in general, it seems that i don’t know what to say, they didn’t survive the stages yet, and the previous points are called этот мировая . extreme volunteers, who before that were going to let everything in not for money for some kind of good, but just to help people, and people went, er , such personalities. sports, yes, that's it filmed with restraint and everything is fine, the intelligence was there, it was possible to get caught up in something, talk, uh, think about your future, how we will see together, beat the team, you will be a group, uh, all the time

, we held on, that is, recognition of roles, distributed responsibilities, what the administration says, uh how is it ? that is, on the border, there will be some kind of publicity within the limits. that's right, nadezhda vera in her loved ones is the subject and all of mr. kostyantyn's attitude. you are not at the end, please, just briefly . do you know approximately at least how many prisoners there were ? how many could survive after the terrorist attack committed by russia, because no one gives exact data, i will tell you that part of the number of dead that is called it is very little, the

rest with the number of people who followed, i don't know what happened behind two weeks from the moment of voting, this moment, the theater, but on the fourth of july, when, thank god, we were released here, we are allowed to be released, uh, there was a plus minus, 50 people were written out , 2,000 people were taken, uh , prisoners of war, and in that number, and the administrator was detained. there are several different statuses, that is, well, in general , there were 2,000 people, and for this there were more . half of six thousand people, if we take a report from the moment of the resumption of work, this is the destroyed and looted colony in february, the month of this 20, in fact, it was on july 4, mr. konstantin. we wish you a speedy rehabilitation, and after those

sufferings, our best wishes and courage to our brothers, too, and congratulations recovery thank you for what you are. we have such and such ukrainian songs and you remind us to fight death at the garbage level. they arranged a money economy, so i apologize in the water of zagreb, which, as i understand it, i am waiting for what mr. velichko said is very interesting, echoes from the gulag archipelago oleksandr, he did not say that he loved ukrainians very much, but he noted that the unity of ukrainians always cut ukrainians off from the rest of the people in the soviet zones the volandians of these stalinist torture camps and he said that ukrainians always stick together and in and and this is what distinguishes them. they always somehow look for each other and somehow help each other. so we see this

it may be a national feature of the stay of ukrainians in captivity or in a concentration camp. it is good that there are people who survived. we hope that there will be more of them . and i am a lawyer from zagreb, a state representative and the monopoly committee of ukraine. i asked about the program, and what is the major specialty of the lady, as she is from zagreb, he said. she is a specialist with a wide profile . i have a question for you, if it is true, if i see surprise in your eyes, we were going to talk a little about international topics, but nothing

prevents the other. it is very important. i would also like to talk about it. how much pressure do you see as possible with, well, everyone says , well, not everyone. many people say that after the meeting between putin and erdogan in sochi, an important situation is when erdogan will put pressure on zelenskyi with the aim of well to somehow make such a truce, such a lull is temporary because many experts say that the russian army feels very weak, is afraid of a ukrainian counteroffensive and really wants to somehow rest. so how likely is this? i don't understand at all why we are talking about starting to press , did redugan ever stop pressuring about

reconciliation. it seems to me that starting from the 20th of february, after the invasion, erdogan was one of the most active persons who offered himself as a negotiator and we heard many statements from rydogan and from his spokespeople, diplomats , ministers from the ministry of foreign affairs, during all these months when they offered us different formats of a peace agreement, so of course i think it will continue, but the question is different. the question is, how much would ferdugan push? it is possible that zelensky was not ready to agree. but it seems to me that the circumstances are such that it is impossible to conclude a peace agreement between russia and ukraine, an agreement on a cease-fire or any agreement of the first year that concerns this a war that today would not foresee that ukraine must give up part of its territories and

part of its sovereignty, including in terms of determining its foreign policy and geopolitical course independently, ukrainians will never agree to this, that is, in essence, there is no middle line on which today we can meet, and western diplomats are very clear about this - all these negotiations, they communicate, they say that ukraine has always been and is and will be ready for negotiations, but as of today, russia is not ready for negotiations that respect the territorial integrity and sovereignty of ukraine, which means that we continue to help ukraine with defense aid with military aid in order to strengthen its hand at the negotiating table. russia will agree then someday if it goes like this but then the

question arises in the winter when it gets cold for the europeans they will start putting pressure on their governments their governments will start put pressure on the same zelensky, why let us calm down because we are cold in our homes, this is not an option, you are not ruling it out, you know, we can measure, for example, the reaction of europeans in germany why because germany is most dependent on russia's energy resources, we know that germany had the most almost from all other countries of the european union, relations with russia, and just recently, just when schrüder was in the kremlin and returned, i really liked the headline in one of the german media: why is he on vacation stojnor met with putin and schultz with the turbine yes and here is the reaction of german politicians to this visit and to everything that schröder said. it was very revealing, and german politicians almost all

spoke with one voice about the fact that they do not see an opportunity for today of course, everyone communicated this in different ways, but the opinion was common, if we look at the mood in german society, we will see that the majority of the population still supports sanctions against russia they are ready to pay more a for energy resources and today we see how in all the countries of the european union measures are being introduced to limit the consumption of energy resources, therefore, of course, putin 's blackmail energy resources, he will create difficulties for europe, this will definitely definitely be supply restrictions, everything else, but i don't think that this the difficulties will be so significant for europe that europe will be able to give in to putin, because today everyone has a clear understanding that everything will not end there, what if we make further concessions

it will be worse, so i don't see that they are ready to make concessions even because of gas blackmail, but you still evaluate the physicist to germany from the point of view of german interests, he was already the last trump in the deck of cards for germany to solve the gas issue putin face-to-face face-to-face and allegedly he did not manage to get you to agree. because putin, after all this visit, after these meetings, still said that you will not receive any gas until the sanctions are lifted. i would not talk about what putin was there oh, i'm sorry, schröder was some kind of german ambassador, germany's ambassador to the kremlin, because few people in germany take schröder seriously . he was the only chancellor in the history of germany who was deprived of all privileges, and it still seems to me that schröder's trip to moscow was more of

a practice session. sorry schrüder's salary and nothing more, because well, who is schröder ? putin's precious souvenir. as mykhailo zakharov said in his book. as oleksiy navalny said that he is on putin's salary. and about schrüder in germany there are fables, just like in ukraine, so i don't think that it is necessary to exaggerate his status, schluder has long -standing ties with putin, including financial ones , so it seems to me that here only these are personal issues of schrüder , which he wrapped up here envelope, i solved energy issues, and despite the fact that there was indeed concern that these messages, what kind of people would return to germany with them, they would be able to split german society, and that is, giving an alternative opinion that in fact putin is allegedly ready for negotiations if nuclear said i have good news for you, but i see it in the german media and that schlüter did not achieve his goal and even german society he was not able to split

and why did he then make these statements because he essentially offered me no shredder reformul a which consisted in the fact that we must fulfill and return to the minsk agreements , but also expand them to the south of ukraine and create a certain federation from ukraine. well, he actually led switzerland, which is the confederation in the example with antony, if, for example, you believe oleksiy navalny and i believe more. for example, navalny . yes, shlodorov. and who mentioned that the scoundrel receives a salary in the kremlin, well, it may simply be related to this. something, people work out their subpoenas, work out their money , and i wouldn't look for more there because if there really was some other deep purpose in schröder's visits, then his messages, his proposals, they got some kind of life

. i am not talking now about those absolutely pro-kremlin politicians who are still talking about the fact that ukraine is even partly to blame for the fact that this happened to them. few of them are marginalized, but a large part of german politicians did not take it seriously, on the contrary. the same day, pay attention when er scholt met with the turbine he already met with the turbine in fact at the same time when he also went to spend because the shredder came with what message for the germans he came from there and said that moscow does not supply gas because they have technical problems, that is, there is chancellor scholz, there is the minister of energy, there is the minister of economy, that is, the entire state machine of germany, the entire state apparatus says that this is blackmail, that it is not related to technical problems, the entire leadership of the european union says that it's all blackmail, the usa says that it's blackmail, canada

, great britain, and that people come and say no, it's not blackmail, they just have technical problems on this very day so that the schlueder could not spread his message to the german audience because he was designed specifically for the domestic consumer, it was a message for the germans, and on this day in another country, i took a picture, shot a video against the background of this turbine and said, here is the turbine. here i checked it. it works, but we can’t just drop it in st. petersburg, we need russia i just gave the address where we should take her. and maybe the last question, look, we talked about this at the beginning, how do i drive, that is, when you talk about um, answer the question that i asked, did the attitudes of europeans change. in winter, when it will be cold, after all, the mood will be influenced by european values. they are now convinced that russia is an unpleasant neighbor

, that is, the europeans did not have pragmatism, they are ready to get rid of warm homes for the sake of principles, for the sake of values, for the sake of some european metaphysical uh-uh situation yes, no, no not concrete heat, but such metaphysics. i am for values ​​and i will be freezing. it will be 15° in my house. it's all right no, it's pragmatism exactly why are these values ​​pragmatism pragmatism in the fact that today and every country in the european union, its leaders are interested in almost every one, okay, i won’t speak for everyone, because we have them. for example, there are some countries where dubious persons are currently in power. for example, hungary. yes, but they lead the lion’s share of the countries of the european union . leaders who

do not want to have influence on the european continent . persons like putin will have influence in the future because they saw the consequences for their economies . and this has absolutely pragmatic practical consequences, that is, they lived normally. they invested money in development, education, health care, today , because of one person, because of putin, they are forced to take away, cut spending on many social articles, on many technological and other development projects, invest it all in and in defense, help ukraine, they perfectly understand that in 5-10 years it is will return to them with certain problems, yes, this is underfunding, and they do not want this to happen again , that is, they are doing very well, and then there are these leaders, taking into account the fact that the people elected them because they are all democratically elected leaders, we do not have them there autocracy they know how to communicate with their people and they convey to their people with various

messages why it is important and we recently had such a viral video, again mentioning germany because scholz’s viral video when he explained, for example, at a rally at a pacifist protest why ukraine it is still necessary to supply weapons, why not supply weapons to ukraine - this is not an option and they explain it to people, of course, it is difficult to explain this sacrifice, but i follow the western media carefully, it is not the first month there three experts and analysts publish there articles with advice and reflections on how it is better for the leaders of their countries to explain to the population why these victims are not exclusively, as you say, such valuable physical ones that they really have an absolute offense authorized by the antimonopoly committee of ukraine from 15 and 19 years old. and

let's go directly to the war oleksandr musienko i hope he will appear now and he has already appeared mr. oleksandr, i'm glad to see you thank you for joining us on saturday evening instead of drinking beer like all normal people, he joins in oleksandr, as always, he can’t be the helm. beer , at this moment, is the director of the center for military and legal studies, but let’s talk less about the legal and more about the military. recently we talked with you and it was so optimistic, and this morning some pessimistic notes appeared. and what a very large crowd, exactly . in the south, the russian troops are very large, the ukrainians may face problems there, they seem like we don’t know what they are preparing for today, experts say that we have a counter-counteroffensive, yes, that is, as if the ukrainians they should not join, now they want to

intercept this agenda, and they believe that on the contrary, they will defend themselves there, they will make fortifications , there are some very complicated stories there to prevent the ukrainian army from going on, what is actually happening here in the kherson region, as far as possible, the successful ukrainian offensive as far as possible can be a successful russian us well, i am inclined and belong to that category of people, probably colleagues who say that most likely they are there to defend themselves because everything is coming together right now eh so that the russian forces of the russian army do not have the strength to carry out any counteroffensive actions. i can even explain why, let's see now. recently, again, the russian propagandists, and through their military, in particular, there are military leaders , collaborators, and so on, that they are going to to go to mykolaiv, yes, i want to say how many there are in

general, what grouping of troops they now considered sufficient to move to mykolaiv, they transferred about 10,000 russian servicemen, yes, when in in march, they tried to capture mykolaiv in march , when there were fewer ukrainian forces, they retreated from kherson with battles when there was no such firepower, so they did everything possible in those directions, but still it was not enough then, uh, russian forces were much more, at least in twice no, they were not able to capture mykolaiv now from the position of more strengthening of the ukrainian forces, more units, and accordingly the situation with weapons with long-range artillery has improved, that is, for today, these are the statements that are heard about the fact that russian forces are going to advance, this edition is actually wishful thinking, because with disrupted

logistics it will be extremely difficult. well, in addition, we see that the task of strikes by ukrainian forces on precisely the enemy's positions. it is quite successful there in that direction continues . and what are they counting on? i think the calculation is such as not to give the opportunity to develop counter-offensive actions by the ukrainian ugh, and of course if there are any mistakes , they also think that if there are any mistakes and there are chances for the russian troops take advantage of this and somewhere along some lines go into a counterattack and improve the tactical position, but this is not the main motive. i think it is not the main strategy that the russian units in the south currently have, but mr. oleksandr's priorities have shifted from donbas to the south. currently, the russians have from there, the troops are regrouping. will they still hold on to donbas, especially in

donetsk region, where the fighting is still going on partially? now the russian troops are advancing in the east where they can advance. that's all and there are not the same forces, but they still have forces in two directions - this is avdiyivka - this is avdiyivka piski and bakhmutsky, from where they are trying from the south . in the yansk direction, in fact, the offensive of the russian troops was choked and a combat-capable group, in fact, there is one of the combat-capable russian groups, which was under izyom, it no longer looks so combat-capable, and the report you removed just the same part of the units, but there where they still can to advance i think that they will advance and they will say well, they also understand very well that if they completely stop offensive activity and remove all their combat units, then this opens up the possibility for us to do it, and everything depends

on the fact that they will not do it and they will still be in the east, where they can continue to advance, and p. oleksandr and if you can briefly describe this ukrainian offensive, look, if they will create many echelon defenses, they will put up fortifications there, moreover, i am a person which 12 years in a row i drove around the kherson region in the summer i see these so many canals so much human nature, natural there half human and half natural and various such things that do not allow you to move quickly and then and ukrainians do not like to shoot at civilians that is , it makes it difficult the offensive, then what kind of offensive will it be, these high mars will simply destroy everything behind the front line, break all the logistics, destroy the leadership

team first of all, yes, that is, the headquarters and wait until they themselves run or the ukrainian army will to move without waiting for the russians to run, you know. the point is that in any case, as i have said before, it is important not to rush, you know, not in the sense that it is clear that it is important to work for the deoccupation of the occupied territories, but not to rush in the sense that it is not necessary we sometimes have let's let's let's let's go ahead in my opinion today and er the strategy and tactics implemented by the ukrainian armed forces are absolutely correct, she is clear, she understood, she just means this is the second option about you talked about the fact that such conditions are being created so that the russian troops well, it was simply impossible to gain a foothold and receive additional logistical support. and by the way, i want to say

that in the kherson region it is now being demonstrated, perhaps for the first time in this war, when the russians are looking for acts of valerian, throwing pawns back that they feel that they do not have parity in long-range artillery with ukrainian units, this is a paradoxical thing which , in principle, is not the first time. what this indicates is that the logistics are broken , and there is no proper provision. of course, the calculation is to squeeze them out, that is, the tactic of squeezing them out as much as possible is to create unfavorable conditions. it is quite profitable because it causes less destruction. it causes fewer victims, fewer losses, and it is very good that now they are working effectively on this, and then it is normal to wait for the exact moment when the command decides that this is the time when it will be possible to break through in one direction or another and, er, move on, but here really

you have to understand the landscape, take into account the terrain and many other circumstances, and the fact that according to the compositions, the russian forces are really entrenched there . but i have to say that everything looks like it is going to be more on the ukrainian side, you just need to have some patience and wait. well, yes, please, should i be afraid now? seven is worth it to ukrainians because we are basically living in a war, but as far as the southern points such as mykolaiv zaporizhzhia and odesa are concerned, odesa is of course very necessary for the russians to get to transnistria, the connection of occupied transnistria with the russian federation is direct, but mykolaiv , is there a state of war in this city? zaporizhzhia, as a regional center, is it possible that you think they will try to capture these cities? well, we

see that in general, the south and the southeast are everything makes sense for the military plans of the russians, we can of course draw conclusions about it judging by the way they developed the offensive and when there are certain statements of the deputy commander of the central district the ministry of defense of russia was there such a general teminykov who said that we need a corridor to transnistria or when the minister of foreign affairs of russia lavrov talks about the geographical conditions. moreover, i want to remind you that both he and putin said at one time that occupation is not the goal of this war, but we we see that of course the south is also of quite serious strategic importance for the russian forces and for russia they perfectly understood that they should not use the opportunity to cut off ukraine from the sea and for obvious reasons because it quite serious, well, we perfectly understand

the economic issues, but now, again, there have been quite a lot of statements that russian troops are ready to go. well, frankly speaking, i do not see at the expense of what and with what forces. at the moment, they are ready... to carry out such offensive actions, they do not have the strength for this, and instead the protection of the southern coast, in particular odessa, has been strengthened, and we can see that they will say, uh, the situation that arose when it was possible to create a protected coastal zone around the odessa coast it made it impossible for the landing force to land and connect with the land contingent that was supposed to go from the mykolaiv side of the russian forces, that is, today we can talk about the fact that they can do it, i don't think it looks doubtful and is practically impossible right now at the moment and besides if

we talk about mykolaiv, unfortunately, we see that the city is suffering precisely from rocket attacks, and therefore it is quite critical to move this border away from mykolaiv , or let's say that the shells and rocket artillery did not arrive. well, rockets are just ordinary means of air defense so that there are always questions like this, here is a short 20-second reflection due to the fact that you talked about the general staff of ukraine, which knows when it retreats, retreats. i remember my own. it must be some kind of ukrainian luck. 97-98 already in the 99th year, i asked. and how do you hit? as you say , we generally defend ourselves. our version is that we don't get hit. if we get hit somewhere once, he will fall. that's why our version is not to attack. we stand in

defense and and we are waiting for ours and now we have mr. oleksandr says and now the general staff is sitting and waiting for the time being on the camera, finally they will tire themselves out to knock in response if i have time and there is oleksandr i still have one question if there is yes because i don't see him simply and there is okay one minute literally and not mr. putin's head will explode because lately it is no longer a military issue, rather a diplomatic one, we see problems in armenia, problems with negotiations with turkey, problems in syria, and the deterioration of relations with israel and in russia , that is, the ukrainian war well, there is a lot to do putin and his clovers will endure, let's say so, here are all the problems that surround him. and you see the situation