from the 16th to the 19th year, the diplomat of the policy of the servicemen of the armed forces of ukraine is volodymyr. thank you. i will only allow myself to say that it seems to me that on the one hand i absolutely agree with you that well, academic time is not on time, but on the other hand, it will be somewhere behind the scenes, maybe academic , maybe journalistic discuss the model model well, i don't forbid you, because we are realists . language policy in the end i don't know there humanitarian policy museum policy we have something to do everywhere and then through these discussions through television through some academic meetings we can in a year or two come to something understood not only by politicians and society and society will be down look, before the creation of all this,

i talked about something, almost as smart no, not as safe as portnikov was just talking about, but i hope that there is political science and international this is vera kostiantynivna kostiantynovich, who is not there yet, and this subtly hints that we can continue here to talk about interesting topics. that is, i can't. this is the most important thing. i think that this is the problem of all presidents without exception. what is what i always expected? what is the problem today? there is a problem . and somewhere the government does the president gather experts and they sit and discuss and short-term something or long-term medium-term what are we doing today what is absolutely necessary what tomorrow what in a year what in two and eventually the picture of the world people really like to look ahead to the picture where it is clear how

they pay taxes like their children, the children pay on which roads and why they can drive at this speed but not at that speed and so on and does the roadside cafe have a toilet or not and what gas stations and where is the electricity well, in short, this is all and then people will understand what do they go to work, what do they have, what will they leave to their children? is such a country or such a country or such a country with such taxes or s- with such a price for cabbage possible? yes, we understand that the market will not implement the price for cabbage political scientist i'm an international woman and i'm still not used to feminists. i'm sorry, but i'll try to behave responsibly. good health. thank you for finding a time for us on friday evening, mrs. vera. well, we have a wide range of questions. and 10 minutes

of this time, so not everything will work out correct. i understand that today putin and erdogan are deciding the fate of armenia and syria, plus ukraine and ukraine are interesting. maybe in putin, i am not convinced that i will find out anything interesting besides the ukrainian grain. well, i would say that i will find out a lot of interesting things, and considering that regional ambitions it seems to me that right now there is a unique chance for the turkish side to achieve some foreign policy goals. at the same time, i really saw information about the situation in the south caucasus, and also the fact that there are contacts between the three parties, this makes me

think that now, feeling the criticality of the moment, the turkish side is also trying to strengthen its position in the mountainous karabakh, rather in the settlement of this situation. and the fact that the contacts are going not only at the level of the leaders. by the way, the contacts are with the system at the level of, for example, the ministers of defense of the countries, and there are constant contacts. i think through diplomatic channels, at the same time, it is an interesting point that now a new one, as you know, was submitted a few days ago. the statement of the ministry of defense of azerbaijan regarding the operation that they conducted in the area of ​​responsibility, so to speak, of the russian peacekeeping forces, that's why it seems to me

. the south caucasus in connection with the fact that the russian situation is a threat in the war in ukraine and politically there are processes and the weakening of the influence of the russian federation on certain regions ms. vera, look, there are such rumors because we do not know because and mr. rodogan mr. putin they such people who do not like to do something so public, but there are rumors that putin will persuade erdoğan that verdigan put pressure on zelenskyi so that zelenskyi would agree to negotiations, the war would be over temporarily, because putin feels that he donkey - he will weaken every day and he needs a break putin needs a break do you believe in such and such a theory well, you know, i have heard about this, er, this position is not the first time, and

the russians are quite actively promoting this position. well, there are anonymous telegram channels regarding the fact that now at this moment it is necessary to enter negotiations and try to bring the two sides to the negotiating table, at the same time , the ukrainian side, in my opinion, very clearly articulates that negotiations will be possible only after the military defeat of russia is achieved federation here in ukraine and the restoration of our territorial integrity and sovereignty over the entire territory of ukraine in accordance with the internationally recognized borders, at the same time from the point of view of practical diplomacy. of the active phase of the war because it is not a question of the interests of ukraine exclusively or of the interests of russia, it is a question of regional stability - it

issues of regional security, including us, we understand that now any security architecture where the russian federation is present is a priori inefficient, and therefore it is now possible as an option to talk about what turkey as a regional as a possible regional leader can provide , including er, the stability of the security architecture in the black sea region, however, it seems to me that it is incorrect to speak about the fact that someone can force the ukrainian side to do something that is not in the interests of ukrainians, mostly in in such cases, i always say that the ukrainian people have quite clearly and unambiguously outlined their position on the battlefield, so uh, to say that someone can somehow force the military-political leadership to do something. i think this is absolutely incorrect in the middle east, very briefly. i am not convinced that this is

interesting to anyone except me, and maybe vitaly, but look in vain, there are still a lot of problems - it is syria, the interests of russia, which is coming out, well, at least there is such, well , more or less convincing information that it is reducing the contingent there by transferring this contingent to the iranian forces and therefore the absence, for example, of tenyak in israel makes the existence of israel very problematic in the future, because israel and the iranian forces do not like israel much more than the russian forces, which not so long ago had their bases there, which are now occupied by the iranians, and there is an aggravation of the conflict very much - it is very possible under the condition that there is a ukrainian-russian war and the russians are very involved here, they do not have enough strength to do something even in syria and syria becomes such a

stumbling block and a new syrian war is possible arab israeli let's say so generally what you say i will say that this is a conversation at least two hours ago that this system of problems that exists in the middle east did not develop yesterday and not the day before yesterday and not only with the participation of the russian federation, but at the same time it is important to understand the really strategic the partners of your regime in syria are russia, iran, while the weakening of russia is going on, another player has to fill in, the other player is iran. well, in view of the processes that are taking place both in terms of the normalization of real relations with arab countries and in terms of building such a regional alliance, which some foreign

experts have already dubbed an analogue of the middle eastern nato, and those processes that are taking place in iran itself because as you know, i don't know. unfortunately, unfortunately, there is no such significant interest in these regional issues. at the same time, for example, the interdependence of the prices of food products , for example, in the same iran, absolutely reacts to the fact that what is happening here in ukraine, i.e., the cost of some of the internal political processes going on, but at the same time, of course, after the situation, for example, with drones that will probably end up on the ukrainian front, and, for example, the strategic partnership that president putin likes to talk about and his recent visit to the talks with the leader it seems to me that the processes taking place, including in the middle east, reflect the situation in the

world and the war situation in europe at the same time it is still necessary to explain how the war in europe, the war against independence, will in the long run affect countries in other regions, so here i think it is very important to talk about it and pay attention to it, including in our media, the speaker dripped you representatives of the united states of america on the day of her visit to taiwan, she said in a column in the washington post that the main purpose of her stay on the island is that she wants to support the trivandrum people at a time when there is a confrontation between world democracy and the world authoritarianism, and it seems to me that the russian-ukrainian war is still not considered in ukraine. that's how many people think that it's just a war for the territorial possessions of russia behind the soviet

union. it seems to me that it's not the first days of this war, but already we have simply become a fragment, and they are a very large one, of this great confrontation between democratic authoritarian, let's say, antagonists of the western world, so far the big question here is because you know, for example, if you consider the ukrainian-russian war from the point of view from the point of view of the essence, which will be clear, for example, for the arab countries, then this is an absolute anti-colonial war, that is, the attempts of the russian empire to restore control, relatively speaking, over its former colony, and in the understanding, for example, of the historical context, it is necessary to talk a lot about what the ukrainian russian relations than they have been for centuries, and not just in this specific micro period of time and from a historical point of view. of course, many common things can be found, if you ask yourself with such a goal or in relation to

the situation around ivan has several opinions and several positions that our foreign experts articulate a lot and after the visit there were a lot of discussions about whether there will be an aggravation of bilateral relations or whether there will not be an aggravation of bilateral relations, my point of view is that the aggravation will be at the same time in what dimension is still a big question, because in fact, after er-e spoke, not the representative of naisipus flew to taiwan to the usa er-er and for- well, on to my visit that iconic signal moment that china started military exercises around pio around the island , therefore it is important to understand that the situation in europe, for example, and russia's war against ukraine is only a fragment of the big picture of the world at the same time, many

experts emphasize the topic that this trend to the destabilization that is present in the global global arena so that it does not provoke a kind of domino effect so that all those conflicts of the war that were in a frozen state so that they do not resume their active hot phase because it is precisely the situation with ukraine that leads to the opinion that international law. that is, you know, this is the final call for the international international community that international law must work without exception, and i hope that our example and after the victory of ukraine will finally show the world that we are civilized the rules of coexistence, they are important and it is impossible to deviate from them in agreement with some political ambitions ms. vera,

see such a clarifying question a-a when we think about china about chinese and chinese chinese relations, that is, chinese-taiwanese relations, but we constantly hear criticism very often that we are not enough for our diplomats, they work in the chinese direction from beijing with the beijing government , but i have a question, and beijing is generally interested in ukraine . i imagine a huge country of 1.5 billion people who trade absolutely cool with america and the whole of europe and there is a little ukrainian woman who says to her minister of foreign affairs, why don't you go, the chinese go there, she is persuading them, they have good relations with russia, he explained that russia is the aggressor a and that’s it. listen, what’s the matter with a ukrainian who doesn’t want to go to china at all? he talks to russia in a divorced manner. it seems to me that it’s generally out of

old habit or when it’s not enough and stalin means we’re all being led to communism here. i don’t agree. delegations at the level of the central committee of the party, which we said that they really want, yes, they will all be, and they all, even in swaziland, want to be friends, talk, they were, they are chinese , they will smile and always say that we all this is necessary, but mrs. vira and you know. i agree with the thesis that the chinese side is interested in ukraine despite the fact that there is, well, it seems to me that the informational presence of ukraine in the china-china discussion is insufficient, at the same time, you know the approach of the chinese people's republic regarding the fact that economization is first of all as the canalization of bilateral relations is, you know that one of the top 3 economic partners of ukraine is china, so to say that the chinese side

is somehow biased towards us i would not at the same time, there is a really big problem. i wouldn't say that, well, let's just say that we have insufficient efforts in ukraine by ukrainian diplomacy in the chinese direction, on the contrary, but the fact that, in terms of information, our adversary, for years, has invested in discrediting ukraine, such an independent state. we we also have to take this into account and it cannot be resolved in a few months of war, at the same time the chinese side systematically declares that it is considering a diplomatic way of regulation, the chinese side spoke about the principle of territorial integrity of sovereignty that is why it is obvious to me that right now, when ukraine is in a state of war, it should double and triple its efforts to inform the chinese audience about what is happening in

ukraine and the crimes of the russian regime against ukraine . er, they systematically inform, translate and try to inform the chinese audience about what is happening, and this is also one of the factors that arose just after the start of the full-scale factor of the full-scale it seems to me that the volunteering factor of the language is now uh, just using the tools uh, so to say yes, well, public diplomacy, yes, um, human uh, human contacts, they can work precisely in favor of strengthening the ukrainian position. of course, china as a permanent member of the council by the way, from the first day, as far as i know, he is currently in the security council of ukraine, and this is an important period,

including for our ukrainian diplomacy, in order to contribute as much as possible to the establishment of the position ukraine is certainly not going anywhere in the russian context, because the russians are systematically trying to discredit ukraine, they are trying to instill some skepticism in chinese political circles with narratives. nevertheless, it seems to me that precisely from the point of view of chinese national interests, we will to wait for the autumn er with the administration so we will see, but at the same time i feel like saying so vera i understand, thank you, but i will say that when i read that he is bavchi zinkov, then i watch well there just some chinese clerics visited ufa. that is , there is a lot of information about sino-russian

relations, huge, spacious territories. well, i am talking about this and i say that we can go so far, we are not interesting, but we thank under all circumstances the faith of konstantinov political science, the internationalist, and we will move on to ivan krychevskyi, a military expert this time we have as many as 11 minutes for him if he sees us we see him at least mr. yevgeny thank you for finding again you have a sly smile on your face it's again we won somewhere so i you i i am asking you as a specialist, but still raisin or kherson , because british intelligence officers tell us that the russians have a big problem, that if the ukrainians move the russian troops even a little near raisin, it is just what we talked to you about last time, this is a little kaftan and you will emerge to or we need to

focus on kherson or raisin, there are no options. what do you think about kherson? still, they will want to keep or hold back the ukrainians near raisin. will be forced to fulfill two questions at once and restrain us in the kherson direction and at the same time repel our blows in the izyum direction because, well, you know, to eliminate such a significant threat in the east in the form of the uzyom grouping, this is very important, you know, such a weighty goal for the achievement of which it is worth competing and judging by this, the armed forces of ukraine are also feeding such a creeping, slow but sure counteroffensive and in the raisin e-e direction, simply, as they say, for certain reasons there, well

, there is no certain emphasis on this it was right, because it turns out that the armed forces of ukraine waited until from there, even in the direction of izyum, they began to transfer troops to kherson region. then they began to develop their efforts there, that's why. well, let's go. now we will watch further live, literally, how the russians will begin to tear that week kaftan because they did not calculate the strength for the means to achieve your strategic goals and mr. you look and some such confident calm in the south and this is me i say i do not understand anything i just feel from the words which are used according to the reports that are written. that is, it is a different phraseology very often, and there you can already say that the initiative is completely in the hands of the ukrainian

army. if you speak metaphorically, a similar situation looks something like this: the russians have released the initiative, their group, and the armed forces of ukraine are just trying to get their hands full, because the first important step has been taken, that is, damage to important of strategic and highways. well, i’m taking the air out of important command posts and ammunition depots there, and also a plus in 53 necessary populated areas of the kherson oblast. it’s also not worth forgetting . well, the burning of ukraine’s forces is like this. so , with a change of phraseology , we demonstrate how our military he is just getting his hands on the initiative in this direction. and you know, during the war, everyone more or less becomes patriots, even journalists, although in reality they should be excluded. and i will ask you a question that i have asked several times.

i love it. i love it so much when you answer this question that i mean once again, you would like to hear it and your answer, and it is possible in principle to change the tactics and strategy of the russian army , because a lot of times when i talk simply on the street, when people come up, they say well, they well, they can now, but they saw the mistakes, they saw the flaws, they saw it's different. there will come some smart, super smart general who read this to clause, unlike the other generals, whose even last names are similar to everything. i don't know about everything they don't know and he will redo something there - he will overpower the ukrainian army, it's possible, it's possible some young investigator - a four-year-old general a-a napoleon eh, that's who he came to paris after the victory, i don't remember tut tut on that once upon a time there was no corrupt government, in

short, not a fact. yes, so, i can appear a young napoleon, well, even if we assume that somewhere there , the headquarters of the armed forces of the russian federation is really in trouble, you know, even napoleon, at least copy of erwin rombil she is simple we are the tension of the german population, that is, for a person who knows how to competently use the available resources to achieve a non-standard task, the problem is that everyone has their own resources specifically for a strategic turning point in the war, that is, when a situation was created there that the russians are squeezing us on all fronts and you create threats through schemes, they will still take mykolaiv, odesa , kharkiv there, they can return to the north of ukraine. so, to our great happiness and to their great regret , they are the resources to achieve such a goal.

wasted, let's call it that because, for example, there really is, for example, a factor that you know is voiced so that the russians have a lot of armored vehicles in storage warehouses, why can they return it all and put it all and the like and here's this armored horde unleashed on us from one side, it's like this the problem seems to be that, to put it briefly, the russians do not have resources, otherwise they would not be, for example, because they are forced to use such a format of hidden mobilization , that is, workers from industrial enterprises take well, it is forced there through the military commissariat, and you can enter, they say, the dough field into the repair battalion to restore armored vehicles, that is, imagine what the situation is like there, what is it like there, if what is the point, if it was simply assumed that the russians will repair armored vehicles with the help of civilian enterprises, they had to simply take away the employees of the military commissariat and there you know

, you can cite quite a few examples that indicate that the russians lost, let's say, time and resources after reaching such a critical turning point, but unfortunately, we are a little bit in sometimes, you know, the conversation needs to be more economical in terms of duration, and tell me, in principle, it is possible to understand to what extent the russians are aware of all these mistakes that mykoly talked about, do they learn from their mistakes at all, because sometimes it seems that they have plans, they are behind him good question, good question, it doesn’t matter how long, and then it will be winter, it will be easier to play such a hypothesis, because now we can’t actually confirm it. in fact, quite a large part of the people around there are specialists or people like that, because actually in there have been such commentators, well, that is, there have been warriors , razvidos, yes, there are enough russians, just bitter, you know, there is such a one, even there, let’s call it a

layer of conventionally bad russians, well, that is, militarists, they actually understand it, they russian women now quite often in open sources there are such statements about their mistakes as there, for example, obviously the russians, for example, it is finally clear that it is necessary to conduct direct mission intelligence, and not just to land without results for them, without results, on our positions, but it seems that already here they are resting on the psychological features of putin’s i salute the non-state actors, let’s say where are the state operators of the backlash from the non-state representatives there, it doesn’t work for the state, that is, they can only write there bad russians about the mistakes of the russian army, but which ones are necessary. both parties realize their mistake, and on the other hand, there is no way to correct it. well,

again, these are very pleasant notes, i really like listening to these reflections of mr. ivan, i will pass on the word to a person whom i also love to listen to anzhelika sezonenko will now tell you about what happened while we were here vitaly portnikom is conducting part of this broadcast thank you, colleagues what is happening in energodar, occupied by the russians, explosions are heard allegedly flying into residential areas in mykolaiv, there are wounded and dead as a result of enemy attacks during the day well, from the good news, the fighters of the azov regiment were captured about 50-6, among them russian officers, details in a moment, 163 days of the russian-ukrainian war, for your attention, news on espresso, anzhelika sezonenko works in the studio in in the temporarily occupied energodar of the zaporizhia

region, explosions can be heard, the time interval between departure and arrival is only about three seconds. this was reported by the mayor of the city, dmytro orlov. according to him, the shelling is coming from the side of a