw jt t hd, arfatocoon isancc ivaouwa gi fm cacrh, fl in bht oonhetas, k cliitanhe yein scega, sltice tet i thbale mity marae omiltoeve.
9:38 am
e ear e vety inur t gat t lelooofonte a isily en deh. moo ff aonssn revewiin wk t, t meonssn mpms n stevalee, ns n ng. e osctf fu rovy ithatedf tu t la sooorortoso, orfrkl stath nssn. bi a leincae ryelatedea a sily t utestes eylla e inin mmth'rprenbl inonye anehe we t as2.miemgey eptmt si, eieraler cbiti oernjie bkedo tt aninu ou tetr dathe wi babt 0 i lad e darenvits64 i lae hpilitins a 1tb rat dth
9:39 am
isaye siifan desma othbu a ect udfr te ires spalf phadph fndhaam piaicopatn, mt % e esti i arfailti prca stis. he a osi othsce ofurntatcah abits. eury owth rulin cotsf 41ilonnn we aut5100po anreeaoneledrebi vit tthemgey pames t ute at i202. apromaf es o 2500wed onth yoge arithr yrsl ncsis,ncdeicli, ecatnaretear tbl,astbl,laro acviesndocr. 23 e stutof
9:40 am
digiliteonssn ocrrgnohposn me anremmdaon inudg cdabut e nd oebeerndstd d eecmeatn ll dco taisanovsea tialurilncsyemo acurte tei te cincofpolad coamg ut5 2yes d. enatg esda i diict cae litio inurntetd ou cre ste dno caurcoonth our tse oanedpos tt e t enn n th ao n dumt e ti pye le fee efsi lem ifoba, durcesefothfid y,he inoecd onssn sty ern' novy. aeroienroenl sn d ti wh pts icli fe oth peplonhean taycd hawi sve aseof ccuioanalag aos ei san iiso reneuso e isro spendf ure
9:41 am
trereomecoms sclehawereeazi, to a t cegeril pt ccuio ty d raomecd il i trerenye me peeednheas 1 moths rerdssf us usg sytobad ecis otti ccuivil beatoredaspoib obl ome efite di un. s peend d ei te palssiaonitth evnt r ame,neit ach, uredisonr entityo gh b nser psie he d a onssn. tsehoerknkeou t cscusssou b mo cegiz ahangad onssn fitily ilent, 'lbeblto pvi ste eimesf ccuio d arutiziofoofeah coclio udet
9:42 am
ffens d tu tpl, tu tlen d tu t rkroco, d vea naon eime r i te.isily r e rs prvancowifimtb tonowh wreacg d r evti eor a nge sote nd da. wdeed rv a e abotesitnde arrey te e svelae stnaon ca ith$5ilon reeditn e 2 esens dg a prriedo c. s adtoo r rtfur welatoonnutomp daa lad t tbe ueranthprle ta bteth rnsp twn i seery d tcesro inncthugollaesnd enem iro imlentioofssti a vincbartrspsre esntl aienguroa ndheivsi opane an psptis selehe a scric tmein
9:43 am
shedinert rungh r. agn,hk ouorhe viti tay lk ' gngo enupnd. k quti. thk u, .owys re loi iawhipo ithmeo. iss piurof- ' tbeipu ai bt, aersi t flidkes. y hecaio i ss"mreigtsh peui ge. nt testg. e ithspt voed he? s wt 'rloin foancousoninlv thha "y n h t b ala tha aonssn. meerhipiurwhl e nsreowin haonmapuhiarou prend yog y o heki -th w h
9:44 am
s. >>haprend s n om swerentonssto te ur oth, h anpose lo thngtoge to t m thwhi o, w jin mcoin on rk wht e mef e st ndapectefas ou couson 'moi tur oer . ue iol stus nrogil isde a e. ou dn'kn y we in toetaln rs i nto k u,re omunra ftsr snctis nd kw o rhtt e se ifotr ieis wt s setngwwil lln u. gohe yo hetothmiopne cle y a tne >>ur tnk mh. plase sro hrend on sao isrcti tnkhee ean tnkhe a, unrtaty,ued lk knlee. i init iornt
9:45 am
i aou ccuioapa e umf auti aiinry i hi ts ntne inurth tumran inryoefr t md t ser a is t tug ardiinisng t-fsetenho a tt ogssn t sge sits otrmac brn juy. th oerisncti -whh i n se erodages wi -us tbeai wth cousonf u ok ith brn,ouou n s ytng th'sotru ihi wde edee d miospein tint heimof ccuinn il,he ia mp rcesaf ans atr cri ithcousv evt.
9:46 am
ihi ithbiogo ssn,t n wl o bu ihi tt wl ar a orov te. sos 'sot pel ncon aorli. et inonn thbrn ri tse- ri couson th oerhi aea ntnewhch2yes o pplwod sfff moa,o ckutndla idy athas t e se sohas edc, e rofulplotr ou ikthacemofeulo's denecoite,utu idin f rurtopos. i inthsea bn keup byoarod e uny. d that rllben imrtt. onthg m t rebo i edeth wdot o ou tcosepant wedonoth iishi peti ccuioth gs eidinroleth i l ncsi i ofnm - i c b, r reusthe ts spctm hd inju. buthki tt veeean arabut to trube. irt nssn eye d
9:47 am
up ds. ona up wks irona up mth ihi gti tt t s ve ior its ve tghhi f t rtsndidecll algiceo e tyf thps i sor tgi u ndakthseesutf cteiothe. bu ihi tsereheew is tro o tbi t >>ouantosk qstn? ut d ] >geth me lile cle >>'mor. myautewaplinbaba ihi sooseoreaane s t t b sh sfed couson cay eyai y kw, weotanyotolaagn cae ihpe ain oue intoava ris prle
9:48 am
shwe tcoeg hes frhm icoegno nd cpltis wt let cead fntg ind enheasn olge bushdon'pl a srt yme cae wt ey sad. noi ann meayits orna b s h t cousonwee enol n'pl srt-- mn n' cta srt yo c j -shjo -bu on py ntt or. t f d e f e suonsse tsasou ald outhsptr n , u n' nesri kw oui iowecsehe owshs t ppedo o anthg re utf u tse thgshowou enno hewos,ou aou hisptr, t msik wreeangoranmo - lst'meangs pant moe d rehaanhi cn dag lie eldnotolaat
9:49 am
a. i ul'tanava co othd ncsi. t yu u jt lle abutha thsptr a t ubncsie. w oe tteteto ecumhayomeiod? se. ihi te rmoly s lileitt sker den ohoyothk ncsi w iti pelehohtf asoon oscocisns. w ha kd wt t yde w ia an tt'rely rzeatheimof in tres chgen urogalunio anth iwht ssf coscusss bui inifba emoe,therchge i neolicunioth non ou rogzenleyer st. sothabittoctlltet e ern o oth litg cts. ithe bccuiv evnt iou tnk- isis hotsi o cldtu
9:50 am
tseol. d eifhe'sa an oer me mae mee hefos u cme oth. iavnointh titeesorvebo uthe a se uwh ak ce ccuio 2yr ivetanarof 2000leitbrn juy. i ove e reorn l eaononns ekyotfai. u ou rurtoctit wihia y t oa couson tonctpos. aarro rti, syi aho inoth trtmt r ju. inny, clin nssns vhasiiny f waa rrlet alrit? iast opd.t e rl in'sc atuprtpelehodn ply or aer ccuio s al b f o yth itd r r ofsia
9:51 am
nvvetoprd atelf. weeewamo reah. ol ia t reah. burely triso iee asa d'tlaspts tea ncsi. >>abt seesf nssns anoualabt at se. y g o ccuio rs o a, ndso e ed.its treleati ancu cdionusonha ju ourd. ybdyinh omcod o . s ryartose sve toassst en wk to twas. mthafrwd stboosbl i unbiarfothvaysm d lphaupndn inthrear ithvaor th. 'selha t dafr e ouavon it aesd. u ke dgni hapeonetba t tita y t. alrit? est aypos,utet bk o tity tba tsco
9:52 am
eye r g ath ncsi f t feval owantoe fnten bu u' t mh gh rk fa tgehet see, yodot bk pbls t, ju wtefr m niee. s ws nhfae. e s ldoto ho >i owng 'sro. -foth s wks ony as s gadt w ecsehelehedohis te >>hehod veee acvad icr. iasefity ldoto docoac srtagn d f ithaed sentie. kw. n sp a >>homayothk te a ern'hainiacouson aveitcaesth ty ouurtoctitfaly icy? dr cli, veeeto clic oiteoutoehaus e u ay ithda, dn danhi f lg ris t yovde loofesrcin isre
9:53 am
an cme ites wt - ais mh ate edo die age olhertlwh ho cmes. e y n'fain wema tmeouprre i r otrtmt ts nj wee arngo enfy ifre stys ccuio a mchg rtn eaen tseifre cnil prfis. thghe educmo roecveesrcto ndstd e mi din oftrtmts wcoecve m reny ttur a aeeha cousons trtae in talre igr wh thco rarngou aute. ihi tt atn'wa dis- e nda sngfrm rthee ry rid awee l d . th tths oblyn twen sowhe tmsf e t'woe anhawehoht itbuits t b a att bngadoutoe. adans 'vma itrtmt e gnic wod gg'sev bn
9:54 am
af thaonssn an itisig n bau oth adnc tt veeema om tatnterecve weetati trnha ti aroheatanagemt an tatntreuce efcaouth sti ia arrom. i re aotf obmsro th plophofutngid da rm tmsf roc xitychon mrae, ks o e ica eenveuiidlo. weeetoetheba t or. y h aueioonhi pat? mquti igog ba ite ffen soou-- >drmc iantoaka re gss nel ckou cmear an s tt s oblya fali sryn dil sech ccusin son ama pplinhiro kw,a go tlyrotol n
9:55 am
ocuty0r 2 yrsgo ia or sti a ta ar eeninheilar ct dinatinthnaonl naate. d e foune sio weren rrtli inis 'vreheth awa sge omaurtyclt aleen, ate' me orustresvethlat 20yes atutusn poti tha ts scsid. t t se methtoc s enelad tt plisplit chhaal thehde, clin srtnt aumwe lrdythanertoll e italueio a ty wt osanerno a tre pha mre scntt binhato o tcupitthpu rrtie.
9:56 am
i ine dere sid anngowe kearo atles t sele d dunghensngay s ckpoteouwi eaenre, tef ertn,hexpssn teu or roaisha cousonpaicar ia srtg vinmt,setoe mageon stc heayouersytofr, aouda pnt ot vel ar a,evalay tuedo llonct aivy,havethspt g b wee ard loov t yersbo t nur te oue rovy inal a wnomagethteon al didoiedut wedotlithswcthda ty' s fe. iroceo-ctit d aerd nexsu coac aott thteo o ou sgeo
9:57 am
reabio clat rch pnt wre eyre mpteymom fr, d tu tacvi eth a se soro alicareve sndin he tarothrent ce tuy rgoutcom d duioofept jues inthsa ccuio 4 d 15o 99he t aaonssn ud rlstiemo tn 0%f meean pet cousonocrr whith r t ds t fs cocuio inhcuensty eris 0%ncen oreat anthavaginrv f dys os sllumr f sa-ssoreatonssn ds std fe y t wk aotf op inheoohe h h rt anatnaimctn w tref hlesnd mity rve mbs d oe o lel tum ris.s lt pnt o, ju satinthsevie.
9:58 am
kw ryite outh deyi nrooly ts juy. ass snd, ow l autowitak f thinvio lls at erecoplelsyt fe r corebuwevey ltlabt w t ke uimelwe le kw e nsrso oscric qutis ouunrlngat f yslo a rovy a ailel me evti beddesis ourerno tity >>rgia,ouad cmt tt >> jt nto wt . mraisefri ti asal t reah dg wee rrtlacir, st wile aleenanyong altapietoir, noasppedunr chdr. soe e ki se apof
9:59 am
itiner ohowepp t he tt edee ow nihik heil anweorime esonha asd a peni wh suli lomyhi t dox,, ri aivy. wdot veho awe y. te teweal kw tt wt dso aiv kw a t befs at hae rey enisssd o srtono nyevs. d t alitiou knlee ks,raw vtoe reauou dbtbo tt. buso oitayr y t prrie. anitpprshagis veboh fre skan dfentractieof coryhaweavtoetr uneranbeusthe y a ffret ogal a fre pchogala diert omhacareon frcs ahe b unrso meoewi yng cldn wl. ts e rcti tt we o, ahomo aut threnjy ane o. bui n llouhath oed iattsowt t yong ks.
10:00 am
>>r.any. > anyove mh. fit keo inth nrsti bk se ucoen, prenti rp, icishatb afec rthn stthte ts rllasigigedn yo beferthtiofh yridndhaooathe mity rsne at t o cleuero cd jstoteoutreisat 2.miiopele yr congemgey omwi onssn d thor datsereraat brn ju. th oerss ith tres lstwoilono re miiopelehaner ek oumecaca. ewh tseatntgeto e megeyeptm ve ueshash tt eral tm e ss. iouoninnifuedtu, ll tactb 'inpaen atw wes reouefrefo foowp. e repeplacay agseinn ernc pame a11e s tumceerinheour dwh wou ith l haha othe atntar aulyefre
10:01 am
f flou the aerlobainer fngp thhis at wkn thotr scceioisha e' tat ccuioan binnjy aevt d t pres beau wlo as e, ens ct'v bn kie trmac aiinryor yes. wedot ueti flothe atnt ule y h dbes,ea dea o nc. owhaweooath reika see ocs d wi sdi le actban mofheths atre fdewee ki qstns ate veasd fo en inthmecauny d e ndg an jst sucousvelo en ne ncsi c ahe coseofsoo'li i pld e mmtefo inhitoheorro. mli pplsurot aerfes erraat aiinryanweeay ed todo r i
10:02 am
iuswa tpot t at inoth aotf sncti autten couson e viwacae ouson autte buinllurxpiee 'v ev sn e tea ng couson es soat wh raon ofexsu tretiveea imct culaveurtoowev soonssnsner rrat whte veeemuip sdi, creti wh e mb ocouson b wdoeeercoisnt thyes py,heea aanndidl eos, saplinfoba, bin atoese tbessiad wh e skorte e ng py t igr veth y py,he grteth rsk
10:03 am
tnkoumrchrn. waa rgn hrturon beori s cgrs. soy esons intoe stto-bo pma en,o sak ucio d ha fr dsllheay omge3 a 1 thy ayocy,llla ocr. i psollpledooalin hi soo i ay hke. yoaldetot lileit eson l o sechaye nen ul, gog iyoh atays dfeen ia tis eoe th- op s te pin sllevelopg gntlin yr s. tstn ha iwh d pelehi wshlde in inurlents d gdechlsearl kw thurnt aille
10:04 am
inrmio who sckg pelendakg res ra r ki py,ndh sa, ats e teia freesf w esthg pt ul a so oth in mbeifrely ythan al. w wtso spd tt? >>ap tstt f e onrsio m re nbeofol wl bentesd n nn i' o t airyoa f usfoba. a ithmei deresaghe qstn s,t atgeo inode ffentys t ge dfentndidl agintepdsn rono omhi, ouphicl atit pchogal mury. wteh e men ffenwas? eranocy s neis evopntod a aotf os e okg tt w
10:05 am
aseay emoratin th pso eideloenl e,nd mendtsarcur il. ne ac y kw,r moifchkig? miftali a blckg? wmofyor entin th delmealev cno sutainnd tnkt' a erimrtt eson wrelyeetoraso sechrod osqutis. thnk ats tug weanerin ructht s a breci tuno ntt atoeones sprt b sllea ge ppprte, y'rno puinsobo io mtiveitti tal ppad,s ay ur cllge 'sot splaner cetalyomheor has enonwi t hds p otllros owg mrectn ger jieaselasonssn. weano rethg nd ai ido'tno tht sw to wt adoe stt esthgst.
10:06 am
t tin igseyndha wc lokatphic ecaonnchl d ndstd w w buldecstng, ate hi m bthimrtt nd ofntivbiog kd faor h dwe authe tduti osptst es soeby pchogaly ea fr. r meean lod ntt or. ha aonth'sotis hig. th'y. a nn. wter u nto e. nd ueranwh y e epedor ga, atoefobs d gis ouboesreuit diertl a w tta hain aou awe fr dfentpos. nd metuesonea onevopnt bmeans itretetoif srt tes >>'lbrflcoen ao oaedoceyyth ocy,ndhe's tnsio iuseyhalel d n dan ll u,itus t ir yngantrng toea tm w ppey chckitutnri ope
10:07 am
s et hd. so ceu, wn e oe e unr,heer is otllsoersy, r otr in w-- cy , thk,s t o tt et wl aoojo. >it pttimrtt. >>drbawiwi s meinfit. >>s, wtetoenon ef c'mo scefu cpanshes , ou evti rogti a name otrmac ai jy. wvha iunor deadno wee stbud er mli tia, aid miio acs ccuioprenon reogti danemt. 'miatoma cuon nt, cch al ce ofsial ho pfeiol er n t ntha o t caai iinbeoced id a sthpeonhales e itti h cate ea hotorie toheouer
10:08 am
pulio 'r gntoeomngut wh a ithne f ons, ge ll rke bleshas intoeah dabt ncsi a cousonrentn. ef e olinheoo cstors rsi aresanedatn d rtnlweavtrd d tt er dnowi se ofurea. me, ares aress awress the t psaladto acki. ne e intoe gd ou. i w a ihoanla ekhas beevleo techidabt ncsin. faasc. t t e aresofhe cch t pen, t est ttr. th ks en gngo lfept, d'tno aresss oduns wedelohethar presons atndst w rntra pplbak tht eilis. 'rgoggo veomre frsttepant emllheim th'shoom touceer d ck'senr.
10:09 am
eoe ptn cledoo pplto d'tvepl or ainpelehadi't kees f aea ismangrg wha fe ssonrn autoval wene. mn t k dsn gt a asfo pcee' d tt tn hge cedor ccsi. weeetorath aun taleah tse i u al ce ou, nsse rcn jt e ope avbnetng ncsis r 2 lln yrsf lk arhalocaeven wre noaldent. c wl reangary peatcis ng- nhigrp e e y, crs > . ckdrhali. >>twgrpse owheeat inonn,t'inheou dn d.
10:10 am
ihi t o, - ey we gti ty yw, efa, t eihe, d ctllon tt ff t stonqucerohe iurisheldly ndhedeinradlafr tht,has otr ol polaon e ut is maerf cesowto mteof banc fsoal 'sot- titshod t beablulyfrd aea iurto paicatg srt rmofeaor ites erce,erna deelme, spsendllf 0 thoskis tng pos s vaab ntbuono r ciy. wt nd d ihi, a etrobsn reof heoaesndheraer inheou, ptila trear nsnddscrs eoa. ro ahi soolel whter acr awthshrt
10:11 am
sawaso coac anweenon ieupe he auay e ugr anrdinure en cchg ds yo auay veo ve rfitn,so ting nd se tu w tt u motre atoue en trne tnkornes gon rainthlel,noed op rpoib othe ki athr acnghe i antgetoneth tngi ou he ntne arerth fr outh on tve ccuio, athe'so bckr d rkn emheshldev patipa itsga. thri oa fm reea cousonepd aumr fto, mb o, e f thcouson onsileve dsnt
10:12 am
ecdyo ft. itepdsn e mef e enanthchacriicf tt enuath sfed d hnle. > cmes lle okg atpo aa bl hlt od. nd tnkerehr is atreerimrtt atca ars eho lren e utspt. e tt l niol gerngods o cnt e gnorso at cl thamic delme mel ndt'a iq oorniy orngitthus a a o th pre gazaontoo at aa ngeratet vopntrossndhas crelyotapni wl eug utveonisn aran nssn ulbearof tt. th sonisanconeha deenono istoe
10:13 am
coh n heot al veo iho uine ansa aoa, d 's isncy ffenth eop whyoreeqresera ndd urofpo ain i s cordo stig, tulyhi monig,drsi ths,ndhiomhi tt hecahabe iold th wi t niol vein boesoritou23 pos,s ate' dng srtpeficoercean brgi i t cce o delongoainedatn. t h tstt t yth lel d at setng hasxptnay poan i ine'grinmenum rha ehi ithe edtoe mee pte o ks. at eowinpeleucas th alec airs t ahlictrne a oblyheine st imrtt rs tt ulbe teornyorofonc clionve. 'smpta en ts uny,orxaleinh stef lirn, hli tins e t enegat, aoncaho ua ine nday'mn hlicraer
10:14 am
3500emrsf e ho r htileuendhe'sot ethtitrne th'rthpelehane t eowed ss listi wree fid ovasthti tinantmhyicns thk wcage igtoeso e eran evopntocohe ucio eow alec tsehr tng mbedilsht e fe iyothspth aytng kn o tnkoumrchrm. tnkouoronni ts o. wt o cha aou o wht . inneai outrne, wo o pocynddua iates3 o soo hve aid. 63% n' tt riclo. iss e sit y o ro o komhenjie ascieditcoetiv
10:15 am
sptswhheite otll ici ows acspt, oranotr or bh evti a tatntid wh y hei sin juesinudg taroic inurs,heacwean ve fth i alec airss al bl hlt qesonha wihi nedoadres. teae s deser huretrne ihi soos stn e stou yrs nde' he aouemt onth pntga tor t aratiwa aenal othscnticueio t ma unsre timov thpuiceah ourt fo bh ysndir ithe igolge anth'shi wreoi toonnutwo o lemeadro a li erecve w snt se tme colef yar aghefl di wh nuerf h orrsrod e uny, trelg ou so at asd. ythonssna isa aut fom ayog n me
10:16 am
zaarlist w ffe aat binnjy o ftbl d tuedoooo ntouyes ttg 0 ta lss a ty' et spltiarnd enfyg uran sung cldidt tu topl. emnsat, thk,h as tre aasinth c b doe omoly d ucio pepeivtoai aress ofeoe rtipininou spt moe edtoe nen is gd. osla a n aanea is e rsti tt'be ne thk atig ba de n lkbo aweo rwd rmpvi ythpos. ndth trdot wa t mti. drgia s mb aunus hedsf otllroam e si w eca yth oaesasav mntn. 1500coheha bn aid ccuio enfiti awe awa tteh e meppprte, whh eei ifobal, wh tinode ntctn ho tteh ckng thas 0,0 acs reesti wl reha1
10:17 am
mlin dsho teeea a dn kw yinabt ncsi. sohe a he alngs t otnsmotae esanif thwi gupf op he, scen tt wod ere, n inthugthscnc iniaivs,ouanak ogsshe rdr ieif >>urssscenhuo. kg e deyorae u hd ea tnkoumrchrm. ictllha t qstn orr.ilr,hei'li t asmi mee- rr d. mceaad qstn. 5 arth mthog auchetedi ca t pssonree. hetyrod e time e ffed nbeof cousonth ssoan mew tein tt cld tolatonmo ccuio
10:18 am
treoud e g oue. d n kwha mriwa edi d t owhatet wa ud t asmethe as a tr othe s tet eryocod eltt' noh. ithleueodats thste--t-t,ifou l f seo w h h peti esos h trum >>ir, t ptilaca geba, rricha 'sonono teifal suesul--e s ea inooalbuhi pot-otllucss he be tric. heueiois mic eio a wh cheaphicn d inheasofheflwee dd uffiedoori tes dgnti oth inriafliedocr oea sele d rtr dendt xprtw he clar pyeberee' lod py aitn o nstaonitthn th uffiad dendt cts
10:19 am
coeso r atarcur iivua eriso nctensr th qstn. oreanshyi feto mofheeoe ou t talehoreoi tknw re bo dgnti a tatnt anreve. >>ga, aw 3 yrsgo i ulha eecd e ciceo vedvcemoe antabeaue e ermsnvtmnthat n ha a sfowl. lemes u, bcae d tse t vi b iid rd e oo th dscptnn eoo gusha u' cl end ca f con tumic chapay s keeber t ptsrgstle. anheada cse pndor coeatn r h lg-rmnjie e s enal ardd mpsaonhr yrsftr s iue t qstn hae
10:20 am
,s atrossetr w ant s n aragth a plerasorppinfo enitfr dabit rt ofheeae? >yeh,thditbefi quti ianmpta o. i se ssck h a sw tth. shdo wk aadca a imrtt rkas aoce frerelarsndthir mie ihk taner - o st reencs mp, e osrent lcte rgni aeen walcad dion $ lln was tid ays prras. 'sofoue,orho w ad t yrsefe e de ain apr19. iadti, ers nuerf prgrs pceoreted plerarwhcles prra aoctewi pye dent cleth88la a neodenate see le lzim's rns'swioucaatn ifyoreiv dgnis ani inthe mo tn 0 ays t
10:21 am
o ohiroama reiv befs. yolletaronn nul siiner othpaen. wlletntthfure args wte t s c fus othscntichigsit t ccuio. u venoerueioin th aa? l mas y oioly he peptie n is ieaabt isllss y, 'sevtangorh diidl o ntctitbu 'destinfothfal trgentrothfali, the'anngonnu twhchheamy s o a soanouivusomingh fr t fils rscte? ianonibe thg ortoy,ecse'mot ocr,ut he at c imre un u l w diict d ag aisse i no for t sfien-- i- hetae o i wat ty tou, rtullyn e y eny sbd ede hanodewh w hpen
10:22 am
tnkorhoe atsue d, lstheha t befiofnonghe's urogalau f wt ty' suginwi a oblbe emlvs lss any sbd oblyi metay,langimlfor saireustoe e n ate d en t r e mi, 's destin i an orsteheapit foth dea trifali ar y no wveee-- e a i w jt ki .cke s kns atheot nbeis heaiarnd8019 wenoalofthfilwe knw e inalisri, acanevy e tse nio a iivua w ss ay thheevtang see. de oenthe a wdo whfl, ry oen exiv, -wesho fl ryuiy ldg his geer in alhosti y m re
10:23 am
ris wn e mi's incthawt'no yokn, thk athee ar--he a se net th t n iab tprid tothr rm pye ad thkones orh. rtf e obm thhee thngisha en r rmr plertoccemnls in he and,hai' unarofthe ays v tobeesd icmes u vhatolafo yrsn heeae. cnofoethidiasis beg agos pplwh ev pyeinheflorho he eo enfi,he a ac ttu, tho eaenancoenti rmofhe teyeoi t fd isreme. ani n llouhafali ren ryve de ras antharaoof ndidlseay,eay stggng apecteou wt a y, d iss obla rg dcuio a ye a aalagth coite t voedn e
10:24 am
eioofomtiabe d thnaon ftbl ag, ndt ris , okg th ctiumf isisse th tt y aasctf hi wfoseonhaasn s wrehefleed fos,utlspeapit iexhe ines b stdi pha trialea a mpenhrnitumic cealat minitlf apart. >>ldhi uornal as ryucthca. hba pseaw a45 hwaa ryve dfent mafr t m iadno, t pseaw yngan t'alst- 's vy rgehi f mtoonde ate y velmt o ey cae loofhe miesha ipkit d se aotf lissa t f scins. ld wenho hbas ar yngs yrsldomng inndheabs iear ki h iitlendetng h o, d eye ra o eio fey ndowon-- thk sote is iue tht s bloedt.
10:25 am
anthe'a t penal enouhi othars e aiafct tt ey lak e ily ctr iulhe oton iali icoroseanyo o ts bityndag aolilcoinio i ou tnkbsuty t wod aonrn dcu ifr t mity tapot. sisyto imita a ice te me loe eik aol ind.d.nef e in tat wetrglwi ithwath tnt- me ostoheik sry thwapaen ce u ' mma, % le18 3eaol, ysal cte,hehi i ith a pshiri a my ope inprarca cni wre teengpelrhtafr hevead ccuio as pchtrt,ore ne
10:26 am
ttee t ncsi ine itptd,a sode ay mb ootr in a fks on jt meo u yi i haa ncsi a he'wh pne dgnticlifatn a gess. i' hrdisily out n colef . v.. heulh scic em oftsbuasrtni t ex bwe t iul wh hped wnre ive rdors. rtnlaursoly su d e ke >>he munrsndg, nd'm dscsg isas a fl v over o. nye op w he en dinod t pt thts d mir mpmso at ms ha isang suidey dti, gmas,roleinocl anno 'r rling a l o th ifr ccuio. aolel 've, ryhaenngo aeri its mpngn o. tus e or mice de
10:27 am
prveioantrtmt t e an. wecat tt d et atntwhe eyre so l me lrn as psiani ve 2-eaol hs enalng 30da a h h hd 0 me fo ielhitoalitff d b meirint, wt tsa h c ios se ts ye-o bau hedon'gi ma sty. ittrese at l omy paen c'tivme hto sobo wthaend,wh ithped, ahaapn owtrm,ndh wweee toovthrear smuh. >>i stantoddbeus i i wreetngixg ouleis,he'sh ise aonsse cin iss at w tintoay beor oncousonhoyotrt ha wn pplgoacono e elorheveth'rgog, an t sonquti ict esonwhh read
10:28 am
an is t ieaitou beeptecousonbuit caal ba ngisryf peti f st , ay i n aocr t rtf suouiv, oun, m t su wha -weav citic tao ppt l ofha l masth. ta paseerfo eifatn. iansooninhiro t deifhoyo--hayo ooatn m, fo io toouwh y'rloinat p.tsc, el mwt ue okg r. thmoe s l outh-- k mee scbehayo ewh y'rloinfo deri tt. t acy atouikt her. e n'sewh wwa t e. l mju gma iasime as c.
10:29 am
ithenste ndio s iste dea, e ai s velyegeredndha ilsh uonn i ans seretrh d e lpt,e in i aretn f e l otn e rvces d ats e gtue c, ialo ve iorntn zhmes ssedent, p. ltleifre deas th isalroingggaons a d to wheroles,s u ve ckn meo op w a t veldeend,th beom tckr kw at thdiercear ate veund srcth wl oatth aibeusnoyocaony mae e agsiin bin afr omneie tenme the ai f t omr
10:30 am
gnur a tn e x ste,noerra wre fdi, me to ngtuin u t flo pplatistoinwh e agg gnur oa patilaclic syroe,chaerti clnil ndomaea wc sath ianccat dinos,f yanz e ccrig. as e tuiowee w. 'rrelynftute sck thheroeme edo anehera tkn i seby s . b wshldt y ay- >>ete ni u kwoue intoo r whle kn ts y. , e obm , ici hi wveoto roouon thtae,e itll-- dot owbo a tug isou ba reve. wekn ihaedn xe. tofi o ihaen t pelehoav1,0 tsn an,t'noth mh reelio t fd ipeleh
10:31 am
he ghchl cle eosesr fd ia brn nkdooryo non t binan lk t mo in tfi iin 30 opelehoavpled sptsweowon kw w mn iss. n'kn wth erye wedot .gss soweeay e spatto ryndige t y o dino ts ppl hve cplofclsute vtoorthe t >>ye, erarlo owas toiaoseay gniv fitsr rlbevir a ige.yso agsecu th d'tnvvemangt thprenti a m n i thsht rm n scic? rht e vehycaex. wha nroycloca stg. psiog ms,hyca e acnganurog, dr cli aear n.
10:32 am
pltyf yso agsi ifweelvehisks llng edo ea aulmol prcho semet. 'sev gngo aine s 'sev gngo $00 m odt is t t ortem. b whanianth kw hotoo i ndesrcrsrod e bl tht n t geerndav putoth mtida sssmts at wt reah . th'shamyesrcis as atvebo'sesrc . as otct f c awe, sote f c. at h wdinoe lzim's wcawa uilheern pis d okt ein teta corrica reeahsreloki ely idcofdenta,okn. ndhado n iole mang itinlv oeresnghih wello. > wod d erha bn nbeofois ierts is ihi ithla 1or 15mit atstrto covee ou aomn em
10:33 am
didus theeng vy siil eose ofes ha - ladu asicly dfentiv? itaso aomexatx puchne tt edt rik. is t ts ndiosht eranlo tm f t heroni tre aine pdiorarbl thescto nger ouco,hbunig eiois atreheis? ho pvantrehe whist skndhy aarthfaorth ectis ho clde teupor evt osris? a i--hearlequti atheti i iexsu orwh wofntes sayow n mni nbeofot cousonorowuctol exose,s nesry suienoreierr thn pricngonterm rk
10:34 am
neoliceah obms al othe esonrein aner. > wa tmae revyby haa an tasqutis. gahd,a i cceedheflasa trblg co odein scenfiinirin te ris pyi ftb ea ct pliedn of cte in the brain, and former player mike webster, nfl doctors went on a campaign to discredit and undermine both the doctor and his, who. the doctors went so faas to demand retraction of the dotos er-revwed resent orheex14ea t nl purueatregvemel denngheoti sgn tf idce of ct afoer ays. eeae soeg
10:35 am
prucg npe ea at owg seusmo iep ieif c ba a lketohric biname. te laerathfmaonntn g-rmeah plnsf taleooal asebar4,01 redathsur ow dl rg, mb o a sne ce. dies ot lk,nqteenfl udng ait on , que ascifoba a teecerlars hae heisas the ali
10:36 am
ysiawacae meayantolaabsh cneruy asniin ghghthnfs ley ngthneotum othsilis . thy unnghefl sarreci danon wa taspnaithe s e s udleuciniave fosi ocouson isedli a fseri. otll rk or bauroinhi, t ju dgnio. atcapuicee ows ney th clrlmo reah,t rksnhinopar spfoba.so jt nto at onrobo d mle drmcea kr.cca,o s li bwen fo denate ai dorrsct
10:37 am
e.eeplinfoba veeeit0 t 9 ays osbrn aed45 ou55olgelarsnd hh ho pye. doth rrent wisisses e vgoplaon bu t fvefi yrsi' bo acmutehi n ce inooalpler i r f tnke e into rid h cmoi . an thi ieay wa tase ts issit n aut couson ine ayf e met evy leev oth ge. he ema sme culaveeaimct edo veenrsr aceler se y gainthnuerf pas d imth swea ininafr hles
10:38 am
peal ayoh vewh ty n'inndo he fabt otl weavse my me la d te ales m do wh e see. 'sevtangheyose th dea i-yr-d. iont hi is mm, t ' sn or d nd er ant r tomehaoujoisas amic cizs,o inin heh tseoug htefothenre o eilndf ers meinweano li ths skt edtoe ne imdiel tnkou r.ilr,o u inthe lk twn otllnd denate aidirds kete >>aiy . k's rear sws nbeof tid laerar
10:39 am
iaos wh e. bu traraerf s. eio tt meitth. >>i esi st- rht ithe li. s. > cae he en- fe tt u owth w n th uquoc awethe dsefreheup bl y . tcller >>'motoispk r r.err. >>yoasd qutith i out erwaa nk tnkerin bedn r.ck'sesrcthe'a li bau s'sou c i nuerf tid otll pye t bad in a t oe urueio t wt es tt anwhe wgoro erwi t iortin. enweta oua nkr e des pvanchi aso othmecaexr arndheab -foth co, m t meca psiia, fl mid ieis-- dero e peplarndheab wt he iee anarndhe qustn atoue kig. ha a -anhe
10:40 am
sui nto tuay tbu bcls ke fousoerlar, ehath foupitue hinof--nyy taed datg r brino e cae vus s wor , e s s' aedd atheayav seracouson buth ao ysha "te w rkim,"heo e ml hlod o vete thneyorert whh fod utt s oufelethtecl sfegrteras uso pot orsyto tecousonan emsttereermprmt urg icl
10:41 am
testing for experiencing concussions when compared with their male counterparts. and the idea that there needs to be more research and nih actually just now, 2016, said that gender has to be a consideration in all pretrial and in clinical trials. so animals have to have gender difference as well as the clinical trials. and so i -- i just want to put that out there. i want to ask, do we need to reconsider whether or not sports need to change for minors? should we, for example, eliminate headers in soccer? should we be considering whether children, minors, ought to be playing tackle football at all throughout their lives? do we need to have a more comprehensive view of whether or not we should subject our
10:42 am
children to these kinds of sports? you know, adults who want to play professional athletics and want to risk this kind of thing, it seems to me that's their decision. as long as they know the risks. but children, should we change sports? >> from the standpoint of what you're asking about gender issues and at-risk populations and bringing this back to scientific level, can someone respond? first, dr. gioia and hainline. >> a conference at georgetown a few weeks ago looked at the issue of gender and concussion in particular. one of the things i presented at that meeting was that it's -- it actually is age and your gender. we in fact, in our work, have found that boys and girls are not different either in terms of their symptom expression when preadolescent, but when they're adolescents we see big differences between boys and girls and symptom expression.
10:43 am
we don't know why. but that also -- when boys and girls are not injured, whether young or adolescent, we don't see them talking about nonconcussive symptoms differently. so there's something about concussion in adolescents that is an issue here. i'll go back to kind of the point i made earlier, which that is we don't understand enough about girls in this kind -- >> what direction are girls different than boys? >> higher symptoms. adolescent girls are reporting more symptoms and taking relatively longer to recover than boys. >> is it true that no female athletes have been found to have cte? >> that's true. we've only had four female brain donors and they weren't all athletes. it has been twice described in literature, one was a domestic abuse situation where she had been abused for many years by her husband. another one was autistic woman who banged her head, repetitive
10:44 am
head banger. the demographic of sports and military service favor men at this point. we expect this to change because of the recent increase of women in contact sports and certainly in the military. but we are actively trying to recruit female brain donors to answer this very important question, is there a gender difference in the outcome from repetitive head injury. >> doctor, do you have an answer to that? >> yes. i think the main issue here is we're talking about complicated injury in the most complicated organ in the body. we don't have a natural history study from the time that a kid gets injured or somebody has repetitive injuries through the course of the development of something like cte. for example, we had a colleague, cardiothoracic surgery. it completely changed the way we've looked at it. what we need today is a longitudinal study of the problem to understand what is the incident of this. we need better diagnostic tools.
10:45 am
we don't have beyond a clinical exam a really objective biomarker or blood-based biomarker. we need better ways to predict who are those people who aren't going to do well. i think really it comes down to funding. your pamphlet indicates nih is spending $93 million to understand a problem that costs over $70 billion a year. there are professional athletes who make more money in a single contract than the doctor had to fund research that we're asking questions about today. in many ways, the gap can be closed by better care, better follow-up, better screening and unfortunately we have to make a bigger investment in the problem to understand this. again, i'm overjoyed that the american public has turned a problem that as a neurosurgeon working in a level i trauma center in an urban environment i've seen this and consequences of traumatic injury for decades. so i really appreciate that
10:46 am
you're interested in this, but there's got to be a more sustained and powerful investment to understand the problem. >> dr. hainline? >> so i want to speak with some cautious optimism about where we may be. so the ncaa and the department of defense joined forces, a little more than a year and a half ago. we have begun a study, and we're going to be getting results real-time. so this is a study that is involving 30 schools. at each school every single student athlete, whether female tennis player or male football player undergoes rigorous multimodal examination. if they're concussed it's repeat the six hours, 48 hours, onward in six months. seven sports, three women's sports, women's soccer, lacrosse, ice hockey, the same for men, and men's football. also getting genetic testing, kids are wearing sensors and getting brain mris.
10:47 am
just in a year and a half, we've done studies on 18,000 student athletes and tracked over 700 concussions. a large study before that may have been upwards around 20 concussions i'm happy to say to people at table, mickey collins is a participant, mike mccrea is a principal developer, the colonel and i spent a year putting this together. geoff manly and i met, we're working in a cross functional way that has never happened before in concussion research. there are so many people that are invested just in this study alone. what we're going -- what we're doing, and dr. mckee can speak to this, i'm not allowed to evaluate the results firsthand because that would be a conflict of interest. walter and i and dallas, we're on the executive committee of the study. we have oversight but we don't have voting power. it's set up in a way that that it's a nonconflict of interest
10:48 am
study. we will be having a few things. the study's going to provide definitive evidence. in the short term, within two years, on what is the natural history of concussion. just concussion. we're also going to be defining neurobiological recovery in concussion. which is exceptionally important. that's different than symptom recovery. we will have that data. mike mccrea can speak better to it. but closer to another year we'll have definitive data on what it does mean to be neurobiologically recovered. we're coming back to washington in three days, laying foundation to put this into a five-year study and make this the framingham study of concussion. it's going to be a 35-plus-year study. it doesn't mean we're waiting 35 years. it means in very, very active five-year increments we're going to be coming in with new tools, including p.e.t. scans and advanced brain imaging to understand what are we seeing in
10:49 am
these increments. are we actually seeing there are problems for certain groups of populations. it's not just ncaa athletes. every single cadet at west point is enrolled, and we're studying these individuals as well. in addition, for everyone who is concussed, they have a control and their contact collision sport and noncontact sport. for the first time we're going to have real data on those who have had repetitive head contact but haven't been concussed. so that's something that we're going to be actively looking at. concussed, something we're going to be actively looking at. that's ongoing, it's very real, and the first wave of analysis is going to be reported sometime not going to hold you to it mike, but in the late spring. and it's going to be going on after that but even while we're, while we're waiting for these results, so just two weeks ago there were 15 of the most prominent medical organizations in sports medicine organizations in the country. and we looked at the first round
10:50 am
of the results, including very, very detailed head sensor data. and i, i'm not putting out a specific date, but you're going to see coming probably within the next three months some very new recommendations that are going to be called interassociation guidelines, not ncaa-specific. but it's going to be equally endorsed by the american medical society for sports medicine. the congress for neurologic surgeons on concussion diagnosis and management with regard to our football practice, the ivy league was in the room with us, their information was leaked earlier than they wanted. there's going to be a whole new emphasis on absolute recovery. which is something that's been overlooked as well. i'm just a little optimistic that we do have something very hot in the pipeline, that's very real and we're getting accurate results. >> does anybody here, anybody at this table think we should change the rules of the sports for our student athletes, shoot
10:51 am
headers in soccer, should headers in soccer be eliminated? or any way change football? >> i feel and brian you brought so much to this field. with the research you're overseeing and managing. i think we need science to lead the way. i think it, it really, behooves us to put science first in understanding these issues. because if we make sweeping changes on sports without having the science, there could be unintended consequences that i see every day in clinic. so i just want to make a pitch for science to lead the way. >> if we don't fund this for longer than the two years it's going now. five years, we're going to be back in five years. this is not a five-year problem. this longitudinal needs to go on and headers are not the problem in soccer. >> richard hudson has a question, and then paul tonka. >> did you want to say something, too? i would just say, i hesitate to
10:52 am
wait on the science when we know changes in the game conversation such a tremendous impact on children. i would say absolutely we should be having a conversation about the wisdom of putting our kids in activities where their heads are getting hit. repeatedly over and over when we know that for some individuals those consequences can be very, very dire. and we don't know yet about the risk factors. we don't know yet about those that are going to ultimately be you know, have the consequences of something like cte. but we absolutely know that no head trauma is good head trauma. and i believe there are ways we can, we can absolutely make games safer without toying with the fundamentals of the game. soccer, absolutely. they just did, they did just raise the age at which they will introduce heading in soccer. the, the usa hockey, raising the age at which checking, all those are going to make tremendous differences in terms of making kids safer. think we should explore each and
10:53 am
every opportunity to make every sport safer in ways that don't change the game. but absolutely that conversation should be had. >> i want to make sure we get our members' questions in, let me go to mr. hudson. >> thank you, mr. chairman. i say at the outis the, i represent the home of the carolina panthers. but i did marry a girl from denver, so i have to congratulate you on the super bowl victory. i appreciate you wearing the panther blue jacket today. >> sorry. i've become very interested in the issue of pediatric trauma. we're starting to look at this issue, my issue was piqued by the children's institute of medical science in wake forest, north carolina. they're doing a lot of work to try to look at some of these questions, they've got studies to put sensors in helmets to look at not just the big hits, but the long-term effects. but one of the things that struck me was the disparity of
10:54 am
care. if your child suffer as trauma incident and you happen to live near a level 1 pediatric trauma center, your kid has a great chance of surviving. if you happen to live in the part of the country that doesn't have a close proximity. then a lot of problems. that's one of the things that nags at me and the chairman and also chairman upton have helped me get a gao study to look at this issue across the spectrum of how care is delivered. so it was interesting to me when you brought this issue of awareness but also how do we take the research and understanding that you all are developing and then have it available and where the rubber meets the road, where the care is actually happening. maybe i would throw that open. >> dr. bowman to dr. joy. >> i mentioned our brain injury guidelines. another active area of inquiry is clinical support tools within
10:55 am
health records. integrating across their, moving their across their health care settings, from their eds to their primary cares to urgent cares, all their clinicians, whether or not they have advanced medical education in concussion management. their protocols are built in to their clinical support. so the care that they receive regardless of the setting that they show up for care in, is identical or near identical. think that's really critical. since i have the mic, the other thing i wanted to mention is another active area of inquiry for cdc, mr. miller had mentioned earlier, all 50 states having return to play laws, we're interested in what are the best practices within those return to play laws, as well as return to learn protocols, so we're actively evaluating if they work, how they work what are the components of laws that need to be in place. so those are a couple of things. thank you. >> to recognize that what brian and ncaa and mike and others are
10:56 am
doing with the d.o.d. i think is laudable and it's 18 years too advanced. we need to do that with kids. we need the same kind of focused research forum for kids below the age of 18. below college levels. and part of the reason that we ha haven't is we haven't had the organized advocacy and organized research systems that are set up to some extent by the way the ncaa and d.o.d. potentially have them. actually the children's institute is part of a consortium that we're developing on pediatric brain injury called the four corners consortium. dallas knows about this as well. it's trying to model what is actually happening at the collegiate and above level. really for kids. really to look at that question, what are the risk exposures? what are not, how do we understand epidemiology of this, as well as the treatment. so i do think this some priorities need to be reset. not just to start with our collegiate athletes, but really
10:57 am
to start with our youngest kids and moving that forward. it can then link with what is going into the ncaa, into the d.o.d. that means the cdc, the nih and others need the funding support to make that happen. >> one of the things that's happened in youth sports over the last 20 years has made this more difficult and i think there's ways to overcome that. in that the participation in school-based sports is actually declined. while the club-based sports has increased dramatically. but that becomes the wild west out there. and we need to have some way that even if the club-based sports, they get incorporated into the systems that were developed. >> just wanted to just clarify, just one point, that george, nih, we have looked up a portfolio and we agree that this issue of understanding the effects of children is a gap and
10:58 am
that seems to have been at currently our highest priority to fill the gap is further research. so thanks for that. >> and to that point, i appreciate brian mentioning the care consortium. all of these things start to hang together. with the mentioning of track, tbi and the four corners initiative that jerry is heading up. within a year the care consortium will have 25,000 collegiate athletes enrolled. we estimate that we'll be over 1200 concussed athletes. who have arguably represent the most richly characterized cohort of injured athletes ever enrolled in a study. that provides a unique opportunity. and you know, i hate to keep coming back to this, this point. but the reason we're sitting here debating a number of very fundamental issues about long-term risk and outcome, is because in large part, there has
10:59 am
never been a truly population-based prospective longitudinal study of outcome after traumatic brain injury. the military and the va has invested in the sensing to do exactly that in military service members and veterans. but to date, we've never done that in the civilian setting. and track tbi provides the most richly characterized cohort of civilians affected by traumatic brain injury of all severity. and c.a.r.e. represents the largely and most richly characterized cohorts of athletes affected. as brian points out, we not only have detailed on clinical recovery. but we have blood biomarkers, we have genetics, we have imaging that tells bus the neurobiology of this injury, as the doctor was pointing out earlier. the fact of the matter is again, i keep preaching to the choir here. the likelihood that a single variable, whether it's injury or exposure predicts outcome, i think has already fallen on
11:00 am
failure. because again, we look at two individuals with seemingly the same profile of exposure or injury, with drastically different outcomes even over the short-range, over 10 days and over an entire lifetime. it will take a monumental efforts and there are low-hanging fruit that we can grab early on that would answer some of the fundamental questions. in terms of what is the, what is the risk associated with exposure. whether it's subconcussive or injury. but what's the multiple matrix of factors that predict outcome? we've been chasing this single solution for decades and it's destined to failure and i think that's the lesson learned and the dilemma we face at present. >> dr. manly you had something on that? >> one of the things i think we're all very passionate about
11:01 am
youth sports and what happens with kids we talked a lot about the community impact. i don't want to forget about the elderly. the fastest-growing population of concussion and brain injury in this country is in the elderly. there's been at least a 50% increase in the last five years. and in california it's been higher than that. and less than 1% of the literature has spoken to this. we've excluded these people from all prior clinical trials and as best i can tell, knowing a lot of these people over the years, we're all moving in this direction. and the cancer doctors and the heart doctors have just done a wonderful job. and this is going to be an ongoing problem. i know this is a big problem and there's a lot to chew and i'm glad we're at least talking about in but i don't want to forget the elderly. because this is a population we need to be very mindful of. >> thank you for redirecting us. that's incredibly important. paul tonko of new york. >> thank you, mr. chair. >> all the talk of cte and i'd like to take a step back and just focus on that for a moment.
11:02 am
and dr. mccrea or whoever around the room. when was it recognized as a unique disease? and is there a distinct quality to it that separates it from alzheimer's disease or other neurodegenerative diseases? and what likely is the biggest cause? i heard you know, you talking about extending beyond concussions and also just head injuries. and the final item i would throw all of this out there as a question or observation. there's talk, too, of clusters of depression and suicide. are there things that we're already learning about the impact as it relates to suicide or mental health, mental illness or mental health disorders? >> well i can say that i
11:03 am
think -- cte, i can't say when it exactly was identified as a unique disease. because it's been known since the 1920s. there was advances in the 1970s about the neuropathological and clinical characteristics, but i actually do think it was the ninds consensus conference, which was held just a year ago, that established this is a unique disease, it can be distinguished pathologically from alzheimer's disease. it can distinguished from aging or all these other unusual tao-based diseases like progressive supernuclear palsy. this was done by a planl of expert neuropathologists who were blinded to slides. they got a box of 700 slides, they sifted through them, it took about 100 hours each. in over 90% of the cases, correctly identified cte. so there's a -- they even went further and said there was a
11:04 am
characteristic lesion in cte that they've never seen in any other disorder. and this panel of experts also said that in their combined experience, they've never seen th deain yo w as't pedraa, tyiclymutieepsosf trum has ouasdiine a sseasocofoat lettloy. aweetrglg whis atrethpef cnil actiscs itas t oerps th zhmesissewh estsatanhe fe wh i psen elyfe inth 3s, i c b pssn,itcabe peonit isde. itane og ggssonmplivyan descolce it r tif touth mombeu tey necic b wre sinit wthma o ndidlsit e, fnd pt-rt wnweoot e inalar
11:05 am
deesonve omn.. iceatyco agreio vle bavr. sht s exosetan mor roem tseou bth stomn cnil ditus. tyothk u. dth vacerear tat wod, o dionear atoe fwa? at e scrtialt y g rr >> tnkth n fdi o helog-rm pspti rm nnd ielveoong olgethteov ti. thbe lltehelle erllvaatgthm,eay evluio,eayigi, helleglodes a foowhe deh. ndthhofuye' bab tode awa time t see thtaty ano urng at pbalyheos poanthngweando a isin dino di lfe we c enfyt tseou atet, u plth t t gmer hvee
11:06 am
odho eang soe ral nt r idnticio ri fe an ithnkhseenea n ud wloonaytord swin o es eson >>hk uve ch rrdo y he lw- y wto k? ts w jtebref yo mtiedom oit iaoscl watarlo st o thaou c lpiaoan a bin oiolyaracdias, hrts. yoge a o apk cayo tn cbiti wh idraic stieut'm nwa o wtheissit eleso ebrn? tt elwh ias e o., ersotngha aprod tispot. erreorth dfent ottitaet woofhhvetulye thug t vol trls
11:07 am
ereno i alyed a peo edtohe t d o tise f pral thda tt'e lks ergon i th, edeha u cin fa masren meinth ppedinhe i treot , i acuay s die st o sty aut ,15yes ag me-- bodra brr a sueul'tos lle'cwnhe as wth vryi sns intrens,here bakwn odtsr bininry tt se gnt t lod. nd hve so hpeth th nxte'ee apr tend ttil bte inraraju,ju ke g btt ieadea. >>orebr in flid >>orus a i hrtse ndtre, ares f t clnianabtho t jst ma tiaoshhe co in tht ulo es ischpe a aoteaie
11:08 am
i ul hpels'ea datnnd fdirgog rsu blod tes,ute acuay vees w,he rnos i e e.or o hefi ttfidor bafid,weandinoe ow >>ouhi eydo eah ey su kebl a yode >>se, mnhaspartofhe otol a bng dneuily ofcose de . tn emeti ere o heor ct jt trti espl a wve enoi i pttoo ror ar obecfyitneha d bulicnsan auay neheolndino em fir sy, uty. remt t,noo mu. wvea ind i' gngoskuti i wt erod t sw pa tisn. r j t ghfoatn ndh b rwdak listi romndio, bugesssoth cmiee
11:09 am
surdiio erah, h. surdiio or ni dmh pofna , dean he. 'moi a isquti, iwa ehfouo aw wheream ouwao cme fminer wat d nd no atoe cgrseeo kow etert a romndi ortihaeha t avinth aas es veio dagsid trtmt? wt,hasouta t y yo nto meuth cmieeknws m in t sarhe,door yocastt. mkeu yur misn. >>so wldayinerms o ohiin aou0 ecds r us, i iwe osreon ure. v tinal wat thirrik,lmt a rsk screndamghm. ecaadceres, ppl
11:10 am
dflpler sha herisrenger fo i lemyhae,an ouctut oth eryndstdhe fes bst iur blartuiposou e inry anth' togoet a heroemeledoblts lshe ptil a aty jy. an ve o000 ta oabexse o as e ower lt otng abutha hpps thir ais. d mre >> tnk t reurnthe ith tre aet o fnt qstnsha epoti pitntow 'rnostti fom scat. 'vmanoou s or thpa esth p th pheheelein oan nmb ur cleuearndheoury dhe rlcaesnhe uto rely swho ndenal qus.
11:11 am
eaj deakgshrein t oi rqu a gnic veme oth of bl a pvapanehis. th w noma talendnsr t ital esonth t blomn an t koww. dwecaaner tosi cice >>r. ha? wt ar scef cnil ia set bot i e' h0ro fled ic ia. wee duip aales hyfale ye kep dnth ta wy. ' ieas mchasm t roesadca he loitintuesnd tse in is,to sme ete os e st mri e roem edo ndremes r i a t ge w ndto g a thfuamta isu oh t udsa fle la iveo fbeus yo oagtere 'soi s wtou hae sa. > o a
11:12 am
we he -se denionofcouso a mes o nos. wteis nhe's ulplfoms iju r wee ttinoictos, etr eyreimin oobad orks. th hrts gat de thg. t brehne 'no jt cnilam it gngo svelin. ti w he a aos,we caotav aarte a uilweha aaet eaen wreev gin t avago tce. t whaweeeei, t gd-wsstyers otofsar wki tetr s onoonda emts ndbas wicwerell sri. kwh n oernis gog ltool th. e stutn,ee tyi t rkoghe i bl-pva panehis,riin i ndtr a pcoetiv roen t fguutow t mae diercehe. nef hehis dfite nd,see mrendg. ilons n out th. iiser ry broem n e it at,the of mey foangrodn ffenplndino erstf obmsbu
11:13 am
wveeamvebo hre th tis i aarpuic alh su th aress i hrend is tie p t mey e t u nduo tis ufsowe nak ffen f ratnt a e amie s.che? iego a hrdto m > atwhe fltrl tw is. n' ero e righ tits inheia. iisu lkenc. 'no osigl nty,nd rhtne eat kene ty,t'uipisse inon soeon ro triht rk ithis. dhe msus atre rnt udto aeseter e'sifrece ihe atnt i fdantly ad. t'as upeur tt ha vy ltto di t patho f wat gng n t ss weee t solvehe obms helicarils a ffs ldiigfft to tht. ha,o
11:14 am
romndio? >it carth ters l istknwn as th nedo no autcocuio ofth tatnoccs o tatadhetred v ourd hba, wld vy chn eut ncsis nel. an iideveda wiarts o ires lesaraed en nssn,reme wh-n gson. dhe's smu re pveiothcoldhaenby jt isss o awens. somu mre a ndso ont ttgthrica inrmioinhe nd o e oehet llak a ffen. d atud n jst t coch,ot st t alec airs tbsulyth thmsvehethte tnyo >>o i i w nd b todignhe ut inr t cncsi th bte tet. u non deore h alde fncsi, wldeb mit e a ju uil
11:15 am
core thwe cul t ksgoba a p fe. inn ialor,lote focouson w edtota geti. eit eid a ndoddsshe ti ad iacnd msu absh t doe/spse r a ags bod test, cfe a myb t tn sanngnd thomahe ags ri lfe a gves ur sthaceo nirreme andelo atatn anthlalywee t folo o u aleesro yothnt ddag eayndst a e ntriks o cta spts wellno srtrextme imrtt. e nturki tl or, buweneounrsndhe sk >>ha yu, dfa tre ellf tse
11:16 am
qustnsmbde i t dete thy eapanhestiere ctllntra ae acal tlkto ech otr. osof unllf e tuestoetr. wee t sdioju ntuend fis an y knw, a eye,we dotee n ues,0 w qutis. al o e ueio, w l art eermein ' a arf. we en he ltli wth eltsonha a gti iur,e' ai tam eson ty fmchdro de d erhin twn wh eisju oai csaotofus tulyre magi tseol eecve. twenetoco wihe phof sieee' d teea o deea. teay,if c st knd ofha t lk tatrell liedin es stie oronth f aea t xtiv ar n nr,e wl veth sws. nd veo ve
11:17 am
faasic mti ain thheamelofas qutins weee t sea a s anpuwa whe' i tmiit is na,l, chdr eer >>hak yo dr inne >>owiego e uds,i'st it i thk eayetnghe an a tunngso imrttmoarn ye inrent tin twodeso ea ryel ths, is trenpalle coabatthpots atna veidis, i din fo oer25 a,i' nh dgr boritea meat opimtian illu b sie thgh aubc trlyobe po, n urndndhand toc
11:18 am
ucioovuerleisnhe lkf cchng itto eow res, mper a el b cny. at i gn,trlyoee ate ahlictrne, edo eowerhem a make ceta tat they a re part f vey,specially contact collision sporting event. and thank you for this opportunity. >> dr. collins? >>'dli t san f th iit he. and iwa tchhai' hed nfoks syihi aeron ihi nedpe. aee cplel th d he. ' neree lloranwereig w. ' nernoreh w dorit w. dto ol t siece ecio othses d thnkheciceis cin vy ooinms oheinto anerho eio. wtotrshin pisbee20 paendhe's ryewi ieeha n' g t or tat eyvey
11:19 am
d n' sthordi th'sei dcuhee. re ahm bwe tt a fte thke ndorrear o ct bt udeta tat cstcts dto i istoth. bu a t mre weetobe de. d'thkwee eer en molloriv tnkth siece tun dhieneori fo w mke a lgeca ci >>mr mier >>wel,s t nod/.d eb. wehkeoule fom pele t ane a spe sech an a ioarungrp lloreitaumerf peplhe,o. sitoun'beurisg eath ato t quti wlesbl wat ny ofth oerhasuesd.
11:20 am
puresr lls to a ew ct onis dti tex i evti a fal trtmt. in ters rorgrth fry rscteathefl lfthe ars. s hre wav reah rtli whuic an pvacoabatsn csf00lln. a this c dve ch buis,he ppwh eer a mny pp le eoi oth senwh rrd so gsswold sggstom ehigsth'vhed ody keroecve ontuna u. li mremoey bined hetrtmt. tt uc avac l hethgs tin gup pop a dng a me t sei g tus a bte plce rlaveon >joa? >>asutnolet, ehe s. moito rc emase athe orio atar pni rhtowrelael y a io tns a
11:21 am
beon elyneoost uryot lve detahos aoheenitha g wi i temsof ates knwetae,ha c w o rees t,w emagend eekiti,av f,ll thadntehe s. 'vgooprrizehefa vopnt sctnry, >>anyo tunan woldsa cinal eqpose ysha wan rksn befis. anhi wco u wh a uvealrenontreg ee t ban tisan beefs.otovngsadorou no mvi i bfo yr caioscarysm,hi i alo dor yrbrn ig owy-yds n hgi ou i hie'ot arg foba lm aou inis hoe,eovg. iolyene mhe
11:22 am
d'tthnkwe aswth ndenalueio aut trmacra iju tut ldialstdis. amgh ge a hdf parsntsiti yers a tntpled a ihk y kowerin e' g a reachpres i no d koshze a m llgu a d..d a v tud esprle d thnke' gngomo ith xtecerso >>bawi i weeerat ro chis detain cte ciumans, ocoes ilungibityndof crs vy ha'sogo hlp d o is. ndstndherlee ev a tteelnd unrsndifll erenon fos ate'tainut actll mki a dierthk u.
11:23 am
midett 'm ndoor bha wa t tanffo y ci reohang urknlegeh us t' alnsucan t'w lke t tes outaesroti tti. m seby owoks l inmyareron iu o sck a h ttvinc wea f in ttwee knwn- man ez'v no auttin i w a tt d. itiselyshki. an ils hpp tbe a pso wh tinhaha ul'tedong plcy es 'svincbad. so lk orrd ml yorelloioghn srstie a io orrdtoetng el tt rear. iju wt ay la thngas mo ou 'ta ao ms sti rethi blth
11:24 am
mont noeaat tistle anwh io s isf d a yewh w iinaban il n iidry t tytw ute lcehke uthe dtoa ble nsad no aot f,ourobl lge ancsi i baetbuif h a yr-d tt is,ior bo, hoas yi ettoo pee ck hinpeleo asa w ndoet me eree ane yom ou at n ,hakisf py thshldehang ahe a o hasoon ory,d v neae' gng vesoe,omaur logidial uds,h oun' sis s otr.
11:25 am
do a iay i rll har wt u' syi o t bu athsa ihi iornt w te me ofhen dta ttweav anstt tt lstuto ptolsnleor ki, juli t ls. it s,its lars ryo pve se he ssenjie ateay anangasefs. ius m sns wbe tt enhe fnt en r pveiofomhi whlet meimyo stdyg y ceayri do f bh agsi a eaenanvepmtf prtols >>ha u.m. i wnt hk eryeor bengertoy. hiisui wvelene i fel kehod vego se onnungdutiretsfo ths. t' azi heh geernd'muyore i ctiueto rk colaravewaas y oed sor a sndi
11:26 am
cainth ahowe fose aot o sorsnd cdalyila a enon sme oethg h ppl awahi tis ar tki thus meer thtcas eroal ndhaseangauf a aeon 6 o olr. t vic aeseang caesorchdr a yun alt veo ar orhiredgau eahs ne aedtr tau itak aig en. bngnestn m arndce angele i dse tmoieonssn" anit othestng moie ikn jt aou evyn. beg om pisrg t ls kwi oe ewnd h mh in he haednth ltewea, toebltoal tdr e mooa shgser
11:27 am
enre dfentuste aanh ano difentoco, eenu tngasovngheyoi eonicofas rendusry edi bi m aeerf he d rksi-pie it anwh suc shoe n abuthi fomth lirynd ho wveot nore plina or ihoean 'vchge sdatoe fotbl y d thuhda csal b iishe1% ovoer w t ufo a eoh,hk uor yur s, 'srety an u dnto kowhe sci focearstl utthrend t piesh ell thre wth t a fce o ee bre o vy e.s, aneoe wha aut
11:28 am
1,0an 00pod mb i ty aihe ccuiv wveha ctiestoyo go tou em f tonst me ou ta rsutsof uradlostan s pbl,h msteangt ndhe wldav te ymomth y dscbe sa ivcenitme olio o mpr. my cessuid g a lornhe. y'relngs resl on tse in. mtt, bom tng is ay adofsang efrt tsshpf. wtooust i tch seesof hrisonth whh w gheert' kiuthra iitti isulndd. kn a oheyto oth a i t ea o nt lns, iopngwe nea a tabuthas l aut f hofals we snd hf arli dla yar mtal-rat pbls de'trngto fi oortw bli ll yrta cre tt
11:29 am
di m tth's e' a eeve' a intoin fdi f th, wh cldeang aot lis. ndhas er i in ers unnityf oni ang mrsofcore,e hve tathas ewe hve fi t y. aginthk u,'mmd wi yur owdg an peata tch wth u diah rt ruisd. any. >> wveoten mllon peleeihti op fat. do tatacalme f iivu lis? medyhoisn dau asn ermusnhr ha esha an ldlds nocrit
11:30 am
heksereomo ce sohereh o r th usgrk. eywa t baro ge trk be y knw, eyeivgneioo atsot eob ar th ndori twk. herehu of g asab pce ln rhr arnd ty ve toea ,

1,132 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on