will they allow us to effectively carry out this rehabilitation of all these bodies for the benefit of the ukrainian state and ukrainian society? i really hope so. valentin, in your opinion, are we not seeing some kind of more global process or its possible completion of changes in the president 's team? what am i leading to, what is facebook actively discussing again? that's it. and here is this photo from paris from the 19th year, which means that zelensky went to macron and in this photo together with him danylyuk bakanov and ryaboshapka already is not in this team just like bohdan is not in some other uh people sitting since the first prime minister of zelensky's time, how is the president's team changing in your opinion, how is the president's team evolving? yes, this is a political team, it's not a mafia structure, well, it's in a mafia structure in the structure, everyone is connected by some kind of blood, related by some kind of

ties, and there they are really like that, together and to the end, and in the team, in the political one. this is what happens with the need for change. well, someone does not see his future in this team, well, someone on the contrary the team does not see uh in its ranks and no, well, i do not consider you as someone who can be useful for this team. this is normal, a completely natural process. well, if we take the verkhovna rada of ukraine there right now, yes, that is, how many interesting processes took place there with the presidential as a faction , we can name a bunch of other names. well, yesterday they went together. well, today their paths diverged. someone put their own ambitions higher than the interests of the team. someone simply demonstrated their unwillingness and inability to play in this game. the team, well, someone's executive and professional level does not correspond to the tasks facing the team at this stage. well, i'm selling you such an example.

you know, from football, usually when a team goes from the first league to a higher league. well, the team's composition is updated to a large extent, that is, they buy new players and those who won the first league usually stay in the first league, but in order to win the higher league, the squad needs to be significantly updated, because other performers are needed, and zelenskyi in this aspect is absolutely normal in demonstrating his personnel skills politics well, i'm saying at the very beginning that either a person pulls well, where are the results if it's not ready, then why should he sit? the elections were held together. well, you have to understand that it's simple. well, when they went together, they had the task of winning the elections. well, in order to win the elections, you need one team. when the elections are won, you have to perform the function of governance. well, you need other specialists. well, they gave a mandate to trust it on

scooters , what was his name, where is he now? other characters, that is, it is just normal here and vice versa, why will they be changed more often here, on the one hand, yes, this indicates that there are mistakes in personnel policy. well, if you appointed someone and then remove him, well, that means that you probably appointed him incorrectly, but on the other hand, it also indicates readiness to recognize it mistakes that if the person you appointed does not meet the tasks to solve which you appointed, well, such a person is removed and the next one is appointed. a natural process wherever there is a yard, so not only in ukraine, not only in politics, i will make this up, i always say that billions of dollars and euros are spent on the football transfer market, and

most of these transfers turn out to be inefficient players then don't play because they were paid for it, everyone who talks about who is there, who recruited the team, let them look at their teams, let them see who slavko vakarchuk recruited to himself and where he is, who was recruited by other characters who are now talking and they teach whoever is going to be there valentin thank you , thank you for your comment valentin glykh political analyst of the public organization slovo i dilo or you are with us thank you and in moscow on july 20 there will be an inspection of the public notification system and sirens will sound, the local government announced that messages will also appear on radio and tv channels, officials explain such actions by the fact that training is necessary to practice timely informing residents and the actions of emergency and operational services in the event of natural and man-made emergency situations, friends, we will discuss now this topic with our

next guest, mykhailo sheitelman joins our broadcast - this is a political technologist writer, mr. mykhailo, we welcome you good night good evening mr. mykhailo, in your opinion, what are the notification systems in moscow actually being checked for? what are they preparing for? is this a normal check because they are afraid? is it after all in order to scare the residents of the ukrainian capital ? mobilization by the military if now everyone will be taken to the military enlistment offices and taken to the front but they don't want to instill fear, but in principle remind the population that the war is going on because they haven't made the final decision yet one of the options they are still considering is the total mobilization of the population. it is known that the kremlin has different points of view on this matter, including one of the points of view that this mobilization

is being carried out. and would you agree that if they suddenly start carrying out the mobilization, that is, we had nothing with whom we did not fight, nothing happened. and suddenly, the mobilization is clear, something is clear, so apparently they decided to carry it out, because i can’t recognize it in any way. before that, it didn’t happen for 30 years. and now a friend happened , it’s unlikely to scare the population, they also don’t prepare to scare, it means that putin and the government made a mistake somewhere that arose how the guitarists don’t have to do this, they want to do it well, i think it’s better to mobilize so that people so to speak, they pulled up, and mikhail, in that case, interestingly, he will also discuss with you the last statement from the kremlin, they commented in particular on the negotiation process, we know that the negotiations have been unblocked, but as for the results, well, for now there is little information about the process going on. yes, but

once again they said about the negotiations in general , er, armistice, about anything, that is, and about stopping the war, yes, and er, again they complain that kiev does not want to at the negotiation table, you insist that the conditions will be worse a-a um. what do you think, why are they like this, uh, they are peddling exactly the topic of the negotiations, they need more than us, they need more than us on this floor, and we don’t have that much fear, let's even be honest and a little bit in society, they exist that these are the negotiations it seems that it can end with the fact that one of the conditions of the russian federation will be some truce there in the south, and we will not be able to carry out an attack on the kherson region, and so on. what we would not like , of course, at this time. it is possible even today

that another attack has been made. as you know, odessa has probably been hit. this is also russia, all this is done to show that there is no. look, we are talking now. and how about 10, we will fight. consent to the history of grain, but i think that our negotiators will rather refuse the transportation of grain than agree to a truce, that for us it will definitely be a disaster, the car is unacceptable, well , this is what all the military experts say, because it is impossible to give you the opportunity to dig in, it is impossible to give us the opportunity to bring ammunition back to where who has been knocked out by the martians? this is what is needed. who needs more negotiations today? of course, russia is there. maybe this is russia. he really wants to consolidate the successes they have, to consolidate them on paper in order to continue. he says, look at everything, you wrote the contract yourself . goodbye, they have their own conditions. let's say that because of that, they published something in one of the american newspapers. well, where are they, apparently, they

publish it for money, or do they publish everything in the newspaper ? they even mentioned a-ah and sounded in the following way at home the press conference in the sand, they asked if they had read it or did you read this 15-point peace proposal that was published in america, he said no, no, at the first hearing, we don’t know anything, well, such miracles don’t happen . it was written clearly that eh, in fact, their proposals consist of the fact that they take themselves away from donetsk and luhansk region, they give it away, give it to the kherson region, and as the first part of the kherson zaporozhye region, they take away crimea, and ukraine accordingly destroys practicality, speaking army, this is their requirement for today. this is what they want, and they will not agree to such a peace. well, we do not agree to it, even close, so it makes no sense for us to introduce it now. the conditions of the mayor who was at the end of march here in istanbul, and after that lavrov already said that we would look at the situation on the battlefields

directly, and ushakov said today that the conditions would already be second, hinting that they could take away the south of ukraine what do you think when they talk about other conditions than those proposed in istanbul? does this mean that they are really planning the annexation of the territory even beyond the limits of donbass beyond the limits of the granite exchange of the donetsk and luhansk regions, which i now i listed them, you will absolutely convince me that if i offered them to putin today, i absolutely agreed to them. day eh when you talk about what is in istanbul these were the conditions these were the conditions of that side i.e. these were not offered to me our these are the big conditions today they frankly lie by the way even in this statement about what the conditions are it will get worse, don't talk about what happened in istanbul. we already almost agreed. well, in fact, we agreed

that they speak more there, and then ukraine went to another ukraine, for example, his negotiations , and so on. then she behaved very professionally and even beautiful such crap, well, original for diplomacy, the fact that our delegation simply announced all its proposals out loud at the press conference, each member of the delegation came out and announced his piece and that's all ukraine offered everything to be documented, eh , what russia offered was not documented, because they always do it all in secret , they do it secrets are never spoken and it is not clear, i didn’t want them to offer anything well, what ukraine offered is known to the whole world russia was offered the fame of some individual statements there, putin 's shebe medvedem, who has a year, and this clearly does not coincide, there were positions that coincided, and they wanted 100 times more than what ukraine offered them, therefore now they are saying in their mouths that it was supposedly agreed upon. well, they continue to threaten the tyranny that they say.

and we will continue to be even worse. their latest is what they were able to achieve in the luhansk region, the occupation of several cities and almost the entire territory of the luhansk region, and by entering , they secured this success through diplomatic channels and military means, and all rocket attacks of our cities far away from the front lines are connected precisely with this pressure, today we are losing on the battlefield only because i said that our diplomacy is open, our positions are all, and president zelensky and that's when the delegation in istanbul and the circle announced everything about it kuleba announced it everything in the interview, in my opinion, the timeson gave, of course, the times, turn to yes, that is, all

our diplomacy is open, it is putin's diplomacy is closed, all ego propagandists then talk about putin did not speak, and putin did not promise putin that's all fulfills what he said. why did he go? he doesn’t say anything. here, for example, was a rather funny speech. i remember the former director of eko moskve and mrs. venediktov, who says well, how is putin our president? look, he didn’t promise this . he didn’t demand it. i wasn't going to join you. that's all they scared zelensky. well, that's complete nonsense, and then he tells it, he repeats putin's words as he likes, so he won't have to pretend to be diplomatic afterwards, he said no incorrectly. everything will have to be justified at the diplomatic level. and in front of his own people, he can still face the truth because, unfortunately , he enjoys such a large support that, in general, they are all blowing on him, and for now, it doesn’t matter to them, as putin said, so it is necessary, mikhail. what do you think? are the negotiations on grain a-a a trap with the aim of unblocking the approaches to odessa and for a further

attack on odessa, after all, as putin said, they have not started anything yet. the authorities of the military command, in general, immediately disorganized, frankly, they said that we understand that they will use it. this is an opportunity to penetrate our ports because it was all used in mariupol, as we remembered during each humanitarian corridor, it was fought . corridor, therefore, ours immediately clearly indicated that this is not the case, it is impossible, and that i have no guarantees that they will attack, we will not go, but we will go if there is an escort of military courts in turkey, for example, or some turkish aircraft or something else, that's why this question. i think from

our point of view it's completely closed here. the conditions for making a truce in the south, and this will definitely solve our chance for this victory . that uh-huh uh -huh almost fell under these kaimarsy kerrienko himself just arrived in the new kakhovka, i’m trying to inspect something there or ready uh-huh a raincoat probably for some kind of further political actions well, in general, how much do you think that's how it is in principle . kyrilenko could have come to kherson oblast , kherson oblast, and the more puck now , too, he came there, where one occupying the territory , they all take turns, and people more important than kyrylenko have already come to kherson oblast , and for example... eh usnulyn is generally the vice-premier

such a person who is close enough to putin, well, personally, there is nothing personal. of course, there is nothing personal. no, but it is still important, it is enough figures , that is why such officials come here. but when you say that we can quote jellyfish, i was more careless with jellyfish. it's a rather subtle point, and what's the point? yes, there are certainly honest guys who left russia to have the opportunity to preserve freedom of speech, but they are russians, i don't live in the russian agenda, and they are among them. they reprint some things, well, they don’t reprint, well, when they read the russian media, they are exposed to this knowledge in a way, that is, because of them, i still think that russian propaganda works, not in the sense that it is corrupt, god forbid, not in the sense that they work by order in any case, but they simply find that they live in that agenda, they cannot be not subject to it. here we are with you, we live in the ukrainian and international districts there, so it is not suspended from the russian district, but they support , that is, some of the theses, or regulations, or

phrases from russian propaganda sometimes penetrate even into the text of medusa mmm this happens indeed well and the rain channel we can remember yes today it resumed its broadcast today it was at 20:00 moscow time 1 broadcast eh what do you think if there is some meaning well, it’s exactly a complex structure that was created in riga, he has the main broadcasting there, it’s necessary to temporarily and in georgia , as i understand it. -that is, only correspondent or the studio is still in one city, i don’t remember it now, it ’s in germany, but i could be wrong, and they have it there, and so to speak, you know everything perfectly well. well, to say that we understand the level of professionalism is absolutely very high, here are those people who the channel is created and again, it depends on my view , that’s all, that’s not what the people of the jellyfish effect know, you yourself have confirmed my version, this is what

i often have to do with my friends who live in ukraine. well, on ours, who supports us, but at the same time, they are not from ukraine and strey of those countries let's say from israel and the baltic states, they read jellyfish all over there, and then they tell me, look, look, that's what the jellyfish said, and i have to explain and lead this to work, and here it is important whether the rain can withstand this, can you withstand the rain, what is it i'm used to some russian agenda, it's a very big risk, a big one, and a danger. i see that there's also a live nail that someone tried to create, too, so he wants to carry out the same problem with the jellyfish. you can't we can. well, for now, it’s not possible to give people a chance now, judge them for their sake, in any case, you have to watch them. i will honestly watch and then i will say something about it. at least they don't support the war and they don't support putin. even if they don't support us either. well, even if they have a sword, it wo n't happen anyway. let them have something that

unites them. что well if you look at criticism that is already sounds in the address of the rain, then um, of course, first of all, eh, he asks the question, eh, and why ? well, there are questions here. what do you think , will this tv channel be able to pop this bubble ? uh, how realistic is it at all to crack it with the help of a youtube channel which have not been done somewhere abroad with a large number of cable television providers,

in particular, it is in georgia, magdia in latvia, it is three krupnesh, there is a provider in israel, two krupnyshki, i am interrupting. smg, or there is a space where people who understand russian still live, but often the main task is to convey the truth in some way to the russians who live on the territory of russia and who choose this government and they will go to any elections again, or all the elections, that's the question, yes, i'm not making money. i meant that they simply have a distribution network. unfortunately, of course, they will not be accessible to the russians. you understand the rain channel . how he was closed, only those who were against the war were watched unequivocally. putin was hanged on red square, this is the only way to convince them that even then they will not be

convinced that putin was wrong, they will think that this is a fake, in fact he was alive, so there is no need to convince them. the second, and he brought, i can bring another benefit, this is the consolidation of russian russian opposition forces because, as vladimir lychlenin once said, who was still there and a very good person, but he was a great organizer revolution. he said there in his newspaper iskra that it is not only collective propaganda, indeed, and a collective organizer, you can say to the organizers of the call, which today certainly does not exist , how they have all this disintegrated into parts. единых таких есть отдельный одельный канльчики бесплатный бесплатный бесплатно, including those from ukraine . they have very different positions, different positions, some of these people are our

real allies, but they will name names, why do you know all of them, but who really says that it is necessary that russia must return all occupied territories, consequently, including crimea , mandatory compensation for everything that is destroyed i am obliged to lead war criminals, but others are not like that, including positions in the russians, they say no, well, there is a need to think, after all, krym is what there is, not what we are, why is that? yes, yes, yes, we are only in one police question well if the only user of this resource is the support and consolidation of the opposition, then the question arises and what is the use of this position ? in some way to justify the country as a whole, uh, by pushing it. everything is only for this terrible putin

regime . and the rest are not to blame. they are these people, the rain channel will not work for ukraine, it will not work for us and you. and maybe he will not even be our ally, he may turn out to be our enemy, if he does what you are saying now, he is trying to justify some part of the population says that they here it has nothing to do with putin's army. i'm in such a better position, since i don't talk to the russians on the air, of course, and i don't talk to the liberal russians on the air. i ask them all the time. if it's putin, it's a non-military prisoner, they don't get it like the geneva convention, some kind of private office, that's right, it's some kind of group of bandits, and then the ukrainians are obliged to be captured by the ukrainian army. or they can just be shot. but if these are your citizens, your army is responsible for them. even if you came from russia, you are still responsible for them, these are your soldiers and officers, that's all . that's why they kill and rape your soldiers and officers, not putin's. they have russian federation written on them, so if this is a channel, it will be

to introduce such a police as you have now told . so, it will be our enemies. i hope that there will be a hundred to introduce a different police . let the probability of this be small, but when they will be, if the situation develops, this is the third class in russia, and this is our only chance to have at least some kind of relationship with the russian federation, anyway , the russian people will be the enemy of the ukrainian if ten years well, simply because everything has already happened yes, but either we will have an enemy with whom we will be shooting every day, or we will have someone with whom we have historical contradictions but with whom we can enter into negotiations, that's the difference, so we expect what will happen someday people will come to power in russia and we will get a free country next to us with which we can have a dialogue, not what we have today mikhail if i talk about putin's entourage if there are people who secretly do not support the war in ukraine and are waiting

of a certain moment yes of course there are so many of them and there is so much evidence for this , let's be honest, and there is even someone who openly stated this in direct text, for example, oligarch derybaske stated three times that the unconditionality of all oligarchs is well, well, one of the structures of the closest abramovych deribaskoy, er, alesharov, there was a rumor , and there is er, a trick that you didn’t tell the servants, but obviously there are many people, here are actions, words, something won’t support, they don’t support for them, it’s pure the war will make all this happen. we are there for a long time. they are thinking about some psychological excursions and theories. why did putin start it, but he does not hide it in his head , that's all. he stumbles upon these historical books, and that's all he's doing because of the start of the war, among other things, sitting next to

him are not only the same idiots. not the most noble people, perhaps they are also murderers like him, but it is interesting that they wanted to be rich people, and did not want to sail on yachts, live in the west, and i need everything, this is war , and of course there are many such people. and if you believe those who are good he knows what kind of people there are, let's say in the environment, it's good, how much do you think putin still has resources to continue this hot phase of the war in ukraine, how long can it last, and what is it, and when the most important thing is that it will end with three resources military, political, financial, means financial , he will have enough because, in principle, the people of russia are ready to endure for a long time, therefore he can print those rubles, rubles, and pay the military with rubles , this will be enough for you, therefore, financially, he is not limited, the military resource is very limited

because he cannot produce new modern weaponry thanks to the actions of the west are important not only financial, which of course russia suffers, but first of all a very technological loss, they are capable of producing technological weapons. and today, without high -tech weapons, they resist the fact that we are asked, they can’t. because they can’t even produce tanks with active armor, i’m not talking about some rockets and so on. they can produce, but their resource is very limited, literally. i think that er, that is, they can not fight only with primitive weapons, this is a huge problem for them, but putin’s most limited resource for today is not even a military one a resource and a political resource, because i already said eh in response to your previous question that the majority does not support the war in his environment and only while he has some victories, he gets carte blanche for its continuation and they are forced to tolerate it putinum hello because he won something there near luhansk but if he would suffer a

defeat if the ukrainian army goes on the offensive if the ukrainian army day after day liberates populated areas that there are more than two thousand captured how president zelensky announced today that after the liberation of populated areas, putin will lose his political political cardigan, all this is a continuation of the war and the reality will become a threat of retribution . this is the second possibility, in addition to the military of ukraine. there is no politics, it is so improbable that, in my opinion, it is possible with all the rumors that what kind of daughter, yes, listen to russia, such a country, where some kind of daughter is weak someone will wash first, secondly, if he wanted to prepare, he would have started to do it a long time ago , well, lukashenko has been preparing his son since he was six years old. at the time, heydar aliyev was preparing his

son ilham aliyev there too, well, years ago. 15 of his president was preparing his son for the presidency, and president nazarbayev was preparing his daughter in kazakhstan for a decade. well she worked in politics for a decade to prepare a person for politics. well, she is putin's daughter. she should have been at least 10 years old. that among the candidates there are more than them, yes, that's how you estimate such a probability, of course it's realistic, it's realistic because he's just being prepared he's been holding you high posts for a long time and all kinds the directors of gazprom, among other things, and for

this he entered some other companies among them , of course, his prospects, they doubted him, they could only put him in putin's place , that is, when putin is overthrown, it would be logical to put patrushev in the casting of his son there is no doubt about the poor man here. well, patrushev is not elected very much, let me tell you honestly. as a polytechnologist, the patrushego has complete shortcomings , as does the candidate of such a public public politician , that is, there is much more at the same olympic games in russia. more people with charisma son papri что меня i have the grace of a priest what kind of public charisma if you see him on tv in russia they will laugh they simply have never seen or heard how to talk how he behaves he can't do any of this at all this is a check for which there is no biography of a single person i haven't worked a day in my life, i haven't done anything, they don't know how to do anything, this is going to be a big problem , because there is little to hand over power, you know, or to someone, today, formally, further, check, somehow, you chose, you won. excuse the elections there, medvedev won because putin pointed his finger at her, that's why he chose