to. prevent beethoven's pastoral symphony is the foundation of an international art project. mark the 250th anniversary of the composer's birth he took in more acquired. through project storage june 4th w. n n f c yeah it's obvious that the private housing market isn't helping bro and that's why we see expropriation as the solution and i know this is sort of that socialist housing policy and has nothing to do with market forces that are nice to

russell but they don't have a right to an unlimited return at the expense of the city social fabric. when looking for a place to live a lot comes into play size design neighborhood proximity to work school or to friends and family but often the most decisive factor is price and that depends on supply demand interest rates demographic changes geographic location overall economic growth you get the picture it's complicated but the simple truth is everyone needs a place to call home and a combination of those factors i mentioned can make finding a lasting shelter difficult for many our theme for today's edition of made in germany is the housing shortage as well see it's a big problem. well start right here in berlin it's a city with the fastest rising property prices in the world in the early 2000 the castrol a german capital sold off huge chunks of public housing to private interests the

dearth of affordable housing has only worsened since then berlin has become a battleground between renters real estate investors developers and politicians. tenants in berlin are fighting for their rights in an unprecedented move they have founded an initiative demanding that some of the property owned by large real estate companies be nationalized. they gathered $77000.00 signatures for a referendum petition. 3 the referendum question is based on article 15 of the german basic law it states that property may be transferred to public ownership for the purpose of socialization this article is never been invoked. in terms of history and law and also the market economy we see this is are really i think of all we call upon the city government and the federal government to put an immediate

stop to the whole affair with. the campaign wants to see real estate companies that own over 3000 properties sell them to the city this would entail ownership of some 245000 rental apartments transferred to a public agency in return the companies would receive compensation to the tune of double digit billions funds that could be used for new construction projects. the german capital is witnessing a battle over affordable housing between tenants real estate owners and politicians . living spaces in seriously short supply has a shortfall of tens of thousands of apartments speculation is on the rinds the last decade has seen rents double at the same time as a construction boom entire neighborhoods are sprouting up like here in the district of. those housing complex is brand new tenants are paying up to 16 years per square

meter a studio apartment costs 350000 years making it financially out of reach to many but there just aren't enough affordable. apartments for rent owned by public housing associations like this one a 54 square meter apartment for 500 years a month in the heart of the city. the place like this will always attracts a lot of interest. in various like. 15 people sometimes what it really depends. to a location price everything culture views i want more than a roof over my head i want to enjoy life that's a factor too. difficult but no you know. it's famously affordable housing helped make berlin the vibrant capital it is today

but now rising rents are pricing people out of the in a city. the left wing government is making efforts to control the situation the senator for urban development in housing is defending the rights of the renters she'd like to see a rent cap in acted before the end of the year this would seem monthly rent capped at a cost of between $6.10 euros per square meter depending on the building's age and overall condition there rent free means would remain in place for 5 years. tenants would have a legal right to demand a reduction in rent and landlords who refuse will face fines as of yet it's unclear if the draw floor is legitimate. critics fear the plan would scare off real estate investors and that the move would actually worsen the housing crisis as property

owners this would amount to a partial expropriation because they'd go longer be able to charge the rent they've charged so far it would be reduced in keeping with the rent that socialist housing policy in has nothing to do with my. that forces not. someone who owns an apartment and is renting it out naturally has a right to do so in a financially viable way but they don't have a right to an unlimited return at the expense of the city's social fabric at the expense of the tenants existential security and there's no denying that the current situation is strained to the point of the redcap is to find the right balance again . finding that balance is also the motivation underlying this construction project at alexanderplatz and. the east german house touched artistic is a prime piece of real estate worth a tidy $15000000.00 yours it's undergoing an extensive renovation when it's ready it won't be a shopping mall or

a luxury hotel it will contain 300 affordable apartments small businesses facilities such as child care centers and studios for artists the property was bought by the city which is renting space to the district of mrs housing authority and an artist's collective among. market is driven by profit but in this case that just doesn't work what we need in berlin is affordable housing and what's being billed as expensive if it goes on like this we won't have any culturally diverse spaces and not the necessary social infrastructure we need to put a stop to this situation which is spiralling out of control. of course the property market needs to invest but political efforts must be made to ensure the market remains fact and berlin new avenues for housing are being explored.

through to adequate housing is enshrined in the universal declaration of human rights adopted in 1988 but we knew long before that that shelter is essential to individual survival and social cohesion here's a brief look at the history of housing. a roof over your head that protects you from the cold heat wind and rain. living space is a basic human need. cave dwellers and early humans places where they can protect themselves from predators and enemies in time humans learn to build their own dwellings whether in the tropics the arctic the desert or the mountains. for a long time humans lived near their place of work. farmers began settling down they turned their dwellings into homes. with the industrialization of the 19th century

living space became a commodity which was sold or rented out. there was high demand in urban centers. sometimes entire families lived in one room apartment houses were built row on row to cover the demand. companies build housing for their employees right next to the factories later entire cities were built to house workers they started commuting to and from work. today living space varies from place to place and depends on what you can afford a luxury home in the u.s. can be over 4500 square meters large in germany the average house has around 150 square meters of space in overpopulated cities like hong kong apartments are often smaller than 20 square meters millions of people worldwide can't afford any place

to live they're homeless or they live in slums in the indian city of mumbai for example there are around 1000000 homeless people. in many cities around the world rent prices are going through the roof in europe zurich paris and london are some of the most expensive locations in berlin rentals and purchase prices have doubled over the past 10 years of. living spaces have also become objects were speculating and that can pose a threat to the human rights adequate housing. now adequate housing may be a human right but cheap housing isn't at least that's one standard argument property developer christoph is of the view that having invested in berlin means he's entitled to reap the rewards and that he then has every right to reinvest these had rewards in building as many luxury apartments in the city as he can but

as ordinary berliners are priced out of the property market should grow not be allowed to keep doing got our reporter chris and chris davis how to few questions for him. it's late but christophe groaners just calling it a day on this prelim building site the real estate tycoon is always busy but he's found time for a brief interview gruner is one of the richest men in germany and he didn't inherit his money he made it himself his company is turning this high rise office building into luxury apartments. you think gentrification is going to change berlin a lot it intervenes here. i think palin will retain its identity there's no law that says we have a right to live in beautiful old apartments with stucco on the ceiling for a mere 6 euros a square meter it's not a fundamental right. there is a fundamental right to housing or not yes to housing but who says it has to be

cheap and in the heart of the city in future affordable housing might be on the outskirts rather than downtown. tell us about the building were in how did you find it before and picked tom. nobody was interested in it it's an old office building and was riddled with asbestos so we approached the local author artes and proposed turning it into apartments. for. the purchase price was 21000000 euros his company is investing a further 50000000 on transforming it ripping out the old offices installing a new facade and building all those luxury interiors. the building will have a generous 4 year and a dorm and of course the lower stories will sell for $5000.00 euros a square metre higher up twice that amount in a season self as a pioneer a very high end construction projects in berlin. after in 2008

everybody said stay away from berlin it's a nightmare you know so i headed to berlin and invested lots of money they said i was nuts for. i invested counter cyclical e that have been proved right by 2012 at the latest it became clear the berlin was set to boom. isn't it have you doubled in size and way more than doubled since the financial crisis of the defense case how much bigger are you 10 times as big. as investments in several cities across germany he says he has a staff of over $700.00 and builds about $1500.00 apartments a year 2 thirds are to rent one 3rd he sells he also bought this derelict office building and surrounding plot in berlin local authorities set the condition that 30 percent must be rent controlled housing for low income people so grana had to sell part of the property to the city of berlin. couple times do you feel any

obligations to society yes it is the capitalists have obligations my company never invest in property where people are already living we only buy empty buildings high rises and office buildings we launch greenfield projects and start from scratch and i make it easy for myself by avoiding the issue and the corresponding conflicts. but is it really so simple more and more luxury housing is going up across more and more ordinary people are being pushed out because of soaring rents is this the kind of city berliners want or deserve. now traditions and customs vary from country to country when it comes to property some place great importance on passing the family home on from generation to generation but not everyone is so attached to property take a look. at home of one's own

for most people in europe that's a reality in italy 72 percent own their homes which is higher than the european average of 69 percent germans however are last on the list of homeowners in the e.u. germany the land of leasers. now the whole point of a roof over your head is to provide protection from the elements and possible danger but what if the place you call home is a hazard in itself in india's financial capital more than by building collapses have caused the deaths of many people in recent years or india correspondent sagna found the car went to mumbai to find out more. young has lived here for much of her life this building a century old was built just as world war one ended. it's a tough climb for the 55 year old chronic need but that isn't i mean.

she says the building which is 80 tenants is crumbling. recently the slab of stone came loose and fitted seriously injuring the neighbor on the ground floor. in the one room that yankee shares with the family cracks run through the wall the plaster speeling and bamboo sticks prop up the ceiling the monsoon rains make the structure riskier each year young pieces she's repeatedly complained to the landlord would little success. you know there was no way that i live in fear that the building will collapse my children are away at work all day so at least they're safe my husband the nice stay at home we could be killed but the way i see it we're old we've lived our lives. leaving the police isn't an option for young whose family owns a modest living tenants like b. just $10.00 a month here in grand some pay even less. that's due to

a colonial era law that limits reigns for old buildings like this one but that also means owners get little money to invest in repairs leaving the structures to rot many parts of mumbai in. a home to old rickety properties data shows that are more than 14000 buildings in the city that are groups of collapse due to a lack of maintain a nice and government apathy earlier this year of 4 storey building collapsed at the spot killing more than a dozen people and injuring many more disasters of this kind aren't uncommon in the city. one buys chronic housing was also linked to its dense population and scarcity of land the city is surrounded by water on 3 sites and has no space to grow. more than 40 percent of its 18000000 residents live in slums and shanty towns

experts say at the heart of the problem of the city's sky high real estate values and a powerful builders lobby. has sort of in the last 20 years. the situation will be a collapse of a building it will mean that there will be an option of a development for the private developer and also because then they have much on most of these buildings out in the island city and that. the prices of. cities. even for residents who do decide to run down buildings in these prime areas things on to much better. family used to live in an old building in south mumbai until it partially collapsed one day during repairs. the governments and the residents here to the so-called transit camp to wait till the

building was demolished and rebuilt she says the current through too has developed leaks and gets water logged out of the monsoon. that's the only really when we moved in here we thought it would take a year or 2 at most but now 13 years have gone by and we have just somehow continued living here in the hope that someday we'll get our own home. for young key home is a much loved but dangerous place option would be to get out and lead a much broader life in a far flung suburb either way it's not much of a choice. as populations expand and cities grow ever denser optimal use of space is becoming increasingly essential but the architects and urban planners envisioning the residential projects of the future may be able to draw on lessons of the past in 1900 walter gropius founded the bauhaus school of architecture famous for minimalism and functionality 100 years on his influence is

still shaping the spaces where we live and work. what will urban has the look like in the future. good spaces and good light supply is tight and prices are soaring i foresee colorful cities but dense and. urban design needs to be reinvented. systematically question every time. designing a. new venture for architect hart building a complex of 140 units in the german city of. good living space and attractive architecture for citizens with low incomes it was commissioned by the local authorities. until now designing single family homes for the wealthy has been his

speciality this is a new challenge clarity of line and form rectilinear a minimalist aesthetic then its work has been inspired by the bauhaus. gendered an entirely new movement that's as relevant as ever to this day. what inspires us most is the clarity and the holistic approach of the bauhaus. a group of people came together to create something new in their teaching and in their practice ranging from skyscrapers to products to graphics every area of design. for the benefit of ordinary people. runs in their subsidized housing project will be 6 euros 50 per square meter very moderate nowadays in a city like. but it's not only about being cheap.

everybody has the right to good architecture and good design. germany lacks affordable housing experts estimate it would take well over a 1000000 units to meet demand and construction has lagged way behind rents are high and rising and so she's like mulek. there was no queues housing shortage a century ago as well with math of overcrowding and terrible sanitary conditions in gloomy tenements as here in berlin poor people often also worked in the spaces where they lived. the bauhaus movement was founded in 1919 and soon came to champion a vision of society and design that was radically new even revolutionary it wanted to create good housing for everybody. to achieve that goal that developed standardize units and industrialized production to bring down costs. it was at the

forefront of modernist architecture championed simple forms free of ornament large windows and light colors. it also pioneered prefabrication at the time it was simply not technically feasible to put together an entire modules as opposed to manufacturing single component. but that changed. the code for a company makes much use for the construction industry. at its factory in holland for example it makes 16 prefab units a day including flooring and windows. they'll be put together on site to make say a kindergarten school or hospital this kind of construction can prove much faster than building in conventional ways. so standard complaint used to be that this is somehow inferior to simple architectural inflexible but that really

doesn't apply any longer we can do anything. conventional construction can do apart from circular but we could do that too. for local authorities to create affordable housing construction costs have to be kept low. when an apartment in this complex in munich goes on the market has $100.00 people apply the rent is 10 heroes a month per square metre that's cheap for the city. the complex was designed by these 3 architects for munich's municipal housing department as homes for people with average incomes their remit to build good housing as cheaply as possible. the demand for accommodation is rising as job growth in the city continues. the market of heating for so we're going to have to reflect on our expectations and requirements. how can we create high quality small apartments.

and how small is small. this doesn't mean doing without generous bases we just have to minimise a little and get a little cleverer in design. unadorned for standard windows the same layouts on each floor simplicity is key that's something that our house tours as well. but the comfort of those who live there also plays a central role in designing the rooms are large and laid out well you have all. the challenges that space is limited and things are getting more expensive including browns. oil. so we have to respond by using this space still available to us for affordable housing. one of the. that is indeed a tall order

a major challenge for housing authorities urban planners and architects buildings that are cheap and actually nice to live in and. that's all for me this week but as always we hope you'll post your thoughts or comments about the show on facebook or twitter thanks for watching.

conflict. despite the coronavirus time that makes close government push for a presidential election in may in the expectation that it would waive my guest this week from coming to so many kardashians keep punishing me feet from the looming law and justice policy forces government guilty of trying to put politics ahead of

people's lives conflicts of. yes and $39.00 s. off to dublin. you can enter the european union and indeed that's what the turkish government told the refugees before the coronavirus gundam. the azimi family from afghanistan and many others took it as it's was. the start of a painful journey that is still known to. some kids in europe. 90 minutes on t w. hijacking the news. where i go from the news it is being hijacked journalism itself has become a scripted reality show it's not just good 1st is evil us versus them black and white. in countries like russia china turkey people are told is that something

and if you're a journalist there and you try to get beyond that you are facing scare tactics intimidation. and i wonder is that where we're heading as well. my responsibility as a journalist is to get beyond the smoke and mirrors it's not just about the fear and balance or being neutral it's about being truthful. funniness point golf and i work in email. frank food. international gateway to the best connection self road and rail. located in the heart of europe are connected to the whole world. experience on standing shopping and dining offers triallists services. alan gassed.

managed by for. this is the w. news live from berlin china comes under fire as it approves a plan to impose controversial security legislation on hong kong it is likely to further inflame tensions in territory where protests have been asked to late in this week we will hear from joshua long the pro-democracy activists who fears the law could spell the end of the city's autonomy also coming up a 2nd day of.