understanding what happened and why exactly the benedictine dictator, for example, why exactly did they fire the dictator, who reacted quite violently immediately to her resignation. that is, she even suspended her for the resignation of the suspension, she did not recognize her because it was done in violation of the current legislation of the constitution on this all the lawyers spoke, then finally on monday a corresponding application for dismissal was submitted in a non- dictated manner, she came and reported on her work and there was a vote on why exactly she was dismissed, well, on the sidelines of the verkhovna rada version a lot, but given the fact that we have a situation where almost the entire law enforcement system is under the leadership or supervision of one person, it is

quite dangerous for our state, because in this way we lose the balance of the branches of government and, accordingly, we lose the quality, including the activities of the general the prosecutor's office, which with a new head can turn into a controlled toolkit not so much in order to deal with the rule of law as in order to deal with persecution by the opposition well, mr. kraev, finalizing this topic after all, the question of our homework is how fundamentally important it remains in our cooperation with the united states, and in the first lines there is always a demand for us to appoint the head of the sap, and ultimately hold a competition it's on the head of nabu and it's not for nothing that all this is happening. but at the same time, we are now watching the appearance of new sticks in the

wheels with this process, well, seriously, let's imagine a tatar person who is de facto now will manage the general prosecutor's office will sign the importance of the head of the sap who led that as a detective i will have a case against tatarov well, honestly, it is difficult for me to imagine and it will be a miracle if it happens nevertheless, uh, do you have any understanding of how the united states is currently watching and react to what is happening in our anti-corruption law enforcement agencies. you know, the position here is in many ways similar to how they see the events and the situation in the office of the president of ukraine, let's remember with you how we had a situation with the ambassador of the united states in ukraine in principle, they will explain to us the american point of view on these issues, who is the ambassador of the united states, apart from the fact that he is generally the leader of the diplomatic corps of western countries in kyiv, he is primarily a personal contact center between the two presidents. he is the

most trusted person who should work with the white house staff from the administration or now the office of the president of ukraine should know everyone who should be known by everyone who can be trusted who can trust these people himself and now we have, relatively speaking, yarmak since the 19th year and already at that moment americans, well, on an unofficial level, american experts said so, guys, how can we appoint an ambassador if we are not clear about who makes which decision? how do we know it is proposed by the president, it is proposed by his adviser and this is an unofficial proposal or is it yermak’s operation at all and this is his proposal everything is the proposal of the ministry of foreign affairs that’s what it says well from whom how but can we trust these official positions and to understand that it is really from this person because it is

what they called an unofficial hierarchy, he did not say that this is the biggest problem of the ukrainian system of power, power means both the executive and the legislative. unfortunately for the judiciary , the official hierarchy in our case has become the key sin that did not allow any reforms to progress in many ways, well, remember at least the situation of the president, remember the situation with the constitutional court, all this just shows this official hierarchy and when they tell us about sap about nabu, this is precisely in their vision, these are the best tools for controlling this hierarchy, because in essence these internal relationships, these unofficial contacts are based on what americans consider corruption, corruption is not necessarily a big package with a big wad of money , corruption is also making decisions in accordance with one's own or group interests and not state corruption - this is turning a blind eye to what you consider more profitable for yourself and not for the state, that is, and that is why the americans insist on this and that is why

the americans are very surprised that the team is quite patriotic, which literally works with its people for 5 months in the conditions of a full-scale war and does not want to do the most patriotic thing. thank you. thank you . dear viewers, live broadcast of the espresso channel in the midst of analyzing the most important 14:00 - 35 minutes sunday, july 24 khrystyna yatskiv all months of the large-scale invasion of the russian the federation has a lot of events, a lot of points that are worthy of our attention, let's outline it now, it's the economy, contact us igor chalenko, political and economic expert igor, we congratulate you glory to ukraine glory to the heroes i congratulate you well, let's calculate what we came up with by the

sixth month of the large-scale invasion, well , we have at least six and a plus. against russia, this is somehow by the way, it sounds hyperbolized, we also have a whole pool of our internal economic problems and decisions that were adopted by no one to solve these uh-uh problems , and we also have very unpleasant numbers in the exchange offices and the understanding that our national currency really devalued gasoline from appeared well, thank god there is gasoline, people drive, well, this is a question , the situation in shops has changed, well, at least in peaceful areas, relatively peaceful areas. that is, well , there is some process, something is moving, but you know, in broad, beautiful strokes, outline igor

situation well, in fact, these broad masks are quite painful for ukrainian society because, uh, you just mentioned the same course, uh, or uh, i can remember the discount rate, which was taken up to 25%. and the biggest problem of both business and ukrainian society is that all this was done without warning, suddenly, like a thunderbolt in the middle of a clear sky. attention that in two days they started spreading the rumor in the e-e means of the mass media information and even had to refute and say that there will be absolutely no changes in the exchange rate without any silence, and here at

9:53 there. on a separate day, but this is about such nuances. but if we talk about the economy in general, not even the rate, not even the fact that there is fuel, there is no fuel, the problem with the availability of work is our biggest problem, because according to the methodology of the international labor organization, we lost more than 5 million jobs, of course, ukrainians, millions of ukrainians left and today they are actually subsidizing the countries of the european union with their labor resources, because we already see live people getting work permits and even low-skilled people are starting to do some work, but they are not actually working directly for the economy of ukraine, although indirectly, there is still a certain plus, and i will talk about it later. but nevertheless , this very problem is a crisis in the

labor market today, and it creates the biggest problems for social workers today it limits the opportunities for business to develop because, again, if you want to develop, you have to find a highly qualified worker somewhere, the worker is not there . months, is there a stabilization of the attack, is the attack active, and then, accordingly , physically and assets are destroyed, and well, in general, any business. pay attention to what is happening . for example, in kharkiv, the famous barabashov market is one of the largest, it seems even most of all in europe, those who worked there wanted to resume their work. accordingly , they had already gathered, as if they were discussing how to get out of this crisis, to start work, but bach, the russian federation took fire on that very day near the barabashovo market, there were two dozen

the corresponding injured, several deaths, and business cannot in any way today predict how to live on, that is, this one will not be enough , that is, the impression is that the russian interventionists are deliberately working even purely in economic objects that is, they are deliberately trying to destroy our economy in order to cause a certain social collapse. you very correctly, mr. igor, noted the barabashova market. so on, it all affects individual regions, i absolutely agree with you, and another option is what we see now with these istanbul initiatives, the so-called agreements, only russia has put its signature and in the form of the minister that his and the

next day bach the attack on odesa is of course the russian federation says that there are no problems attacked but now the question arises and which insurance companies today will allow ships to enter the same port of odesa in order to to transport this is already ukrainian grain, which carriers today will send their ships there, that is, we can see that in all directions where possible today, the russian federation is completely disrupting our economic activity. please also pay attention for example, for energy. and what is happening now at the zaporizhia npp. we can all clearly see that the biggest problem is that today the occupier is trying to disconnect it from the unified energy system of ukraine. accordingly, we cannot guarantee, for example, the further export there of what we sell there on the market of the european union,

which we joined literally in february and actually started commercial exports. during the last month, there is also the question of the situation with belarus. and as one of the options, what will enter, one of their goals is the rivne npp, that is, again, risks and what kind of business you won't go into today. there are questions everywhere, let's go down there, we'll go to our people, we'll go to the socialists. likewise, today, people who have already lost their jobs, we see that there are many they cannot find this job. and even the social assistance that should arrive on time is very often delayed. and an example is the same six and a half thousand hryvnias. where the verkhovna rada had to make changes to of the state budget for this year in order to close all the applications that were submitted at the end of march, they were closed at the end of may, uh, and those were big

problems, that is, they sent more than 30 billion hryvnias, i could be wrong and what is happening now in fact, our social standards have all remained at the same level, ah, well, the only thing is that the subsistence minimum has risen a little since the first of july there by 6%, but this in no way, as we can see, has blocked the de-innovative infectious processes, and accordingly, people see the prices of such shops that their life is starting to get really worse today, this indicates that, of course, the financial and economic bloc of the government is trying to do something, but due to certain structural errors that occur, again, due to the fact that their policy today is not predictable due to the fact that there is no understanding will the government continue to promote the same devaluation of the hryvnia or not because we perfectly understand the government even today you want to say

that the situation with our economic condition could be more predictable maybe a little more softer, if the government resorted to rational and adequate solutions, and not only the government, we do not see today the normal connection of the work of the nbu, the government of the nbu is doing its thing, it is completely fixated on the topic of reducing inflation today, the government, on the contrary , says that it is necessary throw the economy with money , lots and lots of money, that is, we see that these are diametrically opposed concepts of how to get out of the crisis, and in connection with this, today we really have a little bit of a swan cancer and a pike , so i would honestly like to in the following months we saw greater coordination of the authorities, this is really lacking today, because i think it is possible that our external

partners would have given us more money than they promised if they had seen the appropriate signals, because for now, but waiting for the signals, we should give to the west ms. igor, yes, we understand, well, there was a conference that was full in lugano, yes, they gave some projects there, so we already planned our future there after we beat russia, but now you are talking about the short-term perspective, it is really obvious that first of all, of course, there should be political signals, and despite the fact that we still have mr. klymenko , the competition commission said that he is the winner for the head of sap, but we see that they immediately went to check his e- on the existence of corruption risks there, and again, we do not have the same prosecutor general now, that is, already

today, there are two degrees that separate the same klymenko from his position -e for the head of the garden, there is no competition for the head of the house, the same situation today, we see that it is unclear the reaction regarding the termination of ukrainian citizenship, a number of other political questions are being addressed to the authorities today, of course , from an economic point of view. of the action plan of this road map, because everyone gives money to cover the budget deficit, but again, how rationally is this budget used? of the fund, but if you look further at the expenses, you

know that interesting things appear on the one hand , that means, for example, naftogaz wants uah 150 billion to compensate for the issue of gas for heating and right away he buys some incomprehensible armored vehicles for a million euros absolutely no one needs eh and also there to take further what purchases are taking place there in the state structure of course everyone sees it and this is the whole situation today absolutely it eh well let's say it deprives us of the chances to get it for this one thank you mr. igor for this analysis. well, the key point is that our western donors still help us. despite all this, igor chalenko worked live on the air of the information and analytical marathon of the espresso tv channel. for that, we are sincerely grateful to him. ah, very soon we will have a

guest in connection with the studio. for now, i will take the opportunity to quote bridget brink and remind you that she is the us ambassador to ukraine regarding the declaration of russia as a state sponsor of terrorism, we are considering this issue it needs careful analysis in accordance with american laws, we use all available means, including many that would be used for a country that is such a sponsor, that is, in the united states, most likely , the relevant processes have been launched. well, we will wait for them to accelerate . volodymyrets glory to the heroes well, what has happened , the domestic ukrainian political cycle is unfolding, it all started with the resignation of venediktova bakanova, now the case of korban has joined

, there is a feeling that something is so powerful in us is happening and soon something will happen, share your inner political intuition in this direction and explain what kind of processes started, well, look back in april when , er, only the first drafts of victory and well, in principle, this is the feeling of victory from the enemy driven away from kyiv at the bank, they already tried to convert it into some uh, well, some new additional political dividends right now, when uh, in fact, uh, such an international uh, coalition of support for ukraine has been formed by more than 40 countries, and this uh, total solidarity with ukraine is uh-uh gives hope for a normal military success in liberating the territory and the political forces are already feeling this kind of under-the

-carpet, silent game. the pre-election is already aimed at the elections, and we roughly imagine the main players in these elections, the main public executions that will be. well, let's say so to fight for its presentability well, we can say that strange processes are taking place in the ruling party itself, also related to the preparation for the elections, because the removal of, for example, tyshchenko from the leadership of the transcarpathian organization, further eh scandals with kovalev's treason, which were apparently arrested by this personnel replacement of the tyshchenko, that is, a lot of preparatory processes are taking place, uh, this is more.

well, for the average person, for an unprepared person, it is not perceived as preparation for the elections, but in principle, the professional environment understands this very clearly, it all started, of course, with displacement from the media space three channels, including yours well , if we talk about the terms when you can roughly wait for the elections after the end of the war, so to speak, as far as i understand after our victory, on the other hand, we understand that now one or another election format would be extremely beneficial for the government and we see how they have created their information agenda. so we understand that, for example, the rating of the arrestee now exceeds the ratings of leading ukrainian professional politicians and so on. in some generally incomprehensible phase. well, there is also prytula. the dropped ace in the e-e sleeve of the bank and there are still characters, but

the essence is different e-e. at first it is such a unification and redistribution of the media space, and then we wait for more and intrusion into the legislative field because, as far as i remember, in order to blackmail the parliamentary groups and make them more favorable to the bank, and the election code was introduced on january 1, 2022 , i.e. e election code that provides for e-e regional lists of 26 regional lists kyiv is divided into two territories of dnipropetrovsk region into two territories into two electoral districts crimea is attached to e-e kherson tauri electoral district well, but now in fact it is worth to wait, that is, as soon as intentions to

revise the electoral legislation appear, we can say that the process has started, because it is obvious that we will have to settle with the majoritarians by returning to the majoritarians to the mixed system. this is the first. and the second , then we have a very cunning scheme, and the shortage of the parliament will be less somewhere 400 deputies because it is impossible in luhansk region and it will not be possible in part of donetsk region. well, everything will depend on how the war ends, because if the government declares a return to the borders of the country by february 24 of the current year, it can be said that part of the territory is unlikely to be transferred before the elections, and here there is another important point, special blitz elections can only be held until the end of october of the current year, when there is less

than a year left before the current elections, special elections are not are being held, well, let me remind you that in the 19th year, zelensky pushed for such special elections, and then you were frightened, the constitutional court of course recognized these actions as constitutional, but it is unlikely that it will be possible to reverse it now. well, all the more so, judging by the fact that the er cycle of er supply of weapons has been established, it is likely that hostilities will continue next year, mr. volodymyr, the story with the er attempt to clean up the gas to eve stables, yes, we are talking about the ukrainian special services, i don’t know why you considered it, but yes or otherwise, the 17-page notice of suspicion, which can be read on the dbr website, says that the ukrainian security forces, ix vice prime minister volodymyr sivkovich and the now former head of the main

directorate of the security service of ukraine oleg kulinich, who are suspected of cooperating with the fsb, tried to influence the leading and middle echelons of the security services of ukraine hid evidence of russian preparations for the invasion of mainland ukraine from the crimean peninsula. and what do you think this is, is it really an attempt to clean up, well, at least at a certain level, the ukrainian special services? is this, well, i don’t know, an attempt to emphasize that what was happening in the sbu under bakanov, it was not okay, well, first of all, the real number for the cleaning of the special services should be reduced to the reform of the sbu in general, the replacement, so to speak, of the whore , or the rearrangement of the visa seats is not necessary yes, you understand, but it doesn't change anything, the most important thing is that the signature under the decrees on the appointment

of general naumov's linemen is not approved by bakanova, but personally by zelensky, so it looks like an attempt to find snipers a little, well, shift the responsibility ... eh from the banking company that formed all this personnel potential eh personally well, somewhere locally to the special service, well, it hardly changes eh at all because persecuting the representatives of the yanukovych government eh and releasing the portman is eh well, it looks like an uncoordinated action, but it is very, very coordinated. there are no accidents in zelenskyi , so we should not be happy that this is not a professional government, this is a government that understands where it is going. well,

let's put it this way . did she understand what goals she promised to achieve, well, to certain certain external players? well, the resilience of ukrainians and the readiness to defend every valve of their land with weapons on er, well , destroyed these plans, that's another question. only he was not lazy and did not talk about the decree, which formally does not exist, that is, the existence of this decree is not confirmed in official sources, but korban in fact never stopped by and there are no official comments at least, well, that is, if there is no decree and it happens, er, sorry, some very strange story , officials they have to comment on it, refute it , in which case it is true, well, it is true, well, it is possible that it will turn out later that at the bank, they did not advise, the official

confused gennady korban with viktor orban, and that is why all these maneuvers are more likely to be called let's say to remove korban and kolomoisky from the list of oligarchs so that they would not have such discomfort in relations with the ukrainian state, but their assets are not threatened. such an anti-oligarchic action. imagine what veres would do on channel 1+1 after the deprivation of kolomoisky's citizenship. did you hear any hysterics? well, my eyes, we don't watch this

beautiful tv channel. well, acquaintances distant relatives and the like, i can tell you that there is not a single wave of discontent and not a single note, er, high note, er, so to speak , mouse sand from channel 1+1 eloquent, that is, if it is possible to do it in this way, then maybe some lists will be added well, i think that everyone who does not want to appear on the list of oligarchs in order to have a certain, well, additional, uh, additional devices so that the representatives of the special service, so to speak , the members of the list, uh, for it is not a sin to pay in order to get under sanctions. after all, people from

with a fortune of more than 10 million dollars, they, as a rule , have not only wealth, but also additional citizenships. whom you do not strengthen, you will definitely scratch off a citizen, both in cyprus and israel, then they spread something. let's solve something with their ukrainian citizenship. we lack fundamentally important things in the legislative base. i don't i understand what you can rely on when it comes to depriving a ukrainian, regardless of whether you like him or not, because i said to ben-gurion at the dawn of the israeli state, i do not want to create a state righteous people of some superclass people and no, it should be a state where there will be righteous people, criminals, prostitutes, and so on, but they will all be united, that is, national law and the constitution go like this. well, that's why we understand citizenship, we live, we'll see, there is a ukrainian constitution. and accordingly there is an answer