quite collapsed eh, probably in connection with everything that is happening in ukraine ah and he himself admitted that putin told him on the eve of the war that ukraine and belarus should not be independent, but it is strange that he eh if he received these signals from putin, but somehow did not react. it turns out that i think that they understood everything perfectly, but there is a certain analysis of putin's personality. they thought that he was apparently bluffing again about all his promises that he had made before that he would not go to military scenario ie he will try to act hybridly by hybrid means, that is, there was a miscalculation. well, let's remember that on february 24, the head of german intelligence was in kyiv, yes. that is, he was also suddenly taken hostage by these events, therefore, precisely with regard to germany. i think that they really need to revise their understanding of the russian federation and try to to act, well, that is, to move on to the

understanding of the countries of eastern europe and central europe, which understand what russia is, what the soviet union was, i wonder what the rejection of erdoğan might be, why will he go to early elections does he need it, or can there be surprises here, at least theoretically, the head of turkey can change, and if so, who could it be now , the ratings, again, the elections should officially be held in june next year, but just the economic the situation inside turkey itself on the eve of a rather difficult winter requires some quick actions from erdoğan, that is, those indicators, in particular, inflation of 80% per year, and this drop in currency, which is happening at a very

slow pace, forces him to use at the moment, at the moment, erdoğan is very actively conducting political actions aimed at improving the image of turkey - this is, in particular, the issue of the russian-ukrainian war, this is an issue in syria, and erdoğan is primarily interested in reaching certain agreements and returning those syrian refugees who live in turkey, it is also a matter of reconciliation with israel, that is, what atlan is doing now, he wants to use it for his domestic success , and if we consider the domestic political situation, then there er because of just bad er economic er parameters er the party is reprimanded it has now lost its leadership in the first place the republican party ah well but there is a difference of a few percent before

saying that some force can quickly replace erdoğan it's hard enough, but really there are such politicians as merinkars, he claims to take the position of prime minister, in particular, he belongs to the professional republican party, i.e. andriy karakuts, the head of the non-governmental organization center of applied research and public organizations, the center of international security and candidates of historical sciences were with us we are going further and we are adding to our e-e-e conversation yaroslav buzhka - this is a political consultant and oleksiy hlybocki, a political technologist and the head of the center for political studies, doctrine, congratulations, gentlemen, congratulations, congratulations, let's start again for sure after all, from the death of my daughter , i don’t even know how to properly say an ideologue in russian, and here is such an appeal that says they are taking this responsibility, although i already suspect that who does not already it is your responsibility that others prepare themselves

, however, how do you see it? well, what can this mean in principle. this is a murder, let's start. well, i don't know, mr. oleksiy, let's go with you. well, do you understand this? i've already read so many versions. i just read that it is dugin himself from the fsb, so if you want to evoke sympathy from putin, who loves maybe only his daughters, he sacrificed his daughter in order to finally force putin to go for the option of war that he thinks is more necessary for the present of the day yes, he is very much, i don’t know, the second is not enough recently. yes, he is a supporter of this line, which is total war, that this issue is not just a

solution of some kind, without the issue of security, this is a question of the survival of the russian state and, uh, a special operation, it will not be solved, these tasks need to be total the war against ukraine against the west for russian civilization, the story of what is this idiot , she was acquainted with a blind candidate for the president of france, and she was allegedly involved in the transportation of money for the campaign of these the money disappeared well, that's when the answer went, so to speak, and many other belts are just the ones that are most interesting to me. therefore, here you understand to believe that our special services, of all the tasks, understand this is not easy, it's practically moscow. and this is serious organizational work for that to kill the arcs on well,

it's just hard for me to believe it , it seems to me well, from this point of view, it was more important . yes, because he is a war criminal, he is a person who really took part in the capture of ukraine, and the second is, well. at this stage, he appears to us somehow an important person at the time, it really is a marginal personality, which is especially important in russia. it just so happens that these marginals are in the russian mainstream, but in the authoritarian system, the mainstream can represent and lead and in general only the leader of the country, i.e. putin yes, well, there cannot be ideologues, uh, other uh, except for putin, and there may be some of his entourage. well, it is possible, uh, and the partisans

, so to speak, are russian . i don’t know any internet la-lacators, where did they come from, who are they? no, it’s clear that from an informational point of view, from an informational point of view - this is a good start of some kind of information, we will understand that this is all of this, uh, the car explodes if not those who did it are caught on the spot, so it is possible later, after all, yes, any organization, eh. that is, it will be a good start for such an organization, you mean. it can be absolutely ritualistic, that is, yes, it can exist exclusively in a computer, exclusively social networks, and you take responsibility for it, and of course, this is what the name will sound like. and it will be good, so to

speak. well, i don't want to just frame ilya in some way in the sense that i don't believe it, well, me, me it's hard for you to understand, russia proved its history that uh, 20 years ago, so what can exist, just can militants and terrorists follow them, yes, it was 25 years ago, there are 200-300 km of people crying 100 dollars at each checkpoint and then take over the hospital yes, well, this is the famous basaev, yes, yes, on the other hand, what the fsb can safely do this to solve some of your questions, so to speak, the whole country. well , in this regard, it is completely uncontrollable , not predictable, and that is why it is here. i am afraid that this is this incident. is this a murder?

to well, well, two or three more days and we'll just forget about it, mr. yaroslav, let's say ksenia sobchak, whom many ukrainians considered to be such a russian woman who is on the side of the ukrainians, who supports ukraine, and here a message appeared from her yesterday that uh, don't touch children, why are you touching children and i am thinking the same one that was with a certain icon for our human rights defenders, many ukrainians, also similar, similar. even now, when there is a full-scale invasion, these people still remain good russians, ah. these are the statements about why they are touching the children of some arch ideologue of the russian world. ah, they will finally influence the ukrainians. they will stop seeing russians as good russians and look for something good

to hold on to like a lie. big problems, firstly, they are russian, and secondly, they are liberals, respectively, you know, already from these moralistic, somewhat hypocritical statements by ms. sobchak and ms. latina, uh, we begin to understand why these people do not were able to come close, at least theoretically, to the seizure of power in russia, because, well, imagine a fight with police officers would start and they would also write flowers like why touch omonians, why shoot fsb officers, these are children, these are conscripts, these are the same guys over there they spent 23 years in the hostel sorry, i also don’t believe in what this energy is. yes,

the national republican army, which took responsibility, is some kind of product of a completely russian position. it is most likely special services , either russian with some internal goal, or western. or maybe even ukrainian, although i doubt it mostly because there was no point in the large-scale liquidation of dugina's daughter as to whether ukrainians would stop accepting this nonsense about good russians and bad russians, eh, it honestly seems to me that the problem for people is because they perceive not so much the content of these messages. and they simply react loyally to some insults. for them, the source of the message, if it seems so trustworthy, is that it is some liberal poet, then they begin to believe what they say, and unfortunately for this person and people who still believe in these things, well, it persists, it is

primarily people who do not understand very well how politics works, i.e. cultural figures yes ot and sobchak and bykov there are other russians there hudkovyy svetami eh they all definitely can exist as some sort of russian cultural phenomenon. but i have little idea that this phenomenon would have at least some influence on russia politically. even if a revolution begins there, you know, this suggests an analogy with the pre-revolutionary party of spheres, which before the revolution was the most popular police force in russia empire, and then when the revolution suddenly happened, this party did not understand what to do in the new conditions, and the summons was saddled with the bolsheviks, of whom there were only a handful. the reactions of russian liberals and the fact that it is possible that the russian special services have turned to terror not just

against strangers, but to terror against their own people. well, in comparison, dugin was an adviser to the head of the russian foreign intelligence service on ryshkin, through arcs on establishing contacts with the western extreme right eh, yes, and it’s not only lepen and salvini and many such small marginal but far-right radical movements from many countries of the world, and suddenly terror begins against these people in russia, you know, this is the first marker of that great turmoil which is looming over this country and the specificity is that this turmoil for russia cannot be avoided, even if they achieve some tactical success in ukraine, even if they report tomorrow that they have captured the entire donbas there, this turmoil is still looming over russia and because of the lands she has under her control, the russians simply will not be able to avoid her. by the way, i

wanted to go to ksenia sobchak's page on instagram, because on facebook she is quite passive in 21 years of posts and instagram to me said that i can't go to ksenia sobchak's page because in my region, access to the profile is limited, so i think that she closed it from ukrainians or understood that there would be righteous anger . after her words, she mentioned gandhi there, ukrainians have something... it's a sit-in defiance to meet russian tanks, i'm surprised. it's just that there's a head of these people, but less so. i'd still like to briefly mention that we have, uh, well, we have such interesting characters, uh, from the last one, we learned that, for example, oleksiy arestovych famous commentator that's all, and he's what it's called, and he

turns out to have no official status . in tandem with him because photos appeared everywhere. where he is sitting at the same table at the press conference with the gentleman for whom p. worth to pay some attention because well, if we don't do that, that's it, that's it, he's just simply using that audience when they are what do you think about it mr. yaroslav oleksiyu no, what do i think about

detention centers, well, she's talented, of course, a talented manipulator well, simply well, first, let's do it he still became famous, not now, he became famous at the beginning of the war, that is, 8 years ago and served the interests of another president, let's say yes, just not so brightly, because he was just starting out, he was only adjusting his abilities, let's say, he was honing and now it's time. yes, it's a stellar time when people understand. we live now in a period - it's in this world, and ukraine doesn't stand out much here, although again, uh. well, we just didn't have this stable democratic stable democratic process that continued even though it would have been there for 100-150 years. well, society has learned to distinguish, well

, in its majority, so what is a fake? well, you cannot distinguish it from there are certain institutions that allow society to somehow filter how odious individuals are, including such as arestovych and it doesn’t always help, so in america it’s for help, but for strumpu, but now we live in a post- prada era, when emotional perception is much more important than the fact itself, and the broom plays just great on this topic, this one never understands when they read these uh debunks arrestovych that he was there with dugin what what is he there this that he is there that and most of the award just spit on the first er 90% of klimitili and arrestovych are unknown 99% of his supporters yes hmm they are simply unknown they are nobody for them absolutely their words otsi ot eh it's almost there

arestovych well, here i am recalling a policeman with whom we encountered even before the war, who said and you and who are you and what magazine and what channel i don't know i tolik serhiy listen you listen because the post is an expert society in general besides yes there is no significance here well i've been talking about this for many years, so , so, i see myself now. yes, on this screen, yes. believe me, for 70%, 80%, even 80% of the audience, if there, uh, i don't know . do you have two or three faiths up my sleeve? and there won't be the same expert as i do for the majority of the population. that's all. well, it's already a bit of a table. i

know the intellectual level of many of my colleagues. it's excellent. yes, it's just great if there's a large part of people who don't differ. in general, they just know how. how can i tell you? do you know that everyone is good at cars , football, politics, yes, a person can learn so and so in a surname, a couple of facts , he makes any conclusions with a reasonable appearance, and when you watch the story, you understand he says words, a set of words, certain, yes, which we are simply confused by, and for which there is no responsibility for everything, absolutely yes, that is why i am not surprised that he does not have any position. and why does he have a position, in principle, why does he need this kind of any when it will all end when it will all end yes, everyone is like that, and what was it? and who? well, says roman. and what kind of leaflets did not work near us. it was just a phantom, so to speak, and they will never come to our borders. well , at all, we only had president

zelensky. yes, because you you voted it elected and all this is delusional and so on i absolutely doubt that he at this stage, they are not doing anything, he can practically start a faction of some kind of parliament in the future . looking diagonally, it is clear that arestovych works primarily for the arrestee and he appeared in the opp as not quite his own cadre, that is, when we think that arestovych checks all his actions probably a little cunningly, because in fact arestovych simply took advantage of certain weaknesses of the office. well , he helped, you know, from outside and in the conditions of the war, he

took on this function of a communicator, and obviously he had to report things that, er, well, then they would hit the person who reports them very hard, that's why the president probably didn't take on this job, that's why this podoliak did not take up the job, other people, arestovych said yes, ok, i am ready to change, for example , part of my reputation. well, what share of popularity did he transfer to this conversion? now he has a political image, and i am more sure that arestovych in the future is just as much an individual independent political project that large groups of influence they will just want to invest money, uh, there will be some such table-top secret chaser and it is still unknown, you understand, komoristovych will add more headaches, whether the opposition is conditional or something on the contrary, the authorities, who have so loved him in the media and mowed him down, and i think that the president's office is so close to him and does not allow him. he does not take,

for example, to the staff. speak because he took refuge here, conditionally speaking. he works anyway in the field of the conditional poroshenko. and here arestovich is probably the opposite, maybe it’s time to talk about it more, it will contribute more to it. the actual situation at the front is a little bit different now, but very much at the match of thoughts, what was shared with them p oleksiyu p yaroslavovych yaroslav bozhko-political consultant and oleksiy glavutskyi political technologist and head of the center for political studies doctrine were with us e hm now with us will be valery ivasyuk doctor of medical sciences and people's deputy of ukraine of the first convocation , a member of the kyiv city council of the city council and ex-advisor to the president of ukraine, mr. valery uh, uh , uh, as a person who was an advisor, and here we are talking about arrestees, the same as a person as a people's deputy of ukraine of the first convocation. tell me anything the best convocation and yes yes yes yes it may be that now ukrainians

know the surnames arestovych without being asked, but if you tell them, for example, the surname chornovil or lukyanenko, i think that many of them are thinking about the cloud. andrii, honor to you and honor to the espresso channel. and regarding well, i would say yes to doctors and medicine, it always remains in the shortest time according to the residual principle, but i am satisfied with it, i listened to oleksiy yaroslav. i still love the russian poet yevgeniy yevtushenko . he is very talented, democratic, and absolutely not controlled by the communist party, yelets , putin, his personality. he has a wonderful poem where there are such lines about my cat came er in

about the arrestee, they are very er random and they sound in russian yes and what without a whisper then a voice in a whisper then already silent beloved about the arrestee - this is e. he also declared that he will run for the presidency if zelensky does not become the president. is it ukraine that is bloodless with flows round in this war where arestovich is er in a clown appeasing such-and- such barboval yes, not all she will choose er this figure, but regarding your question you know last week on the media sites the following political scientists evaluated the events in moscow and the protests of good russians they have the communist party of ukraine 31 years ago, and the democratic masses of russia liquidated the ussr,

they say the same thing as the young sypalite, and the katsapas came out in a sharp counterattack against the narcissists, drug addicts and alcoholics who made up the ccp and them i just liked gorbachev and liked the maddened rascal. they are democratizing, but not against the ussr, but ukrainians in kyiv starting on the 19th. and today, tomorrow and the 24th, they came out against the cpsu, against the party, against the ussr and for the independence of ukraine. this is the difference . what kind of independent ukraine? i am convinced that there is a mass that was lying under some kind of tanks there, and these masses are good russians, of course, because not a

single person in moscow who sincerely welcomed an independent ukraine responded. it was all of novodvorsk the regime of the alcoholic yeltsin and for that i hated all the chubais, the gaidars, are such greedy chauvinists, imperialists, that putin, in order to know and understand for sure the cause of the inconsequential connection between the current trouble in ukraine and what happened 31 years ago, you need to listen to witnesses and participants those events do not exist while we are still alive and do not die among us, it was just that good ruska who was truly a patriot of ukraine, she was a good jewess well, yes, between us girls, you know, there was never such a good andriy sakharov and elena bondar

his wife is also the deceased, who also supported ukraine and the path to independence, right now, on the eve of the independence day, i would ask valeria like this. could history have turned out better for ukraine, was it possible, for example, to prevent this current war , was it programmed from the very beginning, was something possible to change, or in principle, there is nothing to regret, you know andria. and recently there was the anniversary of the great lina kostenko, and there was one fool who a boxer came up to her and said, you are a great democrat, so-and-so, such a figure in ukraine. you are a piece of shit, what are you talking about to a person? what do you

know ? yes, regardless of who heard ukraine, ukraine itself as such is what russia hates, she says that i knew as soon as the verkhovna rada of ukraine declared independence there would be a war and this is the truth about vyacheslav chornovol, gentlemen, the biggest sinner, the biggest thief of ukraine kravchuk i worked all the time, i say , starting with the lie of the adoption of the act of independence and was supposed to go number 14. and before that there was supposed to be decommunization, the creation of an army of money, and so on , that is, the communist states voted with pleasure and i am waiting for the root of the flag, which they want to be in power what happened and then they

turned into oligarchs in a row about whether it was possible this could not be because we left the soviet union and as there were 15-17 percent of pasionarians then who are now society must recover from this trouble 300 or 400 years or destruction, but you know andria . you are very fond of humor. i see that i have little time left. i want to remind you of one such hutsul proverb: a man is grazing sheep in the mountains and passes by the house of his godfather. do you answer there , muscovites, i’m dripping, wait kume, you have a beer, the answer is not diluted, i have time and i have the desire, so there will be enough time and desire in ukraine today, this was a question on your airwaves, you

asked it and this wonderful woman, this volunteer a smart girl who left for her child and then extrapolation to this state happened. and as for whether we will reach moscow, we will reach it diplomatically until moscow exists, but as long as russia exists in this format, there will be no peace in the country, we will reach that place, my grandmother said when i asked, i say, baba, what about moscow, what about moscow, so that a lake would become in that place, what about this prophecy, yes, mr. valery ivasyuk will grow on this fertilizer. word