religion we never understood and yesterday we tried to understand and today we tried to understand and still couldn't and what was it in probably fiosfaltu that it was theophany what's the matter because i still didn't manage did they become independent or did they just mother cyril the patriarch of russia or what was there? this is now another independent autocephalous church of moscow. article 12 of the law on freedom of conscience of religious organizations tells us that all religious organizations that have their spiritual center in the country of the aggressor are obliged to bring their charters and names of their religious organizations in accordance with the current legislation, which means to indicate there the country of origin or the world, the name of its spiritual center, the spiritual center is called russia, the slava

church of the moscow patriarchate, so this is the rpc in ukraine, and the rpc in ukraine yesterday held a theophany in the monastery, let's say on the outskirts in kyiv, in the women's monastery, they held a meeting , they themselves called it a meeting of representatives of the diocese, usually, according to the statute, the governing body, or the bishop's cathedral, the bishop's council, all the bishops of the church gather at the local council, the bishops gather, one representative from the clergy, that is, one priest a representative from the e-e monks and one this representative of the podmorians from each diocese and they have the right to the local council to change the statute and to elect a superior, what took place yesterday in the feophany was officially called just a meeting e as usual sly servants of moscow again, slyly, you know. well, he is trying to create a fog to please the ukrainians.

why? because the local council, er, its decisions have legal force, in particular, the introduction of changes to the statute, other legal consequences of the legal consequences of the meeting, eh, there are none we can with you in three with a magical angelica is going to decide something for herself but will it have legal force well, it is doubtful that it will have and that is why the moscow patriarchate once again took advantage of this good tradition, the eye of affection, that is, they made some decisions journalists stretched these decisions, they made them into the headlines, but unfortunately or fortunately for the moscow patriarchate, these decisions have no legal consequences, and if we read and by the way, there are very interesting spicy facts that i managed to find out , well, first of all, it is interesting that this happened everything is in the women's and panteleimon monastery in the feophany in the women's monastery because the head of the moscow patriarchate in ukraine lives there, this is the first violation of the canons, which should be widely discussed

and reported to ukrainians moscow the patriarchate constantly tells us that they are canonical, but when the presbyter violates the canons, the presbyter he is a man, he has no right to live in a nunnery, he lives in a nunnery, that is why they decided to hold this council there. well, look for the second time, probably in the history of the moscow patriarchate, they are their own. these are the meetings are held in some regular secondary monasteries, not in their main cathedrals, not even in the kiev-pechersk lavra, in which it would be appropriate to hold gatherings of a similar level, and they hold schismatic kharkiv cathedral of the 92nd year, at which the moscow patriarchate in ukraine was formed, and it was formed in 1992 in the month of may, 30 years ago, the moscow patriarchate was formed in ukraine, at which volodymyr sabodan, by the way, then a citizen of the russian federation, and well, only ukrainians , was elected as the head by origin, the head of the ukrainian church at that time did not take into account the opinion and did not invite

the then head of the church in ukraine, metropolitan filaret, to this council was also not canonical, then you all your evaluations canonical coincidences are always held in such non-statutory secondary monasteries for some reason, that time in the pokrovsky monastery in kharkiv 30 years ago, this time in pokrovsky panteleimonivskyi, and the outskirts of kyiv were also guarded by a huge number of employees of the security service of ukraine, the police close to this monastery it was usually not possible to get close to the park, where a lot of kyiv residents rest, it was surrounded by security forces. it was impossible to go there. all the priests were searched so that, god forbid, something was not recorded there that religious experts or journalists could later discuss, er, these are the decisions that were then published, and brought to the

cathedral, er, metropolitan antony pokanych, pokanych is called a watcher from patriarch kirill and from the kremlin in ukraine, that is, in fact, we can conclude that, based on this coincidence, the moscow patriarchate's squirrels adopted what moscow allowed them to adopt, and it is clear that all these things were agreed with their superiors in moscow i would not rush to say that we have something in moscow, and if allowed separately, i will dwell on this. well, the most interesting thing is that actually the main coordinator of this meeting was the anti-deacon of the russian orthodox church, the chief, as they say, the cashier of the moscow patriarchate in ukraine , the oligarchs, vadim novynsky, which mahasyan, we can see him now on video because, you know, there is a church protocol that all the hierarchs are clearly according to their titles, the most honorable, and those closest to the prize of the land, first sit, well, in

in this case, the metropolitans sat closest to the president, and behind them the archbishops, the bishops, then the monks, and then the laity, i.e. simple and secular people, the participants of this meeting, that is. of these metropolitans well, as the photos and videos from this cathedral show us , practically the entire cathedral mr. novinsky overslept because, you know, there has already been such a meme on the internet, you can sleep when you know the script in advance and you know how it will all end. and they say that such a coordinator of this council was vadim novinskyi. well, and regarding the decisions of the council about any church independence, this meeting did not declare any, because in the language of the church, it is called autocephaly from the greek word autocephalic, i.e.

one's own head or one's own administration is possible only with the granting of a tomos, it is clear that autocephaly is granted by the ecumenical patriarch bartholomew e-e well, in any case, any ecumenical patriarch pronounces the very meeting of the holy court of the ecumenical patriarchate, why is this happening with regard to ukraine, because ukraine received baptism from the ecumenical patriarchate from constantinople, therefore, in principle, the fate depends on constantinople, there cannot be two local orthodox churches in one state, there is such a concept as those that is, the list of local orthodox churches is now in the diptych of orthodox churches. there are 15 orthodox churches, and in fact, in all countries, they are in one way or another tied to some naro-carp, tied to some people does it belong to any country? the patriarchate of jerusalem. the patriarchate of

alexandria . recognizes local law, let's say ecumenical orthodoxy, and it's very strange that another church appears here . this church, which yesterday allegedly proclaimed an auto and its ecumenical orthodoxy, is not admits, that is, it is not canonical, such a church can become independent only in one way, losing weight from the orthodox church of ukraine, so far it is not a canonical grouping, which, by the way, from the point of view of religious studies, we can even interpret it as a legal, legal religious organization, because orthodox dogmatics says clearly that salvation is possible only through jesus christ, this religious organization, which is based in particular on such an anti-orthodox teaching of russian

imperialism, which is called gruz kemer, and they claim that salvation is possible only through unity with moscow, that is, in their dogmatics, believe it or not, christ has been replaced by moscow. this is just the latest heresy of such heresies in the history of universal orthodoxy. well, there were hundreds of them, even she was already given a diagnosis, it is called ethnocelitism and this ethnophilicism is condemned by universal orthodoxy, and unfortunately there is really such a religious group , e.e., near orthodox, which suffers from such and such a heresy, which is called napilitism, the moscow patriarchate in ukraine, unfortunately after what is left and such a clarifying question, nothing has changed in this church, and the worst thing is in all these articles, all these conclusions of the council . this meeting was, you say , the eye of the eye, but who are the believers of that particular church

, because it seems to me that if bombs are flying at them, they have seen the occupation of ukrainian cities by russian troops, torture, rape, the killing of civilians and still continue to say that moscow the patriarchy is not involved in this. so who will prove anything to them, no, this is the biggest uh, this whole gathering. it was such a theatrical production, focused on uh, first of all, on the internal, on the internal consumer, on the followers of the moscow patriarchate, who are now hesitating whether it is possible for their communities to transfer and joined the orthodox church of ukraine because in fact we see that the moscow patriarchate in ukraine is bursting at the seams, we will see that already about 400-450 communities in ukraine have joined since the beginning of the full-scale of the russian aggression on february 24, 2022 joined the orthodox church of ukraine and here it is real that the hierarchs of the moscow patriarchate felt the danger for their religious

organization. they see that many communities are ready to transition and they are simply, first of all, interested in removing from their charter all references to religious organizations associated with russia and the moscow patriarchate and actually withdraw under the influence of this law on freedom of conscience , article 12, which limits the reality of such religious organizations in ukraine with a spiritual center in the country of the aggressor, nothing more than that thank you for the last time you know such priests from the kiev-pechersk lavra of worship and there they continue to commemorate patriarch kirill, nothing has changed, this is the most important thing, mr. andriy, it was very good for you and save yourselves heroes, glory andriy kovalev, political scientist, religion expert, press an officer of the 112th ground defense brigade of the ukrainian armed forces, kyiv, or contact us in the direction of communication. well, the time has come for an interactive with mykola in september, mr. mykola, let's take a little from yesterday, because why write down a lot

the government constantly announces a new date for the end of the war, it causes nothing but irritation and fatigue, why all this speculation if klimova explained to me that in her understanding of the word power, we have many people in power, we have a president, we have a prime minister and a minister of defense, it is already relevant now man, we have different speakers, different combinations of changes. therefore, it is necessary to somehow understand what power is, and also one of them has his own point of view, and each of them, for example, on the contrary, i think that they all say approximately the same thing, firstly, secondly well, i wouldn't believe it none of them because no one knows when the war will end. you will ask people in the 44th year when the two wars will end, friends, no one will tell you, or you will ask in the 17th year when the first world war will end, and so on and so forth there is no word power in russia in ukraine, by the

way, everything is very simple there, putin is the only power that exists in ukraine, there is no such analogue of putin, that is why people think, they appear on television they are not you, i would urge them not to trust anyone, put them under suspicion all their words but very many of them prevail moreover, some circumstances may change in the summer, namely due to the supply of western weapons and possibly some wars, it is also possible due to the heroism of ukrainian soldiers who exhaust the russian army and maybe by the end of the summer something will begin to change , i have not heard anywhere that someone said that it will end on october 27 or december 13 i have not heard of such a war, but these are approximate options. well, yes, they exist as

world leaders. and you don’t like my voice. wanted what uh, well, all of them take turns to be the most manipulative and populist today, you know , i wouldn’t say that there is so much manipulation and populism, why? because i was just tense for the first two months when i saw that somehow the government and many journalists were very optimistic looked, we are there, we are staying there, we are coming to the counteroffensive, such things, on the one hand, here there is no good answer , i will not take any objective step, even close to objective, because there are options, that something must be hidden, and this is the customs of war, the government during the war there is always something hidden, no government

will tell us what was destroyed there, they will always tell us that we destroyed someone there because of that, and on the other hand, people need to be informed somehow and even the negative consequences of the war cannot be talked about in our country, that is great, then we will be then why are we fighting , then we are like the russians, let’s surrender right away, because in russia no one knows about their defeat, they don’t feel it anymore, if we are the same as russia, let’s surrender and we will live together, that’s why, but here between the drops here, pass on one side, give more- less objective, i repeat a more or less objective picture , on the other hand, you can hide what is necessary , and on the third hand, prevent the enemy from finding out where the troops are, how they are going, where they are coming from, what weapons, where, where there are shortages, and so on, this is the third option which one should also be taken into account, so there is no good answer, but recently

, when the so-called government started talking about our difficulties, i told myself that it is much better than when they talk only about victories, and that is why it is important, but i feel that i i am simply obliged to say the following: why is the government what sent the authorities, this is a very cunning approach, we are not to blame, such people are sitting around their houses and say this is the government, that’s all. and by the way, this is very appropriate, putin loves it very much, when inside the country, i you and i talked about this, and i don’t know how many weeks ago, but we were paying attention to the south of ukraine. i just mentioned this. there are people who say that they abandoned us and forgot about us. it’s not putin who came to you. it was zelensky who came with bombs

and missiles. and came bombed and then left and after hiding medicines from pharmacies, this is the most joy in the kremlin when this kind of thing starts. this is not us, this is the real thing. by the way, this is a gift to the kremlin, and i will give one more example , although mykola and i have already talked about it a lot, and today i saw the letter in social networks as it spreads very actively, the article is written well , some blogger is very famous there, but she has already gained a lot of likes and shares, respectively, and e. there the title is like this, it is necessary to correct the mistake of donbas, we must admit that he is ukrainian and finally help the people of donbas and they say that ukraine has forgotten about donbas for 8 years, we have not taken up this narrative of the kremlin again, and we are repeating it, and the supposed goal of the article is good, to help the people there, some money is being collected, and so on,

humanitarian aid, but you cannot use such manipulation to draw attention to the general public, on the other hand, you have to already for the people who read all this and spread it to grow up and have their own heads and understand that even if we collect 100 million dollars and send it all to donbas as aid, the leaders of the recognized republics will put it in their pockets my god, thank you, ukrainians. well done. what you gave me to earn 100 million dollars in the war is great, but this money will not reach the ordinary people who live there, do you have this in mind? that is why all these conversations are cunning, and in russia, it is not for nothing that these pr people earn a lot of money. this is thrown up, moreover, there are people who will do it knowingly, but i think that what they write here is unconsciously, just a combination of words, our government, and then anything else you

can say, our government is not right here, it is not right here, it is not right, and we have already forgotten that putin attacked on ukraine russia attacked ukraine we are we are not the aggressors yes we are the victim and the criminal are changing again, this is how i always like it, well, i don't like it, and in quotes. in our country, it is very often fashionable to switch the places of the victim of the criminal and say that it was not russia that attacked it. someone here we have an internal enemy, let's go further, i'm silent, i'm going to leave, your point of view regarding the horde, their return, considering the fact that they are under occupation for a long time, they are fighting with ukraine, not against the murders of ukrainians, and they do not have their own self-determination, who are they? well, here is the last phrase. have their own self-determination, this is a very correct phrase and there is nothing you can do here, there is bad news for them really often. i do not say in all 100%, but there is a fairly large percentage of people who are not

defined. and this is bad news, it is very difficult to determine, especially during war especially under the influence of russian propaganda. but the good news is the following. i have always said this. my observations, let's say not objectively, but subjectively, show that in crimea and donbas there is a lot, a large specific weight, not 100%, definitely maybe not even 50. and there are 40 people who obey the government, what kind of government was this, and when they tell me, oh , they need to be reeducated. but i have the impression that as soon as the ukrainian government comes in, there will be no ukrainian government for 8 years, or 28 years there will be the ukrainian people they immediately immediately line up everything neatly, we we understood that our authorities are new, it is not three-colored, it is two-colored , yellow-blue, everything, i have this impression because, you know, when i had many relationships, it was

sevastopol, and e is translated from greek as a city worthy worship and i constantly mocked them because all the people who wanted to conquer sevastopol during the entire history of sevastopol or even from the kherson period and they all managed to conquer sevastopol, there was never such a thing as what i want to conquer and i did not succeed in the 20th century of the 19th 18 it's always been the same, that's why for me, they're all theirs, we're so cool, well , it never worked, but i have the impression that they obey who came, well, and well, they came from the 91st year, the 91st year 57 percent of sevastopol 54 will not be we will lie for ukraine, we will be against later we again for later we vote for pro-russian parties then we

meet the russian troops with bread and salt in short that's all that's all i think it's like that and they will easily accept other people yes and and and and that's all and there will be nothing wrong next question and then something i i see that in fact putin does not have the full amount of information about the state of military affairs in ukraine. putin is such a mental illness. everything is putin. putin is a putin. i think that when i find it, by the way, i, for example, do not rule out that in time this feature will be named after putin. there is such a thing. a disease when you twist everything that happens to your advantage, that's any story that happens yeah, it's not ukraine fighting yeah, it's america fighting yeah

and you eventually start to believe and they're all sitting now and they really have at the beginning you know long ago to prove as the following was given in school, but they prove through their heads where there are 20 or 15. are there five parameters that are not ugly, good, they are bad, we are not provocateurs, they are provocateurs, but the khokhlys are not the nation , but the rabble of ukraine, not ukraine, does not exist, this does not exist. donation and he will be told there they suffered flag conditionally yes, they were defeated there, they were defeated there, they were defeated there, they were defeated there, like hitler at the end of the war, and here comes some piper and says, here in the village of pupkina, the collective farm named after the 22nd division of the cpsu , three russians went on a counterattack, yes, we are

attacking, hello, everything everything is fine, we already won the war, you understand, and this is such a disease, by the way, i would n’t throw a stone at a person, this is such a disease for a person . when it is massive, then this disease somehow this pandemic is already a pandemic and it must be studied and the world will study it and i am convinced of me my daughter is studying now in europe and i always told her study russian history you will have an exact job because if how how and when the war is over, the whole world will start investigating these phenomena, how is it for mothers? i just listen to russians a lot and recently there was an interview from the interview it emerged that in principle 5 million uah rubles and a mother can renounce her son and you are just

imagining that this is not nature nature maternal and other there is no price, the mother will not give up the child, but here it turns out that there are people who mass it is not one case, not two or three , where mass mothers say well, how will they give 5 million? go to the attack and here they say, son of events, the stairs are fighting , people are killing there, and women and children, well, they are making excuses, the first people will be fine, that ’s fine. it’s just that in these everyday phenomena that come to us and we are surprised here, but believe me, a million candidate theses will be written doctoral dissertations will be created institutes institutes there i don't know russian psychiatry institutes of russian political science i apologize and so

on and so on i'm absolutely cool that it will be sooner or later because really there are many things that i'm not i many smart people much smarter than me day ca n't understand different specialists of various specialties yes historians psychologists political scientists psychiatrists are sitting what is this what is putin will be studied maybe posthumously we don't know but it would be better during his life ah because it gives more opportunities to reveal in this way i don't know him as a person, whether he is mentally ill or with some kind of disability, but he is a really interesting figure , such a figure in a negative sense, but well, we have something to say here. they are still interesting figures and there is no such thing as hitler. it is for studying why why there are few good books about hitler simply has hundreds of volumes written by everyone. it is interesting to study this phenomenon. by the

way, our next question for the viewer concerns dictators. what is your attitude, dear gentlemen, to the idea that historical practice shows us that every dictator raises his hands only when already because they are falling on his head and the ceiling is also falling on his head napoleon hitler milosevic putin well no i am the kind who die their own death and the same mao zedong is calm to himself in the 76th year i think i am not wrong i may be wrong sorry he died in his bed and that's all he was fine and that's why there is a dekator who doesn't actually die of his own death without which, without any bombs. well, there are definitely hitlers and stalin. by the way, he died absolutely beautifully . with environment and ukrainians begin to dream that maybe someone like beria will be found near putin and can throw something there. so we talked with you. what exactly is the

murder and maybe putin said the same no no it won't happen putin putin loves himself very much putin is such a unique person and all around there are no people , it’s already around him, it’s some kind of monster, he doesn’t want them for people, a man in putin’s understanding, he is no one anymore. look how they waste people on the fronts. look how they poisoned people in europe. 30 thousand they are ready to serve. i don’t i believe that ours here can't be 30, but maybe 22 5 yes, yes, but plus taking sanitary losses means for three 20 minutes. well, there are already somewhere under 100,000, i'm not convinced that they won't stop even if it's 150 , so for him the value of e- only one thing is his personal value, everything else is not valuable to him. i don't believe that he will ever be able to, you know, for the first two months or even three months. well, he doesn't

understand where his conscience is, such people are computer scientists of concepts , he doesn't think about anything. he gives the order to shoot , and he is like others on another planet. he is what he is he sees that yes he flew to kyiv flew there flew here flew here died there he can already easily provide himself with photos of the destroyed yes he can easily afford all this i think he avoids it he does not order show me what happened there or there or there he doesn't look at it there, but it's such a phenomenon, and there are still questions , we have two minutes left, we have what can be done to stop unclear bills and actions of the authorities, the law on fences. the criminals that we mentioned today , the arrest of poroshenko, the medvedchuk affair, criticism of nato,

people's imaginations wander, and i have the impression that they want to disrupt our country's aspirations to join the eu or cooperate with nato, such ridiculous actions when we are under the crosshairs of the world community, what we, citizens who pay taxes and live in ukraine, can do anything to prevent this from happening, you cannot elect those people who will not make such mistakes as the ones you are talking about, as long as we have democracy, you will not go anywhere, yes, they elected such people people, they say that, by the way, not everything is bad, even though we are like that, the barrier of the tribe is undeniable. well , it all looks absurd. well, i will not qualify any of the deputies, although i have qualifications, but i said something, my silence is eloquent, because well, there there really are such people among the deputies who are also worth studying , not only putin is worth studying, there are in ukraine