er, even if there is a certain declaration that leaves here, then you just have to ask the question: from whom does this declaration come, if it comes from the united states of america, it is very important, and such a message is a certain message for the whole world about what russia is, what it is now the muscovite regime and what is happening in ukraine that is, it will be a certain message and it will be a certain impulse and for the purposes of a number of other states in order for them to take such steps accordingly and this will also be a certain pressure both politically and in principle psychological on those subjects who probably still cooperate with the occupying state or are going to work. by the way, this is the same. similarly, if the united states of america took another very important step, it actually recognized

moscow as the occupier of russia as a state that finances terrorism. on the one hand , it was probably, well, of course, a more declarative thing, on the other hand, it would be an impulse and it would be a general demonstration that no one has to deal with this state anymore. because if such things the united states of america speaks about such things, this means that the weight of these things is very, very large, because in my opinion it is important for our country and the first and second. another question, that is, it will not be considered there in the near future, but as regards the genocide itself, as regards the actual genocide, let's

say the assessment of the aggressive war, the destruction of the ukrainian nation by the er-er occupiers, um, this will be really important for us politically. i once again i emphasize that political support is possible. well, legal . of course, this will be a certain legal fact. we will see that this is actually a legal decision, but politically it will have a certain weight. by the way, a certain weight is possible, for which, among other things, they will be dragged, they will be dragged, and there will also be a number of certain sanction restrictions in the future, because how can we as a state be able to specifically refer to the united states of america admit that, in fact, muscovy is a state that is now organizing genocide on the territory of ukraine, and we will be able to appeal to including to other states that today take either a neutral position or, let's say, only a

declarative position that they supposedly support ukraine's positions and the political and international legal positions in this case of the occupier will be much weaker , so i welcome such a decision and such decisions they are very they are even already i would have said a long time ago about the new sanctions magazine, the official european union published a list of personal persons subject to sanctions, citizens of the russian federation , the mayor of moscow, serhiy sablianin, was sanctioned also russian actors serhii bezrukov, do you remember the brigade, the film volodymyr mashkov, the host of the putin rally, the eu sanctions list includes the son of the head of rostec, serhiy chemezhov, stanislav , the vice-premier, andriy bilousov, the leader of the biker movement, the night wolves, oleksandr zal dostanov, the deputy representative of the president of russia to the north caucasian district, yuriy chayka, the former prosecutor general of russia, also on the list, the governor of the kemerovo region, serhii

tsiviliev, the kemerovo deputy of romanov, the son of oleksandr, who bought himself a business mcdonald's in russia state duma deputy adam delimkhanov, the sanctions have affected the employees of the security forces, this is the first deputy director of the fsb of russia, serhiy korolev, the first deputy director of the federal service of the national guard, the commander-in-chief of the national guard viktor strigunov, and then there are also various russian entrepreneurs and businessmen, and also under sanctions russian collection bank hit well, so far gazprombank has not been sanctioned, the main bank through which overpayments for russian gas are made and various hydrocarbons mr. volodymyr, i didn’t even want to ask you about the sanction about today’s meeting in istanbul at 4:30 p.m. there they have to sign a certain document, a certain agreement on the unblocking of ukrainian ports and on the export of ukrainian grain. we don’t even know who is part of the ukrainian delegation

officially - it’s not who will sign this document and its details are also being disclosed . as a resident of odesa, you do not fear for the fate of your hometown as a result of signing such agreements and unblock ukrainian ports, please, what is the fate of the city? i think that i am not afraid because, after all, we have already learned to hold a blow to a certain extent and we understand the situation in the region, we understand the limited capabilities of the russian navy in terms of striking or carrying out amphibious assaults of operations against odesa, it is very limited, these are the possibilities for russia now, and we have weapons accordingly, we understand this actually, the fact that a few days ago we learned that russia is transferring even part of its forces to naval sevastopol away from novorossiysk, this already says a lot, but as for this agreement, we really need to see if it will be signed. what is written in it, as the

americans often say, the devil is in the details, that is, we need to separate ourselves more carefully, who, what, and how i personally remain a pessimist from the point of view that this issue will be resolved, that this problem will be resolved. i think it will rather hang because i actually did not see a great interest on the part of russia in unlocking the ukrainian coast in of the ukrainian ports of the black sea, this is a very important factor influencing the ukrainian economy, ah, well , drawing attention or focusing attention on the problem, as russia says that it is because of sanctions, so there is a shrivanka, or someone will not receive, accordingly , food products and so on. and therefore it is too much it is important, so important for russia to put pressure on ukraine and the world and so on. they will not think that even putin's efforts to get rid of him will put himself in such a better, positive

light to see. i am trying to solve this issue you asked me to sign such an agreement, i do not think that it will prevail, but we will look at the agreement and really, what is written there, who is responsible for what, what verification mechanism, security measures , and turkey will also do what will be the turkish military ships, where will they will stand , what will they do, where else will it be located in the russian warship, we don't know yet, so we don't really evaluate this agreement until we look at at least some text, it will be a little bit, well, it's too early, well, but by the troops of the so-called guards are definitely already under sanctions. it turns out that six months after the start of the war, as of the day before yesterday, they could freely travel there in the eu, go for a walk there, drink beer , return to moscow. i am asking the mayor of moscow to be among the

absolutely agree. i think that many such people should have been under sanctions not long ago, there is no doubt about it. therefore, this is some kind of oversight, i do not know what it is. you are not the competence of the relevant bodies of the european union, but i personally do not really believe in personal sanctions, mainly the majority of experts who analyze the sanctions against russia believe that only systemic sanctions against specific sectors of large banks, enterprises and russian industry. they have some effect, but directly some people and some accounts . it is clear that it will not happen or suddenly we need to really go to the european union, i don't think that's why i'm so declarative . has a strong influence on russian behavior, it is necessary to understand that no, thank you andriy smoliy, your reaction is yes to the grain agreement, i would like to

add briefly, oh look, in fact, we can already state that russia already has a certain path from this possible grain agreement why because we we can already state that certain certain sanctions have been eased. yes, we are already seeing something, well , there are also certain statements from the european union. i understand that this is happening within the framework of the actual agreements behind the scenes regarding this grain agreement , in fact, it is really so hidden. so all this is not public, we really, as you rightly pointed out, do not have information about who is actually included on the ukrainian side in this negotiating group. the second question, we can clearly state now that there are probably certain , including behind-the-scenes to the youth, regarding these issues

, including outside ukraine is participating here, and the united nations is also participating in turkey. the question is that russia . two data. as far as i understand, today at 4:30 p.m. this agreement can be signed, that is, i understand that practically it is not that it is already at the final stage, it is already, well, almost signed , so in this case, i think that it will be signed after all but then we must also be aware that the occupiers can at any moment disrupt the signing, well, disrupt. i mean , the implementation of this agreement does not prevent anything, for example, eh, they should do the same thing as they did on february 24, that is, any moment

if they don't like something at any moment when it will be necessary to exert further pressure and demand the relaxation of certain sanctions or certain relaxations on the part of ukraine, they can again block exports, commit some kind of provocation, shell the waters of the black sea , vessels will pass there for that is, we have here, on the one hand, i agree with my colleague that it is absolutely unprofitable for russia to have ukrainian exports, on the other hand, i understand that now russia is trying to play a double game, on the one hand, to weaken the sanctions or, in the end, to stop, so to speak, the intensity of the imposition of sanctions, and on the other hand, they will continue to blackmail and

can at any moment, er, do everything to stop ukrainian exports, er, with russia, trust russia even with the signing of any agreements, i would not believe it, because many things have already been signed with them, many things have been agreed upon with them, not only now, but in principle for tens of tens of years, russia has never fulfilled those obligations what are they? she took it upon herself, please . thank you, political expert, candidate of legal sciences, and volodymyr dubovyk, director of the center for international studies of odesa national university. gentlemen, thank you for the meaningful discussion and let's move on. mykola malomuzh is already with us, general of the army of ukraine, head of the foreign intelligence service since 2005. to 2010 and the 10th year, mr. mykola, we congratulate you, congratulations, glory to ukraine, glory to the heroes, general, let's try to play what

rammstein brought us 4 this was the fourth meeting in the format representatives of the defense departments of the leading countries and partners, but it was held under the seal of secrecy and there is very little information. what do you know what weapons ukraine will receive in the end? first of all, it must be said that rammstein was precisely of strategic importance because russia and all the opportunities it has to reduce the price of active support especially in the armed format, ammunition, missile systems in ukraine, and that is why you hoped for germany, france, for example, italy, many other participating countries, more than 50 countries that today are members of the civil group, but the clear position that was expressed especially in the speech of the head of the pentagon clearly defined that there will be no relaxations, this is the key phrase from the other side, all the programs that are defined and legally

and accordingly, the abandoned part, they will continue until the complete victory is the strategic position of the rorozhdan group of leaders of these countries. this is extremely important, something that the russian federation did not expect. in fact, the most important thing is that today we are not talking about supply only units, for example, missile equipment, a weapon unit, for example, there were four, five, that there were commerce or, for example, other systems of howitzers, for example , 155-caliber. and what is the transfer of systems to us, for example , air defense ? and this is precisely a complex system that provides early detection of descents or the ascent of enemy planes and, of course, their downing on the flight path, here is also the same system. for example , cameras, we are really talking about what is already in operation for example, not only 12, but six more

will be delivered, 2 more will be delivered later, a similar system will be delivered to britain in addition, and it can already be 20 or more, but just this is more, it is absolutely a part so that russia can adjust its capabilities in various ways in directions both in the east, in the donetsk direction , and in the south, where we foresee the release in the nearest possible periods, the second part is a radio-electronic system - it is a closed secret weapon, actually, it is not in a combat format, it can strike me, but it can also control these regions of hostilities or even part of the russian territory, on the other hand, neutralize missile guidance systems , for example, aviation of other means against ukraine, but this is precisely the important part that today, already at the beginning of the day, the defense system about which we ambiguously always said that the sky is closed, these systems will already be american, the only thing is that

deliveries are not foreseen here either. i think that in the course of 2-3 months they should be some of the closest week, on the other hand, all the other participating countries, including britain and germany, even joined in and announced that they are leaving the iris in the anti-annual defense system by the end of summer, which is better to directly assert as a priest in a global format than an iron dome, an iron cup, a reliable sector and that is to say, israel compared a small sector, and the u.s. means british - this is a whole complex system of protection of the state of ukraine and large, powerful industrial centers and large cities of ukraine, this is what today gives advantages and the most important thing - on the battlefield - this is a missile system - this is according to this - these are self-propelled e-e installations, both missile and artillery, which hit from 40 to 80 km . was up to 300 km, if we are talking about the

analogues from britain, and then, accordingly , russia’s advantage will be practically completely surprised, because warehouses and logistics, respectively, and all systems, for example, for the sake of hurricanes of death, which they launch today along the entire perimeter of that er lines demarcation and but also the old story in kharkiv and donetsk region and zaporizhzhia, for example, the dnipro alone. and even if they reach other systems, they will be devalued, because these systems are relentless, they will destroy them at such distances that they do not reach our cities and villages. well, and it is clear that the armed forces of ukraine have changed their minds not only about effective defense, but also about all the prerequisites for offensive times, and i will also say under water or the outcome of this very meeting, as well as our analysts and our intelligence and exactly the same as foreign countries confirm that the period of decisive events in rio is coming, it is just possible that there will be drastic changes in the layout of the military provincial of russia and ukraine, and

it is very possible that just the przemyśl group for two months in a month and a half, all the means and our already trained military personnel will be involved in this work, and it is clear that everything effective tactical strategic offensive operations have already begun, especially on the rooster, this will create the prerequisites, respectively, for the victory and blowing out of the enemy and zaporizhzhia in the kherson region . and if panic sets in, accordingly the prospect will also be in the east of the donetsk luhansk region, this is precisely the format that is not only declared as the supply of system armament of equipment and support by other means, this is precisely the turning point that is imagined by the provider for ukraine and for our partners, which represents the creation of mykola i to another topic i would like to go to the grain of the unblocking of turkey's ports and i will quote it, i don't often quote it, but i will quote oleg lyashko wrote when turkey buys goods from russia for 30 billion by 45%, increasing the purchase of oil and

gas during the war is the same as financing the aggression of the kremlin against ukraine and like any other country for which bloody russian money is more important by the nature of ukrainian blood, when turkey switches to mutual payment for russian energy carriers in rubles and liras, it is help for the kremlin to avoid sanctions that we we hope so, that's why we don't need to deceive ourselves and call turkey a friend , because of ukraine, only because we were sold a few dozen berektars, erdoğan pursues exclusively his own interests and helps himself at the expense of of ukraine, as well as in the export of grain, for which ukraine turkey expects to receive a big discount today at 4:30 p.m. the signing of an agreement in istanbul on unblocking ports and on the export of ukrainian grain is announced, everything is kept secret, we do not even know the composition of the negotiating group, who will sign you as a scout to of this story with the unblocking of ports, how should we treat or should

we sign similar agreements? and if so, what should all the agreements be written down, who should be the guarantor, i am asking for it for today. yes, really for us the big problem with agribusiness business is , respectively. export of grain is an important component of export for us, that is, obtaining and currency, respectively, and selling these products. but yes, really, in order to unblock the supply of grain to international markets, but accordingly, it should not be a monopoly of turkey, for example, all the more so powerful participation and the secret of the russian federation, we do not know to the end what was discussed in tagheran . russia's turkey, when i met servagan, uh, there eight years ago, he spoke clearly when he convinced her. why are you shutting down a lot of gas projects, for example, a nuclear power plant, others on the

russian federation ? you won't get anywhere, that's how it turned out, that is, they are tying up the russian, so to speak, segments of the energy and technological sectors, for example, you even have a recreation base, just as russia gives 5 million, so to speak given the situation, turkey is playing in all directions , even with nato. it conducts itself, especially so often against nato policy, here is precisely the position of the authoritarian regime . in all elections and from russia and from ukraine and from the west and from the third countries of the world, how did he unblock the grains, as if he conducts a noble commission together with the un, respectively, but they receive powerful intermediary financial resources acquire accordingly, the authority in this region as a coordinator and the like, why at the moment i am

in favor of how did you once escort the ships of the latin gulf when in fact the representatives of the nato countries provide just in the first time the entire model was worked out full control and ports of the escort of ships but no turkey and not russia, by the way, could only be a participant in precisely this accompaniment, but independent and powerful participating countries that provide full control over the passage of stay in the ports of all, respectively of ships, as in ours, for example, in the turkish one , that is, it ensures security. why? because, along with that, russia overcame a number of issues there related to the easing of sanctions, it is possible to supply sozana, which itself supplies up to 40 million tons and more per year, and it also needs to be unblocked what kind of language does she put to unblock russian grain? and against the background of the fact that there may be a famine, everyone supports this very project , so in this situation, i thought that we did not finalize the model than any, first of all, the agreement on unblocking just uh, and the actions of the russian federation

and the main thing is to ensure security, because on the one hand, yes, the previous speakers are really discussing, all the rules can be violated at any time in russia, they are not bound by anything, and the most important thing is where we clear mines, where we accordingly ensure just uh, debilitated zones in russia for some time, it can disrupt precisely the regimes of the passage of grain and strike at these systems, which we actually do not have today. it makes a lot of sense because it can be in the process of offensive operations that an additional zone of security and danger on the part of the russian federation that it can start amphibious operations storms landing strikes accordingly and in the direction of odesa and in other regions therefore between no format according to the student just and powerful countries -participants who provide the whole process and not just there, there is a check here in turkey at the ports and

everything. and then the control of the russian federation, that's right . this approach is wrong on our part. i think that the participants are, in principle, they were to analyze the surname, but these are representatives of the cabinet of ministers or agricultural policy, for example, the ministry of foreign affairs , according to our law enforcement agencies, they conduct this work, but i think that the starting format today is not powerful for ukraine, to some extent there are risks, and on the other hand, russia will receive dividends today, we see not only grain. you see how it is, literally, we have repeatedly spoken to americans of crucian carp in european why don’t you block even then, for example, the supply of titanium fell before the war, now during the war they removed it because this is god, this is logic, this is, accordingly, all the missile and ship systems of france, germany, and they literally lifted the sanctions on strategic raw materials with the russian federation, which will try to bring 40-60% with the

russian federation to these countries. the sector, i will simply say , was partially unblocked by the european union, especially before the winter, this is a repeated discussion with them on this issue, they take a position first, sanctions, we restrictions, and then, accordingly, go to the concessions of the russian federation, the scandal of tonight actually yes what at the last moment of the last, this is the seventh package of sanctions or the sixth of the european union, the russian titan was struck out , as if at the request of the company's management, not even a battleship in my opinion, but also airblass, well, it's no no no no not very important but you know what the argument was, the novel was such that there is only 154 millions of euros per year for that titan, we will not be able to do bad things to russia with this amount of money, but for the european economy we will be able to do it is bad, so it is better for the russians to allow this titan to be

exported to the european union, now the situation of the militarist company and the lock and other strategic companies that produce missiles and submarines, but in the same way russia will get a perspective for the development of this industry why because the width comes from different ends, including from ukraine according to the crimean titan, that is, it goes from remote territories there, the raw materials are processed there and ready and where, according to the strategic so to speak ports of the participating countries, and russia itself uses its quote for missiles for caliber for powerful anti-air defense systems for submarines that are in the black sea for renewal today already missiles that are really hitting ukraine, but they can’t get any components, but the titanium industry imagines the basic ones for production. where is the answer to the formation of

just combat units that is, this is a very sensitive issue , and here the issue is not even about money, but about how efficiently this industry will work, and on the other hand , the main violation of sanctions is a powerful chain that should block everything, and here they are already on real concessions because it is the advantage of one's own interests. especially in aviation, i see companies not only in france, but only france was an external zone, as we are talking about dozens of companies including american, canadian and european interested in this project. from the front line, the russians shelled the dnipropetrovsk region tonight on a large scale, they covered three districts with fire, there are dead, injured, destroyed infrastructure and district ot throughout the dnipropetrovsk region, nikopolskyi sinelnikovsky kryvorizky, that is, the south of the region, the east of the region, the west of the region. what do you think is the purpose of such shelling, or is there an intention to make

an operational advance deep into the dnipropetrovsk region of the dnipropetrovsk region? i ask for the first priority. dnipropetrovsk region, that is, there is a format of diverting our attention to other regions, which today , so to speak, are in direct conflict, for example, donetsk, luhansk, zaporizhzhia, kherson region - this processing is where today in another region, he has already extended this option for several weeks in order for us to keep anti-air defense and anti-missile defense systems there, because they are approaching us, respectively, contingents of troops, the idea is that on the one hand, uh, to keep us in belarus direction in the southern direction and, accordingly, continue fighting in the donetsk direction , already attack there, for example, siverskyi bakhmut. today, its cities are slavic and kramatorsk, and

on the other hand, it will not allow offensive operations in the south, it is assumed that we have thrown all the means even of the dnipro region. here it is literally far away to the kherson region, we accordingly created the conditions for the concentration of powerful missile systems , artillery equipment, military contingents of tanks, for the liberation of, for example, the kherson region in this situation. regions, especially now dnipropetrovsk region , because i think where they will shoot from, on the other hand , they anticipate that there will also be production of our of new weapons technology, the logistics are sent there, as if from abroad, which is far from the case, today we will not say where it is located, how, but accordingly, someone gives information about such possibilities and the placement of our defense unit there, so they drink and strike from another side, why is this terror not only from

dnipropetrovsk region? today we are talking about these big strikes. thank you. or to all regions in order to force the population. the people of ukraine were scared for several days in a row , thousands of people are calling me, even i will say that a powerful attack on kyiv on all regions of ukraine. i said that he and putin listened to him somewhere, but also through various information channels and even unofficial channels. there will be a powerful offensive, there will be a powerful shelling of everyone, people are beginning to be born to some extent, even some are leaving even from kyiv, this is exactly the sign of a psychological war, so they must be reinforced by something so that there are blows there were victims, it was possible fear and panic in order to force us to negotiate, that's all i'm running out of, they wanted to declare now to freeze the conditions that they are declaring today and putin and lavrov and piskov others - understood that