heat, which belongs to the same er russian oligarch friedman. we can recall with you the latest news about the fact that helsi is a system where and we make an appointment with a doctor, where all our medical data with you is stored, it is bought by the structures of alpha bank, that is, they are included in partnership with this company that developed it, and in fact friedman can get access to the medical data of all ukrainians, is this national security? yes, of course, that is what is happening. why is it so? you know, i think that if we now include the minister of justice or some deputy minister of the economy, we will now hear 101 reasons for what is preventing the dancer, yes. that is, it will be different to do it here and prosecutors and something here , someone is not doing something there and something is not written correctly in the law, but it seems to me that everything is a dry residue it's very simple, while our armed forces of ukraine demonstrate at the front that nothing prevents them, nothing prevents them from impressing someone, well, what doesn't prevent them from surprising the whole

world with their actions and how they can produce extraordinary results with limited resources, we don't see it with you the same from our front of officials and politicians and this is the assessment of their work if they wanted if they had the appropriate professional and mental abilities if they had the motivation to do this everything would be done instead we can open the forbes list with you russian oligarchs to see what crazy money they have and to see that nothing has been confiscated in ukraine, and here the question is whether or not oligarchs are paid bribes. does this still mean that our officials are so helpless that they cannot even do such elementary things to do on the sixth axis after six months of war, and it seems to me that any answer to this question is negative for ukraine. and it sounds like officials and politicians should pay attention to this. if they are unable to

do so, then they should write a statement of resignation and give way to others who will able to do it thank you, please, well, you mentioned the premier palace hotel, you meant yes, in kyiv, er, there is also babakov hotel, hotel dnister in lviv , by the way, it turns out that oleksandr chastkovu bakova also owns a very, very wide business brand, what do you think? what prevents us, well , at least, to join the sanctions that have already been introduced against russian business by our american and european and transport partners. all russian-aristovate us to give while we continue to work with russia at this time as we cannot seize assets and transfer them to use a-a withdrawal a-a and i think let’s they invent a bicycle, and the ukrainian government

has always been operationally incompetent, and it is very slow, it stumbles on any solution or paper, and they always come up with a bunch of excuses, so everything is done, here is the cabinet of ministers, a phishmogul, there they announced a huge letter. there are many legal entities and private individuals and so on. everything is announced for tomorrow, that is, everything will be fine with us, but tomorrow, and it happens all the time. why i think so because it is very poor operational efficiency - this is basically a negotiation for the cabinet or bodies that work in the state yes, to those politicians who cannot be active logisticians of this process and the second is that it is most likely natural corruption , let's not forget about it, and we have it correctly, there are so many different

ways, how can we say that now we can't draw these assets because we are allowed to conduct criminal proceedings now, that's all we will start criminal charges against you production to make it impossible to a-a draw assets and transfer them to the state a-a well, how can you say that i can even say that as a citizen of ukraine it is bad , it is terrible, many of these assets are known public, known even until february 24, a huge number of activists including me , they talked about the fact that these assets should not be controlled by the russians in principle , you understand well, that is, they, they, they are not now, they should be confiscated, they, in principle, we should not have allowed these assets control by a citizen of the russian federation, well, we did it, that's why, marko, it somehow affects the real military aid to us

from our partners. military aid, after all, military aid is a bit different, and the west is collective, and now it supports ukraine because we are weakening the russian army, and every day, we are making russia less capable of waging war somewhere in in the second place, they will attack nato or someone else. and therefore, in this case, corruption in ukraine is not corruption in ukraine. help will go to ukraine, but it is quite obvious that if we work, and if we do reforms, if we will transparently seize assets if we have a transparent logistics system in the ministry of defense , we must not forget that we still have a paper army, that is, of course, aid to ukraine will be more and easier because our adversaries have the help of their adversaries украине будет

молчите менеше аргементов казать почему we need something not to hand over or to do even before bureaucratic control, who should deal with this issue so that russian business well, he did not conduct business, especially big business and business that is tied to national security, in particular, oblenergo now winter is inflicted in us. yes, it is very difficult and difficult. and it is not at all known what will happen. will there be light, or will there be water, or will it be warm, and here the russians own oblenergo. the president is the nsdc, is it the parliament, or is it possible for some special representative of the president to seize russian assets in ukraine? well, it is possible to introduce such a position, please. in fact, if we look at the legislation, the president has the authority to submit to the nsdc the issue of imposing sanctions, the use of confiscation, and the president will sign a further decision the national security council, the body that implements it, the ministry of justice, we know that it is also headed by a person who is definitely a person

from the president's team, this is denys malyuvska. if we were to say who is responsible for this process today, i would say the president of ukraine. a situation when everyone around is engaged in this. yes, and no one is actually responsible. when i tried to find out who is the body that is supposed to put all this together, each body sent me to the next one. that is, it lasted there a few days and i realized that you won't find extremes here. that is, this is a typical situation. it certainly seems to me that it would be appropriate , correct and effective .

lack of authority, they have a register on their website that contains all the sanctions that have been imposed on various entities in different countries, ukraine and all our partners, where there is a list of their a-a property of these oligarchs and companies and those close to putin which they have in different countries, and moreover, this site is already used by our international partners, wall street banks and global insurance companies, who, before opening an account for a russian, before allowing him to make a purchase, they open our site, which is not a nazk register is provided for, which is not provided for by any legislation at all, which they conduct simply on a volunteer basis, in fact, they take information from there and can, on the basis of this information, prohibit something to someone, that is, something is not open to someone, there are already similar cases therefore, it seems to me that it should not have been zaka. given that they have the authority and already

have the opportunity to make a lot of trouble for the russian oligarchs and putin 's cronies, but i have little hope that they will determine the nazk because our bodies are determined by officials in principle, how close are they to yermak, how do they find a common language with yermak, and if you are not yermak's person, if you don't communicate with yurmak or if you have some misunderstandings with yermak, then i will never entrust you in this state to lead some important functions in ukraine or do you know something like that , thanks to which you will be able to do pr, yes, that is, how is it calculated in our banks immediately, will it be possible for an official or body to do pr on this or not, so i think that, unfortunately, music will not be determined, but someone will be determined again, you know, who cannot give significant, significant results. and we will talk with you here again, but for today there is no specific person

responsible for the entire sanctions instrument, the only mechanism, that's why i say that it is the president. i love listening to both of you and to read, but it becomes sad after you tell us how it actually is, we have a schedule, this is all political, and what is the law, it seems, but one or several people decide, in certain circles, agia zagrebelska, thank you for your expertise and analysis, a high-quality lawyer, state commissioner of the antimonopoly committee from the 15th to the 19th years of ukraine, mark savchuk also keeps his hand constantly on the anti-corruption pulse, the advisers on this topic demo axes and the head of the public control council will take part in moving on. about the fact that canada returned to germany the remaining five turbines of the northern stream, despite the sanctions, what does this indicate

? is there an international columnist with us, is mr. yehor with us? please tell me now, let's add mr. vitaly . let's start with you regarding these turbines. this is the first position, the second position - it is obvious that the issue of ensuring the genetic security of the countries of central and western europe is number one in the dialogue with their trans- atlantic partners, and the german government focused on these turbines, and they were the focus of the negotiations. states with canada, therefore, under the pressure of the german lobby, the german government nevertheless struck out such a

preference for itself, and turbines are brought to germany, will this mean the launch of nord stream-2, or will this mean an increase in the capacity of the current gas pipelines, as far as i'm concerned, let's give it some time, the statement of mr. kibik - he is a representative of the free democrats in the government of germany that in the event of a threat of a disruption of the heating season in germany, the issue of resuming work can be considered or let's say the launch of the work of the northern stream-2, as far as i am concerned, these are statements that are touchstones that are being launched in german. i would like to note that for me, for example, such statements are surprising in them. i especially visited the democrat because their faction in the government

the traffic light coalition is the most pro-ukrainian statement of this political force, their position on the bundestag, their position on the ministry of finance, the ministry of defense, it is more radical, the democrats wrote down various partners of the greens, they have always been supporters of ukraine and provided national support at the political level, and here kibyk makes such a statement that contradicts the positions of this faction and others, but this indicates the strengthening of the work on the pro-russian lobbyists of industrial circles . client patrons and free democracies and social democrats, they crack down on the government and it is obvious that similar ideas will arise in the

german government constantly something is in such a stretch than different interest groups, on the one hand, it has obligations to the conditional a collective measure before the union of the states of a-a there is a position of an agreed policy with britain, but on the other hand there is an intra-political request er-er the rating of the traffic light coalition is now over low , everyone is talking about a possible political crisis in germany about the fact that er-er this coalition is not will last a long time, the rating of the insurers is tightening the belts for the heating season and the supporters of austerity in the energy sector are now losing political support, and this is also the political orientation of the germans now

seriously moved in the direction of pro-russian political forces such as an alternative to germany or berlin at the same time uh, well, there is no need to talk about re-elections. this is a normal political process, it will shake long enough and immediate decisions or some immediate threat to ukraine from these turbines it is not worth waiting now, but what we have to do is increase the pressure on germany, on brussels, er, to hold a dialogue with our er, transportation partners about preventing the launch of any new gas pipelines, especially nord stream-2 they are possible, er this should be done, especially since there is supposedly a certain consensus in brussels regarding the reduction of europe's dependence on russian energy sources , and this policy is followed in all

doctrinal documents of european countries and the european union as a whole, on certain plans, on certain management decisions, i.e. there is a strategy of plans up to 25-35 years, and there are specific decisions when the country refuses russian gas, coal, or oil, and such decisions become critical in the majority and already some countries - we can even remember the parting speech at the prime minister's drive minister of italy, who showed his successor to carry out a policy of reducing independence from the russian states, that is, this consolidated position exists, and it also takes it into account. international viewer p igor we greet you good day how do you see the consolidation of this position and the european and the intentions of germany i

would like to talk about the climate dimension here because in the 19th year the european union made a decision that by 2050 europe will become the first climate-neutral continent in history this means that almost all emissions of e-e street into the atmosphere were reduced by a little more than half and accordingly this is a story about increasing the share of renewable energy sources wind turbines in solar panels and many other things from the other side of europe for a long time and now it is dependent on russian oil and gas and this has been going on for more than a year and even a decade, and canada, by the way, is the first country in nato where a center of excellence on climate issues will be created, and this was announced during the summit to a crowd of three actions

and the minister of defense canada's anita ordered that we should do everything to make our defense and security more ecological and climatic, that is, a lot is said about it, and now this story with the turbines between canada and germany shows that in fact the west cannot do enough quickly abandon russian energy carriers although they talk about a lot of things and make important statements, they take important steps regarding the construction of new natural gas terminals in europe, but the logic of canada is the following, and germany wants to anger putin. we want to show ourselves as responsible partners. what are you looking at? russia wants turbines, and we give them to russia, that is, and at the

same time they point out that russia definitely uses energy as a weapon, but we can’t do anything about it except to behave like a normal country, of course interesting logic, because if you are already fighting putin and the kremlin's energy spat , then you have to do it definitively at the same time from the ukrainian side, well, ukraine, as the main transitor of russian gas to europe, should not forget that we are still transiting russian gas from the european union, that is, the same for us it is important that everything is small and that ukraine also receives money from russia, and i think that it is important to reach a joint concert. that is , all countries will gather together with ukraine and

decide what to do next, because with for one thing, for example, in january, the european commission generally recognized nuclear energy and natural gas as ecologically clean and climate-friendly energy carriers, and this also essentially plays into the hands of russia, that now vladimir putin is almost the biggest climate eco-activist, and that is why it is such a difficult dilemma how combine climate change and russian energy sources er pro-russian gas yes er it has already increased in price in general the price of gas in europe rose yesterday to three thousand three hundred dollars per 1000 cubic meters this is an incredible price at that time russians burn their gas on

on the border with the european union, russia burns a large amount of gas, while in europe the prices of energy carriers have risen sharply, this gas was previously exported to germany, the bbc reports with reference to its analysts, a plant near finland, in particular, burns approximately 4.5 million cubic meters of gas daily which is about 10 million dollars, scientists are worried that the occurrence of large volumes of carbon dioxide and fuel oil, they can worsen the melting of the arctic ice due to incomplete combustion of fuel, black carbon is formed, which settles on snow and ice and accelerates the melting gas for combustion comes from the new plant for the production of natural gas in the northwest of st. petersburg gazprom sp-portovoe the first evidence of anomalous activity came from the citizens of finland back in the summer they began to notice large fires i have never seen so many flares at a production plant lng well liquefied gas, said an expert on

satellite images of the university of miami, dr. jessica mccarthy, the port is located near the compressor station at the beginning of the lawn, the clinical flow of which the gas is supplied to these supplies to germany have stopped since the middle of june, the russians claim that this is caused by technical problems, but germany is convinced that this is a political move . vitaliy, a political move. isn’t it political? will russia now blackmail germany and even the nord stream alone, when it will be able to shut it down in winter, for example, because of certain invented problems there? there is a technical technological nature to close the supply hall and when this finally what do you think, well, the fever regarding the price of gas in europe will end at what mark i think that it will definitely happen, russia will blackmail europe as much as possible due to the lack of a people of carriers will include or stop transit if it does this with its alleged partner kazakhstan by

turning off e-e transcript trans-caspian pipeline due to so-called political and technical reasons, then i am not talking about the european union with which they are in the configuration and obviously they will stop the transit, will they audibly stop the supply of gas to the european union, will they play for the last price? medvedeeva and patrushev and putin directly believe that because of this pressure, in the winter we will be able to break the position of the european union in the direction of ending support for ukraine. this is a tool for knocking europe out of active support for ukraine , so they will not necessarily do it, the price of gas will rise, moreover, cover the deficit -e russian shops here agree completely at the moment of the european union is quite small, there is a small possibility that there is a country that was not dependent on russian citizens by 70 or more percent

, respectively, germany itself, regardless of of russian countries, we are not talking about reducing the price, we will not find it, we are talking about e-e benefit for german companies, we are talking about direct provision of heat and at least the support of minimal housing and communal services in germany and other central european countries, and so this blackmail will intensify, especially at peak temperatures negative when europe begins to freeze and it will be necessary to reduce the degrees in apartments and this will affect the ratings of the poetic forces that will call for savings, this will affect the rulers political e-e forces and putin is counting on this when it will stop, maybe it will stop when this transition to alternative sources of energy supplies will take place,

when their critical mass will exceed dependence on russian when it will happen outside of general experts say about the 25th year, but during this time with europe may or may not be frozen , that is, we will significantly shake support through energy weapons, significantly shake support for ukraine, especially in those countries that are really dependent on russian organizational and this far from hungary, it can be in france, it can also be in austria - it's the balkan countries, it's primarily germany from the wall, it's necessary to work and the germans are now on the way to find this alternative introductory uh, again deconserving the mines uh, they agreed for the construction of mines in poland, they have started coal production in most european countries, they are deconcentrating again, where it is, and they invest as much as possible in small hydropower in small

energy projects, but this can be reduced from 15 to 21% depending on that is to give somehow, there is an alternative, e.e. qatari gas or gas from other countries through dropped through rolenzhit terminals, it also does not cover all the deficits for germany and this and this is a huge problem, that’s right, mr. yehor. how do you see the winter in europe, what will it be like considering the well on this whole situation, it will be a very powerful factor on the part of russia, well, to restrain and keep everyone, well, if on a short leash, what will winter be like in europe, winter is close and we don't know exactly what it will be like in terms of temperature,

but europeans need to prepare for the worst the scenario when there will not be enough gas to heat the house, and accordingly, now the main task of ukraine is to convey to our european partners that this is russia's problem , that russia is the root cause of all this, that this is banal blackmail, and i think that the european union was just more quickly aware that only by having different sources of energy can you avoid this blackmail and not be its victim, because we can recall the stories of yushchenko, when putin simply unscrewed the valve and said that it was ukraine who steals gaza from europe, now putin does not have it it is necessary to do and say what you see there in

ukraine, uh, we are conducting a special military operation, and here, uh, they hit something there, the ukrainians again hit some gas pipeline, that is, in the same way, russia can use any, any, fake story in order to disperse with your propaganda, and here i would also like to mention about southern europe, which mr. vitaliy mentioned about the balkans, there is a project that works perfectly, this is the turkish balkan stream, when russian gas goes through turkey, further into bulgaria and then through serbia to hungary just since last year was serbia and hungary are connected by pipes, and hungary, as you know, uses only russian gas because, first of all, there can be no restoration of energy sources because of the history, the terrain of ukraine, and

the same for hungary it is profitable to buy russian gas, and that is why ukraine should think about cooperating with the balkan countries in order to ultimately reduce the dependence of europe on russian energy resources, mr. vitayu. how do you assess , in general, we have a minute left of european unity on this issue and whether they have some agreed on the policy, what to do this winter, please. i think that they have such a morning agreed policy, they are really creating independence from russian gas and other energy carriers. they are trying to find

alternatives to russian gas in the middle east. they are working on hydrogen energy and other renewable sources, so to say that they do not have a vision is a crisis scenario. gas and disconnection, as well as reducing the temperature in homes, the german governments are working on the municipalities, the municipalities are already creating heating points and possible food for the vulnerable population, that is , this work is happening even in berlin , there is work with volunteers who are preparing for a possible such crisis the scenario i.e. europe is preparing for