it is necessary to look at and then to accept our partners, it is absolutely correct, then we all need to realize that we went there and after aleppo, as you say, it is all correct, just now when we appeal to the world, we must remember everyone about it, yaroslav boyko is back , congratulations again, mr. yaroslav, there is no yaroslav boyk , they can hear us like this, please, yes, unfortunately, friends, i wanted yes, if there is no sound, let's get in touch, i wanted another interesting, well, sociology, if you can use this word relatively russian federations, a russian businessman has printed very interesting opinions of russians regarding the war in ukraine. therefore, the opinion that the so-called special operation of russia in ukraine has dragged on, do you know how many 59% of russians support this, according to a recent poll by

russianfield . residents of russia are equally ready to support the signing of a peace agreement for this 65% of respondents and a new attack on kyiv for this 60% of respondents, well, the expert edition of komiksan explained such a contradiction with reluctance society to think about big political problems . it is also interesting that almost a third of the 30% surveyed. only 13% of russians believe that the special operation will continue for more than a year and that it will end in the next three months, while the majority of russians, 62%, are sure that the special operation is more or less successful, while the other opinion is the opposite, that is, only 19% are unsuccessful. how many hesitated to answer well, and it is interesting about personal participation, 29% of russians are ready to personally take part in military operations in ukraine and mainly it is men, men are meant from 40 to 59-year-olds are not, and almost two-thirds 62%

are ready to take part in special operations, 62% are not ready to take part. there are also not so many people willing to help the russian military materially, 67% are not at all ready to donate their money to the army, and 12% are ready to spend no more than 1000 rubles a month on it. well, these are the ones i would like our political scientists and internationalists to comment on everyone, i don't know how contradictory the data of russian sociologists are, please, do we have a connection ? if you haven't read what you heard now, please, i was waiting today, what morning well, in principle, it's a rare case when i agree with the russian comment , and it especially concerns them and they support the offensive on

kyiv, and yes, yes, almost the same number of respondents answered about the fact that the rear compass is a so-called special operation. this really demonstrates that the russians do not have their own point of view at all, or even if and that they should be afraid of her. speak in a voice, that is, absolutely they are, this is arab psychology, and such is he and resolves in the same place and further comments, for example, there is an appendix and an explanation that when gorbachev came, the coolness of the soviet union began, that's why the russian people are very dissatisfied with what they were given and their opinions, and the brother is responsible

for himself for his own decision. it is precisely the willingness to answer for one's decisions and to make one's own decisions that is the difference between a slave and a free person, a slave always hopes for a master who will decide for him, therefore, just somewhere, a direct percentage, of course, so-called years in front of the russian population, they are actually not much more, all the cultural ones there are 86 out of 159, but that does not include that is why in all these polls that it should not be addressed to them, this is a multiple confirmation and an additional argument that we should not hope for the fact that the russians will cringe even when there is a

parallelepiped, only possible hands there, they will dare to some kind of revolution, for some reason nothing will come of it, only a military defeat will embarrass them to retreat from their plans a people, well, you know the mentality, it is formed over the centuries if you look at the history of russia there since 1861, that is, there is a little more stability in the years since serfdom was abolished, of course, the vast majority are involved by rapists. so we have the results and the conclusion, that is, not by slaves after the abolition of serfdom the rights of only six generations, relatively speaking, of russians, and the other previous ones from the time of the golden horde, well, they are used

to paying tribute and will be a tramp . we are with economists that russia's gdp will fall by the end of the year. it is predicted only at the level of -10 -10 for comparison, the world bank in ukraine predicts minus 40. that's the difference here, hoping that there will be a rapid economic decline in russia, too, unfortunately, we don't have to, we have to count on the armed forces are correct well, all the more so as we see the key revenues and now they should be recognized in this way adapted to these sanctions and the accounts of oil prices just beauty another record taking into account the structure of the russian economy eh hope for economic rights, as we didn't want them to be introduced

well, even more so if we discussed before this the mentality of the russians, they will endure to the last, this is a hamster people, the chipmunk people, as the famous propagandist prokhanov called it there, they will start to eat they will go to the forest for their native mushrooms there, but in any case, i will continue to be sick with imperial dreams of, as they say, conquering about on this site, remember the price without in buchi, who allowed you to live so much these buryats looked at the ukrainians, it was their outrage they really saw the difference between the picture on television and there they were fed for at least the last

eight years about the decline of ukraine, the mess, they looked at the conditions in which they live, but here it is also very interesting, the social survey, too, in general, is at 10. this is buryatia, like the strong regions of dagestan, there the situation is it's already very difficult. the prices are incredible. the carpathians are very low even compared to ukraine. but nevertheless, they lived and nothing happened , too, unfortunately. of oil products and gas, we should not expect an economic boost from russia in the context of what you said about the countries that sponsor terrorism, in fact, de facto

- a country without terrorism offices, the prefix european countries and the same germany, france , italy and which there, the leaders of the purchase of russian gas, oil, which are sponsoring the war in ukraine, are therefore taking such steps, the europeans are very afraid that their inflation will fall, which will lead to the fact that the european people will vote for them, and they are holding back, and even those who want to literally should not everyone doesn't do this. well, i'm not saying this about all kinds of bodies that will always be found in the european family, which have been receiving bribes and contracts for years and discounts at that time, namely gas and navpa, and

block the driving of three of these options against russia constantly max thank you yaroslav voyko joins us by phone, we established a connection yaroslav, we congratulate you once again, can you hear us mr. yaroslav, i can hear you well. it's wonderful. and kurt volker gave an interview. and here we are for the second day discussing what he said there, this is a former special representative let's remind the us department of state for ukraine and he said that regarding ukraine and georgia and when they can become nato members despite the fact that part of their territories are occupied by russia, volker considers it possible to apply the so-called rasmusin formula, which was proposed two years ago by the former nato secretary general, it provides for an agreement between nato and the candidate countries that they do not return the occupied territories by force. he said that in the case of georgia this is possible, at the same time he said that

this formula is not suitable for ukraine now because russia attack destroyed such an opportunity . please comment on these words of bulker. i agree with a highly certified diplomat. and in general, we had a situation like this for a long time when they said that the country is territorial claims that are not settled, it can not be a member of nato. it is possible if we follow certain procedures and this is exactly the formula of the russian federation that gives us the opportunity to do this in the case of ukraine. we should not really allow 20 or more percent of the territory of ukraine remained under occupation and you. moreover, with the goal of standing all of ukraine is, of course, kyiv is the capital and the entire territory of our state, at least the right bank

, only the left bank territory, that is why we should not allow this conflict to be frozen at some stage, as it was in the 14th year we had a forced respite, and the minsk agreements were specifically aimed at winning such a defector, and these agreements, in principle, they were from the ukrainian side and should not have been, well, it was not assumed that they would be implemented. and where is this there was such a hook on which the russian federation sat down . in this case, we have to work on our entire territory, including all of donbas and all of crimea, and then we can raise the question of full membership in nato, it will not be soon. it will be very bloody difficult, but i see that there is another way out in we don't exist and then we don't have to go according to the razmusana formula, but to be a whole and sovereign country and which will join nato on its own terms. maksym and how do you see this

perspective until the war? i am convinced, uh, we have no real chance to join the ranks nato even if all these formulas will be implemented , because i was talking about our european integration, what can i say before nato integration, there is not only urban, there is also france, there is also germany, which blocked us from granting us a passport in 2008 , they are these politicians they rely on public opinion within the two states, and there, unfortunately for us, at least so far, the majority does not support the euro atlantic integration of nato. well, it should be reminded that we

signed there last year. e during themselves tons and there are such conditions that it will even overcome this, not to mention those reforms of the army, which, unfortunately, have not yet been brought to an end, unfortunately, there are enough signals from our military that many commanders are still fighting according to the soviet models, which leads to the death of our soldiers where it is not expected. therefore, it is still a very long time if we win. if when we defeat russia on the battlefield, you know, there we still have to think about whether we should join nato. is also unfortunately, it is ineffective, that is why our closest partners are the same poland, the baltic

states support ukraine so much because they understand that russia will not stop at ukraine if it achieves its goals, they will be next , that is why poland is now there despite the fact that it has the guarantees of the fifth article of the north atlantic treaty and purchases active weapons, in particular, from south korea of ​​the psu system because they understand that it is necessary to count only on this, so let's think about today about the victory over the poles and let us help by the way, if you look at the military aid not of individual countries, but only of you can also see that there it is meager regarding medical aid, logistics, the purchase of energy carriers, and

even the president of the united states constantly says that they are doing everything to not to enter the war on the side of ukraine, that's why they didn't close the sky and still don't close it, that's why they're afraid to provide even us with the much-needed aviation systems pavel, so let's leave these you are the formulas for politics, let's concentrate on what is happening today and now, until the war is over, we should not talk about it. i am convinced that when we win, our army will be exemplary, much stronger than any other, except of course there for example, the united states and turkey, which are the two most powerful armies of nato, everything else has already demonstrated everything, germany, france, why they do not provide us with enough

weapons, it is because, as it turned out, they themselves do not have them in sufficient quantity and they are all not ready to the point that, god forbid, russia will not fall on them. thank you, the professor of the department of mat, an international expert, eh, the international topic continues, but viktor and wertsner are joined by the israeli military and major sakhalo. victoria , we congratulate you, i congratulate you, viktor. the situation at the moment, is it safe now in the state of israel, please? yes, it is very safe now, there are no shellings, uh, we can say that this operation is completed, what was

the success of the sahal during the solution of this combat task well, it can be expressed in one word, the initiative, the initiative in this case belonged to israel, israel decided when to attack, where to attack, and also decided where to complete this operation on time, what is your forecast for the next month or two, or will it be calm because we are very worried, you know, that the fire of the ukrainian war does not spread to europe, the middle east, and that the attention of the world community is not diverted from ukraine to other sources of instability. so quiet from the side of the gas sector, but

any small outbreak somewhere on the west bank of the jordan river can, again, renew this conflict, viktor well, and you evaluate what should be done in ukraine for in order to be ready for the permanent threat of missile strikes, how uh, how did israel build this readiness, how much security did israel build for itself, how much time and money should ukraine need in order to protect itself from possible missile strikes that could start in israel, for example, any the same moment in ukraine is now asking you for this to get or build a multi-level pro er system of anti-

missile defense israel has such a system iron dome er is only the last lowest last the highest level of this system this system includes er three levels er of defense - this is a hmm missile complex, this is a hmm farewell to david, which works in the middle layers of the atmosphere, is it a p-2 or arrow-2 missile complex, which works against e-he missiles in the upper layers of the atmosphere and the рро 3 missile complex that operates in the e-e orbit is all e-e belongs to of the unified air defense system and about uh what uh this system

is called uh homa or where is wall uh wall and it coordinates uh the work of all uh all uh systems such as climbing the dome and others need a lot of time, this is an expensive project. but if the country wants to protect its uh-uh air, uh-huh, it must be done. they will live the information. we all are told about the iron dome, the iron dome, and that's all. it's news to me, too, that there are three additional systems to iron dome and all this together make up a single system pro well, she asks how much does it cost a i have another question. how long did israel build this system? it took 10 years. 20 more . it took time and money. if we are talking about the

system in general, it is more than 15 years, but only with the iron dome. it was developed very very quickly, uh, somewhere in two years, uh, 2006, if i’m not mistaken, the first samples of the iron bulkhead were already delivered, viktor, and in terms of money, at least how much maintenance costs per year, you don’t know how much money is allocated for maintenance and renewal, or what well, a bull or a set to these to these missiles, it depends, for example, on whether these means were used this year or not at all, one shot of a missile and the peace is an interceptor missile or an ironclad, the funds are currently somewhere around $60,000, at the beginning of this project e one shot cost somewhere around $100,000. and

victors, but during this operation of the palestinian icelandic jihad, i read that 350 rockets were fired across the country, of which 162 were intercepted by the air defense system. this is exactly what we are talking about, the iron dome, another hundred fell in the gas sector, more than 30 the mediterranean sea was there and several more missiles fell near tel-aviv, that is, not all missiles and such a powerful and inexpensive system still intercept so that we have no illusions . during the 55 hours of the operation, there were about 1,100 rockets from the gas sector, of these rockets, some 200-200 rockets fell on the territory of the gas sector, and more than half of the rest of the rockets it was flying over the

cities of israel. it should be borne in mind that... rockets that er don't vibrate over populated areas don't match don't intercept er because it 's this it's it's very expensive only those rockets that which er er aim at populated areas or some other er - it is a strategic object, and some numbers are lost that were not shot down, 90-6% of these missiles were shot down. this is a very powerful indicator panel, but how about the accuracy of the russian super-duper, as the russians say, smart , expensive, high-precision missiles, we mentioned that we have 40 days approaching, that there is already an attack on vinnytsia this is my month of strikes on vinnytsia, more than a month of strikes

on kremenchuk, hits right in the central square , shopping centers, residential buildings. how do you, as a person who is familiar with military equipment, assess the accuracy of these strikes? it was a mistake of the missile or the receiver of these missiles, please no, i think that modern russian missiles are quite accurate, but er, probably, er, they lack er, er, such er, er, such er, er, that is why er, er they use old soviet, soviet ones maps, they use some kind of stupidity, they don’t see, for example, the hangar, and i think that in this hangar there may be some

ukrainian equipment or people or soldiers, that ’s why they attack this hangar that's why i don't think that the latest russian missiles are not accurate, they are accurate , but so are we. in my opinion, there is not enough intelligence about the terror of the civilian population. e in my opinion, they will try to keep it going. that is, this is a conscious maintenance of this tension. viktor and what they say in israel, we have been talking about the mining of chernobyl for three days, they wanted the chernobyl zaporizhzhya nuclear power plant, which was captured by the russians at the beginning of the war, and now they

keep military equipment and bc there and declared that they mined the station and are ready to blow it up in the event of an attack by ukrainians there, liberation energodar, what do they say in israel? regarding this situation, please, are people informed at all about what is happening there? yes, it was uh, on those, it was uh, the changing israeli snake spread this information, it worries the whole world in israel is also uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, the state of the zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant, that's why it's such a hot, rather hot topic here, how do you assess the overall dynamics of the advance of the front line from the east to the south? in a month, the successes of the army in a month of russia

in donbas, this is an advance of 10 km to bakhmut, in other parts of donetsk region, in lanchyna, the success of the so -called advance of the enemy was no more than 3 km , can it be called a successful special operation that are they an unsuccessful war an unsuccessful offensive , i ask for your assessment extremely that this cannot be called a successful operation uh, it looks more like this at this stage of the war, ukraine has er has some success in this struggle because it is exactly er because

of what ukraine has been doing in the last er sundays er russia is transferring troops to the kherson directions and this and i i hope that this is the idea of ​​the general staff of the armed forces of ukraine to transfer these forces to the fact that are they weak in that direction, are they ready, are they preparing for an offensive in that direction, or are they preparing for defense, in your opinion, first of all, this indicates that they are currently reacting to the actions of ukrainian er-er ukrainian er-er soldiers, they er-er are forced to react and what they will er-er what they er-er will do next it depends on er-er on er-er the decision of the russian , specifically the russian er-er armed forces er-er in my opinion er-er it is likely that they will try

to attack -e in the kherson or e-e or near the kryvyi rih direction and it will be e-e not bad for of the ukrainian armed forces, because the hm is prepared in advance within the limits, it will be possible to grind these last airborne formations that were transferred to that direction" israeli military major sakhal and iryna koval are ready to tell ukraine and the world the news directly now iryna good afternoon, thank you, colleagues