in the form of extra payments, bonuses and everything, we know that the salaries themselves are small, but because of all the types of extra payments that exist for a civil servant, this salary rises many times more than that, in fact, this responsible work should be carried out without any explanations, without looking back, and then it would be in society more trust in state institutions because we also sacrifice what we can sacrifice now because in fact in 2589 with such inflationary processes it is definitely impossible to live ms. yulia, are there any mechanisms, real mechanisms which could be launched in order to somehow help people, i don't know. i'm not talking about some kind of mine, i don't know. super eh, so to speak, optimism or some kind of populism is easy. well, maybe you know some effective mechanisms, how can this all be done quickly ? what kind of system was implemented, see uh, the system should really put uh, the subsistence

minimum must be real 2589 uah - it is unrealistic, the real subsistence minimum is more than the minimum wage of uah 6,700 at the moment, well, even let's take 6700, which will be minimum from october 1, this is the real living wage, yes, plus or minus, and it really must be calculated. it’s just that you and i are talking like this, approximately, we have the entire legislative base and all fines, all payments, everything else, etc. linked to the subsistence minimum, this is the main problem, that is, the subsistence minimum must be sensibly untied from everything else, definitely raised to the real dorian value, because it is not about a person, people cannot live on two 589 e-e and you must understand what many people now rent housing, have moved and pay for additional expenses because they, well , they don't have houses, they are either dilapidated or

unsuitable or have no heating, we don't understand that we have more than 12 million internally and externally displaced persons and all these people bear additional expenses because actually, you need more. you don't live in your own house, where you can dispose of something, reduce something, increase something . definitely this issue must be resolved and the living wage must be real even during the war. i understand that this will increase our external external debt, but it will stabilize the situation socially within society. if we have such poverty, you understand that putin will use these and the kremlin in order to social troubles inflate inside the country, important news has arrived , the european parliament has approved the allocation of five billion

euros of macro-financial assistance to ukraine ms. of income so it is possible that 5 billion of regular aid will arrive somewhere someday and so on, and we understand that maintaining all such machinery and state administration and apparatus and, in general, well, social payments is necessary even now, how do we cope with that, right? you are talking about the past period of time, we have already seen it, i once even introduced such a selection of all the aid that ukraine should have received and should have received, and even more so if it is to replenish the running funds of the budget, but to date, we have only received from the promised somewhere around 50%. and this is good, because we are learning, we are already developing practice, and here, well, it is very important, i really want all the aid that ukraine receives to be used transparently and rationally,

so that we trust the government, which is now the full manager of funds, people's deputies have nothing to do with spending and the very approach to priority spending is established by the cabinet of ministers itself. this is the first part, but we must be very careful because for next year we have already heard statements that in the european union also has problems with finances, budgets and so on, so it is unlikely that they will be able to support us so generously, and we must now pay attention to the fact that in our budget for the 23rd year, 50% of the budget must be provided by borrowing, and we have pessimistic expectations regarding domestic borrowing and the ministry of finance is indeed more focused here if they see opportunities in the fact

that the national bank will buy back the bonds of the domestic state loan, military bonds. and we understand that this is additional inflation - this additional printing of money and all the rest, we will still expect the help of our partners in order to even provide these guaranteed protected social articles. therefore, now more than ever, we need to think about the spending part so that at least part of the protected articles still have sources of coverage in our it will be a very difficult year for the budget, but it is necessary to direct everything with joint efforts so that the budget is real. and for this we need to get real answers and joint work with the government, then we will be together for what will happen take place in the country thank you ms. nino yuliya klymenko that nina from yuzhana says to think about the expenditure part well, i understand that, in simple

words, think where to save, where to distribute it more rationally, where do you see the moments in the budget where you really need to cut here and add here, see uh, the first thing is uh maintenance of the state apparatus e-e. we cannot afford to maintain such people during the war, to make such expenditures on the state apparatus at all levels. therefore, we need to think about how it is effective, at the same time, we need to ensure effective state administration, that is, the best people should receive normal, normal salaries and work efficiently for the state, for this, in fact, the reform of what is called the public administration of the state apparatus is long overdue, when 40-7 billion are working there and 13 billion are directed to debt payments in addition. do we need at the moment, all the roads are because we have a separate expenditure on e-e in this budget for the renewal of infrastructure in the occupied territories and after hostilities, that is,

it is still possible to include expenses, including road, and not build any bridges and roads which at the moment we do not know if they will be needed and if in fact the infrastructure will be completely different after the war, you understand, depending on how the war ends, we will need some bridges some bridges some roads we will need to rebuild some roads maybe they can wait and so on, that is, all this should be sat down and not be cut by 10% e or by 17% in general, but to look at each manual program and approach it efficiently and economically, otherwise we will spend money again, it is not clear where what eh. well, no they do not add any added value, not to the economy, not to jobs, unfortunately, we must not forget that you and i are returning, veterans will return to us, military personnel will return, they must be provided with work with a normal salary, and we

must think about it now, because we have a million people in the army who need er will be provided with jobs so that they do not feel themselves, so that they can socialize normally, for which i would like to clarify with mrs. julianina and look, we are not threatened, so to speak, by a parade of mini-defaulters of unequal bodies local self-government because, as far as i understand, many cities of oblast significance and district significance have taken out certain loans , and now it is far from a fact that all banks will go, particularly from abroad, will go to meet them. how does the situation with this look now, ms. nina, and it belongs to territorial communities and cities is a huge problem, so that you know as of 01.09, the amount of frozen funds is more than uah 138 billion, and that is why i

want to draw your attention here, something is happening and it is absolutely unknown - i do not know how to explain to people, especially in those in the regions in those communities where housing was affected, there are no conditions for living infrastructure why should they wait for a national program if today it would be possible to attract local money from local budgets and then compensate after we develop literally all the registers there, we will find methods and so on autumn has come and a huge number of people are standing on the street with their hands down, and you 're right, you saw the scene when the road was paved in buch or irpin, people went out and they began to scream and demand help specifically because they are on the street today, so with regard to

roads, this is a separate topic altogether, i would coordinate repairs and infrastructure restoration exclusively with the military and the commander-in-chief, or something like that, because where we think it is needed, we definitely have to stop now and take into account all the circumstances of the war and the plan of the military and so on, because local budgets are a separate topic and we have to study it deeply, because if there is debt , the more it is guaranteed by the state, then here the state a priori should intervene and one of the specialists should already work on this project in order for it to be completed without default for the city. thank you very much for yuzhana, people's deputy of ukraine, member of the kyiv committee on finance, tax and customs policy, honored economist of ukraine, and yuliya klymenko, people's deputy of ukraine the first deputy head of the committee on transport and

infrastructure, the deputy minister of economic development of ukraine in 15-16 years yes when they for this work thank you extremely important topic yes anya from me will be very important. in the focus e-e we attach oleksii ryabchyna, adviser to the chairman of the board of naftogaz of ukraine, deputy minister of energy and environmental protection, 19-20 years old, mr. oleksii . congratulations, the prime minister of ukraine, mr. shmygal, warned us that we are preparing for the most difficult in stories of the heating season so we basically guessed that everything would be far from easy , how difficult everything would be, taking into account the fact that the russian federation demonstrated its intentions by shelling the civil infrastructure below the barbaric shelling of kryvyi rih is, so to speak, a testimony of the further steps they can take. i completely agree with your emphasis that the

government, as the prime minister said, did everything depending on it to ensure that there was an appropriate resource in the gas storages in the the government is doing everything in order to prepare the boiler houses to boil the pipes of the network, that is, the government is doing everything it has to do, and even more so we are preparing additional plans. electricity supply is very difficult. we all understand perfectly. well, we know that it will be like that, that's why it's only russian aggression, russian war, russian missiles, russian destruction, so , unfortunately, it is. well, the most difficult situation will probably be with those territories that are currently temporarily in the occupation, where many things have been

destroyed and, unfortunately, the situation will be difficult and tense on the line of contact, where not only rockets of that caliber and those with wings can fly in, but where artillery can also fly in and another. as far as i know, a decision was made in many areas to simply drain the heat carrier water . something will happen from the school there from which government schools will be there . some kind of accident simply did not break these pipes. well , even to the point that they simply heat there with firewood and prepare small pots for people to present. i imagine the return of those glorious good times in quotation marks. so when will coal be unloaded from the ship or firewood sold at the bazaars ? and everything that can be done is done as much as possible, that's why

i really believe that it is very important to talk to people about the problems that exist so that not only the responsibility lies with the authorities, with the prime minister, with the president, with the mayor there, or with the head of the relevant department of the city's housing and communal services there people also understand ukrainians very well, they are not stupid, they are not small children, they understand everything, please go , i was on sunday with the construction supermarket, i went to the department where there are electric heaters, there were no electric heaters. well, you can, sunday evening already everything is sold out, people understand perfectly and they are diversifying who buys heaters, who do i know now make decisions, for example, to take parents from the village to the city yes, on the contrary, the achievements of the children are transferred there because your work will be there, there are many different, many different situations and people people are stupid people they understand that it will be difficult. well, people in our country are not used to hoping that there will be

some centralized solutions that will help . many people in our country are used to saving themselves. and the government has some kind of specific plan tools or how do you say the steps, we are working, we know what is planned to be done because in the liberated territories there is nothing at all, no gas, no electricity, well, nothing, there is some understanding. what are we going to do or, on the contrary, evacuate people from there or try to fix something there? well, we see for example, even such a phenomenon as who needs a forced evacuation there from donetsk region and kramatorsk slavyanska konstantinivka there are many there where there are there where there are hostilities where well, you cannot guarantee that there was no government and military of the civil administration local that can't eh well, we don't know because a projectile will hit and whether there will be eh gas supply, that's why the decision was made to evacuate and it's an honest and frank conversation with the people, they made the appropriate decision, i can answer for example, we

invested our own in oil and gas funds for the development of a boiler plant of a bio biotech in one of the northern regions, i will not name where in which region in order not to expose to danger there was a water supply there, it was completely destroyed due to russian aggression, it is now being restored, it will not be gas boiler house and bio pilot boiler house yes, from the plains, that is, we are showing such very good signals for europe to restore . our recovery will necessarily be post-war green. that is, we show that ukraine is ready for this and even during the time with them we are still doing this, well, a town with tens of thousands of e-e residents who will be burnt due to the energy of nature a tell me about this example in more detail . how much did this biotheque cost you and how much can it work at

home? it can work and i was happy to talk about it, and it is already in the queue at this boiler house that is being built. let's report it, you'll see that i'm sure that very distinguished guests will come to these objects to cut the ribbon and we'll show how we change galina and yulia kli menko to whom they tried to reconcile, so to speak, a debit with a credit in to our planned state budget and now i would like to ask you to tell us what prospects we have for filling our beautiful large gas storages, they promise that by the beginning of october there will be 15 and a half billion cubic meters of gas in the storages, they promise that there will be where it will come from, taking into account the sky-high prices and, in general, will it be enough those

cubic meters, those billions of cubic meters for the passage of the heating season. i think that to your january viewer that 15, what 10, what 20 or 30, she will not say anything. well, if you do not say in comparison with something here now gas it was about the same, well, the average from the 14th to the 18th year, that is, you have the same reserves . i have reduced production this year during the war year, you said in your account that we cannot extract gas in a part of the occupied kharkiv, donetsk , luhansk oblasts, that is, we cannot extract there, and the production fell by only 2% less than, for example, private companies which fell somewhere on 10-11%. that is, now the release of part of kharkiv oblast , where the evaluation of those objects of the gas infrastructure of the

gas production infrastructure, some of them were mined, that is, we hope to connect those objects and we will give even more gas and we will be there conditional zero, we really want this well, we finish how cubic meters are being pumped into storage. therefore, everything will be fine with you, as the prime minister noted , we are winning victories, victories are intense with other partner countries that can help with gas in case we don't have enough of it yes, it is really expensive. gas is now on the european market. i haven’t seen the latest prices there. well, there is a conditional price of 2.5 thousand dollars. we sell it for a conditional price of 200 dollars. that’s why they ask, uh, where is the business here? we say that it’s war and gas. at the moment it is part of the social component and not the profit of a state company or others, it is a complex complex process and here is a complete unification of all branches of government in order for the four police departments of hispano

oleksiy gas lend-lease from the united states so because there is also hope that will come or is coming for about 2 billion cubic meters of gas from the united states in the process. as far as i understand , they will be unloaded somewhere either in the baltic countries or in poland or in the balkans. well, i understand very well , do you want to talk in the news about future events that will take place and the biotheque, which we have already started to announce, and about gas from the united states or from norway, i would pragmatically like discuss this event that has already taken place, but the negotiations are going on, they are difficult, they are complicated, and i am sure

that they will end in themselves. ukraine will have a resource that will be enough for heating, and what is the probability if they will be removed from our government there coal we won't be able to or railway some events we won't be able to drop er coal there will be electricity in peak hours especially it will be on gas although it will be golden and expensive electricity er that is, the country is preparing for a very difficult this is the last in general hope er- is of the russian federation to freeze ukraine in order to reduce the will of ukrainians to resistance to freeze europe in order to reduce europe's desire to help ukraine, but nothing will work out of them, we are ready thank you, mr. oleksiy oleksiy ryabchyn, advisor to the chairman of the board of naftogaz of ukraine, was with us, we will continue to form, let's finish this hour with a crooked horn viktor mudryy is already joining us, the

head of the kryvyi rih district council, mr. viktor, we congratulate you. glory to ukraine, mr. viktor. so, we wanted to ask you about the current situation in your heroic, without exaggeration, because literally a couple of hours ago, the enemy launched rocket attacks again. glory to the heroes and death to the enemies. yes , you all already know . according to the hydrotechnical structure located on the karachunov reservoir, the territory of the city was flooded in order to prevent a disaster from selen 23 street and perevukiv, again in the city of kryvyi rih, namely of the central city and the ingulets district , but thanks to the coordinated work of the state emergency

service, the military administration and the communal services, it was actually possible to prevent further flooding as of this morning, and 40 cm of water fell by the state of nazar, and this is in various at points this level is still there, i know it is much higher depending on the point downstream of the ingulets river, that is, if we are talking about the city of kryvyi rih - this is today, as of now, it is approximately more than - somewhere approximately 1 m. the water has already gone down, and if we are talking about shykivsk community, which is again adjacent to the territory of the river, the water will rise there by about 2 m 45 cm, but the situation remains under control. today, a

rocket was also hit at three o'clock on the territory of an industrial enterprise. viktor, how do you explain the massive strikes in kryvyi rih in recent days, what is the reason for this? i believe that our guys who are now in the so -called kryvyi rih direction have some victories, and the enemy is trying to attack the city of kryvyi rih in order to increase social tension with it and put psychological pressure on people. the second version that you state is that it was intentional. a man-made disaster was made in order for the guys who are now crossing the ingulets river by pontoon crossings, their pontoon crossings

actually washed away, but the enemy did not succeed, but we understand that viktor will not stop his shelling or accordingly i don't know, some conclusions were drawn and relevant preparatory work was carried out in your city, in your region, and in general, this experience should be accepted. well, i think that the whole of ukraine should look to predict where the next strike will be. i think it 's actually impossible, uh, communal services actually have some reserves just in case emergency situations and some situations they over- they predicted it as you likely but again it is impossible to predict everything p victor oleksandr oleksandr vilkulo reported the head of the military

administration reported that as a result of these of yesterday's arrivals, private houses were flooded, about 112 private residential houses from summer cottages were flooded, and now with human settlements, it is mainly a program , this is the so-called district of kryvyi rih, which is the closest to the ingulets river, as far as i know today at home who has at least a small basement of water in the houses there is no longer er and on different streets there are already different streets there is already a er situation and sometimes there is an exact street there are passable but er in most parts there is still water it remains in the yard, in the yard, that is, there is no water in the houses, people mostly come back and start to dry their buildings, but the yard remains flooded. well,

finally, mr. viktor, we would like to ask you about the preparation for an extremely difficult winter, what are the specifics of kryvyi rih see, if we take kryvyi rih directly, it is 99 99.9% ready for the heating season, as well as traditional heating systems, and some reference sources have been prepared . but i say once again that in fact, this is the preparation of the city's infrastructure, if any gas pipelines are cut off, then in fact the city is not protected from this, thank you, we have a few minutes of points and more. tell me what happened to kryvyi rih, i mean the caliber of what arrived today, i won’t say because it wasn’t in place, we

went to the positions of the guys before and still don’t know the situation, but as for yesterday, it was daggers and sparks, that is, the enemy used nato’s limited resource and an order for that what uh because of uh enemies, uh, to us, uh, telegram channel, the scheme was spreading. well, how will the territory of kryvyi rih be flooded, then it was uh, quite a prepared attack , that is, they even had time to make computer graphics to show it to people, which part of kryvyi rih will be flooded, they simulated a flood in kryvyi rih, and how are the locals reacting to it all, they manage to achieve their goal there, to frighten very much all the local people, the situation was more frightened because there was no water in the taps for several hours, that is, some panic began and they started buying water in the retail network, but somewhere around

10-11 o'clock, in fact, the water supply in the city was restored, then in fact panic spread among the people, mr. viktor. thank you very much for participating in our broadcast. viktor the wise, the head of the kryvyi rih district council worked live on the espresso tv channel. well, it arrived news from dbr, the former state secretary of the ministry of foreign affairs, due to his negligence , caused losses to the state budget in the amount of three whole two-tenths of a million hryvnias; he gave state premises to use for free with a total area of ​​about half a thousand square meters, the entrepreneur with whom the mfa employee concluded a contract on the organization of food, so and so, so and so, for free well, so and so negligence of a person was announced as a suspicion for, so to speak, for official negligence that caused serious consequences, the sanction of the article provides imprisonment for a term of up

to 5 years, this i really like this approach, the state means no one, you know, you can give it to everyone for free, we hope that after the victory, we will have more and more effective certain managers who we will be hire and carefully monitor what they do with our money. iryna koval also carefully monitors the entire situation in ukraine and the whole news team in the future.