the implication of this for them is that they need to show some results, well, that is, this special military operation has been going on for six months, what do they call it? well, what are the goals and what are its results, uh, these questions are causing more and more questions in russian society, well, accordingly, something must be explained, well , that is, i understand i have repeatedly said that even the residents of the russian federation cannot be called citizens, they are subjects or citizens, they are those to whom the government is accountable to the russians , e.e., the current government is not accountable to the residents. they are accountable to this government, they are subjects, but even among subjects, when questions arise, yes. that is , it can generate frustration and aggression there, it can pose a threat to the stability of the political regime, it is still necessary to somehow explain to them why their lives are deteriorating, why they are perceived more and more in the world as some well, it’s not that there’s no spine. and

some harmful junk, data-toxic junk. why is the standard of living falling, for some reason, a significant number of them, and i don’t know their relatives there, have already changed their sons, brothers, i don’t know the parents there to lada kaliny, that is, we will fulfill the story, it all requires answers, that is, it is clear, and well, and also a representation. we think that russian society is like it is shown on russian television. well, but beyond the borders of russian television, there is still real russian life, and it is not a party, only a tool. confirmation for ordinary russians through tv of what they are doing. everything is correct, and there is another aspect - it can also be used in the future for them. as a kind of subject or ground for e negotiations, that is, regarding the settlement therefore, i am inclined to think that in fact all this rhetoric of zelenskyi, which many people do not accept , and there is a cap from it, here are ultimatums, and about the fact that

if you hold a trial against the azov fighters, then there can be no further negotiations. or if you hold referendums, then in there can be no further negotiations, so i tend to think that this is not empty talk, that in fact the russians understand very well that they need negotiations. well, sooner or later they will still have to settle this issue through negotiations, and that is why they need one on the one hand, to have something that can be put on the table, and on the other hand, that it is something that they will have and put on the table, it is not impossible to hold this meeting in principle, and in the end, let us forget that despite the fact that all these ultimatums are from zelensky as if no one took it seriously , nevertheless, they are effective, none of the things that related to the content of these ultimatums have not happened yet, and what's more, i'll tell you this, well, my point of view, i could be wrong, i tend to think that it won't happen, that is, i tend to think that the russians

they won't hold all these er performances, because even last year there was such a widespread thesis that everything under the russian security umbrella is not touched. how is it, yes, well, agree, this is even for many that er is already here then, of course, our center there against the information of these western experts, uh, broke it down into details. yes , but this message went very well, so in no case should you mess with russia, because it is an aggressive nuclear state. yes, and after belgorod , after cotton in crimea. fact yes, that's all the power of the russian security umbrella is a little bit, not even a little bit, it is completely broken , and if, for example, a year ago, the words that russia wants to annex a number of regions of ukraine to its composition could cause real horror, then today everyone understands. so what? this safety umbrella will give

it more than confirmation of the thesis that it is possible that nothing will happen. well, i tend to think that nothing will happen, well, that is, i mean honestly, in order for this to happen, there must be some significant transformations, in principle, in the awareness of goals and of this military company both from the side of the russian federation and from the side of ukraine and from the side of the civilized world today is very revealing. by the way, for me, compare the rhetoric of crimean platform one last year and crimean platform-2 this year and just compare yes who as what to say. so, for today, it seems to me that it is no longer a matter of discussion for anyone what is the goal of this war for ukraine, the restoration of the territorial integrity of state sovereignty within the internationally recognized borders that is, there can now be discussions

about the tools for achieving this goal, well, i would say uh. it does not rule out that we will return not all the territory directly as a result of a military operation, but the fact that we will return them to us is guaranteed for me does not cause any doubts that is, yes, that is. but again, when i say that only by military means, it means that by what means. well, there are diplomatic negotiations, how long will it last, who will be the subjects, what will be the side issues, we do not know all this at the moment but it must be understood that when the parties come to the realization that they can no longer change their negotiating positions by military means well, then let's go, they will have to look for well , not compromises. it is already being used, you run the risk of not breaking up, screaming like that, let's do it, no, no, no, no compromise. well, some acceptable solution, and the acceptability of this

solution will be determined not only by the subjects and the immediate war, because its acceptability today is global, so why did everyone change their attitude so much, because everyone understood that if today ukraine comes out of this war having lost part of its territory or part of its sovereignty, it means that similar actions have already been carried out by many other states and this is a chain reaction. maybe well , to take place far outside the borders of the current europe, although it is the same in europe, and this is precisely what scares the most today, well, those people who are interested in preserving the predicted table development of human civilization, so if i answer your question the question well, yes, it's very concise well, i don't see how to say the prerequisites for them to go to this step because, well, all as a result of this step, well, they will look even more funny , even more difficult, well, because they create worthless solutions, eh and this decision will worsen their

starting positions, you see, someone said that politics is an art, it is possible, accordingly, who is a cool politician, he is the one who expands the space, it is possible. and it seems to me that the current putin regime consists of people who have done everything possible in order to narrow down as much as possible the space of possible foreign policy for russia. i want to pick up your opinion here beforehand that they did not plan to hold any referendum and they became hostages of the events of the 14th year in the matter of control of these territories. how was it in the military issue, yes, they saw ilovaisk, they saw the events in debaltseve, well, we all remember. yes, and they believed that the attack on february 24 would take place. about the same. occupied territories, as was the case in crimea. and let's remember that they brought the tsar to the kyiv

region at the start of the sitting in belarus, e.e. yanukovych. and why did they bring them, in order to hold a referendum later? no, they wanted to change the government in kyiv, seize ukraine, establish return yanukovych and then force yanukovych to bring back to ukraine the occupied territories in the donetsk luhansk region and create a friendly puppet country just as belarus was, as it is, and what are we there, ukraine served ukraine served friendly russia, water to crimea, we recognized crimea and putin was in favor of such scenarios. and when things did not go according to this scenario, they were forced to invent these algorithms, the implementation of which we are seeing now, and the holding of these artificial referendums and that . they planned it at first until may 9, yes, and then, uh, someone was there somewhere, somewhere in june, yes

, it was like that, now it is already sounding there on september 11, then it already appeared on september 14. and here in marathon , ivan fedorov of melitopol turned up. he says that they have already refused from the format of a single day there some kind of vote they say we'll drag it out, the russians say we'll drag it out for a week or two and we'll go through the apartments of people with boxes with submachine guns, there's a knock on your door , the military comes with a machine gun from the box, and you have to decide with them whether you support er, the joining of these territories to the russian federation, this is the format they see, but really, it seems to me that ah, this is already such an option, but there is an option there, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, and in actions on the territory of ukraine. one nuance eh this is a question of legality and legitimacy of those bodies that approve certain decisions, then you

mentioned the events of the 14th year. so it is necessary to take into account the fact that the events of 2022 are significantly different, because in the 14th year you remember that meeting of the verkhovna rada of ukraine of the autonomous verkhovna rada council of the autonomous republic of crimea, which they allegedly conducted and which allegedly approved the decision on this alleged referendum, that is, no one knows whether there was a quorum, no one knows who i voted for, but formally they refer to the alleged decision of this body, the same they tried and did it in donetsk and luhansk , so were the local self-government bodies . no one questions the legitimacy and legality of the verkhovna rada of the autonomous republic of crimea, no one, the fact that they approved a decision that goes beyond the constitutional powers and current legislation is also quite obvious therefore, they did not recognize any results at all, but the body itself was legal, legitimate . the same applies to donetsk luhansk. and to date, someone can name at least one a local self-governing body, at least in one

settlement that is currently under russian occupation, that would approve something like that. well, you can look at lysychansk in severodonetsk . well, show through mariupol, that is, the peace of the city has left the city. yes, we have lost control and the mariupol city council has also, in essence, continued to exercise its powers. well, simply formally speaking, as in exiles, but they have not lost their legality and legitimacy, well, what are the occupiers doing in these territories, well, they are trying to find someone yes, with some illusory legality and legitimacy, and they do not find them by and large, he succeeded , uh, he also already talked about it, what is this except for this balance, because he had at least some status, yes, that is, this balitsky, too, again, these are the people who want to

somehow be presented to the higher league of ukrainian politics, but everything else. yes, malinske, we will talk about this in the second part of the program just about the collaborators, the balance disappeared altogether in moscow under the pretext of poisoning. it seems to me that here is your version that he staged it himself and in order to get out of the game he scored points in the conditions of the coronavirus pandemic to declare that he is sorry, i got sick under no circumstances. i will not betray the interests of the republic simply i'm sick, what can i do, but i want to talk about one more event , the opening of the embassy of these unrecognized republics of the dpr , the lpr, on the territory of moscow and in north korea, this is very revealing, but before that, let's do a little pause for a motivating video and we will return to the conversation of reconstruction before we start, we will win what are you no news together we are strong that monday in the marathon the only news is we help to look for the missing in the project of kateryna osadchoi to find their own we are here to

become your assistants thousands of families divided by war project this was the only hope their stories and thanks for the opportunity to see each other again, you do it, we will find the missing with the support of the national police of ukraine and the national information bureau , call for help at 16:48 and 122 or leave a request in the chat-pot of the telegram channel search for missing persons if you want to find missing persons, subscribe to the project's social network, maybe you will recognize those who are being sought by the unification of insurmountable see that monday is the only one in marathon news at 9:30 p.m. now a cruel war is being developed they shouted at the russians in ukraine, all the gymnasiums fell silent here, there was no more inaudible applause after the performances and

victories, ukrainian gymnasts had to leave their homes and training to save their lives, but not for the talented family the gymnast from mariupol, katya dyachenko, did not manage to save herself, she died as a result of the collapse of the house after being hit by russian shells. russian gymnasts are also taught to be silent. records and titles are more important to them than peace. however, we athletes of the world should not be silent . on the sports front you can stop the war silence kills share your videos and posts share them on

social networks with company hashtags with support ministry of youth and sports of ukraine watch the project to find your people kateryna osadchoi from the search for the missing every monday at 9:30 p.m. good night to everyone who joins our broadcast 1+1 project night watch work in the studio yevhen kuksim yevhen plinsky valentin glykh political expert e-e candidate of philosophy scientists, we are talking about a pseudo-referendum that they are planning to hold in the occupied territories, and we are discussing whether they will be able to do it and whether they need to do it in view of the fact that they have lost all the possibilities of implementation of our original plans and we wanted to talk further about such an unexpected event, this is not

just recognition of the territories captured by russia, but such a step as the opening of the embassy of these pseudo-republics on the territory of russia and, well, although it sounds very funny, but from an international point of view, this is still a step towards legitimization. although among countries like north korea, yes, why was this done? it was not a step. well, let's do something to do it. it's not so clear. to create such an illusion that the dpr and lpr , so-called, supposedly at least fall into the partially recognized states well, but they don’t, well , that’s what the paradox is. well, in principle, they will continue to try to do something similar, let’s forget what it seems six countries of the world recognized the results of the referendum in crimea, the so-called

a, that is, but among them, i think no one will name a single one, which of them is more or less unconscious, now we will find yes well, maybe such a referendum in crimea and they issue there, it seems six now there can uh this something has changed there well, that's why nothing has changed there can say three more to open this embassy well in syria they can open this embassy they have enough diplomats you understand but i'm just really uh this is interesting to see uh- of the employees of these embassies, who works there, that's one point, well, it's their efforts. but will they achieve the goal? no, they don't. well, because everyone perfectly understands that in fact there are no ldns. what i listed. yes, in belarus, bolivia, venezuela, armenia, zimbabwe, cuba, nicaragua, north korea. russia, sudan, the main thing, and armenia. well, it is really a dead end. that is, it is also here, just like the

north, yes, north korea. well, it is not in the full sense of a sovereign state. yes, it means that formally there are subjects of international law, but de facto it is. well, they are a vassal of the people's republic of china, they are not that you recognized the annexation of crimea , they voted against the resolution of the un general assembly on the territorial integrity of ukraine, in which i will emphasize in particular that the referendum in crimea and sevastopol has no legal force, that is, they are directly what did i say that this is not about the annexation , it is only about the alleged referendum that was held in the city, that is, about recognition in general well, the annexation is not about this in principle well, because it is so obvious, i will tell you more here, all this then stirred up society, well, the world, because at that time there were already cases when whole states ceased to exist and there was such a thing, if you could say well, there is such an unspoken consensus

about what can be shared, you can take it away, that is, in principle, even declare independence crimea was much more uh, hypothetically, how to say a productive option, he did not give advice in any case , and well, but hypothetically, that is, the reaction could be different to this, well, and take annex uh. this has such precedents at that time, because since the second world war well, no one remembered that. well, that's all again. well, it's just some kind of bad game. well, they. and why is it not consistent? well, on the one hand, they talk about what is there. it's as if there are some ldnr or some independent people there. is this nation supposedly a sovereign subject? concepts of political theory and then it turns out that all these leaders are members of united russia and members of their legislative representative body, a simple question arises. well, if you

are a representative of this body, it means that you are a citizen of this state. that the dnr is headed by a citizen of the russian federation, what kind of humiliation is this for putin yes, the president of turkey, erdoğan, comes out and says crimea is ukraine , after that he says yes, we will accept your cards, what kind of cards are you there? yes, but crimea is comes out tokaev, who was invited by the president of kazakhstan, who was invited by putin and is next to putin. he says that we will not recognize the occupied territories of ukraine and the only ally is kim jong-un, who is masha to putin and says i am your friend, i support you and further, this is absolutely going nowhere . well, that is, just like in the russian public, information about that, i then putin re-recorded a telephone conversation with the president of mali. you even made me wonder where mali is located. and what

is that? well, i think that it is really powerful the breakthrough of russian diplomacy in the meeting is big. you - the eight, roughly speaking, yes, before conversations with the president, they are small, so what can we really talk about here? they think that they are more stupid. they think that everyone else will dance to their opinion. well, that is not the case. among their population, a large part of the population is, as it were, silent assent, that is, or that is, they remain silent, and this silence is perceived as consent. although from the point of view of political theory, this is also far from always the case , that is, consent is not always present. well, silence is not always signs of agreement, silence can be the same. disagreement , but this is the subject of another discussion. well, then they can fantasize about uh, uh, delegating someone there somewhere. at this point, i would now reflect on another aspect there that can also catch up with them, this is how legal are the places of the russian federation among the permanent ones members of the un security council, well, this

is important, but this is also a legal loophole for which we can be caught not only by us, when will the question of the transformation of international bodies in general, in particular the un, be resolved later, remember the one that ukraine did not sign with russia at the time of the year of zero yes, when the assets and liabilities of the soviet union were divided accordingly, so to speak, and many other nuances, that's why the russians don't understand whose jinn they really released from this jug, they thought that this is what evgeny said yes , the nuclear umbrella guarantees them something there. that is, it is far from waiting for the end of the hot phase of the war in order to start systematically squeezing russia out of all international institutions in the format in which the current russia exists that is, the current russian political regime does not leave the russian federation any other way than the way behind the iron curtain, how much does the russian state and

the russian federation want to sit behind the iron curtain . i don't know, in order to crawl out of this iron curtain into the world of god . well, when he has to crawl out, they will have to approve a whole series of decisions that uh, well, they are not even ready today consider but it will be inevitable, let's go. i just remember how the soviet union fell apart. the russian union is not a red flag, and grandfather elenia did not have it at all. place in the soviet union, we will honestly understand that there is no such thing, that is, it is all illusory, but simply refined magic goes step by step along this path, and

starting with the same, the initiator of the creation of the ussr started with this - this is terror, this is the destruction of all of those who disagree with the current regime, 168,000 denunciations in six months, despite the fact that you remember how the soviet and no one joke yes, to shoot beria and stalin like that, but someone also wrote these two million denunciations russia is going this way, but that's what we are talking about this started this conversation in the context of the future. that is, she walked along this path for a very long time, 7 years until the moment that they, they, we all did not have toilet paper, if someone scored, i remind you of many other things . perceived as absolutely normal things yes let's go back that they will have to

return sooner or later and accordingly they will have to give up everything that they have done and not just if the soviet union just bounced back very easily well that is it really collapsed there in the warsaw pact yes that is the country of the central and eastern european countries gained their independence, joined nato, became members of the european union, democratization took place in russia at a certain stage, the soviet union collapsed, these republics also gained independence, but by and large, no one condemned the soviet union as they should have done it , but come on, but i expect russia to be guaranteed, that is, if you don't think that they will bounce back, as the soviet union bounced back at one time, simply by getting off lightly with the whip, no, it won't be like that, they will have to atone for a very long and painful time for all that they nakoils continue to the great regret, koi jani, in conclusion, your opinion, returning to the topic of conversation, yes, i wonder if the russians will be able to hold a referendum right there and then, again, we all know ourselves, we

change the accents when we talk about the form of these referendums, well, conditionally, even for the three of us. right now, there is nothing to take a camera from one to another, take papers from a third, knock on five entrances, and then issue a report that he is there for a month, we would go e- eh, in the apartment, but they asked something, something was decided, so it’s all eh, they are finalizing it, eh, i think it’s all about the form, here we need to talk, in fact, the key question is with which piece of paper putin, you know the beautiful saying that putin, as an old kegebist with a legal education , he appreciates and understands only one thing that will be on paper yes what kind of protocol will putin come out with? and what will he do with it? it seems to me that everyone has already realized by completing this part of our program that russia cannot keep the captured territories under any circumstances. they did not

succeed in this referendum. they did not manage to get the support of the population, they did not manage to seize our lands with little blood and little force, and to hold the territory with a military contingent , setting up round-the-clock terror there, it is impossible for a long time, that is, even if they manage to falsify something and they can go for it it is not will make no sense, they will not receive any practical profit from this story, a very important eloquent fact that just indicates the future, and the russians are engaged in banal looting of those territories, that is, not very many russian investments entered donetsk and luhansk regions, on the contrary, they rob, steal, take away the same thing is happening in the south, which is the best confirmation of the fact that he himself realizes that they do not stay there for a long time, and as of today, as a joke, you know, the russians could not

steal the harvest in the south of ukraine, because before that they stole agricultural machinery there , let's put an end to it yevgen kuksin yevhen plinskyi valentin glykh political expert candidate of philosophical sciences night watch 1+1 we hope it was interesting see you on the air we will change bandages we will change our clothes we will win the news together we are strong before the war i was a photographer and now i am a combat medic all my relatives were surprised that i became a soldier, because i look fragile. and i always remembered olena stepaniv, who fought for ukraine in the first world war, also small and became the first woman officers in the world, 15% of the ukrainian army are women,

with their work, courage, honor and courage, they proved that they are no different from the other 85%." their lives were taken by russia, we will not forgive, we honor everyone and we win everyone for the sake of your memory, angels of sports, angels of ukraine for more than 160 days

without a day off. a step away from danger, more than two thousand kilometers along the front line. scouting groups with callsigns risk their lives every day, and every day he says i'm not tired, i'm not tired of defending ukraine. you saw the crime of russia help the federation bring the aggressor to justice, use the anonymous bot or the application form on the tell the truth website