for today, unfortunately, i cannot say exactly how many medics laid down their lives because the book of remembrance stopped registering. well, it is clear that during the war, during such hostilities, it is not really possible to publicly publish data on losses, but there are a lot of medics of various levels we have already paid for the fact that we live, we exist, we struggle with our lives , many are in captivity we are glad that they have returned to us staira eh, but he is still in captivity , the doctors are growing up eh, it is difficult, it is difficult to say something now well, we will fulfill our duty so as it is and i would like this day for today not to be a day of celebration as it has always been the handing out of medals, there are prizes, congratulation seeds and so that we

remember those who hold in their hands the lives of the defenders of ukraine, say this, you understand why the enemy is targeting our in medical institutions, this does not correspond to any norms of waging war, you know for me, er, in general, all the norms of the introduction of war and everything else, the whole world turned upside down after we worked in the buchan morgue and helped with the identification of bodies immediately after dismissal and actually for almost a month, why does he play around hospitals? why does he destroy , probably because everyone knows very well that the war is won by the easily wounded, those who returned to the bench, people who came wounded, who have experience, they are extremely powerful warriors, this is the first moment, the second moment is the destruction of the medical infrastructure this is

the most painful let's say an insidious blow and er hmm well everyone is suffering civilians are suffering medical workers are suffering the ability to provide er timely medical assistance is critical infrastructure on a level with let's say this with the transport fuel industry a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a-a - g the mykola pirogov medical hospital, for example, which is deploying a mobile hospital on the site of the destroyed hospital, which was

provided to us by one of the nato countries. well, we will not announce where and when and how, but this is another step in order to help with the restoration of this infrastructure in the future. what do you think about ukrainian military medicine, in principle, i can become such an expensive directive for europe because it is tragic, but on the other hand, our doctors are now gaining the experience that their european doctors obviously do not have, even in in north american circles, you are absolutely right, and already today we have unique technologies for today, doctors are working together, starting with stabilization points, military mobile hospitals, military hospitals, clinical centers together with the research institutions of the national academy of medical sciences with such powerful centers as the mechnikov hospital, we have accumulated enormous

experience that we will develop and use this asset of the whole world has been and will be for many years, and already in 17-18 we were asked to come to us military doctors from nato countries, because to stand next to our doctors and see how we work. because those unique technologies, those unique operations that lead to treatment that were formed in our military medicine, they really this is a material for study and for spreading this experience, but unfortunately, i emphasize once again that the experience and history of military medicine and the property of rules, standards, protocols, all this is written in blood, how to do it. yes, for us journalists, so that people are better. knew about the exploits of ukrainian

military doctors, what would we know about people, not only about facts, you know this is very important. it seems to me that especially today you know well, for some reason, most military doctors avoid publicity perception let's put it this way, there is a moment in the world of work that, unfortunately, not everything is good. there are certain problems in the managerial echelons of medicine, both civilian and military, which i don't want to expose to the general public. let's discuss these issues, there is the command of the medical forces of the armed forces of ukraine, there is the medical service of the national guard, where the

border state border service e.e.e. hospitals of the ministry of internal affairs e.e.e. in the civilian sector, everyone is working for victory, everyone is working to preserve the health of defenders, i think that journalists should just come and watch, i would recommend spending one day in a military hospital in a mobile hospital to understand what it is, thank you, thank you, mr. vsevolod, once again for your holiday i will remind you that a military doctor is a velo stalk. we were in touch on this important day for ukrainian doctors. many people owe their health and lives to our doctors today. soldiers. well, this is a very important point about which we need to say, now let's go to our

interactive, there is already the first question, mr. volodymyr babenko, mr. vitaly, it is interesting to hear your opinion about the coexistence of the two worlds of western civilization and the russian world, how to explain the current situation about what kind of event does russia buy energy carriers , the russians, it is money that buys western weapons technologies and then puts forward claims for world harmony, questioning the coexistence of the existence of western civilization itself, perhaps it is not worth sponsoring russia and, as a result, get rid of of the current problems with china, the same situation, thank you. i am completely redundant, mr. volodymyr, i agree, she wants to remind you that vladimir putin has been preparing for his attack on ukraine for many years, and by the way, i have already repeatedly said that this very

system of bypass lawns began to be built by russia immediately after not putin just came to power. and how putin's team, led by oleksiy miller, chairman of the board of gazprom, took control of this mining company and all these bypass gas pipelines, we talked about it from the first years were needed precisely in order to start a war with ukraine, but the west did not believe it, western politicians did not believe it, because they assumed that well, how can you slaughter a chicken that lays golden eggs, they did not understand that profits are so important to putin, especially in everything can be stolen from russia without cooperation and intervention, when you run a corrupt system and putin has important territories, and this became a huge mistake of western politicians. today i read an interview with the former federal

chancellor, what an angel, merkel, who says that we wanted to trade with russia precisely so that their aggressive ambitions yielded to the interests of the development of their own country, and western politicians still do not even understand why putin attacked ukraine without even waiting for the licensing of nord stream-2, and because i am not interested in any licenses are not interesting, such things are interesting to him. he is interested in the fact that there is already an iron pipe at the bottom of the sea, which means that the europeans will be forced to use it if something happens to the ukrainian catechism. he does not understand what rules are and does not understand what norms are he did not believe that the west would begin to give up russian oil and gas, and i absolutely agree that russia does not need to be sponsored. this is an absolutely obvious thing, and the west will be forced to come to this situation, but i would like to remind you that even if the entire west gives up russian oil and

gas in russia will have a great opportunity to sell its raw materials to asian countries at a discount, but selling and this money will in principle be enough for the further militarization of the russian economy , don't forget about this, there is competition now of the two worlds of democratic and authoritarian, that is why the people's republic of china, which is still led by the leaders of the communist party of china , and this issue is not an ideology, a way of thinking, it is so interested in the victory of russia over the western world, not even over ukraine over the western world, and it is a question that is very important as far as the situation with china will be the same situation with russia as far as the chinese leadership wants to, let's say, start a war in the taiwan strait just to achieve those goals, which, let's say, are the same goals which putin sets before himself in ukraine to prove

his right to the region by force, because the chinese economy, unlike the russian economy, which is a raw material, is also an economy that is connected by the sale of goods quite strongly and quite seriously with the economy of western countries in principle. we have just crossed this the limit of february 24, 2022, when the real war between democracy and authoritarianism began, this war is not for a year, not for two, the winter will be long. the tests will be difficult not only for us, but also for the inhabitants of democratic countries but also for the inhabitants of authoritarian countries, there will be colossal tests, however, the next decades , a world in which authoritarianism, democracy, and co-operation coexist will end its existence, or democracy will win over authoritarianism or the

authoritarianism of the democrats. however, i want to remind you that even our compatriots are always with such i would say breathlessly looked at all these authoritarian a regime with a twinkle in its eye. look at singapore . look at how china is changing. the communist party of china is our partner. you could hear this even from our deputies a few months before the war. now, every ukrainian should know the cost of the lack of democracy - this is murder missiles, death and tears, do not hope for an economic miracle created by an authoritarian regime , because it is an authoritarian regime. after this so -called miracle, everything will come to you, it will take away your loot, it will rob you, it will kill you. well, you should get rid of your

illusion yuriy serhiychuk vitaly, should ukraine spread the narrative that putin is deliberately destroying the fighting-capable part of the ethnic slave national minorities of chechens, buryats, marits, tatars in ukraine in order to prevent national uprisings against the empire? this is what putin has been doing deliberately since the moment he came to power, it is russifying national minorities, i must say that over these two decades from the point of view in the russification of the peoples of russia, ethnic russians achieved more success than during the 70th anniversary of the soviet government, which was also a russifying government, because , firstly, everything possible is being created to destroy

the cultures of the peoples of russia, and secondly, precisely because of putin, who is such an absolutely convinced chauvinist, it was necessarily canceled the study of national languages ​​in the republics of russia, and you know about it, the burning of albert raizin, a teacher who protested against the destruction of his native language by the putinists in the capital of izhevsk. is happening in all the republics of russia, even in those republics from which ethnic russians were forced to leave, this primarily concerns the caucasus because they could not get along with the local peoples and local thieves and the question is that the social level in these republics is very low, but the social level is very low throughout russia, the russian state as such, we must understand it does not exist, there is no city moscow that squeezes juices from the entire territory of russia, as you remember, there was once such a novel by jonathan swift, gulliver's travels in

the king and his supporters lived on such an island as it flew over the country and they had a wonderful life there. the country was poor. when the uprising began in the country, they simply threw stones from this island at those who protested against their savage regime. and moscow is such a mess. another version is a country of poor , destitute people who have no prospects for civilization, or in some big cities such as novosibirsk, st. petersburg, or khabarovsk, you can live, but in provincial russia as you can see, even a toilet is a booty, and of course, when we talk about the russians themselves, they are just a big people there. they become millions. and when they go to the army for social compensations, it is all so special and a military path is created, some military ones are there. town,

the opportunity to borrow money for apartments, then ordinary russians die in these wars and conflicts, but they do not become much less because they are simply a large nation. although now, in recent months, the birth rate in russia has fallen to the level it was the last time after the second world war, so the depopulation of the population is also beginning in russia, but when it comes to such peoples as you said about the chechens, the buryats, the mari people, if they die in the war, they are simply destroyed, the population itself, the nation of the buryats is the last there was a time after the second world war, a huge number of buryats died during the battle for moscow, this was their feat when they defended the russian capital , they were used as cannon fodder, he was practically never mentioned in russian historiography because the russians always needed ethnic russians to liberate russia, and they did not want to notice the exploits of other peoples of russia, especially non-slavic peoples, especially non-

orthodox people, because all this is not integrated into their nazi concept, now with the buryat people, by the way, not so much even they are afraid of the republic itself, how many of these village fences, aginsk , boyansk, etc., there is a national catastrophe, but the people of the great social choice, if you are serious, do not have it. this is what the russian state looks like, so of course we need to talk about it we don't talk about it, we don't talk about it much, but it is such a part of the genocide that the russian regime is waging against its own countrymen volodymyr vinnyk do you know the conditions of the russians that they handed over to our delegations on april 15, 2022 in the form of additions to the soapy istanbul proposals of our delegation, with a high probability the russians will not insist there on the annexation of kherson oblast and zaporizhzhia, they are ready to liberate this region

if ukraine ordered for 15 years will threaten the issue of crimea and donbass and abandon the nato promises water to crimea if the conditions are exactly like these, do you consider them acceptable? is it better to liberate the donbas crimea by force? i believe that there are no such conditions on the part of the russians, that this is all a delusion , because for the russian political leadership, the issue of crimea and donbas is closed, crimea is considered part of of the russian federation and no negotiations with the ukrainian leadership regarding the crimea. russia ukraine you understand that what is approved by the president of the russian federation is not a topic for negotiations with representatives of any third countries. especially when it comes to ukraine, the state sovereignty of which is called into question by the very political philosophy of the russian federation. for the russian federation, there is no ukrainian state , the president of ukraine does not have meaning who is

zelensky or poroshenko looks like the leader of a separatist entity that should be eliminated with the efforts of the armed forces of the russian federation, this is all you need to know about the future course of events thus, we have to understand a simple thing that in this situation there is no other way out and if, by the way, russia recognizes the independence of some kherson or zaporozhye people's republic, it should have annexed them for itself, the issue of these territories will also not be a topic of negotiation again, they simply will not understand this it is to talk. if you succeed in liberating these territories by military means, it is one thing, but no one in russia will conduct negotiations regarding the territory that russia considers its own, but remember these words, even if there is putin's succession will be difficult, and putin even forget all this delusional crimean conspiracist mr. volodymyr, the finns in 1939-40

beat the ussr hard for 3.5 months, so that he would be blinded for a decade in advance that it is better not to touch the finns, and then the finns compromised, he did not right or wrong, firstly the soviet union did not delay anything for ten years, the story looks completely different, mr. volodymyrivna, the finns compromised because at the time when they compromised the end of the winter war, they were afraid that they would not will be able to gain defense, the course of the war began to change in the direction of the soviet union, but there is a soviet army, the red army was already exhausted by this war, and that is why the finns made territorial concessions to stop this war, but you need to understand an important thing, we do not know what would have happened if it were not for the second world war we don't know what's behind them in the soviet union, maybe stalin would have returned in two years. in three years he would have occupied all

of finland . the finns were allies of hitler's germany when they took back all these territories that they had given to the soviet union and captured several times more all of soviet karelia and then the allies, not only the soviet union but also great britain , really wanted the prices to get out of the war and disarm germans who were on finnish territory and for this they were ready to guarantee finland the preservation of its independence, but in the borders that were recognized at the end of the first war, not the second war between the soviet union and finland, but the first it is winter, it is so-called and not wars continue and that is why finland preserved its independence although they put their internal and foreign policy under the control of the soviet union, these were not only soviet guarantees, but guarantees

of great britain and the united states of america, because everyone wanted prices not to fight then on the side of the nazis, if the second world war had not happened, we do not know what would have been spent in finland by the soviet union and whether it would have remained on the political map of the world, but this is all off topic for discussion serhiy kolyada what do you think will accelerate the provision of arms to macron scholz after personal impressions of what he saw in ukraine? i am sure that politics is not influenced by personal impressions, especially when it comes to political figures who were able to achieve the positions of president of france and federal chancellor of germany. i believe that weapons of ukraine are given precisely because there is public opinion in the world which is related to the promotion of our country and this is a very important issue which are

issues which are issues of national preservation the security of not only ukraine, but also the security of the west itself, and volodymyr vinnyk continues the dialogue with me. i will even read this question. do you really think that it is in the interests of ukrainians to continue a total war with a nuclear state and refuse negotiations? is your hawkish rhetoric connected with certain political-technological tasks that given to you , taking into account the colossal sacrifices ukraine may suffer, you should not be afraid that at the terrible court you may have questions. thank you , mr. volodymyr, and i will answer this question absolutely specifically, i believe that ukrainians have no choice in a war with a nuclear state for one simple reason, mr. volodymyr, which you should remember

once and for all for this nuclear state. - join russia in the regions of his time, said president putin , er, president lukashenko, and therefore we simply have no choice. because no one in moscow, believe me as a person who lived there for some part of his life, considers and not the ukrainian state, nor the ukrainian people as a subject for negotiations. if we manage to win this war, ukraine will exist. what sacrifices did she suffer? if we do not win this war, the ukrainian state and the ukrainian people will disappear as if they never existed at all, and i am not afraid of questions that i will be put on a terrible trial for one simple reason. i belong to a people whose contemporaries have disappeared in the history of the world.

the ukrainian people also remained not in the memory of people, but here on the planet earth, and this is what i will say to god at the terrible judgment, and i am sure that she will have a very friendly and serious dialogue with him over a cup of tea, mr. volodymyr. and now i will pass the word to my colleagues from france 24 programs that will show you another current report about the events of this war, thank you who about the war ukraine this year expects to harvest 50 million tons of grain starting this month, but elevators throughout the country are still storing last year's harvest with three weeks left

before the new harvest, but some elevators are completely full here, about 7 thousand tons, which will fit in two freight trains, it takes time to load them. therefore, we have to find alternative options for the placement of our new harvest, the placement of our new crop, time is running out precisely because the ukrainian railway networks are unsuitable for export agricultural products from landlocked countries ukraine does not have such opportunities viktor discusses the limited transport resources with one of the company managers, we have slightly changed our sales strategy before i was looking for a buyer and then i dealt with logistics now we first confirm the transport and only then look for a buyer look at our contracts volumes the next day five trucks arrived each of them can only take 25 tons this is a small fraction even of what is

available on one farm to transfer all the corn, wheat and barley currently stored in ukraine will need a million such trucks . we are loading products. now we are sending several trucks to the land border of ukraine of course in peacetime, all this went by trains directly to ukrainian ports, but today all the seaports of ukraine are either occupied or blocked by russia, dozens of cargo ships with crops have been stuck at sea since february, there are 28,000 tons of corn on the panamanian ship in this port alone, there are 8 more fully loaded ships this type of corn can certainly rot if left here, the ukrainian military is afraid of attacks on the ports and asks us not to show any places or people, not that there is a high level of activity in the ports personnel only from time to time a truck takes

part of the grain, the docks are not officially closed, they are simply dangerous to stay in, 10 ships were fired at, including ships of foreign registration, a bangladeshi citizen was killed, he was a crew member on one of the ships, so the ports are physically blocked, how can you enter the port if you may be fired upon, this is a big risk. several more ships have been sailing the ukrainian danube river since the invasion. this is how about 4 million tons of grain were exported for security reasons. surveying river ports early and ismaila prohibited activity on them has increased significantly ships sail from the salt flats in romania sometimes directly to ukrainian ports and sometimes they take cargo trucks and trains in the romanian ports of galats and ibraila then leave the sea again but the impact of our

visit barge which was expected in braille and the grain did not appear, and you see pigeons are often late because they spend 6 to 8 hours at customs, for us 8 hours is too much because during this time we could load two or three barges, promise the eu should deal with the bureaucracy to speed up the procedure, so far they have not been very effective, i have not seen any concrete actions, we really want everything to be done correctly, but we need to draw up the papers and check the goods as soon as possible, but we have to speed up this procedure, the problem with the documentation is not the only one st. george stops at the port of solyna, we we waited 19 days to enter the river. tomorrow we are going to ukraine to load with grain. one of the

reasons for the delay is the lack of pilots in the port, like viktor luka. we sometimes have to return home sleep change we can't work all the time especially at night simply because the ships are quite old they are not equipped properly according to him training additional pilots port takes 6 months so this ship and two others spend the night here good finally rest once we waited two weeks last time a week the romanians can't handle all this we need bigger ships the only way to do it is to win the war we will win and then everyone gets their grain when the ports are opened everything will go from there and