and the war will not end, and the fact that you mentioned this law was not adopted in the second reading, the reason for its not being adopted is purely organizational or just my suspicion that there is simply no money, you know, just as in our country they are lovingly waiting for the payment of 2,000 vpu there and they do not come and they don't come, but obviously there are much larger sums for restoration. and maybe there is simply no money, that's why the authorities are simply not afraid to admit that there is no money. therefore, while the approval is being delayed, here in the second reading of this law, look at the money , we definitely do not have a huge budget deficit, that's all what is our economy doing and everything that we borrow abroad and where exclusively for our army and for our security and defense, i.e. to finance capital expenditures or any losses at the moment there is no money in the budget it is possible the authorities do not want to say it directly but as far as i am the opposition, i can say that, unfortunately, they are not there , so hope, yes, look, but the law consists of two parts, one part is the method

of assessing losses and their registration, and the second is direct payments, you understand the method and the assessment must now be made with an assessment of damages, otherwise we will simply be left without information and then without primary documents that can be presented in court and take this compensation from russia. us in every city, district, its whole departments, departments, as they were called differently there, but the procurement of people who worked on the infrastructure and are working now at their level. is it a district? is it a city or a region ? carry out all these defective acts of inspection and record, and then wait for financing, what is the problem, you can look at it, it is necessary to do it,

but it is necessary to have, as i have already drawn up the legislative field of the legislative field for this kind of damage. at the moment, there is no large volume therefore, they can do of their own good will, but what to do next with these assessments, besides, i want to tell you if you look at the court decisions, uh, regarding compensation for damaged property in 2014 in donbas, and what lawsuits were filed applications and natural persons, all the others none was actually satisfied and won because all the courts demanded an independent assessment not from the local authorities . we will go to court with these losses, russia will say yes, they drew the losses, that’s their government, they drew them for themselves, someone should independently make an assessment of these losses, well, it’s not someone, it’s people with

a specific license who can give girls in of course, it exists in ukraine, but you understand that we cannot put these additional funds on the citizens, it must be some kind of state i don’t know the policy, which is determined by law, how to make an assessment of damages so that they can then be proven in court and the funds taken from russia, you understand we do damages, not just an assessment of damages, it's for the sake of just remembering it, we want to receive compensation from russia for this. and for this, we need the right legal mechanism, that is, but the government could regulate it for example, while we are waiting no, this is just what he actually ordered, there is a resolution on damages, but it is, again, at the level of an internal document , it is possible and suitable. - in any

case, something needs to be done. well, that is, to move somewhere at least from one standard and explain to the local authority how to act now. the people who are returning to their destroyed positions do not have much time left at all. it's true yuliya klymenko, she is a people's deputy for the first time, the deputy head of the committee on transport and infrastructure. thank you for your participation. at this point, ukraine has completely gotten rid of the threat of air alarms . you see, a fly has also flown to us in connection with this, so you can already leave the storage. therefore, for now, from the storage we continue our broadcast in order not to interrupt it and now we started talking about money, the latest information is disappointing for ukrainians the world bank worsened the inflation forecast in ukraine to 20% by the end of this year april preliminary forecast predicted 15%. inflation this was reported by the regional director of the world bank in the countries of eastern europe, arup - beneji, his name is

inflationary pressure, quote, so at this stage it is expected that inflation will continue to grow and may reach 20% in december against 15% in our april forecasts, he said according to his growth inflationary pressure, in particular, is caused by the need to cover budgetary needs in march and may at the expense of the monetization of the national bank. dmytro zolotukhin, the founder of the institute of the post-information society uh, we continue, let's uh, i'm reading some information, yeah, we need to see what they write to us in our messengers. the state duma of russia was proposed to cancel the independence of lithuania. this is the sensational information that the deputy of the russian state duma, yevhen fedorov, proposed to cancel the resolution of the times of the union regarding the recognition the independence of lithuania was informed by ria novosti that deputy fedorov submitted to the state duma a draft on the cancellation of the resolution of the state council of the union of jurisprudence on the independence of

the republic of lithuania on the process of lithuania's exit from the ussr was painful, was accompanied by victims among the civilian population, we are already adding this from ourselves, since the soviet troops tried to suppress the mass movement to independence, among other things, at that time, certain views in which alexander was granted or not granted citizenship covered these events, well, obviously, defending the position in these visas, which russians fought against the soviet russians, the independence of lithuania, the publication of russian troops for demilitarization, and where on these classifications, well, this is grotesque, god forbid of course well there are many media faces of their own, which are now called the only news. also, how many six months ago, or how many medvedchuk channels there were not so long ago, they were calmly telling themselves that we don't need nato, you can't spread it

on bread, they interviewed all these of pro-russian people who in fact were brought here russian peace and now, well, if there is no political and professional responsibility, in particular , we want to talk about this, because the approaches are slightly different. well, in principle, all of this is multiplied by zero . she is doing titanic things now, this is the armed forces of ukraine - this is every resident and citizen of ukraine in defense of european values, why do it if we tolerate these same values ​​or tolerate the absence of these values ​​just now at this very moment lyudmila opryshka should be with us already we now let's see if we'll hear her so-and-so so-and-so it 's grotesque but we work with bunkers ludmila you have a media lawyer public organization human rights platform we hear you congratulations and how do you feel about this, well, a scandal in fact arose in connection with the granting of ukrainian citizenship by oleksandra nevzorova, at first they informed

me that he received a passport, then the secretary of the national security and defense council oleksiy danilov said that they did not provide a passport , then the most nezorova was asked by our colleagues and how did you get the passport of anizor, they said well, it is closed the information was given to me by the president himself, and i will not tell you about it; it is a secret decree. well, almost verbatim. to which later , on it, the ukrainian segment of facebook expressed complaints to him, saying that how well it's not russia, it's all secret with us, well , the president has to explain his steps, why you were given this passport, and if there is, for example, a swindler or some other swindler wants to get this passport , will he be given the same passport, or should he contact you or whom ? communicate. how do you evaluate this scandal from the point of view of legal, so to speak, and social significance? i would like to say very briefly here. i am in favor of greater openness and those issues that concern

society and are called such discussions. unfortunately , i have to give some kind of legal assessment on this issue. i can't anymore because first of all neither you no i haven't seen any documents on this matter and then as a specialist in the field of media law i would still give preference to those issues in which i am an expert but tell me about these issues do you think the president should explain his actions, that granting ukrainian citizenship to one or another person, especially if he already had the citizenship of ukraine-the aggressor? of course, this issue is very painful, and since it caused such a wave of discussions, i believe that there should be maximum openness here mrs. lyudmila, today there was an event dedicated to military censorship and this is your profile. yes, today we already talked about uh, well, about many controversial issues. according to media media, everything is now facebook, it is also media. yes, everyone has it. now you don’t

have to learn to work as a journalist. journalist in order to be a member of the media field, so the people's deputy posted a hospital in bashantsi, the 130th district. i understand that mykolaiv region posted it on facebook in facebook. it seems like some kind of social network information about hospitals bashantsi mykolayivska the region where the military aid came, the hospital from the netherlands, he put the name of this hospital there, what does it include, how many beds, well, that's all, it's placed, the most important thing is that after a couple of days, bashtanka was hit with artillery or rockets, it doesn't matter, and it was included partially destroyed, this multi-purpose hospital in which this hospital was located was obtained from the dutch and now, well , the deputy has already changed his post several times, rewritten it, but the fact remains that we have power over some journalists, well, in vain, well, how the russians say and accuse, and you

can’t show a photo of the bridge in severodonetsk, which is just under the open sky, its satellite can be photographed, and the people’s deputy can hang photos of the hospitals received from the dutch, indicate where exactly it is, please, you can lay missiles, that’s right, eh this is a media tip . look. well, first of all, we cannot say that all those who write on facebook are journalists, after all, journalists are professionals who work according to standards and confuse contributors with users. facebook and journalists are not needed, on the other hand, there is a basic principle, the main principle is that whoever exercises the right to freedom of speech, elections, assumes duties and responsibilities, and this applies not only to journalists, but also to people's deputies, including when a people's deputy decided to make certain information public he had to take

into account all the risks associated with it, and it is clear that during the war freedom of speech should be limited as much as it is really necessary in the conditions of martial law, how much ms. lyudmila, now you can say this question specifically, three opposition channels were turned off, this is censorship because we have a war, this is a violation, it is possible to correct it during the release. let me tell you about this. well, first of all, when it comes to restrictions on freedom of speech we know whether there are norms of the constitution that allow this, and whether there are norms-conventions of the european convention on the protection of human rights that allow us to deviate from these obligations, and ukraine itself has deviated from its obligations to comply with ten of those that guarantee the right on freedom of speech, but the same european convention does not allow arbitrarily retreat, it

says that the retreat should be only within those limits required by the urgency of the situation, that is, under any conditions, the government cannot act arbitrarily , even our law. i emphasize the legal regime of martial law on the fact that the government must still act on grounds within its limits guaranteed by the constitution, that is where we come from. therefore , in order to turn off the channels, there must be correct grounds and there must be a decision relevant decision as far as i understood from the information that is in the information field that is printed in the mass media, there was no such decision to turn off three tv channels, including espresso, and it was simply such an act of a city-state

enterprise that simply turned off channels from of the digital ether, in fact, i made such conclusions after reading the answer of the state special communications media detector. so, based on this, i believe that such actions of the authorities, even in the conditions of martial law, they are such an act that has signs of this view. the story of butusov, in which some deputies try to forbid them from visiting the front lines while they themselves are there. the same deputies are there in military uniform. well, according to the version there, some journalists are being monitored. well, bystanders , they advocate for certain soldiers under the leadership of certain military units so that there is nothing there. no, they made some incomprehensible decisions there for the top management. how do you feel about the

story from butu? i did not fully understand it from a legal point of view, because if yuriy butusov received accreditation, he has the right to be in the areas where military operations are being conducted, to remove him from er, the possibility of staying at military facilities can be left by the leadership of the armed forces, so these are some of the demands of the deputies not to allow him, they do not matter from a legal point of view, if this suspension means that there should be some written document where the grounds for such suspension should be stated well, it's crazy what yes yes no nowhere what are the grounds in connection with which of course there were certain discussions related to yes his post about the road of life about the city that connected

donetsk yesterday, but on the other hand, as a lawyer, it is important for me to have a document that forbids him from visiting these areas, then he will be suspended again, and he will remain in the desert again, and maryana bezugla is a deputy from the servants of the people. not only did she ask not to urge him not to be admitted, she even said that he should be dealt with. she said that if the sbu does not do anything about yuri butusov, who is constantly doing something there with impunity, destabilizing, undermining, then there is no point in any gradual reform of the sbu such a call is just to figure it out there, plant it, destroy it there by the nails, well, it’s not even not just a ban on visiting the front line there, let’s figure out no legal consequences, it

’s uh, on the basis of her statement, criminal proceedings have been opened. so if they opened it, it was against botusov or against bezugly or in fact no, we are talking now about butusov, do you remember she makes such political statements? well, she makes many statements , they are forgiveness. well, is it even possible for a people's deputy, a parliamentarian, who writes the project himself? the law seems to be there. about reforms in the sbu, contact the sbu . otherwise, without it, any reform of the sbu makes no sense, or there is still a queue , you can figure it out here as well about this let's talk we know that maryana is cornerless, she is just

advancing with the reform of the sbu and obviously she uses this fact for his political statements, i rather evaluate it that way, and mrs. lyudmila, let's go once again. let's analyze the essence of this wording , er, military censorship, so that predus is meant, that is, if we have a war, then it is not possible and that it should be the rules are the same for everyone, they are there somewhere, they are written somewhere, there are some rules for the minister and for the journalist, well, look, there is order 73 for journalists - this is the order of the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of ukraine from march 3, which stipulates what information should not be distributed. and actually here it is foreseen that it really writes about the time of distribution, there was a certain background here, because indeed after the commander in chief issued this

order number 73, many journalists faced difficulties in fulfilling their professional duties, and actually due to the fact that journalists expressed their public protest against the fact they cannot work in the ministry of culture and information policy. the ministry of defense, together with the media, concluded a joint joint statement, they appear, and in it they predicted after what time can information about the content be published arrivals, you talked about it. yes, i understood the process, that is, this order of the 73rd commander-in -chief only provides for a list of information that is forbidden to be distributed. but at the same time, journalists must cover the events

that take place during the war, moreover, even when ukraine appeals to the international community and asks for help, then it must convey this information to the whole world to show what is happening in ukraine, that is, the work of journalists is extremely important and it is important to timely cover all the events are related to the war for the citizens of ukraine and for foreign partners for this world, and that is why the question arose about how to work for journalists when, say, there is destruction of civilian objects in the depth of the territory of ukraine, not only on the line of contact, they can film it and the public association human rights platform itself. thank you for your participation and the draft law. yes, with dmytro zolotu, we can already

invite dmytro zolotukhin, founder of the institute of post-information society, teacher. of the kyiv-mohyla school of government, former deputy minister of informatics, 17-19 years old dmytro congratulations, i congratulate you, i hear you like this, it seems normal, we hear about the censorship of this military, what is your opinion? to what extent are these restrictions that are there, they are mandatory for everyone in terms of their implementation? that we have given examples of publishing information to e-e journalists. it is not possible for deputies , or vice versa, they cannot say about deputies, they do not obey any laws in our country very often, and about journalists, i wrote for the publication the media detector is a large material regarding the recommendations for how it is better to cover events for journalists, uh, from the point of view of the law, i can

point out that it is prohibited by the constitution, but the state of martial law has the right to limit the rights and freedoms of citizens in the matter of censorship, it is absolutely justified in the period the problem of martial law is that we do not have a military sum in ukraine, because military censorship is a democratic procedure, no matter how it sounds, but during the period of martial law there must be a document that approved by responsible officials , including, i think, the cabinet of ministers, and it is possible to adopt a relevant law of the parliament that says what can be said, what can be said, which says who is the responsible censor, and how journalists in that period of martial law can contact the responsible persons: the ministry of defense or the security service of ukraine show them the materials so that , accordingly, these persons say whether they can be

aired or not. this procedure is absolutely justified, but we do not have it, therefore, accordingly, we cannot you want to talk about censorship in ukraine in general, because it doesn’t exist and there’s nothing to talk about. and why isn’t it? well, because we have, in principle, all the heads of military administrations now, they have also become so media -active. just create three channels, eh, there are opposition parties who could afford not to consult with the president's office, eh, and in this way, the hives no longer know why such a procedure has not been introduced, this is a question rather for the people's deputies and the office of the president of ukraine to the supreme commander-in-chief, i would absolutely support the decision that said that here we turn these off, here we turn them on for you, but the question is that there should

be a procedure that will be later either appealed or , er, so that the person who accepted such a procedure was later responsible for it is her political responsibility, when the war ends, when ukrainians are fighting for people, for territory, for a path, for the future, for identity, for their values, for democracy, it has become an unacceptable thing to turn off 3 television channels that have always been oppositional and have always shown the ukrainian view of the world, this is a video appeal in support of the espresso tv channel, which i love and respect. thank you for your good work, for the fact that you always truthfully cover events and always kept the ukrainian position correct, in my opinion, to turn off patriotic television channels during the war, well, that in fact, very last thing. for this they did it. this is another question, but this is another evidence

that our armed forces do their job well and give a sense of security. security and reliability, and because of that, some people in the offices of power begin to feel so carefree that they have time for intrigues, and i am already asking you not to do nonsense and return the digital broadcasting system, espresso direct and fifth tv channels - turn on these channels, we them we want to see turn back the full information field, the fifth of stress to the body and direct, because on this fland it is written every combat unit that will approach the victory of ukraine as soon as possible, let's not take any actions during the war were destructive within us. i want

to express my support for the espresso channel and er insists that this channel be returned to the usual information space. espresso unites ukraine, we need their point of view. i call to return a from the press to the air and return all disconnected channels to broadcast because these channels work for ukraine. glory to ukraine, the president and zelenskyi, return expresso to the air. let's protect the information front together. glory to ukraine. good evening. we are from ukraine. vasyl zima's big broadcast. my name is taras. winter two hours of air time and my colleagues and you until 21:00 two hours of your time we will talk about the most important two hours to find out about the war it turns out our air serhiy is burning military summaries of the day and what the world lives what in the world yuri the physicist will tell for two hours to be these economic news edited by oleksandr

marchenko he tells us about the economy during the war and new sports yevhen pastukhov is ready to talk about sports for 2 hours in the company of favorite presenters about culture during the war is ready to talk lina or otherwise, the presenters that many have become like, maybe the weather will give us some optimism, mrs. natalka didenko is ready to tell us, and we will also have a distinguished guest of the studio today, volodymyr grishko, if all goes well , the events of the day in two hours, vasyl's big broadcast in the winter , a project for smart people and to those who don't care in the evening naispresso good evening we are from ukraine good evening we are from ukraine it is very important in this difficult time to be aware of what is happening, we

tell the news and help to understand the events, but the war can make its adjustments in if the broadcast signal is lost, watch espresso on the satellite now espresso has become available on two satellites at once if you have a question about freedom life my name is vlas and lamana on the pages of radio svoboda on facebook and youtube, as well as in efi