this would have been, you know, say like, good everyone to ok, retiring into the microphone. sorry. check out the award winning outcome. don't hold back. come have a page. is this out to be highlights new every week in your inbox, subscribe. now. nearly 22 months after russia invited to ukraine's much heralded counter offensive has failed to deliver the breakthrough. the key of expected claiming that russian forces are improving their positions. vladimir proteins, meanwhile, as dispatching more soldiers, weapons, and munitions to the battlefield. ukrainian forces and citizens are bracing for another tough winter with us support hanging in the balance presidents lensky warrants ukraine could lose without us help. meanwhile, russia has launched

a diplomatic offensive in the global south, and a hybrid attack on the west are question today. russia's war on ukraine will put in, get what she wants, the and it is a pleasure to welcome our guests here on to the point with the julia is and associates fellow at the german council on foreign relations. the the g p. he's an expert on eastern europe and a mediation advisor on ukraine at the center for international peace operations. great to have you with us. and more had scotsman reports from eastern europe and currently ukraine for the german news magazine status. and finally, we are very pleased to welcome from london, intervene to borrow a gun. she is a russian investigator journalist, co founder and deputy editor of ogden, tour

a dot. are you watch dog of the russian secret services activities? great. have you with us every now and more it's we're hearing the world word stalemate mentioned more and more these days. do you think that term is justified? is this conflict edging towards something that you could call a frozen conflict or? well a frozen conflict. uh would be uh from the line where you don't have the shooting anymore, but that's definitely not the case at the moment. what we see, basically since last november. so it's 20. 22 is the patricia war. basically don't have a big movement of the frontline anymore. neither of the sides can conquer any big cities or territories, but it's an attrition of war from trenches to trenches. the. the use of drones is

very important at the moment. it's becoming more and more important. makes the better blog or even more. and yet it's an patrician war with the thousands of victims every month. and um, actually at this moment no, and i'm side, i'm, can i just ask you, because i know you have been reporting from ukraine. the for you to has also recently been there, but the counter offensive. there were high expectations of it hasn't delivered any gains at all ukraine's kind of, uh, unfortunately it is concerning the frontline, uh they haven't been a lot of gains. ukraine has gained some square kilometers, some square miles. the butts. uh, the, the big aim to push through to the, as of the see i haven't been reached. and of course, also because of these big expectations. i mean, the landscape at the beginning of the year talked about

a year victory. and this is why, but inside ukraine, the frustration is also very big. and it's irina if, if i can go to u latin been put in, has been looking and sounding pretty confident lately. should he be? how is how well assured is support at home on it's, it's not, uh, it's not an easy question because, you know, uh m, russia is, uh, a sort of thought on the machine um, on that, uh, sort of thought energy and people on not a simple and not free to express themselves, and especially in nowadays, in the rush of people are frightened up all the time and like comp express themselves really bought. the last polls shows us is that uh, the main question was, and people, russian, people want to ask fulton is when is a water bill? and so it's bills is that he's support

a little bit. so there's not a lot of people who are approval and put a support in terms of uh, in terms of continuing the war is not so strong as it used to be. and it rushes, pouring a tremendous amount of resources into this war effort. how long can it sustain that as long as it, as it needs to to be almost off o. a lot of analysts, many of them including me, fail to predict how strong zip codes and resume is and how good, how go to the his economy is doing so far. the economy is still doing quite well and, and there are a lot of resources still a lot of resources that put him come, come, spend on the war. he was successful to some of the fi, older sources into, into the military, industrial complex and russian military. industrial complex is much strong guys and

it used to be 2 years ago. so let's see how i know how it will go. but i think that she still has at least 6 or 8 months does out that and problem we've had this lead of nato's secretary general young stoughton bag recently said that the west should be prepared for bad news from ukraine. i'm quoting here, and they seem to discount the current stand off saying that wars go up and down. they have good and bad phases. yes, it's of course true. and the problem is how long the wall to wall goes bad for, for ukraine. and that is, that is a problem, but it's also a problem for russia. we should be clear because not every thing is very nice in russia and in the long term. also putting knows that as a collective best is if he's really, really to a support ukraine for a long time. has a superiority in technology and also in financing that's clear. and that is

actually the case because why russia is now launching that hybrid media campaign. also is a global sauls to get the impression we are mighty, we can do everything and to, to bring uncertainty and intimidation into the rest of society. so let me ask you about that and we will come back to that global south outreach that he's been of the global tell us, i don't like i know in the us, but everybody's wanting time. where is this says that, but let me 1st ask you in regard to what stilton power has said, he basically went on to say in the same, in the same as a statement that we should be prepared to support ukraine in both good and bad times. but are we the us the senate has just torpedoed a $1000000000.00 aid package for ukraine. and i, you know, there's a doubt about the degree to which the u. s. the biggest supporter will be willing to maintain that support. yes, of course. and of course,

what i said is only true if the rest is really ready to support your credit for a long time. and it's not only because of liberating crime, yes. and so what it is to defend to ukraine also simply the problem is i think that we still do not know what is the outcome in the fights into us. because we still have many republicans who are who are very willing to counter against russia against pollutants, russia. so i think that is also part of a bond beginning, but it is of cause it makes the ukrainians answer such as a problem. and the 2nd problem is, what i see in europe. yes, we scaled up our support. yes, we already achieved very much. for example, germany now is the 2nd deliver of, of weapons lots. very interesting. however, we are not on the way that we really will have an important risible share which can compete with us in order to convince these republicans that it is the voice

continuing to support the war in your off. let's pick up on that important in the moment. but i would like to take a closer look 1st at the situation on the battlefield in ukraine. the us defense secretary recently said that russia has been badly weakened by the war, but at least for now that weakness is not readily apparent at the front lines. an increasing amounts of lessons and more and more sold just russian president troops and wants to increase the number of troops in the russian armed forces by 170000 people to a total of 1300000 at the beginning of the 2nd twins of the war russia remains strong. we are now fighting, not just for russia's freedom, but for the freedom of the whole world. for them there is a country that is now with the full front of the building, of pharaoh. well judah, without so silver and strong russia is no longer like

a stable welled. odom as possible through which these they've been in the middle of the view as much to accomplish this person. also, except pine losses. his soldiers, which stood the ukrainian counter offensive. they even went on the counter attack like and of the account. the russian army never seems to run the hour, so that munitions, that's successful basle plans also include the increased use of drones and electronic wolf fat. on top of that cyber attacks using refugees as a means of existing pressure and propaganda patients, hybrid whole strategy is working despite international condemnation and sanctions. is russia getting stronger? and let me put that question to more it's and perhaps also ask you to talk about how we are seeing that in conjunction with the battle for of the data. now every, it's both sides have been sustaining very, very heavy losses. they are,

the ukranian government says its soldiers are standing their ground. is that your assessment? they are standing the ground, but especially ukraine has more and more problems to get more soldiers to recruit more soldiers inside the country because the people see what kind of war it is at the moment. and you don't want to gets one way. tickets into the trenches as possible. of course, if you're a man and you created today. so what i would say is what we need after the so 21 months of a war is a realistic approach, a realistic approach that doesn't underestimate the enemy, russia, but that also doesn't over estimates what ukraine can reach and what we can do for you. crane and i have the feeling, but especially the last year 2023 at sold,

especially these problems have problems that we also overestimated ukraine. we were thinking that it could, the, when the war and this year, but ukraine itself, they also over estimated what they could do and we under estimate the dresser. so this is what i hit most of the key findings that i would get from this. yes, with realistic approach, would you agree? yes, but the realistic approach means also to, to differentiate why russia maybe has a momentum. i do not think that's a in quality really. it became stronger at the moment, but that can happen if he would not change strategically or you create a support for ukraine. you'll see, for example, the enough, the if goes that the is of course, much more last as long as the russian sites. so it is clear we have and of course the losses and i have to the degree of us missed the government to be the ukrainian . so we just came exhausted. that is a big problem of cost, but they are still not ready to give up. that is also very clear also in society. but what we should see is, yes, russia now has more than one nation, but excuse me,

is a rent out of one dish and they had big problems a several time ago. actually, it was optimal, the munitions they still have big problems has mechanized briggs look who is going to have the because it's only in front of people, go on foot to the front lines, not supported by a big and make a nice picket. so what i only want to say is we need to realist on both sides. and we have to formulate such aims, which are realistic also when it comes to offensive. and also when it comes to defense in order to make really successes, which, which bring ukraine in a better position and bring do not mix into a fable fuel crate. so let me go over to irina, and ask you about the real situation for russian forces. the us national security council recently said that russia's heavy losses at of difficult or depressing the russian troops morale. and they claimed that russian commanders were

threatening to execute entire units if they retreated from ukrainian artillery fire . can you tell us whether that is true, that claim, and 4th, the mood is amongst the russian forces hall? i don't know whether it's true or not, but you know, is that all in, in the russian past is this sort of to you and in as a used this mess that's and i'm in this message i've all successful. and if i mean, at least is at the thought it was paid. but no, i don't. seems that uh, that current pool is a little more seconds. so harsh mess that's could be such that successful to some extent, but you can use it every day. but to me so far, um put his position as

a reference position on the, on the front line seems kind of strong. i'm, i'm very sorry to, to, to say is this. but it seems they found a lot of sources including people or sources as a difference between between as of last and the roster is that the last is usually can about the soul just about the people about the human resources. but russia does not, as a criminal, don't pay a lot of attention to how many people, it's sacrifice and it's a buckle failed. and it seems, besides that russian public does who cap a lot to. so that's the difference. and we'll come back to the way the rest of the public sees it. but move for you. let me ask you this. this conflict has become a war of attrition. as more it said in his 1st uh, answer earlier. does that automatically give russia with its size and its resources, the advantage? and how long can rush to sustain the kind of of spending,

but it's doing it. if you count national security and police, russia actually is heading towards spending 10 percent of its g d p. if that sustainable. i think it is sustainable in the, in a certain time for certain periods but, but not a, not automatically for a long time. and so it is actually why russia now is one things east companions, because they know if the west will decide for more support technology and financing of ukraine. they knows that in the long run, russia is a v cousins invest, not, of course, because then ukraine, you'll have to to be clear. yeah. yes. of course, but restaurant when it comes to pass, note when it comes to resources is more, might even ukraine, but not if you repeat and us will be making ukraine for a long time since the 1st thing. and let's make a little remark. onset war of attrition. that is not completely true, we should never the less take also a deeper look on the from science and receipt of costs that ukrainians manage to go

through. so sort of became line on certain points. a problem is ukraine has lots of support of got craft, and russia has a full superiority in the air over the occupied territories. and so it is a problem, but the problem can resolve in the next time. that's a much more better for ukraine. the 2nd point is, please do not forget that ukraine achieved to reopen the humanitarian corey door for the crane export and for the exports of goods of ukraine, which is very important because they could push back very much. so russian blakeslee fleet, and they could really substantially home as the russian facilities on the c sports . one question, and then i want to shift our focus to the diplomatic side. but russia is not only ramping up production of military hardware and ammunition. it is also investing massively in drones and recently launch the biggest strong strikes since the

invasion began very briefly if you would. what effect is that having on operations on the ground? well, i mean, of course we see more drones attracting ukrainian cities. but the, i would say that's a ukrainian air defense. it's coping quite well with that. but the more important is the drone of warfare over the trends of it's isn't it terms, least the frontline to kill zone where basically soldiers can't get out of the trenches without the getting killed. and that is another important factor. if you need a pot for drones, you don't have to get a pump. your don't hesitate pot onto the front to protect your things which would go forward. yeah, yeah, yeah. thank you, irina. so let's move on to talk about the role of diplomacy and all of this. the quote from protein that we heard in our report just now was part of a speech in which he depicted russia as a champion, pushing back against the hedge,

a monic west. how many countries of the global south are actually buying into this message? and what does that mean for russia's war effort? it does things that's a lot of conscious around a mile away is saying want because the author to come, contreras acts too many for as in the as a new oh does i need money? is a need is the last months and russia are ready to go for life as a support too many to some african countries and because a lot of african refugees, they need, uh, city security. um, do you know, walk in the opposite rock to do that for us and minnesota. lot russian pride with minnesota company provide some offer because there seems to be a security based protection. so that's why 2 tools put 10 spends a criminal narrative is more come in that often countries, but i mean, is it done by these is i just need to support them. his mind you are saying that's

probably true for the last time i made a good contrast. so i'm huge onto medicaid is reach us right. handles this concept for uh, for some very genuine reasons also is better helpful here. more it's a put in is just made a rare and very quick trip to the united arab emirates and saudi arabia and to declare the relations with the em or etc at all. time high as he said, does that have anything to do with the fact that numerous russian companies have now made you a either temporary base and are using it essentially to evade western sanctions or? well, i think we're getting to a point where we have to admit that's if you want a more realistic approach. that's the, the, the, the power of the west is very limited. we thought at the beginning of this conflict that our sanctions codes leads to the fall of russia somehow. but we have to admit

the 21 months after the beginning of the war. that actually there are lots of countries in the world who maybe they are not russia friendly, but they tell the west, this is not our conflict. we wants to stay out of this. we won't, don't want to get any negative impact from this the, on our economy. we will cooperate. but everyone and this is a very different situation, maybe from 20 or 25 years ago. just the time. however, i do not fully agree visits, please, takes effects look at the summit with us. so there's a sole controlled assault and must cause the african summit. many state these us did not come as they did into for me. yes. so piece, so it was quite disappointing. and what you also see is that's when we now speak this uh with brazil and sells in america about some mecca. so agreement that this

actually, what's the west still has the potential to do also with india, to give them something concrete substantial and to say, okay, if he, if he makes that agreement, we can, for example, also speak by some you'll need not to take. so essentially see, but please keep to summer with so we need much more diplomatic investment because what 14 declared is about the globe itself. that is only a pop is a realistic result. and the other thing is to find out more, it's when we look at support or lack there of from the west. what difference do you think that the were in gaza is making? is it diverting western attention isn't attention and potentially also resources at this very critical moment when you create most need some. this is of course the, the attention is a very important resource. and what we saw for us since the beginning of the gaza war is that to the attention is going away from ukraine also because of the fact

that from you came, you don't have for so many good news as i'm home. and, and yeah, of course the tension is distracted from ukraine. but also i would say that the cause of war is a moral problem from the west. because you have a situation where israel is bomb being. at the gaza strip. there are heavy civilian casualties, and of course in many countries of the world whom we told over the last 2 years, that's russia, it's bad and the more really bad they ask now. okay, what is the israel doing at the moment? so morally, this war is also a big problem for the west, joe biden, to abide and said when the senate defeated the aid package for ukraine, that it could certainly become a big problem for the us as well. saying that it could be that we see american

soldiers fighting russian soldiers. if the u. s. c says to provide support the free do you think that will change any mines? is what i didn't the of if, if a rock job i, instead of the u. s. continues to deny additional support to ukraine. it. okay. it, well, could be that hotel and we'll get what he wants and that the u. s. could warrant and fighting russia. i think that is actually what we should still understand. yes . that is the do not support. now ukraine, it is also a problem for our security for the american security and finds the way. it's also important for the republicans, because if you want really to contact china, you'll also need to come to contain china, instrument and euro. that's important at the end of the gaza, very important. it's also about geo politics. please do not forget the fuel and has the concrete interest in his basis as ends in the east. that's also very important . i'm going to not go there because we have very little time left on the clock. and

i would very, very, if you'd like to, to come back to the point about morale that you made earlier. irina, how do people in russia and especially mothers in russia see the prospect of this conflict? continuing, we seen mothers demonstrating in ukraine and isolated demonstrations in russia itself. how high is the dissatisfaction there? oh, as i can size a do such as function in russia is not a lot of huge because for him, for the last, for the last small says for him, for most successful to recruit most people from on in on trucks, stores so on. my bill is ation stopped for a while and people what happened is that on sofa, a sofa shoes is fine, is a truck. those people qualify for money, so they have family else such as 5 business money. and as that's live and all the

time of the process against the war and more, it's those protests in ukraine itself. could they undermine the war effort? one sentence once that, of course, if the war continues in this attrition mode, this problem will get worse. thanks very much to all of you for being with us today . thank you. out there for turning in the

you know, we are being chased and they are falling out of people that has to be very fast check. when you have reception please, we might have the zip code for environmental is, are on the run from the to the mass. yeah. the illegal simba trade is a 1000000000 dollar business with no regard for people or nature in

15 minutes on the w makes your in good shape, finds out the genes uncontrolled. only if you every day nice is nothing to things with you in a cloak, it can be just for mental single health research techniques. so how keeping instinct in good shape in 190, dw, the, the taste we have a problem that was in the us middle class income has fairly risen in the last 20 to 30 years to fix the hops. okay,

so it gets the same time that keeps right. 300 trillion that the truck stuff, december 9 on dw, the words people have to say yes to the that's why we listen. because every weekend on w, the the,

this is the, the news life from berlin. israel is really tre, campaign intensifiers in the south of the gaza strip. the army says soldiers are facing fish for distance from home. aust. benefits about gun fire opportunity and asked strikes have that to even more finest and in casualties leading the us to goal for more production of civilians. plus the tension in the taiwan straits typeface is china has said fighter threats and a weather balloon into ty,

with these aerospace triggering alarm bells.