i won't count it's not the 14th year it's the 22nd another role of social media other recording capabilities and so on and so on and so on anyway well i can say right now with 95% certainty that they will just give up on 9/11 they feel that they don't have enough effort, they don't even have enough effort to recruit the so -called heads of local administrations, they bring them from kaliningrad, they bring them from ryazan, they take different young people there, they put them here already as ministers and so on, it looks ridiculous, but this is an indicator that no one does not go to cooperation with the occupier. pay attention to the documents of the offensive of the ukrainian military, and we can talk about this with our next speaker, but thank the voters of ukraine. thank you, a huge optimistic view. the only thing i want to add to mr. stupak about the fsb is that oleksiy. i

was just researching this today . through the so-called russian mass media, and there is a very interesting moment that the opposition people who follow exactly what is happening and tell such half-truths , they say that the most knowledgeable the organization of the russian federation, namely the fsb, does not want to push an officer into the kherson region. it is very difficult, they do not want to go there. they know that the military will go there. they do not know, and the fsb officers who know, no one wants to go there. it is a huge problem to find people who will do all this. well, if they were to serve from the point of view of the fsb, the occupied territories are stupid, there would be no officers there. they know everything. they can read and no one goes there. so there is another problem that mr. losii said that we are full of fsb there, not full of fsb because i think there er, what is it called, the voice of a partisan is audible, very

audible, especially in the last few days, and they blew up a--a settlement in the luhansk region, i don't remember a ---the collaborator's car directly, and the same thing that mr. koshel mentioned when the collaborators were cut down , and it's now... it happens every day while the military expert ivan stupak is with us. good day, studio. i congratulate you. good health. good health. what is happening, mr. ivan, in the east? i can't understand whether there is a front there. are the muscovites still advancing because they say that in the last month well, they passed 10 km, how can you say, to what extent do your thoughts match - your imagination about it coincides with what i read well, indeed, we operate with data from open sources and we see messages, then the slides are pressing, then ours are being taken back a little and the situation is really changing. well, nothing it's strange that we can

sometimes once every six hours there, certain settlements can change from hand to hand. it really is, but it's important that the friend of the world who said that we would wash our boots in the indian ocean for a while there, but they got stuck in the donetsk direction they haven't been able to advance for almost 6 months. that is, it already shows a great achievement of the ukrainian army, that is, you won't break through the protamanian ocean and that's it. here they are stuck somewhere in the donetsk region, nothing is moving. and just before your inclusion, i saw a message from anton herashchenko that the orcs are starting to evacuate for the dnipro river yes, i understand that, and this is exactly my question, because i was definitely not involved in military affairs, and my last name is not a funk clause, but when i am told that the concentration of troops in the south is increasing and

they even hint that ukraine may postpone the counteroffensive to a later date, and the russians are taking troops from the eastern direction, so there is a relaxation there. well, as i understand it, and but they are still pressing, what is going on there, after all, they found somewhere in russia some troops, also because i can't understand where their troops come from, that they advance there and stay there no, well, let's note right away that they are advancing with manpower, well, a little later. young a young technician, and indeed all the best troops are russian special forces there, landing forces, marines , they are all in the south, in the kherson region, and there in the east, the russians are still in any kind. they are mobilized. but the mobs - this is what people from ardlo are pulling there.

do you remember being there ? grandfathers stand in the photos and say that we are going to fight the fascists in ukraine. well, let's see, they really have such potential that they can move because of inertia. there are many warehouses with weapons there with ammunition. - less they preserved it, they concreted it in the east, but in the south they have to save. they also saw what a prospect it was to lose the kherson watermelons by the end of august, and they began to drag everything that can be dragged there, this accumulation today or there is the report of the head of british intelligence. he says that until the new year, the front will stand well, he assumes, he does not say so, but he says, well, it seems that what this means is that despite providing ukraine with even more military capabilities, namely weapons, we

will continue, do we still have the potential until the next one, if they will continue to supply weapons in such quantities as they have already started to supply recently. yes, i have heard such a statement. indeed, for all ukrainians, it was so, to put it mildly, not encouraging. for many years, everyone has gone down. if all that is the new year, i will say at least yes, he is also a person. we remember that there is not only british intelligence, there are british scientists, they are not always objective. in ukraine, well, two days, well, a maximum of three, we are not considering the question of whether kyiv will fall or not, it will definitely fall in just a matter of time. well, 170 days have passed and no one has fallen. that is, their analysts were wrong

, so please be calm. let's put it this way, with this statement, we really have a serious prospect, we have armed chains, er, weapons supply, they are not interrupted, and ukraine is doing everything for this, so that they do not break through, not for a second, not for a minute, that's why we calmly believe in merit everything will be fine. can we state that after all, the rashistas decided to completely occupy donetsk and luhansk regions and directly hold their positions, which they have already occupied for half a day, and part of the territory they occupied until this moment and some other offensives there, as it was reported that from belarus or another offensive or what will happen, that there will be an attempt to go to kyiv and so on, there will be no such thing in the near future, why can't we say so. so while you are starting from the end, look at all the e-e messages about there

it seems that belarus is preparing to go to kyiv again, yes, indeed, such a threat is always there, we do not reject it, we cannot say 100%, then it is nonsense, this was done in order for our troops to keep part of the troops there in the belarusian direction, that extremely large section of the border we we hold it there, and if there was an opportunity we could withdraw the troops, it would be much more difficult for the russians to hold kherson, well, your capital. that is why we are now so stretched across the entire er part of the front. this is the second time. what do the russians have in mind? the minimum task for them well of course at this stage it is to go to the border of luhansk donetsk and then say everything ukrainians sit down at the negotiating table europeans let's end the war ah accept the realities that exist now we will cut off from ukraine donetsk luhansk region plus a part of kherson well of course there they were able to take a bite out of the zaporizhzhia

region, accept it later in case everything there turns out as they plan, and after a 3-4 year pause, they will rewind the sanctions and make a real import substitution and somewhere there for the fourth or fifth year they return again under the old slogan reunification of originally russian lands of the kherson and zaporozhye regions, that is, the war will be 3:0 there, it will start again, that is, this is such a simple strategy of the russian federation. and look at ivan , one more question. well, look at 10 km of millet, but on the other hand, i understand that even the entire luhansk region up to the administrative border is occupied by the russians. the minimum, namely the seizure of the administrative

borders of luhansk and donetsk regions, will they be able to carry out whether the train has already left, the train really did not leave, but i want you to understand that even if they capture 99% of luhansk region and so on, one percent will stick out right here in this place in them and he will not give rest, you know well, the gestalt is not closed well, it must be closed and there will be no victory even this one percent is a formality there odnesylsk region donetsk region luhansk we know there and what about donetsk region they continue to have these rosy dreams in the throat of this mmmshchik, they have dreams, they are planning something there to create some kind of resort areas, recreational areas, although there are beekeepers, although the beekeeper says there that he was caught.

no one will restore the entire ruin. i want everyone to understand this, but there were no hopes. yes, okay. so what about daurionism and what is happening there ? borders on a solid russian-ukrainian former border and the russians can no longer advance to kharkiv. what is happening in this area ? kharkiv will now receive constant flights. of course, such and such a place that is flourishing constantly receives uh, because the russians have the opportunity to reach the creation of kharkiv by artillery. unfortunately , the priorities of both ukraine and the russians have changed so far, that is, now all the roads converge somewhere before noon .

to draw troops there, i.e. in the region of the raisin no, we, well , we can't, the russians can't have such a plus-minus parity there, the war is going on, but there is no one's special advantage there, neither the russians over us nor our advantage over the russians, this is the status quo but here in the south it's just the south is a more emotional story, the only regional center that the russians managed to take is kherson, if they lose it, well, it's just a telegram channel, and that's where the russians are, they're just going to break their promises there - i'm sorry, they're going to smell it and it's going to stink for another week 3-4 and it's going to have the long-term consequences for them are still interested in the subject of mr. ivan and the explosions at the zyabrka military airfield in belarus, and some military experts say that hmm, well, first of all, the maxar company released satellite images and it can be seen that there were clusters of russian military equipment and directly behind the opinions according to some

experts, there could be very serious complexes of s-300 or s-400 zeni missile military trucks and radar systems, tell me if you know about what we could really destroy and in general how much will it weaken the russian army about this ? the airport is an airfield, or rather it was used there by the soviet army for basing planes, the carcasses that could carry bombers could carry nuclear weapons, that is, it is not just some ordinary airfield, it really went into serious decline somewhere in the 90s, it was abandoned there and here, now there, the russians are coming back , taking it into operation, i don’t know what there, renting , leasing, there. well, they take whatever they want from belarus, and as far as i know, without notification, again, our military had anti-missile complexes there

s300-400 squadrons stood er and er radar stations, and i am more convinced that whoever hit these objects er, the target was not these s3400 complexes, well , this is nonsense, it was the radar stations and maybe from the canders that fired at that including our territory, we still do not officially know who is really smoking . what do we not know? well, i don't know what to do, because i'm afraid. let's quit, it's harmful, it's harmful, i see that people smoke and that's it i'm already in the house, i think i've been and will go out somewhere because something will explode in the house well, it's not serious, well, listen, we're quitting in ukraine, and there let

our neighbors start. no, if we have joined, there is nothing better to discuss about what we will probably start with. no, about the new fedorivka, by the way, yes, this week was partly marked by a-a, hmm , the new fedorivka, that is, the explosions at this military airfield in saki, in the crimea, and directly ukraine is so official, did you see the message from the ministry of defense very sarcastically, they reacted to it all, it all seems media cool to me. well, it’s like that, you already know, i said it very conditionally only when i moved to lviv and started working here, i constantly said that the mood plays a super important role when we we see that the russians are so frowning, serious, they are discussing something serious. and the ukrainians

were already joking and invented them until then, smiling despite the war, despite death. and now even the ministry of defense allows itself somehow to ironize it means the health of the nation, the nation is healthy, it understands that there is a time for sadness, there is a time for smiles , and there is a time for sarcasm, etc. - this is a person, she cries at the right time, she laughs at the right time, that is, god does everything. and when you look at what is happening in russia , you understand that they have uh-uh, what kind of concerns do they have, or moreover, yesterday i studied the so-called liberals and there are also concerns those that they are not being released or are planning not to be released abroad

and this is so it is so so terrible i just called my friends there and we discussed the north that they are invisible and who am i i have one question okay the russians are not to blame it is only putin and who do we what what to do with that, he is shooting, he is not this one, he presses the buttons, one there on this one, so that the missiles fly to ukraine, or he flies there on planes and drops bombs, maybe we don’t know something, we don’t know something , i have such a refection of the crimean tatar people, we can already with us add him to our live broadcast, we congratulate you. good health. i'm glad to see you. it's very nice to see you and to see your smile despite the war. so, mr. refate, tell me honestly what 's happening in crimea. you know the mood in crimea. i sometimes read what's there. the majority of the population. well, we about the

crimean tatars, where do we speak because there we understood the patriots of ukraine at least 95%. we also understand that there is a certain number of people who are not crimean tatars, who are also patriots, but recently there has been some information that i liked it very much. one woman gave an interview and said that every normal crimean has a piece of paper where he writes down the names of the collaborators he sees around him, and i liked it very much. i liked it very much . this is related to as you said, different people with different expectations accept or reject the russian occupiers, but we will proceed from the fact that the majority of the people of crimea still like them, er, they are waiting for restoration

of the state sovereignty of the ukrainian state and all these eight years. they heard a very well- formulated message that we will return, that we will restore sovereignty, that crimea is ukrainian, people supported it, but it was rhetoric, and finally on september 9, people received, but first, such a certificate that all the words there were virgins. what does ukraine think about the occupied crimea and ukraine will do everything in order to clear it from the occupiers, but a large part of the people thought er and are thinking about it er, you know i already say it in many interviews, but this is it there is a part of our crimean tatar life, when something so joyful happens in us, well, let's say a child was born in the family,

or there are guests, but the neighbors come to the one to whom something joyful is like that and say the goat, let's go, that is , you have joy. and he serves coffee and that everyone is called kolesi or in ukrainian - this is holiday coffee, but people still drink holiday coffee in crimea on the ninth of september, this is absolutely true, they call and tell about it, but there are those who settled in crimea after the occupation, and there are many of them or rather, there are a lot of them, according to the occupation authorities, such russian citizens who settled in crimea after 2014 are about 600,000 , according to independent experts, about a million , and this is the artificial settlement of crimea, the relocation of its population, we understand why this is happening, because somewhere

there very deeply aware of the fact that when it will still have to come under pressure from crimea, moscow thinks that after leaving crimea, it will remain with its people there. i am sure when the families and fsb officers and the occupation resistance and so on. i think that with the approach of the armed forces of ukraine they will approach chongara, and by the way, i see, i said in chongara, i immediately remembered. i think what you said about it but it has already happened literally for about an hour and a half. therefore, very good attacks, strong attacks on the territories of the kherson region, by ukrainian artillerymen, and one of the powerful blows came on chaplinka, which is literally 15-16 km of crimea

from the administrative network, where this armyansk the city and the titanium factory. so i just mentioned it to the point that, well, the people who call, they say that you should not stop, there is sevastopol with berths where russian warships stand, and finally there is a bridge, or a bridge over the kerch strait, over which they roll day and night troops from the territory of russia's own territory on the territory of the occupied crimea. therefore, the people also have a task, well, it's not a task , people expect it from the armed forces of ukraine, and if such messages will now be systemic, the spirit of the people will be on the rise all the time. and from this a lot will depend on their behavior as well, mr. rifat, look at a very important question, well

, i understand that you have to knock on wood, i do it this way because there is no tree near here, but when i imagine an optimistic scenario, which, by the way, you also described, i don't know, i don't i knew that chaplinka was being beaten by the chaplinkas, and i was very happy about it, because i often rested in those areas. i was like that for one night . and nova kakhovka 50 km this is official denmark. look. and here we imagine an optimistic scenario and ukrainian rockets destroy that kerch bridge . there are also problems in chongar in chaplinka. then crimea

is surrounded and does anyone in the ukrainian leadership think about what to do with those people who came to crimea we will not shoot them, we are a civilized country, so there remains, as you yourself said , from 200,000 to a million immigrants from russia who will not be able to leave because there are no more bridges. so they should have been warned earlier, so what should be done earlier yes, well, they need to be fed with something, i don’t know, somehow i don’t give them a toilet, well, that is, well, it’s a whole problem, what to do with those who arrived. look, it’s absolutely correct, we are not russian barbarians, uh, and it’s clear that uh, that’s all we’re going to do is will be absolutely within the limits of national legislation and especially international humanitarian legislation , we are now calling on these people not to wait until these cataclysms that you

spoke about occur, so that they do not occur, there is no doubt that they should already leave for their lands their homeland, because in my heart they all realize that they live like thieves on someone else's land, using someone else's property, and i have no doubts about that. well, they are not the same. forgive me, they are stupid or stupid, that's the first thing we call them, but we have to prepare. from the point of view of legislation, we have to improve our legislation, because there it is stipulated that foreigners or stateless persons illegally staying on our land are subject to administrative punishment, and you are outside the borders of ukraine but when you have one, two, 100, and when you have a million of these illegal aliens, that's why we need to improve the law, which allows us, let 's say, with the help of international mechanisms

, to help these people get there, if they are innocent, if they have not committed crimes, because there are very many nuances, we, as the medzhibiskrim-tatar people, are now trying to actualize this issue not only in ukraine, well, but at the national level. recently, when we had mrs. secretary general of the council of europe in may, we talked about this problem and they said that it is necessary to discuss it now on international platforms so that later it does not become, you know, such an opening for human rights defenders, they say it is human rights, they are not to blame, they did not think or listen to distort our will of the crimean tatars, ukrainians living in crimea, they cannot there stay and decide our fate with your vote, one more question about our brothers, about the crimean tatar people, let's imagine optimism again, but we know that

the most physically affected by this are the crimean tatar representatives, whom they condemn who are sitting in russia, who are being judged mostly. as i understand it, they are sitting there in rostov-on-don, and they are sitting there. the question is, in the case of an optimistic view of the future, how to get them out of these prisons, where are they ? what are we , what are we all hoping for? there are a lot of citizens of ukraine. i don't know the statistics, but i feel that those who are sitting in prisons on the territory of russia actually are political prisoners. crimean political prisoners are a special category, but they are not the only ones. i do not rule out that worsening the situation for moscow, they will hastily transfer to their territory and

prisoners of war who are currently being held in the occupied ukrainian territories, in particular in donetsk . to say about what development option there will be for this or that period, but all the same, when we are talking now and communicating with the audience, we still get some kind of picture , expectedly from one of our sides, but imagine that tomorrow kherson will be liberated from the armed forces forces of ukraine will approach crimea on the administrative border, how will the other sides of the sands and defeat on the russian side, we have to imagine that there will be some processes inside russia, including that in this den of bandits

called the kremlin . well, if you like the idea that this process exists, they will already testify about the fall of that regime, and we need to prepare various options, including in order to find communications with those who will come to power, i don't want to say but in moscow specific regions of russia. i really want the geographical dimensions of that russian federation with the victory of ukraine to be completely different, so that their effect is still a very important question for us, and at the beginning of the full-scale invasion of the russian federation in the occupied part directly in crimea, it increased the violation of human rights, discrediting and torture, torture, illegal , illegal arrest, or vice versa, completely weakened

the fire because of the relationship because it is connected with the fact that the russian occupiers want to establish control over society or crimea is a border territory where hostilities take place and before the repressions , the depression spread beyond the borders of crimea, they are now in the kherson and zaporizhzhia regions, and there crimean tatars are also the object of persecution of the crimean tatars. but again, not only crimea from the tatars, all ukrainian patriots, we thank the chubarov effect, the head of the forest of the ukrainian tatar people, take our patience and expectation of ukrainian victories, this is what i convey through rifat to all the crimean tatar people, how are you so far, our dear tv viewers you can ask questions september colors 18:40 we will have an interactive on the official espresso.tv page on facebook as well as in the live chat of espresso.tv on our youtube channel