Skip to main content

tv   Close up  Deutsche Welle  July 30, 2019 12:30am-1:01am CEST

12:30 am
nico case in germany. why not. it's simple line on your mobile and free. music a learning course called street german made easy. european agriculture has been an environmental disaster in many parts of the continent it's ruined the landscape climate and biodiversity but the e.u. continues to pour money into a system that's obviously broken. we should be funding organic farming not the over exploitation of nature. the e.u. appears to have no interest in environmentally friendly farm policies is that due
12:31 am
to the influence of powerful interest groups. and we feel calling me a lobbyist is a mean spirited allegation. the e.u. is now negotiating a new multi-year budget will it include farm policies that do more to protect the environment. of. farm fields as far as the eye can see this land all 2600 hectares of it belongs to one of germany's largest farming businesses agro bird aglen we've come here to talk to the companies managing director or bun unit. it's a successful enterprise optimized for efficiency and production but unix doesn't seem to be truly happy in his work. so at this moment
12:32 am
a lot of it's not farming in the traditional sense we use the latest technology and our productivity is extremely high but there's always pressure to do more. better gun produces $10000.00 tonnes of potatoes a year for a company and braman that makes french fries they grow only one kind. potato here and they have to be as large as possible. like most farms burdock own uses fertilizers and pesticides to keep by they also receive 700000 euros a year in e.u. subsidies that helps to keep them competitive in world markets. and relied on from that 65 percent of potatoes and up as finished food products. but we're also competing with frozen french fries from the u.s. if it really is a global markets that we can global market. the e.u. actually promotes the development of these agro giants because the amount of the
12:33 am
subsidy is determined by the size of the farm environmental concerns are often ignored. that's not the case with this small family owned farm located near munich they follow the principles put forward by the by a land organization which promotes organic agriculture practices the farm grows 20 different kinds of potatoes and they don't use artificial fertilisers or chemical pesticides. yup this year my beautiful i learned traditional farming methods then when i've driven my spraying vehicle through the fields for the 10th time i know that i've made the right choice. since while you were going to talk of you have made this puts it was the mention of corn is it seem i wanted to avoid using chemical pesticides and that's what got me excited about this kind of farming. country as hot zone gets
12:34 am
a 55000 euro annual subsidy from the e.u. and another 50000 from the state of bavaria because he uses organic farming methods . hartzell invests the funds in his farm polls indicate that most germans approve of this kind of agriculture because it helps to preserve the landscape soil and climate. there are only 2 viable business models in e.u. funded agriculture huge conventional farms like bird a clone and organic farms like huts old. the common agricultural policy dates back to 1957 its original goals included increasing productivity and providing a stable income for farmers today the e.u. provides massive subsidies to help agricultural products. compete effectively in world markets. about 38 percent of the e.u.'s entire budget $58000000000.00 euros per year is spent on
12:35 am
financial support for farmers. $6300000000.00 euros of that total goes to germany. most of that money 5000000000 euros goes directly to farmers based on how much land they own. $1300000000.00 is spent on financial support for rural areas only a small amount goes to promote the development of environmentally friendly farming methods. the 8 years agricultural policy rewards big farms like braddock owned which is run by or by year itch most farms don't turn a profit today one half of europe's total farm land is owned by just under 3 percent of all farm businesses. the e.u.'s top priority is to provide maximum crop yields so that farmers can compete with cheaper produce on the world market there's not much money left to promote organic farming.
12:36 am
agricultural policy has led to the creation of large tracts of farmland that often lie empty. the use of chemical herbicides like life is a has turned fields into reddish brown deserts. the e.u.'s common agricultural policy may be responsible for killing off large numbers of birds and useful insects. we've come to northwestern germany to meet some environmentalists who are waiting for lap wings to return from their winter migration the birds come here to breed since the 1990 s. the lapping population has declined by nearly 90 percent in this area. environmentalists are concerned about that. step festus it's clear to me that the fate of the human race is more closely connected to the fate of the left than we'd
12:37 am
like it to be missed but it's important. to. our ecosystems are becoming more and more unstable he was and the reduction in the lab going population is an obvious symptom about problem of any of it and i just got it. my point is like to breed in fields but about 3 quarters of their nests are destroyed every year by intensive farming methods the environmentalists mark the birds nests so that they won't be run over by tractors or other machines but the real problem is that there aren't enough insects and larva anymore for the birds to feed on. friend. if the e.u. doesn't make fundamental changes in its common farming policy we lose more and more insects on the left wings will disappear. and then the farmers will be hit with court rulings more of elations and other punitive measures. because it's a tie in with
12:38 am
a board that will make the lawyers even more difficult than 50 lanfear chuffed and in the end we'll have a catastrophe on the hearns boat for farmers and for the environment to get up to trust. intensive agriculture also contributes to climate change for example by converting large areas of forest to farmland germany's federal environment agency says the e.u. should do more to promote green agricultural methods. top few ticks. wouldn't occur in the u.s. policies are not sufficiently promote environmentally friendly practices. believe that farmers who adopt green methods should get a larger subsidy and big farms that don't should get less mostly get the most and. that would be a major turnaround for the e.u. but recent polls indicate that more and more europeans are becoming concerned about protecting the environment it would seem that the german farmers association would
12:39 am
also be interested in promoting green agricultural policies 90 percent of all german farmers belong to the organization. in june 28th hundreds of farmers and policy experts gathered in vs budden for their annual convention one important discussion topic was the future of e.u. subsidies. but there was hardly any mention of environmentally friendly agricultural practices. the focus was on preserving the subsidies as they are now. the federal agriculture minister. declined our request for an interview but in a speech she defended the farming industry against its critics. i their clout does not have no one believes that agriculture is exclusively responsible for damaging the climate and the environment the land itself should and allan's i guess
12:40 am
is. that i want to make it clear. that a number of different sects contribute to this problem. of those who claim famine are intellectually lazy and are not doing their part to help us move forward i the agriculture minister is supposed to represent the interests of all the people but she seems to be particularly close to the agricultural establishment. camp of i'm fighting feel i know how you feel and i know you. took no speech went over well she didn't want to rock the boat at a conference like this but why is the farming industry dead set against the proposed restructuring of the e.u. subsidy system. this event was sponsored by a number of corporations that's the 1st clue. what do these companies have to do with german agriculture a new study by the institute for labor and the economy at the university of payment
12:41 am
has come up with some answers. researchers found a number of connections between the german farmers association politicians the agriculture industry the food production sector financial companies and the chemical industry. some very some big players here b.s.f. by a crop science and saying get into the institutes experts have documented a total of 560 connections this could give them and they all talk to each other. the study names $75.00 companies associations and political parties there's one group at the center is of the german farmers association. the study indicates that top association officials represent a range of interests besides farming in the mall for example association
12:42 am
president joachim rick reed is linked to 18 different companies. this graphic shows all of your wacky feeds connections. for example he serves on the advisory boards of the or in v.n. surance company. can renton by germany's development agency for agribusiness grewal areas into the us and could be tones of i doubt so if i gave him. he's also on the supervisory board of. a corporation that sells various products to farmers like fertilizers and pesticides on the. feed where is the number of different you not really sure whose interest is actually representing. his interests of the fact that. several other top officials of the farmers association have ties to big corporations the companies that these people represent make good
12:43 am
money selling products and services to farmers the associations general secretary ban talk chris can see is no conflict of interest here but it's important to note that all of the companies you just mentioned are owned by farmers. and if they didn't have these kinds of business connections they'd be in real trouble. for. it's a traditional cooperative effort even if some of these organizations have now become corporations. if you knew it. but most of these corporations generate billions in sales and have other business interests besides those of farmers. the farmers association executives benefit substantially from their ties to corporations that sell farmers the products and services they need and the farmers pay for all that with the money they get from
12:44 am
e.u. subsidies. so the association has a vested interest in keeping this subsidy system just the way it is. over several decades the farmers association has built up a sophisticated lobbying network that allows them to influence the political decision making process and its public opinion as well in my experience protests and it has actual time for some game. it seems as though the association will not be supporting subsidy reform any time soon can the e.u. do anything to help we've come to the european parliament in brussels to attend a session of the agriculture committee the members are due to vote on a proposal to cut some of the farm subsidies. perhaps some of the money would be better spent to promote farming methods that help to protect the environment a majority of the committee members belong to the conservative people's party group
12:45 am
. and germany's on bad debts has been the party spokesman on the committee for 10 years death is not only a powerful politician he's also chairman of the board of one of the various largest dairy cooperatives buy on mt we asked him whether he's using his political influence to keep down the prices that the co-op pays to farmers. as alicia's will boost for calling me a lobbyist as a mean spirited allegation for q. and making my constituents have known me since i was a young man help me i had the best election results in all of bavaria in 2004 when i 1st ran for the european parliament when there were more than 30 parties on the ballot i won with just over 70 percent of the vote of the people of my district know me and they would reject such allegations of that sort of question. test has also been active in the farmers association for more than 40 years and he's
12:46 am
a member of the parliament committee that certifies the use of pesticides plus he serves on the bio advisory board by the us sells products and services to farmers including pesticides desk doesn't seem too concerned about the deadly effects that these chemicals have on useful insects. well farming methods in my part of the country haven't changed in 40 years ago so why blame farmers now for the decline in insect populations lots of pesticides aren't responsible for its windham of profit 40 years ago 70 percent of the pesticides that we used were highly toxic we don't use those anymore but back then they didn't bother the useful insects so this discussion is hypocritical to me for global. but numerous studies indicate that the use of highly effective pesticides is indeed responsible for much of the decline in insect populations. a few minutes later
12:47 am
deaths and his party colleagues voted against the proposal to reduce the subsidies so the payments will continue for the time being. and there will be no reforms of the e use common agricultural policy before the next european parliament elections. if you're sort of i'd rather have this position on the committee than serve as a national agriculture minister because i have more influence here than a minister does if you will if you're not in full swap it was real not so and by saying that i'm not being disrespectful of the ministers only because it is of they have a difficult and complicated job to do with your week but here i can talk to colleagues from all over europe from all over the world. i can meet with agriculture ministers from britain the us brazil new zealand australia and african countries.
12:48 am
will the almost like. those countries and others will continue to buy subsidized european farm products maria notional also serves on the agriculture committee and has called for radical policy reforms. to distrust of it there's no law that says we have to focus on international markets and i'm not opposed to trade or exports but our 1st priority should be europe we should take a regional approach. it's absurd for us to export milk to australia and then have australia export milk to us on this that milk is being dumped on the world market by this australian and german dairy farmers aren't making any money and people wonder why we should not export basic food products like milk. to farm. the system which is supported by billions of euros and subsidies appears to be broken and those subsidies are financed by european taxpayers can consumers do
12:49 am
anything to help fix this situation. perhaps they could make different choices when it comes to buying food. germany an organization that promotes sustainable agriculture. she's brought. consumers should be concerned. this is made to see as if this flour is very inexpensive. because but it also has lots of heating costs that we'll have to pay because this is the cindy cost for example the week comes from soil that's being ruined because of the over use of fertilizers and pesticides. so the prices we pay at the supermarket may seem cheap but they're really not american discounted. products are also inexpensive in part because pig feed is cheap the main reason for
12:50 am
that is that it's made from products that are grown on farms that are heavily subsidized by the e.u. . is good. comes from cakes that have been raised on factory new farms so that they quickly end up weighing 122150. 1 of that before that food kill the phone is used concentrated feed and they completely ignore the basic rules of raising livestock. hudson says that many consumers don't know where their food comes from so they end up supporting an agricultural system that is focused on profit and damages the environment. and claim is alone can't change the situation because the farm policy agenda is set by the politicians as i'm the 70 i live in occur. so we've come to berlin to
12:51 am
talk to some politicians after all any reforms to the e.u.'s farm subsidies have to be approved by the governments of the 28 member states the bundestag has its own food and agriculture committee. m.p. renate coon asked a member of the green party serves on the committee she was also the federal agriculture minister from 2001 to 2005. he wanted to get the ideas and prod the committee her. has been discussing the important issues that the agriculture industry faces some members press the fact that they are farmers but these people don't act like m.p.'s they make decisions based on business interests. go on. and indeed a majority of the agriculture committee members own farms and are members of the farmers association. these m.p.'s have the political clout to block any efforts at
12:52 am
reform. says that committee members should not put personal business interests ahead of the public interest she wants the e.u. to develop a new system for allocating farm subsidies. i distrust as i simply see every public money should be used to finance public services. i believe that a large part of the subsidies at least 15000000000 euros should be invested in a nature conservation fund that farmers could use that would definitely be in the public's best interest because it would help stop the damage to biodiversity and the environment we should be funding organic farming not the over exploitation of nature oh i'm going out to work. but only a few of the agriculture committee members agree with you now just most of them want to keep the e.u. subsidy system just the way it is the situation in the german parliament is almost
12:53 am
identical to the one in brussels. the politicians seem more interested in preserving the status quo instead of protecting the environment the farmers association is also opposed to subsidy reforms. and we return to the institute for labor and the economy to learn more about the association's lobbying network. to see if that sells or stored or trying to find out why serious agricultural reform proposals have been consistently blocked in both the german earned european parliament's and you know or pearson we wanted to get to the bottom of the situation. where the political interests that work here and what role if any the loveliest play lobbyists most of. the researchers came across a little known organization called the forum for modern agriculture. before m
12:54 am
m's to inform the general public about the benefits of agriculture on its website there are no reports about environmental problems factory farms or the extinction of animal species. but we did find an article that justifies the use of glyphosate a controversial herbicide. the farmers association helped set up the forum. for this form of good has nothing to do with politics predicts 2 of those it simply brings various farming groups under one roof and tries to inform the public about what these groups are doing to it's you to inform you. the forum supervisory board includes executives from agro chemical companies like buyer crop science. and the association of farm credit unions a lot of pretty important people are associated with this informational forum.
12:55 am
they gave holes we believe that it's an attempt to identify the industry's key policies and then coordinate them with the politician us critics argue notes of. the chairman of the forums board of directors as you walk him hook feet the president of the farmers association. members of the advisory board include the head of the federal agency that advises the government on potential health hazards including pesticides. these misguided policies taken together have created a huge agricultural waste land in germany. but there are still some small farms scattered around the country that you sustainable methods for growing crops as part of the effort to protect the environment biodiversity and wild. life.
12:56 am
on. the road of being eco complex is located about 50 kilometers northeast of berlin and it covers 1400 acres which makes it the largest organic farm in germany the farmer aims to restore maintain and enhance ecological harmony the animal feed is 100 percent organic and half of it is grown right on the farm the idea is to maintain a self-contained and self-sustaining enterprise that is compatible with the local environment. yvonne was often fed on we grow our crops and harvest them. and those cups contain new trends that are found in the soil. we also sell some of the grain to bakeries. but we use a lot of it to feed the animals. also have that's not true zones and we take them in your compile stead and then put it on the fields as fertilizer of the fed are.
12:57 am
they don't use liquid fertiliser here unlike most conventional farmers. the broad having complex also receive subsidies from the e.u. but not enough to make up for the lower crop yields that are common among organic farms. to increase profitability they market their products directly and charge higher prices. still brought over even has shown that organic farming can work on a large scale. i don't blame any farmer for the situation that we're in now from and so they were doing exactly what was expected of them to cut costs and that christopher chanson for tariffed or didn't. but here we've learned that there are alternative methods and it's incredibly exciting for me to be part of a project that does more than just simply grow crops. it's supported.
12:58 am
e.u. farm subsidies that encourage environmental protection would be a sound investment because they would benefit both farmers and consumers. kicked off. neo soul. in the us some. in our side yes some yes some news it's a kind of culture walk the media sunniest phenomena.
12:59 am
are family on a level. d w. stories that people of the world over information they provide the opinions they want to express d.w. want facebook and twitter up to date and in touch follow us. the world is getting worse and. more news gets us to feeds a lot of problems. the global 3000 talks with team of british researchers who take a more optimistic view. though while it is not always a good plan but is much much fairer than it was
1:00 am
a hot. is the world really getting better. because. a global $3000.00 special report. starts august 19th sunday to the. russian opposition leader alexei nevaeh he has been discharged from the hospital and sent back to jail his personal doctor opposes the move saying she believes no vonnie may have been poisoned by a chemical agent in a valise arrest came before an unauthorized protest in moscow on saturday where more than 1400 people were detained i. beijing has condemned the ongoing unrest in hong kong and reiterated its support for the city's leader kerry lamb.

41 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on