ah, what our sport all about in winning fighter scoring we say they're about never giving up the most exciting sport stories about people passion and their dr. sports life every weekend on d. w. o o, the dime or veterans table has, but that's what ukraine's foreign minister, the mitchell, calais, barode and a facebook both this week he stressed that this year ukraine will finally receive armstrong with allies, with fantasy lost in britain. and poland have confirmed that they will send martin heavy dance to ukraine,

while the u. s. germany and france also promised i'm would be goes for the 1st time since the war began in february. but you can say, it's not enough mean by fighting continues in the region of dunbar for the last 4 months. so on to the point we ask for ukraine is the west joining the war with hello and welcome to do the point on our panel today. we have crystal fun, marshall. he is senior correspondent, the bowling b as newspaper, dia, dog, and speak with jessica bolen. as a political analyst and founder off this strategy consultancy goals truck. and joining us from bon b, have jerome on gunshot ankle is from ukraine,

and vauxhall and t w's russian desk. thank you for joining us, kristof. i'd like to start with you. now for the last 11 months we've seen a kind of reluctance on the part of the western countries to directly get involved with in the war. now that these tanks and armored vehicles are being delivered. is that door taking a yoda? and would you say that? no, i wouldn't think so. natal countries are just delivering weapons. they are not fighting on the grounds. are not sending troops or so nothing has much changed. of course it's a difference was are you just sent old soviet type weapons or no wisdom? a technology, but i think the pressures are growing and are we will see in the next 2 weeks are really opened. the bid was a german legal part heavy fighting a tanks should be delivered and not only by germany, but through the consortium. a coalition of european countries were wanted to do the right jessica, since the beginning of the war, the western countries have been talking about this red lane,

that should not be crossed. do you think the red line is getting crossed now? absolutely not. like christoph mentioned, sending equipment does not make the west party to a war. if this were the case, then iran would indeed already be considered a party in this conflict because they have been supplying drones and missiles to russia. so the logic or the fear that somehow by sending more advanced weaponry to ukraine, the west is becoming a party and the conflict is simply factually false. also, it becomes a bit of a moot point because if we look at the equipment that is already been sent by western nations, including germany last year, hobson gay part, so cheaters, anti i b m r, air defense of missiles and, and vehicles we already have sent a lot of deadly weaponry amongst the western nations to ukraine. so the fact that

the caliber and the size and the number of weapons would increase this year, does not change that dynamic direct. i'd like to go to rome on now in bon roman b. know that there's heavy bat did going on in a bar mod an solider, but now that the western countries have decided that they are actually going to deliver the dogs and the weapons. do you think the situation can be brought under control or do you think that the decision was actually taken to lead and this should have happened a few months back? well, yes, i think the decision is too late. but. but maybe it is just on time to stabilize the situation the cause to deliver infantry light vehicles like the german marta. we had them in spring and germany said no ago the german industry said yes we could do. we could send dozens of mazda tanks. i if i've reached a to ukraine very soon, it didn't happen then. so what has changed?

i think one of the major reasons could be that western intelligence now has enough information that russia is preparing newer offensives in ukraine this year. probably in the coming weeks, maybe in spring, but definitely do there's something going on. and just like we've seen, as western intelligence knew that russia was preparing to invade and starting to send light weapons to ukraine, for example. javelin on to tank missiles which were very important in the 1st weeks to stop the russian invasion. i think we are, we are seeing something of the kind. now, when the west knows, there will be an attack and it wants to help you crane to withstand. and of course, this is not a game changer, like for example, the u. s. rocket system, hamas was and still is. it's a system that allows ukraine to strike a di behind the russian lines about 80 kilometers. and we've seen how it was used

at the beginning, or during just on the new year's eve. and then many russian soldiers were killed by mckee of car. a nother digit not don't ask, but that is a game changer. sending tanks is not again, james, at least not at this moment, is the worst, has been sending tanks before, but they will soviet tanks. now they are western tanks and they will help ukraine stabilize the situation. but sending main battle tanks like the earlier part to the german one, there is no decision on dirtier in berlin. that could be something very important. but as i've said, there is no decision on that yet. right. sending these thanks is not a game changer. that's what romance says. it was about a year back when germany had provoked outrage by offering to supply 5000 military helmets to ukraine. germany's reluctance to send military equipment had caused a stir. but now things seemed to be changing. is it pressure, or is it

a change in the strategy? let's take a quick look at the supplies that ukraine is expected to receive. in the coming months. it was quite a diplomatic bang when french president emmanuel mccaul announced the delivery of the am x ac 10 armored vehicle to ukraine. it might be a discontinued model in france, but it is still valuable for ukraine with its $105.00 millimeter gone. the western allies are under pressure to act. the us is following suit by supplying its bradley infantry fighting vehicle. it only has a $25.00 millimeter gun, but it's defense missiles can engage elemy, takes up to 4 kilometers away. at the same time, germany has also promised to deliver 40 martyr infantry fighting vehicles, some from bonus fair stocks and some from the private industry. it will take about 8 weeks to give ukrainian soldiers the required training. great britain is going

one step further by offering ukraine, the chance to acquire challenger tight battle tanks while supplying western tanks. turn the tide of this war. will it turn that? i'd crystal. what do you think roman just said that these are not game changes. where as you okay saying that it actually wants to deliver banks that will change the game. do you think the cable get changed? it starts at the dynamics that might change the course of the war as the situation when it gets to the question whether we get to talks between russia and ukraine or putting made quite clear that he is not willing to stop the ward and swore until you rush, i can keep serv, tori, tory or she occupied, and from ukraine inside. it's clear that he don't want agrees to that. so there is a necessity that are ukraine. air has to re occupy it's territory and therefore the needs are these heavy tanks. and for the time being, as we have scenes, eve,

the martyrs, the french thank thee, earth the bradley fighting vehicle, seats. these are not the heavy tanks they need for a ground offensive. and to, in order to do that, we will have, we will get to the discussion of that. the needs is heavy tanks and the best model for the situation is the jermel your part. all experts agree on that for, for different reasons, is there enough in stock earlier our spare parts, which is not the case in for the french belting and the american tanks must be 1st delivered, oversee atlantic to europe, which is also and not quite a very pragmatic way to, to, to do things and most, most western armies in europe use already really or part and they are enough or government willing. and they are just waiting for the germans permission, the export permission to do so. and the pressures moving because the commissioner of the european union, or the law on the line of germany, politician or talk to the state and said she is in favor of sending law parts

ukraine and sweden has now the presidency of the routine union. the government is in favor of doing it. poland asked to do it lithuania and spain asked already in summer to do its all. it really all concentrates said chris are on the german government. so you have to decide was as it gives the permission to export, says german, her mate's legal part to ukraine or not. and i think they can't afford for a very long time, not to not to permit that. you've talked about lee about to add, lend, jessica, i'd like to actually understand the difference between these are banks. i don't mean to get very technica but we just saw the briefly in the report that about the 4 countries. so what is germany? what is france? what have you as and what is the you'll get actually planning to give and how do we differentiate between the heavier tanks and the, the later ones? right, so routine than the non changes, the infantry fighting vehicles that have been committed that to go to ukraine are

you could say light tanks, they have a lighter builds and body. they're a bit faster, but they also do not have the amount of armor or also the higher caliber of ammunition, that the main battle tanks the and b t's have. and the real crucial issue here for the m b t's to arrive to already get the approvals and be sent. now it's crucial that this happen as soon as possible, so that the ukrainian armed forces are able to receive and train on these vehicles in time to launch their spring counter offensive. and these vehicles, not only these tanks will not only save lives, they will help the ukranian armed forces to liberate more territory and to defend against the assumed pending russian attacks in the coming weeks and coming months. and it's incredibly important for the european union,

the european allies and the united states to move quickly. now, because for the past year, what we've seen is western aid being enough to keep the ukrainian is a life to make sure ukraine doesn't loose. but now, this year, we must ensure that ukraine is able to win and we need to arm them accordingly. this is crucial because time plays to russia's hand. they have more weapons, they have more manpower, they could drag this conflict out for very long time, if allowed to where is by acting now. and by giving the ukrainian armed forces, the tools, the weapons, the support they need to win decisively and to liberate their territory. will deter russia a from any, any further kind of aggression on this scale, but the more time they get to regroup and to re arm, and the more weakness and hesitation they see on the side of the western alliance

only serves rushes interests. therefore we and especially here in germany, need to pull ourselves together and act now and what is stopping job an event. that is a question that could fill an entire show onto itself. but at the end of the day, and i take no pleasure in saying this. but from discussions with german politicians from all the major parties, including the s p d. the problem is the chancellor re, is olaf choice and his colleagues in the counsellor in the german chancellor re, they have been blocking the export approvals, the export requests from our ollie's for months. and the main argument that they've been using. number one is all of shorts loves to repeat, we don't want to go it alone, kind of a line gang in his words, right. and the issue now. however, as christopher mentioned, there's a lot of pressure building on both sides of the atlantic for germany to approve of

view the live parts to be sent. now germany, so known, but in a coalition. yes, yes, i'm a lawyer that we, we need to approve the exports for the other countries. and of course, we need to contribute our own. but even if we didn't contribute german leopards, we have been blocking. our government has been blocking the delivery from other countries. but now, by still holding out that not going it alone, that has been all our choices, main excuse, is becoming the going it alone. so that excuse has, that has already a sort of fallen apart. and the 2nd one, the 2nd of fear, i would almost call it rather than an argument because it is not based in a technical or even legal reality. i think it's quite, quite frankly, a subjective fear that that sits heavily in the staff of the chancellors. and indeed, and personally with the chancellor himself. this, this notion that if germany sends to many weapons, russia will consider us

a party in the war. and this is, am as previously mentioned, or just and nonsense argument. that's not how declarations of war work. if this were the case, then iran would be at war with ukraine and they are not. yeah, and you don't have to, johnny already would be for the weapons we've already sent or the united states for sending high mars. and if, if hymer is, are okay, why are leopards not? and it is indeed an irrational argument. that seems to be a decision that germany does not want to take a lot. and all of charles has said that we can't a big decision without our transatlantic partners. and i called, he said specifically without a united states of america. christopher, who is actually going to take the decision germany or the u. s. whoa, formerly germany has to fix a decision, but they will be pressured by the us and the argument which is used by the time to the not going it alone or we don't have a consensus. it is just factual in natural. we know that the are the lies and the

american government has made it quite clear that germany is free to take that decision, sir, to haven't yet set of his lead. you have to go because that's also not how a diplomacy works, but it is pretty clear that the west and european allies not, not all of europe, but enough european allies would be in a coalition with us. if c townsley would decide we want to give li parts to ukraine, it would not be a german going it alone. it would be a coalition and probably trans lendy coalition. and maybe the u. s. government has to make it even more clear publicly in order to convince the chancellor and all saw so german public because as we look at the opinion polls after the decisions that we sent to light tanks, there was a majority in favor of it. it's a moments as a majority against sending leopards, but if the government would explain why that should be done and that we are in a coalition of countries, which i am save of it, i assume also in this case the public,

the mood would change and or would support it, in fact, the sterling from the chancellor, he has been having a negative impact on public opinion. they are sewing the doubts in the public themselves, and they are about 2000 leverts in europe. the different countries and ukraine has said that it needs at least 300. thanks. i'd like to ask romando roman, do you think that's a demand that could actually be met 300. thanks. well, it's hard to say it is very important to start. so we've seen that as soon as some kind of equipment is delivered, then the ukrainians learned very quickly, and then more of that equipment type of equipment can be sent. so in the end, maybe by the end of this year, we could end with hundreds of western tanks and not just leo boards. maybe some other challenges from the u. k, as you have mentioned, could be sent to ukraine because it needs them urgently. what we haven't mentioned yet, but i think it is very important for us to understand why these things are happening

. why are we talking about western countries breaking the table and finally sending what ukraine has been asking for for a year. like a light things have tanks and also into our craft system. air defense systems patriot, which was also kind of a red line which has now been crossed and berlin is on, on the ticket, delivering it or promising to deliver it together with the united states. one battery of patriot. so russia is speeding up and increasing its military. russia. and just in december, russian president announce, and his defense minister announced that the russian army will be increased by half a 1000000 are soldiers. this is already happening. the new year started at the decree by president fulton is now in force, increasing the russian army of fort worth by over $100000.00 soldiers. and one more

increase is expected. when a spring, conscription campaign begins, are russians up to 30 years old, will be drawn a drafted to the army. these people will be sent on the battlefield. the russian and military is producing in the russian plans are producing tanks, day and night. they will be sent to the front. the west had to respond. right. so you're talking about what's happening in russia. let's take a look there solider assault, mining town and east new cream has seen some in dance fighting in the last few months. the town is located about 10 kilometers, not off back mod, in ukraine's doormats region. and the capture of this region is widely seen at the kremlin war objective. the muffled thunder of cannon fire is relentless in the heavily embattled towns of buck, mood and solid on both sides have spent weeks firing at each other day and night.

russia has been mounting pressure with tactical advances and claiming ground most recently in solid are back moved and solid are, are currently the bloodiest places on the front, according to ukrainian president zalinski any one who was able fleas like this woman from solar dar only it was oh, who survived by hiding in different apartments available. when one apartment was destroyed, we moved to the next hour. when it became unbearable, we fled. i would have liked to leave earlier, but i couldn't leave that the key for you. at the same time, russian and bella, ruffian, army units are training in neighboring bella. bruce, this is one of the reasons why concern is growing over a new front north of t f. but in the russian army still strong enough for major offenses. is it christoph, now moscow had claimed in september that it had

a next this raised me up in january right now, and the fighting is still going on. well, i have from dia, perspective on this year. i don't think that the war will end in this year. i think we will see heavy fighting. we might hope that ukraine is able to re when territory . but there's also one more aspect which i would like to mention is that the question to which degree europe is an international body on itself, strategically autonomous or not. and we see again this year that without american help, europe is not able to stop a war on its continent. so from my perspective, things are, they are not looking bad, but they're also not looking very good at the moment. and that has to be more done in order to get in a better position to end this war rather sooner than later. right. and salter,

jessica. that is militarily, it's not a very relevant place. why is russia so keen on capturing the street and, oh, it's like you say it's not about the town specifically, but it's geographical location. and if they are able to capture this town, then it opens up by moot and, and from there further territories within the region. so it is on a plate, enables them to advance their offensive. but i'd like to come back to what the crystal said there, there is indeed the possibility of this war dragging on for a long time if the ukrainians are not properly equipped by their allies. that is what last year taught us do not underestimate ukraine's ability to quickly absorb and deploy western technology, western intelligence and western hardware. so this year,

the debate we are currently experiencing around the delivery of main battle tanks. we're going to have to have this debate about aircraft, about fighter jets and about long range artillery systems like the american outcomes. so we need across the trans atlantic alliance to clearly define what is our goal for this year. what is the battle field goal? if we, we in europe and across nato, want this war to end in 2023. and especially for the americans. if they want this war to end before the 2024 presidential campaign, which i think they do, then we must act accordingly and arm ukraine. now, this is a sheer tactical reality, and as roman had mentioned the russians, they are pumping on full gas to re arm re quip and re men their

army. and they can do this all day and night. so if we do not respond with the same intensity and conviction and speed, then that is what turns us into a long war. but that's primarily enabled. we're going to the last year of the show, sorry to interrupt you there. i'd like to go back to room on lunch before we can conclude roman. i'm do you paying now christopher and jessica. they're both talked about whether the war will come to an end this, you know, not how do you see this? do you think the war will come to an end in 20? 23. i don't think the will will end this. yeah, i think most of them optimistic scenario is next year. so 2 years more of fighting. but i absolutely agree with jessica. the speed of, of this war of the temple when it ends, how it answer depends on the will of the western countries to deliver more and to deliver fast. and right now the temperatures in ukraine,

it's like minus 15 to minus 20. do you think the weather's also making a difference? do you think in the coming days we might see a different situation, bender, or better becomes a little more made? absolutely. so general winter is, or at least in this moment, on the russian side, we hear reports about ukrainian soldiers freezing in the trenches. and this is one of the reasons why they probably are lost solider, but this fighting is not all what it continues. and the news of western or light tanks and may be heavy tanks in the near future that could be delivered. this would stabilize the frontline. absolutely. i'm sure of that. thank you. the war is not over and that's also what paul is president answered. daughter has said allow me to court. he said the war is not ending. everything indicates that russia will continue to wage a war of attrition against you. create the rest and defense minister. we'll meet next week to discuss future military, a well joe money given to the pressure. that's the question that remains to be

answered. if you are watching us on youtube, do let us know what you think about it by leaving a comment. we'll see you next week. thanks for joining with

. ah, i don't set is how uncommon dream. a young man from blue india boots joined the dying escalations are jeopardized by cultural barrier. nevertheless,

twi, down for a famous sound global 3000 in 30 minutes on d w. we've got to understand that globalization work, but he does not reach more than 30 percent of the world population. very simple in the mediterranean, as become a kind of great sarcophagus business. it's business to come with your whole life. people gonna believe in many believe life is better in europe, but that's just a fan of single globalization. where do we stand in 75 minutes on d, w o. a question about life, the universe and everything he knew the answer. well then give it

here for me to the answer to almost everything our documentary series with clever crazy and groundbreaking questions keep going to the after life i dumber and dumber. how can we feed every one. 2 questions for the present future and heads filled with ideas. 2 been when we learned something, the hard or, and software of our brain changes. so get ready for the brain up to 40 to the answer to almost everything. starts january 15th on d, w. ah,

ah, ah ah, this is the w news life from berlin. russia makes advances ins, only dot holds off declaring victory. ukraine is called the intense fighting and you cranks east a difficult phase in the war. as all the $500.00 civilians are trapped in the small town. as the boar intensifies, russia looks to step up. can.