well, you know, it does not reach the people, and here directly to everyone, i am in favor of funds doing it directly, and not through officials, because they can delay somewhere if it is carried out through our officials. oleksandr savchenko, financier, banker , doctor of economics, professor, did not last long with us a pause, then we will return to stay behind the spear, the bells also had holes from bullets and fragments, there is always a need for equipment, they always strengthen the hull, in addition, they gave an iron-type base so that it could be restrained by bullets with military equipment, the car should be higher. put on the wheels and we will not stop as long as there are needs, we will work and do this much 24 hours a day, we rolled up our sleeves, there are car repairers who are making their contribution, now this is fire, this is pumped into our joint victory, because the boys need a car, ukraine is working so that

ukrainians do not think about they didn't talk about the first place , the war still comes out, the war is our victory, seven days a week from monday to sunday, seven different spheres of human activity, sports, culture , politics, eight presenters of express, journalists , experts, opinion leaders in real time about the most relevant events through the prism of war every day author's projects on espresso our life will not be the same as before home to the industrial district and for the sake of the future the knights of reconstruction are already working the work is carried out according to the schedule the task will be completed time they will restore our cities and we will breathe life into them a very grateful battalion of

builders here our front wild creatures are not able to choose anything else and we in ukraine like to choose everything even if it is insurance on hotline finance hotline finance insurance of course online we continue broadcasting on espresso analytics thank you for supporting the ukrainian view of the world with us yehor chichurinda in the studio and hanna valevska with us two people's deputies oleg dunda is already with us people's deputy of ukraine mykhailo tsimbalyuk is also a servant of the people mr. mykhailo mr. olezh good health ivan, do you see us,

hear us? good afternoon, dear colleagues . the fact that the war in ukraine can last at least until the summer of 23rd year, very difficult times are still ahead, this was stated by the former us special representative for ukraine kurt volker, according to the diplomat, ukraine is currently unable to quickly expel the invaders from its land for objective reasons, the war against russia will continue at least until the summer of the 23rd year, volker emphasized that difficult situations are aggravated by the energy crisis in europe, which is caused by gas blackmail from russia, he warned that the whole winter will be difficult for everyone, for europe, for ukraine, and for russia but we will provide not only military aid, but also financial humanitarian aid, meaning

the usa and the european union, our other partners of ukraine, what threats does it pose ? the income of the population will actually be somewhere up to 40%. proposed to implement a special program to give all ukrainian citizens just $100 of support per month so that somehow people could in the event of a continuation of the war to make ends meet by next summer, what do you think as representatives of the government, what program should be prepared regarding the support of the population, i ask oleg, well, first of all, look according to the message of mr. kurt volker, eh, i don’t know where he gets such information from, but you have to understand we only have time to win this war for independence, it is first of all the responsibility of the united states that

they will supply, provide weapons , support, the time depends on that, when we divide our territory, and this is only this whole the responsibility lies with them if they provide us with weapons as soon as possible and in accordance with the nomenclature and quantity as we need, the war will end with our victory, and this year if they pull supplies, it may not even end in the 23rd, but only in the 24th everything is worse in their forces, its capabilities in relation to the economy, we understand, fortunately, we have already begun to understand and this cannot help but please me that moscow has chosen another front of the war against ukraine, and this is primarily economic pressure on the countries of the european union to the countries of the west in order to agitate them through society so that they do not support ukraine, and we had to be ready for this, including through an information campaign, etc., and including

supporting our ukrainians inside ukraine in this times are a difficult period, but i am talking to many of our ukrainian soldiers, we all understand that there will be difficult times, we must grind them down, the main thing is our victory and everything for the sake of victory, there will be no victory, these 100 dollars how as you are talking about, they will not help anything and in general it will not be necessary for anyone, the main thing is victory and all the money, all the resources should go there in the first place . olezhe, i support you. this is not my proposal , this is the proposal of our previous expert . i understand, we talked about the fact that we still have enough military power and human potential and armed forces, thank god and the desire to win, but there are still purely humanitarian issues . approximately 30% of our pensioners receive a pension, and

it is a disaster when food prices have already risen by a third there and the minimum pension has remained at the pre-war level, it was not very high before and these people will have to be suffocated until spring. your assessment is precisely this humanitarian component of the continuation of this war. thank you, first of all, i will correct our respected presenters . of the people is just one of the factions and has appropriated it a little. and this is the general name of the servants of the people - they are people's deputies of ukraine. i did not mean the political power of the remark. thank you. thank you. he currently holds a not so important position, but still he is known to

ukrainian-american politics and his statement should be taken extremely seriously, especially by the current ukrainian authorities, because of that, i think that we are in for a difficult winter. and although i personally our team wishes to end the war as soon as possible through the victory of ukraine over russia, by the way, today they celebrate the professional holiday of the air under the power of ukraine. we congratulate and wish them success and constant superiority in the air, but we really have a difficult winter ahead of us, and here we should also think about the minimum pension should be du about subsidies and how the central and local authorities will ensure that people's homes are warm and that they

have something to eat, especially those who work in the rear for the front. they should also have a decent the pension is positive what is now and the salary is positive what we see is that today we are the second caravan left our ports with grain. and this is more than 120 million tons of wheat and corn and other grains, there is a chance that the currency will go to the ukrainian budget because it is almost 40% of all receipts in ukraine, it was from the sale of agricultural products and their processing, this is important, but we need to think about those people who are internally displaced, displaced, almost 8 million, and where they will go, and we see that the authorities are still carrying out forced evacuation from

the territories of donetsk and luhansk and is already starting in other regions such as kirovohrad region, poltava region , vinnytsia region, as well as the western part of our region, that is, that these people are especially few mobile pensioners, people with special needs, that there is a place to accommodate them and that those e-e enterprises or institutions that accept are actually citizens received support from the state, we see the government's statements that they will already pay for the reception of resettled persons not 400 hryvnias per month but almost 900 hryvnias so that the citizens who granted asylum could also pay utility payments and now there are new challenges to help those people survive the winter because of this, we see that the verkhovna rada has allocated funds or passed a law that there will be a purchase

of gas, too. what lies ahead once again. the situation in connection with inflation as citizens should be supported so that they spend the winter with dignity in warmth and in more or less hardship as much as possible during the war. well, i have already quoted our prime minister denys shumil. he said that while we are at 60% we are ready for the heating season, but we will be 100% ready before the start of the heating season. what are your premonitions about the start of the heating season, which threats are there today, and whether you will ask this question to the government at your meetings . why are the sittings of the parliament not currently shown to ukrainian citizens, at least in the

recording. i understand directly that this is happening for security reasons, why not show what you are doing there, the higher legislative bodies, well, in the recording. show any please let us understand what questions you are asking the government, what answers, what bills, what discussions, who votes, please, a simple enough question and a simple answer . including the motherland and its people, a large number of deputies after the meeting report on which bills were voted on, which decisions were made, that is, if whoever wants it, it is not a secret, on the other hand, we we understand that being in a state of war, in order not to shake up the information space, so that some of our deputies are so separate, emotionally unhinged, who try to use the platform at any time to promote themselves politically, in order to shake

up society. they approach work not from the point of view of benefits for the state. they come to work so that the dog in the yard knows them about how they shout jumpers so that there is no such possibility and yet the parliament wow during martial law is more effective for this time and was not used during these broadcasts so that such a few of them are not many there up to 10 are not used as an opportunity to destabilize society and thus do not play a useful idiot for moscow, wait for the heating season we are not yet finished, see here if i remember correctly, we have about 12 billion in our warehouses . of the heating season, somewhere around 14-15 billion minimum is needed to pump in order to pass

uh this season well, in the winter, but it was in peacetime, to date we have lost unfortunately, i think we will return, but now we are spending a lot of industrial volumes in our east and in the south, it is also in the north, donetsk and mariupol. i use a large share of gas for my production, so the amount of gas used in winter will be much less than in peacetime, it will no longer be needed 15 although mr. shmygal still is trying to set a bar for himself to accumulate as much gas as there was in peacetime ago, based on that i think that we will pass the winter time mildly enough, although maybe in some regions, uh, which uh, somehow, may be under military attack or, for example, kremenchug, which was also bombed, they may suffer during the

heating season from the lack of heat, but in such regions, i think it will not be so much, and therefore i have great hope that this winter we , well, the part that is not occupied will pass enough 'as if of course there won't be how to tell if there won't be a deliberate bombing of our heating infrastructure by orcs from moscow, gentlemen, if there will be what is the main threat and what is the main question , do you understand if there will be, we can't put air defense systems on these mountains and over these cities unfortunately, none the country, even the united states, does not have the appropriate amount of it in order to protect such risks exist, and for this we use our planes and the ones we have, if it flies, well, then we will try how can we not solve this issue quickly, but we will not

be able to be 100% insured against this. there is a war in our yard. well, we need to understand this or hear your opinion about what mr. oleg says that all deputies write after meetings. is this and there is a full extent of reporting to inform people about the activities of the supreme council, because after all, it is at will. i want to write. i want to write . the verkhovna rada is right of course, more than that, who visits them is generally very important during the war, and we hear this from citizens with whom we communicate, that the verkhovna rada demonstrates the openness of this work and citizens see that this is a legislative body that works fully, passing laws that are expected by civil society, our economy, etc., because of that we we insist, including this position, as far as i know, of the

european solidarity of the voice of others, that after the plenary session is over, the session of the verkhovna rada should still be broadcast in the recording, so that all the citizens of ukraine once again felt that there is no panic, that the deputies did not flee the country or they work in session treason, and it is very important that you saw the discussion, for example, about privatization during the war, and there really is something to say about the approved salaries, etc. because of that, it concerns us it is radically different and we will insist on the agreed council to still broadcast and this will make it possible for all of us to see the adopted citizenships. you also have a very powerful supervisory and control function. i would like to be with you again to talk about the interview of general krivonos. he gave it to a new level. if anyone has not seen it, go and read it. he speaks very harshly there, but we believe and are convinced that we should talk about everything, well, within the limits of

not inciting panic, but we must also talk about negative moments now, because this is the price of our victories, so he says that the industrious cannot do certain things because the president's entourage controls his processes, and he says that this same entourage meddles in the defense processes, puts incompetent but dedicated people in important areas, such a policy. and about the fact that terroboron now, well, there is no preparation for territorial defense, that is, mass exercises, and he says yes, the victory will only come at what cost, because it is still a big loss, mr. mykhailo, do you agree? the elite of our time, he really got the title although he was seriously wounded at the front, i am very

sorry that his experience is not used to win victory, he can really advise and his work in the council of national security and defense as i was very professional, although principled, and some did not want to hear the truth from others. i don't know all the secrets, he still knows more, but the fact that his statements are objective. there is a certain caution, should they all be voiced publicly? i think that after such an interview with our senior military leadership , this combat general is still to himself, i emphasize because he has a lot of rational proposals and enjoys a certain respect in the troops among ordinary officers as well as higher ones

ranks and his medical education, i repeat once again, served to increase the professions, increase the professionalism of the armed forces of ukraine and accelerate our victory , he also says that this is the result of his communication with the active military, because he really is in contact with them very often, i want to hear your comment. the fact that there are currently no powerful exercises at the territorial level, well, this is a fact. and this is a war against the ukrainian people, and we have to prepare. well, well, we did not prepare for war in a year and in three months although we were clearly and frankly told about this from abroad, but now why are there no such general mass trainings? well, why did you decide that there are no trainings, if you do not see them, it does not mean that they are not there, for example, today they came to me from our kyiv anxiety guys, we talked there

we supply them with a steering wheel. well, what do they need? well, they are now under the kharkiv kyivske trro and under slovyansk, but in a week we will go there to see them. they are there, they are on the front line. they are studying . to be sent to combat operations, you have to somehow learn how to hold a weapon. don't interrupt our guys, those guys who went, as i know, they were in kyiv for three months studying . the guys under the fast go through training every week, but recently, a man of mine, a friend of mine who for 60 years ran all day on the training ground in a bulletproof vest and with a weapon, she has training, why did you decide if you didn’t see them in the village, there are no such trainings, and i have guys from the 58th brigade under with bahmut, funeral girls constantly come and say

that they were thrown there without training, why aren't there mass trainings, there are already two places and they don't know anything. well, what you're saying, we understood as you show it should be training, it should be a mouthpiece at the stadium above all teach let the missiles fly there well, let's talk seriously about mr. kryvonos, this is about what we said about the verkhovna rada about you when the politician got there are a lot of politicians who get a platform and they start saying who knows what and god found us for his own sake, we get to know each other. unfortunately , some representatives are former military personnel, unfortunately they have become politicians or see themselves as politicians. i listened carefully about two weeks ago, i listened to the stories of mr. kryvonos on the radio, i treated him normally, but what he ordered about zhulyany how was he there, well, listen , it doesn't go to my head, but then i had the desire to see the quotes that he took and officially

go through all the quotes, what really happened and what he did not correspond to the reality of one very good thing all the time they reminded me that the interview will probably be held and i will conduct such a fact-checking of what happened and what he says. well, if he has a desire, i am sorry. i want to help him . i'm sorry, i'm sorry, what you just said, i'll probably do it. thank you, friends. here's one more question, very important. i'm asking about the economy today. i'm asking all the questions, yes. denys mygal said that from september 1, privatization will start massively in ukraine. the president of ukraine has set a task. launch privatization from september 1 to this parliament passed the relevant legislation, the government developed all secondary legal acts, friends, should we sell during the war, when the prices are in the dirt , to start a large-scale privatization ? during

martial law, it is still necessary to do more of this kind of mobilization economy, to develop the economy through a defense order or through a state order , and this is more important than giving it to privatization maybe some individual enterprises make sense, but this is only pointwise, it should not be a systematic work, like mr. mykhailo, it is also very, very concise, this is exactly the bill that would be worthwhile for the citizens of ukraine to hear the discussions in the neighboring halls. we are a team, the faction of the homeland did not vote for it not a single representative of the government was present. the state property fund was not present. this bill allows preparing to privatize everything at book value, and i asked a public question which of the people's deputies are ready to sell their an apartment during the war, they want to do the same thing on behalf of the state, i think that some enterprises do not work efficiently, then rent them out for

hryvnia so that people will work for them, and not sell everything during the war, this is a really wrong policy, and if only the citizens of ukraine would hear what is there some spoke up and said, maybe they really would change their minds if the government in this difficult period is taking exactly those steps that will stand for the safety of citizens and provide them for the autumn and winter period, not those who are planning to go there, a little remark if possible well, in a nutshell, i will remind mr. mykhailo that we were already in the 90s when we rented out for 1 hryvnia. at that time, a large number of strategic enterprises of ukraine were privatized under this scheme at the time of the war. it is understandable, thank you mykhailo tsimbalyuk and oleg dunda participants in our discussion thank you for an interesting and interesting conversation oleksandr pavlichenko, the executive director of the ukrainian helsinki union for human rights is already joining oleksandr, we congratulate you good day well

, this emnysti international who didn't make a fuss i knew, now i found out about it, it is a human rights organization, they said that the ukrainian forces endanger the civilian population by creating bases and placing weapons systems in residential areas, in particular in schools and hospitals. trying to stop the russian troops . dmytro kuleba, oleksandr. as you can see, what is this statement about, more precisely, where does the wind come from ? it is now only with the sanons, which concerns the prepared amnesty international of the world, and it is said that it concerns the question. compliance with the norms of international humanitarian law by the ukrainian military as indicated by a-a and this only applies to the issues of staying in the military in the combat zone in such e-e

institutions as e-e hospitals or e-educational institutions of the predovtsi school and e-e how it was done how it was designed and submitted actually caused a discussion and doubts about the general assessment made in this press announcement, let me remind you that this is a press announcement. and you have to start with the fact that there is no report about they actually say it the heads of amnesty international, i will remind you that she drinks calamari , she spoke several times there, she even refuted the criticism against her , uh, how does she think she is biased and uh, she called everyone there bots, who speaks differently than

they do showed this material. we managed to analyze virtually verbatim this entire text that was made public. it really violates journalistic standards and does not comply with such requirements for analytical materials. in fact, there are no serious references here. er confirmations of what was said and uh, the conclusions that were made. they uh, too, do not correlate with the understanding of what the standards and norms of international humanitarian law are, and that's exactly what mrs. ani is like a pen. a blow to amnesty international because they are trying to act as if they are

there and uh, i apologize for swimming in the standards of proof, trying to manipulate the situation, so to speak, to the conclusions they made, because the conclusions are really uh, the fact that they do not take into account absolutely uh, a number of necessary necessary facts in order to make an assessment of the situation, was there a violation of international humanitarian law or not? first of all, there is no such thing. second, well, we cannot even say what methodology was used, that is, what methodology these researchers worked with, how they collected materials. what did they rely on and research , for example, at what time, under what conditions, did the stays take place, for example, on the territory of specific institutions, what are the accusations

made in this material, let me remind you that stays in both medical and educational institutions institutions is not in itself a violation of the norms of international humanitarian law, in addition , we are also talking about the fact that the ukrainian military held defenses in strongholds, when in fact the school process involving students and placing them directly in schools did not take place. institutions, they have already ceased to be, let's say, institutions designated for conducting educational institutions. therefore, this is one such small touch that should also be taken into account, the second element that should be taken into account is this or there was an alternative for the ukrainian military to be in another place, what mission function do they have