hoped to escape. by the way, i think that he himself does not really hope, because i will simply remind you that his first decree as the head of the so-called republic after the disposal of zakharchenko was about the guarantee of financial support for the family of the head of the republic in the event of his death the first decree, therefore, he perfectly understood what he was doing. what is another matter, of course, russia is more interested in him becoming a hero of russia posthumously or well, maybe he will still be used, but it will not be decided by him, but they will decide in moscow, it is necessary, if not , the so-called prime minister of the dnr is being purged, and he is really in moscow now, he does not hide it, he is there, he is a figure in the telegram that he visits russian ministers there, negotiates about the affairs of the republic but it is clear to everyone. why did you go there now to make an agreement? first of all, and secondly, let's not forget that among russian citizens, he

was the head of a department in one of the russian ministries. he went there on a business trip. he immediately returned to pushilin. the beekeeper is a completely different category. i don't think they will be able to decide for themselves. when they have to go where they have the ability to go. we are with this in due time. this is what you are talking about. has it become clear or not in your opinion? they were waiting, she was interested . she won't have to defend anyone in herself, and they beat her own. well , dad, i want to correct that the local population voted for russia. she voted for independence from ukraine, yes, as one told me. when a woman who went to the referendum and then e- is she couldn't admit that she made a mistake and they said that we didn't vote for russia, i even voted for secession, we voted for independence, that's what happened, and we can say

that the first thing is disappointment in russia, which turned out not to be so how strong is it, they told them all these eight years yes, and this narrative has broken, that russia can do anything, if russia comes, everything will be fine yes his people expected that it would stop when the special operation began, but it turns out that the war , on the contrary, came to them even more the first is e now there is an insult in russia, ah, because the same russians, how they explained their fighting from kharkiv oblast, don’t worry, they wrote their russians, there were not russians, not russian soldiers, but mobilized from the dpr of the lpr, and of course in donetsk luhansk they are now writing openly to social networks about the fact that we were framed, firstly, violently mobilized , secondly, and used, sent there without weapons, without equipment, respectively, and now they have also done what

is this program? such evil in relation to the russian federation, and the mobilization continues, we understand that the men are hiding, and there is no one to mobilize , especially there, they just went to the places of deprivation of liberty in the zones of the so-called convicts, as far as i know, there are already 1800 men were mobilized precisely in the colonies in exchange for the fact that they would then be rehabilitated, that is, they would be given their freedom, and there is such information that this is not enough. that is probably why the ministry of justice, the so-called dnr, is considering the issue of sending all of them without even asking prisoners to the front, except for political prisoners and our prisoners, therefore, in this sense, the mobilization continues. and i don't know who to

approach already. sergey, we thank you for finding time for our broadcast serhiy garmash , analyst journalist, we talked about the so-called people's republics of the people's republic of the people's republic of the people's republic of china, which are now very unhappy and resent russia for not wanting to protect them. good, we wish you good health let's talk about the forced deportation of ukrainians to russia as a war crime in the european union in the european parliament at the session, this issue is being discussed, what are the prospects of bringing er to justice for these crimes of russia, in principle, it is clear, it is necessary to form er

a special international tribunal is necessary, this is the first, the second, it is necessary to collect all the available facts of such war crimes, it is necessary to determine, well, at least try to determine the specific perpetrators, and our special services, it seems to me. and the fourth most important thing is to end this war victoriously. because it is precisely after its end that the issue of extradition of war criminals to international justice will definitely be raised. after the defeat of russia in moscow, he will be forced to somehow stay afloat if he is allowed to extradite all these war criminals

. therefore, this is not a matter of tomorrow, but it is a matter that is definitely promising, because if someone did not hide and when someone did not run away er crimes against humanity, war crimes, crimes of genocide, and so on and so forth. these are crimes to which the statute of limitations does not apply, that is, even after 10 years, if there is a need for it. and she will find the criminal, no matter where he hides. e p volodymyr, the session of the european parliament is about to end in strasbourg right now, and there were a lot of ukrainian issues, in particular, the deputies decided to provide ukraine with additional funds from the eu budget to compensate for losses from the consequences of russian aggression

i don't see the numbers yet. how do you evaluate this gesture? and what can this money be used for? i think it's not a gesture - it's real help and we should be grateful to our european partners for such steps. they're not the first. the latter, of course , they are extremely necessary for us, they will be transferred to the government, and the government will already find those items of expenditure that, in his opinion, will be the most relevant at one point or another, but the situation is actually in the budget plan. i think the budget is clear to everyone will e-e addressed with a large deficit e-e the deficit should be set directly at more than 30

billion dollars. this is in a positive version, so to speak, and maybe 35 years without western aid and the demands of the european union without the help of the united states of america and the international monetary fund. and other countries and structures, we definitely need this budget, but still there is hope that if this money, which will not be enough , will be distributed among many of our partners and friends, then we say that it will still be .”

you know, i'll tell you frankly what uh well, uh those politicians who i think the european political elite should be compared to in sura hutsul , they are not secular, well, she is one of those, because next to her, boris johnson is next to he is lystras, if we are talking about the european continent, and on the condition that it is really funded, those people who demonstrate new political thinking , they raised their heads and looked beyond the political horizon, and they perfectly understand that without ukraine there will not be a free, democratic and safe europe, that's why they are trying to help as much as possible in order for ukraine to integrate

into the european political, economic, social , military and any other space in order for this to happen. therefore, now the ball is on our side, i think, in most cases, because we still need to fulfill all the requirements that were recorded when we were granted candidate status, unfortunately not all of them have been implemented yet. but we still have a few months until the end of the year, and i think that despite all the odds internal opposition in the european course, however the parliament will still be able to do what it promised. i hope that the public support for this will be maximum. please, mr. volodymyr, specify what you

mean by the promise of the parliament. i mean that the main task of the parliament will be to adopt those laws that have to combine ukrainian and european legislation into a single whole is what concerns the quality of this er tactical task that stands according to those seven er points about which we are all well aware as well as in the strategic plan if we are talking about the direct integration of ukraine into the european legal space, because this is exactly what is being discussed during the negotiations, which i hope will begin in the 23rd year, in fact, and is looking at how quickly our ukrainian parliament will be able to adapt our legislation to european, but when we

finish this process, then we will be able to say that we are ready. and now, dear colleagues, make a political decision. actually, our course is quite mechanical and quite clear. well, there are some. i think that uh cataclysms well, they are not predicted, but for now our parliament is just preparing to complete its homework there, to pass european integration laws, uh, ursula fenderline said a fantastic thing the day before that europe is opening an economic market for us, meaning something that did not exist before, how do you evaluate such a decision what is it it means for us, for us, it means that the ukrainian business will be able to earn money. for us, this is really critical. well, we know what the european market is for us after the ukrainian economy stopped.

in fact, contacts with russia are the main market, and the fact that our businessmen will now be able to work much easier in the european market means that we will earn very well . take, for example, the topic of electricity. this is actually fantastic . a breakthrough that was planned for next year is already being implemented today is being implemented very successfully, we are starting to earn billions of billions of euros from this, as we used to earn a few billions in transit from russian oil, we will probably earn more billions on the export of our electricity to the european union, i.e. for us, this is an extremely important moment er, whether to take any other things that er, well, concern us directly for

the european union, we as a trading partner are not too er serious, so so for a moment they easily turn a blind eye to the fact that in this case we will be in a slightly better position than them, but they do it absolutely consciously and clearly in order to help us in this already practical integration into the european market if we are now it will happen in the near future and we will achieve, let's say, customs visa-free to industrial visa-free, then this will actually mean that we are really not on paper, but really integrated into the european economic space for us, this is the number one topic, volodymyr, thank you very much for finding time for our viewers volodymyr hryzsky minister of foreign affairs of ukraine from 2007 to 2009 thank you for being with us stay with espresso

judicial control just now watch this week in the program judicial control took a bribe but not guilty as mukachevo, the judge avoided seven years of imprisonment, when the terms passed, they played in monich, why the opponent of the judicial reform rushes to the high council of justice about the fact that the participation of international experts in this is unconstitutional, he is now going to participate in the competition and how to acquire a special judicial talent an apartment in zhytomyr for $1,900. congratulations, this is a judicial control program, and as always, we are talking about the main reform on which direction our european prospects depend, how the new judicial power is being formed in ukraine, and why judges from with a dubious reputation, prone to abuse and involved in corrupt practices and still not giving up trying to get to the renewed ranks of the supreme council of

justice about all this today, but first, traditionally in the news, the grand chamber of the supreme court refused ex-member of the supreme council of justice viktor hryshchuk to grant an appeal regarding his dismissal hryshchuk appealed to the ethical council and vrp and asked to invalidate the decision about his non-compliance with the criteria of professional ethics and integrity as an active member of the council, also hryshchuk tried to appeal the order to stop his accruals and payments, the administrative court of cassation of the supreme court in june refused hryshchuk to satisfy the claim, now this decision has been confirmed and the large chamber of the verkhovna rada has taken the first step for the competitive selection of judges of the constitutional court before the competition, it is proposed to attract a new special body to the council of a group of experts the relevant draft law was supported by 281

people's deputies - experts consisting of six people will be proposed by the president of parla by the congress of judges the venetian commission and other international organizations that provide ukraine with technical assistance in the field of constitutional reform, the prosecutor's office completed the investigation of the case against the traitorous judge from kharkiv oblast, the head of the vovchan district court , iryna ukhanyova, the indictment was handed over to the poltava district court, we told about ohanyova in our previous issue, she was a spy of the russian occupiers who helped them to create an illegal judicial body on the basis of the ukrainian court and called on the employees to take sides according to ukrainian legislation, she has not yet been released to russia, because the body authorized to do so, the supreme council of justice, has not yet been formed, however, the court verdict in haniv has to correct this injustice , especially for treason, the judge faces

life imprisonment, recently an appeal of the higher anti-corruption court overturned the sentence of the judge accused of bribery, this decision deserves special attention because it raises many questions as well as doubts about its impartiality, let's tell you why it is a judge of the mukachiv city district court mykhailopak two or three fucking dollars bitch for 1,000 uah fucking on this recording he complains about a bribe of 2,000 uah. it was because of him that the judge was detained by law enforcement officers in september 2017. then, according to the investigation materials, the judge made the necessary decision in the case of the social welfare department of the mukachevo administration together with the pack they also detained the head of the legal department of the local administration of the pension fund, who was the mediator in the deal, nabu detectives during the investigation

recorded a lot of interesting conversations, come here, ivan brought the application because i don't know it's possible there either i will say that last year, the higher anti-corruption court sentenced mykhailo pak to seven years of imprisonment with the confiscation of all property, and suddenly in august of this year, the appeal overturned the verdict, two of the three judges of the panel of daniil chornenka and inna kalugina voted for this decision, despite a series of ironclad evidence from video and audio recordings, the judges recognized mykhailo paka innocent lawyer of the anti -corruption center vadym valko emphasizes that the appeal decision looks too disproportionate as if danyila chornenka and inna kalugina deliberately wrote their

conclusions in the case in order to save a colleague from punishment, there is a lot of argumentation. why was it not possible to cancel, why was it not possible to close the proceedings? the arguments of the court are being prepared for the fact that this case was investigated in a certain period of time at the initial stage, not by nabu detectives, but by investigators . - only the very fact that the case was investigated by the allegedly wrong body cannot be the basis for the annulment of the sentence in my personal opinion, from the point of view of a non-lawyer it looks like that well, as we can see on the video as judges of the bar the bribe was released by the judges when the decision was made , the fact of the transfer of money recorded on the video was simply ignored, and after the arrest, the judge admitted that he had framed himself because of a bribe of only uah 2,000 with the decision of danyil chernenko and inna

kalugina . opinions of the judge of the appeals chamber of the high anti-corruption court, mykola glotova . crimes were not carried out as a result of erroneous conclusions and the application of a norm for which there were no grounds for application in this case, it looks very strange when the separate opinion of the judge looks much more motivated and well-founded than the court decision e-e which has gained legal force, this confirms the doubts about the impartiality of the decision of danyila chornenka and and not kalugina how mykhailo paku managed to convince the judges of his innocence, we asked his defense and

the lawyer oleksandr rezonenko turned out to be not too talkative hello, i congratulate you, mr. oleksandr, this is a judicial control program on the espresso tv channel, we called you a few days ago on the question how did you manage to convince the judges about the innocence of mykhailo pak, i talked to him, i could not get him , e.e. nature light comments we hope that the prosecutors do not they will turn a blind eye even to the bleaching of judge hapuga and the appellate decision will be appealed in cassation, taking into account the guilty verdict of the first instance and the separate opinion of one of the judges, mykhailo still has every chance still end up behind bars, the ethics council continues interviews with candidates for the high council of justice, a key body of judicial power that is responsible for the professionalism, impartiality and

integrity of the entire judicial body. in past issues, we have already told you about desperate candidates who, despite their far from crystal clear reputation, have dubious biographies and opaque fortunes still hope to get into the updated composition of the vrp and we carefully monitor such cases and today we will tell you about one more desperate person, this is bohdan monich, the chairman of the council of judges of ukraine, the judge of the seventh administrative court of appeals. he is one of the most active blockers of judicial reform. last year, he sabotaged the creation of an ethics council. he claimed that judges do not like this law, and internationalists are critical of the council - this is wrong. he hopes the expert of the anti-corruption center halyna chyzhik does not

hide her indignation. experts in this is not constitutional, he now goes against participation in the competition, we assume that bohdan monych forgot that he is against judicial reform , which he now wants to be a part of. but we have not forgotten about his bright past. monyach headed the council of judges in 2019, the judge of the district administrative court, pavlo vovk , an official during yanukovych's time, andriy portnov and the then head of the presidential administration, andriy bohdan , ousted oleg tkachuk from the chair of the council chairman, replaced him with the convenient bohdan monich, this was recorded on the so-called wolf tapes made public by our colleagues from the investigation

. info correct nikka ne smoženiya nikka er- er never followed orders and did not touch the code, the administrative court publicly defended him and criticized the presidential bill on the liquidation of oasco. he er-er is obviously er-er dependent on er- e judicial clans from influential judges such as pavlo vovk, the chairman of the district administrative court, and bohdan romanich received his position as the head of the council of judges thanks to pavel vovk. the instructions that he receives from the same head of the ops, pavel vovka, there and from other leaders of the judicial mafia, first of all, a full-scale invasion of russia. bohdan monich did not lose his enthusiasm in the fight against judicial reform and

independent judicial bodies, taking advantage of the war , he tried to eliminate the ethics council from evaluating candidates for the supreme the council of justice, the system demanded that this function be transferred to the council of judges headed by him, the judicial mafia simply decided to use the war in order to try to remove the ethical council from the reform of the supreme council justice, that is, again, in order to ensure that the right people get to the supreme council of justice, in april of this year, meetings were held on the basis of the committee on legal policy of the verkhovna rada of japan, or there he commented on various initiatives, advocating that in fact transfer powers of e-e selection and possibly even e-e election during martial law

is the joy of the essence, i.e. even the congress of judges should not be convened, the council of judges headed by language speakers should choose new members by themselves of the supreme council of justice, because supposedly the war writes everything, the family of bohdan monich owns three plots of land, a 330-square-meter house near zhytomyr and several apartments in vinnytsia and zhytomyr. a house with more than 300 square meters costs $19,000, and an apartment in zhytomyr is only $1,900. we would like to be happy for such luck in buying real estate, but unfortunately, we can only state that this is very similar to banal manipulations and attempts to hide real wealth bohdan monyacha's mother loves her son

so much that she gave him more than half a million hryvnias over the course of several years, although her official income in those years was slightly more than 32 hryvnias. the ethics council has already conducted an interview with bohdan monyacha . have studied the biography and career achievements of the candidate for the vrp, the decision regarding him will be announced later, however, the reputation and the members of the ethics council themselves have a lot of questions in one of our in previous programs, we told you about one of them, volodymyr severin. in short, he was repeatedly the hero of journalistic materials , through the court he tried to reduce his age in order to postpone his pension and was criticized because of his decision and the large amount of expensive real estate of dubious origin in his

family members, then he refused to explain to us his wealth referring to a large amount of work so we called again hello mr. volodymyr congratulations this is a judicial control program on the espresso tv channel have a few minutes for us we called you last week you didn't feel comfortable talking to us one question in how did you become a member of the ethics board having a lot of violations and questions about mymap want to talk about your property where it came from what it is so precious me several times we are checking and not only one commission. we will continue to closely monitor the decisions made by the ethics council regarding candidates for the supreme council of justice, in particular, the decisions of volodymyr severrin so that his past mistakes do not become

basis for new ones and he suddenly did not let unscrupulous applicants into the vrp. and for today, i have everything. if you want to report corrupt judges or illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to this email address. see you in exactly a week, a hundred flooded houses and the evacuation of the population after rocket attacks along kryvyi rih, the ingulets river overflowed its banks, what is happening in the front-line city of bakhmut, russia inflicted in