tv Q A CSPAN May 4, 2014 11:00pm-12:01am EDT
11:00 pm
scarlet sisters: sex, suffrage, and scandal in the gilded age." then from the british house of commons, prime minister's questions. and then the house hearing. >> this week on "q&a," author and journalist myra macpherson discusses her new book, "the scarlet sisters: sex, suffrage, and scandal in the gilded age," as well as her career covering politics and culture for "the washington post," "new york times," and other publications. >> myra macpherson, when you think back of your career at "the washington post," how many
11:01 pm
years were you there? >> i think it was 23 years. >> what is one of the highlights that comes to mind? >> one of the highlights has been that i was covering the mets in 1969 when they finally won. they wouldn't let me in the press box because i was a girl as they said in those days. i had already covered the indianapolis 500 where i had been the only woman in the country. i found this interesting because it was a magic place to work. ben bradley hired me for style and it really transformed and revolutionized the paper business. it is not at all like it was then. you would do 2000-word pieces and people would read them. that business of not being able to go into the press box to write and file my copy -- it struck home and read smith, the
11:02 pm
great columnist wrote aps saying, "isn't it time we change some of these rules?" i felt it was a bit of moving on up for women. >> what excuse did they give? >> because i was a woman. they just didn't have women in the press box. they used to say that if a woman was on a ship, it was bad news for the ship. i have no idea, but they just banned them. there were a lot of places that banned women. the press club, the women had to sit in the back when they were interviewing somebody or somebody was giving a major speech. the cosmos club, not until the 1980's did they admit women. the discrimination laws came in. they were more afraid of losing their liquor license than being
11:03 pm
egalitarian and letting women in. it was a strange mad men era for many of us. >> do you remember how old you were when you met jack kennedy? >> 24 or 25. >> what do you remember from that? >> being scared. >> what were the circumstances? >> i was doing a column five days a week. the first time, they were on the tarmac waiting for the children to come to the white house. he was mr. effusive, talking to everybody. jackie kennedy was in the limousine with all-black windows. this woman that i didn't know said, "let's go ask her a question." we went over and this woman said, do the children know they are moving into the white house? jackie rolls the window down
11:04 pm
this far and says, "what?" she said caroline knows but she doesn't understand the full significance. up went to the window. that started a great friendship. i had a couple of times when i covered the press conferences and talked to him. he was very eager to talk to journalists. he loved that give and take and conversation. i got ted kennedy a lot more because i covered him on health issues. >> thinking back to the days when you couldn't get in the press box, did that have -- eventually writing this book called "the scarlet sisters?" >> my first book was called "the power lovers" and it was on the
11:05 pm
effect of marriage. everything i have written comes off the news in many ways. with that book, i was watching the primary. muskie was running for president. all the male reporters said he cried in the snow after there had been this hideous editorial about his wife. i am not so sure he cried in the snow. anyway, we came through and went back to new york. i was in the bus and he was talking with some reporters. i looked up and saw the children with a whole lot of luggage sitting around and said, what is going to happen to the children? they won't see their parents for two months. that was the genesis of how difficult is a political marriage in the time. that was pretty much a feminist book then. i always have this desire to go back to the feminist movement. i covered the equal rights amendment and all the issues in
11:06 pm
the 1960's and 1970's. this time around, everybody in 2008 was talking about the possible miracle dream team of hillary clinton and vice president obama. there was this tiny bit that said in 1862, victoria woodhull ran with frederick douglass, an obscure third-party ticket. i had read something about her but not the whole thing about frederick douglass. then i read about her sister, which had been pretty much eclipsed in all the books about victoria, and decided to do a dual biography of these
11:07 pm
symbiotic, fascinating, and outrageous women in american history. i decided i could never make up -- >> your first line in chapter one, victoria and tennie's father -- >> they grew up in this ridiculously dickenssian world of debauchery. this family was nothing you could believe. the father was sort of at the head of it all. everything he did was a scam. at one point, the story went that he was making counterfeit money. when the sheriff came, he put the money in his mouth and swallowed the evidence. he was always doing something, painting horses black and selling them before the rain came and got out of town. these two women grew up with nothing but shyster tricks and
11:08 pm
not being real people. when she was 11 years old, the youngest, tennie was put to work as a fake fortuneteller and sat in a dirty old hotel for 13 hours a day, selling fortunes and the father collected the money. there is a scene in the book, she was -- they were chasing her for manslaughter based on one of the things that they had done. they had a horrible childhood. vicki had gone ahead and gotten married at age 15. that wasn't looking well. everybody says, how do you think these women came from such a very low rent part -- as you know, the victorian era is so stratified.
11:09 pm
there was the very rich, the middle class, and there were the robber baron achievers -- the life and times of these women was in the most the near time that you can think of -- most buccaneer time you can think of. you had all the barons out there making a lot of money. i think it was easy for them because they had been running around with low-rent con artists. now let's go with the big boys. they were beautiful and they were tough and they were driven. they were driven both for power and individualism, but as i say
11:10 pm
they could have courtesans but they were pushing for their independence and women's independence. they were talking about equal pay for equal work. we still don't have it. everything they pushed -- they were for free love which got them into a lot of trouble with the press and the clergy and other people. >> you do this in a five-act play. how did you divide it up? >> instead of doing part one, part two, i decided their life was such a drama that i wanted to do it that way. there is the beginning, then part two is when they went to wall street and made their fortune, bankrolled by cornelius vanderbilt who was rumored to be the lover of tennie.
11:11 pm
it is sort of a given, historically. they had used their ability as clairvoyants to convince him that they could talk to his long dead mother. vanderbilt was the richest man in the world but he was incredibly superstitious. he also believed in spiritualism. they wormed their way into his life and then he bankrolled them and they became the first women stockbrokers in the world. that was the beginning curve of their life. part two goes into the development of who they were, the newspaper they started, various other themes. i am forgetting which parts right now. i know the trial against henry ward beecher was this high drama and the final one was the siege of london, when they left the
11:12 pm
united states and married two of the richest men in london, after they were run out of the united states. >> the victorian age, where did it get its name? and how long was it? >> queen victoria started in 1838 and it went until 2001 when her son became the king. she lived forever. >> what did it mean? what did they call it the victorian age? >> she was considered not the virgin queen, but her husband died when she was very young and there was this era that had preceded it, major debauchery. the concept of victorian is him -- victorianism was that you have a moral fiber to life. a lot of it was hypocrisy. i have a chapter called sex and the city circa 1861. the concept of the victorian era was a sense of fidelity to marriage, a sense of honor, etc. which is just not the case. it was based on her life, living as the queen alone and ruling as
11:13 pm
the queen alone. >> vicki woodhull was born what year? >> 1838. she was named for the queen. >> and her sister was born what year? >> 1845. >> where were they born? >> i am not sure where but they grew up in a little town in ohio. >> what was buck doing there? >> buck was supposedly setting fire to his gristmill so he could get money for the insurance. teaching the girls how to become clairvoyants, and then he -- they were run out of town. the citizens in this little town
11:14 pm
didn't take kindly to someone who was fleecing them to get money for the fire that he had started. he was always a con man. when they got out of there, he had been the post office manager and they found all of these envelopes that said, "money enclosed." the money was gone. they started this caravan world of just going all over the country. in that era, spiritualism had become enormously popular. there were something like -- various groups in the united states at that time were really spiritualists. it is not much different from a lot of religions, the idea that there is a life after death.
11:15 pm
they said they could see manifestations of that. he glommed onto that and said, i have got to wonderful good-looking girls. he touted them as spiritualists. he made up fake medicine. he called himself the king of cancers. all things healed by little tennie. he was a real piece of work. in later life, came back to haunt the sisters in a very sad way for them. their mother --their not wholly sane mother -- was a revivalist, eccentric, and they wanted the sisters to be with them, particularly tennie, because she
11:16 pm
was very pretty and vivacious. when the women went off and became these incredible successes, not only did they be the first women stockholders in the world, to own a brokerage firm -- not to be repeated for 100 years, they had a radical newspaper, they became lecturers. they were celebrities. they have headlines with just their names. it is like madonna. they were very famous based on their beginnings with vanderbilt. the family just kept threatening them with blackmail. they said, we are going to expose you. the mother started this ridiculous court trial when she said that victoria's
11:17 pm
then-husband wanted to put her in an essay in asylum, wanted to kill her. the press went wild and wrote about this very trashy family. the sisters has been trying very hard to hide all that and they were inventing and reinventing themselves. they were not the least bit educated but they said they were. anything that would help them, they had moved on forward with. they were willing to wreck their whole life just to get tennie back to tell fortunes. they had some really rotten characters in the family. >> you say that buck's wife annie had 10 children. how many survived? >> seven. >> you write about annie where you say, one tale describes her mother --
11:18 pm
>> it was in a book that i read. i thought, do i use this? i have to say unsubstantiated because i have no idea if that is truthful. it kind of sits in with who they were. >> you say the mother was not sane. >> their phrase was, never wholly sane. she was always a bit off. they clung to them like burrs. once they started making money and became famous, the family would just turn up. there would be a raft of these family members that tennie called deadbeats. they were like locusts eating off of these two green stems that were upholding the whole family.
11:19 pm
they spent an awful lot of money on that, and were afraid to leave, because they understood how much this family could do, the harm that they could do in the press. they had everybody's support. they had susan b anthony. they were looked at as the new wave of feminists. victoria became the first woman to address any member of congress. she addressed the judiciary committee and argued that the constitution , 15th amendment, everything said citizens. it didn't say male, it didn't say female. the only time male was used was in the second article of the 14th amendment. it was used to define black male slaves versus female slaves. god forbid the female slaves could vote. she had a very strong argument. as i said in the book, they were absolutely keen on finding the best men who could help them.
11:20 pm
they had general ben butler, a great friend of lincoln and grant, very powerful man. he pushed all that getting into the judiciary. they were very much a part of the more liberal ring of the women's movement. when this whole family scandal broke, everybody started saying, how could susan b anthony have anything to do with these women? it really was very hard for them. >> in your own life, how often have you seen favoritism toward men versus women? >> oh dear. [laughter] >> plus a couple of examples. >> there were these attitudes that there were no women capable of doing the same job. in 1972, the first year i covered a presidential campaign, i covered five of them. that was the first year. the book written about the
11:21 pm
reporters was called the boys on the bus. because there were so few of us women. i would not say -- i have children and didn't want to be out there full-time. i remember talking to david broder about raising your son at 14 or 15 and he said, i skipped that year. he had a wife at home who helped. the system while i was in it was almost completely male-dominated. when you say examples, the question is, do you get passed over for an assignment? i talked to many women on wall street today who say it is still the frat boy system. when the sisters were on wall street, they were considered whores just because they were out there.
11:22 pm
i don't mean to be rambling but it is hard to come up with a specific. you started out with -- i remember when i got out of college and i had been an editor at our state college. i won some awards so i thought i was really ok. i went to detroit to look for a job and the editor said, we have no openings in the women's department. i said i wasn't considering the women's department. he said, we have no women in the sitting room. two men with lesser credentials got reporters jobs and i got a job running copy. it was institutionalized sexism as opposed to totally being able to say i couldn't get this job because i was a woman. i think that happened a great deal. if you look at politics, the treatment of women -- hillary
11:23 pm
clinton when she ran, it was fierce, the kind of sexism that went on. for a long time, women could never get enough upfront money to run for politics. the whole system was stacked. >> your late husband -- your first husband, what year did he die? the 1990's? >> yes, 1994. >> the reason i bring him up, you guys were in the same business. was he better? was he treated better because he was a man? >> yes. i have a story. i was at a table -- several sports people. i said something and they said, we are not interested in what you think. you are only here because of mare. as far as i am concerned, all
11:24 pm
broads are a piece of raisin cake. i said something i will not repeat. i pushed out the table and walked away. this great sportswriter, he said -- i said, let's not go. i walked in and the first thing he said was, how are you? i had distinguished myself by being enough of a male to tell him off that he was respectful. you saw an awful lot of that. the baseball dinners were always
11:25 pm
stag. after we got married, i said, you are just not going to do that. he said, i am going to have a surprise. his keynote speaker was liz carpenter. some of the old guys were grumbling about it, really grumbling about it. it was an incredible thing. my daughter became a three-time emmy award-winning espn producer. when i meet young men and young women in sports, they are aghast. they can't believe that you couldn't get into the press box. when i covered the indianapolis 500 in 1960, i was the only woman covering it. i couldn't get into gasoline alley, i couldn't get into the press box.
11:26 pm
now we see women covering everything, which is progress. >> you wrote a book about your daughter. what year was that? >> i didn't write about my daughter. i wrote a book called, "she came to live out loud." that was when i was at the hospice foundation. i interviewed a woman who had breast cancer. >> you lost her daughter. >> i did, 10 years later. 2010. it is emblazoned in my mind. she had given birth to her third child. she said, "i am going to give up working for a while." they came in and said that she had stage four breast cancer. there had been no indication whatsoever. she had a valiant fight in which she wrote a website that was so popular that 60,000 people followed it. i still can't reread it, but she
11:27 pm
was just amazing. >> how old was she? >> 43. >> what did she do that cut her into espn as a producer? was she treated equally? >> she thinks she was treated mostly equally. she had a few points where she didn't think so. she never wanted to go on air. she loved being a producer and being out there. we both knew john walsh, the news editor for c-span -- espn. he had been at the style section with me. she got her job through somebody that neither maury nor i knew. she said, john walsh didn't give me the job. i did it myself. one of the assistant producers went to pick her up at the airport. he said he was so taken with
11:28 pm
everything she said, he said, you are hired. you don't even have to go anywhere else. john said, that is myra's daughter. she was very independent. there is one hysterical story. they stationed her in dallas. they were covering the cowboys. they were at the center line and they kept moving them farther down the goalposts. they said, why? they were sitting on the cowboys side and they were behind them on the bench. he said, well her cell phone ring bothers them too much. she was playing "hail to the
11:29 pm
redskins." [laughter] >> as long as we are talking about your previous books, i want to run some video. you were in the audience for this. tell us what you got interested in this person. >> i believe that no society is good, even if it has social welfare, free rent, where men are not free to speak their minds. in that sense, i believe very thoroughly in america and its a -- its egalitarianism. i criticize its shortcomings but i have not lost faith in it. i am not an anti-democrat like my poor friend socrates. therefore i will not drink the hemlock today. >> what did you think of i.f. stone? >> i quite adored him. i interviewed him and his wife at their 50th wedding
11:30 pm
anniversary. he was a neighbor and i did not know him well. my second husband said that was we bothbook, because decided it many ways that he was be pivotal, defining boys in the 20th century that could have kept this country honest. i realized that is the, three weeks after lyndon johnson used the golf as a point for escalating going into vietnam, that he read every single document and he ended up saying that this can't possibly be true. he said there was no
11:31 pm
after-report or debris. he raised a specter of it being false three weeks after lyndon johnson. i always thought if the president was more interested in doing the world a favor, he might have avoided that terrible war. then -- id he do back think you said he had 70 house and -- >> they were mom-and-pop stores. he literally went to and carried them out. was at seriously democrat. was unbelievably thrilled , he hadedgar hoover
11:32 pm
more coverage than anybody i ever knew in the business. >> you read all 5000 pages? >> yes. i knew who was saying what. aey followed it him into cigar store and reported he purchased 2 cigars. been a lot of very controversial book. when he knew this one man who turned out to be a kgb agent who was also a press attaché, i found and proved with walter went meant, he talked to him a lot more.
11:33 pm
2 plus 2 andding getting 5. his treatment of human beings, he was invasive of their lifestyles. >> i know that he wrote books. was most of his work done in a weekly newsletter? in the 1930's he was an editorial writer at a liberal paper and he was writing about the possibility of hitler becoming chancellor. i twinned him with walter let alsoegos walter litman was accused.
11:34 pm
and he did not cover anything about the holocaust for the longest time. this reporter had all kinds of scoops. his background, which a lot of people didn't know, happened to be amazing. during the horrible years of the mccarthy. , all of the little papers were shut down and he had no place to his own littled rag and because the timing was fortuitous because he was so anti-vietnam, and the antiwar everybody had to read it and pass it around. he got very lucky with that. he wrote something about underground palestine, he was the first reporter in the world
11:35 pm
to go over to the holocaust survivors. it really reads like a grandma green novel. it is really a wonderfully written book. there is another journalist who could do that. >> do you remember what it cost? five dollars per year. think, if i am adding right. >> do you remember what year he died? maybe 1987 or 1988.
11:36 pm
no, right after tiananmen square. 1989. wanted to read it now, where would they go? there is a website. .e got two different awards one for excellence in investigative journalism will --. there is a lot that is online now, that i was not able to read . you put an emphasis on tennie , let's get back into the story
11:37 pm
and listen to this. he borrowed money, brought back his own stock at reduced prices. market, in the stock got control of a major railroad, and all he had to do was not cause a major financial panic. in and stopto go the panic and show up on wall street. it.broker said, i knew >> cornelius vanderbilt. how did the ladies meet him, and why did they find him? they had a golden mind.
11:38 pm
they knew he was into spiritualism. tennie was known as having magic healing hands. many people, by then had moved up town. he was 74 years old, and he had bounder.e a he was not faithful to his wife, and tennie was a track death. in 1868, and they did not start their bank until 1870. i think, probably very strongly that he did have an affair with tennie.
11:39 pm
was a. in between his wife and when he married another woman. he thought the sisters were witty, and funny. her comingstory of into his office and sitting on his lap and him calling her his little sparrow and she called him an old goat to. felt alive with the sisters around him, and he gave them money which was a lot for them. the word on the street was that cornelius vanderbilt was helping them. everyone, the major financiers of that time, wanted to see what they were like.
11:40 pm
theme came out just to see opening the doors and walking in. >> how many times were each of them married? >> tennie was only married twice. victorio was married three times , but the? she hadys whether really married her second husband, because you have to understand the premise was you did not need a piece of paper. you had a horrible marriage a piece of paper did not help, and if you had a great relationship it did not matter. love,st needed to be in and it was very much the way it is today with people not getting married. they strongly believed it was an
11:41 pm
ok ring at a time when no one -- when noll stop one else did. went to england -- everyone made it seem like they had so many husbands but they really did not. when the family had this trial it was disclosed that she was living with two husbands, a former and a current in the same house which was a mansion. were --d to stay, she she tried to say to the new york she was helping take care of a man who was an morphine addict and was dying. but the press did not care, they just went wild.
11:42 pm
equivalent of the tabloids. they rode everything you could think about and made the news out. >> how do you define a spiritualist? >> it is someone who believes there is some way of communicating with people on the other side, someone who is dead. there are various permutations of that. some people say there is evidence of that. people who are very interested , they started to say that the things that came up, the andal sounds and so on having the tables move and all of this made it seem like there
11:43 pm
was a possibility it could be true. of this wasl discovered, something like 300 -- i think america it was everybody's desire to believe. the bulwark of all religions, if you study them. that there is life after death of some sort. >> in your book you talk about whether or not the two women were prostitutes. it was very easy to be called a slot in those days. if you are by yourself walking down the street at night, it was something you just did not do.
11:44 pm
-- edith wharton, has this a womanhing she said, has a lover who cared about her and although it was mean and awful and doesn't make sense, the rigidity was there so much that as soon as the sisters did anything that was out of the norman and they were immediately s. the to be prostitute idea that maybe they ran a house of assignation, maybe they were occasionally prostitutes under 's weighing.
11:45 pm
and they were in jail for a while and were hounded. there was an impact on america manfree speech because a managed to get a very stern up sanity law passed. he was against all of the great literature that was written. he drove margaret sanger out of -- forntry for dove dibs. agents wreck to their printing press.
11:46 pm
having been in prison was enough to make them no longer valuable. they tried to keep the newspaper afloat. years.y did, for six it was amazing. did, -- you should read it. see how io read it to get around the question of whether they were or were not prostitutes. they could even needed to without saying yes or no, and it is amazing how they did that. description,brief i want to see if you agree or disagree.
11:47 pm
>> she was a presidential candidate, she was a prostitute. she was known as the prostitute who ran for president. she preached free love. she came under the influence of benjamin butler who believed women should have the vote by a declaratory act of congress. she presented a memorial in front of the joint members of congress, the only woman who had ever done that. she was a mass of contradictions. all, i do not like to do this but i do have some negative comments. anecdotesa lot of that do not have a primary source of verification.
11:48 pm
her comment that they were flat-out prostitutes is just wrong. there were people who said that constantly, but there was no proof. they had a house of assignation in chicago is not proven. i take issue with it because i think we ought to recognize, gave aday, -- tennie great speech where she said if a into questiond for anything, her sexual life is always called into question. there is still this attitude. for them to be so outrageously upfront on everything, for example she loved her children but she wanted free love.
11:49 pm
love wasitude on free so strongly, they thought divorce laws were horrible. women could not get divorces then. they did not get divorces, they could not get her children. actually, the sisters tried to say they were more moral than anybody else because they did not marry for money, and a woman who marries for money is a legalized prostitute. their attitude was that you should marry for love. you have to remember, that in those days, the temperance woman started out with the attitude that drunken men were beating up
11:50 pm
11:51 pm
>> i want to ask you about bill clinton. what do you think matters about the moral situation of people running for president? >> that is a very difficult question to answer. when i did my first book, i had -- ap there about it chapter about it. a psychiatrist said that these guys have so much testosterone which keeps them coming and also what keeps them interested in other women. it can have a disastrous effect on families, that is for sure. to know what we should be looking for in a mail? a male?
11:52 pm
appearedail sheehy who when we are talking about ill clinton. >> right before the vote, we knew there were going to lose, she was the campaign manager. a were locked in a room together to find out what was really going on. hillary was giving him the third degree. takeaid she even had to bill clinton's girlfriend as her babysitter to get her out of the way. hillary started swearing and cursing. of -- a meleehe thato one ever mentioned bill clinton had the past 70 of a buddha.
11:53 pm
.t was never his fault it was always somebody else's fault. >> if mrs. clinton runs, at this is going to come up again. >> it already has. association, if she could stay with a man like that, etc.. think the hardest thing is to make a decision about where does a private life have importance and where doesn't it? the women who are going to run are going to get an awful lot of heat about their relationships, no matter who they are. the treatment of wendy davis. funny, the sisters
11:54 pm
were accused of being too trashy and wendy davis was accused of not being trashy enough. she was only in that trailer three months. exaggerated. calling her and empty dress as a takeoff on the empty suit concept. sexism is here to stay and it will be very noticeable if hillary decides to run. i happened to be on a bus in arizona the day ted kennedy died.
11:55 pm
of these people were bringing up chappaquiddick over and over again. they were saying all kinds of stuff about chappaquiddick. saying that here had gone into a second life towards the end of his life and had done very important legislation work and everything else. >> what about you? what do you think? aboutas your reaction what bill clinton did and how hillary handled it? all, it how hillary handled it and bills handling of it. i thought it was a despicable act on his part. a lot of women thought she should leave him. shouldomen felt she
11:56 pm
stand by her man and had that attitude. , i do not knowe what their relationship really was like and i do not think anybody does. have think they intellectual respect for each other's work and intelligence. one point, keeping it together for chelsea was important. she is obviously very ambitious. a womaniated that when runs she is ambitious, and when a man runs it's because he wants to help the world. we have these adjectives. but i think it was despicable on his part to lie. what do you think?. >> let's go back a minute to the
11:57 pm
scarlet sisters, sex and scandal in the gilded age. rate your books based on how you feel about issues? >> everything i have ever comes from how i feel. the vietnam book came after i had written a two-part series about vietnam. how they felt ignored for their homecoming. i interviewed a lot of of veterans. about 500 veterans and put together a book that i had started out was about veterans, but there were so many how they came
11:58 pm
, postnd felt betrayed traumatic stress was not even mentioned at that time. feeling of sorrow for so many of the men who went to that war and came back quite troubled. yes, it is an ideological thing for me. i like the on-the-job training. youstart out with an issue want to write about and it always expands and explodes here and there. don't even have time to get to henry ward beecher, which is the reason why many people want to get to the book and read it. senator jack gorden, is cdc deceased?s he
11:59 pm
12:00 am
transcripts or to join us to see more, please go to our website for podcasts. >> a collection of interviews with some of the nation's top stories tellers. war, the beginning of the you are afraid of holding the gun. when we went to the first battle and we thought and i shot somebody, killed somebody, it does something to you. it is very difficult in the beginning. after time went on, it became easy. it became normalized. in the context of war, this is what happens. you normalize the situation so you can actually live through it. >>
40 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CSPAN Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on