when, well, how will they survive this winter, but even after the winter, they must continue to sell gas and oil, which remains. if i am not mistaken, almost half of it is made up of some pretty clear. how will they, how will the russian economy balance without selling gas and oil to europeans? - first of all, we know that since the 1970s, the soviet union has been planning three energy expansions in europe. the first was oil, the second was gas, and the third, they tried to make a power station, but no, no, no, they did not have time, the soviet union collapsed . the union and, first of all, it is, today, we can state that russia is not considered inferior to european countries as a supplier of reliable supply,

and in general as suppliers of energy resources to europe for a long time, the first is the second. what will russia lose? it is clear that there will be a huge hole in the budget and there will be financial losses, because gas and oil are the income for the plot, they made up somewhere around 50%. there, up to 50% . these are colossal losses and thirdly the following question arises, technically, what should be done with these wells, they need to be conserved, and the conservation of wells is also a very large material expense, and when it is weighed, they are conserved, and it is not a fact that it can be deconserved, it is very difficult, therefore, russia

as a whole can rub it in and he can lose his oil and gas complex, he can already be sure that it will not be such a powerful oil and gas complex because there will be no buyers . they will not be able to build it and so on, and china is there, and other countries, well, they won't be able to me to compensate, and they don’t really want to because they see that russia is not a reliable supplier. well, they are there, turkey is there, hungary is there for a short period of time. er, russia as a reliable partner, they lost this war, they hoped that they would frighten the jews , which will not happen. they will not be able to diversify and so on. and they will come back again. they will ask. let us, er, put

nord stream two into operation. they look at what they came to, they closed the northern stream, they almost closed it, and it didn't scare the europeans, yes, they are busy, they are worried, but we don't see that they were already so scared that they will go to some negotiations from russia and now we are entering the barge and sanctions on oil, this is a very big blow, we know that the negotiations on the nuclear deal are going on, and if there is some kind of agreement and the country reduces its nuclear program , then the sanctions will be lifted and maybe supply oil very big boys to compensate for the supply of russia, that is, in fact, the russians are cutting down the branch on

which they themselves are sitting. they like fairy tales now, to remember all kinds of phrases from fairy tales, so here is a little saying, they can cut it down . clarification ivan is crying when the ex-minister of pavlov and energy of ukraine, the chairman of the council of the union of the all-ukrainian energy assembly e-e was with us, he explained a little about the megate report, he explained a little about whether europe will freeze as it threatens to her putin and what and what will become of russia that she will keep everything that fed her in her bosom well, the main conclusion for ivan is that russia lost the energy war with the west, we all this is something that all the soviets could not afford the general secretaries, that is, what were they holding on to, they were holding on to this pipe, they were holding on to this pipe, because they understood that the state is a gas station

. thanks to our viewers who responded er, under the comments under youtube, they say that it is a broadcast. some people say that they don't write, they don't comment, but they watch to understand the processes, but they don't participate in stupid conversations with bots, there's no need to participate, and we're just interested in feedback or are you interested in the topics we are talking about, do they hurt you, how do they hurt us? well , actually, now we are going to talk a little about the pain with volodymyr vyatrovych, people's deputy of ukraine and member of the committee on humanitarian and information policy, as well as the head of the ukrainian institute of national remembrance in 2014-2019 volodymyr good

day good day to you from pain - this is the last one this is the last post i 'm glad i saw about the broadcasts of the tv channel because before we were used to that so that it was possible to calmly watch what is taking place in the verkhovna rada. now it’s somehow like that, there’s no broadcast, that is, the valley comes to us in such pieces of video. someone, somewhere, someone filmed a short reference, if you allow it, at the beginning of this year, before the war, it was decided to increase it. well for example, actually in the budget of the last year, it was decided to increase the funding of the rada tv channel almost every time, and it is almost uah 400 million, this is at pre-war prices , that is, the rada tv channel was engaged in some kind of business, now the rada tv channel

actually. and it doesn’t exist, it doesn’t do anything, only that there are several presenters, even in this, they have invested money in this nationwide marathon, but at least 400 million are definitely going for something and they are going for a noble one, as some people think the business of our politicians, this matter is simply propaganda, not even propaganda of the ukrainian state, which is perhaps what the ruling party needs, because , unfortunately, the only thing the rada tv channel is doing now is simply praising the people's freedom party with the participation of the people's servant party itself . we stopped talking about the need for some kind of state television many years ago, thank god, ostensibly declaring that we are moving towards europe. we began to abandon the need for such a state television television appeared public television appeared public television there were some were

black some of different kinds in private tv channels , that is, it was moving in principle in the right direction and one of them was divided last year when it probably became clear to the authorities that public public television as a tool is not convenient enough for authorities for the propaganda of one political party and the leadership of the state then began to follow a different path by creating or inflating the tv channel of the council, in fact, the essence of the existence of this only one tv channel actually broadcasts what is happening in the next hall, it is important because it is one of the elements of democracy, ukrainians must see what is adopted and it is no less important how it is adopted, and in principle this is the element of democracy that ukrainians are probably already used to it seems that since 1990, if i am not mistaken, the first broadcasts began in the 1990s, this is the first democratic convocation, broadcasts and sessions began, and indeed, despite the fact that it is obvious that politicians use

this one in particular for some public moments, but in general in fact, it was a very positive, very correct tool that provided transparency to this authority in the legislative power, and so ukrainians could know what was being done under the dome in the verkhovna rada , what decisions were made, and why ? decided that it is not enough to simply show broadcasts of the verkhovna rada, when in fact someone's youtube channel would have been enough for this, and it would certainly not be necessary to throw away half a billion of state funds to obtain gold for a tv channel decided to give this almost half a billion funds to this tv channel, the presenters appeared in interesting jackets with its equipped under the dome of the verkhovna rada, an expensive studio was watched by strange experts over time with some very pro-russian bracket that at one time came to light like petrov, who at one time came to light in all

kinds of pro-russian informational tv channels, and all this was just before the beginning of the large-scale invasion , and it seemed to the authorities that they had found the right way to use this instrument, although in parallel, inclusions from the verkhovna rada were still issued, in parallel, they even tried from time to time to give representatives of various political forces, not only the servants of the people, in this tv channel at the beginning of the war, it is obvious that the situation began to change quite seriously as a result of these changes, further such monopolization, even party monopolization of this tv channel, we can practically say that yesterday it found its own some kind of already legitimate affirmation in the e-e resolution that was adopted on the initiative of e-e new in fact deputy bozhkov, he is given only a few months , maybe even less, and he is a deputy, a new deputy from the servant of the people, someone went through the list, which, in fact, now we do not oblige the rada tv channel

to broadcast the meeting of the verkhovna rada at all, this was all done with great pleasure - the majority of deputies from the people's servants who for some reason believe that even some recordings with the broadcast of the verkhovna rada can establish a danger for the legislative body of ukraine, so let's do better, we will do it quietly because we need to preserve the integrity of the legislative power, we need him to continue in the parliament, that's why we won't allow anyone else to broadcast any broadcasts from the session of the verkhovna rada, well, it's obvious that it's a great tool for returning to the parliament, eh, some preliminary approaches the desire to solve some private matters has returned. and it seems to me that it is absolutely not accidental, you know. yesterday's decision to cancel the broadcast actually coincided with an attempt to change such an important tool that

put an anti-corruption policy in ukraine, how to remove it, he presupposed the politicization of this body and not the affiliation of its head to any political forces, therefore, taking into account the fact that yesterday such a decision about e-e regarding the rada channel was adopted. unfortunately, it should be expected that such incomprehensible to the majority of ukrainian citizens, decisions ah, for me personally, quite unpleasant decisions, which are far from moving ukraine in the direction of europe, to move ukraine away from russia, unfortunately, they will surely become more frequent because what is very important there was in ukraine, in ukrainian parliamentarism, it is such a fairly dense citizen control, it is obvious that after this decision, well, his opportunities will become much smaller, the fact is, volodymyr, one clarification is that this is the tv channel rada, it is included in the list of these tv channels that participate in the marathon, the only news and there were complaints from certain deputies that

they don't get them, they don't attract uh, the other day she wrote about the fact that in six months she was never invited to ask a single question, and that she is she who is she and she is actually the deputy head factions. yes, she and the deputy head of the faction and the members of our faction are very, very rare guests at the marathon and probably even more rare in their abilities on this tv channel. the inclusion of mostly e-e from the presentation of volodymyr petrovych the historian, but periodically it was necessary to remind that volodymyr petrovych the historian is still a people's deputy of ukraine and it is obvious that he is ready to talk not only about the past and the present e-e, there is no doubt that these analyzes of the content of the tv channel are welcome that are carried out, are there marathons, the only news

that are carried out, for example, the media detector, show the complete dominance of one political force, the servant of the people, that is, about 90% of the air is occupied by politicians of this political force, read by experts who talk about big the achievements of this political force are both in form and in content. well, as a historian, only a people's deputy actually reminds me of the soviet past , it really reminds me of absolutely soviet approaches to prove this, what is being done in ukraine even speak i absolutely do not understand this information policy that is currently carried out in the country in particular and in the context of hostilities in particular and in the context of war i do not understand why in order to understand what is happening now in ukraine on the fronts how our soldiers are fighting like gains in we have to look for this information somewhere in some foreign media. i don't understand why, in order to understand the scale and features of the battle for kyiv

, this is probably one of the key at this stage of the war between russia and ukraine, we have to wait six months and it was necessary to wait for the investigation of journalists in washington in order to understand what exactly was happening around kyiv. i believe that such an information policy is not only incorrect from the point of view of political from the point of view of mobilizing the population from the point of view of mobilizing ukrainians to protect ukraine, ukrainians must understand what is being done in the country, ukrainians must be ready to defend their state, well, in the end, even if we talk about this the same battle for kyiv. well, there are all the reasons to be proud of our army, to be proud of ourselves that we managed to achieve such a significant turning point in this war. unfortunately, we know this . by the way, the existence of the tv channel is a pleasure, now as a state tv channel that actually covers only

the well, even chernenko and oleksandr have already joked. what's honest then, let's rename it treason. i mean the office. since the councils are not represented there, the full ones are represented there , mostly the position of the president's office but does our legislation in principle allow uh to have an office, for example, the president or the president or a political force to have a channel financed from the state budget i say once again 400 million almost 500 almost 15 that he does not allow of course he does not play but it has been constant since the time when president zelensky became president there has been a constant desire to actually master some information channel to have his own television and his struggle so-called with oligarch, it was not aimed at intimidating them in order to get some funds for the

development of the country, it was aimed at the very simple thing of getting additional media into their hands , that is, if the oligarch got rid of the mass media , he ceased to be an oligarch, that is this is exactly the kind of proposal that the president made through this law on oligarchs in those whom he considered to be oligarchs . i will remind you. propaganda channel, the president's office made another attempt through its now -deceased deputy kovalev, they purchased the so-called fourth tv channel, which was apparently also considered as a possibility of some kind of information tool for the servant of the people party. er, he began to serve a little different people, he ended up in the territory of the kherson region, and

his service was the longest, not for a very long time, and because he actually died in the fight with ukrainian partisans, and now the state, by the way, becomes his own one more tv channel, which we will learn about with the briefing information of the head of the state cinema, mrs. maryna fedorchuk, who declares that the state will own another fourth channel and, you know , against the background of all this, some statements about european integration that we, especially in politics, have possibility, we are discussing the media law, we are moving in the direction of europe, well, it looks absolutely fake, it absolutely looks absolutely, well , those who differ on the matter, no, unlike the european experience, we have state tv channels are called party tv channels, which, with state funds, are engaged in promoting some kind of information signals, which are profitable, which are needed only in one political force and the office of the

president . power as a legislative parliament is some kind of self-sufficient independent body that determines the policy in this country now over the last two months, it seems to me that it has deepened even more i.e. because deputies simply lose their subjectivity as deputies simply do not decide anything other than to carry out some political orders of the president's office and everyone understands this and unfortunately, well, i do not see any uncomfortable discomfort in my colleagues deputies who, in order to somehow assert themselves, show that the legislative branch of government in ukraine is still the main branch of government. well, it should be enough for itself. i remember there was a pandemic and journalists were somehow restricted from the sidelines, now journalists can communicate with

by the people's elected officials no no no no actually that is, it all started everything really started with the pandemic everything started with the order regarding the decision of the chairman of the verkhovna rada razumkov, which limited the possibility for journalists to enter the dome of the verkhovna rada er limited geographically, that is, they had the opportunity to be only on the third floor now , in fact, the only journalists who can be in joy are also the journalists of the rada tv channel, who are only interested in deputies from one political force, which is the servant of the people, that is, so very limited understanding of the role of the media and the role of the parliament. this is what we are witnessing. and it is very unfortunate because i think that in fact, in ukraine , only a normally democratic ukrainian state can act against russia, and not some you know what a quasi-democratic model. thank you , volodymyr vitrovych, people's deputy of ukraine, er, with

a member of the committee on humanitarian and information policy, he joined us. a cup of channels that er are not er of different er people's elected officials, regardless of which political force they are close to and whether they belong to the government or not, they belong god has mercy on it. it is actually very, very much too. well, to a certain extent, well, this is why this is ours this is our space where we live where we exist for example there well, we are journalists, yes, that is, here i am, look here, i can tell you my story and the fifth channel tried to close kuchma. i worked on it, then tvi tried to close it yanukovych worked on it, then the direct channel tried to close it, we will not point the finger at who until the war. well, you are also in the know. well, now,

for example, we are working with lesya on espresso and also espresso . someone said yes, they turned off digital broadcasting. well, in fact, in the west, they see all this, and even from time to time they lose patience, as it actually happened literally this week. so we will talk a little about the draft law one that was worried about er jaysoven and tetyana ostrikova, a lawyer, a people's deputy of the eighth convocation, ms. tetyana is in touch with us. good afternoon, half a year, er, the event, jaysoven , will answer all the questions, do you have any misunderstandings, and so on no no no no everything is fine we all support the ukrainian government they are fighting hard for them well this time they lost their

patience a little they said no stop a little and this is about what is about the fact that a draft law was submitted that was supposed to be voted on what they quickly convened several representatives of the servants of the people. as they say, the infamous smyrna tatarov and the office of the president, who manage the power bloc, were behind it. there was a bill that could quite easily remove any director of the national agency from the struggle. god, everything is now nabu by the word of any manager, nabu ot well, but shabunin and the company worked on time, it gained a certain publicity and there was a statement by the big seven itself that they are watching this law very carefully and it is the same as if it had disappeared, i am right yes, that was it it is no longer there, it was and still is, but the other

bill voted by the verkhovna rada today is no less strange, but let's first go back to the first version, and here it is worth mentioning that it was submitted by a people 's deputy from a servant of the people named klochko, this people's deputy heads the committee not at all anti-corruption wars, the committee of local self-government and state construction should have taken care of the problems of communities and administrative reform and local self-government, but for some reason it suddenly took over by which demands are made to the head of the nabu, to the head of the specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office and the national agency for the prevention of corruption of other law enforcement agencies, and a single person submitted a bill that caused, perhaps for the first time during the war, such strong criticism

, in particular, from public activists, you have already mentioned e p shabunin vitaliy his the anti-corruption center of other anti-corruption organizations and also that the main ambassadors of gs1 countries second what was pluchko known for is that he is a figure in one of the criminal investigations that are being carried out by nabu, that is, imagine that a law enforcement agency, a national anti-corruption bureau, is investigating a criminal proceeding regarding the legal enrichment of mr. klitschko and a piece of chicken . during his term as a deputy, his relatives were overgrown with expensive real estate and some means of transport. and that the committee did not see that there is a conflict of interests of this particular deputy, that he cannot speak and that

you know, really, according to the law , there is no conflict of interest in the legal sense, but actually in the sense that there are criminal proceedings against a person. she should be engaged in local self-government and state construction, and suddenly she is single-handedly concerned with the fate of the nabu and the appointment of the head . a sane person is led to certain reflections, why would this suddenly happen, and also being a figure in criminal proceedings, which is being investigated by this very body, here it should be reminded that this mr. klochko owns two apartments, a house and tesla, in fact, his mother is behind the last two years, it was the 21st year, it was just a year ago, there was this information, she became the owner of property worth 14 and a half million hryvnias, and you know , in a strange way, he suddenly

changed. about nabu last year was brought into line with the constitution precisely in this part, in the part of appointing the head of nabu, and because he was appointed earlier by the president , the president does not have such powers, the constitutional court recognized the norm as unconstitutional , therefore it was mr. klochko and his colleagues in the parliament this law was already changed last year, and what suddenly happened, less than a year has passed since they wanted to change it again, and the answer here is very simple in august, and the competition for the actual competition for the head of the national anti-corruption bureau should have started . imagine you are members of the commission and suddenly an honorable people's deputy, a servant of the people, a representative of the monomajority introduces a bill that changes the actual requirements and criteria, good as a leader, well, of

course, the commission says well, then what are we going to do to work to accept documents and then the law will change and all our work will actually go to nivea , so we allow ourselves to winterize as much as possible, but in fact the purpose of submitting this bill was to delay the competition and in this case, as always, in the most interesting place, we have some problems with i would still like to hear about it, there are still three minutes, two minutes , even before the news is supposed to start . refer to your sources that in fact this deputy was not even behind this, it is clear that he has his own interest directly in order to make

mrs. tetyana ineffective under the control of the national corruption bureau of ukraine, and we actually have two minutes left before the news. can we miss that this is not only the initiative of one a deputy who has problems with the law, but behind this are also the people of the president, namely andriy smirnov and oleg tatarov, of course that and mr. klochko is simply fulfilling his certain obligations to the president's office and the goal the purpose of the draft law is to delay or make it impossible to hold the competition, and why is it extremely important, because if we look at the composition of the budget revenues for august, we have been given a record for the amount of international financial aid and have already exceeded the amount of taxes we pay to the state budget in august, this is already about 109 billion hryvnias of financial aid, and there is definitely a question about how to spend it, whether again for some constructions and so on or, after all, for the army and to support those

who were primarily affected by hostilities and here definitely the question of the distribution of funds and the question of possible corrupt actions is the direct competence of the nabu, that is, who will control the nabu, the one who will control the distribution of these funds is so simple . arithmetic is interesting. by the way, they really want to remove it from the norm that does not allow having a ku-ku- contestant in a parade with party forces nabu and they really want to put a deputy from the rural people on their head. so, let's continue this topic, let's dissect all these bills into small pieces. tetyana ostrikova, the lawyer of the eighth people's deputy the convocation was with us, but now iryna koval will be with us, who already has a fresh selection of news for us and will tell us about it, so the occupiers continue to terrorize the civilian population of ukraine. i will tell you more about the shelling of our territories. and also about