and the argument is impossible not to comply with orders and keep the position. and perhaps there is another argument in life, it has not yet appeared publicly . you and every russian, today we are weighing complete russians and even some others say that it was not a guarantee, as he says in words, everyone then understood that ukraine would instead be an independent country within the borders established during the soviet union russia has definitely violated this treaty, and many times ukraine did not have operational control over

that arsenal. it also did not have the ability to keep it in a safe state. but since russia violated this budapest memorandum, i believe that as a measure we had the right to present nuclear warheads to ukraine so that it could protect its independence, that is, a very important moment. well, this is a very important moment to take advantage of the budapest memorandum in a proper way, this means in our favor, and maybe there is still some chance since we understand what the kremlin is threatening, it is possible not only to attack ukraine with tactical nuclear weapons, but it is possible to talk about the so-called dirty bomb of strengthening, since the strengthening

of the old friendship between putin and the kremlin and the environment in the middle east is possibly about representatives from various arab structures, a dirty bomb would be nothing did not give to putin, that is, innocent people would have died, but putin would not have achieved either a political goal, or a military goal, or any other, but obviously we must introduce him to uncertainty about our intentions so that he takes take this into account in your calculations. what is the chance of change , that is, it is about the rebellion of the russian elites, i understand that in 1944 something similar happened in germany not only because colonel von stautenberg was such a good person, but he understood where he had led his country, it is about

germany hitler, and precisely because of this, part of the elite in germany began to very actively prepare a certificate how do you assess the readiness of russian youth today for changes in their country yes yes stauffenberg was not a liberal, he was a german nationalist and believed that hitler is harming germany and i think that many russians today think that way about putin, only this is a very centralized system, a personal personal dictatorship, paradoxically, but more centralized than the soviet union. i will remind you once of the death of stalin. he was arrested on the spot

, that is, there was a group of people who could make the decision to remove the leader from power in the same way when khrushchev ridiculed his solution to the cuban crisis the soviet union was talking about placing nuclear missiles on the club, but sent him to retirement , that is, today putin is theoretically the democratically elected president of russia, so he can be removed from power. was also destroyed, and his son tsar oleksandr was the first, but knew, but washed his hands and began to rule. maybe something similar

will be seen by patrushev and more some similar to him and there are some other russian affairs, but there is one more aspect that is important to explain to our friends in western europe who do not always know the history of russia as well as we do, that is, they believe that feeding putin with ukrainian lands is the way to some stabilization and some relaxation and you and i know that in russia, reforms took place only after lost wars, such as after the defeat in the crimean war, which operations in the russo-japanese war, i completely agree with you , even in a certain sense. after the defeat in the first world war, but unfortunately the kremlin seeks the destruction

of ukraine as a sovereign state, where nazification means an attempt to destroy the ukrainian people of ukraine, and we have already seen something similar in the realities of the kyiv region in irpen bucha and so on and so on and the same mother, this is really a terrible reality of the russian plan, and when, for example, we talk about the realities, what scenarios do you see in the next few months? politics is classification, deportation, the introduction of currency, the appointment of traitors in the occupied territories, and it is obvious that mariupol, and

mariupol, but its kherson, but also mariupol, but also kherson, but there is a part of zaporizhzhia, and so on, here russia can no longer pretend that it is not, this is not official to serve as a politician. we all know that putin has been speaking with brutal honesty for a long time. it is enough to read his essay from july of last year or his speech at the beginning of the war or various texts. for example, the text that came out er, in ria novosti, when they already believed that kiev was taken, it is the intention of extermination when it comes to the

statehood and identity of ukraine. wars of liquidation elites destruction of culture destruction of otherness and then there is no management with a russified demographic population devoid of leaders believes that such are their plans but he has already failed the rest i think it is very strange that putin did not no conclusions from the 14th year, because in the fall of that time they already tried to do it with the help of those points. you remember in mykolaiv in the character and odesa they wanted to take control on the same mistake arguing that a russian-speaking ukrainian is a

russian and wants to live under the leadership putin but this is an absurd theory, please try to tell an irishman that he is an englishman and that ireland should be ruled by london again. continue. try to say something similar to an american who also speaks english, because it is absurd after all. i i believe that identification in ukraine today is not only ethnic, linguistic, but also political. i have the impression that today ukrainian is partly a civilizational choice for europe and against the autocrats of the autocrats ivan . why do you think why did putin start another intervention ? on the part of intelligence or was it some kind of mental reaction of his? why did he

start all this? i think that by 2011 he wanted to be on a converging trajectory with the west. this may confuse you, but i will remind you that putin was the first head of russia who visited, for example, katyn when i was in moscow. i visited such a former training ground of the nkvd, where during stalin 's time they trained orthodox priests. they told me that putin would be a frequent guest there. but around the 11th year, putin decided that the west was trying to prevent him from holding the presidency again, and in the 14th year, he decided that the west took ukraine away from him, as it were

ukraine was ours, or was this opportunity taken away from someone during the pandemic, he read some nonsense of duginsky or stalinist tsarist propaganda books, he picked up an absolutely distorted history of russia itself, you know, in a certain sense, he follows the traditional path of russian tsars, many of whom began as modernizers and reformers, and ended as reactionaries because it turned out that reforms in russia are too difficult and this is a defeat modernization but at the same time testing the system and you know how it turns out and this in full sensei, it is reassuring for us that a system based on coercion of lies or thievery

was ineffective. who would have thought the truth, the truth , i must end our conversation and i must thank you for your excellent analysis, we are holding on. glory to ukraine, glory to the heroes, glory to the heroes on the air of the espresso tv channel , sikorskyi, the former minister of defense, was delighted former minister of foreign affairs of the republic of poland and now a member of the european parliament , another round of negotiations took place with the participation of the russian ribbentrop minister of foreign affairs lavrov yes and it is as if the parties have not reached anything, but the most important thing is the fact that russia is forced to look for one or another point of contact in order to get out of its way out of the kremlin-untangled by the russian people

, to get out of their war in ukraine, on the other hand , we understand that russia is now looking for so to speak additional negotiation sites are open not only in istanbul but also in paris, brussels and berlin. but fortunately for us and generally for the good fortune of the entire western civilization, russia has no chance to withdraw its interests in public because the cream and putin have become too toxic about this about the other iconic american political scientist andriy piontkovsky who is in washington glory to ukraine andriy andriyovich those who see you in the studio of the virtual studio of the espresso tv channel and good morning andriy andriyovich we understand that when certain negotiation tracks are going on one track we are all

experiencing right now the so-called istanbul track appears information that mr. abramovich worked extremely hard on another track that you see now the prospects of erdogan's of various propositions, he is interested in trade with putin, he has a lot of rain when god plays this conflict in syria and in libya, in egypt there, and not in africa. -е есть and as for the direct one, i absolutely have a budget so that emochka was 35 years old and remains, uh, putin's man , i also work in conjunction with him, well, it seems to me that uh, the soviet efforts are follow-up, uh

, in the same direction as that in kapitalyanskoe the proposal so calls the italian lord of the world behind whom they stand. while they are offering me something, er, i will trust the respect of the reaction of ukraine in the last days , well, always, then i have already negotiated er, all the speakers of the ukrainian government zelensky hummingbird, the day of his assassins, aristovych, the second representative of the er, presidential administration очень резок полская область 30 bad in which it offers eh or france germany well, here are the formats about the collective zelensky andriy andriyovych and mr. rahamia confirms for the court that abramovich helped to save 400,000 ukrainians write about it z-times so we

understand that we have very different groups of influence in our leadership well, of course, this is not for comments, but simply returning to the topic of abramovich, as for arkhamia, i do not consider the ego abandoned by the ukrainian authorities, and by the way, i remember what anti-american things did he say during the time they preceded , er, putin's version, er, they changed each er, they talked panic that there is no speaker and then let's not forget, er, let's be the source of the fact that er, again, it is european sovereign, what is the so-called they impose on ukraine the capital points not because they are afraid of the path but because they are the fighter of the victory of ukraine the victory of

ukraine and everything is going on in such a change in the international structure of international relations of the security systems, not france, germany will lose the role in which one hypolytic speculates the last there are 30 or 40 years, but the last divorcing role does not dilate, that in relations with the kremlin, eh, this is the so-called childhood of france screen, which is so called the french political lita means that all the time is running out. hmm, the distance of the contemporary states to make a theme-credit of filth, insert the rights to a good film, remember, uh , what role does the french president have in the soviet space, when the heavy captured abkhazia, south ossetia came to sorkazy from the paper money, how come berlin with the paper paper of america and i will make it clear that i am talking about some kind of international

agreement. we were probably talking about the kremlin planning to use an attack on ukraine for the purpose of further negotiations, but they gave them a hard time and the history of 2008 did not repeat itself in georgia. so when sarkozy appeared, now someone else could have appeared instead of sarkozy, but there is no symmetrical situation that the kremlin hoped for, but still there is too much blood. now they are scared in uh, not georgia on the whip, say now very serious resistance to win in the battle of kiev in the battle of kharkiv and here i am again , it's black tolerates the french fedentsim, eh, he worries about the prospects of the victory, and he's not a casualty, eh, the biggest friend of ukraine in the west will be johnson he proposes to think about a new union, uh, again

, the continent of the united kingdom of ukraine, uh, of poland, and i am on the second vostochaetsya state of central europe, including the baltic well, this applies to great britain andrii andriyovych i would like to point out that when it left the european union de facto now returned to the continents influences now perhaps eu policy more than when it was forced to coordinate its efforts with france and germany i.e. britain has now returned to its traditional of continental politics, the triumph of which was the defeat of tsar nicholas i in the crimean war. after this defeat, nicholas and, as the classics said, skanchalsya from

karapostizhno . it's very suitable, let's bring it to such a state and the second post of the kremlin is absolutely agreed with the great father that you are from europe and from the european union, britain has returned to the continental one. proposed by putin for the bracket, he also sponsored this, this is this party, uh, the project for the result said that the sacrosanctly opposite britain was inserted as a leader, in fact, for today, this is the leader of one world, coordinating efforts to repel putin's version, well, just a couple of minutes ago, andriy andriyovich, we talked on the air of the espresso tv channel with radoslav sikorski , the former minister of defense of the republic of poland, the former minister of foreign affairs and the former speaker of the polish diet, this is a very influential informed

politician, he is now a member of the european parliament. and he agreed with the thesis that never before has russia or the soviet union found itself in such a powerful isolation, even those people who should have formally played along with putin have now backed away from him, become disgusted with russia, and the kremlin 's power has become so toxic that there was no there are no people or political groups that would support the kremlin, on the other hand, we see that, despite this, the cream is still holding, that is, the great collapse that everyone was hoping for did not happen. it seems to me that i never hear everything better, what we consider polish politicians, if i say, uh, sympathy for the youth of the people , when in the same france, germany and ger

are especially dragging ukraine. once, there will be three european countries , old groups. where would i not be ideals ? i remember rammstein said even on the 21st of the seventh president, we will turn the earth, the earth and the sky to help ukraine, and we remember the task of the m. types of fine laws are allocated hrodnye hrodnye amounts of money but we do not see it. while there is not a single

hayaks on the field, business on four is trained by ukrainians in poland. in any case, we understand that the lend-lease program is open, and we are waiting for the necessary amount of weapons and ammunition to arrive - the lend-lease program is not about declarations, it is approved, that is, whether they want it or not, but the process will move from the other side maybe they are really giving the kremlin one or another chance. i don't know whether to change my mind or to start returning to negotiations and the withdrawal of the occupation troops from the territory, you know, this is a continuation of the fact that they have been giving a chance for 15 years and are starting to withdraw from ukraine they don't understand the chances krym only understands

the norm and this argument is written into the law today, that's when this document will appear in the field, they were in ukraine, so where it will probably be possible to talk with the kremlin about something until, uh, they have not given up on their series of destruction of the ukrainian state and will be the investigator by all available means, how seriously can you evaluate the statements, in particular , the environment of kadyrov, and some other russian professional fsb political scientists about the end of hostilities somewhere before the end of the year, why these are the dates that are being formulated, and they will be in 3 days, luckily, if i understand your question , does this statement mean that they are ready to limit their goals in some way and think of a cease-fire, i

repeat once again, the destruction of the ukrainian state it has not changed, it is possible to achieve it by different tactical bribes. kiev, for example, planted medvedchuk or muraev there, it didn’t work out now, they want to destroy ukraine with legacies with the help of m-m e-e all kinds of amateurs, the last part of macaroni , e-e, the road is already there, it is urgent to force this ukraine will agree to a cease-fire on some line on which they are asking for the truth vinnik how can we go further and fix it in some uh new ones there minus three minus 4 it will be a prelude to the next one klima for the further advancement of aggression besides they don't count on what we are the truce is as if the freezing

of the captured interviews is a very serious conflict in the ukrainian society. i ask now how it is never simplified. and the rest for 91% requires believing in the victory of ukraine and requires unity - that's it. the exile says that the entire tv channel, therefore, today they have the task of the ukrainian state through all the abramovichs, when the honor of the macrons is set to sign the country in the presence of the russian troops, and in short, not only varva and crimea, but also in the kherson zaporozhye region only she is in the war of arms supplies and the transition of the ukrainian army to the accession contract, which may lead to some kind of change in the situation .

zelenskih repeatedly answered him very well, by the way, and someone already proposed not to keep them in russia. in short, they understand me. why is a 15-year-old jewish boy male jewish boy in the 39th year so humiliated the swindler of the german people, adolf hitler, that he left germany and found a place to stay? -he is in the states, where he made a career, i have no reason to believe that ukrainians sometimes go to compromises that are imposed, well, andriy andriyevich, you know , maybe there is a certain seed about the fact that it is not necessary humiliating russia, russia must be judged, the kremlin must be judged very clearly based on various articles , and i think that the so-called mariupol tribunal

would be extremely good at sorting out and establishing the specific guilt and guilt of each of the actors, and here we come to the interrupted putin transit , in particular, we see how confused we see medvedev getting a little confused because i think that putin himself understands, despite all this conspiracy theory that they say that putin is being operated on, that he will either survive or not, everyone of course hopes but in any case, putin. and the elites understand this very well. the downed political pilot. putin has become so toxic that it will simply be a matter of speaking in the tone of conducting negotiations with them. i think that this or that secret transit is being launched in russia itself, well, you have known for a long time but at the level of the christmas behavior of this person, the former president of russia, medvedev, whose blogger

calls them two proses, so that all of these are couch chairs and iphones, without noticing. what are the most insane statements ? ukraine well, as far as everything is concerned, it is obvious that this person is participating in some kind of casting, or it seems to him that he is not participating in some kind of casting, which means that he knows better than you and me about what is being released, what kind of vacancy is it, of course it is won't break it, but he's ridiculously insignificant, but his behavior shows that the casting is going on . well, i wouldn't exaggerate the importance of this, but if putin dies tomorrow, it won't be such a big event, it won't change his behavior. it's russian of the political elite, they experienced this shocking, er, escorting

near kiev to kharkov, and this is of course, you are an application of the influence of putin's authority, well, you know, the lowered fence of the gangster structures, they did not plow, well, this is not changing their imperial thinking, they are now there. well, they now have such a concert so that with the help of our community - one, too, in the west, we will try to disrupt large- scale arms supplies to ukraine, and the ukrainian government will be forced to agree to negotiations with us, where the ukrainian people will stop, and i see eh why didn't they condense like that arrows peaceful population of living quarters well, because yes, that 's also the official earthman of the ukrainian government, how many people are they waiting for the ukrainian people to say ? on