the elite departure of khatud as a result of the defeat in kyiv sumy chernihiv ukraine was not yet a coin flip, they still kept their strength, but kharkiv finished now we can say that a real turning point has happened, and this is not only what we see with you, this is the evidence of that, i am the anal allies of moscow from central asia reacts exactly the same well, why don't we react in a different way, they also evaluated in this perspective, look at how they change their orientations, by the way, the president of kyrgyzstan, as far as i understand, is late by how much at the time of the meeting with putin, they already showed putin who was waiting for the president of kyrgyzstan now. as for the fact that ukraine itself, among other things, is becoming a regional sub-hygemon, for example, will ukraine determine the fate of belarus? дальше теперь what about schedules in russia and how from this, in principle, how one of the options can go to moscow and all these

problems , but i would not include it public evidence, you know, we must hear the voices of the dissatisfied from our own circle , then it will be possible to judge how these schedules have been broken down right now and who belongs where to whom, who is gathering to protect putin, here you are , from what i see, putin has a loyal ally, kadyrov, although many say that he will turn him in at any moment, but it is not against the talking points. yes, because putin protects you, who protects you, you must understand that he will not become putin 's next. but putin still has some kind of hope for that that he will be supported such as the beautiful structures of putin, the believer has the feeling that behind him is some part of the team that was dragged in by peter medvedev, who has no power resources. defense and

general staff in the trenches, there are no defenders of any soldiers . officers, there are no force structures of the fsb, but only a part of facebook. lost, who loses crimea, who loses donbass , other structures, they are derivatives, too, at least the guards, at least the police, or some others, all this is not defining now, the key is the position of the army, the police, the fsb, but at the same time where would it be possible to get rid of it, putin will hang on to it всё грехы сказать ето всё он ето не мы объекс к этому трайов но не протият вас that's all but the issue of the army mark, look at this very characteristic moment, so during the aggression against ukraine they started to push someone to the first place gerasimov, the chief of the russian general staff, and the minister of defense, shoigu, although he should not, according to

all schedules, lead the aggression, that is, he is a person who should, i don’t know, be there to provide for the troops, logistics, and so on. and it is probably possible that this is due to the fact that putin made a bet on him as a person whom he will push into the first roles in order that, in the event of something, well, i don't know , to stop the offensive of patrusheva bortnikova, and maybe with the participation of naryshkin, and i think there is a different way, i think that it is putin who will hang all the dogs as soon as possible, because he will be forced to tell me that it is not me. here are the particulars that he gave me. in fact, it was impossible to provide them, this is just very suitable, and look first, that his real military and

popularity in the army are not used. he cannot be popular in the army by definition. he is, so to speak, a plywood marshal, yes. well, he is not russian, that’s what he plays too, that’s what he does. someone says that it’s not important, in fact , it’s easier to tell you that he’s not russian. you want yours to follow him and this is always fashionable in russia, it means there are only enemies around, jews of all kinds take turns and so on, this has always been a popular idea, so here it will simply be easier to take a gentle russian gerasim to him, it’s interesting, and then you’ll see how no by chance, they went to the taiga in the 21st year, and before that, that is, they discussed exactly this there, and putin, you also did not accidentally put it on everything that it was a long time ago, and it means the minister of defense, but he understood that it is easier to connect these things with a person who is vulnerable in some respects, neither military nor russian. a person who cannot lie. you know,

the fairy tale about talented management is that it was invented so that, in general, on the one hand, it is a purely hardware device. yes, they are bored like a ball, so that later it will be easier to burst when too much i had a lot of trouble in this sense to pass eh so that it is not a problem, and gerasim can too, but gerasim has a certain influence in the generator, that is, this is more of a problem. of course , they won’t be filmed now, but after a while, he will be removed, and gerasim can be taken away, and all the dogs will be hanged on them. it’s easier to do this, of course, the potrushef and the clan, and the so-called mobilization team, which represents primarily the force wing of the fsb. let's tell the board of the fsb that bortnikov is a member of his colleagues, then of course it's easier for them to say that it 's not our fault, the army is fighting well, and

in particular, that's what he who controlled all of it an opera under putin himself as the commander-in-chief yes , he has a general in command, now he has appointed this young man with the direction of the center to the western military district, this is the main district that should be elected by nato, that's it, that's all there were the leaders of this team still around who stayed for 15 days for a good 15 days and now let's say that the lapin who is putin's favorite is the hero of russia he putin gave him the name of the hero for the operation under north donetsk lysichan eh appointed him a-a well in there is no raw material there in the south and so on, but remember how many surnames how many years have changed, we can tell about it, of course , a more reliable belt for the period of these 6 is heard in a six-span place as commanders, sent by the commanders themselves as a special operators, who now remembers dvornikov or

zhidko, who will still remember him, it turns out, you know, they have a shuffle because not one of them can achieve any result, this is the idea with the 15th of september 15 to reach the borders of the donetsk region well i think that the wooden one was such a story. why was it under the version? well, under referendums, let’s solve the question there. we quickly held a referendum and what was the result? well , the result is obvious and that’s how it rained. kharkiv front is russian. so they left a lot of equipment a pile of corpses and prisoners retreated, saying that they were preparing some kind of reorganization and regrouping, but in fact we see that now they will be pushed to regroup in the south, most likely in the zaporizhia region. but putin has to sell all this, that is, he sold himself before as a ensures stability and so on, here he brought the war and at the same time he has to somehow explain these colossal defeats. so we see that this

could rather be only the beginning if they did not start shelling civilian objects of ukraine up putin is nothing real, then he is silent, maybe you haven't heard a single comment from him, give us the first, that is, the only commentary, the last days that the russian servicemen who are dying in ukraine are dying for russia. eh, the kharkiv operation, what happened there, i heard the stamps, most of the time the audience also felt the tension. it is clear that he is following kharkiv on the street, that's why putin is silent. eh, he immediately attacked me in the face of konoshenko, the statement was made after this security situation, constantly with what putin conducted. he came out

and said that by regrouping everything is normal. they moved away so that later well, in general , the crazy one has chosen the option explained crazy absolutely to whom he owes the effect that it is not clear, well, god, you have problems with him, and the problem is that putin does not understand this very important, that is, there is nothing more good explanations, they all ended somewhere between march and april. now it’s all in the minus. and then i think that now it’s already critical to put together situations with reserves, with equipment, with ammunition, with people, with personal stock, that is, where are the brothers, well, in the concentration camps in prisons, brothers, we saw this guy with a beautiful or pseudo-beautiful person who starts to recruit a prisoner. no, i'm not exactly 100% beautiful, and you know, when we talked about it there in april, here i am on my

channel and so on. vytal in society, i don’t have it, that’s not what it is like in ukraine at all well, how is it, that’s what’s being tried, yes, who told you such a fool, where it’s impossible, they were critical , therefore, they were thoughtful about it, they were noticed, but you understand better than here, they poured it out with records, so it’s necessary that 450,000 are located in places deprivation of freedom pours in the convicts and it is necessary for this to spread widely so that it becomes a recruiting meme. he says there are few chances, because there is no way back, they shoot him, he says yes, it means burying the body, handing it over to someone, taking it away, burying it at the base of the dude, and so on, it’s just live meat . they don't know how to screw it up, they will just

die in packs, but they are needed for this, and they are needed in order to get rid of their corpses . they did it, they revealed it, they mixed it, so that it didn’t sound very good, because in no country in the world are people convicted of killing other people convicted by law, they don’t give weapons to such people anywhere, they don’t give such people the freedom to behave like this, they will be kicked out and shot. and if even those who can allow the criminal to fight. they have gelindland consciousness and gelendventnye intentions. you understand this terrible crime , it is certainly more terrible than those for which you will be punished mercilessly. you will come to them for this. и так далее we understand who will, so to speak , carry out the direct, so to speak, leadership of that contingent, that is, not some major, the major for them, so to speak, was when they were sitting and after

they got the barrel, a long barrel, conditionally speaking, a kalashnikov, what is the word, that is, only they will listen to the authorities. yes, of course, they will nominate their own authorities who will er manage. well, you also know objectively how 39 wearing a uniform with epaulettes is considered a carnage. well, how about you? отдель формы you mean what is the state? what do you mean? something like that, well, i need to jump out. it’s sitting there for a dozen. and so on. for months, they’re going to deceive everyone. how manure is laid on the ukrainian land, but the second question is, what’s going to appear, uh, it’s going to affect everyone. in the arabic law, this is happening to me. we can't deny what and how many people are collecting, we don't know what hundred it is and thousands. such implement

a recruitment of potential combatants. yes , they definitely won’t return the ego there, you know , that’s why they are actually trying to avoid the collapse. the amount that they were still sick, we cannot control, they controlled the amount, if you do not announce mobility, even 50,000 people are gathered, you have no control, no one will be able to control there, and it’s even worse for nothing, criminals understand it’s a big show, well, on the other hand, mark, we see so that krevel begins, a very strange signal appeared, it is about the fact that they began to apologize for the cossack, do you remember that there was such a person who was in charge of the negotiation or

pseudo-negotiation process instead of surkov, who poured down the toilet from history, so the cossack is said to be intelligent, adequate, acceptable, and so on. and he was just proposing one or another plans that did not work for the army, and accordingly he was rejected, but the main thing here is not that they apologize for the cossack, at what point, so we understand that now the kremlin is basically leaning that they can't win a military campaign. and here they are starting. i think they're looking for certain diplomatic corridors and diplomatic formulas and talking for an hour and a half with scholz is also evidence, so to speak, that putin said something not ready for negotiations well, what to talk about with putin for an hour and a half if it is so clear that he is not ready for anything. no, i am convinced that they are not ready for negotiations. to be a prosecutor, they are to be sent, i just run to them, for sure, they are sent, and the

problem for them is that ukraine puts forward a legal precondition for the start of these negotiations, you leave the territory that you occupied illegally, well, at least until 24 февраля что сейчас это хосте говая после харьковской операция тродом себя представления что эти модель творится украинская страна украиных прогенов , вы высовернеты в украинская срана украиных прогенов, вы не не высо, это не не высо, вы доставка, вы программы, что вы дайте сайдем мы дайте сайдем за 100 three of us will plant a scapegoat for you against the war. look how sweet, and you will talk at everyone 's expense. let's go to luhansk. no matter how we don't bombard it, we wo n't need to. well, no one has applied

it anymore. istanbul yes, as they say, we already have some kind of framework, uh, before the offer was made here for the country of ukraine, yes, let's just start it. means pre-conditions from the country ukraine, well, let's leave the lands, let's start talking about what lands, i will also allow them later . you mean you, you will find troops, you will withdraw them there, we will deal with it simply unilaterally. but if you do not do this, everything will continue as you continue. - eh there how was it said that the word even such a capitulation was offered to scholze, that is, i sounded it to you well, that is , i assumed that the end of the military operation and you saw it отвежал смотреть украинская страна обстреливать donetsk will be bombarded by the zaporizhia as, he started his harmonica again, he twists it endlessly, you know how

reikin has it, and i mean, i am oranges with these boxes, somehow there. well, barrels, this is from the second work, it is not important to me. they did not exchange telegrams, they fooled you understand and so here they tell him the withdrawal of the army, he starts talking about the zaporizhia npp, why are you talking about the zaporizhia nuclear power station , no one will buy it, it's all over already, the withdrawal of the army, well, we just need it comprehensible, it is perfectly clear, he simply takes off his rants, sits on his seat and leaves, and everything goes on, some kind of conversation begins for putin, it is suicide, so he based on his personal and no long ones, interestingly, he does not do this, they do not gather for but in any case, i think the process is going to be stopped by me and if not putin will accept this decision, what does that mean a theoretical solution? the thought that instead of a total military defeat, we

would rather find some kind of outcome with western negotiators and ask for honor to do at least something if something remotely similar happens again this month . what happened in the kharkiv direction, i want to assure you of the process in the park that rather something like this can happen because individual commanders of individual russian occupation units send signals that they are ready to surrender and they demand that they be provided with all the procedures, so to speak according to the geneva conventions, that is, this is the task, their task is not to fight for some kind of united white russia, their task is to survive, and they are already sending signals, and we understand that this is not an isolated story , there may be a very correct question here . the company formed and did not resist, a little bit, the army , and that means iraq is hussein, and then they just

took me, they went away, where is my mother ? we don't fully understand the complex process, how the higher command is not able to cope with it, and i put forward the idea that some element of sabotage is going on . prigozhin and what are you doing ? i don't see the generals of frodovoysk commanding the districts of some representatives of the operational department of the general staff. we see many of them in general. you can better if there are all sorts of code forward to the first plan, the beautiful ones and the rest of the dandruff go away. let them be responsible for everything

about it. the pressure on the top commanders will disappear, these seniors, yes , the command of the generality, this is the process that you are talking about, the quick delivery of any negotiations that i say that the ukrainian country can stimulate, we can understand that on the radio let them be the way to communicate. in the 21st century, we already have telephones and mail and so on. this can speed things up, and it’s not even necessary to be taken prisoner, but simply to leave the position. leave them. leave the position and everything. you have a brick brick for a couple of hours and just sit down from the position and leave, leave the city, it 's not a bad tactic. it's not a bad tactic . but i repeat him

it will speed up, it will speed up. essentially, if there are any additional politically important defining events, mark will hint at what plan these events could be, which would so accelerate the dynamics of the processes, so to speak. ah, it's just morale, those who sit in the trenches would finish the final ones. i'm not even saying what's happening there in russia, but you see that it's all in vain that you breathe in the trenches because tomorrow crimea will be occupied so you are still sitting in this trench choosing to advance where you need to lower this spirit of confidence among the soldiers and then these processes will run faster because it is more related to the situation as a whole at the front if it is like that then you did not understand at all what we are sitting in this the trench, if tomorrow and it is like this, our

enemy will still take it, what is the point of dying for it, so what is valuable in this trench, and there must be a mass of all kinds of symbolic events like this, and they will definitely undermine and sharpen the spirit confidence in the fact that they are here, what will be the mission to understand something important. after all, this is a war of mercenaries that you understand very much now, your people with a salary for money for 200,000 uah, a salary war , you understand that there is no salary. but why? and you will die for putin, he is the same i want a big one more seriously than putin. well, that is, it needs to be deepened further. that is, if you feel that you will not live even for your 200,000, what is the point of this? pay the grave, so to speak, unfortunately, dear mark, i have to end our conversation . thank you very much for this meaningful and extremely deep analysis on the espresso tv channel.

i would like to remind our viewers that mark feigin, a member of the russian opposition, a former member of the state duma and a well-known video blogger , worked for them. of our analysis of general broni waldemar skszybchak, the former commander of the ground forces of the republic of poland, we will of course talk with mr. general about the biggest mistakes and mistakes of the russian general staff and the non-trivial colossal the success of our armed forces in the east of ukraine. i sincerely congratulate you, mr. generals. long live poland. glory to ukraine. long live ukraine. glory to poland. well, mr. taras, i would like to ask you to proceed to the so-called detailed analysis of the miracle in the kharkiv direction. we understand that the armed forces of ukraine struck so powerfully that the russian front you have been showered with success thanks to the fact that from april 3 this year you conducted a defense operation in the area of ​​the

donbas arc in donbas, and in the battles you conducted, you led the army very well. you very well defended yourself by bleeding the russian army so that your best troops could get to know each other, but with the teeth of your defense in donbas, you caused incredible losses to the russians in donbas, the russians lost all their potential, and thanks to this defense, which exhausted the russians, you will be able to win the next battles, repeating the first biggest battle, your greatest success is your defense in donbas, the commander who successfully led the defense for four months is for me your hero as a result of the fact that the russian army in donbas has been exhausted and it no longer has the strength to defend itself whether to fight and what happened in the kharkiv

direction is the result of two factors, the first is that the russians were defeated in donbas, and the second is that your president and politicians misled the russians about the intentions of conducting the main operation of the main strike of the president, said president zelensky and your commanders, what do you have the intention was to do it in the south in the direction of kherson , operations were also carried out to confuse , many means were used. actually, under this cover, you gathered the army in the north to the east from kharkiv south of chuguyev they hit the russian defense which was not ready and consisted of a weak army because the best troops went according to your wish to the south of ukraine in the direction of kherson because it was you who confused the russians about your intentions from there this success in the kharkiv direction and seems that this is a lightning battle in which you defeated all the russian forces that were

east of the siverskyi donetsk river and north of the raisin; now they are still trying to dig in and defend themselves. but in my opinion, this attack of yours is from the south along the eastern bank of the oskil river will destroy the russian defense and the russians will go north to the border because they no longer have the reserves that could secure those positions and they do not have the reserves that could delay your advance, i don't know what the ukrainian commanders intend. do they want to continue beating the russians in the kharkiv region but it seems that it should be completed mr. general we do not like the russians, we even coldly hate them but we never thought that their commanders were so stupid or incompetent in the group what could have happened what did they do so much big mistakes, this shows that the russian

commanders are weak commanders, i don’t know them in particular, but they are definitely weak or poorly prepared, because they allowed themselves to be deceived about the course of that main operation, they were convinced that it would be in the south, they transferred troops there, and you struck in the north, and schoolboy bondar said that this is a school mistake of the russians, it looks like they are not in a position to predict the course of the operation and now this is one very important thing, the advantage you have is your intelligence that monitors the movement in detail russian troops, in turn, the russians cannot scout the maneuvers of your troops. so you have an advantage in intelligence over them, and an advantage in intelligence is an informational advantage. and when you have this advantage, you know where to strike and when to strike, at least the initial h-obeyscha that found the opportunity to highlight to us the so

-called crabs, because we are still waiting for leopards from germany, which is a rather strange situation. how do you evaluate the western aid? we are talking about those countries that promise to help us, for example, spain, germany, but today we do not see those tanks. what do you think is happening? they are afraid of the russians. is it possible that they believe that ukraine should not defeat the russians? because russia can use nuclear weapons. what do such negotiations look like in general? the question was : leopard tanks. what they give to the czechs is scrap, it is better not to take it, as a tankist who knows those tanks, i do not advise you to do this, it is better that the americans gave you their abrams or poland their leords but this is already a matter for politicians,

but if we talk about western countries that should help you who declare help but in fact do not help, it seems that the policy of berlin, paris, madrid is a policy based on expectations of putin, that is, mr. editors, actions that contribute to the prolongation of the war, in my opinion, pursue such a policy that should serve to prolong the war, this is not clear to me because because of them, the war will be longer, if they do not allocate help for you , then they are sabotaging it, that is, they are helping putin, after all, the new year only plays for one thing, hold out through autumn and winter until spring, if there is another scenario, then you it will be smashed and thrown out of ukraine by the end of october. it will probably happen, but there can be no paris, berlin and madrid games for putin, because this number

will cause the war to drag on, cause more victims in ukraine in this war. and this cannot be allowed, sir editors i believe that putin will not use nuclear weapons. of course there are idiots out there, but not so much that they want to use nuclear weapons. firstly, secondly, they must take into account what the americans clearly say. who knows how they would use nuclear weapons? weapons or we would not have received an answer in any case. now we have a conventional war and you very accurately named the critical date for the russian army against it is unknown what will happen with aid, what will happen with tanks and so on, but we are entering, or have already entered, to be more precise, the autumn campaign and a winter company is waiting for us, in general, russians are not ready for winter at all, in my opinion