how things stand and how the situation looks like putin's relationship with the big generation is not becoming after the counteroffensive of the ukrainian forces in the kharkiv region realistically, everything will not happen so quickly, well, nevertheless, when you, when you hear, it is necessary to prepare for the fall of putin's regime, when they say this in the european union, in nato , somewhere in washington, what do you mean by with these statements, how can the west prepare for such a thing? i think that the west cannot prepare for this election reaction, er, irrational emotionally, and they include, er,

there is a problem associated with it, er, no one really understands, it will lead me to such a difficult time putin , how serious can this be for him, even a full martial law? today, what will this lead to some kind of rebellion in russia against putin's fall of his regime, respectively? we have this, this is the expected emotional victory ukraine, as desired, is a reality that is projected for a maximum of two months, and to be honest, it seems to me that the military actions of the losing russia will continue even next year, and russia is clearly preparing to try to go into a counteroffensive in the winter, when it will be especially difficult in ukraine, not only the warring armies and

the main population of the country, which is one of the main factors in general and the winners of this war, and, accordingly, to forecast until later than january, now there is no sense in the action at all a fair russia sergey mironov proposed to the state house to invite the russian minister of defense to a meeting of the minister of defense sergey shayba вите государственное i think does not calm down, they probably want to actively take part in these processes than putin allows them to if vladimir putin is not on the verge of death, he will wait for what he will command, therefore, in this case, it is more likely

that there is some kind of conflict between the political part of the presidential administration, which controls the state house, these are the very people that we put under the control of the occupied territories, the first deputy head of the presidential administration, sergey kyrylenko , the head of the internal policy department, andrey yarin, and in fact, now the powers are in the hands of the hawks, and they are acting for tightening them accordingly administratively simply bureaucratic unfortunately, it is necessary that the war intensifies accordingly they are most likely like that they are asking to press sergey sheygun, and the final decision, as usual, is left to vladimir putin, the puck cannot come. as it has happened many times with russian ministers, and it is widely expressed to send our state duma

after the russians with a fire ship, i turn her claim into an incomprehensible one, or for example shaygu try to make eh guilty of all bad luck, the second option chose no path, turn the puck into the main financier of what is happening, send him out of office because the puck is a man with a very high the level of informal support of the russian elites and it is not so easy to cope with it and get rid of it under the control of russia. the bakhchysaray district court in crimea brought the organizers and participants of the wedding to administrative responsibility for playing the song chervona kalyna, which the russian court called the battle song of ukrainian nationalists . were found guilty, and six people were sentenced to various types of punishment in the form of fines

, as well as from 5 to 15 days of administrative arrest . it all started with the fact that the pro-russian crimean blogger oleksiy talipov in his telegram channel published a video of the crimean wedding, which took place on september 10 in the arpat restaurant, on the video the guests are having fun and dancing to the ukrainian song chervona kalyna, and also that lipova published a video of another wedding in simferopol, which featured the song stefania of the ukrainian band kalush orchestra, which won at eurovision well, ukrainian songs at crimean weddings outraged the kremlin-appointed head of crimea, serhiy aksyonov, actually began to threaten criminal responsibility crimeans who listen to ukrainian songs and literally said that listening to ukrainian songs is treason. now we will discuss this story and this situation, but first, watch the video of this same crimean wedding where red viburnum was played

. in fact, ukrainian songs have been played at weddings in crimea before, but this is how they reacted. they did not call, what has changed now , kateryna nekrecha, a journalist of the radio freedom crimea realiy project, katya, is joining the air. my congratulations. well, to begin with, please tell us what is known about this a specific wedding about this restaurant, where it took place, where this music was played, maybe you managed to talk to the direct participants of this event, how do they comment on the attention from the law enforcement officers? who was arrested, who was not arrested because this story ended not only there with public uh such grass in social networks from the russian blogger talipov or

threats from serhii aksyonov controlled by russia the bakhchisa-bakhchisaray district court held the organizers and participants of this wedding to administrative responsibility for the reproduction of the song chervona kalyna, which the russian court in crimea called a battle song of ukrainian nationalists, but according to the version of the russian indictment, the court at the same wedding discredited the actions of the russian army in ukraine e- will be prosecuted at all - as far as we know, six people have been prosecuted and, according to the russian state tv channel of ukraine 24, the most severe punishment is 15 days the owner of the restaurant in which this wedding took place was arrested in arpat, it is called in bakhchisarai. and actually, the dj and one of the participants in the wedding received 10 tips each, the rest, the mother of the groom, five verbs, the mother of the bride and the wife of the owner of the carpathians and 50,000 they received a fine of rubles because they have minor children, well,

actually, this is the story, and the ending is of course. wedding, they deleted pages in social networks, that is, they were wary of anything, so commenting in this way because it is not at all clear what the finale in this story might be, and we managed to communicate there with close people and we heard what the witnesses of the participants of this wedding, some of them, said in the networks, they even openly say that you did not arrest everyone. i was also at this wedding, let's wait. i am also probably guilty of something. also, am i a terrorist or something, or do i have a relationship with it, that is, there are even calls from people like that nevertheless, it is actually especially among the crimean tatar people, because it is precisely at the

crimean tatar big weddings that ukrainian music has been playing all these eight years, even more so, ukrainian music is trending or such a classic, you know, sofia rotaru, one family at the table, or just folk classics there, verka serdyuchka these songs have been playing all these years, what happened now is wrong and not directly with people who, uh, well, sometimes they themselves danced to such songs and heard it on holidays and are turned on during holidays, they do not say that they wonder why such a reaction now and binds it perhaps with the fact that after the full-scale invasion of russia into ukraine, the crimean authorities are probably nervous , especially after the successes of the ukrainian military, and even more so after the deoccupation of some ukrainian territories. of the crimean tatar people, he says that the crimean government probably understands that their days

there are already coming to an end and therefore they are trying to somehow terrorize the people as much as possible. well, of course, now there is such a misunderstanding of what to do, on the one hand, those with whom i spoke say that they expect perhaps some kind of greater reaction from the ukrainian authorities, which directly deal with the crimean issues there, to this situation. because the same financial burdens yes, they are generally correct - well, that is, these decisions of this russian court in crimea, uh, well, somehow, people want to see some kind of reaction or help, at least with such actions of legal aid or something else, because questions arise as an analysis to teach and another interesting fact is that, for example, this restaurant in bakhchysaray. this establishment was not closed immediately, it was closed on monday, that is, two days after that wedding, and it was closed

when the next holiday was already there, when they came to visit, the holiday was about to start fsb employees also came there. besides, there were some checks like the tax office. well, actually there , everything was closed in this way, that is, the business plans of the institution went to pieces, and the plans of people who somehow planned their events and anniversaries were also there. the wedding also blew the socks off, but the main issue is safety and that you can generally express yourself in crimea, because the important point is that even those people who are loyal or have been loyal to russia in crimea, they already started with the question and what is music and we we can't listen there, well, in particular, stepanivna's song is known throughout europe through the eurovision song contest, yes. that is, it is also about trending music, including or about folk songs that were performed there by russians, in particular, russian ones there the kuban choir was once a red viburnum, for example, yes, such questions also arise,

how much will people feel this terror, these bans in crimea, even in such formats that they already listen to playlists at weddings, and even more so because such conversations you know , the participants of this wedding were also held with the organizers, and as a result of these conversations, the owner of the restaurant and the dj of this event posted such videos of forgiveness where they apologize for carelessly partying, that's what happened yes and again the question arises whether these people recorded these videos of their own free will - a video apology. was it some kind of moral pressure and coercion? it's interesting, of course i don't remember that either. i read the news that allegedly from september 19, leaving the occupied crimea will be possible only with written permission from the military commissariat. do you know

anything about this? it might be investigated. you mean leaving the territory of the russian federation , because of the background. well, i understand that yes i do i understand, but maybe i'm wrong, there was no ukraine until now, so that you can get to ukraine directly now , they can't include it and only by leaving through russia, then getting to europe and then to ukraine , if everything is in order with ukrainian documents , because you are the ones who, for example i haven’t received a ukrainian passport for 16 years. are those who are 25 or 45 years old not getting a new ukrainian passport? they have big problems with this entry into ukraine. they need to get their documents in order first. regarding such cases, crimeans should not be released from crimea. we were not contacted, we were not informed as far as possible, also the question is because the crimean bridge for cars works there, yes, you can also

get there by train, we will communicate with this situation , including if you have any information from crimea, you can write to crimean journalists that property and of course if you are interested in the topic of crimea and it is very important nowadays despite the fact that throughout ukraine many regions are important yes, but in crimea there really is a part of people who are waiting for ukraine and are even ready to experience hostilities are preparing for themselves they set up the same storage there, for example, and listen to the advice of the ukrainian authorities about what to prepare, how to behave, what to prepare, for example, i.e., these people are also here , you have to pay. thank you, katya kateryna - the best journalist of the crimea realiy project was on radio liberty well, now about the budget next year , ukraine will spend more than half of the state budget funds for 2023 on defense and security, this is laid down in the draft budget, which

has already been drawn up and approved by the cabinet of ministers, the second largest item of expenditure is social assistance for pensions, subsidies, assistance to low-income families and internally displaced persons, the cabinet of ministers pledged 35%, i.e., from each budget hryvnia, more than 50 kopecks will go to defense and 35 kopecks to social welfare . will amount to approximately 18.5 thousand hryvnias, which is 4,000 more than this year, but this increase may eat up the projected exchange rate of the dollar. at the beginning of the year, it may fluctuate around 42 hryvnias, but by the end of the year, the hryvnia will devalue to 50 hryvnias for the dollar, the government predicts that the price increase will not be avoided. next year, the information may reach 30%, according to the draft budget, the draft budget must be submitted to the verkhovna rada later tomorrow, and prime minister denys myhal said at the government meeting the day before in order to win

, let's discuss it with us live yaroslav zheleznyak people's deputy deputy chairman of the verkhovna rada committee on finance, tax and customs policy yaroslav my greetings good evening i already said half will go to the defense industry and a third to social worker, i wanted to stop at the defense industry, please explain, soon the united states land-liability will work and we are constantly promised to provide weapons and all kinds of support that should go to the defense industry, what exactly will this money, uh, that you have put in the budget, go to the salary? for the military or for something else, yes, for understanding, because people say that there will be land forests, why then as much as 50% from the budget, well, let's start with the fact that 50% is not laid down, where did the prime minister or someone else who referred to this percentage take such data i don't know there, uh, on security and defense, security includes the police, well, conditionally in the

city of kyiv, where yes, it does not give age or armed aggression, well, at least as actively as it happens in the product regions, so that's all one trillion 150 billion the entire budget is two trillion er well, almost 600, so there is less than 50%, and well, not all of it is going there, not a war, this is an idea and a lot of things, border guards in our country, borders will not only give the russian federation, thank god we have others borders and the sbu is laid there, again, there is someone is engaged in the war. and there are those who are engaged in other issues, this is also laid out for that. well, if we are talking about military expenses, yes, they are less, more , nothing. first, the largest

expenditure is salary. second, these are additional payments. third, this is the purchase of equipment repair. her all these things related to preparation conditionally yes yes until the winter of this form to buy it on updated certain things of food in the army therefore a very simple figure we are on the provision of the army with including having the element forest having help having help including and uh monetary and non-monetary forms for our army we spend only on the army for related expenses as much as our everything everything everything spends in peacetime approximately 130 billion

but such realities differ greatly peaceful year 2021. i would like to ask about the salary, the budget stipulates that it will increase by uah 4,000, but at the same time, inflation is about 30%, the dollar exchange rate there is up to 50, and well, it will all just eat up this salary increase, and i understand what it is will also lead to a rise in prices by a third, maybe less, maybe more, i don’t know. now you will comment, i somehow wanted to say so honestly , what should a ukrainian prepare for? well, first of all, there is an average rate of 42 on the horse - the end of the period is worth 50, i will honestly tell you this is for sure it's already eight o'clock the ninth macro forecast that i see, well, no one in this world can say what will happen to the economy during the war and what will be the real course well, there is no such

person, and even more so well, this macro forecast is made by good officials but nevertheless, officials, well, what if they invented then somewhere on wall street they were a billionaire each, so treat these figures very, very skeptically, and as you know the next forecasts and you can look at bmw investment companies, they will be completely different, now the second part regarding the average salary is also the same that's right, you said that if there is inflation of 30%. then the average salary, if frankly in real numbers, not in nominal numbers, but, well, conventionally converting it to what can be bought. it almost does not increase there by a couple of percent. but again, no one knows how it will end. well, it will be ready , we know that it will end our victory but we do not know when our war will end, what other losses our economy will suffer and how

the world market will continue to behave, so in this case it is not included in the budget, we do not include these numbers the macro forecast according to which the ministry of finance, my example, together with the ministry of economy, together with the national bank , there are hundreds of states there predicting something, they used to guess with these forecasts, just as weather forecasters sometimes guessed, but i counted in the last 10 years, they guessed only once. elections to the verkhovna rada were planned. and now there is a question in the state budget, well, at least in this project, the financing of the central election commissions is not indicated, which means that the elections will not be possible then to state or it is possible that if the situation without a peak will help, then

funding will be found from some other sources . yesterday i wrote this in my telegram channel, and there the text of the budget ends. the following is the law, yes, there are appendices about the budget, where, of course, there are lines to whom since financially, the text of the budget ends with the next cabinet of ministers together with the central election commission in after the end of martial law or the termination of martial law to submit together with the cec to the verkhovna rada an amendment to the budget for holding the reorganization of regular elections of people 's deputies of ukraine, if we go by the text, it says that as soon as martial law is lifted, the parliament together with the government must pledge the money , can elections be held during martial law? elections are not. well, for now, this is. well, this is a fairly logical norm,

so i would draw conclusions now, but there are certain feelings that even if there were no war, what we would really like here, of course, hmm, the authorities would would interpret our powers of our parliament not as 4 years and 2 months, but as 5 years and two months, referring to well as an interpretation of the creative constitution, which had to be creatively interpreted by the constitutional court, which we now know is quite well controlled by the authorities, but all this could be very interesting and so that we don't have a war. it seems to me that as soon as the war ends with our victory, the government will be the first to be interested in holding elections, only we will fix it before the budget, this is only a draft budget from the government of the verkhovna rada still has to vote. that's why i'm telling our viewers that we'll be back. yaroslav zheliznyak, people's deputy, deputy chairman

of the parliamentary committee on tax and customs policy, was on radio svoboda and another topic for attacking journalists. the former head of ukreximbank yevhen medgar will pay a fine of uah 3,400 in in the case of the attack on the journalists of the program of the radio freedom program kyryl ovsiany and oleksandr mazur in ukreximbank, the holosiivskyi district court of kyiv today found guilty the former chairman of the board of the bank, yevhen medgar the former director of the security department, igor telbizov, and the head of the internal security department of the bank, oleg osipov, and imposed a fine on each of them. now, as i already said, he must pay uah 3,400, and two of his henchmen are accomplices, each amounting to uah 1,700 . this is how the story that began in october 2021, then during the interview, ended. the journalists of the scheme asked him about a large foreign currency loan secured by a problematic asset , which the bank issued to a businessman whose company pays

taxes to the dnr group. med-gru did not like this question, and he ordered the security to take the cameras from the journalists and get the tapes from these cameras, so he literally said at the time, on the orders of the nurse , the bank employees used physical force on the operator of the scheme program, took away from him two cameras, the cards on which the recording was made and deleted the recorded video now we'll remind you how it was, then we'll discuss it , the guys have this film left, they wrote it tomorrow no, there is no in the sense that it's not being written now give

an interview i don't give you consent to the recording everything is correct god igor take me away normally это не на до мне сейчас after this incident and the honey from gray itself, ukreximbank actually denied the nature of the crime for a long time and tried to avoid responsibility. and only after the journalists restored the deleted video, this is from the resonance and honey from the game. his subordinates admitted guilt by contacting us journalist of the program of the scheme kyrylo oatmeal kyryla my congratulations, how do you assess this kind of punishment, the sentence, a fine of uah 3,400, eh, this is the maximum punishment that they could receive.

responsibility in general in the case of the attack on our film crew, this is a significant decision, but the punishment itself. in our opinion, it is not proportional, but the holosiivska district prosecutor's office of the city of kyiv, as a state prosecution, asked for exactly such a punishment for the former head of ukreximbank yevhen vetsgar and the bank security officers imposed on him osipov and ihorya talbizova, and the court today granted this request in full, in principle, because we were an emergency for the victims, or rather, we are even on the side of the process, but the participants in this process and our interests should have been represented by the prosecutor’s office, and for the full measure , the third part of the article under which sms was accused of hercenary, the strictest part of the article is about the

suspension of journalistic activity, and it provides for the maximum punishment, which is the restriction of freedom for a period of up to 5 years of deprivation of the right to hold certain positions, but the prosecutor's office did not ask for any of these e-e sanctions, at the same time, the prosecutor's office only asked for a fine. satisfied, please tell me, kirill. and you have been following this man all this time for honey from the communities after he left ukreximbank. i know that the journalists of the schemes also reported that they were going to appoint him as the deputy head of the ministry of economy, but this did not happen. then there were also reports that he allegedly can become an adviser to the minister of infrastructure oleksandr kubrakov, is it known where he is now, does he hold any public office or not? do you hear yes, does he currently hold

any public office ? state structures, but at the moment i can’t definitively announce anything, public positions according to this court decision, so far even the sanction, well, the prosecutor’s office that requested it has not come into force yet, but he does not have any restrictions on holding management positions or any -what other positions in the civil service i understood . thank you very much. it ended so unexpectedly. this story , a journalist from the kyryl region of the radio svoboda scheme project, was on radio svoboda. well, even in this world, wild creatures are not able to choose something else. and we in ukraine

we like to choose everything, even if it's insurance on hotline finance hotline finance, of course , online, so that ukrainians don't think about so that they don't talk first, it still comes out war , war and our victory, seven days a week from monday, monday, seven different spheres of human activity, sports, culture, politics eight presenters of express, journalists, experts, opinion leaders in real time about the most relevant events through the prism of war, every day author's projects nayspresso