still play the role of a minister here, but he has the competence - this is information policy and dealing with issues of disinformation, issues of russian meetings, he led in the first moment, if you are talking now about the security service of ukraine , it was probably correct to ask the security service of ukraine , not me man, let's ask questions correctly. well, i think that if you, as an adviser to the minister of internal affairs, would also ask some of your colleagues why such things happen to volunteers and whether whether they are on time, i would like to ask if we are talking about the security service , then we need security, if we are talking about some other body, then hand it over to those who are responsible for it, but now we are having a discussion in which i am, in principle, a deeply incompetent person . i don't really know what it is. well, actually, sir. if we talk about the informational

policy, the informational component of this is, well, i'm just interested. i understand that there are now a lot of volunteer organizations, a lot of volunteer activity, obviously, as well as there are probably people everywhere who are trying to make money here, in fact, what is a crime, for example, with a humanitarian worker, this is actually importing something, for example, without customs duty, this is actually evading the payment of customs duties and then pretending to bring in contraband under the guise of now i am thinking correctly, or is it embezzlement, something to be bought, for example , for the donation of people, and the third option is when money is simply stolen from the budget, as it happened in the case of what is now being accused of one of the of the heads of the ministry of defense in embezzling $ 500,000 of budget funds that were actually

intended for various humanitarian projects. that is , these are three completely different stories if we even, well , that is, we assume that there are people who were imported, for example, the same pickup trucks for the armed forces of ukraine somewhere they are actually abused there, and we understand that there are such cases, we saw how they were imported there en masse at the very beginning, there are various bentleys and so on, but but the question is simply that it is always a different weight of damage that is successful it is one thing to not pay taxes to the state, for example, there is simply a customs duty, for example, they took away an imported car, and it is a completely different thing to steal money, for example, from the budget, on the other hand, it is a shame from such stories when there are well-known people who are engaged in this volunteer work and suddenly it looks like a whole is working against them the police or the entire security service of ukraine, and this may have signs of automatic reprisal or repression. well, it is a very

serious blow, in fact, to the information field, how to prevent this, or is it possible to investigate end at least one case and punish those who were behind it are being investigated and indeed these cases are now working on the whole case plus everything else well, that's your question. that's actually the answer to it. our entire law enforcement system has turned into uh, in many respects, i freely believe in the situation. when someone has the best map, in principle, and talked about the fact that either he conducts or it is the fault of the law enforcement officers, so in this case, of course, i do not reject the fact that there are huge problems in the judicial system and the law enforcement system of ukraine that have been going on for many decades already. and for today, but once again i would like to say that the worst thing is when we start playing in criminal proceedings in the situation of who is the better pr.

that is, in fact, this is also a road to nowhere, well, actually, when we we have a rule of law, then only such protection mechanisms work, uh, we do it too, well, if we understand it like this, and p. i will also ask at the end, if possible, briefly a-but actually, regarding the situation with everything, they will switch to another topic. but this er, i just didn’t have time then, so that in our country, estonia, lithuania, latvia, er, and poland have agreed that the russians will not be able to enter freely. how important is this history and will they not be able to use it in finland? how will the russians now enter the to the schengen countries , er, the schengen union, well, clearly. are you no less concerned? the russians will obviously enter through turkey through other countries, but this step is one of the strongest moral blows to the russian federation. why? this is a very serious moral blow.

for one simple reason, because for uh 22 years they were told about getting up from their knees until they were 100 years old and they said that uh we can be rude uh and in response words and frightened europe will take two steps away and we will to get a word, and here, completely unexpectedly, for the first time in 22 years, they say that we continue to homite, and suddenly they put us on our knees again and turn us into people of the second court, eh, here is the noise, the russians did not talk about the fact that it will affect a small part of the russians, because now everything a little more than one million membership visas have been issued there to residents of the russian federation - to citizens of the russian federation, yes, this is supposedly the 130th, but at the same time, it is a global moral blow to the russian federation, and that is why they are so seriously worried about this, they have become the second people a person and this for them is not getting up a scalar, on the contrary, returning e-e for a conversation for

answers in one denisenko, an adviser to the minister of internal affairs of ukraine and the executive director of the ukrainian institute of the future was with us at in connection with him, they found out what happens in the end with the volunteers who help our soldiers at the front, in particular with the fact that cars are supplied there at that time. actually, i would also like to ask our military personnel who they drive cars to the extent that they make life easier for them, but here, of course, i just raised this issue in this conversation. i think that of course there is some damage, i say there is, but there is always a question of priority. one thing is when someone is there somewhere resell some turnstiles and there is vile and ugly or brings in some low-quality ones. well, it’s already worse there. yes, although there are always significantly different

games, there are always different gradations, relatively speaking. but it seems to me that what concerns these cars and pickups , for example. well, it is better to let them in than, for example, to paralyze all this traffic of cars now, because this car in the war sometimes lives at zero, but it lives constantly all the time, because this is the life of the people, this is the life of the people, if, for example, the state would completely i could somehow ensure the purchase, but no, for example, the background, come back alive, taras chmont, they bought the first 11 currently armored cars, the lc-79 fighter 2 , and they will be, and they say that they will only deal with cars in the future. this is the biggest need now , in fact, the army, or can zuluzhny say that there is no need for cars anymore, all the volunteers seem to calm down. no, he says a little differently that the war will continue in the 23rd and we need a lot

of resources and we are paralyzed by such things now. well, i don't know, i don't know alone and if even here there is no political subtext, then there is simply idiocy, an idiotic subtext, so that during the war it is also a crime to talk to the military, who i am currently on the front lines, and i think that in them we will ask about how the irivka, what function it performs, how many of these are needed a lot of cars are being lost, but for now we are wondering what is happening in kherson, kherson oblast , volodymyr-volychanov, kherson political scientist, in touch with us good day p volodymyr good day please tell me here the french general says that ukraine can liberate kherson before the winter. what do you think of these forecasts or how realistic are they? is it just such encouraging and feeling

that it is theoretically possible, moreover , it is necessary for the people of kherson, the residents of the city of kherson, because half, if not more, now those who remain depend on the central the heating of which is standing in the winter will not be due to the fact that all the heat-generating enterprises, having taken over the substations, have established their administration there, and therefore they will not be able to even write, they would not be able to purchase gas for the needs of these enterprises, and gas is supplied there not from the crimea, not from any other occupied territories , but from the side of mykolaiv. that is, it is mainly ukrainian-produced gas, so there is a huge need for gas for heating for the winter, if it is released in kherson, there will not be. and so, of course , the people of kherson will have to additionally

they are expected after the destruction of the bridges and the gradual reduction, let’s say, of the occupier’s ability to transport not only their military cargo, but also to enable civilian transport to move from the left bank to the right to kherson expect a shortage of literally all possible consumer goods and, in particular, it will primarily be fuel, since the occupiers are now trying to establish a solar pipeline between the left and right banks. but i think that the judgment will quickly destroy these efforts, and therefore there will be a shortage of fuel of all types on the right bank, it is possible will also cause the impossibility even within the limits of the right bank to deliver food, for example, from bulls to the city of kherson, and thus expect a shortage of both food products, he said

warm and of course the rest of the false goods , that is, very unpleasant times await in kherson in addition to the security crisis, which is connected with the occupation and the terror of the invaders against the civilian population. therefore, first of all, this liberation is necessary, on the other hand, it is clear that a lot depends on how exactly and in what way the occupiers will resist now, i.e. if it is possible to establish an effective countermeasure to any of their supply, then they have a possible option or leave voluntarily, which is unlikely by order of the command, because they politically made kherson such a very important asset for themselves for the entire criminal russian

society, which rejoices at the capture of this, on the other hand, so that the troops ran away from waiting for the guesswork base, perhaps it is still necessary to do approximately the same as they did in vysokopill, that is, to destroy all the existing also on the right bank stocks of e shells eh well, in addition, we will still have to carry out certain assault actions which, unfortunately, do not do without losses, that is, for kherson, with two lines in the beams, it will not be easy and eh, i don’t know when will it happen, but for sure. it’s not a matter of one or two weeks. and how is the mood of the people of kherson after this video? i think everyone has seen it and probably watched it several times, where the occupier is filming how they are happily trying to cross the dnipro, and then the filming

stops, and most of the suns are happy about this to the destruction of the occupiers, and for them this is such an additional evidence that liberation is closer than it might seem, because in the occupation, the time dimension is a little different, and all the right-wing statements about the speed of liberation that were heard in the summer are not pitiful they only add to the disappointment and do not believe any statements, believe only in some practical consequences and actions , and this fire control, as established over the crossings, has such consequences. well, all the more so that in addition to the actual crossings, finally, our artillery pays attention directly to the russian object in kherson itself, i.e., what

started in july in nova kakhovka. now, for about a week, it has already spread to kherson, i.e., the impressions of the objects are, first of all, the location of various occupying structures, such as the national guard the effect b or is a sign of work and we all expect that additional supplies against harm e radar missiles will allow us to finally destroy the pkovaya forces, which are quite significant in kherson, and to use not only artillery against the occupiers, but also without by the way, we have good information that norway gives us 160 missiles help file well, we'll talk about this a little later with the military experts, vladimir, i have one last question, and the deputy chairman of the federation council of the russian federation, andriy turchak, has already said that let's hold a referendum before

accession with the russian federation on november 4 already on november 4 and this is the self-proclaimed leader of crimea and traitor to ukraine aksyonov said that let's just join them without a referendum, anyway, then no one pays attention to those referendums, what do you say about it? i think that it is a strange proposal aksionova is more realistic in russian realities than the proposal of the turkchak himself. the turkchak is now representing a political wing in the russian government that lost the fight for kherson region with the death of salda, well with probable death. balance or with his removal by the actual e-e, this is the wing that is seasoned by the russian army and the united russia party, which is the deputy

whose head is turchak? less competent than the balance administration, but they have already dragged one of the members of this administration to themselves, the so-called now minister of health, vadim yermiyev, who also headed the social administration in the same way. continues to formally head the department of health care, and in this way, it means that a referendum is proposed to be held on november 4 on groupings that russia's opportunities will not improve . on the contrary, it will worsen even the only option

of holding a referendum, or rather its imitation, such as bringing in actors who will play the roles of voters and play the roles of members of the commission e-e preparation premises that will play the role of precinct commissions . well, the preparation of some kind of paper that will play the role of ballots for russian tv channels is not just impossible, at least on the right bank . a russian military train headed for melitopol was destroyed in the genichesky district, that is, there is no place, and since this referendum, and in general, participation in it is a criminal offense under our criminal code, so that such precincts will be a legitimate military target for shooting there, that's why i think that on november 4 they won't

even be able to make an imitation, and it's not bad for us that uh, there are still two months to finally destroy them and uh, let's say to convince the collaborators a couple of collars we don't have much, but we still have it. because russia is not forever and not for a long time, and therefore it is not worth helping you in particular in trying to conduct this referent. well, as for aksyonov's idea of ​​joining, it is so simple that there are many forces in russia that are against the joining of kherson oblast and in general, they are against the accession because, first of all, it is a security problem for the russians, because they are afraid of such new russian citizens who are scouting all over russia and then will commit various acts of sabotage there, they blame the ukrainians, even in crimea, for the fact that they will ask dnipropetrovsk too many ukrainians to draw ribbons yellow and blue-yellow

flags draw russian flags as they do in kherson infect the word crimea with the ukrainian spirit thank you, mr. volodymyr, for the news from the kherson region volodymyr molchanov of kherson the political scientist was with us. we go further and add to our conversation artem ruban, a soldier of the freedom battalion of the national guard, he is now in the donbass. we congratulate mr. artem. congratulations studio. glory to ukraine. they said that the russians write that they have again focused their efforts on bahmut. that is, this is the main point of the attack that is happening in the donbass. "."

you can hear all the volley fire systems are working, from time to time there are attacks, but ours repel them quite successfully, so if we say so for the time being, that’s

all eh. for this brief information, here is the question: are you in the car now? did you get this car from volunteers or where did it come from? good question: this car came from my very close friend rostyslav melnyk, who gave it to me. by the way, avdiivka recently burned down under the hood, so there is nothing left of it before as my close friends also gave me. so she first came under artillery fire, then i tried to pull her out, but she was finished off by the grads, and unfortunately, how important is it for the military on the zero on the front line volonte, what volunteers transport these cars and

transfer pickup trucks, it is very important, it is extremely important because a car is like a drone - it is a waste, that is, we constantly lose them and there are no roads, unfortunately, in donbas , we constantly break the volume on these roads , it is very, very, very difficult for you to drive a car, and the car is here because we save our wounded brothers with cars. -menee was normal, that's why the car is for us let's say everything here. i'll fall in love with this car, do n't drive it into that area if it's hidden in my place, because if this one is broken, i wo n't even have it home, so he has to go. thank you , mr. artem, i hope that they will find an opportunity after all in order for the ukrainian volunteers to be able to drive these into very important pickups

for the military, which are a matter of life and death. thank you, mr. artem. take care. artem ruban . let the car take care of you. you take care of it and support each other. but none the less i i think that it is also necessary to protect those volunteers who are taking risks now by driving cars so that they get to donbas and are afraid because these cases are opened one after the other, but they also do not add optimism and do not motivate in order to support the army because each begins to think about his safety and his freedom well, let's continue oleksiy hetman ato veteran military expert joins us oleksiy good day good day glory to ukraine glory to heroes remains with us literally six minutes for a conversation before the main one right away valeriy zaluzhny

co-author by the way with zabrodsky deputy and general and combatant hm actually written and and by the way the deputy and the parliamentary defense committee what have you read, what should you pay attention to they published an analytical article in which they see this war like this. this is a very interesting article, and finally we heard from specialists who directly take part in these hostilities, who understand that it is not uh, according to some insider an interesting analytical article where they analyzed what is happening now, which are not more dangerous directions, what should we expect in the coming months of the war, how should we predict hostilities for 2023, that is, they directly said that we

should not expect that it will end soon and they analyzed very interestingly whether or not we should liberate crimea right now from a military point of view, from a political point of view, it must be done definitely more precisely, and from a military point of view, how forest-like is it all, and secondly they analyzed the probability of the use of atomic weapons by the russian federation, and there are nuclear weapons against us and what is necessary for our armed forces in order to provide certain descriptions of thousands of the enemy, this is very much an article and it is them, i understand that they have prepared and it is not exactly an article, some kind of article the data of the article are said to be analytical conclusions, this is by and large scientific and military work, if you can call it that, if it is necessary to discuss it, it is necessary to focus on one of the directions

more than you said that it was six minutes, there were four left. general zuluzhny can hardly be called such a person who is public, who records some kind of posts. that is, we very rarely see greetings to the day of independence there, or there is a thank you to the poles, their greetings. and here he writes an article and publishes it. why did it appear just now ? why did he decide to talk to ukrainians in this way? you know. well, on the one hand, we can say that he lost his patience because we see a very large number of so-called positive bloggers. who are starting to say that we have defeated everyone, we will bomb everyone. and now we will raise the yellow-blue flag over the kremlin, he, together with the commander-in-chief, the commander of the er-e behind the alkaline, he says that first of all, the artillery power, which is now

going on, the artillery war is superior, well air the war is about 10 times greater than the ukrainians, he wrote that near bakhmut, near the fields, in other directions, there is a large advance of russian troops in the clinic, and this can be dangerous. he explained that we if we continue to fight, as in my opinion now i.e. russia has weapons that shoot at 1.5-2000 km, and we at a maximum of 100 km, that's it, and we can't destroy their bases, with the exception of technical passes that are located in the immediate vicinity of the front line, then such a war can last a very long time and it will to go to exhaustion, who will speak faster , most likely it will be you, because we are not such an economically powerful country and we do not have so many weapons, only the russian federation has them. therefore, we need more long-range weapons, er, we need some pressure on the russian federation of our western partners. well

and a number of measures that they propose to take , including anti-aircraft defenses, what do we need, a missile, these new weapons, well, this is the arm standard, the so-called 88, to destroy their anti -aircraft defenses, and what anti-aircraft defenses we need. well, preferably, of course , preferably planes because after all, this is an artillery war, an air war, an infantry war - this is already going on. it is after the destruction of the infrastructure of the military infrastructure of the enemy. finally, i would like to ask, what do you think, whether this article will be well or not are there any among the addressees of this article? also, i think that it is partially directed at western leaders who also need to know the vision, and i also think that it is also directed at ukrainian politicians. well, it seems to me that there were certain such rumors and omissions that are not always there are good

relations and i like this, it's two things, as i think the truth is, first of all, what he said about that in order to win the war , we need weapons that will destroy e-e warehouses not at an operational distance, but at a long distance on that including in the temporarily occupied territories of our country, our temporarily occupied territories are not far away from where such missiles flying several thousand kilometers can be fired, he gently pointed out that we need weapons that will destroy infrastructural military facilities that are used against we are on the territory of the russian federation, we have some kind of strange war, they shoot at us wherever they want, at least in the field, even in odesa, and we cannot shoot at their military base because it is somehow something over there something violates or i don't understand at all what it is thank you

as regards uh directly likes what i like deserved well of course he many people didn't think about it because uh there are people who don't uh in their thoughts not how to win wars but how much do you keep your rating? when will the general stop being more popular? they are such childish jealousy during the war. you can’t do this. then we’ll figure out who has what. let’s win this war first. thank you, mr. oleksiy. he still didn't give birth to please everyone, there is such a beautiful saying, er, such a thing but, as we can see, he pleases ukrainians and pleases abroad with what he does er .