this is the story. and what about our budget, oleksandr kramarenko said a little bit about the courses, we have a huge budget deficit every month, and maybe the government has some kind of plan to somehow plan our borrowings or do they happen chaotically, who is patching up these holes, ilya ne schadovska, what about us with a budget, well, first of all, it would be necessary to register by the 15th of the current month, alexander, if you don't know, please, no, no, three weeks after three months of no registration, and now try to register, try for real try me, i already registered, i already registered on the 15th, if you registered, risks, risks, risks, even foreign companies

are listed as risky now by the tax office, again , as a non-theoretician, and as a practitioner, i tell you that by the 15th, the tax invoices that were in in february, march-april, may, the months registered are not registered, they are risky and nafigs from the beach, let's give a specific company, let's not invent. about the exchange rate i support the position why because there are a lot of, let's say, negative consequences here, you asked a question about the budget, our budget is repaid at the expense of external borrowings, so now, as a result of the low exchange rate, the budget does not receive due to the sale of, well, the

actual implementation of that aid which is to be found from abroad, it is 1.5 billion dollars, a billion, there they actually lose one billion, they lose 3 billion uah that could have entered the budget, this is at least and in some cases even 6 if accordingly, they calculated at the market rate, that is, in other words, the national bank, as a result of its policy, actually robs the budget, it steals from exporters as a result of such a policy . and this leads to the fact that we have today . here, he constantly declares the need to increase the discount rate, but excuse me when he creates deposit certificates, at the expense of which banks have the opportunity to freely place their funds at 23%. this is generally sabotage in wartime conditions, simply put you start printing funds and giving them to

commercial banks and thus, accordingly, it is actually an incentive not to sell accounting gdp directly to you, and the banks will not invest in gdp and the population will not invest in gdp, this is a road accident. when we have such an important foreign language, i think they said oleksandr kremenets, look at me er, i would like the story about the bond of the domestic state loan about the external debt , maybe we could talk a little at another time. it seems to me that this is a serious and big topic, let's go back to the prices, and we actually had the increase in prices in the previous three months, four months, to be more precise, almost already, this is primarily due to the exchange rate, this is due to the fact that goods are sold on import, and the currency is

not really bought at 29, and that’s all almost clear. and very there is a big problem with the so-called critical imports in general. that is, this is a list of goods that can be bought at the rate of 29. there is a big problem with borrowing and grant aid in zomba. i would prefer that our minister of finance and the prime minister focused on attracting external financing every morning. they have to postpone all issues related to customs taxation and so on and the like and ask to ask to ask for external financing . 2018 predicts an approximately 40-45% drop in gdp, that is, with a gdp that will be

60-55% of last year. we have tax revenues of 70. do you not think this is strange during a war when business and the economy are barely breathing 70% against 55 the real thing is that most of all in the economy, this means that the tax burden has increased, and by the way, this is about those who are not registered in the tax invoices . so, i would like the focus of our government 's work to shift a little to foreign borrowing, i will name two figures of russia's gdp in approximately 10 times more than in ukraine, gold and foreign exchange reserves before the blocking of a certain part were 20 times more than in ukraine. do you think our

country can survive without external financing? are focused on attracting external financial aid, that should be 90% of their defense work, a very simple reply. i think that i should have known that the tax burden on our main who was currently sleeping, in particular the agricultural sector, was very low due to the fact that ah, they are on the simplified taxation system of the fourth group, accordingly, taxes are paid less, they received vat refunds, and the number of employed people there is insignificant, but they gave a significant share of gdp, so this difference is precisely explained by the fact that those stopped industries that did not pay significant amounts of value added tax and other taxes and at the same time, accordingly, they provided a significant share of gdp, and for metallurgy, they also fell into the same situation

as a result of receiving a vat refund, which they paid, in fact, their tax burden is it consisted there in the orientation consisted in taxes on wages, that is, in other words, much lower than in other a-a manufacturers and other e-e enterprises that are in this sector, in this case, accordingly, their fall now the balance sheet gives such a cut, that is why the tax burden has not increased to date. thank you, ilya nezgodovsky, director of the institute of social and economic transformation, and oleksandr kramarenko, a journalist and editor-in-chief of the деньги.ua magazine, were our guests about e-e budgets about money about e-e course well, our discussion turned out to be so meaningful. and ilya nayskodolska says that you cannot hold back the course because it affects all processes. well, i have one piece of information for the rubric of the world in the world of animals, the mayor of moscow serhiy

a sablian citizen signed an order on the assignment of the territory near the us embassy, ​​before it was just a territory, now it will be a square, you know what it will be called. now, as dinar square, it was not called before, now the moscow authorities promise to name some other street or other square in honor of the liner. well, to it was not lunchtime, the russian mass media reports on everything, now the american embassy has an office address, the square of the donetsk people's republic, building one, one building, one dash 9, according to the official version, this name was chosen by muscovites themselves for this renaming option said 44.5% of the 278,684 residents of the capital who took part in the survey. well, the government promises to be the first to name the object named after lynore. andriy osypchuk is with us, people's deputy of ukraine andriy. we congratulate you. good afternoon. iryna gerashchenko,

your colleague should join us. let's start with well, i don't know if there is anything to respond to here, i have only one question what is in the heads of those people or is this a real poll is it a fake like all the polls and votes in russia, well friends we understand the catastrophic level of social degradation that is now in russia federations this is really a social drama it started not today not yesterday not the day before yesterday, we understand that actually on the head of these homo subjects who inhabited the territory of the former soviet union and in the russian federation, of course, people have always had a certain life well, not certain real, some kind and social economic savagery and they have been receiving daily propaganda for 22 years now, again, one

must not underestimate the level of information influence and which took place throughout the 1970s, well, imagine a person who was there 10 years when putin came to power and now 32, that is, all her conscious life, she only heard all this delusion that they planted daily through tv, first of all, through all mass media , so there is nothing to be surprised at all, this country is generally a perverted reality in general, i now have the suspicion that those who began to manipulate public consciousness, they have already moved away from business and actually do and manage these processes are people whose consciousness is already perverted and they themselves do not know where the truth is what are they doing with information, informational informational negatives and so on, so there is no need to be surprised at all what is happening in this madhouse, you just

have to watch it, namely defeat the russian federation for us. to move on to more serious topics, the leaders of the european union in brussels will approve the recommendation of the european commission to grant ukraine and moldova the status of a candidate for joining the european union this is stated in the latest draft conclusions, the eu itself reports a number of european mass media, the euro council has decided to grant ukraine and the republic of moldova the status of a candidate country, the draft decisions are discussed, the eu leaders will meet at the summit in brussels on june 23-24, that is, tomorrow and the day after tomorrow they have to decide on further steps regarding the accession of ukraine after the full fulfillment of all the conditions laid down by the european commission is attached to the draft decision of ms. iryna, are there any surprises for you in this decision, why is there no georgia in particular b

to this trio we spoke with our georgian expert er he was gela oh my god i forgot i already gela vasan i will remember he said that before georgia was the leader of this trio at the beginning of this integration process but now for some reason it fell out of this trio well obviously he says because of a certain the position of the georgian authorities is your word, and indeed we have made an incredible and this path. such was the case four months ago, which seemed unrealistic even at the beginning of the war, when brussels made a statement about the european future of ukraine, how could such irreversibility still be very big doubts regarding the fact that already in the summer we will be able to get the status of a candidate for eu membership, and here all the teams worked well, the president and diplomats and

the government and deputies, our political team, believe me, we did our best to also ensure that on all international platforms we insisted that this is not an advance for ukraine and ukrainian society. yes , it is an advance for the authorities, because we really need to complete such a serious and domestic task in the field of fighting corruption and in the field of freedom of speech, in the field of human rights, and in general, it is realistic reforming our judicial system, but if the european union made such a mistake and did not give ukraine this candidate status, i'm sorry, and then there would be more threats to build an authoritarian regime. i believe that this will be an extremely important and powerful signal for ukraine moved in a democratic direction, and in fact, it is difficult for me to say how many there are. i personally, our team, ivan koli husitsadze, who is

the head of the european integration committee, petro poroshenko and maria ivanova, well, in fact, all our deputies are for these held four months of diplomatic meetings, conversations of beliefs. once again, i want to emphasize that this will be a very big joint victory, because we give credit here for having worked well, of course , the government and the president and deputies from other factions. it will be a very important joint victory, but the main one . battles for european integration are our army, without these terrible victims , all this would simply be impossible, and in fact, the argument that our army defends european principles is key. and actually tomorrow, when this decision will be officially made the day after tomorrow, it is very important that the politicians in this euphoria do not forget about this for a minute and do not forget about our homework that we have to build a

democratic country and there is no chance of autocracy. well , we see that there are such threats in our country i will say our last remark that i very much now see the great task of the opposition without pathos, precisely such a controlling role in order for them to give any chance to autocratic tendencies to develop. to help us now in the war, well, first of all, i support rina in her rhetoric that in fact the ukrainian army won back and the ukrainian people in the broadest sense won back the right to be a member of the club of the rich and intelligent, to live in the same european family, and a legal political decision which we expect in two days, it is critically important for the ukrainian government, whatever it is, whoever is in the offices on hrushevsky street or bank street, whether they very

clearly and irrevocably move in the direction of civilization, in the direction of the european union, we we have to understand that this is also a very clear homework task. they will already voice very few compared to what could have been. i think that there are many more direct demands for the ukrainian young democracy, but they are now narrowed down to what i am not mistaken from the seven tasks and by and large, everything revolves around what i have been talking about for the third year. my colleagues have all been talking about the rule of law for the third year, because if we do not ensure that the supreme voice on the one hand of human rights in the broadest context, on the other hand, we will not we can guarantee the safety of money and economic transactions, because the protection of contracts is key for any business in europe and this is what the european economic union is all about, and contracts can only be protected through an independent

law enforcement system, independence of courts, independent law enforcement agencies, it sounds like as if it is already banal, we are talking about this for the third time in a row. but if we do not do this homework, there will be no advancement to the european union, and the last thesis i think is a very important lesson for the council for ukrainian politicians have the fact that georgia is not on this short list of candidates for eu membership, this is an example of how you can search all the huge opportunities georgia yes, it was in the forvator of reforms, the shaper of the movement towards the european union, but i don't want to use bad words, but you all understand what i'm talking about they are talking about wasted huge opportunities, and i really wanted all the residents of political offices in the city of kyiv to look carefully at georgian history and understand that it is possible to get a candidacy, but also his

it is possible to lose, and it will be, i think, a catastrophic failure for the future of ukraine, so i really hope that this is joint work that is really carried out by everyone, regardless of party affiliation, because those who live a little longer, they have been waiting for this moment for 30 years, they have worked for decades in various forms in order to bring this is critical right now. it is important not to waste this chance. and for this, i repeat once again, you need to do a little homework. it is clear. therefore, you must reject ambitions, reject desires, reject this . this is the approach that has been in place for the last three years. it is called present family. to give friends and preferences, forget about all this and just move according to normal algorithms of democracy, which are outlined in the european union. i hope that

in 1.5-2 years we will we can fulfill all the requirements and become a member of the european union simply by closer hands ms. irina, do you agree with such terms, well, it is not long enough 1.5-2 and we have a lot of work to do i have great respect for mr. osadchuk, but i am not afraid that mine is such longer parliamentary experience, and maybe ukrainian women, they are more like that, you know, realistic, pragmatic, but i still give five years here and it would be a very good pace, i will tell you what, uh, when we are between the agreement there and obtaining a visa-free there 3 years worked like this. it was very cool. now we see 5 years there without a visa and candidacy. this is very, very, very good pace. and really, i completely agree with that. i give five years, and that's really under the condition that the authorities wake up tomorrow, you know. in another country

where it will be governed by the responsibility of not this victorious relays, some kind of fanfare from all the teapots every day, not realistic, but responsibility , and in this responsibility , mr. osadchuk is absolutely legal, we need to work together a lot, starting from the political culture, where there really should be a bet on professionalism, on responsibility, on the formation of a government of national unity, because today we have patron dogs on the airwaves of this single marathon and the fact that she does more than government officials, this is an abnormal story . we do not understand what is happening to the sphere in our country education, we need to understand more about what we will have with the economy, we have absolutely little with the economy, we have really huge problems in the field of human rights today, this is related to the war, and here we need to talk more about it, actually, absolutely right mr. well, osadchuk, what is the rule of law? well,

this is a glaring problem in ukraine today, and when the portnovshchyna ruled the courts in our country for the past three years. well, let's not hide it, when we have lists of activists for filtration camps since the 19th year and are not being implemented now. not for that has no responsibility. this is abnormal, and it seems to me that the authorities should very seriously reconsider all these mistakes so that we wake up in another country with the status and move forward according to european principles, starting from respect for human rights to opposition to freedom of speech, so that zelenskyy notes this important history because they included 3 pro-ukrainian tv channels in digital broadcasting, that 's why censorship is the worst manifestation of sovietism and an authoritarian regime. that's how putin 's russia began to talk with the government too. and the government

perceives any such remarks as out of time, as it is criticism , but it is not criticism, it is actually my personal struggle for ukraine to be european and the last ones. i believe that we still have to work today as well these days, for ukraine to receive a proposal, i am very scared of the throwing of power from one side to the other in relation to nato, and from the 19th year they forgot the charm and then became nato supporters, such hawks, then they again began to tell that, well, this is a possible question. it is impossible to imagine a cake, but only membership in nato guarantees security to ukraine together with our best armed forces. therefore, we have to work as actively today as all of ukraine to ensure that ukraine gets the kudachi and the same form in the window . thank you, mrs. rino. in all cities. it seems to me that it seems to me that defenders should be included in this

story. because when i see him being transported from city to city, from chernihiv to lviv and back and passed from hand to hand, i just start worry about the psycho-emotional state of the animal, you understand. because he does n't need these scenes and these applauses, because he's not a person, fortunately or unfortunately, i don't know anymore, well, this is my personal opinion, maybe there will be some top five on the list of future flights they did not drink, well , in fact, the authorities cannot stand competition, of course, about the reconstruction of ukraine, i wanted to talk to you about more than a trillion dollars, a trillion, that is a thousand billions of foreign aid, ukraine may need to compensate for the damage caused by the russian war, he announced such a figure the head of the european investment bank, werner heuer, reports bloomberg, i would allocate a trillion because i saw in the public space numbers that i consider completely unrealistic, which are obviously still voiced when i look at the level

of destruction in ukraine, heuer said. he added that europe will have to play the biggest role in this p andriyu ot we talked with our economists , experts ilya nayskodovsky oleksandr kramarenko came to the conclusion that in general well, all the activities of the ukrainian government should start now and ending not only with the collection of taxes in ukraine , but also with the search for financial assistance already today and now, in your opinion, are ukrainian government officials putting in enough effort to collect this trillion, well, well, this is a huge amount, which unfortunately they are not giving us yet, please. let's go. let's be very realistic and agree with one simple fact: no one will give us a trillion just like that, no one will give us 100 billion, we cannot count on the fact that we will rebuild ukraine at the expense of donations from the european union or the united states of ukraine it will be impossible to rebuild at the expense of the taxes of developed countries, everything should just be accepted. yes

, they are now helping us to patch holes, so it will continue, but this is not the money that is needed to rebuild. for reconstruction, we will need two sources of resources. the first is reparations from the russian federation, which can be received already because of frozen blocked assets in the west and you know that this work is being carried out by us. by the way, we have worked a lot on this and are working on it, all of canada is now passing the relevant legislation. we very much expect that in the united states will pass appropriate legislation and we will use russian assets as a source of e for reconstruction, and there we are already talking about hundreds of billions of dollars. and with another source, i hope that after victory it will be possible to create a mechanism for reimbursement or receiving part of the funds from russian energy carriers, because they one way or another, i think they will be sold in the future, but they must be sold through some special test

fund, perhaps most of this money would go directly to ukraine to compensate these huge needs, but the third is, of course, it is necessary to build and create phenomenal conditions for investors in ukraine, because no one will give money, but investing money will be a pleasure if suitable conditions are created for this, i explain to everyone i see a lot of things or not in the forest in any, even very risky conditions, if you can make money, i knew guys who worked with me who were building a mobile communication network in north korea because they were promised security guarantees there, they were given excellent financial conditions, they despite what went, earned money and left there, that is, the business will work even when i am certain of brazil, but for this the government needs to do a lot of work here, of course, and the blog of the rule of law, which we have already talked about with you, but also the investment

conditions, and it must be done honestly and beautifully, not as we do to this day. yesterday irina and i witnessed this show about industrial parks, this is a bad example when, under the guise of the idea of ​​attracting investment, everything is very beautiful there, but we actually create a competitive environment in the middle ukraine and we are actually creating a layout plus businesses of the state. when i hear the industrial party, i immediately think of yanukovych's youth industry parks. for some reason, iryna gerashchenko's associations just wait. the parliament met for three days and it's one thing when we vote on the tamburg convention, and i think, by the way, that it's very a good story, here is where the war helped some completely non-ideological deputies to press this green button because they like something istanbul what is there some other

convention but it's cool that it happened and it was a nightmare was defeated in this case, but all the other questions there were really, uh, there were a lot of lebist schemes, and when the green ones were returning there, you know, there are corridors for smuggling , this is all absolutely shameful, and in this context, you are the right colleague, what should i say about the supremacy of the right, but also to return the controlling role of the parliament , because one sometimes gets the impression that our government already likes martial law, it is complete, and the possibility of controlling the media is empty, empty without the media, the parliament is multiplied often at zero parliament, this is wrong, no investor will come here if this is going to happen here, you know, when we have this conference, it will be an investment conference in lugano, and the ukrainian government is going there. this is good, but it

is almost full there there are deputies of the sending party. they are going to control these flows. well, there will be no investments. there must be a very clear and transparent mechanism of how to get here, and the authorities need to realize this. we answered, you know. well, we are actually doing a very good job. annoys already, well, if only our colleagues. maybe, but without the adequacy of lack of transparency, irresponsibility , there will be nothing." it's interesting, and we really didn't have some colleagues in the hall who were at the front. and you, nina yuzhanina, unfortunately, the button didn't work. sometimes it happens in the parliament. our faction is ideological, and some, as you know , defended the istanbul convention for 11 years, well,

some listened to the position of the council of churches, and that's just says that, well, this is a myth, you know that european solidarity is a leadership -type party, democracy within a democratic party, thank you, mrs. iryna volodymyrivna. it is true that there is no vertical management system, and that is great, but iryna gerashchenko will say that i fought for it to be written for your struggle, as a woman, i support andriy er-e osadchuk yes er-e part unfortunately, he dies for democratic values, this must be understood further news directly on the course and we say goodbye ihor checherina were with you for the last five hours, be with the press events, the most important events, events that are happening simply