there will also be a cultural desert because the hatred of the occupiers of the crooked language will eventually transfer to all russian-language , including russian culture, and these boys are there, and i don’t want to say anything bad about them, but their cultural horizon is very wide, not very wide for our boys you still have some three degrees, but that's a--and it's a joke. and further, seva added one more thing about the language, you couldn't do without an unconditional question, of course. he said that he couldn't imagine a textbook, for example, on quantum physics in ukrainian because the language seems to be ukrainian, there is still not enough tools to talk about not such serious topics as quantum physics, quantum mechanics , by the way, one of the presenters said that he

lived in holland for a long time, i can’t imagine the same textbook there in dutch, so the dutch language is also obvious there is no toolkit, but russian, of course, has a very cool answer to this. although no, it seems to me that i did not answer, but i just got stuck because, ah, answering russians is already a bad enough tone among many ukrainians we just comment on some of their statements, if they are already very bad. sviatoslav vakarchuk, who is a physicist by education, wrote a story like this , let's see. i will quote the first textbook on quantum mechanics in ukrainian, written in the 60s of the last century as a theoretical physicist, doctor of physical sciences, or yukhimovych glauberman, my father, ivan oleksandrovich vakarchuk, also studied with him, who , by the way, wrote another textbook on hidden mechanics. but that’s the way it is.

on february 24, 2022, rock music, the music of freedom will be played in russian. syava navgorod knows that. well, judging by the way rock musicians behave, the majority of russian musicians , even those who seem to have declared their aspirations for freedom, how do they behave now, how do they write in each posts that we are out of politics , of course, and about how the music lesson is, well, it can't be normal, ah , let's figure out what happened to seva, a novgorodian, anyway, why did he say such a thing, to his credit, by the way, if possible, somehow his to justify him in a comment on a social network, they put the self-cover of ivan vakarchuk's textbook on it. and to one of the comments, seva replied that it looks like this book will haunt me for the rest of my life, well , that is, i want to believe that he still

realized that he was a wolf, but the reasons for that are even very intelligent smart, subtle people, russians, who may have even left for some european countries a long time ago, why can they say such frankly disrespectful things, as if the hero of the movie brother 2 could say something like that why does seva novgorodtsev resort to the same thing ? does he not understand that such a thing cannot be said? i will tell you that from my point of view, the soviet information and cultural policy is to blame for everything, which, unfortunately, also affected us ukrainians in the same way, we almost have it behind us too watch out, and the russians are in the top, everyone else was ridiculed or surrounded by stereotypes of nationality, i mean the jokes about the slow baltic people, do you remember the dumb chuvs who are absolutely not dumb, now you can

find many programs on youtube that simply open your eyes many people who believe russia's anecdotes , sexually disturbed georgians must also have had a place in this old cuban line. well, of course, all this cultivation of chauvinism, which has remained in russia, and we are getting rid of it, thank god, anyway, led to such a scattering of aggressive of chauvinism to such an intelligent man, we can remember the image of a ukrainian in the film 12 by nikita mikhalkova, what a cunning man he is, but you know, he is all dressed in some terrible clothes, because a ukrainian cannot have a normal appearance, yes uh, he's a dumb, talkative guy, but he's very cunning when he needs to, he'll find something to do, and uh, you know that's why i'm surprised that the case of seva

novgorodtsev is because his name is actually vsevolod livinshtein, and he's a jew, and who but jews should know the price of such chauvinism such a stereotype with which certain nationalities are surrounded now we can see on our unfortunately, on the example of this genocide that hmm actually, this all leads to certain such very sad consequences and the main thing is that even educated people are not so simple boys like said vsevolod, but such educated, high-minded men like him do not bypass this topic anyway, because even if they do not read, the lesson still remains unlearned . have not been to ukraine, they are not familiar with our context, just like vsevolod was not. he was

familiar with the fact that the ukrainian language has had a toolkit for a very long time ago for discussing very complex topics, he simply did not i knew he allowed himself to say that, so he reminds more of such a stupid version, for example , zadornov with his constant phrase americans are stupid and you know, unfortunately, i follow such a slightly older generation of people there, people who, let's assume, are 55 plus 60 there plus, not all of them, of course, but many of them still live in the paradigm that americans are stupid, american cinema is some kind of shit, american actors and actresses are all the same, although these people do not know anything at all about hollywood cinema, about american cinema, what it is completely different and one of the coolest in the world , you can find anything there, but all the same, this

stereotype is still alive... someone has forgotten, but very recently, in 2020, on channel 112, the now-deceased, a show was launched that called people and the presenters became an example of commentators, swarm molchanov, deputy editor-in-chief of strani.ua, svitlana kryukova, musician oleg karamazov, from the karamazov brothers well, syava novgorodians well, when did they start? to close all these tv channels, in particular, and the 112th, all of them are taken to the very beginning to protest against this, and began to say that this is an attack on freedom of speech and that this is impossible in a civilized country, and what does it mean, how is it possible, and i quote, now a hole has formed in the air многочисленные русскоязычная из большое has no

informational and cultural source in the country , there is a tension tension, nothing good can end well, you know, there is such a definition, useful idiots and i think that it fits him and it falls to the pity of seva novgorodians and this is an example of the fact that even thinking people are educated and it seems, well , you know, people who have long chosen the civilizational path to development will not escape them neither chauvinism nor thought-out phrases a-a well, let's say that you can leave russia, but from unfortunately, we will now move on to another type of russian liberals, and among them is anton dolin, whom we will talk about now, but i also want to say that anton is not quite a film critic, but he is a much thinner, more intelligent version, for example, bozhena rynska already on

rynska, let me remind you. here she is, she is there, a candle, a reviewer, and all that. and we all laughed at her recently, because she started writing posts in which she predicted a wonderful future for ukraine, they said that ukraine would certainly win, and then the government of our country would be seduced by all the wonderful people. cultural kyivans who will simply come to us, the rain channel will move to us, this hardness will move to us, and finally our culture will be enriched with such wonderful representatives of the elite, and our dna will of course be replenished with such a wonderful mk of russians, and we will finally we'll get better, of course, they talked about the fact that we don't need this friendship and dna and your friendship with the theaters until today, and i don't know if she understood, but it's about the same the same situation is happening with anton dolin anton

dolin is one of the favorites until now, there were many ukrainians who are interested in cinema, but now he remains a favorite because he is an example of the best russian. it seems to me that it is ironic or not, it can be said ironically because he repented of everything. by the way, career he lost several jobs because he refused to work there a-a or where he considered that he was a disgrace. although he worked in the urgant show that was running, this show was broadcast on the federal channel a-a he constantly consistently spoke against er-e there putinsky for the government, he sympathized with ukraine , so on and so on, plus he is a very good film critic, he understands movies well and i am very interested in talking about him, that is why he is a superstar of film criticism in russia and in ukraine. now on march 6,

he posted on facebook that he is with his family he is leaving russia. he gave a lot of examples. he showed a photo of his apartment on which the letter z was written - it meant that we know where you live, bastards, and we know we read what you write there. what is your position? he wrote that enough . well, i don’t know if you can call it a repentant, understanding post about the fact that um, every minute of this life in russia turns you into an accomplice. let's see part of what he is wrote this, it is important to understand in order to further understand what he is saying. already now the quote, the whole world collapsed 10 days ago, the life of every person who lives in russia, who speaks russian or is at least

involved in russian culture has changed irreversibly, just many or most have not yet realized this in ukrainians will have a chance to rise from the ashes of turagin, they will only become stronger and will be able, if they want to forget about the suffering we have caused, for forgetting, we will have neither opportunities nor rights, but it is not even about friends, he wrote about his friends who ukrainians live in ukraine. hello, they will win conditionally sooner or later, but they have already won irrevocably. and we are going through a catastrophe, not economic or political, it is a moral catastrophe, wrote anton dolin and found support among many ukrainians who wrote to him in the comments that anton, thank you that we understand that there are still good russians in russia, like you , fashion, clothes, nadezhda well, what is anton dolin doing next, it seemed to me that in my understanding, at least, in the understanding of many people, that anton dolin is simply

he will not touch the issue of ukraine, ukrainian cinema, he will probably move somewhere to some country, he will do volunteering or something else, he will not, for now, do not touch this topic, because he should, as a reasonable person, not read he is an intelligent person, you understand that he is already perceived as part of the aggression and he himself admitted it, and that is why it is not very pleasant for us ukrainians, it even hurts when someone from russia, from such good and wonderful people, starts to get into our internal problems. we need to analyze us and even sometimes criticize, but no, it seems to me that he forgot his words about taring and began to be indignant, for example, he wants a mild boycott of russian cinema, to which many ukrainians call, many ukrainian filmmakers in general from our

community, and they say that he has enough er, such a position is widespread that it is possible to boycott films that were created, here is one of his articles , for example, on jellyfish why do we touch independent cinema created by talented russian directors there, maybe with some non-state funds, why are you such cruel ukrainians, you can’t do it, he defends his friend serhiy loznytsia, a ukrainian director, whom i’ll remind you a little, somehow, it’s not in time and expressed uh and his you from the ukrainian film academy for the fact that he wanted to participate in the festival from lviv to the urals imagine what a wonderful film festival in france and in particular for this

desire to participate in such a film festival he obviously carries with him the idea of ​​friendship between ukrainians and russians, despite everything, despite all the troubles, and he was excluded. well, for the fact that a ukrainian director, in principle, cannot morally participate in such a film festival. anton dolin defended loznitsa who , by the way, named people he was expelled from the film academy by the nazis for such a decision, great , absolutely no warming of the russian federation , often anton’s fate well, i don’t like the comments that ukrainians write to him en masse in e on facebook, again, i don’t understand why so many people are looking for him dialogue, but there, for example, they write to him that please do not touch the topic of ukraine, and you can simply not discuss any ukrainian topics , ukrainian cinema, to which he ultimately conveys an opinion

that can be seen very often on the internet, saying that i have i will write on facebook what i want. he very often starts to argue with ukrainians. they are offended, as i think, when they tell him what to do. they tell him what to write. well, for example, he writes the following. everyone will have a conscience, how exactly was i supposed to stop the flow of my troops to ukraine , i won’t even ask, well, it’s not very clear. why does a person oh-oh-oh write first you are a repentant frank post about the fact that he feels guilty and so on and so on further about the fact that his nation will be cursed for a long time and when, as a matter of fact, this is what happens, he feels this kind of attitude from ukrainians in particular , for some reason he begins to be

indignant and does not understand. that's right, but when the time really comes for some kind of responsibility and accusations, well, they start pouring down and somehow reneging on their words , the correspondence between us and our ukrainian director antonina nobramova was quite interesting. well, now we can see , antolin posted something about andriy tarkovsky and here antonina wrote that they say that now there is only bucha, there is no russian culture, there is only stinking biomass that cuts people and, uh, pussies and dogs, we have uh, just on the roads well, what is anton dolin said that you know many people in ukraine who are now comforted by tarkovsky, i can only imagine what is wrong with people when they are comforted by tarkovsky now and they are still writing to anton the fateful one about this, and antonina then writes to anton about that

hmm, that's the difference between ukrainians and russians, that we went to the maidan, uh, and you don't go out, why did anton say that you have an emotional state right now, uh, it's possible to disagree with me, if so be it, the ukrainian people are beautiful russian horror, if you like it, it makes it a little easier for us friends, understanding that love and further admiration for russians, well, russians in general, even those who are considered very interesting and wonderful people to us, still leads to such a result, we can not understand each other now because we have such different ideas, so different emotions and so a different goal, because we will still disagree with them on some issue, we will quarrel and realize that they do not understand us at all, and

it will hurt us, just like many people who absolutely admired anton himself then they wrote to themselves oh my god, how could anton write like that and the story is quite interesting that happened - it is that ukrainian film critics began to write a project on the russian website medusa, which is now positioned as latvian or lithuanian , it can definitely be wrong, but there is absolutely no information there about the baltic countries, however, there is a lot about russia, and here, in particular, anton dolin started a project that will analyze the latest ukrainian cinema, again, all the requests to disengage from us do not work, and moreover, ukrainian film critics went to this collaboration and began to write in the first issue hmm, they started to write some

analysis of ukrainian films on the russian media, well, this project began with the film atlantis by valentin vasyanovych, this tape is about the year 2025, when ukraine won, but it became so that it is impossible to live in donbas, hmm because it is completely burnt land, it is poisonous, and there will be many tens of years to come , demining will have to be carried out and somehow this land will not be brought to order. i found it, i thought it would change at least once, damn, what the hell , everything is the same in them. and in two years, there will be a desert here. and it is already all around, even in the river, the water is salty , and it is already being taught that it is not possible. anton dolin wrote his

part of the review very complimentary, yes. there is nothing bad to say about ukrainian cinema, and two film critics volunteered to write it, first of all, andrii alfyorov, one of the most famous ukrainian film critics, ah, hmm, but i was interested in aksenia kurina kurina yes, i hope the accent is correct, which has been missing for a very long time she didn’t write anything, er, that is, i know her as she dropped out of school in the distant past. that is, she doesn’t write . she has actually been outside the context of ukrainian cinema for a very, very long time and is not engaged in a profession. she is engaged in something else, and here she decided how she wrote film critic and she wrote something to write. she wrote quite an interesting phrase in general. well, the most

quarreled with atlantis, she said that this film from her point of view is quite opportunistic, it was shot in order to receive prizes at film festivals, but another previous film by valentyn vasyanovych, which is called the black level is much cooler, and in general valentyn vasyanovych is one of the best ukrainian directors she writes but here she writes the following phrase describing atlantis er they write what describes a world in which there is no er hope for the future but life has not stopped, and here is a quote in the original language, i will translate it for you after february 24, 2022. atlantis has turned into a terrible prophecy. которой прозыгглашает победу но очажается привещение себе будущество после неё well, i don't know if each of you understood exactly what was meant, but

translating from the language of film criticism into human language, well, apparently ms. aksenya wanted to criticize the ukrainian authorities for the fact that this is how she rejects pacifism how inappropriate the idea is and that she is almost to blame for such a terrible future befalling donbas, on the one hand, it may be wrong. of course, because it is such an aesopian language. but it seems to me. if you want to speak directly, then speak directly, but most of my acquaintances took it precisely as a criticism of the ukrainian authorities, which they say should be about this pacifist, be against the aa war. unfortunately, i want to say that ukrainian film critics in general, our film fraternity is mostly, even those who were sufficiently pro-russian have changed their point of view a lot the critics got these films, critics who were

printed in the russian edition, even which is considered oppositional, but still, in our community, it is considered completely inappropriate , but we have people who are engaged in art and cinema, which still stand in positions there, as if it were a war. they are absolutely not affected . they continue to speak for peace and continue to insist that we hate russians, that we do not boycott russian cinema, that we do not remove monuments to pushkin, because, well, what is culture? they say it's all too radical, friends. let's be a little calmer. well, it seems to me that such a position has already somehow shown its inability, it is the inability to protect itself, but fortunately , there are fewer and fewer such people, we will move on now. to oleksandr rodnyansky, who also remains a favorite of the ukrainian public. it seems to me

that he has every chance to continue already in ukraine, ah, some kind of career as a tv producer and a film producer . kinotusovk signs as a ukrainian film producer, which from my point of view is absolutely appropriate because he lived in russia for a very long time and was involved in two tapes and series that were absolutely anti-ukrainian. however , oleksandr rodnyanskyi is still very popular in ukraine in spite of all that he did, the main thing is that oleksandr soviety talks very interestingly, he is an interesting person, he is involved in the creation of, for example, the 1+1 tv channel, even the old one, which was loved by so many ukrainians, which was, on the contrary , revolutionary from the point of view of ukraine, he began to speak ukrainian thanks to this channel in the

90s, many people even switched to ukrainian , they saw that it was cool, but then he moved to russia and started a career in russia, let's see by the way an excerpt from the tv series that came out in 2000, in principle, set the tone for the material produced in ukraine, this series is called bourgeois's birthday , this ukrainian-russian series was very popular,

but it set the tone for the following, that the main roles in the series must be performed by russian actors the series must be russian-language, some characters can partially speak ukrainian because , according to one producer, part of the film community, who evicted publicly about it, ukrainian is unsuitable for dramas, suitable only for comedies, and that's it of this tv series and then there was such a trend , ah, already in russia, in russia, i wanted to say that although in russia, he began to make different series, very ambiguous, which also set a certain brand , first of all, this is my beautiful nanny, a series that we can don't watch the excerpt because we already don't have time, here we will remind ourselves of the main characters viktoria prutkovska, the main character's name was a nanny , so she came from the city of mariupol, friends from

mariupol came, ah, her mother is coming too, and uh, they settled in a family, you can already have such a man intelligent, too. and she is such a bully. i apologize , well, zmiriupol from ukraine, who can come, and for many seasons, russians and ukrainians were very enthusiastic watching these characters, too, such a stereotypical view of ukraine and ukrainians is quite insulting, and a ukrainian was involved in it producer oleksandr soviety in particular well, then he made the series cadetship as the premier , which was also popular in ukraine and in russia - this is a series about hmm cadets about the students of the suvorov school, and already then ah he ah already in 2006 prepared both russians and ukrainians for the fact that the russian army is great and invincible, even starting from the suvorov school, the ninth company was also a film produced by oleksandr rodnyansky, hmm, about

how they all died heroically there, what a good fellow they all were, the white guard probably, the biggest disappointment of oleksandr sovetsky is the tv series eh, hmm, in 2014, it seems, uh, in 2014, this series was not issued a distribution license in ukraine, but in 2012, it was released, we all know very well the ukrainian-phobic tendencies in mykhailo’s work bulgakov, no matter how cool a writer he was, if he had not continued to be loved by many ukrainians, but white as the guard is one of his most ukrainophobic works, and here alexander the soviet became a co-producer of the tv series well and chernobyl, too, the series is the answer to the hbo hit. and the soviet also produced that was the answer. to be honest, alexander the soviet now regrets in every way that he did it, but he is doing it again. well, it is quite careful to

sit on two chairs, as it seemed to me, but now it seems to me that it is not the right option when it is possible to sit on two chairs you need to choose your clear position ah because you will lose and many people will lose who choose uh and here and there and well , i don't know, let's see what will happen with the soviet ah but many ukrainians are waiting for him, you can do it in different ways that's all i have to do with this, friends, i pass the word to anzhelika sezonnenko, who will tell you about the news, the latest news , anzhelika, thank you for the word, colleague, for a moment, the news of the 73rd day of the russian-ukrainian war is on the air, news on espresso is working in the studio, anzhelika season eye another loss among colleagues at the front died magazine