simply. to get. discovery. subscribe to the documentary to. museums are tremendous instruments for creating knowledge. one of the things that confronts ethnological museums today is the need to understand the way in which our pasts are imbedded in colonial history. the way we present the objects in museums speaks volumes about the way in which we understand ourselves other people the

past the present and our hopes for the future. once again there is a palace in the heart of berlin. the rebuilt historical berlin palace it's resurrection has triggered a torrent of debate what signal is being sent by reconstructing in a period of royal residence. the most controversial aspect of the palace is its utilization plan as the humble forum behind the gleaming baroque facade is a modern building which is also designated as the new site of the ethnological museum keep parts of its collection. originate from the colonial era. jonathan fine

has headed the ethnological museum since 2020 we've had the opportunity to follow some of his work over the last 5 years in this ring how will the humble forum deal with the burden of its colonial legacy. in 2021 we accompanied jonathan fine on a tour of the almost complete but largely empty exhibition rooms together with the exhibition designer tim then to me. these collections or things that when we look at them today are very difficult i want to cite a colleague who said if we looked at these museums today we would probably never build them and if we looked at these collections today we would probably never assemble them but they are here they exist and we now have to decide what to do with them. the museum complex and dolman the location of west berlin ethnological museum for almost 50 years began preparing in

2016 for the move to the humbled forum. we 1st met jonathan fine during this transition period at the time he was the curator for west africa cameroon. as well as the coordinator of providence research at the museum the world around us is the product of 500 years of european colonization. with the decision to display the collections from around the world from asia from africa from oceania in the humboldt forum a discussion was kicked off in a prominent way in a more prominent way than was possible before about what that history me. because of the prominence of the building and its prominence in the capital of germany in berlin at the center of this capital on museum island i think the humble forum offers an unparalleled opportunity to come to terms with or to ask. questions

about difficult periods in not just german history but world history. and it all all. aiming for a more open exchange on how to handle objects from the problematic german colonial era and what is now in the media jonathan fein initiated a project to study their provenance together with namibian institutions. this critical engagement with collection pieces that may be burdened with colonial violence is intended to take the discussion in a different direction and exhibition in the humble forum will give an insight into the joint research process we enter into cooperation with the museums association of namibia and the national museum of never to be a and we asked them to choose the partners and they sent a fantastic group of scholars of cultural heritage officers of artists to berlin who worked with us close to a year about the collection here in berlin and talking about it and understanding

it. i'm a fashion designer clothing technologist i studied in germany this is why the fashion design community thought that i was the person to actually sent to berlin a while history and fashion ysabel hot rock rock all and all the timeline of the european timeline but nothing about africa it's about time that we start running into writing our own history and these objects here can help us get to. wherever 3 projection for put this is known but the program and then this here would be the horns were supposed to be rolled so that it can depress into points of the crown we've only seen one that's removed most of them appeared open on the world i think we like to think about museums as places that store objects well but i think you know when you

see something like this you see an example of an object. having been sort of really stored in a way that deformed over time i've discovered for instance. it covers the head of the hair or woman it is very important that is always kept with the little crown on top is the pride of the woman once a woman is wearing and it's you cannot just take it off in public the leg will take off my head this is where you start wondering but how did they get it because no hair or woman would take off their corrie and give it to somebody it's hard to underestimate how old little people understood about the objects that they. that they had brought into the museum i think. you know and if you would hang around the neck or do. it susan you're hot and. you don't carry it around with you ok the shell of the turtle there's herbs and powder in there that you used

for cleansing yourself as a woman. and there are many of those objects is something that is very close to me is the door and then if you look closer it was hence to choose very even hand stitches which is telling me that it was done by a child with the lady over how i was. pushing. me and you can definitely see she's wearing a pretty coat. as a child my grandmother used to tell me the arrows are wearing more than one particle because they are scared to be raped and this is what you see this a betty colt and everything i want to look at this is just. it brings up emotions that you took some something from a child you brought a tear you never shoulder to the world that this is what children in a movie are making you put it in a box in a museum dusted and that sort. of.

you never know you know not have to check or it isn't out of colonialism has levels of violence that you can read from from the object. i think this out just can't tell the stories but in namibia and germany. we can i just say well this objects were taken from them via let's take them back even when they take 2 and i mean yeah where in namibia is this very much importance. this objects have obviously connected in germany and just pretending the objects is not enough so namibia and germany need to continue in cajun wi fi chadha through these objects my wish all these objects all go home. the next phase in this process is to bring

objects back to namibia to expand the conversation and if they want to make a case for returning them permanently for keeping them in namibia then i fully expect that out of the conversations they will be able to make that case and make that request here you'll see an ordinance to lation by and then maybe a fashion artist named cynthia it shows to me. a figure a woman trying to break out of the cabinet trying to break out of this part of it and behind her she's carrying a blanket and is covered with black and white photographs and many of those pictures are very upsetting pictures of people being mistreated in chains hanged and things like that and we work very very hard. so that you'll only be able to see some of that because oftentimes very violent photographs. can titillate a viewer in

a sense i mean they end up in the producing the impact of what's actually going on there. the location where her work will be exhibited still seems questionable to send. that plane. i don't know i don't understand it's. i don't even understand why are. they reconstructed the whole boarding and what message are they trying to bring now by doing this. the reconstructed facade of the berlin palace where german colonial policy was once pursued is a contradictory symbol for the humble forum is this an appropriate place for exhibitions on such a problematic chapter of history. we meet the head of the berlin savvy artspace bon of and to of soy to kong an

internationally renowned curator who has worked for the documentary exhibition his exhibitions examine the present day effects of colonialism and the challenge of displaying foreign cultures in european museums. he argues for a fundamental change in perspective. what knowledge is created above when you bring the so-called objects over each year museums we have to go back to the huge tree of it in the graphic museums we have to go back to. the birth of the notion of anthropology to be able to understand what went wrong and i think that at the core of all of this is the creation of of when we do. talk about.

history's. situation it is not about the office it's a whole. how can you enable such a shift in perspective. in 2017 jonathan fine curated the exhibition beyond compare and berlin's botha museum. it juxtaposed to european mostly christian influenced art with works of art from africa posing a fundamental question are we still seeing the world through a colonial lens when for instance we regard christian cult object as art perceive african art as cult objects. can the humble form question and change such perceptions. many curators have spent decades working on these topics of social justice and provenance and working with source communities and wanted from the beginning to make that the topic of the

exhibition. so this is the pedestal we're going to be putting. the throne from the kingdom. of mark boal object it brings to a point a lot of the sort of questions that people have about the colonial era. the man do yet a new throne was a birthday present from the king joy in cameroon to kaiser vilhelm the 2nd a genuine royal gift or a payment of tribute to the colonial power i always thought it was a gift to the kaiser is that not the story well it is but it's gifts are complicated we know that he really didn't want to give up the stone and the what went through his mind what calculation did he have to make was he going to lose face if he didn't give something important to the cause or was he going to lose. however if you didn't give something important to the cause.

how should this gift be handled today. in 2017 we accompany jonathan fine to cameroon on the traces of the man do you know the throne. how do people here feel about their colonial history. if the throne had not ended up in berlin it would belong today to this man. joy the sultan of them and grandson of king joy who reigns during the german colonial era. in the case. of. the german colonial system in cameroon was violent and characterized by deceit trickery and manipulation as well as the use of

military and political force because king joy offered an alliance to the drums the situation in the bomb kingdom was comparatively peaceful. was one of the most skilled political actors that i've had the chance to study he tirelessly sought to preserve his own autonomy within the very difficult political situation that was presented by the colonial era. the palace administrator a staff member close to the sultan is involved in preserving the cultural heritage of the book. the mental game it is missing here in the throne room is a thorny issue. question we keep press use every day that goes by we are obliged to talk about this thrown. the tourists who come here are constantly asking. so what is the throne of the kings of bar move doing in berlin fear there

are. some people saying those germans stole our thrones on when you talk. yeah sure some beliefs it wasn't a gift. or if it was it was a forced gift for 3. a and how can you answer this question security. you know there is no official answer will he see all. that diplomatic response reveals how troublesome the issue still is.

and from bonn we get a sense of how objects from the colonial context could stand side by side with living social spiritual and artistic traditions in their place of origin. it's an environment that western museums could hardly provide. while. in the car use my house is a studio is all of my daily while we have one off because the sat is very big we sit here and sissoko your prong. artists embroidered the new royal throne for the palace if he also works as a restore for the palace museum why he's gone so hawt. in 2017 workers here packed up their collection to move it into the new royal museum. it's spectacular architecture is dominated by symbolism from the moon's royal crest

a 2 headed snake wrapped around an earth spider. just like in berlin's ethnological museum staff here in from bonn also had to consider how to deal with the colonial past. sits in the group use of the blue and this hall is completely dedicated to king enjoying one this one the time of his reign is often compared with louis the 14th and france there you'll be exposed he oversaw a cultural explosion. a blossoming of creativity and also a synthesis between the christian western world and the world of bom moon don't. see that example that's why in your culture we view king enjoy as a genius. at what are your expectations for the relationship between germany and the kingdom of

by moon today and in the future and pull of india. there is still a physicist to show thank you very much for asking that question to tears it probably we consider that a woman enters a marriage with germany back van in because it was expedient to do so book salumi in the how should i describe the relationship today the role of divorce. in the settlement but hopefully not suite of. yeah we are really hoping for a revival of our relations through greater cultural cooperation us home. could threaten the the germans will understand the mutual benefits involved in helping us to preserve our cultural heritage you know but you might have returned your through to the throne that is in berlin is an ambassador for rich culture rich or.

one of the things i took away from our discussions and from bonn was the clear wish for germany to live up to its historical promise of friendship and i think one of the things we can do is make that expectation clearer to the german public and to make that expectation clearer to german politicians. it's time to engage more deeply in this cultural dialogue. several years have now passed since our visit to from bonn what should this dialogue look like bond of untoward indecorum grew up 100 kilometers from former band and has heard about the throne since he was a child. the cultural ambassador of germany to the us doesn't belong to the us it belongs to germany right. then we should apply if you want to use the analogy of

the cultural ambassador of the throne should belong to the people from right so. i'm all for cultural ambassadors so let me say in also a very important work from its you know culture to. put it in the museum as well it is fine but to we do that it is a one way street so if we want to look at shared heritage let's share it everybody said we did and not just some peoples and others not what should happen to the throne in the future for me is very much an open question because like many of the things in the. we now have this past we've looked into where we are looking into it and as we know more about it we may want to make different decisions about what should happen to the objects for the future should they go back. and that's a decision that i think can only be taken. in consultation and dialogue with

our colleagues and camera perhaps they should go back but even if they do i feel like the story you're telling has to still be told here giving an object doesn't mean that history goes away. the history of a collection is intrinsically linked with the exhibits themselves and that history does need to be told in the humbled forum while preparing the move to the forum jonathan fine join conservators from the museum to inspect some of the collections most controversial exhibits that the name brands of. these masterpieces from the former kingdom of the nene in what is now nigeria were looted by british forces in 897 the artifacts were later sold on the art market. these brands and ivory sculptures have become an acid test of whether the humble forum is genuinely prepare. to take a new approach and enter

a dialogue with former colonies as equals for decades nigeria has called for the return of these treasures only now in 2021 are things beginning to happen how does the process of restitution work and why are museums so reluctant to proceed with it just for fun but a competition as a rule the 1st and most important step in returning artworks is making recommendations as to what we want to give back that has to be decided by the board of the prussians cultural heritage foundation is used to go to that's not something that the president or the museum director can decide and another important question that needs to be clarified is who the rightful recipient of clear ideas there is at the stade or a national museum system is it a local community and that's quite complicated for but just to be clear we will be returning been in bronzes on security also a good beatin the new branch and sort of. part of the bin in works will be returned but part is to remain on display at the humboldt forum so how can these

tainted exhibits be displayed appropriately. this is where this multimedia program which is really a multi screen film will be presented and all the voices from europe and africa including the oboe. and scholars from africa will talk about the provenance of the burning bronzes the idea is using very simple questions to get people to open up and talk openly what are the benny and bronzes. what do they mean to you. what should happen to them in the future and then to really hear what people have to say about that topic this concept of really exhibiting the discussion of provenance and the work of the bringing dialogue group was already there when i started 10 years ago and that's been really the central theme of this entire room of the exhibit what is the future what should happen to these objects

that's an openness that that i really treasure about this process. 'd cultural institutions find themselves battling to remain relevant in their societies. confronting a difficult colonial past poses not only a challenge but also a huge opportunity for museums to take the lead in shaping an important public debate. will the humble forum successfully rise to the challenge. i think it would be a success if we take the idea of a forum at its word and think of the humbled form not as a place that will give us answers to your questions but will enable us to pose questions only. in that way i think can we come to an understanding and find

answers for ourselves about what 500 years of european colonization has meant for the world we live in.

with the cause for injury. which could lead to 911. time most of mine and powerful thing around music sports car choices for many current the easiest. i'm legend an icon and a fellow the 911 the very essence of the porsche. read.

in 30 minutes on d. w. . hy floyd. culture. hair. superman. superfood stylish style icon don't let o's. life style during. your moment. 60 minutes. oh. these places in europe for smashing all the records to. step into a bold adventure. the treasure map for modern globe trotters to discover some

of the most record breaking sites. banks and no also in book form. we have important new members. smoking news healthy. posted signs are good for the beams global warming doesn't exist. don't believe those. not yet the full. range of minority. industry is controlling your thoughts they are tends to leak. science. it's not easy to spot i'm saying one thing and history is saying another. great book so. good 20th century. present day hoaxes.

and who's behind the. menu fracturing ignorance starts may 3rd on d w. 2 . this is day that we do is live from berlin to india appeals for help as hospitals scramble to secure oxygen the e.u. pledges more aid to india as the country's comit crisis threatens to turn into a catastrophe hospitals are overwhelmed by un precedented numbers of critically ill patients also on the program. funerals are held for more than 800 people who

died in the fire that swept through a covert ward and in fact that hospital officials say the place was started.