who have from their own sources from sources from intelligence, and we can use it, and well, verify, do not believe, question it, ask experts about it, after all, the truth is that such information has every right to life. of this military aggression, the total stock of all types of artillery projectiles in the russian federation amounted to about 15 million pieces. this is quite a lot. open sources claim that within half of these projectiles in six months, they used and let's soberly understand that the second half is still there, that is, if the first half of the six months is still the second half, then again, it is really six months for huge shafts of fire, such as they practiced almost the entire war until the moment we learned to break their logistics chains and destroy their ammunition is actually very news. but we have to remind you that, after all, russia had

projectile, cartridge and gunpowder factories at the time of the aggression. they could produce up to 1.5 million pieces of projectiles per year. regular regime, we must soberly understand that the regular regime has long been violated, that is, they are not working significantly on the issue of increasing this ammunition, yes, indeed, in the near zone, the course of voronishin, oh lord, rostov-on-don, all ammunition and reserves have been exhausted, even 12,000 tons were extracted from belarus, but in the distant for the urals, there are still quite a lot of artillery barrels . and on this day, 95% of the war is an artillery war, also at the limit of its physical wear and tear, and they will not be able to produce really high-quality weapons and here the colleague said very correctly that they have quality tanks, but there are also low-quality, low

-quality, too, these are two low-quality t-55 tanks the day before yesterday, but i still have 3-4 there, a weak 76 mm gun, caliber 6 kg, a shell , but ammunition from 50 to 70, she will live for 15 minutes, but she will shoot, so i would lower this degree somewhere even this much. this is my personal opinion, i could be wrong. i even want you to be wrong. i would lower this degree somewhere, because by the new year the enemy will run out of everything. why is this phase now very it's hot right now, autumn is on the horizon , the rains will fall in the fall, we have to understand this. heavy equipment is currently moving overland during the rainy season, it will be almost impossible, but artillery duels , in my opinion, this is the prospect that awaits us in the military sense. i have very difficult and difficult discussions and by my colleagues, military experts who say that mr. chernyk, you are not

an optimist, i always try to drag us all to realism and give, well, excuse me, a harsh example. back in january, 98% of us told me because i knew for sure that there would be a war and that no rocket would fly, this is impossible. this is europe. well, where in lviv is the rocket, where is peter? well, you are an intellectual, you are well done, but be sober. that is what they told me. and now i would like to appeal to all of us to be sober, can the regime move in one go? a day can the regime of nikolai chi ushescu died in one day and the almighty secretary did not calculate this moment, but i have a hard position on the real one, we are exhaling under four circumstances, for 4 the first, the russian federation, where it fragmented, disintegrated, the second - they were not taken away nuclear weapons, the third thing is that a kind of conditional russian republic was formed there, they will be great anyway, they were cut off from the derm siberian oil and gas resources, and the fourth thing is that we joined nato, and now, honestly

, in the studio and to the audience, this will happen quickly if they all raise their hands and say sorry separation payments, but this will not happen these moments . i'm sorry for the intellectual selfishness, i know what they will do, they will take a break and start thinking, not why this war was started, but why this war was lost, and our children and grandchildren, the mad oksana will have those the problems are the same. in fact, the fact that we stopped the second army is a phenomenal victory of the ukrainians , the fact that the state held out, because the main goal of this war is to talk about this constantly, not only about the front, to eliminate this statehood on the planet earth, a tyrannical whole, 1/9 of the landmass with an imperial philosophy, not will come to life with a democratic ukraine either they or us them or they us i may apologize a little for such emotionality, but i would

really like to convey the main message to all of us , this is not a sprint race, this is not a stalinist race this is a marathon and it is really very difficult and it can be long. god grant that everything will fall down a bit. will happen, but it is not the height of wisdom to bet on the eyes of god's phenomena i will end with the words never machiavelli wars start when they want and end when they can but i wanted to clarify a short question for you because i will really reveal a secret we agreed with our viewers that we will not ask too many questions about the south because the situation is such that we need silence, what can we say now? well, well, well, everyone is really interested in what

we can say today. today, i understood the task. today, i will only reinforce the words of my colleagues who appeared before me, here are the troops. i don't understand the question, he said for a few days that he communicated in russian, his point of view . the grouping of troops on the right bank of the dnieper . and now we need to actually give our military the opportunity to drag it out for how long it will take. well, indeed, war is the most difficult and at the same time the most disgusting phenomena in human relations . there is nothing worse. calculations for 95% are calculated by mathematicians and then they carry out the hall so what well in order to understand the reality strategically strategically we intercepted the initiative of the enemy there is nothing else to impose on us in military logic with the exception of

weapons of mass destruction, but i can’t help but remember this is the so-called missile horror, unfortunately, it will continue , the time indicators are drawn, because everything is pulled from there from siberia, that’s why all these salvos were drawn out in time, but at the beginning of the war, the cumulative reserves from open sources, i emphasize the russian federation of missiles they were in the range of 8-9,000 3.5 shot i don't agree with the fact that they can have a philosophy of keeping something minimal for themselves, my colleague correctly said putin is fighting to the death and he will not give up without a fight, he kostyuk wanted a word, please and oksana yurynets, i want to support mr. petro, we are preparing for the worst. and if there is an easier option, fine. we can talk about what is happening in the kherson region, but not about the armed forces of ukraine. let's

look in the mirror. coast from there you can go to mykolaiv from there you can go to odesa from there you can go to kryvyi rih and there is also eh in eh in the area of ​​their attention in the mykolaiv oblast south ukrainian nuclear power plant one more this is just to the point that you can also eh is to frighten, for what? well, mrs. humynyuk humeniuk said it very well, have you heard that there are positional battles, or are they, er, getting orders from putin, they will not take on the general, er, to make some kind of decision? what he suspended and wants to command himself, what to do, i.e. what command will he give , do you advance, die, or hold on until the end, or will i save you in some other way, there are several points that

you should not pay attention to, first of all, from september 14 to 18 belarus will pass command and staff exercises will also be carried out there, of course, and there will be units of the odkb, each of which will be tested, in essence, the measurement of areas , that is, there will be one question that they will work on, this is the liberation of the lost regions of the conditional country. well, you can guess for yourself whether to think that this conditional country of ukraine is ukraine, this is volynsk, the border regions of volynsk, zhytomyr and rivne regions, from the 14th to the 18th, this is the first, but uh, sorry, from september 8 to september 14, i emphasize that now they are looking at what the west will give ukraine and here is 8

september rammstein it will be very important, they will of course want to know what they want, what they will give us, there was an appeal of 20, this is a former congressman, diplomats, military, who appealed to the government and to biden. then in about 10 days, maybe a little more, give the ukrainians an attack missile that would there are 300 km today in the mass media that analysts have already asked american research institutes to give this missile to the ukrainians so that the ukrainians could move on and then if they gave, but i am satisfied if ours is ours, or the supreme leader, the commander says, as they said, we don’t have a holodomer, but if necessary, we will use

it. this is for er putin will then draw conclusions. what should he do because if he loses kherson oblast, crimea will go further, that is, whether by conventional means if we get some kind of weapon, it will be difficult for him, that is, he will use weapons of mass destruction or not, but there is still variant note that says the minister of foreign affairs of russia the minister of foreign affairs of russia has been talking for the second day about how the russian-speaking people are being oppressed in moldova, and today he generally stated that we will consider it an attack on the russian federation if, from our point of view, there are any incomprehensible actions towards our peacekeepers, well those who guard kolbasova with with their projectiles, that is, you understand, but immediately the head of transnistria jumps out and says you know

that a war between russia and ukraine can spread on the territory of transnistria, and then it is russia build will fight with nato and let's reanimate the negotiating group in the format of 2+5 what is it eh two well let me remind you just two eh two two - these are moldova and transnistria a5 - this is russia as the guarantor of transnistria ukraine as guarantor of moldova osce as mediator and observers european union and the united states of america are talking about what they want to involve ukraine in the negotiations russia is a member of the security council of the united nations and transnistria and our south want to do in this way and even now russia understands this situation what is possible they on

at the peak of its capabilities and russia is starting to look for its friends well, i don't know, maybe macron thought so himself, he calls the president of iran and says listen, maybe you will become negotiators between russia and ukraine when macron is told what you are doing and he says that erdogan can and i can't, that is, now in addition to conducting military operations , russia is engaged in the fact that it is looking for a hybrid truce of some kind in order to do it later. of the armed forces of the assembly from the side of ukraine i went to the movie gladiator and when they were taken out to be slaughtered and asked the main hero of the movie gladiators what to do, he said to stand, that we did not succeed, so we must stand until the end, the government

must stand, no negotiations, i think that this will not happen and there will be one more ukraine should now be united , that is, it should not, well, let's say it somewhere, someone can already think about the elections, everyone who can be involved, our generals, colonels, whose health allows, who can, they must be involved because we are in danger a how will it turn out? well, we all understand that ukraine and others most need independence and exit from the border in 1991. when autumn comes, well, someone will get cold. we must be ready for it. that is, we are silently preparing for what is called the worst option, and those who are suffering there sometimes on facebook, why don't they say, well , help with something, if you have nothing to help, they go to the hospital, i'm talking about a specific lvivian, sit on a wheel, you're

injured and you'll be fine. do you think that if weapons of mass destruction are not used, well, actually, what everyone is afraid of, this tactical nuclear weapon, then the russian federation has little chance. how do you assess this probability? i wanted to ask you a question, especially in the context of the fact that they have now started talking about what is already in belarus planes that can carry tactical nuclear weapons and in general, belarus withdrew from these agreements that it lost its nuclear-free status, so to speak, or could there be a situation that putin, with the hands of lukashenka, will use tactical nuclear weapons? you understand. if we don't get what we need , then what mr. petro talked about, there will be enough shells, they say no one will release anyone, they are mobilizing and will continue to use those fire shafts to destroy

destroy destroy this horde. they will give us this amount, no one will give us artillery, they can give us accurate projectiles, and that is already the issue. but when they can give us anti- aircraft missiles, well, the heimers are unlikely to give them, and maybe they won’t give us more missiles, we needed them would we have planes, because now the hymers and the m-270 are in a certain way taking it upon themselves to do frontova aviation, that is, you understand, you can ask a lot of questions. and if so, i still would n’t know it. well, i don't know. for example, when i saw that in switzerland, switzerland has its own planes, they keep them in the mountains, maybe they are already doing something in the carpathians, maybe the enterprises will be completed in six months , they may start working, maybe not just one bohdana

. not i can answer, but you can’t relax, and the russians always go to the end of people, they will have enough of them. well, look at the survey, 73% will do what every one of them calls, there will be no putin, there will be a patroshok, it will not fall, they are all his pupils, they are all imperialists, we do not have a good leader we will have the only chance, and this is what you said, ms. oksana, the purpose of all these generations that fought before us has converged on us. if we lose now, well, it is difficult to say how we will rise, it is very difficult to say , and the galician army and the unr and the upa and the carpathian sich and everyone-everyone-everyone is against us we have to persevere we have to, well, the last moment, you know well, let's not have any negotiations, no matter what oleksandr the player says, i absolutely absolutely agree with more

competent colleagues, this is a war - this is a war of artillery, intelligence and aviation, and of course that our i also consider the task of parliamentarians of the previous convocation and this one to advocate for ukraine in order to strengthen the armed forces of ukraine with what they need . we are already getting a new prime minister who has a clear position regarding the use of tactical nuclear weapons, she speaks clearly and has her own specific visions of how she will act in this position, but other countries are key for us, including indonesia, jakarta where the important g20 will take place in the capital, where it is very important that there are no negotiations or attempts to talk about something like that for a break, the enemy is actually the enemy, and this one is the same as jordan, us, australia, which says little but does a lot, that is, in us there are those countries with whom we always think that it is only there europe and the united states. there are other countries here, we need a very

powerful one. i think diplomacy is its job. it is a pity that the deputies may have been limited. because i used to explain what the parliamentary assembly is. it was difficult. now there is rammstein and everyone understands that it is 30 plus the rest and there are 50 a and that this should be a constant conversation, this advocacy should be, and e, as for south korea, there are those things in different countries, it is very important today to convey all the information and explain how ukrainians are fighting here to be there we came to that agreement, there are things that cannot happen . without our friends and partners such as britain and the united states, if we were successful in these countries , the format of all the fronts on which we have to win is very important for us. we started from a school where we have to study and to be intellectual. and the war , including because we need a lot of high-quality equipment, sometimes not even just a helmet and a vest, it should be good monoculars, it should be drones, it should be those things that today

help save life a-a and e actually they do much more and can quickly destroy this low-quality, high-precision weapon, so another and very important thing is the economy, our economy of ukraine, which, unfortunately, is very, very weak, must switch to military lines, what does this mean, jobs and reorientation of ours sewing enterprises enterprises that sew shoes they are starting to do today very important support in this direction of that particular business and opportunities for people to work and pay taxes at those enterprises because it is much easier for us in the rear than the guys there on the front lines, it will be cold and there will be seasonal diseases. therefore, we have to understand that we have to work for security and there is a very unhealthy trend from the point of view in lviv, including the persecution of volunteers. and it must be said that a large part of security today and this support because almost all of our

relatives. we probably don't have a family. if someone didn't go and was mobilized, he wouldn't sign a contract for at least a year. the war is very close to everyone. and who wants to protect their loved ones today ? children he must teach them they must come to military training regardless of gender e and e today it is very important for us to realize that the one who is in the rear is not involved in military operations he must live very well every day and this is to work for the development of our of the state, and there should definitely be support and a separate policy here. i would very much like that, at least, parliamentary diplomacy, which was in the eighth convocation, was now in the parliament of this convocation, so that it would be more vocal because, in fact, it is the best the representation of people in the parliament is precisely through parliamentary diplomacy, but this is the best way to quickly reach those on whom a lot depends today in making decisions in the countries i mentioned and in the format of building

bilateral relations with those countries with which we were there different sometimes maybe not even to the vision or unfinished er-e agreements are needed, therefore we definitely cannot give the enemy an opportunity and in general no chance for him to wait, and we have to very powerfully and persistently advance our national ukrainian interest in all directions . for the sake of victory, mykola nizhynskyi will now have the floor literally a quote about a difficult autumn by the deputy head of the gur of the ministry of defense and the main directorate of intelligence, this is exactly what vitaliy skibytskyi said. what really is this autumn period will be decisive for us, let's listen to the climatic the conditions are september, october , bad weather will continue, november, winter, but hostilities continue, they may not be so active, but we have the experience of using the armed forces of the russian federation against our

in the sumy and chernihiv regions last winter , despite the fact that they escaped from there near our borders, there are approximately four battalion-tactical groups on the territory of russia. it will be difficult and it is also necessary to understand that not everything is so quick and so simple, you know . i just wanted to appeal to our viewers, to our people, so that we very clearly analyze the information that comes to us for ourselves, well no it happens in the war that someone today says tomorrow we will capture kherson, we will liberate kharkiv and the day after tomorrow we will liberate donetsk for all of us - of course it inspires us all we all really want to believe but if we look at the past days, this information that tomorrow we will take kherson was spread by various sources there was even

a statement that the accounts in the social networks of the commander-in-chief were fake, that they were false, that he did not write anything like that on his own account, suddenly society jumped in that wait for good news tomorrow, there will be good news tomorrow, and maybe we will free kherson and some military personnel. well, not the highest rank, but they make promises. there are already battles for kherson, and this, and this, and this, from my point of view, it can have two reasons, one is acceptable if we want to mislead the enemy because the war is being waged in our country on many fronts, and the front is large, if we have a disaster or a difficult situation somewhere near kharkiv or in donetsk region, it is obvious that if the enemy thinks that we will now start attacking in another place, they forces are transferred from here and they also try to deceive us, these informational operations are part of the war, there is a second dangerous trend, because sometimes politicians allow themselves to

divert attention from what the people now call zach schvars or mistakes when society wants to divert indignation by some actions of politicians because of this, they are already starting to switch their attention to what is happening at the front. we have such great victories. now we will go somewhere. and this can then be very dangerous. because those soldiers who are defending ukraine or are preparing to counterattack on this or that on this or that section of the front - this can, in principle, actually bring death, so with such things you need to do and act very carefully, it is obvious that we all see that we are fighting an asynchronous war with the enemy, we really do not have such the amount of artillery they have is more, they continue to produce it in us until now, and we have little thanks to our western partners.

where they are crowded, it definitely stops them for a full-fledged counteroffensive. we need even more weapons, and when it will really happen, i assure you, no one will ever warn you, but we know for sure that it will happen and we know for sure that we will hear on tv from those spokesmen not from fake accounts but from the commanders themselves, the fact that we won, we won back our cities and our territories , therefore, for this, we must have inner patience , support our soldiers, be convinced of victory and expect not to be disappointed even if you didn't see some kind of easy victory that everyone expected yesterday because there will definitely be a victory taras batenko, i have your word and then we will move on to another important topic. maybe only five of their employees are looking at each other for the future well, but so far there are no specifics behind those decisions, let's try to discuss what is important to us, and for now, taras butenko,

i have a few such thoughts, you know this first mykhailo gorbachev died last week, his wife is ukrainian, his mother is ukrainian, in fact, gorbachev seriously contributed to the collapse of the soviet union by pushing through reconstruction and publicity, such as depressurizing the cabin of an airplane that began to fall, as in the soviet union, this year he buried all those who contributed to the burial of the soviet union and shushkevich and he did not interfere with tailors , but he did not interfere with many things. today putin said goodbye to gorbachev's central committee. in other words, he is a tyrant who is actually in more and more complete isolation and self-isolation every day, and even already to the funeral of other persons of zhirynovsky and so on , we see that he no longer goes. he goes in self-isolation, well, taran. i'm just like historians , a political scientist, it's always a question, after all, who

does he equate to what hat in monomakh? well, i think that he is not less than the generalist wants. he thinks that this is a war for him, the great patriotic war, and it is obvious that yosipiv sarionovich gives stalin's lavra to him to sleep and the first months of the war, when stalin is basically the minister of defense himself as the minister of defense and then i will remove the chief of the general staff, nothing that he did not have a heart attack and so on, many fakes, of course, regarding the generality, the gold mission, which is now being launched by the head of the national guard, a general who recently met. i just turned one phrase of putin, who said that it is and so on, but a special military operation in donbas is being carried out no longer in ukraine, but already in donbas, and already donbas as a strategic goal is heard from him much more than it was heard before, i think that a certain adjustment of the plan is taking place. i think that he understands what, what, what, what his political regime it is beginning to dawn that the curtain and the heavy curtain are

totalitarian and the iron curtain has come down and the stations are starting to act so that the drop in gdp in the russian federation will be just as noticeable not only for the middle class of consumers but also for the lower class of consumers sooner or later next year, even more so and i believe that what can we count on in this situation? i have that we are obviously facing a difficult winter, but this winter i agree with mr. skibysky, who is a representative of guru, who said that it could be a freezing of the active phase hostilities, and what worries me is that, as a member of the cska, to say so about the supervision of the weapons that the western countries give is that the west will begin to cool down towards ukraine and will begin to look again at the war in ukraine, as it is more local the conflict, that is, something over there in the east, something over there is being preserved, the shelling is going on, so we

will continue to be shot at by the rocket, the rockets will really end in them, they will be more economical for this, of course, there may be damage, and that is in the winter and so on, but it will be less than before what to make a missile is not a ballistic missile or the rights to a missile is not easier than to simply make artillery weapons now for the russian federation and more planes in them have already begun to fall, today the cabin of another plane was depressurized, which landed ahead of schedule , that is, russia is a country which is starting to crack at the seams in terms of economy and trade , obviously now he is looking for imports to replace the huge president of russia i believe that in russia under his regime big problems are beginning and i think that after all, next year he will grope this now in the winter in the winter for this armistice and go on a pause for a strategic pause in order to raise military resources and military reserves and then prepare for the next revanch because obviously the main goal for