ah, yes, to be radical. that's a radical mean. go back to the room. he is the son of jewish holocaust survivors. how lucky that i was able to build, you refusing berlin is architecture, is a celebration of democracy and one building. the biggest thing in the world is the spirit of an architect. motions. this kid starts december 25th on d. w. a is a shark coming up today, watching students on see see tv in their classrooms. that's the government plan to keep students safe. but parent say it encourages board ism and violates privacy. who is right, an expert offer some context. for some schools have to put in place your boss to

mechanics done. where did i get? i'd be missing. some schools, how the housing to be investing to die is ation. when it comes to how you can give them feedback for how long do you handle that teacher who have act? ah, i'm british man, you're welcome to the dublin news asia. glad you could join us. the government of the indian capital delhi is installing c c t v cameras in school classrooms. it says it is to keep students safe that reasoning ball not of cds of sexual assault and rapes against students in schools. some perpetrated by senior school students themselves, some by school employees, and others by outside does more than

a 1000 schools run by the delhi government are to be covered by the scheme. but it's dividing opinion across the board as dw corresponded. i'll didn't pot reports this government school in delhi became one of the 1st schools to install cctv cameras in its classrooms at public areas. every day, hundreds of students here are constantly on the serve alliance with each moment of their day being phoned from the come put off, is office principal rockridge. the yard can monitor every thing happening at his school. he says that camera footage allows him to quickly tackle problems like bullying at betty crime. something is there, okay. are a warning system you can say there some students if they have some kind of from frank or something to their also this. so having the idea, okay,

you are being watched, our thing is being recorded to that as to that discipline gilson. but many of the students feel uncomfortable at being under the gaze, all the almost $200.00 cameras in the building. we know the camera, i think no student would want to be watched by cameras in the classroom. and i'm sure if you were a student, you would want that either. so far, cameras have been installed in or 500 schools across the state. concerned with the growing number of cameras, the daily parents association has taken the state government to good thing to day parents association head up budget. i got them and her team are meeting the a lawyer to discuss the case example. but they are preparing for a hearing in the coming week and then we have our project. our sees that live streaming in the schools jeopardizes the safety and security of young girls and

could lead do digital wires them. i waited from the perspective of parents, i think nobody has the right to see if my child or daughter is studying or not studying in the classroom to people, not even parents have that right. i see this moved by the deli government, has encouraging a culture of life, still king stopping commodity, the intern at freedom foundation, an organization that defense privacy rights and online freedom is also critical of the mass surveillance is constant till the lens of children also has a negative impact on their social development. so what is happening essentially is that salinas of children is being increased in the name of making them more secure than not getting more secure instead to they are now being harmed. as increased security at the cost of privacy is hotly disputed around the world. india continues to rise up the list of countries who washed their citizens more closely. the debate

in delhi is whether school classrooms should be the focus of such serve alliance. many parents and students think not. and got him enough more context dot to send you to my partner from giga. that's the german institute for global anerio studies and part of for doctor martha research looks at the impact of digital surveillance on civil liberties doctor mother to welcome. what does the research say? does cameras, surveillance, and classrooms keep students safe? i thank you for having me here. oh, i'm, it is very different because i have been studying schools in daily, in calcutta, in buying at all. so why ccd cameras are becoming standard practice? there is no standardization of best practices. however,

in the schools that i have been to one, these are mostly city based schools that have b k, the bullying from down to an extent in the schools that i have gone to, i think directed with parents with faculty members with students themselves. so when it comes to a bullying incidence, yes. and to an extent, last, if you think the cameras have reduced these incidents of stocking of how this meant . oh baby. i had a lot of my assumptions also challenge to and i did feed were in b because i as you, that students would be a good b would try to change their behavior. it comes to the cameras inside classrooms. however, point of time i saw that they did, they got used to it and they were not that aware of the cameras be there, which was quite revolutionary of the going to eat analyzation of the surveillance

mechanisms that is happening. so just based on what you're saying, but there it of it would appear to have the correct argument that they are keeping children safe. by installing ccv cameras in delhi government schools. is that correct? us? i would like to give it a kind of a curve yet. here because what's important is that you have a reasonable expectation of privacy. that is, that you cannot come and put cameras inside restrooms or in certain areas that be considered to be the private. and here those has to align with the purpose for which the data is be connected, as well as the processes in place to prevent the misuse of data. and this varies from scores to scorn. i go back to my point about standardization of practices. why some schools have put in place robust mechanisms where deed are gonna be misused.

some schools haven't the hasn't been there since at dia, zation, when it comes to how do you handle that data? for how long do you handle that data? or who has access to it for how long is it stored? all these questions are very important when it comes to, especially children, when their data has to be handled with extra care. and there has to be extra deal diligence here, right? so yes, but somebody happy with the decision on jerry, the government that majority of the bedrooms that i spoke to for them, it was a confidence building measures that schools during orientation when they had this bed and are just going back to the point of purpose and a process and the digital data protections in india, would you say the 3rd, the way digital data is handled and the protections around. but defer to the way that differ in india to the where the handle potentially in the worst,

particularly the sensitization around that by west also, it is just shows like in germany it is pretty good. the standard wrinkles g to be or is, are there, and that is also the rules when it comes to the fundamental rights of dish to lead or protection. but in india it does, lacks the gutter, digital, digital personal data protection act ability, which is this is part video and now it has been passed and it gives god blanche to the goldman that a lot of wide exemptions. and then i have your privacy concern, that's the 1st problem. we don't have a data protection bill act in place. second concern is we don't have a statutory body of data protection where people can resist conserve secret dresser . so that doesn't dare. so it's pretty lacks the data protection act,

but this is at the macro nearby. what i would like to stress here is that when it comes to schools that's at the micro level and where they be with parents and parents are pretty vocal about their children's protection, at least now. and mind you let me put in one examiner information here that ccb counselors have become a standard practice across india from 2017 onwards. but abbas 60, i've been seeing this in bangalore in deland, ghana, in calcutta, in mall by recently long by one of those 65 paulson, the civic and private schools have brought in caesar doing cameras. so these are also there, but the concomitant data projection measures those have not been in place. so again, i stress that some schools do good work. they have these control rooms where very

few people have access to the data feed. why some schools just put it in a deception media. i can see what happened in the city. so it's not standardized. let's look at that on. it's our job to a little look at the non digital side of this argument because the government's claim continues to be. look, we want to keep students if, therefore we need to have the city, the cameras. and based on some of the experiences that you have had, it seems to be working, at least in some schools. let's look at the other side of it. is this also a case of the government washing its hands off its own responsibility to ensure that school employees protect children? this is actually a very good question because our did. this also differs from state to state like in daily government, one of their flagship areas, as education and hen. and here, there is this consultation constantly happening between the government officials

and schools about especially the schools that are getting government support. so here the government cannot wash off its hands of security of children when it comes to this place because these are the schools are accountable to the government and the government is identically accountable to the waters, the feds. so in the video they don't. private schools here any we have some amount of autonomy when it comes to the safety of children, but here no one sees it. for example, an inquiry gather. for example, we see that the municipal corporation is adopt into the schools and trying to install the city. we kept us outside the premises to prevent incidences of violence of crime, especially they started with schools which are guns only good schools or educational

institutions. so we see mixed picture from state to state. so here, so i don't think we can have a simple answer here to suddenly a very different score time to the time the tie was in school, which was many years ago. thank you so much for joining us to the doctors and get them up. i'll try for that context. thank you so much. my pleasure. and that's it for today. of course, most orders from the region on our website, the w dot com, forward slash asia. and as ever, you can follow us on facebook and twitter back again tomorrow at the same time with our sports, all about winning fighting, scoring. we say they were about never

giving up the most exciting sport stories about people, their passion, and their drive. boy, life every weekend on d w i, she's got issues to thought they will grade. he will be able to get with ah, i'm steven beardsley in berlin. here's a look at our top stories. a milestone for germany as liquefied natural gas flows for the 1st time through an l. n. g terminal. we'll look at what it means for the energy crisis. russia opens

a new gas field as part of its pivot to china. but can it really replace the energy trade volumes it enjoyed with europe? also on our shows as the destruction and ukraine is growing and the price tag for reconstruction, rising, we'll speak with the head of europe reconstruction bank, about the plans rebuild. welcome to the show. a small milestone in germany today as the 1st flows of liquefied natural gas have entered the country's gas network. it's happening via via a new ellen g terminal. the country's 1st and courtesy of this ship, the hug esperanza lovely name. it's all happening here and bill holmes hoffen on germany's north coat north sea coast. that's where the ship, the central part of the terminal will convert the delivered l. n g back to its gaseous state and the floating terminal in vill hm sullivan is connected to the natural gas network in germany, vh 26 kilometer pipeline. the pipeline cost around $150000000.00 euros and can.