these are your eyes of ukraine as this year yes and the next one will be financed exclusively protected articles uh exclusively the army and the social welfare that's all why the army we finance it from our own taxes and this is the rate printed by the national bank and on the social welfare this year i am sure of the future yes, yes, the result, will the money actually be provided by our western partners, so there will be no drastic changes? where will we get that budget? it is very limited, you can see. now what did we say about pensions, will pensions be minimal? well, we have catastrophe 207 - it's simple for me, it's less than $50 at the current exchange rate, and our prices are at the european level , and will the minimum social obligations of the state to citizens increase, at least to pensioners? in our country, the pension suddenly became like this this year. therefore, to say that there is something so incredible, the capacity of this money has decreased by at least a third, official information from the national bank, inflation this year is indeed

higher, but there was inflation in previous years as well, and the same at 18:00 in ukrainian, again not it can be said that our pensions have now radically decreased, the standard has decreased unrealistically, this is a standard problem of ours, low pensions to take money for which we have nowhere, in fact, will pensions be increased, but according to the law, the rules of indexation, which should take place from march 1, and it is precisely this indexation that takes into account the level inflation and income growth, you or what will happen this year according to the law. they have to do this indexation according to the formula. the formula has been known for a long time and has been prescribed in the legislation. will they or will they not do indexation? it is too early to say that no one has he knows, i don't know. yes, but if according to the law, they have to do it, sergey, what about the dollar exchange rate, what is the figure set in the budget for next year, what is the dollar figure set, the dollar exchange rate is set in the budget , it does not matter to anyone, every year,

something must be set, never. because you need to make calculations, the budget is the mathematical table on the right, on the left, an explosion has arrived, you have expenses that are made in dollars, and you need to calculate them somehow. i will count by and so that somehow i knocked down this sign . but you have incomes that are tied to dollars, this is an imported artist. you have expenses that are tied to the dollar - these are mainly payments for foreign debt or domestic debt, we tie them to the dollar why publish these things, you just set up at least some courses just to calculate everything mathematically, well, your own income, after all, i called this sufro , the budget figure is according to project one 28 trillion, and expenses are 2.57 trillion, that is, twice as much, and er, to finance the deficit of the government is planning primarily through borrowings in the amount of uah 1.5 million. i

don't even know how much it is in dollars, the financiers can calculate it. well, in particular, of this amount, one and one and four trillion hryvnias are accounted for by external borrowings, while uah 907 billion are internal loans. will these be loans? it will be, er, give, conditionally speaking, without returning, er, money, help, well, look, it just completely repeats the situation this year, we this year, by the way , next year, they lay down somewhere around 3 billion dollars of needs every month to attract this year we now have 4 billion in borrowing needs , that is, even these needs know what will be there, while in the budget they write that it will all be a burden, that is, debts, but i think this is a conservative estimate, because what we saw this year, a large part is a game mostly when we talk about our american friends, the americans give grants, it’s not loans, it’s just money, you keep it, you use it, europeans do give loans,

but we know that these are loans for 30 years that do not need to be serviced and the rate is 0:1 and they are not if you look at this budget and these forecasts, they really burden the budget of the following years. by the end of next year, we will reach the figure of god to op at the level of 100%. is it a lot or you or will it be such a figure? but again, this figure assumes that we only have a debt load without limits. i think that a large share will be in grands . which was stated by usula fundal and how much it will be able to earn us more economic effect next year what will be the positive effect of this, of course, because many ukrainian companies, which are used to receiving certain quotas for the european market,

can now sell without blood. no we no longer supply european rights, it’s just a matter of concern about the lack of excise taxes there, additional taxation at the border, well, look, it’s about the lack of everything, yes, additional, but it works now, they are usual yes what kind of customs do you have? he throws out the story . ukrainian business gets normal access to the european union market within the framework of the free trade zone, and if there are some standard customs duties. your products were incorrect there according to the quotas , why did i remember, well, this is a standard story, do you remember ukrainian honey? yes, when ukrainian honey suppliers chose the quota for the first week, well, we remember this about ukrainian honey pipes the truth is no longer known who is producing them now in ukraine , pipes are probably being produced in the conditions of the war, but everything

has stopped, but how does it work, the state is not needed here, the state is not needed here, the main thing for the state is to ensure that it is of maximum assistance, and then the manufacturers themselves will find buyers, well i.e. we are a planned economy. yes, where do you say that the mironov bread product is that you have to sell 100 tons of chicken to france? i found some french buyer. roads and within the framework of the program of the president of ukraine, remember, look at roads - these are investments within the country, infrastructure - it's always done this way. the question is that the tenders are fair , who will build them? and when we talk about business access to other markets, the main thing for the state is function so that there are no restrictions and only restrictions, there is no internet, you can go, search for yourself, trade

correctly, the state is not here to help. well, maybe there, you know, in the embassies, they have to help somehow. and i meet some contacts with something else, but this exclusion of business tasks is not necessary for him here, in fact, if the state was engaged in this, it would interfere with business, such competition would be happy in europe, well, again, probably not, of course, logisticians will be against it. but, again, we will not come there, we will not make anyone unemployed. yes, we do not have such a large the economy does not have such a large opportunity to significantly influence it all around, because it is interesting to obey. yes, for example , they are now opposing us. really seriously damaged some european manufacturers, they are simply afraid of our barano on the mhp product because they are very effective and they really

have relatively cheap order and quality and they are afraid yes, but well, let them be afraid of the market, i wonder what else usula von der line said one question one question she said that it is not possible to make money during the war, all the speeches and said that the profits should also be shared during the war. well, and direct these profits to those who need them, in particular, she is there about, well, about electricity, mining, someone, someone. produces on air, yes. and it costs almost nothing in general, except for depreciation in the initial investments . someone works on gas there, or on coal , i don’t know whether they produce on coal in europe or on other means that use a different fuel like mine, and it is very expensive. electricity is very expensive, but business must be socially responsible. well , relatively speaking, we have a market social economy. we have a social market economy. so we have this. we have a son. is it a socially responsible business now or not? well, i think that

our business demonstrated itself especially during the war extremely worthy and today business works in very difficult conditions, but i think that it is not said here, although in direct negotiations there will definitely be a question about corruption, because if the europeans open the market, they will demand from the ukrainian government officials a tougher the fight against corruption and especially what concerns export and import operations with other countries, i actually have such great respect for mr. serhiy and i am somewhat surprised by two phrases that i heard well first of all, the dollar exchange rate is not important for the state budget, at least it is important in two directions, the first direction is the servicing of the state debt, it is quite significant. so far , we do not see deferrals for the entire servicing of the state debt, and it will actually be in the 23rd year to have sufficiently large loads

well, secondly - this is also a significant specific weight of the budget, especially as it concerns not only budget institutions - these are energy resources. today, we are also tied to the european energy market. i am convinced that this will have a very, very significant impact. well, let mr. serhiy disagree with the fact that, well , pension and inflation are not interconnected, they have no meaning, we understand that today not only the devaluation has passed a significant hryvnia. and we understand today that there is a borsch set or a purchase the power of the hryvnia has decreased very significantly, and those people who buy food products today definitely feel it, and one more thing that we must understand, and in fact, it will be very difficult , it will not be fast, but it will be very important for ukraine is not just the possibility of free exports

from the territory of ukraine without the ministry of foreign affairs without any restrictions. and today it will be the interest of european and not only european manufacturers to locate production in ukraine yes war yes difficulties but if you count our labor force if you count the cost of energy, it will become much much much more interesting and it will balance the issue of security. please give your answer. yes, let's go first. i did not say that inflation is unimportant, of course it is important and therefore extremely important. what was indexation according to of the law because indexation takes into account the level of inflation, secondly, i did not say that the exchange rate is unimportant , i said it is unimportant. what exchange rate is included in the budget, because it means nothing, it is just a mathematical thing for the calculations of accountants, it does not mean that the national bank will set such an exchange rate. does not mean that the course we will get to it exactly. this is just an auxiliary figure with which the

budget is calculated and in relation to the external debt , in fact, you are frozen to pay the foreign debt estimates for 2 years, we do not pay on eurobonds nothing, no interest, no credit, and the freezing of payments on bilateral debt with various countries , including china. by the way, the only debt that we will service next year is the debt to the imf and the world bank, simply because they physically cannot be frozen. there is a very complicated procedure they always go separately, and there we simply need to receive more money from the conditional imf than we will give to the imf . i think that mr. serhiy hears us, well, look, we are talking about the fact that we receive funds, aid from the western world, it comes in dollars and if

$50 comes in, and we sell them at the exchange rate of uah 40 , then we receive uah 200. and if at the exchange rate of uah 80 - we will receive 400 uah, gentlemen, we know this very well, and we understand that for this $50, or one pensioner receives a pension. about two or two, that is, in fact, these manipulative things. they are very, very important, meaning that not from this document which serves the cabin depends on the course will be as it will be because the budget balances the state finances and if the state finances are not balanced as this year the hryvnia will simply fly pass balanced because we have a war be objective what balance can be in the condition even during military operations the question of balance must exist because if there is no balance it means there is a deficit, if there is a deficit, it means there are debts and this is an immediate devaluation of currencies."

in black and white, because in the budget, social expenses at

the expense of donors will be... let's finish. well, this is humor. and if it's real, unfortunately, uh, hmm, those who spoke to me, the speakers , they didn't say anything that the main main influence of the dollar exchange rate or foreign exchange rates, it also affects the red spot if you have an increase in the dollar exchange rate by 20- 30% definitely during the month, all prices in our stores at our retail prices will also increase by 15-20%. and it will also affect every family, every pocket, every household, accordingly , it will affect the budget, it will also affect pensions who will not be able to buy these goods and will stop at everything, but we must pay attention to this, because inflation is primarily a dependence on the exchange rate of the dollar on the exchange rate of the euro, and only then everything else, so if we have a stable exchange rate, we accordingly have stable inflation and not galloping was it before the 90s, you just remembered i'm sorry about putin and

about russia, before the war there the ruble exchange rate was 80 rubles to the dollar, now it is 60 rubles to the dollar, that is, the ruble has strengthened, but when selling, for example, oil for 1 million dollars earlier, the russians received 80 million rubles, and now 60 million rubles and, accordingly, a much smaller number of pensioners can be served by this money in terms of issuing pensions, for example , that is, there is also an inverse, well, inverse proportion , it’s so late, i’ll remind you that friends, let’s essentially pa -e-e, the ruble exchange rate will rise, it should be remembered that the exchange rate rose at the same time, not the exchange rate, but the price of old oil above world prices, respectively , it equalized each other by one component, and based on it, i draw some conclusions, mr. i in in principle, he drew the scheme and if oil had not risen, it is supposedly cheaper now, well, if so,

what if grandfather and grandmother had happiness. probably , she was a blitz . but we live with you in real life. thank you, ms. inna, for your assessment of the budget, we have only just begun to familiarize ourselves with the draft budget, so i think that for now only such general theses can be voiced. and i looked at the section that concerns expenditures and of course, i checked several sections that i am personally very interested in, first of all, education expenses, and which are very significant reductions. i really want to understand how it is planned to reduce the educational subsidy to 87 billion. last year, it was more than 100 billion. so, obviously, this will mean that we will have very significant reductions in teachers' salaries, and in part we can understand that this is explained by the fact that some of the children left, some of the teachers left, but

i honestly do not know how much this figure is calculated there are doubts, the same thing, we see a reduction in university expenses of almost 20%, this is a fairly significant figure, i am not sure that 20% of our students have left, because this is a fairly significant figure, if there were a million students, if it were 20% , frankly speaking, such a figure is unlikely it seems, but this will definitely mean that universities will have to tighten their belts and think about how they can optimize and reduce the network , including but you know what is strange that despite the fact that, on the one hand, spending on education is being reduced and we have there are 38 billion left for roads, and this is already starting to raise questions, frankly speaking, you understand. i understand that there are objective circumstances, there are reasons why the state cannot service everything that one would like, but 38 billion for roads seems to me to be completely inadequate in the conditions when there are underfunding is very significant in other areas and in

education and culture, we observe the same thing, and that is, it seems to me that there are a lot of questions that i want to hear the answer to. let's formulate it diplomatically in this way let's diplomatically formulate the plan of the lega dunda regarding this issue, more than a billion euros for roads during the war, while -20° for universities and the educational subsidy is reduced by more than 10% to 13%. please, panina, very accurate, says that a large number of our teachers, our students, our schoolchildren have gone abroad to the western borders of europe, and accordingly, our expenses for this will be a little lower than what would have happened there , for example, that year, let's look at a few years ago how will it be, how will it work, but it's definitely true here. yes it is happening in relation to the roads. well, the roads have not disappeared, moreover, we are currently decapitating the destroyed territory, including the infrastructure, including the bridges and roads,

how are we not going to restore this machine, let the people live in the state in which they found themselves at the time of the occupation, so that instead of 2 km they would drive 50-100 km on district roads, i do not consider this to be an appropriate question for the amount, let's go ana, let's read , but more than that, i want to note that she correctly said that our budget is often very large he receives in the form of borrowing or assistance from our western partners. as far as i understand that i know that the spending of these funds is not only the sources a and where the funds will be spent, it is agreed at the same time by the western partners, i do not think that the western partners will say so they will think that if we lose on the roads and they see it, they agree that i am some kind of wrong expenses. moreover, they need to be done

, in the end, they have already passed. will the pension increase or not 2:27 minimum, well, this seems to me like bullying. there is already an indexing of the games there is an indexing well, it will be there, i will open it now and there will be two sections, i am just there now well, i would like to hear what it will be like next year, it just seems to me that in the conditions of war in general, this question has stopped bothering everyone, even people's deputies well , at least in some conditions in the conditions of war, including and not only the people's deputy, and including you are primarily concerned about one question of our independence and victory in or is it another unfortunately , secondary for now thank you well, i am in unison because said mr. oleg. i understand that you will not vote at the next plenary session on the decision to take money from the military and transfer it to the repair and construction of roads, because i

looked at the income . and so on to the customs territory of ukraine, the road budget began to receive at least a billion hryvnias a month from this, and by the end of the year it will be 6 billion, and next year it will be at least 12 billion, and to repair bridges that destroyed as a result of hostilities, there is definitely a reason for it. but speaking globally, i agree with my colleagues that the document really needs to be studied, although there are already things that i am not very comfortable discussing. well , first of all, i would like to note that the discussion is about the relationship of the inflation. i want to remind you that inflation and devaluation are not the same thing. although they are of course interconnected and affect the process, there is a much more important issue. you talked about children who went abroad, teachers

who went abroad. well, why don't we go to them next year, we are not going to return to ukraine next year, so that they return and study in ukraine and live in ukraine in general, for me today the question is still open, i cannot say. and how is it planned to finance those regions of ukraine that are currently under the temporary occupation of muscovites? i hope that the budget has already laid down the fact that we will return to the territory and we will fully finance schools and hospitals and the possibility of functioning, including social security in these territories. well, no i agree about pensions because there is a law and there should be indexation, but remember the discussions in the 19th and 20th years, when we screamed in the parliament, please index, and no one wanted to do it very much. i am convinced that this will be the

common position of all deputies that this year this definitely needs to be done, because you can live for 2,000 uah. well, i have no idea how, thank you. well, look at the budget. i note that we have not drawn the budget and did not approve it, anyway, we will change and transfer the items of expenses from one item in a different way, because unfortunately it is not a planned action that we can stop. what will we do in two months? relative to changes and articles corresponding to the budget, including this will be done, that is, as agreed with our partner, because the budget definitely does not have money, i will interrupt you because it is very important for our tv viewers, you have already repeated for the second time in a row

i categorically disagree with moscow's propaganda that western partners approve budgets and approve expenditures, and i am convinced that no one allows themselves to dictate certain conditions to ordinary ukraine. this is part of moscow 's propaganda. more than half of our state budget is western borrowing and it's our partners' money, when they give us money, one way or another, in any partnership, it is reduced, we spend it. like today, approval is different. for the restoration of the territory, it is laid down in the budget of the ministry of regions and it amounts to 7 billion uah. for

comparison, i will remind the audience that 38 billion uah have been laid down for the construction of roads. this is about priorities and about the real numbers that are there. of course, it is necessary to restore these territories. and let it be a priority, but in this in this case, the money should be in a separate subvention that goes directly to the restoration of the territory and not to building roads in the territories where they are still in acceptable condition. of course, i would like to have better roads, well i would like it, of course yes, but the primary priority should be the protection of the state and all resources should be directed there, and therefore 38 billion for roads and 7 billion for the restoration of ukraine. children left. and i agree , first of all, with mr. oleg sinyutka that i would really like to believe that we will make an effort to return these children, and this budget is also calculated for the next school year in including, but even from this point of view,

as of now, a little more than 20,000 teachers have left, which is actually less than five percent of teachers, and i still do not explain the reduction by more than 10%, due to the educational subsidy, and therefore the question is i am sure that in the hall we will discuss with an understanding of all the complexities of wartime. believe me, everyone understands each other very well in holos. two deputies serve for me, my beloved husband serves for all of us - this is very important and it should be a priority, and let it be priority is a this is not another road construction scam olezhe, do you want to answer oleksandr and tell me about this story on the budget of the ministry of regional development, it is not the restoration of these hospitals and so on , yes, but there is no question of roads, this is a separate article, which is being carried out and that is why it is laid there yes, yes, in relation to the budget, yes, in relation to the budget . once again, this is the first teacher, every deputy and there is, uh,

you can submit the appropriate amendments to your legislative area, defend the same. i can also disagree with many articles of the budget, but i i understand. the only thing is that no matter what budget we agree with you now , it is me as a financier who did the planning and the budget and managed the company. i know you are in this situation . year, as of today, it is impossible, this is only the beginning of the budget process. thank you , oleg dunda, people's deputy of ukraine . of the verkhovna rada yehor chicheryna were real with you during the last five hours with news stay with the press at home choose something else and we

in ukraine like to choose everything even if it is insurance on hotline finance hotline finance insurance of course online shine this week in the program collaborators list of mitluzhka traitors in handcuffs, for which crimes they will have to answer to the kremlin's henchmen, sold him information about the location of the armed forces of ukraine, broken dreams, how to find themselves instead of the occupying pseudo -government on the dock of education and why the court released the collaborator on bail, and she was pointing her heels abroad, watch on wednesday, september 14 at 5:50 p.m. the project of collaborators, the list of miklushka on the espresso tv channel how to get housing assistance for internally

displaced persons, you have moved from the territory located in the area of ​​hostilities or are under temporary occupation, receive accommodation assistance in the amount of two thousand hryvnias or 3,000 hryvnias for persons with disabilities and children, assistance can also be received by people whose the house is destroyed or unfit for habitation due to damage to the details on the site vyrod.org.ua i have an influence