so to play democracy about my motherland-motherland and where when democracy harms us and mr. oleksandr, we are forced to interrupt the conversation with you. i think that next time because we still have many topics and we will agree on other topics as well . explanation of oleksandr alferov and historian, researcher of the institute of history of ukraine, nan of ukraine, was with us and he has a blog, by the way, a lot of people now feel the need to fill out programs very briefly in this opinion, what if, for example, us something important needs to be done, for example in the field of economics, we don't ask everyone's opinion, and this is done simply by people who understand economics, for some reason they think that culture is a place where everyone understands absolutely everything, well, it's really not like that, it's not like that, it's about history, it 's science it should be known and historians should decide patriotic and not pro-russian so and everything we will soon return so that ukrainians do not think about so that they do not

speak in the first place anyway war war and our victory seven days a week with monday from monday, seven different spheres of human activity, sport, culture, politics, eight express presenters, journalists, experts, opinion leaders in real time about the most relevant events through the lens of war, every day author's projects on espresso in airplane cabins behind the monitors of radar stations at the control points of anti-aircraft missile systems at thousands of combat positions throughout the territory of our country, they bring victory closer every day. glory to the air force of the armed forces of ukraine, the war in ukraine is the main topic for ukrainians victories and losses, analysis and forecasts, politics and

geopolitics, serhiy rudenko and the guests of his program will talk about all this, people who have information and shape public opinion, people who defend ukraine and create the future right now, the main and interesting thing in the program is the verdict of serhiy rudenko from monday to thursday at 1 p.m. :00 repeat at 21:30 well, i can't come to terms with the fact that there is no more light and heat in the house, it's scary as never but someone has to do it they work honestly i have to collect the trash we're trying to do more do it in a heartbeat, every city and every district will get used to it. that is, it is all over, so that people return to the beauty and order protects the tokovina, if you want, and it will be cool, utility workers battalion,

glory to ukraine. here is our front, some creatures are surprised by the toilet in the house. and we from ukraine can insure cars, be it in the toilet hotline finance insurance of course online well, we are glad to welcome you again to espresso to see you andriy saichuk and i, lesya vakulyuk, the next hour will be spent in our company and also in the company of other people, and it's our turn johann wild political military expert public activist former platoon commander of the aydar battalion and head of the national antarctic science center we congratulate you mr. yevhen glory to ukraine glory

to the heroes glory to ukraine right away let's ask you what is happening in our country at the front in your opinion , the british head of intelligence said what should not be done in the country strongly hope that she will take there, for example, kherson and so on, and that the war will be long, what do you think about it, and yours , how does the situation in donbas look to him now i can say that the british intelligence, which has much better information than the three of you and me together, so the sign is delicate, the british marking is very informed, and when it is currently publishing the same thing that i already wrote about a month ago, it is located the verb is similar to the truth,

so to speak, different people with different sources of information about which you plan to record, but at the front it is very difficult at the moment. there is really no pause for a day, but they were looking for some more creative solutions, they were looking for what they should do with us, uh, nothing. fortunately , they never came up with a really breakthrough, as a result, they simply returned to the same uh, tactics of supporting the filling ground, that is, when ahead there is a barrage of fire , and artillery is also created, and only when one of them fires some area, let’s say it is for the next kilometer, relatively speaking, as a person, and when there is simply physically already there, there is not

a single normal building left. when, in principle, we don’t there is a place to keep the defense, but only then it goes there and goes there, but i don’t want to, it’s very slow and very expensive for them, so ticks, for the whole last month, they are on the best direction for themselves, it’s emphasized for 30 days of difficult gods they took 10 km from the best direction, in several other directions, 3 km, 3 km in a month, this is the speed of the advance of this shaft of fire, this is the speed, you know, the speed of a tired, pregnant morning, but unfortunately, they are not able to invent anything better, but unfortunately, at with all the slowness, and this method is, well, in the end, it is very effective, because to contain this fire, but without

parity in the artillery. balance, until what moment does it still make sense to keep another completely destroyed piece of our land? and from what moment the costs become uh, well, now let's say that the losses of our people become unjustified in this situation, and this next one from below is better a piece of land uh retreat move to the next next position and the next for example in a month hold it already this choice is very difficult every time it has to be done only there on the spot this is this is what is not visible from kyiv what is called uh and uh in the end, it turns out like this: they continue to crawl forward, they continue the asphalt rink and it hasn’t stopped until the end, so they roll around your territory, but the speed of this rink is 3 km per month. that

is, from the point of view of military strategy that's all it's nothing if their terrorist holes are still there a month ago he shouted that at such a pace they will occupy the whole of donbas, i emphasize only donbas in the best case for the first frosts, the letter the other day he already shouted the exact opposite, he even started to talk about taking donbass is all out of the question and it is possible for them. it is time to think about old proven strategies to lure the enemy to moscow before winter and to wall ice cream here and there . unfortunately, this forecast is optimistic and not the most important thing to follow them, look for yourself there the mediator prays is standing, but it shows that this is their strategy, it is not a strategic trip, but yes, of course, it brings us every day significant exercises, that is, to survive under

this continuous barrage of artillery fire is extremely difficult for our defenders on the eve of the line in first of all, you see, they didn’t come close enough. well , in zaporozhye, they are not an exaggeration to say that they survive every day and we get spheres, but they survive in a cell. well, the enemy then started to play. in a clinical cake, our language does not have this expression, but in russian there is a little bit of it, when to sew up a hole in one place, they cut off a birdcage in another place, well, the rational thing is that the ukrainians are somehow helped, where russia is normal, so, uh, on the front, we are now a little bit we put uh, we scared them with the prospect of a counteroffensive, and under kherson, uh, they decided that at least they had to repulse it, uh, not to give up kherson, and as much as possible, on the contrary, uh, overtake our combined attack, and i'm angry there, and as

a result, for so that everything becomes at least in technologies maybe they transfer parts from all other directions, which is from kharkiv, the main thing . we don’t have enough iron and shells, and they don’t have enough living people, so uh, since they have an operation under a special operation, you can’t declare a general mobilization, so accordingly, with the methods that are available to them now, they don’t even serve to the end and the losses that were in general , that is, their groups are actually exhausted by people, and therefore they are not able to form any new units, and here the area is guarded, and the forced reactions are a little bit like this, throwing troops from one to the other, because

now they have the maximum concentration to understand kherson, i these on our side, it was a huge mistake to just take boxing and try to storm kherson from here. the expected attack on kherson has created too high expectations that by the time you reach maturity, kherson has ours. well, what about watermelon? well, maybe we will have to survive this season without canceling the technology. the defense of the enemy without sufficient, actually, without parity, and so i think, i hope that it is dry because of the public mood, because

of these, and, overstated wishes, and our commanders made up, still, i will not say what we the people demand, so let's try, i think that's all after all, urban wisdom prevailed in this case. if we don't have enough iron to buy a chair, then we take it to god. we are building bridges for today. by the way, all four bridges are already in our store. so we are exhausting this group. maybe it will take a month or two, and we may even have to overwinter, because actually when the autumn showers leave, both sides were not there . if we use this winter wisely , first of all there will be a winter stretch for a lot

of things that have reached us now. manually issued a summons, then they gave an automatic machine with a wooden parliament and then one disk, there is no other way out. the land was our land and on my stomach our people who became hostages of this action. and we cannot afford to lose five to one of the advancing party in relation to what is being protected . it's clear how i trade, so accordingly we need to approach this more creatively, we need to seriously prepare for this. and how much time is needed for this preparation, and how much time do the armies need ? the main thing here is that the armies do not cut down the tasks, because

the public simply demands that you know comrade stalin of the spatial tasks of the time, to take kyiv, not to take it at all. but specifically, to the main point, they spoke to the anniversary of the october revolution , well, kyiv, who on november 6, 1943, the bees just put 300,000 red places on this one, that's not our methods. we shouldn't form like that ot and why does the army not have it as a sign, ot ot public demands, demands of the media, demands of politics, and not to allow it to work as a new one. she herself will consider it correct and better. and if it turns out that in kherson we will take for august, as it was promoted in november or even somewhere in april, believe me, this is not a tragedy. no, they also evaluate the final result, but for the correct final result , you do not need to wait and prepare and invest in some kind of preparation, and not just look

at public opinion, which people are tired of something, all victories mean the chickens were driven forward yes yes yes well, i hope there will be no fighting. well, the british actually come to the same opinion that to date we have not been very strong, but this is not at all the same as what is needed for a breakthrough boy, we stopped this asphalt ice rink . not the same as yes and the possibility of a breakthrough uh big strikes at uh great depth uh actually how is it already gone there is not enough in particular and what to go far there is not enough tank armor on which to plant our approach so we are preparing for this we are gathering from peace to thread, too

there, for this contract, we need to train people in such a way that now we already find 50,000 of ours undergoing training in great britain, and they will come with completely different dogs and administrative training, about 100. well, actually, that is, here. the main thing is to understand that this is a difficult , very difficult job that must be performed professionally and accordingly, it is necessary to give an opportunity to do it then and as the professionals will consider mr. evgeny, you said that russia is running out of manpower well, but there are 150 million yes 140 e-e 150 e-e we heard about that that these may be exaggerated data, valery pekar just said before you that no one really knows how many there are in russia and who exactly, but i am here to support it tom cooper by the way , an austrian such an amateur commentator also writes

about what they also have a lot of people and riot police, we can see that they messed up a little there with different limits. is a mirror we have we have a war, our patriotic war for our survival, for the preservation of our state, that is why we have total mobilization, we have already passed three minutes , but they have a different story, they have not declared a war, they have declared a special military operation . of course, the task is that they can only lure people into contracts or as much as they can still do it, a limited call-up of reservists for supposedly training, meetings that later, the truth, why stop on our territory

, that’s all, and that’s why they are starting now well, accordingly, the quality of such soldiers is absolutely appropriate, who is their business, what do they need to admit that this is actually a big, serious war in which they have plunged into, and not a special military operation, moreover, they will lose in this war. to announce a stand-up party for a huge er-e mobilize everyone, this is the birthday of what the terrorist has been demanding for six months now, namely mobilization, he is absolutely convinced that without it they are doomed, but for the kremlin regime to announce mobilization is already a significant miro to get, well, at least a huge miscalculation if and that's why they avoid it in every possible way , first of all, it is from the political mercury things that are economic, er, their economy is under sanctions, and they are having fun with it, points are very styrmfa, and now

imagine also withdrawing she has several hundred thousand partners. how quickly will she be called then? anti-war sentiments. it is one thing to support putin's regime by drawing a mirror in his mind's ruts. so here i am with a beer next to the tv and listening to solovyov's successful specialization. it’s a completely different story when you yourself are being mobilized and women are being mobilized and living in shorts, so uh, your mood can swing very much. and by the way, you are absolutely correct in pointing out that moscow and st. petersburg are now practically not covered by their absolutely mobilization institutions. and why are they, precisely because there are, uh, their reasons to believe that the reaction will be quite quietly patriotic, let's say, not at all the same as in individual cases, that's why, for all these reasons, they try in every way to avoid general mobilization, and then they people are avoiding a very big problem, er,

one of the occupied territories, they can afford everything, that's why they have already mobilized energy and energy. in reality, everything is fine, because of the fact that they even arrested and chased these people twice there, that is, they are already burning their own. when there are no women the front line and precisely because there are simply not enough people, but in russia they don’t do this, they were there only to entice the tsarev to serve. here ’s something the further the further the less i want and the slides on here we have already mentioned him twice in our conversation with you, he is having hiccups somewhere, why was he suddenly detained in the crimea? well, i believe that it is all the arrestee, that he ordered a competitor through some of his connections, but if they really are , who will we read, but how bad everything is you cheered up the russian side of the front

, well, it lifted the spirits of others, i say, it’s just leaflets to competitors. well, if he was joking with us, i am absolutely convinced that they have either already released it or very soon will release their own raven, raven, you, girkin, is doing something there relatively independent steps in russia do not like such a person in principle, but pay attention to the fact that he is allowed such a level of criticism of the south that he is already killing at what cost. from the kremlin's point of view, they have not made up their minds enough. that's right. they are ready to allow such criticism because it is criticism that generally supports the degree of hatred towards us, and at the same time , he is in a very mobilizing mood, he is telling the russians that ukraine must be destroyed, and to destroy even for any even a very high one for the russian federation so we will be yours thank you

mr. yevgeny for your e-e notes of humor at the end of our conversation yevgeny is a wild political military expert and public project i remember very well the beginning of the war p yevheny has always been such a very optimistic commentator, and life has shown that his optimistic predictions not only came true , but even they were somewhat pessimistic compared to what actually happened, and this is fantastic , so we listen to mr. yevgena. and now he is listening, maybe in fact, by myroslav marinovych, one of the founders of the ukrainian helsinki group, a dissident in the soviet era, the vice-rector of the ukrainian catholic university in our time, so, mr. myroslav, we are glad to see you. congratulations, glory to ukraine, glory to the heroes, myroslav, if you open wikipedia, there is an article about you there that you had a

meeting with your mother. me and my sister in a special room and two hours meeting with them through the glass your correspondence was subject to censorship at the slightest suspicion letters were confiscated after the arrest e-e worldwide the human rights organization emnosti international took marinovych under its protection as a prisoner of conscience er-e we must tell our viewers that you served er-e punishments in soviet times a-a very far from ukraine so, emnosti international then and now what is wrong a maybe you think that everything is the same with this organization, what has changed, maybe we have changed, and they have remained in their positions, yes, of course, this organization has undergone a very unfortunate evolution, because in my time, when they protected

not only me, but also many ukrainian political prisoners, the main focus of this organization was to protect prisoners of conscience, that is, those who, through non-violent resistance, fought for authoritarian regimes, and this was a very honorable mission, which was initiated by the founder of amnesty international, peter benson, and continued until the end of the organization focus she always evoked great gratitude from all those whom she protected and i am really even today critical about this statement but at the same time i want to thank this organization for the very important they help and support, but what happened, this focus

has changed, i have already forgotten which of the 90s , when the mandate of amnesty international was expanded by the members of amnesty international , its er assembly, and other er hmm other er rights were included there amnesty international considers it necessary to protect lgbt people in particular, and the attention of the members of amnesty international has shifted. this is the

first . let's talk about, let's say, the crimes of russia, and there were such statements in the international city, then it is necessary to supplement them with accusations against ukraine, and then they say that the organization will have its own truth, so to speak. but this is in this situation it's absurd because i'm sorry for the politically incorrect comparison but for me it always means that the rape victim is also guilty of this crime because she behaved wrongly and she provoked it by accident in this case we

certainly don't have emotions i uh i don't rule it out i don't have no war and no army, and no matter how many cases of violations of international law are tried, it is impossible to issue a statement regarding the violations of the ukrainian side, in fact, without even mentioning the crimes of the russian federation, so it is clear that the desire will be objective played on e signal hunter of the bear post played for international amnesty and they signed in their on the contrary er very engaged pro-russian p myroslava i apologize immediately to the audience and to les and everyone

for the fact that i will try to go a little deeper into the territory now to enter, well, having just such an interlocutor, this is a problem of moral relativism in general, when everyone is right and you are right and there is no black and white, how much is this a problem at all, because it, for example , confused me a little that before the war there was a message that pope francis was going to withdraw from the car a just war as such, it cannot be a just war, so don't we have this wider problem, not only amnesty international, but also wider and the societies that support us now, western and western politicians can also to suffer from this moral relativism, it makes one vulnerable. so we are dealing with a sign of our civilization, which is in principle a very great achievement, but today they turn to us on the negative side, what i mean is that the era of

postmodernism has arrived without anything that no one has absolutely truths none of us humans have this absolute truth. each of us is right to begin with, but often we are wrong, but just as the one who seeks the truth must find it as the arithmetic mean of our embraces of our thoughts and only then will it be possible to find it this provoked the truth, it caused great relativism in the assessment of rights. once there is no truth, then the next step was that there is absolutely no truth, and accordingly, everyone got drunk in something and did not inoculate in something , and this developed in western civilization this mandatory rule to find the

mandatory for every good it's bad because only then we supposedly have an objective uh situation i'm very sad that ukraine today are considered to be guilty of this conflict, by the way, a few days ago i had a dialogue, uh, the first such dialogue was ukraine africa. we spoke with the south representatives of south africa, and in africa it is very common to believe that ukraine bears the blame for starting this war because it for longing